political review | National
washington university
political review 21.2 | October 2014 | wupr.org
Learn about a national movement of Democrats, Republicans and political review | NATIONAL
independents dedicated to a new politics of problem-solving
November 18, 2:00-3:30 p.m. Emerson Auditorium, Knight Hall Al Cardenas, Chairman of the American Conservative Union &
Conservative Political Action Conference Mack McLarty, Former Chief of Staff to President Bill Clinton
Co-sponsored by the Office of the Chancellor and D
EDITOR’S NOTE Editors-in-Chief: Gabriel Rubin Sonya Schoenberger
Executive Director: Nahuel Fefer
Staff Editors: Henry Kopesky Billie Mandelbaum Aryeh Mellman
Features Editor: Grace Portelance
Director of Design: Alex Chiu
Assistant Directors of Design: Simin Lim Andrew Kay
Director of New Media: Ari Moses
Programming Director: Hannah Waldman
Finance Director: Alex Beaulieu
Front Cover: Andrew Kay
Theme Page: Andrew Kay and Alex Chiu
Back Cover: Andrew Kay
Dear Reader, This October, thousands gathered in downtown St. Louis to demand justice. Protesters flocked from across the United States to assemble and march, past the historic Dred Scott Courthouse and towards the Gateway Arch, as they spoke out against racial oppression, police brutality, and the degradation and devaluation of black lives. Too often, justice is assumed to be a static concept written down in dusty law books or etched on the walls of neoclassical buildings. While ancient systems of morality may guide our understanding of right and wrong, our modern interpretation of justice should be grounded in—and responsive to—the times in which we live. Individuals mobilizing in Ferguson and St. Louis are demanding reform of the status quo. This activism should serve as a reminder that established systems of “justice” do not always support an inclusive, benevolent, or egalitarian society. Sometimes, the pursuit of justice necessitates a reevaluation of the very foundations of our social, political, and economic institutions. In this issue, students have written about justice from many angles. In our Campus Leader column, Patrick Easley, Vice President of the Association of Black Students, shares how the killing of Mike Brown and the community’s response have resonated with him as an African American student at Washington University. In a piece about the much less-publicized police killing of Kajieme Powell, an African American man with mental disabilities, CJ Harrington argues that police who use lethal force violate the right to due process. Other authors have explored a range of national and international topics, from the NFL’s role in galvanizing public recognition of domestic violence to an exclusive interview with Singapore’s Ambassador to the United States. We are excited to showcase the diverse range of work in this issue, and we invite all of our readers to respond to these articles or to submit original work to editor@ wupr.org. With best regards, Gabriel Rubin and Sonya Schoenberger Editors-in-Chief
TABLE OF CONTENTS 3
JUSTICE
Michael Brown and the Lasting Effecs of Summer of 2014
21
Mayor Slay Chooses Love Over Law Lindsey Wanberg
Patrick Easley
22 8
When Killing Became Just
Slaves for the World Cup Min Heo
CJ Harrington
INTERNATIONAL
23 10
An International Look at Ferguson
No Justice For Comfort Women Samuel Leiter
Ruby Arora
24 12
NATIONAL
How Much Reality Can You People Ignore?
The Progression (and Regression) of the Status of Women in India Katherine Surko
Henry Kopesky
26 13
When Our Adversarial Justice System Fails
A Chat with Ambassador Mirpuri of Singapore Aaron Christensen
Chloe Naguib
28 14
The NFL’s Long Game: Do We Thank Injustice for the Change it Creates?
29
The Victims Behind Bars
30
Kids in Jail
31
ISIL: Explained Joe Lenoff
20
2
Rick Perry and UT Lock Horns Divya Walia
Benjamin Szanton
18
A Mile in Her Shoes Katelyn Taira
Wallis Linker
17
Ice-Bucket Politicking Xiaochang Song
Rachel Butler
16
A Game of Lives Reuben Siegman
32
Who’s Gaining From Capital Gains? Benjamin Compall
Cruel and Usual
Missouri’s Apathetic Approach to Gun Violence
Samuel Klein
Brady Schaer
34
campus leader column
political review | Justice
Michael Brown and the Lasting Effects of Summer 2014 Patrick Easley Vice President, Association of Black Students
W
hen I first heard about the death of
greater St. Louis—and here at Wash U—in the
Chicago and at Wash U, I have never seen black
Michael Brown at the hands of a
wake of Michael Brown’s murder. The Ferguson
people come together in such a peaceful and
Ferguson, Missouri police officer,
community has shown that we, as African
united way. In Ferguson, I saw people making
I was outraged, but I wasn’t too surprised.
Americans, and more broadly, as members of
their discontent known while still trying to figure
Unfortunately, neither were many others familiar
the Wash U community, can work and protest
out how they would build change. Young and
with the struggles of minorities in America.
together for the common good of our brothers
old, rich and poor, locals and those from outside
Minorities, and African Americans in particular,
and sisters. Those on the ground in Ferguson
the St. Louis community all came together and
are more likely to be harassed and discriminated
have been working day and night for the sake
united to demand justice for a young man slain in
against by the police, more likely to receive
of not only demanding justice for the murder
the streets.
longer sentences when convicted by the courts,
of Michael Brown, but also demanding justice
and more likely to be perceived as criminal
for those who have been the victims of the
by the average American. These unfortunate
systematic structures that continue to persecute
truths have a powerful effect on the way African
young black men and women. By continually
Americans perceive their relationships with
protesting the treatment
law enforcement and shape intra-community
of young black youth, and
discourse, notably at Wash U.
black men in particular, the
The reason many of us, as African Americans, weren’t too taken aback by the events in Ferguson is because the understanding that we will not be treated equally by the law enforcement community is at the forefront of the African American psyche. We know that we are in no way different than Michael Brown. We know that what has befallen him and his community could have easily have happened to any one of us. Police mistreatment is not something that African Americans
Ferguson protesters act as an international reminder that “we ain’t equal yet,” and as much as African Americans continue to attain a larger piece of
Here at Wash U, we have also been taking on the mantle of social justice with many students joining the protests in Ferguson and using their
“The Ferguson protesters act as an international reminder that “we ain’t equal yet,” and as much as African Americans continue to attain a larger piece of the American Dream, we must not forget that we still live under a state of inequality.”
the American Dream, we must not forget that we still live under a state of inequality. This situation will not be resolved until we achieve systemic and structural changes that alter the way African Americans are perceived by non-black
talents to facilitate change throughout the St. Louis community. The Association of Black students has led a series of talks and meetings about the events in Ferguson and the state of
counterparts and a discriminatory legal system.
African Americans at Wash U. Students have
and “questioned” as we make our way through
When I was in Ferguson two weeks after Mike
discuss the future of race relations in America,
the community. While it is unfortunate that
Brown’s murder, the mood on the protest site
and those outside the black community have
some crimes in the area are committed by young
among the protesters wasn’t one of hostility—
become active in working towards equality.
black males, is it appropriate to stop every black
which came from the militarily-armed police
male who fits the description? By constantly
officers—but rather one of hope. It was hope
being aware of our position in society and on this
that we could somehow come together and bring
campus, African American students have no
about justice for yet another young black male
choice but to view ourselves through the lens of
killed by a system that perpetuates the belief that
subordination by law enforcement officials.
black lives aren’t important. People believed that
are unfamiliar with–even on Wash U’s campus many African American students are stopped
Beyond these negatives, many in the black community have been surprised by the swift and direct action of those in Ferguson and
organized walkouts and panel discussions to
I can’t predict the exact long-term ramifications of Ferguson, but I do know that the events of the past summer opened up national dialogue on race and privilege. In terms of creating lasting change, this is a great start.
we would get justice, and they weren’t deterred by tanks in the street or policemen with assault riffles. In all my years of social justice work in
Patrick is a senior in the College of Arts & Sciences. He can be reached at peasley@wustl.edu.
3
political review | NATIONAL
“Human progress is neither automatic nor inevitable... Every step toward the goal of justice requires sacrifice, suffering, and struggle; the tireless exertions and passionate concern of dedicated individuals.” — Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.
