World Bank in India Vol 23 / No. 5
May 2021
A JOURNEY BEYOND THE HORIZON
Development Dialogue How to Vaccinate Every Country
07
Green Power for Delhi Metro
15
New Publications
19
A JOURNEY BEYOND THE HORIZON
T
he Nai Manzil – New Horizons – Program is run
with intellectual and physical disabilities – with an
by the Ministry of Minority Affairs, Government
opportunity to receive a certified formal education
of India and supported by the World Bank with
and skills training. The Program runs in 26 states and
a loan of $50 million. Implementing agencies
3 union territories with six months of education and
under Nai Manzil provide members of the minority
three months of skills training, followed by a further six
community – including school dropouts and people
months of support to help them establish themselves.
Nai Manzil is benefitting more than 98,000 minority youth across the country by improving their education outcomes and increasing their employability options.
2
World Bank in India
Empowering minority women in India
a go of things, despite the temporary setback. Sameera now plans to study further and become a better entrepreneur.
Sameera was just 14 years old when she dropped out of school and soon afterwards her impoverished parents arranged her marriage. She stayed at home to cook and clean for her husband’s
Kausar Jahan, a mother of three, lives with nine
family, like all the other women in her small fishing
drop out of school. Fortunately, some years later,
community in Kerala’s Malappuram district.
Nai Manzil’s training enabled her to get a job at
other family members in Hyderabad in the state of Andhra Pradesh. Married off at 17 she had to
a government hospital providing bed-side care When enrollment for the Nai Manzil program was announced in her village, she joined eagerly with the support of her husband. A year later, Sameera, along with three other women from the program set up Bismil Tailoring, a home-based venture that took in sewing assignments from the community. They earned good money. But the pandemic and the ensuing lockdown took a heavy toll on the nascent enterprise. Despite this, Sameera wasn’t disheartened and managed to get several orders for masks and was able to keep her small family afloat during the crisis. Her education and training, and her exposure to the outside world, had instilled
to patients. When the pandemic hit, Kausar was able to support her family with her salary, as her electrician husband was unable to find work. She now uses her training to provide free health services to her community in the old city of Hyderabad. More than half of Nai Manzil’s beneficiaries are women, with Muslim women constituting the majority. So far, more than 50,700 minority women have benefited from the education and skilling provided by the program.
in her a new self-assurance that she could make
More than 50,700 minority women have benefited from the education and skilling provided by the program.
3
The Nai Manzil program provides education and skills training to persons with disability belonging to minority communities.
Helping minority youth with disabilities
Laxmi was forced to drop out of school at age 10 and
Another notable achievement of the Nai Manzil program has been to provide education and skills training to persons with disability belonging to minority communities.
schooling. She moved to Siddipet near Hyderabad
Anas lives with his parents and extended family in Malappuram district in Kerala. He was born with a disability affecting his intellectual and motor skills. His parents worried about how he would support himself when they were no longer around. He had attended special schools for the disabled while growing up, but it was after enrolling in the Nai Manzil program in his district that he started showing improvement. He was able to finish grade 10 and complete a formal skills training program. At 27, Anas was working as a data entry operator, earning his own money and taking care of himself and his family. Although unemployed now due to the lockdown, he is not worried as he knows he has a skill that will help him in the future.
4
was paralyzed from waist down at age 17. An eager student, she lost all hope of ever completing her for treatment and joined the Program and completed her education and training. She now works as a bedside assistant in a government hospital. She considers herself very fortunate and now wants to motivate and help other people with disabilities to become self-reliant.
The community mobilizers At the forefront, and perhaps often forgotten, are the community mobilizers who play a pivotal role in the success and long-term impact of the program. Being a new program, there was a lot of skepticism and distrust among people at the beginning. The onus of collecting data on school dropouts in their area, targeting the deserving communities and then convincing the families to enroll in the Program was the work of these young men and women.
World Bank in India
Take for example Samina, who has been working
villages of Punjab mobilizing out of school youth,
in the hill state of Manipur since 2017. She helped
especially young girls from the Sikh community, to
mobilize poor youth from the Christian community
join the Nai Manzil program. She says that not every
to join the program. As part of her work she travels
household welcomes them or shows interest. But she
deep into the most underserved areas in the hilly
perseveres, travelling door to door, talking with the
region, meeting with the families and over time
families, convincing the village elders and religious
gaining their trust. Samina is “overwhelmed” with
heads to let the girls complete their schooling.
the appreciation she gets from the people. “Nai Manzil has opened the eyes of minority youth.
The efforts have borne fruit. Vandana mentions
Many students are in college now. Many are
that students who completed grade 10 under the
now in Delhi studying nursing, some are getting
program keep calling her to ask if Nai Manzil can
management training, some are having their own
support them to complete grade 12 as well. In fact,
embroidery business,” she says with pride.
seeing the opportunities opening up for their peers, many young people who could not enroll for the
While Samina focused on youth from the Christian
program the first-time round, now ask eagerly when
community, Vandana has been working in the
the second part of the program will be launched.
Community mobilizers in Punjab, encouraging youth, especially young girls from the Sikh community to join the Nai Manzil program
5
DEVELOPMENT DIALOGUE
HOW TO VACCINATE EVERY COUNTRY DAVID MALPASS
The current approach to COVID-19 vaccination – using limited vaccine supplies to protect low-risk populations in a handful of countries while low- and middle-income economies wait indefinitely for doses – doesn’t make sense for anyone. A successful global vaccination effort must be equitable, and it must stand on three pillars.
