7 minute read
True Print Personalization Is It All Talk and Little Action?
TRUE PRINT
Is it all talk and little action?
Marketing slows down in the summer, and this summer is no exception. People are out and about again, on vacations and taking road trips. They don’t have time to read marketing mail. So what are marketers mailing? For insight, I turned to a favorite source,
“Who’s Mailing What.”
I can’t review all 20,000 pieces of mail that have been added to the database since the start of the summer, but I can select a market vertical—in this case, retail—and look at those mailed to my state, which is Maryland.
Here is a representative sampling of the calls to action of the first 160 or so pieces of the more than 1,000 added in the past month. ● “Get all of today’s flavors delivered.” (Doordash) ● “Get $15 off your first pet food and supplies order.” (Temptations) ● “Instant savings, plus everyday low prices” (Sam’s Club)
● “A little more in your wallet” (Kohl’s) ● “Take 10% off your next in-store or online purchase.” (Home Depot) ● “We miss you! Take 40% off almost everything.” (The Woman Within) ● “Semi-annual sale! 60% off” (Athleta) ● “Shopping made easier + safer” (Kohl’s) ● “We wanted to provide you with an exclusive offer.” (Leaf Filter) ● “Spend less! Lounge more 15% off your next purchase of $25 or more” (Chewy) ● “Peace of mind starts with a clean home.” (Clean Authority)
We talk a lot about the ability of digital production devices to personalize images, messaging and offers to boost response and conversion rates. We love to talk about data on the value and impact of personalization (although, these days, that data is almost exclusively related to digital marketing). But when I look at what’s being mailed, I see little of it happening on the ground. Rather, I see marketers defaulting to the discounts and other financial incentives. Sure, that works if you hit people at the right time or your offer is the greatest discount on recipients’ stack of mailers if the need arises before the promotion expires. But it still has businesses competing for sales based on price. Only two of the CTAs among hundreds of offers jumped out at me based on lifestyle or need: Doordash (“Get all of today’s flavors delivered.”) and Clean Authority (“Peace of mind starts with a clean home.”)
I’m not saying that there is no personalization or targeting in any of these pieces. There may be deep inside the text somewhere. Or they may be targeted based on precisely selected audiences. But if there was significant personalization happening in these pieces, those pieces should look different enough to be flagged by the “Who’s Mailing What’s” AI-driven software as separate campaigns, and that’s not what appears to be happening. Other than price, then, what is really and truly distinguishing one retailer from another?
I think back to a printing trade show I attended many years ago. The presenter looked at the room full of C-suite executives and asked them to take out a piece of paper. He then asked each one to write down what makes their company special—what truly distinguishes them from their competitors—then fold it over and hand that piece of paper to the person next to them. Next, with participants holding the paper from the person next to them, he asked them to open up and read their neighbor’s sheet.
“Did you say price, quality and service?” he asked. “Now I want a show of hands—be honest. How many of the papers in your hands have the exact same thing you wrote?” Sheepishly, nearly every hand in the room went up.
When I look at these retail mailings, that seminar comes to mind. While these companies may be switching up their offers based on percentages, dollars off or special offers like BOGO (using WMW’s lookup tool, I did note that, a little earlier in the year, Ashley Home Store, for example, tried both “60% off everything” and 50% off + 15% [58%] off furniture in April 2021), nearly every one of these mailings was identical in theme—get a discount or save money. So I give props to companies like Clean Authority and Doordash, which presented their value based on lifestyle needs instead.
For PSPs, the question is whether this matters. Supposedly, this industry is transitioning from “printers” to “marketing services providers,” and that means the ability to direct and influence marketing strategy. Printers are investing millions in new, high-speed inkjet presses to produce fully personalized pieces at volume. When that personalization reaches a level at which marketing text and images is truly personalized, I’d expect to see that reflected in the WMW database. Until then, I wonder: To what extent are we talking about relevance-based personalization and to what extent are we actually doing it? ● Read More… Find article at PrintingNews. com/21154841
Heidi Tolliver-Walker has been a commercial and digital printing industry analyst, feature writer, and author for more than 20 years. Her industry commentary can be found in national printing publications, blogs, and marketing publications.
WATCH LIST ─ Videos Trending On Printingnews.com
The Feeding System for the 100K Digital Press
Ami Yaari, R&D Mechanical Engineer at HP Indigo, talks about and demonstrates the feeding system on the HP Indigo 100K Digital Press.
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21154175
Rollem’s Semi-Slitter: The Top Solution for Back Slitting Pressure Sensitive Materials
Rollem’s advanced SS Semi-Slitting technology allows you to back or face-slit stocks on all types of adhesives.
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21154525
The Inline Priming System and Application Versatility on the HP Indigo V12 Digital Press
Regina Guslitzer, L&P Materials Development R&D Manager, talks about the many developments by HP.
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21154562
Heidelberg to Feature Smart Print Shop at PRINTING United
Felix Mueller, President of Heidelberg USA, shares his excitement about the company’s presence at the show.
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21154545 Jim Raffel and Shelby Sapusek Geek Out with Marty Davis
Resident Print Geeks talk about how “color management” should really be “color IT.”
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21154262
From B2B to B2C: The Challenges
Kristen Dettoni founded Design Pool as a B2B initiative targeting interior designers. During the pandemic, she launched Domanda Designs, a B2C initiative.
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21154307
Shutterfly and Spoonflower Execs Talk about the Acquisition
Michael Jones of Spoonflower and Dwayne Black of Shutterfly share the entire story about the acquisition.
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21154736
A Unique Aspect to Sappi’s Business You Probably Aren’t Aware Of
Nicholas Yardy, Director of Release Technology, talks about their product that can deboss wood grain.
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21154708
Modern Litho Sees Growth Opportunity both Organic and Through Acquisition
Modern Litho’s Jeff Davidson, Vice President of Corporate Strategy, provides an update.
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21154907
Amplify Print! A New Event Dedicated to Advances in Print Finishing
APTech and FSEA teamed up to produce a new industry event that will be held 14-16 June 2022 in Minneapolis.
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21155056
Vanguard Digital Set to Join Durst at PRINTING United
Dave Cich, President & CEO of Vanguard Durst, shares his thoughts about Durst’s investment in his company and some of the benefits the combination brings.
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21155126
Warren Werbitt Goes Printer to Print AR with Bill Atta
Warren talks with Bill Atta, Co-Founder & Chief Product Officer at Melbourne, Australia’s Dreemar. They develop augmented reality (AR) products for the printing industry.
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21155062 The HP Indigo Optimizer: Planning Efficient Print Runs at the Press of a Button
Dror Kella, Technologist, R&D, in the HP Indigo 100K Lab, demonstrates the HP Indigo Optimizer.
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21155003
Labelexpo’s Tasha Ventimiglia on the Upcoming Label Congress
David Zwang talks to Tasha Ventimiglia, Americas Event Director for Labelexpo Americas.
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21154845
Warren Werbitt Goes Printer to Printer with Summer Gould
Warren talks to Summer Gould, President of Eye/ Comm Inc. Started by her father in 1990.
Find video here: www.printingnews.com/21155059
Frank Goes to War
Frank heard that American Airlines is discontinuing its inflight magazine. This prompts a discussion of the “war on paper” that began more than 30 years ago.