4
political review | Justice
5
political review | Justice
WHEN KILLING BECAME JUST CJ Harrington
O
ne of the greatest tragedies this
the video (which he was not obligated to
I completely believe that police should have
summer in St. Louis may not have
do), showing the whole encounter. Dotson
the right to defend themselves and I am
been what happened in Ferguson.
also released an initial public statement
grateful for all of the work they do to keep
Only four miles away, on August 19, Kajieme
saying that Powell charged the officers
our communities safe. However, I disagree
Powell was killed by the police. The police
with his knife (something that clearly never
with Dotson when he said in his public
were called about Powell shoplifting
happened). However, riots in response
statement that, “Police safety is the number
two soda cans and a honey bun from a
to Powell’s killing did not stir like those in
one issue.” I believe that when police
convenience store. Powell, 25 years old, was
Ferguson. CNN Anchor Don Lemon asked
academies preach “protect and serve,”
known within the community to have mental
Dotson, in an interview, why this was.
officers are taking a serious, sacrificial oath
disabilities. When the police arrived on
Dotson said, “As soon as it was over, I talked
to perform those acts in the best interest
the scene, they came out with guns raised.
to the community…now they knew what
of everyone whom they are policing as
Powell, holding a knife, walked towards one
happened and didn’t have to wait for it to go
opposed to letting those words only apply
officer yelling, “Shoot me! Shoot me! Shoot
viral.” Dotson completely ignored the fact
to themselves. Thus, if an officer can save
me now!” He backpedalled and then walked
that he gave a version of the truth that didn’t
someone’s life, even if that suspect is trying
towards the other officer with his arms
align with video evidence. Even if Dotson’s
to cause harm, they should.
lowered the entire time. Fifteen seconds
talking to the community did ease tension,
after their arrival, the police shot Powell 12
that shouldn’t explain a lack of outrage. Our
times, killing him instantly.
society has continued to stretch the concept
St. Louis Police Chief Sam Dotson released
6
of a “justified killing” and refuses to fight against this growing injustice.
Unfortunately, that sentiment goes against the way police are trained. The Tueller Rule says that when dealing with a wielded edged object, the police should take
political review | Justice
action once the suspect is within 21 feet
potentially very useful tool, why ask for such
Department understands this. They are the
(some academies believe that this isn’t
equipment and make taxpayers pay for it?
only major metropolitan police force to go
sufficient and suggest being allowed to pull one’s gun and shoot is merited even farther away). The Police Firearms Officer Association, a group which advocates for officers who must use guns in the line of duty, has reported research suggesting that shooting to wound is not a smart strategy due to its impracticality and it not being a legal or tactical necessity. According to the research performed on the topic, it is nearly impossible for an officer to shoot a suspect’s forearm or hand, which are the fastest moving body parts. The legs are a much more plausible option, but certain areas are rich in vascularity and, if hit, could lead to the suspect bleeding out in seconds. They also argue that if the legs are non-fatally hit, the suspect can still cause harm with
Another obstacle to getting the police to have a greater appreciation for the lives they are protecting is the Supreme Court’s strict interpretation of Graham v. Connor. This case held that “an objective reasonableness” should be applied if a citizen wants to claim that excessive force occurred. The New York Times recently reported that there haven’t been any Supreme Court cases where police officers have been held responsible for their use of force. The most recent case demonstrating this phenomenon is Plumhoff v. Rickard. In this case, the police attempted to pullover a suspect for a
beyond stating that it aims to protect lives in its mission statement. They include “A Statement on the Value of Human Life,” which states that “the use of deadly force will never be condoned as a routine response and police officers will exercise the highest degree of care in the application of such force.” This statement was featured in their annual report to the community in 2009 and continues to be highlighted on their website and subsequent annual reports. They also mention how it is the force’s duty to “honor the established principles of democracy,”
“When police do not do everything in their capacity to try to save a suspect’s life, they violate that individual’s right to due process.”
whatever is in his hands.
busted taillight.
Still, it seems plausible that someone has
misguidedly
a better chance of living if hit in the legs as
decided to drive away and went as fast as
opposed to the torso or head. If a suspect
100 mph. The police fired shots into the car
happened to die from a shot to the leg, it
(even though the suspect was not shooting)
could at least be understood that there was
and the driver and passenger were struck
not an intention to kill. Although the result
and killed. The Supreme Court reversed
may be the same, the distinction between
the decision made in the Appellate Court
It is tough to comment authoritatively
the two is crucial to having a community
and determined that the speeding car was
on what took place in Ferguson, as more
truly believing that its law enforcement has
a threat to the community, thus warranting
evidence is still being collected. However,
everyone’s best interest at heart. About the
the police to shoot at the vehicle. Given that
the video of how Kajieme Powell was killed
suspect still being a threat if hit in the legs,
the officers could have requested backup to
is a clear indication that the current training
this clearly does not apply if the suspect has
set up a blockade at a future point, catch the
for police officers does not coincide with
no weapons; it would drastically diminish
license plate number and put a warrant out
principles of justice. Dotson should not
the chances of an officer being fatally
for the suspect’s arrest, or shoot at the tires
have a false sense of confidence because
wounded by any knife; and it would even
of the car as opposed to shooting through
there were no riots after Powell’s shooting.
increase the chances to strike the suspect in
the windshield, clearly shows how the Court
The lack of riots were not due to Dotson’s
the arm or hand to remove a gun (although
supported an officer’s right to use lethal
response. There was no uproar because
this is something that is still probably too
force even when not a tactical necessity.
those outraged would simply be bringing a
dangerous to attempt). Moreover, the use of other weapons like a Taser serve as another substitute considering the suspect is not carrying a gun. Dotson has said on record saying that he is content with his officers not using Tasers and choosing to use guns instead because “Tasers are not 100 percent.” However, guns are not 100% effective, either. Also, if you are going to encourage your officers not to use this
The suspect
When police do not do everything in their
which should include due process rights. However, it appears that the St. Louis Police Department is preaching something it does not entirely believe or enforce.
knife to a gun fight.
capacity to try to save a suspect’s life, they violate that individual’s right to due process. Our legal system is based on the notion of being innocent until proven guilty. Every suspect of a crime is entitled to a trial and it is not up to the police to issue death sentences or any punishment for that matter. It appears that the St. Louis Police
CJ Harrington is a sophomore in the College of Arts & Sciences. He can be reached at charrington@wustl.edu.
7
8
political review | Justice
Ruby Arora | Infographic by Gretchen Oldem
T
he armored vehicles roll in, and tear gas
(as London experienced a similar series
force against civilians,” use of military-grade
fills the air. The officers stand still as
of racial riots fueled by the death of Mark
weaponry, and detention of media reporters
stone, impassable, with their bulletproof
Duggan) but rather in the “dehumanizing
to parallel occurrences in Ferguson.
vests, gas masks, and riot gear. The crowd
treatment of citizens” exhibited by police
is weary of the fight yet passionate for the
toward protesters in Ferguson. The United
cause. The smoke bombs and flash grenades
Kingdom’s Metro argued that the events
and rubber bullets only temporarily deter
in Ferguson didn’t just affect Americans:
the protesters. The tumult shows no sign of
“when the police dehumanize a community,
subsiding. This is Ferguson.
it shames all of us.” The French Le Figaro
The shooting of Michael Brown rocked the small city of Ferguson, Missouri and precipitated an explosion of anger, criticism, and protest that consumed the community and country as a whole. The effects of the events in Ferguson were also felt far beyond our national borders.
agreed, saying, “more than the issue of race
“The events in Ferguson have affected how we Americans perceive our communities, our government, and ourselves, and they have also shaped how the rest of the world sees us.”
racial discrimination in the United States. Germany’s Zeit Online boldly declared that “the situation of African-Americans has hardly improved since Martin Luther King.” Iran’s PressTV also highlighted the “long history of police brutality against AfricanAmericans.” Many of the United States’ long-term adversaries gleefully used the events in Ferguson to support claims of “American hypocrisy” and to emphasize the faults in the American social system. The official Xinhua news of China advised the United States “to concentrate on solving its own problems rather than pointing the finger at others” and went on to describe the racial divide in the U.S. as a “deeply-rooted
is ‘excessive militarization’ of policing that commands attention.” The Russian Foreign Ministry alleged that “serious violations of basic human rights and barbaric practices thrive” in the United States. Many articles brought up President Barack Obama’s impact, or lack thereof, on the Ferguson protests and racial discrimination in the United States more generally. Patrick Bahners’ harsh article in the German newspaper Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung declared, “the first black man in the office of the president has done nothing for blacks after his election. It seems like a joke that he
Ironically, many of same nations that reacted loudly to the Ferguson incident face
enemies but its allies as well. Much of the disapproval from the United Kingdom was rooted not in the death of Michael Brown
urban development and later morphed into a vast series of protests involving “police brutality,” including the use of tear gas and water cannons, and “the participation of young people,” both qualities mirrored in Ferguson. The international backlash from the Ferguson protests reveals that this issue is no longer simply an American one. The events in Ferguson have our communities, our government, and ourselves, and they have also shaped how the rest of the world sees us. Racial discrimination is not exclusive to United States, but the world will now look to our approach to addressing racial tensions and discrimination, and either condemn or commend it. As the chaos in Ferguson dwindles down, we have a choice: change our social system for the better or to let these tensions continue to simmer. No matter what we choose, we must keep in mind that spotlight is now on us, and the entire world is watching.
in the world.”
society apart.”
Ferguson came not only from America’s
Gezi Park incident began as a protest against
is still referred to as the most powerful man
chronic disease that keeps tearing U.S.