6
World Bank in India
The COVID-19 pandemic will not truly end until everyone has access to vaccines, including people in the poorest countries. Worldwide vaccination offers the best hope for stopping the spread of infections, saving lives, and protecting livelihoods. People cannot reach their potential until they can again study, work, travel, and socialize in the confident knowledge that they are safe from COVID-19.
Conducting a large-scale vaccination campaign is a major undertaking for any country, but the logistics are particularly challenging for countries with limited resources and fragile health systems. The ongoing COVID-19 disaster in India and the surge of infections and deaths in Latin America are grim reminders that the pandemic is as bad as ever for many of the world’s poor.
Distributing vaccines more widely is thus an urgent necessity. The pandemic has worsened inequality by hitting the poorest and most vulnerable the hardest. In developing countries, women, children, the poor, and informal-sector workers have paid an extremely high price as COVID-19 took away livelihoods, closed classrooms, and prevented urgent social spending.
A successful global vaccination effort must stand on three pillars.
Delays in starting vaccination rollouts in developing countries are deepening global inequality and leaving hundreds of millions of elderly and vulnerable people at risk. I continue to urge countries with sufficient vaccine supplies to release their additional doses as soon as possible to developing countries that have delivery programs in place. Some countries have gone well beyond vaccinating their most at-risk citizens. But many others have yet to receive any doses, much less administer them widely to the vulnerable. Many of the poorest countries have limited vaccination capacity and will require several months to immunize a large share of the most at-risk groups.
First, countries with an adequate vaccine supply should immediately release doses to the vulnerable worldwide. This may mean exercising options and guiding vaccines to other countries or making clear to manufacturers that they can quickly send supplies without exposing themselves to legal risk. Or it could involve actually fulfilling funding commitments to the COVID-19 Vaccine Global Access (COVAX) facility set up by the international community to allocate doses equitably to poorer countries. The World Bank already has board-approved financing available in 22 developing countries, with several dozen more expected by mid-year under the fasttrack process we used for emergency COVID-19 assistance in 2020. This $12 billion can facilitate rapid
This illogical approach – using limited vaccine supplies in a handful of countries while low- and middle-income economies wait indefinitely for doses – doesn’t make sense for anyone. More lives will be lost, global economic growth will be more unequal, and even countries with high vaccination rates will be more at risk from novel coronavirus variants than they would be if developing countries had greater access to vaccines. The longer it takes to achieve broad vaccination of the vulnerable, the higher the risk of extreme poverty in 2021 and 2022, which in turn will invite future health and social crises.
7
what has been learned from vaccine-readiness assessments we helped undertake with over 140 countries over the last half-year, working closely with Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance, the Global Fund, the World Health Organization, and UNICEF. Thus, the Bank’s online portal is also an invitation to vaccine manufacturers, purchasers, and intermediaries to follow suit, and another plea to those controlling the supply of approved vaccines to release them to safe, well-funded deployment programs.
vaccine deployment through national health systems and pay for vaccine purchases and shipments if needed. Standardized, transparent contracts that arrange for fair and equitable distribution are crucial. If vaccine supplies pass through COVAX, which envisions immunizing the most vulnerable 20% of countries’ populations, World Bank financing can be used to help with distribution and to purchase additional supplies to vaccinate more people. Second, we need greater transparency regarding contracts between governments, pharmaceutical companies, and organizations involved in vaccine production and delivery so that financing can be directed effectively, and countries can plan for receipt and deployment. This is also critical to enable the private-sector investments that will be needed to expand supply. In that spirit, the World Bank is launching a comprehensive online portal that provides easy access to information about our projects, including individual country-financing operations. The portal will also incorporate
8
The third pillar is increased vaccine production. The International Finance Corporation, the World Bank Group’s private-sector arm, has invested over $800 million in health care, including in vaccine manufacturers. And it currently has another $1.2 billion in the pipeline through the Global Health Platform, a $4 billion financing mechanism created to help meet the immediate need for vaccines, medical equipment, and health services. The IFC is actively engaging with governments and companies on early-stage development of commercially viable pharmaceutical manufacturing projects, including for COVID-19 vaccines. The pandemic has overwhelmed health systems worldwide, even in the most developed countries. We must now strengthen them, not just to cope with the vaccination effort, but also to prevent and treat COVID-19 and ensure the full range of essential health services. The global COVID-19 vaccination campaign will be the largest in history – unprecedented in scale, speed, and complexity. Our goal must be to carry it out as quickly, broadly, and safely as possible; learn from what worked and what didn’t; and boost preparedness and resilience for future crises. David Malpass is President of the World Bank Group. This oped was published on the Project Syndicate site on May 19, 2021
World Bank in India
#YOUTHSPEAK The World Bank Group and the Financial Times jointly conducted a blog writing competition for high school students. In the context of COVID-19, students were asked to provide ideas and solutions to improve education outcomes. High school students from around the world (more than 400 students from 62 countries), from different social, cultural and economic backgrounds wrote about how their experience of learning was affected during COVID-19 and shared their ideas about how to improve the learning experience and make it more impactful. Shirin Rajesh from India, was one among the winners.
Education in COVID times - Shirin Rajesh
9
Online learning: The trojan horse of education - Shirin Rajesh The world as we knew it has changed forever. The COVID-19 virus continues to disrupt learning globally forcing the alternative to "in-person" classes: online schooling. Be it Google Meet or Zoom, Microsoft Teams or Classroom, the one thing we all agree upon is that we miss the "good ol' days" of face to face interaction. While learning platforms have transitioned from physical to digital, not much else has changed. The quarks and chemical bonding that we learnt about on whiteboards is now taught using virtual ones and the workload is as hefty as ever. Although the interactive element has been missing, as a 12th grader we never had much of it anyway! This leads me to question, if the only major distinction is the platform, why has our learning experience been so different? Why is attendance dropping and why are scores plummeting? In my opinion, the answer lies in the environment and approach towards teaching coupled with its reception. Nobody was prepared for the challenges that the pandemic threw at us. It's a struggle to tackle the never-ending list of assignments especially with mental health issues in teens being at an all-time high. The administration can be more flexible with deadlines and the workload based on feedback from students to allow for a less stressful learning experience. Our school, for instance, has set a tentative timeline for us to space our tasks to help save us the trouble of scheduling and hassle of timemanagement.
10
Still, schools haven't cut back much on their curricular expectations and "ineffective" learning becomes detrimental for students in the long run. Many virtual classes nowadays choose lectures and slide reading as not all traditional teaching methods can be adopted. I prefer less conventional approaches like class activities, debates and discussions as opposed to assignments to be turned in. With interactive being the way to go, these alternatives can be substituted for a more meaningful, effective and fun learning space. It's important to recognize that teachers only contribute to 50 percent of the equation of profitless E-learning. I learned this during a lecture that I led where presenting my work to the screen of alphabets felt as though my efforts were being invalidated. Trying towards a discussion was met with silence (the analogy "speaking to a wall" seemed to describe the situation perfectly). As a student, I know it's all too easy to scroll through lnstagram while our teachers aren't watching, but what are the consequences of these actions? I empathize with teachers and students around the world and recognize that online learning is not a long-term alternative in a post-Covid world. As someone who would be classified as an extreme introvert, I'm still surprised to see how much the small interactions actually impacted my views on learning in general! Unfortunately, though, all we can do for now is try to find the silver lining and ensure that we put in our efforts so our futures aren't jeopardized.
World Bank in India
INDIA’S YOUTH RISE UP TO FIX COUNTRY’S TOXIC AIR PROBLEM College students participate in a case study competition and suggest innovative ways to improve air quality in Indian cities
Seeing bluer skies in India—a nation known for its alarming air pollution levels—remains a major governmental priority. In recent times, the country launched its flagship National Clean Air Program (NCAP) to provide a roadmap to prevent, control, and reduce unhealthy air and mitigate its effects on development. Yet, much remains to be done, and one can still cough up troubling statistics on the lack of clean air in India: On an average, 248 million Indians lose 8 years of their lives due to exposure to poor air quality. And 1.67 million deaths were attributable to air pollution in India in 2019. Naturally, it came as a breath of fresh air when on April 12, six college teams from across India—beating 1,500 peers in a national competition co-organized by the World Bank and Shri Ram College of Commerce,
New Delhi—became air-quality champions for the day and advocated innovative, practical solutions for a cleaner tomorrow, their tomorrow. “Each presentation was fantastic and filled with innovative ideas,” said Urvashi Narain, Lead Economist at the World Bank, and one of the three jurists of the competition. “And all of this was a weekend’s worth of work. Can you imagine what change these youth can spur if they take on the challenge of air pollution as their main profession?” The other jurists of the competition included Anumita Roychowdhury, Executive Director of the Centre for Science and Environment in New Delhi and Aasherwaad Dwivedi, Assistant Professor at Shri Ram College of Commerce.
11
Rising Up to the Challenge The premise of the Shri Ram Macromania youth challenge was three-fold: pick an Indian city of choice, study its air quality trends, and develop a public awareness campaign to mitigate the impact of air pollution, particularly from exposure to PM2.5—small particulates hanging in the air that cause deadly illnesses such as lung cancer, stroke, and heart disease. The challenge came with two practical caveats. The approach had to be multi-jurisdictional and incorporate an airshed-based management approach to air pollution. Air pollution travels across administrative boundaries, and pollution sources are located both inside and outside of any given city. Therefore, an airshed-based management approach that cuts across jurisdictions is key to achieving results. Also, the approach had to be multi-sectoral, recognizing that poor air quality in India is driven by urban as well as rural sources such as agricultural residue burning, household use of biomass for cooking, and less-known sources such as excessive use of fertilizer, emissions from which contribute indirectly to the formation of PM2.5.
12
Youth: Informed Agents of Change “If not youth, then who?” asked John Roome, World Bank’s Regional Director for South Asia Sustainable Development, in his opening remarks. Narain’s familiar refrain after each of the six rounds, asking contestants what they had learned in preparation for the competition, captured their newfound awareness and insights: “I learned that the horticulture and agriculture industries lead to large contributions of PM2.5.” “Combatting crisis at a city level is not effective, a regional solution is required. Knowing that made a lot of difference.” The future of the world indeed belongs to youth. “I am glad we are catching them young and now, to address these issues,” said Roychowdhury.