However, criticism for the events in
Park protests in Turkey to Ferguson. The
affected how we Americans perceive
From France to China, the world and international media fixated on the issue of
Other reporters have begun to liken the Gezi
similar issues back home. In the Xinjiang region of China, ethnic conflict between the Muslim Uighurs and Han Chinese police resembles the turmoil in Ferguson. Josh Chin of the Wall Street Journal compared the “Chinese security forces using deadly
Ruby Arora is a freshman in the College of Arts & Sciences. She can be reached at ruby.arora@wustl.edu.
9
political review | Justice
How Much Reality Can You People Ignore? Henry Kopesky
I
f you’re reading this, you’re probably a racist.
punched repeatedly in the head by a California
How much reality can we ignore? That
No, don’t argue with me. You are. Maybe a
Highway Patrol officer. She was hospitalized
question was posed to me by Professor Bob
more apt way to phrase that would be “You
for a month afterward, but only after being
Hansman, with whom I sat down recently
confined to a psychiatric facility for two weeks.
to discuss the institutional racism that
are an integral part of a culture that represses people based on the color of their skin.” Is that more palatable? Sure. To be fair, though, I’m a
In August 2014, an unarmed 18-year-old
racist, too. Why? Because I’m white.
student named Michael Brown was shot to
Your blood pressure is probably going up.
assaulted an officer and that he was leaving
“I don’t judge people based on their race!
the scene of a convenience store he had just
I’m a modern person, a progressive!” you say,
robbed.
death, also in Ferguson. The police alleged he
defensive. You’re missing the point, though: if you are white, you are a willing participant in a culture that systematically breeds inequality. Too often, we overlook the fact that systemic equality makes life fundamentally different for people from different backgrounds. It doesn’t take much effort to see that that’s the
characterizes St. Louis. The full account of that interview is available on our website, but I was more struck by what happened after we went our separate ways: that evening, October 8, a young black man was shot by an off-duty police officer in Shaw, 10 minutes southeast of Washington University. The media was
“America’s black communities are indisputably on the receiving end of a long, long train of abuses that dates to the transatlantic slave trade.”
case, though. In March 2001, for instance, a ten-year-old boy named Rodney McAllister
Our Declaration of Independence declares that
was playing in Ivory Perry Park, only five
“when a long train of abuses…evinces a design
minutes northeast of Washington University’s
to reduce them under absolute Despotism,”
campus yet also on the edge of one of the
a people is entitled to redress. Indeed,
most impoverished urban neighborhoods in
America’s black communities are indisputably
the St. Louis area. As he played in the park,
on the receiving end of a long, long train of
McAllister was set upon by a pack of wild
abuses that dates to the transatlantic slave
dogs that roamed his neighborhood and eaten
trade. But whenever a predominantly black
alive. McAllister’s mother was arrested for
community comes together to try to change
child endangerment shortly thereafter.
their circumstances, the popular reaction
On September 20, 2009, Henry Davis, a 52-year-old welder, was mistakenly arrested by the Ferguson Police. Davis had taken a wrong turn and was trying to find his way home, but was taken into custody in the stead of another man with a similar name. Even after officers knew they’d arrested the wrong man,
is always the same: the white-dominated media tries to downplay the element of race, accuses agitators of playing “the race card,” marginalizes the victim with accusations
most revealing moment of the tragedy. As the officer’s car began to follow the man and his friends, their immediate reaction was to flee, not because they had committed a crime, but because fear of white power structures has been beaten, figuratively and literally, into the black community for hundreds of years. And every time you deny that truth or pretend it doesn’t matter, you become the oppressor, whether or not you wear the white hood.
blacks into the mold of criminality. Is the culpability of white America in the plight of black America obvious, then? Each time
him to sleep on the concrete floor of a small
you or I blame a mother for her child’s death
holding cell that was filled past capacity.
in the park across the street, each time we
When he complained, he was held down
blame a defenseless man or woman for acting
and beaten bloody, before being taken to an
aggressively toward the police, each time we
emergency room with a concussion. Davis
dismiss a shooting or a beating as deserved
was charged with destruction of property for
because of a young black man or woman’s
bleeding on police officers’ uniforms.
petty criminal history, we enable a culture of
10
fired on the officer, but overlooked the single
anywhere but on the culture that pidgeonholes
him with a mattress for the night, instructing
homeless great-grandmother, was tackled and
man was carrying a gun, of whether he had
of criminality, and generally lays the blame
they refused to release him or even provide
In July 2014, Marlene Pinnock, a 51-year-old
quick to seize on the question of whether the
oppression that shocks us from time to time, but that oppresses millions every moment of every day.
Henry Kopesky is a sophomore in the College of Arts & Sciences. He can be reached at hrkopesky@ wustl.edu
political review | Justice
When Our Adversarial Justice System Fails Chloe Naguib
I
n January 2014, Criminal Court Judge Paul
inquisitorial system places a larger emphasis
harder for him or her to ensure desert. Take,
S. Biebel of Illinois granted Nicole Harris,
on finding truth and has fewer regulations
for example, a case in which there isn’t enough
convicted for the murder of her son Jaquari,
on evidence in comparison to the adversarial
evidence to prove one party guilty. If that party
a Certificate of Innocence. In 2005, Jaquari
system. In the adversarial system, both parties
did commit the crime, the party would get off
accidentally strangled himself to death with an
present their cases with evidence, with the
on a technicality since the judge wouldn’t have
elastic band while playing in his bedroom. His
judge acting as a passive decision maker who
enough information to adjudicate the trial. In
six-year-old brother witnessed the accident,
just evaluates the arguments presented.
the inquisitorial system, the judge plays a more
but was deemed unfit to testify on behalf of his mother’s innocence due to his belief in Santa Clause and the Tooth Fairy. This assessment about his inability to testify was later deemed arbitrary by the Seventh Circuit court, which reversed the decision and released Jaquari’s mother, but only after she had already served
Some aspects of the inquisitorial system make it specifically more prone to accuracy than the United States’ adversarial system. An innate characteristic of the adversarial system is competition—both the prosecutor and defendant hope to come out victorious at the
active role in the investigation and analysis of evidence. This makes judges more prone to accurate assessments of culpability since they can look for evidence necessary to fill in gaps in the story in order to gain a more coherent picture of what occurred. This means that judges will also stop dismissing cases based on
eight years in prison.
end of the trial. Many assume this is a positive
Harris’ wrongful conviction demonstrates a
out due to the attorneys’ incentive to reveal
widespread problem within our justice system—
facts about the opponent that will push the trial
the high number of wrongful convictions.
in their favor. However, the focus on winning
A study by Marvin Zalman, professor at
makes lawyers more prone to twisting the law
Wayne State University, tallied the wrongful
in their clients favor, instead of attempting to
convictions in the United States and found that
accurately describe the events of the crime.
approximately 2,000 innocent people go to
This results in a more clouded depiction of
These aspects make the inquisitorial system
prison and 3,000 more receive felony sentences
the case for the judge to evaluate, increasing
more prone to accurate adjudication of
each year. Furthermore, many other individuals
the likelihood of inaccurate punishment. The
punishment. However, it’s unlikely that the
can be over-punished in our current system due
inquisitorial system would solve this problem
United States will enact a complete overhaul of
to errors in accounting for environmental factors
since the attorneys play a smaller role in the
the judicial system in favor of the inquisitorial.
when assessing culpability.
courtroom and function simply as individuals
As society starts to develop a greater awareness
characteristic, as the truth will eventually come
“Such flaws in our courts give rise to the question of whether inaccurate sentencing is an immutable part of any justice system, or if reforms are necessary to diminish the number of wrongful convictions.” Such flaws in our courts give rise to the question of whether inaccurate sentencing is an immutable part of any justice system, or if reforms are necessary to diminish the number of wrongful convictions. The United States
the guilty are held responsible for their crimes. Furthermore, this ability creates an opportunity for more objective decision-making, since judges get to interpret and analyze evidence themselves instead of just deciding amongst the arguments made by lawyers.
of wrongful convictions like that of Nicole Harris, the most feasible solution for it to advocate for would be reform. Perhaps reform will entail completely new methods of justice, but more than likely will look to aspects of other justice systems, such as the inquisitorial, that have proven to help judges more accurately adjudicate trials.
who guide the judge’s questions to witnesses. The system is focused less on winning the trial, therefore lessening an attorney’s incentive to spin the story in favor of his or her client.
currently utilizes an adversarial system of
Another key manner in which the two systems
justice, but perhaps it should consider adopting
differ is in the judge’s level of involvement.
a new system more similar to the inquisitorial,
In the adversarial system, the judge sits as a
which is commonly utilized in Europe and many
passive bystander that sees the trial play out
other countries around the world.
and then adjudicates the case at the end. His
While the systems differ in many ways, the
a lack of evidence as frequently, ensuring that
or her knowledge of the case is limited to the information presented in the trial, making it
Chloe Naguib is a freshman in the Olin Business School. She can be reached at chloe.naguib@wustl.edu
11
political review | Justice
The NFL’s Long Game: Do We Thank Injustice for the Change it Creates? Rachel Butler
“I
f this is a seminal moment for domestic violence
don’t get to Rosa Parks without Rosa Parks’ bus
relatively ignored by the mainstream media, to
and the way we handle it as a society, then that’s
driver, and that is me. You should be thanking
the forefront of public consciousness. In fact,
not a burden for us to be that poster boy— it’s
me.” Will the failures of Bisciotti and the rest of
following the release of the Ray Rice video to the
not. Now, I’m embarrassed about it, but five years
the NFL administration lead to positive change
public on TMZ on September 8, the National
from now if things have changed significantly for
five years from now? If so, should we be thanking
Domestic Violence Hotline received 84% more
the better, I’ll be proud of it,” Baltimore Ravens
them?
calls than usual. Call volume rose every time a
owner Steve Bisciotti said in a recent interview.