Solutioning Beyond Delhi: An All-India Challenge India’s capital city of New Delhi has long attracted global attention and analyses as the most polluted capital in the world, two years in a row. But the Shri
World Bank in India
Ram Macromania challenge finalists steered clear of Delhi’s familiar smog to envision bright and bold solutions for cleaner air in other afflicted cities such as Gurugram, Mumbai, and Indore. Visualize It! was one such award-winning solution for Mumbai from the Pune-based Team ACERS, representing Symbiosis Centre for Management and Human Resource Development. The team proposed leveraging new technologies such as Augmented Reality, LED Screens, and Smart Glasses to make the deleterious effects of air pollution more visible daily to citizens. Delhi’s Team Triplets, from the Shri Ram College of Commerce, focused on Kolkata and won kudos for their five-point plan for the transportation sector and a deep dive into public awareness campaigns on air pollution: Hospital on Wheels Campaign to create awareness and provide quality healthcare on the go; Sahayak, a campaign to train anganwadi or rural healthcare center workers; and the Campaign for Lung Cancer Awareness. They also drew on best practices in airshed approaches from other countries. Team Freewheeling3 from Indian Institute of Management, Rohtak, won the competition for their
clear theory of change and comprehensive framework for an airshed management approach to air pollution. The team used Gurugram—a suburb of Delhi that had a mere 40 good air days in 2020—as their backdrop to approach change methodically—build awareness, change attitude, and lead to action.
Act Now or Forever Hold Your Breath One of the evening’s poignant moments came from author and activist Jyoti Lavakare, who seamlessly wove in a personal narrative on losing her mother to lung cancer—a deadly reminder of the effects of air toxicity—with her appeal to youth to be informed, vigilant citizens. “Make yourself very aware and make others very aware, and then try and make sure you keep asking and demanding to breathe clean air,” appealed Lavakare to the youth. “And vote with your ballots and wallets to save the environment.” It’s the zest for life, teased out through such youth challenges, that will brighten the sky and enable us all to breathe easier.
13
SOME RECENT BLOGS South Asia unites to double down on marine plastics pollution South Asia is the world’s second largest contributor of solid waste —334 million tons annually-- and is on track to be the fastest growing contributor to plastic pollution over the next two decades Read more at: https://blogs.worldbank.org/endpovertyinsouthasia/south-asia-unites-double-down-marine-plastics-pollution
South Asia needs a united voice at UN climate, biodiversity meetings The cross-border consequences of climate change and ecological degradation demand collaborative action. The success of South Asia in dealing with climate change will be a major contribution to the global response to climate change. Read more at: https://blogs.worldbank.org/endpovertyinsouthasia/south-asia-needs-united-voice-un-climate-biodiversity-meetings
Menstrual health and hygiene empowers women and girls: How to ensure we get it right If menstrual health and hygiene (MHH) is well managed from the start, it has a surprisingly high potential to contribute to increasing female empowerment at a critical stage of a girls’ Read more at: https://blogs.worldbank.org/water/menstrual-health-and-hygiene-empowers-women-and-girls-how-ensure-we-get-it-right
Installing solar panels at high altitudes in the snow: Mission possible The thought of installing solar panels in isolated, snowbound regions with harsh weather conditions may seem far-fetched. But Himachal Pradesh, a hilly state in northern India where snow and sun abound, is about to break new ground. Read more at: https://blogs.worldbank.org/energy/installing-solar-panels-high-altitudes-snow-mission-possible
14
World Bank in India
Green Power to the Delhi Metro
A 1590 acre Ultra Mega Solar Park in Rewa's Gurh Tehsil in Madhya Pradesh is among the largest single-site solar power plants in the world. And 24 percent of the park’s solar energy is being sold directly to the Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC), meeting almost 60 percent of its daytime demand. This will essentially help DMRC not only reduce its dependence on coal, but also save Rs. 793 crore on its energy bill over the next 25 years.
The park, with an installed capacity of 750 megawatt, has been made possible with support from the World Bank and Clean Technology Fund through a US$ 18 million funding as part of a Shared Infrastructure for Solar Parks Project. The International Finance Corporation, the private sector arm of the World Bank Group, was the transaction advisor for the project.
The World Bank Group is now collectively working on replicating the success of the Rewa Solar Park in other such parks in Madhya Pradesh and possibly in Odisha.
More than half of the Delhi Metro runs on solar power coming all the way from Rewa in Madhya Pradesh. This means that 290 trains across 373 kilometers serving 2.6 million passengers in a single day are now green.
15
NEW PUBLICATIONS
World Development Report 2021: Data for Better Lives March 2021 Data are a powerful weapon for fighting poverty in low- and middle-income countries. But data themselves won’t help lift people out of poverty. It’s the people using them that generate insights that can turn into action to improve development outcomes. Data are currently not reaching their full potential for use in development. The World Development Report (WDR) 2021 explains this problem and introduces an important part of the solution: a social contract for data
16
World Bank in India
INDIA: POLICY RESEARCH WORKING PAPERS WPS9592
Bridging Bangladesh and India: Cross-Border Trade and the Motor Vehicles Agreement By Matias Herrera Dappe, Mathilde Sylvie Maria Lebrand and Diana Van Patten This paper studies the effects of removing transport and trade barriers between Bangladesh and India and focuses on the Motor Vehicles Agreement between Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, and Nepal and full transport and trade integration between Bangladesh and India. It shows that decreasing transport and trade barriers between Bangladesh and India can lead to up to a 7.6 percent increase in national real income for India and a 16.6 percent increase for Bangladesh. WPS9584
Workers at Risk: Panel Data Evidence on the COVID-19 Labor Market Crisis in India By Maurizio Bussolo, Ananya Kotia and Siddharth Sharma This paper focusses on the differential impact on the formal and informal segments of the labor market in India, using data from a large household panel survey and employing a difference-indifferences event study approach. WPS9578
The Cost of a Nutritious Diet in Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, and Nepal By Felipe Jr Fadullon Dizon, Zetianyu Wang and Prajula Mulmi This paper calculates and compares the minimum cost of a recommended diet across four countries
in South Asia. Within countries, the cost and affordability vary across urban and rural areas, subnational areas, and seasons of the year. In a context of constrained resources, this suggests the need for strategic prioritization of investments and service improvements in transport and storage of food and, more broadly, a rethink of food policies. WPS9569
Closing the Gap: Gender, Transport, and Employment in Mumbai By Muneeza Mehmood Alam, Maureen L. Cropper, Matias Herrera Dappe and et.al. A growing body of literature documents the differences in men and women’s mobility patterns. However, there is limited evidence on the evolution of these mobility patterns over time and the role that transportation networks play in women’s access to economic opportunities. Transport appears to be only one of many barriers to women’s labor force participation and not the most important one.