As a society, we don’t usually thank someone
Bisciotti was referring to his own handling of the domestic violence charges leveled against Ravens running back Ray Rice, as well as to the responses of the the larger National Football League
who causes an injustice. However, it is true that high-profile injustice, such as one involving the NFL, can lead to greater public awareness of the issues at hand and in turn lead to social change. A specific incident of injustice that gains
(NFL) administration. Bisciotti and other league administrators have been the focus of a great deal of media attention over an apparent attempt to cover up a video, which shows Rice punching his fiancée (now wife) in a hotel elevator . The league
a high profile often serves as the catalyst for social change, demonstrated in shifts in societal attitudes or in legislation. One needs a specific incident in order to create a resolution that can
new domestic violence accusation against an NFL player hit the news. The hotline was unable to answer almost 50% of the chats, calls, and texts sent during these surges. These surges indicate a corresponding surge in awareness of domestic violence in the wake of the allegations against NFL players, at least on the part of those actually involved in domestic disputes who had a need for the hotline. If the allegations against NFL players led to so many people reaching out for help
also faced criticism for its inconsistency in punishing Rice—his initial two-week suspension was changed to an indefinite ban after the NFL faced media backlash for its laxity. Four other NFL players are also currently facing domestic violence charges, and public criticism has surrounded the
“If the allegations against NFL players led to so many people reaching out for help, could this scandal actually be a step towards a more just and open societal attitude towards domestic violence?”
scandal actually be a step towards a more just and open societal attitude towards domestic violence? The NFL has been taking some steps to rework their policies. In response to the stress on the hotline and its probable link to the NFL
punishments the NFL doled out (or didn’t dole out) in response to those cases.
against domestic abuse, could this
players involved in domestic violence, be applied to that general type of conflict. This
the league publicly committed to supporting the
In his interview, Bisciotti tried to put a positive
is how Supreme Court cases work—using a
hotline, pledging to provide the resources for the
spin on the NFL’s and his own poor handling of
specific case of injustice, the court rules on how
hotline to handle as many callers as possible.
the situation, saying that it may lead to significant
all cases relating to that type of injustice should
Furthermore, the league hired four women
change “for the better.” On his show Last Week
be handled. The domestic violence cases leveled
to create new policies on sexual assault and
Tonight, John Oliver aptly paraphrased Bisciotti’s
against current NFL players won’t go to the
domestic violence for the organization, which
statement: “Really, you should all be thanking me.
Supreme Court and create any actual change in
is significant not just for policy change but also
I’ve handled this situation so badly, I may have
legislation. However, the cases are high profile
because it increases gender diversity in the
actually instigated social progress.” If someone
enough that they may be able to create change in
league’s management. The driving force behind
accidentally instigates progress through some
our society’s attitude towards domestic violence
these actions is probably damage control for
wrongful or unjust action, does that mean we
simply by publicizing the issue.
the NFL’s image rather than a genuine desire to
should thank that person for what he or she did? John Oliver presented a pertinent analogy to Bisciotti’s sentiment: “Think of it this way: you
12
The current issues with the NFL are certainly bringing domestic violence, a crime that is usually
combat domestic violence, but the efforts may still lead to positive results in practice. Since the NFL’s mistakes—coupled with its actions
political review | Justice
in the wake of those mistakes and the publicity
spark social change does not mean we should be
other domestic violence support systems,
of both—may be helping to combat domestic
thanking them.
and has to meaningfully alter its own policies.
violence, should we be thanking Steve Bisciotti?
However, though it seems evident that the
We typically don’t thank people who cause
scandal has caused some shifts within both the
an injustice, even those who try to correct it,
NFL and society at large as of now, whether or
because of their motives. We don’t thank Rosa
not it will create lasting social change “5 years
Parks’ bus driver, because he did not have what
from now,” as Bisciotti postulated, has yet to be
we now think of as justice in mind when he called
seen. Domestic violence has been thrust into the
the police to have her arrested. Similarly, Steve
national consciousness over the past few weeks
Bisciotti probably didn’t have the social change
due to its exposure in the media, which tends
that his actions might cause in mind when he
to sensationalize the crimes and the ensuing
tried to cover up the severity of Ray Rice’s assault
scandal rather than discuss the issue of domestic
on his then fiancée . The motives behind the
violence in general. The increased volume of calls
league’s efforts at damage control are similarly
to the hotline may be linked only to the current
questionable—Roger Goodell’s visits to and
media exposure, and could likely fall after the
support of the hotline seem more like a media
scandal stops getting so much news coverage.
ploy than a genuine gesture, as he was also
The NFL’s partnership with the hotline may also
supposedly complicit in the cover up of Rice’s and
break apart as soon as the backlash against the
other players’ actions. If it were only the results
league dies down. The league’s employment of
that mattered and motives were irrelevant, then
four women to create new policies is slightly more
we might be thanking the players who committed
encouraging for the prospect of lasting change,
crimes of domestic violence for sparking the
but the new policies have yet to be created or
whole scandal in the first place. The ends do
implemented.
not justify the means, especially if one doesn’t have the ends in mind. Just because the unjust actions of NFL players and administrators may
In order for real change to be made, the NFL has to continue supporting the hotline and
Furthermore, consumers of the media need to remain aware of domestic violence even after it fades from headlines, requiring a shift from sensationalizing the current scandal to using it as an educational jumping-off point for the issue of domestic violence at large. If the NFL does succeed in creating change within itself in terms of its attitude toward domestic violence, it could catalyze much broader change, as the high publicity of the NFL affords the organization great influence on the public consciousness, as we have seen during the scandal. If this scandal leads to improvements in how we address domestic violence as a society, the NFL still won’t be deserving of gratitude, but it may be a few steps closer to earning forgiveness.
Rachel Butler is a freshman in the College of Arts & Sciences. She can be reached at rachelkbutler@wustl.edu.
13
political review | Justice
The Victims Behind Bars L Wallis Linker | Illustration by Savannah Bustillo aw and Order, Orange is the New Black, and
and thus can be especially
The Wire are rife with depictions of the
challenging for the mentally
incarcerated criminals and the government
ill. For example, mentally ill
agencies that deal with this sector. But, as is
prisoners can be sent to super-
often the case with TV, these shows misrepresent
maximum security prisons
life behind bars in state and federal prisons. The
like Colorado’s USP Florence
quality of life in these institutions is by no means
Admax (ADX), due to poor
frilly or relaxed; inmates are burdened physically
management and clerical
and mentally by the conditions in which they are
loopholes. A complaint was
held. This burden is significantly worse for those
filed in 2012 alleging that “the
who enter the institution with pre-existing mental
disciplinary model at ADX is
disabilities. There has been a rise in the number of
often an instrument of terror
incarcerated mentally ill inmates in recent years,
and abuse, deployed by staff
which has heightened the injustice of
members… mentally ill prisoners,
prison conditions.
including those in the throes of
In 2003, Director of the U.S. Program of Human Rights Watch Jamie Fellner said, “Prisons have become the nation’s primary mental health facilities.” In 2006, the Bureau of Justice Statistics reported that over half of all incarcerated individuals had mental health issues — a figure of
a psychotic episode frequently are subjected to barbaric treatment…mentally ill prisoners are routinely ‘four pointed’— chained by the arms and legs to a concrete block…”
1.25 million. Other studies reported that by 2010,
Exacerbating the problem,
40% of the total mentally ill population in the U.S.
mental health professionals
had been in jail or prison at some point in their life.
ignore requests for treatment,
This trend between mental illness and incarceration can be traced back to the 1950s when a policy of deinstitutionalization—the emptying of state mental hospitals—took hold. Between 2010 and 2013, mental health service funding across the nation was cut by $3.5 billion. As a result, the mentally ill, especially among the homeless, addicts, and poor, are denied access to medical help and end up facing mandatory sentencing for even low-level, nonviolent crimes. In the process, they suffer an unsuitable punishment. Employees
creating a cycle: inmates become sicker, they are not given treatment, and then they behave worse, justifying, in the minds of
care. Finally, Human Rights Watch reiterated that
the prison officials, a harsher treatment that then
mentally ill prisoners should not be sent to isolated
stimulates psychotic episodes. This treatment
confinement or super-max facilities.
within such facilities is unwarranted. The inmates do not have the same control over their actions, and even their crimes, that the mentally stable do. This handling is not within the realm of due process.
When an individual is convicted of a crime in the United States, he or she must pay for it in a manner deemed fit under the law. When an individual violates the laws, he or she breaks an unspoken contract with the nation and loses his or her ability
at the Department of Corrections are not taught
Something needs to be done to remedy this
to claim certain rights; for example, a convicted sex
how to recognize and handle mental illness. Joe
treatment of the mentally ill. In 2003, Human
offender may not be able to live within a certain
Baumann, a corrections officer at the California
Rights Watch took a stance on the issue, outlining
distance of a school. But locking the mentally
Rehabilitation Center argues that “there’s a lack
possible ways to start a positive change. It urged
handicapped away in regular or supermax prisons
of any real training to identify specific issues and
Congress to enact legislation that would provide
strips the inmates of their basic rights. How can
how to deal with them.” However, this is not
federal grants to enroll the mentally ill in treatment
this treatment possibly lead to rehabilitation? How
only a question of training; existing programs
programs as well as improve the overall quality of
can it dissuade criminal actions? Harsh treatment
are not utilized. According to a report from the
the mental health services prisons provide. Human
of mentally ill patients doesn’t deliver justice; it
Department of Justice, more than half of inmates
Rights Watch also advised that independent
violates basic human rights.
with mental health problems never receive
mental health experts be used to evaluate the
treatment prior to incarceration.
current available mental health services and to
Prison life is trying for mentally competent inmates,
14
bring them up to the community standards of
Wallis Linker is a junior in the College of Arts & Sciences and can be reached at w.linker@wustl.edu.
political review | Justice
Kids in jail T Benjamin Szanton
here are many milestones in the lives of
judge, minorities end up overrepresented in
society believe that leaving a nine-year-old
kids growing up in Missouri. They learn
the cases.
child in a park unsupervised is potentially a
to ride a bike, head off to kindergarten
and graduate elementary school. Then, with
But the main reason that this justice system is unjust is simple: if somebody is legally
their twelfth birthday, they reach a big one:
considered a child in every other context, if
the ability to be charged as adults by their state’s criminal justice system.
they are not allowed to consume alcohol or
States have different standards for when kids
legal documents or vote, they should not be
may be considered adults in the eyes of the
allowed to go to jail as an adult. Eighteen
law. Several have no minimum at all. Almost
may seem like an arbitrary age to be an adult,
everywhere in the country, however, one thing
and it is. A 12-year-old has been scientifically
is consistent. Individuals under eighteen may
shown to have a substantially reduced
be charged and convicted as adults. Two
capacity to plot a crime or understand the
states, North Carolina and New York, actually
justice system. I will readily believe that the
mandate it for all 16-year-olds.
differences between a 16-year-old and an
tobacco, serve in the army, get a tattoo, sign
The law as it stands subjects hundreds of thousands of children to the brutal life of an adult prison, an environment where they are the easiest targets for sexual abuse. Largely as a result of their vulnerability, they are 36% more likely to kill themselves in adult jail than in a juvenile detention center. Never mind that many teenagers in trouble with the law have already experienced a pattern of abuse. A study in the early 2000s found that while people who were abused growing up tend to get into legal trouble later, they
crime. Such was the case for Debra Harrell, a North Augusta, South Carolina, woman who was arrested for allowing her daughter to spend her mother’s work shift at a local playground while carrying both a cell phone and a house key. For better or for worse, a decent portion of society believes that no nine year old is mature enough to be allowed to ever be unsupervised in public by their parents. And yet, if the girl had committed murder while at the playground, she could have been charged as an adult under South Carolina law.
18-year-old, however, are minimal. But that
No other country in the world sends underage
argument could apply to granting any right to
defendants to prison on life sentences
those under eighteen. Why should going to
without the chance of parole—despite a 2012
jail be a more important right to our society
Supreme Court ruling that made the practice
“If somebody is legally considered a child in every other context, they should not be allowed to go to jail as an adult.”
are far more likely to get arrested in the years soon after the abuse — 59% more likely as a juvenile compared to 28% as an adult. Of kids who go to adult prison, 66% have at least one psychiatric disorder. Going to jail as a child also leaves a person with a permanent criminal record for a crime he or she committed before becoming fully mature. Under the laws of many states, if a child is ever convicted as an adult, regardless of the crime, and, in some states, even if he is not convicted, he must always be considered an adult from then on. In many cases, the typical privacy rights given to minors in court are also waived when they are tried as adults, meaning that even if not convicted, their identities may be public. And in a system that generally leaves the decision to charge a child as an adult in the hands of a prosecutor or a
than any other? Eighteen is where we as a
illegal, the United States currently has more
society have drawn the line, and wherever the
than 2,500 people convicted as juveniles now
line is drawn, we must stick to it.
spending the rest of their lives behind bars.
Seventeen-year-olds can be sent to the juvenile system, where people are often held until they are 21 anyway. In the cases of the most serious crimes, perhaps they could delay their adult sentences until they actually become adults. At the very least, it would allow them the chance to avoid spending
It is a system which would not be morally justifiable even if it made society safer. Studies, however, have not shown any effect on reducing crime, with the former child inmates potentially ending up more likely to commit repeat offenses. Kids should not be in jail. Our system must be changed.
any of their childhood in probably the worst possible place for children. Regardless of whom you consider an adult, you will run into the problem of underage people committing crimes that seem too severe to have been committed by children. Think about this for a moment: we as a
Benjamin Szanton is a freshman in the College of Arts & Sciences. He can be reached at benjamin.szanton@wustl.edu.
15
political review | international
isil: explained Joe Lenoff | Illustration by Margaret Flatley
I’ve heard them referred to as ISIL and ISIS. Which is it?
to be Muhammad’s one true successor on Earth.
reestablishment of the caliphate on June 30,
A caliph is the recognized leader of all Muslims,
2014, and President Obama announced the
regardless of sect. He is the embodiment of the
commencement of US operations against ISIL
ISIL is short for the Islamic State of Iraq and
institution of Islam. The caliphate represents the
on August 7, 2014.
the Levant. ISIS is short for the Islamic State of
extent of his influence.
Iraq and Syria. The difference, of course, is in
What are ISIL’s goals?
the words “the Levant” and “Syria”. Both come from different translations of the Arabic word
Where does ISIL come from?
al-Shams. Traditionally al-Shams has referred to
According to translations of speeches by the
“Greater Syria”, or the land that was politically
Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi was not always ISIL’s
Middle East Research Institute and analysis
dependent on Damascus. Nowadays, we call
leader. Abu Musab al-Zarqawi originally led the
by Foreign Affairs’ Robin Simcox, ISIL’s goals
this territory the Levant, a region that includes
Arab branch of Ansar al-Islam, a radical militant
consist of four-steps of progressive domination:
Syria, Lebanon, Jordan, Israel, and the Palestinian
Kurdish separatist group. He then moved this
(1) Declare a caliphate. (2) Consolidate
territories. When Middle Eastern states were
organization to Al Qaeda in Iraq (AQI) and
authority in regions under ISIL control to create
created after World War I, Damascus’ land was
became its leader. He was able to turn AQI into
a solid base and state-like foundations (ISIL is
limited to the state of Syria, so the contemporary
a ferociously effective terrorist organization in
currently in this phase). (3) Take all Muslim
term al-Shams refers only to Syria. Use of ISIL
the Iraqi civil war, but was killed by a US airstrike
lands, Sunni and Shia. (4) Conquer “Rome,” or
or ISIS depends if one prefers the traditional or
in 2006.
the Christian world.
contemporary translation.
AQI’s efficacy was the result of gruesome tactics
The energy that ISIL once put forth into gaining
I prefer ISIL for two reasons. One is that the
and brutality. Public executions and crucifixions
territory is now being used to enforce strict
group’s overarching ideological objective is to
of those who did not pay AQI allegiance were
laws on piety and religious affairs and to spread
recreate a perceived political situation from
among the more heinous of these tactics. Public
propaganda in the lands they control. In these
more than a millennium in the past, when al-
backlash against these brutal tactics prompted
lands, ISIL is beginning to establish state-like
Shams would have meant the Levant, and not
AQI’s new leader, Abu Ayyud al-Masri, to rebrand
institutions—they are regulating transportation
just Syria. The other reason is that the group is
the organization as the Islamic State of Iraq (ISI).
and energy, educating children, and offering
expansionary, seeking to eventually control the
Continued public unrest, along with American
pensions to ISIL bureaucrats and soldiers. Simply
entire Levant (and beyond), and does not limit
airstrikes on ISI leadership, weakened the militants
put, ISIL is establishing these institutions to
its objectives to the two contemporary states
until 2011, when the Syrian crisis escalated and
create a base of operations for the third and
that the name ISIS implies.