WPS9566
The Silenced Women: Can Public Activism Stimulate Reporting of Violence against Women? By Abhilasha Sahay This paper examines whether public activism on violence against women can stimulate disclosure of socially sensitive crimes such as rape and sexual assault. The analysis finds an increase of 27 percent in reported violence against women after the 2012 “shock.” Additional evidence -- generated from selfcompiled high frequency crime data -- suggests that the increase can be attributed to a rise in reporting rather than an increase in occurrence.
17
OTHER PUBLICATIONS SOUTH ASIA ECONOMIC FOCUS SPRING
2021
South Asia Vaccinates
South Asia Economic Focus, Spring 2021: South Asia Vaccinates March 2021
Prospects of an economic rebound in South Asia are firming up and putting the region on a path to recovery. But growth is uneven and economic activity well below pre-COVID-19 estimates. The economic benefits of vaccination are huge. South Asian governments lack the resources and health infrastructure and delivery capacity to purchase and distribute vaccines. A stronger COVAX facility is needed to centrally acquire and provide vaccines for free to countries with insufficient resources.
What's Cooking: Digital Transformation of the Agrifood System Kateryna Schroeder, Julian Lampietti, and Ghada Elabed April 20211 The Report investigates how digital technologies can accelerate the transformation of the agrifood system by increasing efficiency on the farm; improving farmers’ access to output, input, and financial markets; strengthening quality control and traceability; and improving the design and delivery of agriculture policies.
project presents eight indicators structured around women’s interactions with the law as they move through their lives and careers: Mobility, Workplace, Pay, Marriage, Parenthood, Entrepreneurship, Assets, and Pension. This year’s report updates all indicators as of October 1, 2020. Prepared during a global pandemic that threatens global progress toward gender equality, the report also includes important findings on government responses to COVID-19 and pilot research related to childcare and women’s access to justice.
Primer on Large-Scale Assessments of Educational Achievement Marguerite Clarke and Diego LunaBazaldua April 2021 This new World Bank book is a response to the huge demand from policymakers and education stakeholders for a concise, easy-to-read introductory guide on the topic. It is meant to be a first-stop resource for those wanting to understand how to properly design, develop, administer, analyze, and use the results from large-scale assessments of educational achievement. It also provides an update on the main assessment studies of this type conducted in the last ten years.
Debt Report 2021 Edition II April 2021
Women, Business and the Law 2021 By World Bank April 2021 This Report is the seventh in a series of annual studies measuring the laws and regulations that affect women’s economic opportunity in 190 economies. The 18
The second of the series of Debt Reports for 2021 published online, aims is to provide users with analyses of evolving trends and development related to external debt and public debt in individual countries and regional groups, with primary emphasis on low- and middle-income countries, and to keep users abreast of debt-related issues and initiatives.
World Bank in India
Small Dam Safety: Good Practice Note on Dam Safety April 2021 Small dams play an important role in the provision of many kinds of benefits, such as drinking and irrigation water supply, flood control, small/mini hydropower generation, fishing, and so on. This note provides some lessons on how to address the challenges of small dam management with participation of community groups and effective government support for them.
The Potential of ZeroCarbon Bunker Fuels in Developing Countries Dominik Englert, Andrew Losos, Carlo Raucci, and Tristan Smith April 2021 The report examines a range of zero-carbon bunker fuel options that are major contributors to shipping’s decarbonized future: biofuels, hydrogen and ammonia, and synthetic carbon-based fuels. Furthermore, the report finds that many countries, including developing countries, are very well positioned to become future suppliers of zerocarbon bunker fuels—namely ammonia and hydrogen.
Frontline: Preparing Healthcare Systems for Shocks from Disasters to Pandemics J un Rentschler, Christoph Klaiber, Mersedeh Tariverdi, Chloé Desjonquères and Jared Mercadante April 2021 Healthcare systems are at the frontline of delivering critical care during emergencies. Yet, already before the COVID-19 pandemic, many countries were struggling to meet even
routine demands for health care. To strengthen the resilience of health systems to shocks and pressures, this note outlines five principles and priority areas for action. The principles presented in this note can help to better prepare health systems to respond to a wide range of shocks, from seasonal demand surges, to pandemics, climate change, and disasters.