ISI, now under al-Baghdadi, rebranded themselves
fourth phases of its expansionary plan.
again as ISIL.
Why not just IS? As much as ISIL would prefer for the ISIL/ISIS debate to be null and for the rest of the world to respect their request to be referred to simply as the Islamic State, or IS, ISIL is not a state. Many conditions must be met before they can be considered a state. One of the most important of these conditions is international recognition. No state, Islamic-majority or otherwise, has recognized ISIL’s legitimate sovereignty over the lands it occupies.
is not seeking to strike Europe or the United
with the Al Qaeda brand, Al Qaeda sought to
States any time soon. However, this is not to
combine ISIL’s political and military efforts with
say that ISIL does not seek to eventually strike
another Al Qaeda affiliate, Jabhat al-Nusra.
Europe or the United States. In an interview
This effort failed, and resulted in the outright
with NBC’s Chuck Todd, President Obama said
disavowal of ISIL from Al Qaeda early in 2014.
“we’ve not seen any immediate intelligence
There are reports that Al Qaeda disavowed
about threats to the homeland from ISIL.”
ISIL because they were “too horrid even for
The President went on to state: “In the more
Al Qaeda”. The source of that supposition is a
immediate term, it’s an imm-- it’s a threat to
letter written from Al Qaeda leadership to ISIL
friends, partners in the region and is causing all
leader al-Baghdadi, but this source has not been
kinds of hardship.” Note his hesitation to use the
confirmed as legitimate.
term “immediate” to describe ISIL’s threat to the
In summer 2014, ISIL determined the time was appropriate for a military pivot back
What is a caliphate? On June 30, 2014, ISIL declared that it had reinstated the caliphate with ISIL’s leader, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, as caliph. To be caliph means
16
Understanding this process shows us that ISIL
Since ISIL was, at this point, still affiliated
to Iraq and a seizure of Sunni lands. After minimal resistance from Iraqi forces, ISIL took many towns, fortifications, and highways linking Sunni lands in Iraq. ISIL announced the
United States’ friends and partners. It is “more” immediate than it is to “the homeland,” but it is not immediate in and of itself. Immediately— currently— ISIL is consolidating. ISIL will then move to strike friends and partners, and then to Europe and the USA.
political review | international
Where does ISIL get their money and military equipment?
with local communities, will be necessary in addition to the air power the United States is
Joe Lenoff is a senior in the College of Arts & Sciences. He can be reached at joseph.lenoff@wustl.edu.
providing. The United States is quick to point Initially, ISIL received most of their funding from
out that this ground aspect of counterterrorism
wealthy hardliners in Qatar, Bahrain, and Saudi
will be provided by Iraqi and Arab allies, and not
Arabia. Eventually, these governments were
by US troops.
pressured to cut off this flow of funds, and ISIL was forced to find other means to support itself. When ISIL forces re-invaded Iraq, their reputation preceded them and they were largely unopposed. Since the US invasion of Iraq and the purging of Saddam Hussein’s Ba’ath party, the Iraqi military has been largely Shia and has been uninterested in defending Sunni lands. The Iraqi military simply turned and ran from many forts and communities, leaving behind USprovided military equipment and, in some cases, large amounts of US cash. ISIL has also captured many oil wells, and they smuggle this oil through the porous TurkishSyrian border. The oil is then sold on the Turkish black market. Before US airstrikes, ISIL was averaging around $2 or $3 million per day from oil sales. The US has singled out these oil wells in its airstrikes, and has significantly hampered production, from an estimated 80,000 barrels a day to about 20,000 barrels. This is still a significant amount of income, and the US is currently working with Turkey to crack down on their black market.
How strong is ISIL really? The CIA estimates that ISIL has anywhere from 20,000 to 31,000 rank and file troops. This does not include supporters or bureaucrats. One of the things that makes ISIL dangerous is the international character of its armed forces. Radical Islamists from around the world, mainly Tunisia and Saudi Arabia, have come to Syria and Iraq to fight under the ISIL flag. Some are also coming from Europe, and a few from the United States. There is a fear that the international mobility of ISIL recruits from abroad will be a major avenue for ISIL’s global terrorism campaign. Also, ISIL is not a standard military. There are no ISIL uniforms, and ISIL fighters cannot be deterred by traditional military tactics. Counterterrorism tactics, requiring extended commitments on the ground and intensive work
17
political review | Justice
cruel and usual Samuel Klein | Illustration by Ezekiel Saucedo
I
n a harshly lit room, a physician, an employee
row. His death by bullets was
of the state, twists open three valves in
seamless, his pain minimized
sequence. Lethal chemicals, often from an
and his likely mental anguish
undisclosed source, rush down narrow plastic tubing into the veins of a condemned inmate. Within a few minutes, the inmate’s heart stops beating, leaving the body of the vicious criminal motionless, and perhaps creating a sense of closure for those close to the victim. This is the process used in the United States to execute
fleeting. The death penalty exists as a relic of the Hammurabian “eye for an eye” mentality that has been abandoned by most developed nations. However,
death row inmates. Usually it works.
these countries hold critical
For many in the United States, lethal injection
global trade network, and for
can absolve the possible feelings of guilt
a while provided the drugs
surrounding the use of capital punishment; it
used in lethal injections. In
is much easier on the conscience to conduct
2011, pharmaceutical giants
executions silently through a sterile needle than
Hospira and Lundbeck ceased
via hanging, electric chair, or firing squad. In
exporting sodium thiopental
theory, it’s an ideal process—one or multiple
and pentobarbital, two standard
drugs will, in order, knock out the inmate,
elements in the U.S. prison
tranquilize his muscular system, and ultimately
euthanasia cocktail. The former
induce cardiac arrest. But in practice, lethal
corporation is American but
injection often doesn’t work as intended—and
produced sodium thiopental in
the consequences can be disastrous.
Italy, while the latter is Danish.
In the past six months there have been two high-profile lethal injection executions in the United States that have been botched. Joseph Rudolph Wood III, an Arizona double-murderer, struggled for air for the last two hours of his life in July. Just a few months earlier, Oklahoma inmate Clayton Lockett’s execution was stopped after he began to physically struggle on the gurney. Lockett eventually died within an hour of being injected with the drugs. The details of his struggle are gruesome and horrifying. Last moments lasting hours? Gasping on the gurney? Such unintended but disturbingly frequent side effects of lethal injection violate the most fundamental human rights. A nearly instantaneous death by firing squad would be preferable to the unreliable and convoluted mechanism of lethal injection currently employed; perhaps that’s why infamous killer Ronnie Lee Gardner elected to die by firing squad in Utah in 2010. Despite the firing squad no longer being an option for newly convicted felons, Gardner was grandfathered into the option thanks to his 25-year tenure on death
18
positions in the United States’
Later that year, the European Union prohibited all exports of lethal injection drugs, including some that have other medical benefits. Pennsylvania, Texas, Oklahoma, and other states have been under fire for replacing these international sources of sodium thiopental and pentobarbital with undisclosed providers whose standards and reputations are unknown to the public. In
the upcoming decades, they will need to ensure that their methods place the human rights of the inmate over bureaucracy and politics.
the case of Lockett’s execution, the latter drug
We live in a country where we kill our worst
was replaced with midazolam. The new drug
criminals, and we do it in a manner that makes
failed catastrophically as a sedative. Inmates like
bullets to the heart seem humane. If states are
Lockett are being executed with chemicals of
to continue their policies of execution, they
unknown origins and untested effects.
must establish high standards for transparency
Ironically, the extensive efforts of acquiring complex drug cocktails have caused more undue suffering than many conventional poisons would. It is an attempt to ease the consciences of the living that is causing executions to go
and oversight in the process, from the source of the drugs to ensuring their efficacy to the injection itself. Or perhaps the US should do what it should have done long ago—ban the practice of capital punishment once and for all.
wrong, and the system is simply unsustainable. If the 38 states that still impose capital punishment plan on continuing such policies in
Samuel Klein is a freshman the College of Arts & Sciences. He can be reached at klein.s@wustl.edu.
political review | Justice
Mayor Slay chooses love over law Lindsey Wanberg
I
n late June, despite clear laws banning
Koster demonstrates legalistic sentiment
itself is a convincing argument that Slay’s
same-sex marriage in Missouri, the mayor
when he explains that his “duty… is to defend
actions were just. St. Louis Public Radio posted
of St. Louis, Francis Slay, married four
the laws of the state of Missouri.” According
a video of one of the couples, John Durnell and
same-sex couples in his office. When Attorney
to the philosophy of legalism, when Slay
Richard Eaton. In the video, the song “Stay”
General of Missouri Chris Koster heard of
broke the law he endangered civil order. The
by Rihanna swelled as the couple (looking
the marriages he was not pleased. Koster is
United States government was established to
stylish in checkered and striped bowties) sat
a public supporter of same-sex marriages,
make ethical rules based on a representative
on a couch together to discuss their thoughts
but firmly opposes Mayor Slay’s violation of
opinion. As soon as executives start ignoring
before the ceremony.