The Role of LNG in the Transition Toward Low- and Zero-Carbon Shipping Dominik Englert, Andrew Losos, Carlo Raucci, and Tristan Smith April 2021 This report, considers the potential of LNG to play either a transitional role, in which existing LNG infrastructure and vessels could continue to be used with compatible zero-carbon bunker fuels after 2030, or a temporary one, in which LNG would be rapidly supplanted by zero-carbon alternatives from 2030. The research finds that LNG is likely to only be used in niche shipping applications or in its non-liquefied form as a feedstock to kickstart the production of zero-carbon bunker fuels when used in conjunction with carbon capture and storage technology.
Tax Theory Applied to the Digital Economy: A Proposal for a Digital Data Tax and a Global Internet Tax Agency ristian Óliver Lucas-Mas and Raúl C Félix Junquera-Varela March 2021 Tax Theory Applied to the Digital Economy analyzes the tax-disruptive aspects of digital business models and reviews current tax initiatives in light of traditional tax theory principles. The analysis concludes that market countries’ tax claims are unsubstantiated and contravene the most basic foundations of tax theory, giving rise to a series of legal, economic, tax policy, and tax administration issues that policy makers cannot overlook.
19
POLICY RESEARCH WORKING PAPERS WPS9648
WPS9642
Using Poverty Maps to Improve the Design of Household Surveys: The Evidence from Tunisia
COVID-19 and African Firms: Impact and Coping Strategies By Gemechu A. Aga and Hibret Belete Maemir
By Gianni Betti, Vasco Molini and Dan Pavelesku WPS9641 WPS9647
Enhancing Human Capital at Scale Francesco Agostinelli, Ciro Avitabile and Matteo Bobba WPS9646
How Does Trade Respond to Anticipated Tariff Changes? Evidence from NAFTA By Shafaat Yar Khan and Armen Khederlarian WPS9645
Understanding FDI Spillovers in the presence of GVCs By Valerie Anne Mercer-Blackman, Wei Xiang and Fahad Khan WPS9644
Effects of Recognition of Prior Learning on Job Market Outcomes: Impact Evaluation in Bangladesh By Shiro Nakata, Uttam Sharma, Tashmina Rahman and et.al.
By Simon Bilo, Mohamed Ihsan Ajwad, Ebtesam Alansari and et.al. WPS9640
Regime-Dependent Environmental Tax Multipliers: Evidence from 75 Countries By Christian Schoder WPS9639
Does Gender Equality in Labor Participation Bring Real Equality? Evidence from Developed and Developing Countries By Federica Alfani, Fabio Clementi, Michele Fabiani and et. al. WPS9638
The Impact of PTAs on the Duration of Antidumping Protection By Thomas J. Prusa and Min Zhu
WPS9643
WPS9637
Effects of Public Sector Wages on Corruption: Wage Inequality Matters
Containing Chinese State-Owned Enterprises?: The Role of Deep Trade Agreements
By Asli Demirguc-Kunt, Michael M. Lokshin and Vladimir Kolchin
20
The Long Shadow of Short-Term Schooling Disruption: Analysis of Kuwait's Civil Service Payroll Data
By Kevin Jean-Rene Lefebvre, Nadia Rocha and Michele Ruta
World Bank in India
WPS9636
WPS9629
Assessing Response Fatigue in Phone Surveys: Experimental Evidence on Dietary Diversity in Ethiopia
Machine Learning in International Trade Research: Evaluating the Impact of Trade Agreements
By Kibrom A. Abay, Guush Berhane, John Hoddinott and et.al.
By Holger Breinlich, Valentina Corradi, Nadia Rocha and et.al.
WPS9635
WPS9628
Estimating the Gains from International Diversification: The Case of Pension Funds
Trade, Jobs, and Worker Welfare
By Juan Pablo Afanador, Richard Mark Davis and Alvaro Enrique Pedraza Morales WPS9634
The Distribution of Effort: Physical Activity, Gender Roles, and Bargaining Power in an Agrarian Setting By Jed Friedman, Isis Gaddis, Talip Kilic and et.al. WPS9633
Organizational Resources, Country Institutions, and National Culture behind Firm Survival and Growth during COVID-19
By Erhan Artuc, Paulo S. R. Bastos and Eunhee Lee WPS9627
Social Transfer Multipliers in Developed and Emerging Countries: The Role of Handto-Mouth Consumers By Jessica Roxana Bracco, Luciana Maria Galeano, Pedro Francisco Juarros and et.al. WPS9626
Inclusive Statistics: Human Development and Disability Indicators in Low- and Middle-Income Countries By Sophie Mitra, Jaclyn Lourdes Alcala Yap and Justine Francoise Marie Herve
By Yu Liu, Mike W. Peng, Zuobao Wei and et.al. WPS9625 WPS9632
How to End the COVID-19 Pandemic by March 2022 By Ruchir Agarwal and Tristan Reed
Invisible or Mainstream? Disability in Surveys and Censuses in Low- and MiddleIncome Countries By Sophie Mitra, Wei Chen, Justine Francoise Marie Herve and et.al.
WPS9631
The Economic Ripple Effects of COVID-19
WPS9624
By Francisco J. Buera, Roberto N. Fattal Jaef, P. Andres Neumeyer and et. al.
Gender Violence, Enforcement, and Human Capital: Evidence from Women's Justice Centers in Peru
WPS9630
By Maria Micaela Sviatschi and Iva Trako
A General Equilibrium Assessment of the Economic Impact of Deep Trade Agreements
WPS9623
By Lionel Fontagne, Nadia Rocha, Michele Ruta and et.al.
Human Trafficking: Definitions, Data, and Determinants By Stephen Joseph Winkler
21
WPS9537
WPS9616
Do Large-Scale Student Assessments Really Capture Cognitive Skills?
From Health Crisis to Financial Distress
By Rafael E. De Hoyos Navarro, Ricardo Estrada and Maria Jose Vargas Mancera
By Carmen M. Reinhart WPS9615
When Distance Drives Destination, Towns Can Stimulate Development
Mapping Data Governance Legal Frameworks Around the World: Findings from the Global Data Regulation Diagnostic
By Joachim De Weerdt, Luc Christiaensen and Ravi Kanbur
By Rong Chen
WPS9622
WPS9621
Motivating Teams: Private Feedback and Public Recognition at Work By Clara Anne Delavallade
WPS9614
What Prevents More Small Firms from Using Professional Business Services? An Information and Quality-Rating Experiment in Nigeria By Stephen J. Anderson and David J. Mckenzie
WPS9620
A Map of the Poor or a Poor Map? By Paul Andres Corral Rodas, Kristen Himelein Kastelic, Kevin Robert Mcgee and et. al. WPS9619
Does Participation in Global Value Chains Reduce Spatial Inequalities within Countries? By Arti Goswami Grover and Somik V. Lall WPS9618
The Evolution of City Form: Evidence from Satellite Data By Somik V. Lall, Mathilde Sylvie Maria Lebrand and Maria Edisa Soppelsa WPS9617
Long-Term Impacts of Short Exposure to Conditional Cash Transfers in Adolescence: Evidence from the Philippines By Ervin Dervisevic, Elizaveta Perova and Abhilasha Sahay
WPS9613
Welfare Impact of Hosting Refugees in Ethiopia By Ashenafi Belayneh Ayenew WPS9612
Coping with Disasters: Two Centuries of International Official Lending By Sebastian Horn, Carmen M. Reinhart and Christoph Trebesch WPS9611
Do Workfare Programs Live Up to Their Promises? Experimental Evidence from Côte d’Ivoire By Marianne Bertrand, Bruno Jacques Jean Philippe Crepon, Alicia Charlene Marguerie and et. al. WPS9610
A Cautionary Tale: An Experiment on The Stability of Business Environment Perceptions in a Firm Survey By Islam,Asif Mohammed,Rodriguez Meza,Jorge Luis
22
World Bank in India
WPS9609
WPS9602
Understanding the Requirements for Surveys to Support Satellite-Based Crop Type Mapping: Evidence from Sub-Saharan Africa
Trade Barriers in Government Procurement
By George Azzari, Shruti Jain, Graham Jeffries and et. al. WPS9608
Deep Services Trade Agreements and their Effect on Trade and Value Added By Ingo Borchert and Mattia Di Ubaldo WPS9607
The Realities of Primary Care: Variation in Quality of Care Across Nine Countries in Sub-Saharan Africa By Kathryn Gilman Andrews, Ruben Orion Conner, Roberta V. Gatti and et.al. WPS9606
Natural Capital and Sovereign Bonds By Dieter Wang WPS9605
Integration of Venezuelan Refugees and Migrants in Brazil By Mrittika Shamsuddin, Pablo Ariel Acosta, Rovane Battaglin Schwengber and et.al. WPS9604
Damaged by the Disaster: The Impact of COVID-19 on Firms in South Asia By Arlan Zandro Ilagan Brucal, Arti Goswami Grover and Santiago Reyes Ortega WPS9603
Links between Growth, Inequality, and Poverty: A Survey
By Alen Mulabdic and Lorenzo Rotunno WPS9601
The Effectiveness of Environmental Provisions in Regional Trade Agreements By Ryan Michael Abman, Clark Christopher Lundberg and Michele Ruta WPS9600
The Value of Deep Trade Agreements in the Presence of Pricing-to-Market By Meredith A Crowley, Lu Han and Thomas Prayer WPS9599
Deep Integration in Trade Agreements: Labor Clauses, Tariffs, and Trade Flows By Raymond Robertson WPS9598
Global Value Chains and Deep Integration By Leonardo Baccini, Matteo Fiorini, Bernard M. Hoekman and et.al. WPS9597
New Evidence on Learning Trajectories in a Low-Income Setting By Natalie Bau, Jishnu Das, Andres Yi Chang WPS9596
Regulating Personal Data: Data Models and Digital Services Trade By Martina Francesca Ferracane and Erik Leendert Van Der Marel
By Valerie Cerra, Ruy Lama and Norman V. Loayza
23
WPS9595
WPS9589
The Effect of Information and Subsidy Measures on Adoption of Solar Lanterns: An Application of the BDM Bidding Mechanism in Rural Ethiopia
Projecting the Economic Consequences of the COVID-19 Pandemic
By Alemu Mekonnen, Sied Hassen, Marcela Jaime and et.al. WPS9594
Will Every Child Be Able to Read by 2030? Defining Learning Poverty and Mapping the Dimensions of the Challenge
Achieving Privacy: Costs of Compliance and Enforcement of Data Protection Regulation
By Joao Pedro Wagner De Azevedo, Diana Goldemberg, Silvia Montoya and et.al.
By Anupam Chander, Meaza Abraham, Sandeep Chandy and et.al.