state law. In a statement issued on June 26,
the law and therefore representative opinion,
2014, Koster declared, “While I personally
the government changes from serving
support the goal of marriage equality, my duty
the good of the people to the good of the
as Attorney General is to defend the laws
executive. Cue the Hobbesian chaos.
to experience would happen ever. You know,
The drawback of legalism, however, is that
his voice broke. He chuckled and gestured to
the rules one must uphold can be “static” and
his face, which was slowly losing composure.
dated. In other words, they are unaffected by
“Damn, I had that under control.”
of the state of Missouri… Missourians have yet to change their constitution [to legalize same-sex marriage]... such vital questions cannot be decided by local county officials acting in contravention of state law.” Koster sued the City of St. Louis the day after the weddings and asked for the cancellation of the
special circumstances and changing public opinion, and therefore may no longer be effective when exercised. The only way to
newlyweds’ licenses.
change laws requires venturing through the
Surprisingly, this conflict is not about two
Slay’s plan to illegally marry the couples was
politicians butting heads over the definition
meant to speed up the process, thrusting a
of marriage—both Slay and Koster agree
same-sex marriage case into the state courts.
that same-sex couples should be allowed
In a press conference Slay stated, “We have
convoluted processes of democracy. Mayor
“We have created a clear, direct legal challenge to Missouri’s unconstitutional ban on marriage equality. We hope to get this before the courts to settle this issue on behalf of all gay and lesbian people in our state.” — Mayor Francis Slay of St. Louis
Durnell spoke thoughtfully. “I would have never thought in my life that what we’re going just that we’d ever get married.” At this point,
The video then cut to Durnell and Eaton’s wedding ceremony. The pastor mentioned the marriage was confirmed on behalf of Mayor Slay and the City of St. Louis. The couple kissed, and it was made official. At least for now. The newlyweds’ licenses have not yet been
created a clear,
revoked, but it is possible they will be when
direct legal challenge
Koster’s case against the City of St. Louis
to Missouri’s
reaches the courts. This though, is unlikely.
unconstitutional
Public opinion has changed drastically since
ban on marriage
the 2004 Missouri amendment was passed
equality. We hope to
to keep marriage between a man and a
get this before the
woman. It is possible that when the case does
courts to settle this
come up, the justices, reacting to growing
issue on behalf of
public support and recent court rulings, will
all gay and lesbian
strike down the marriage amendment in the
people in our state.”
Missouri constitution. Then finally, Slay and
Sharon Carpenter,
Koster will both get their way.
to marry. Instead, they disagree over what
the Recorder of Deeds for St. Louis, explained
constitutes justice in government. Koster
that because many states have recently
believes one must follow the law or go through
declared their own same-sex marriage bans
the established processes to change the law.
unconstitutional (Utah and Indiana happened
In contrast, Slay, as evidenced by his actions,
to do this the same day of St. Louis’s same-
believes it is legitimate to bypass laws if
sex weddings) it was an ideal time to test if
those laws are unjust. So is Koster’s legalistic
Missouri would follow suit. “It is time to show
thinking or Slay’s moralistic thinking preferable
that the people of St. Louis support equality
in a government?
and will fight for it,” she said.
Western legalism pushes the idea that
The four same-sex couples’ happiness after
following the law is the most ethical option.
their weddings was undeniable, and this in
Lindsey Wanberg is a freshman in the College of Arts & Sciences. She can be reached at lindsey.wanberg@ wustl.edu.
19
political review | Justice
Slaves for the World Cup Min Heo
H
osting the World Cup is the envy of many nations,
and countries around the world vie to be the next host for one of the largest global sporting events. But what is left out of the public eye when such large events occur is the challenge of preparing event infrastructure. Specifically, the majority of observers and fans ignore the workers who bear the burden of erecting the structures that allow millions of people worldwide to enjoy the game. For example, eight workers were killed during construction of the stadiums for the 2014 World Cup in Brazil, six more than were killed in preparation for the 2010 World Cup in South Africa. It is an outrage that workers are sacrificed in the construction of athletic facilities, and their deaths should make us wonder why there was so little objection from the public. The human rights problems in South Africa and Brazil are small, however, compared to the tragedy of workers’ rights in the construction of stadiums for the 2022 World Cup in Qatar. The Guardian has predicted a death toll of 600 construction workers each year in Qatar, which translates to a total of almost 4,000 fatalities by 2022. The Guardian also reported that a 1.2-million person workforce consisting mostly of Nepalese and Indian migrant workers currently toil in 122-degree heat in Qatar. An additional million workers will be brought in as preparations for the World Cup continue. In addition to harsh conditions, workers earn as little as £4.9 ($7.90) a day. Many have their passports confiscated to prevent them from leaving Qatar.
20
How can the world turn a blind eye to the
Certain measures need to be taken to ensure
fact that, in an age of acute awareness of
that while people get to enjoy the pleasure
human rights issues, the abhorrent working
of the game, no one gets left behind in the
conditions for workers in certain parts of the
process. FIFA has clearly been derelict in this
world are almost completely ignored? This
duty. FIFA has failed to take any measures
brings us to a much larger question about
as of yet to either relocate the 2022 World
modern day sports. Sports in all parts of the
Cup or to ensure the safety of workers in
world have become massive markets, and
Qatar. The number of violations in Qatar
soccer has had a particularly powerful reach.
are unprecedented and FIFA need to take
Walk around every major city in the world
a firmer stance on this outrage, not only
and you will see people wearing national team
for the sake of the workers, but also for the
jerseys, club jerseys, or other forms of soccer
integrity of international sportsmanship. The
clothing in support of their favorite team.
2016 Summer Olympics in Rio de Janeiro are
Today, we hire experts just to analyze the
coming up, and they present another threat
statistics of players and their transfer value.
to worker rights. FIFA should take a stand to
The soccer economy is huge, and certain
show that sports games should not involve
clubs have more money than small nations.
the sacrifice of human lives.
While we shouldn’t necessarily condemn the large revenues that sports clubs receive, we must realize that the thrill of sports games has perhaps blinded us to what goes on behind the scenes. Sports are a great form of entertainment, but when audience enjoyment is supported by the degradation of human rights, sports lose their value.
Min Heo is a freshman in the College of Arts & Sciences. He can be reached at minheo51@gmail.com.
political review | Justice
No Justice for “Comfort Women” Samuel Leiter
D
uring the Second World War, the
awaiting justice as politicians wrangle
War II. Compensating a group of people
Imperial Japanese Army adopted
over issues of culpability.” Women now in
is not unprecedented, and the distinction
a policy that forced somewhere
their eighties and nineties have demanded
between a group of people that does not
between 200,000 and 300,000 women into
reparations from both South Korea—which
constitute a nation and a group of people
prostitution. These women came from both
collaborated with the Japanese during the
that does (i.e. Israel) is fairly arbitrary. The
Japan and the nations conquered by Japan
Japanese occupation and the Americans
decision against the Filipino women in 1998
during World War II, including Korea and
during the American occupation—and Japan,
followed a decision earlier in the year that
China. In 2007, the current prime minister of
which used its army to force women into
granted three comfort women the right to
Japan, Shinzo Abe, denied that Japan coerced
prostitution. However, these women have
an apology and reparations—the closest any
women into prostitution, contradicting the
so far been unsuccessful, despite serious
comfort women have come to receiving just
Kono Statement of 1993, which admitted
concerted efforts. For example, in 2008
compensation. But these women did not
that the Imperial Japanese Army had been
several NGOs worked together to create a
receive compensation, as a Hiroshima high
involved in forcing huge numbers of women
case for 122 South Korean women who filed
court struck down their case in 2001.
into prostitution during the war. There has
a lawsuit for 100 million dollars against the
been a recent shift in Japan towards a more
South Korean government because of their
abrasive and nationalistic tone as tensions
mistreatment in the decades following the
with China grow. This tone not only harms
Korean War. This case has not yet been
Japan’s position internationally, but is
decided, but is expected to go to trial soon.
completely dismissive of international law
If past attempts by comfort women to get
Thousands upon thousands were killed, tortured, and punished by their own governments because they were forced to be comfort women by an occupying power. Despite numerous attempts at justice, they
and human rights. By refusing to acknowledge comfort women, Japan is ignoring the fact that these were real women who lost their lives or suffered immensely due to forced prostitution. The treatment of these women varied, but
“The treatment of these women varied, but was often barbaric—survivors reported that those who got sick, pregnant, or exhausted were killed.”
was often barbaric—survivors reported that those who got sick, pregnant, or exhausted were killed. The murder of
some sort of justice are any measure by which to predict the outcome the lawsuit,
have yet to receive any compensation for their suffering. The Abe administration
though, its success appears unlikely.