WPS9587
WPS9593
Meta-Analysis Assessing the Effects of Virtual Reality Training on Student Learning and Skills Development
Poor Expectations: Experimental Evidence on Teachers' Stereotypes and Student Assessment
By Diego Angel-Urdinola, Catalina Castillo Castro and Angela Hoyos
By Maria Gabriela Farfan Bertran, Alaka Holla and Renos Vakis
WPS9586
WPS9592
Aspirations and Financial Decisions: Experimental Evidence from the Philippines
Bridging Bangladesh and India: CrossBorder Trade and the Motor Vehicles Agreement
By David J. Mckenzie, Aakash Mohpal and Dean Yang
By Matias Herrera Dappe, Mathilde Sylvie Maria Lebrand and Diana Van Patten
WPS9585
WPS9591
Trends and Determinants of Female Labor Force Participation in Morocco: An Initial Exploratory Analysis By Gladys C. Lopez-Acevedo, Florencia Devoto, Matías Morales and et. al. WPS9590
A Demand-Side View of Mobile Internet Adoption in the Global South By Rong Chen
24
By Justin Damien Guenette and Takefumi Yamazaki WPS9588
Power Market Sophistication and Sector Outcomes: A Focus on Social Performance, Electricity Reliability, and Renewable Energy Penetration By Djeneba Doumbia WPS9584
Workers at Risk: Panel Data Evidence on the COVID-19 Labor Market Crisis in India By Maurizio Bussolo, Ananya Kotia and Siddharth Sharma
World Bank in India
WPS9583
WPS9577
The Convergence of Sovereign Environmental, Social and Governance Ratings
Invoicing Currency and Symmetric PassThrough of Exchange Rates and Tariffs: Evidence from Malawian Imports from the EU
By Eric Bouye and Diane Dorothy Menville
By Angella Faith Lapukeni Montfaucon
WPS9582
The Short-Term Impacts of COVID-19 on Households in Developing Countries: An Overview Based on a Harmonized Data Set of High-Frequency Surveys
WPS9576
By Tom Bundervoet, Maria Eugenia Davalos and Natalia Garcia
By Carlos Rodriguez Castelan, Samantha Lach, Takaaki Masaki and et. al.
WPS9581
WPS9575
Living Standards of Tunisian Households in the Midst of the COVID-19 Pandemic
Using Twitter to Evaluate the Perception of Service Delivery in Data-Poor Environments
By Federica Alfani, Dorra Dhrif, Vasco Molini and et.al. WPS9580
Titling and Beyond: Evidence from Dar es Salaam, Tanzania By Alexandra Patricia Panman and Nancy Lozano Gracia
How Do Digital Technologies Affect Household Welfare in Developing Countries? Evidence from Senegal
By Alia Anne Braley, Samuel Paul Fraiberge and Emcet Oktay Tas WPS9574
Saving the American Dream? Education Policies in Spatial General Equilibrium By Fabian Eckert and Tatjana Karina Kleineberg
WPS9579
Making Room for Renters: Understanding and Supporting Rental Markets in the Global South — Evidence from Dar es Salaam, Tanzania
WPS9573
By Alexandra Patricia Panman and Nancy Lozano Gracia
By İzak Atiyas and Mark Andrew Dutz
Digital Technology Uses among Informal Micro-Sized Firms: Productivity and Jobs Outcomes in Senegal
WPS9572 WPS9578
The Cost of a Nutritious Diet in Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, and Nepal By Felipe Jr Fadullon Dizon, Zetianyu Wang and Prajula Mulmi
Optimal Taxation with Multiple Dimensions of Heterogeneity By Katy Ann Bergstrom and William Dodds
25
WPS9571
WPS9567
COVID-19, Poverty, and Social Safety Net Response in Zambia
Firm-Level Technology Adoption in Vietnam
By Boban Varghese Paul, Arden Jeremy Finn, Sarang Chaudhary and et.al.
By Xavier Cirera, Diego Adolfo Comin, Marcio Jose Vargas Da Cruz and et.al.
WPS9570
WPS9566
Statistical Performance Indicators and Index: A New Tool to Measure Country Statistical Capacity
The Silenced Women: Can Public Activism Stimulate Reporting of Violence against Women?
By Hai-Anh H. Dang, John James Pullinger, Umar Serajuddin and et.al.
By Abhilasha Sahay
WPS9569
Closing the Gap: Gender, Transport, and Employment in Mumbai By Muneeza Mehmood Alam, Maureen L. Cropper, Matias Herrera Dappe and et.al. WPS9568
Firm-Level Technology Adoption in the State of Ceara in Brazil By Xavier Cirera, Diego Adolfo Comin, Marcio Jose Vargas Da Cruz and et.al.
26
WPS9565
The Covid-19 Vaccine Production Club: Will Value Chains Temper Nationalism? By Simon J. Evenett, Bernard M. Hoekman, Nadia Rocha and et. al.
World Bank in India Publications and Knowledge Resource Center The World Bank The Hindustan Times House (Press Block) 18-20, Kasturba Gandhi Marg New Delhi - 110 001, India
Media Inquiries
For more Information
The World Bank 70, Lodi Estate New Delhi - 110 003
Global: www.worldbank.org India: www.worldbank.org/in Facebook: WorldBankIndia Twitter: @worldbankindia
Contact: Nandita Roy Email: mediaindia@worldbank.org Tel: +91-11-4147 9220
Contact: Sunita Malhotra Email: smalhotra@worldbank.org Tel: +91-11-49247753
Rights and Permissions: The material in this work is copyrighted. No part of this work may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or inclusion in any information storage and retrieval system, without the prior written permission of the World Bank. The World Bank encourages dissemination of its work and will normally grant permission promptly.