has added insult to injury by refusing to
girl being buried alive, and another being
A similar case was struck down in 1998 by
Even if the 122 women suing the South
sexually tortured until she died. Those
a Japanese judge, and 46 Filipino women
Korean government today are successful in
who did survive were often traumatized,
forced into sexual slavery during World War
their lawsuit, little justice will be served to
infertile, or afflicted by sexually transmitted
II were denied justice. One Filipino woman
the thousands of women whose lives were
diseases. After the war, former comfort
broke down in tears as she recounted her
destroyed by violence and the stigma of
women were treated terribly by their own
story of being forced into sexual slavery at
forced prostitution.
countries. One Chinese comfort woman was
the age of 13 to a room full of reporters. The
sentenced to 17 years of hard labor for being
case was dismissed because, according to
a collaborator, and this type of treatment
the judge, international law does not provide
was not uncommon.
for individual claims of compensation
these women was often brutal beyond belief. Survivor accounts include one teenage
Although World War II may seem like a bygone era, the experience of comfort women is still a contentious issue today. As the Wall Street Journal reported, a “dwindling group of surviving comfort women in South Korea, China and other countries are still
acknowledge such atrocities ever occurred.
against a former occupying country. While this is technically true, it does not change the injustice of the situation. Additionally, though individuals have not received compensation by occupying powers, nations have. Most famously, Israel received reparations from Germany after World
Samuel Leiter is a freshman in the College of Arts & Sciences he can be reached at sjleiter@wustl.edu.
21
political review | international
The Progression (and Regression) of the Status of Women in India E Katherine Surko | Illustration by Alex Chiu ver since the brutal gang rape that occurred
against women. Some individual regions of
desperately needed is a shift in India’s (and the
two years ago in Delhi, the status of women
India have taken their own stance against the
world’s) attitude towards women.
in India has been making international
growing sexual violence problem. For example,
headlines. There have been protests scattered
many schools in Mumbai now have a curriculum
across the country demanding more laws to
that teaches students the difference between
protect women and stricter punishments for those
a “good touch” and a “bad touch.” Other parts
who break them. Women’s issues have made
of the country, however, have adopted a more
it into the political campaigns of the country’s
regressive approach. Last year, the Indian media
leaders, an unprecedented step forward. But for all
reported that the state of Uttarakhand passed
this talk of change, has any progress been made?
a law that forces working women in the public
Prime Minister Narendra Modi is one of many politicians with something to say on the status of women in India. He appears to be progressive in his views, and has made many public statements during his election campaign regarding the country’s problems with sexual assault. During his first Independence Day speech as Prime Minister, Modi asks parents to watch out for their sons, because “after all, the rapist is also
and private sectors to stop working after 6 pm. Due to an extreme public backlash, however, the state’s chief minister denied that such a law had ever been passed, according to The Guardian. The ultimate redaction of the law is a good sign, but the fact that it was even implemented in the first place indicates a disconnect between the leaders making the decisions and the women who are affected by the assaults.
someone’s son.” His willingness to talk about the
New laws have been enacted in the past couple
issue and not just blame the victim provides a
years to prevent sexual assault, such as a law
huge contrast to comments from politicians like
enacted in March 2013 that criminalizes stalking
Mulayam Singh Yadav from Uttar Pradesh, who
and sexual harassment and enforces a death
says that “Boys will be boys, they make mistakes.”
penalty for repeat offenders and for rapes that
Modi’s progressive attitude bodes well for a country with few measures in place to prevent and prosecute sexual assault. According to the Associated Press, a rape occurs every 22 minutes
lead to the victim’s death. Marital rape, however, is still not prosecutable under Indian law, so there are further strides that need to be made within the legal code. While the new laws being enacted to protect women certainly represent progress,
The prevalence of sexual assault in India reflects misogyny deeply ingrained in society. Prejudice against women starts before birth, with sexselective abortion. This has contributed to a growing uneven gender distribution in India, where there are about 918 girls for every 1000 boys under the age of six. An Indian government report states that of all the children kept out of school, 62% are female; women account for two thirds of India’s illiterate population. Modi acknowledges the issue of high female school drop-out rates, and has talked about improving the country’s education system. During his Independence Day speech, he mentioned an initiative to install bathrooms in schools and communities across the country. According to the World Bank, about 53% of households use public areas and streets as bathrooms. This is especially problematic for women, as it creates an opportunity for sexual assault. Further, a lack of privacy can create embarrassing and stressful situations, especially during a woman’s menstrual period. UNICEF reports that in countries where menstruation is a taboo topic, girls in puberty miss an average of 20% of the school year. One of the major reasons
the effectiveness of these laws is questionable.
for these absences is that young girls do not have
reported, and of those four, only one results in
In fact, in between 2006 and 2011, there has been
hygiene products. Simply installing bathrooms
a conviction.
a 25% increase in the number of reported rapes
in schools and communities across the country
in India, and the National Crime Record Bureau
could thus yield significant improvements in
reports a 7.1% increase in crimes against women
female attendance.
in India, and according to the National Crime Record Bureau, only four out of ten rapes are
Many people blame the prevalence of sexual assault on an indifferent police force. This summer, two young girls were kidnapped in Uttar Pradesh, and when family members reported the crime to the police, they allegedly refused to investigate. The two girls were later found raped and hanged. These stories are unfortunately common, and have led to public outrage. Indian politicians have spoken out, critiquing the inaction of police officers. The majority BJP party has declared a zero-tolerance policy towards violence
22
since 2010. While this could simply mean that more rapes are being reported, it is unlikely that a 25% uptick in reports is entirely due to a change in reporting behaviors. It is critical that India take swift action now to remedy what appears to be a growing epidemic of violence towards women. Laws to protect women don’t necessary translate directly into a decrease in sexual violence. While changing the laws is certainly important, what is
access to a private space to change their feminine
In the past year, the government has also begun to focus on workplace gender disparities. By this October, all Indian companies are required to have at least one female board member, a sign that attitudes towards women are changing. The fact that Indian businesses are having trouble finding enough qualified women is discouraging, and points back to inequalities that begin at birth. The lack of women qualified to fill such jobs
political review | international
indicates that more attention should be paid to
make up only 43% of India’s total population.
keeping girls in school, and not just those girls
These entrenched inequalities between classes
who come from wealthy families and can afford a
and ethnicities create a culture of hostility,
private education.
tension, and anger between different
If India wants to increase its power on the world stage, it is crucial that it focus on domestic gender inequalities. The International Labor Organization reports that India’s female labor participation rate is only 29%, which, according to The Atlantic, has cost India about $900 billion over the past decade. If India had brought more women into the workforce during the past decade, its economic growth could have jumped from 7.7% to 11.6%. It is thus the best interest of India’s leaders to prioritize women’s rights, if only for the benefits that increased gender equality would
parts of the population, which only exacerbates violence against women. If India were to focus further on providing a good education to all of its citizens, then the early seeds of gender inequality could be addressed. If the leaders of India intend to keep their promises about improving the status of women in the country, then it is crucial that they focus on the root of these inequalities and prioritize the education of women and girls.
bring to the economy. It will take more than changes in the law and a handful of public speeches to make a difference in India’s gender problems. Policy makers need to
Katherine is a freshman in the College of Arts & Sciences. She can be reached at surkokatherine@gmail.com.
take a look at the root causes of violence against women: deeply ingrained inequalities that begin even before birth. The best way to enact positive change would be to put more of an emphasis on the public education system, and to focus on addressing broader social mentalities. Modi’s talk of change in the school system is a good sign, but it is time for those words to be turned into action. Right now, India’s government schools are overcrowded and not particularly effective. Teachers are not always qualified, do not always show up, and are frequently overwhelmed by large class sizes. About 40% of primary schools have more than 30 kids per classroom, 60% do not have electricity, and about 21% of teachers are not professionally trained (RTE Forum). Wealthier families can send their kids to private school, but many are stuck with government sponsored schools with statistics like those stated above. Right now, according to a report conducted by the Indian government, two thirds of students not enrolled in school belong to minority populations, even though minorities
23
political review | NATIONAL
A CHAT WITH mirpuri of
24
political review | international
AMBASSADOR singapore
Aaron Christensen | Illustration by Alex Chiu
O
n September 11, Ashok Kumar Mirpuri,
“Being a very small island state, we had to
However, Ambassador Mirpuri supports
Singaporean Ambassador to the US
have a very strong sense of the world,” Mirpuri
American involvement in the Asia-Pacific region
since 2012, came to campus to speak
explained. “We are very much at the hub of the
and does not fear that an increased American
at the invitation of WUPR and the Singaporean
Asia Pacific region, Southeast Asia and the Asia
focus on Asia means ignorance of the rest of the
Students Association. Having previously served
Pacific region. And that’s really given us the
world.
as the Ambassador to Indonesia and the High
ability to play a role with our neighbors.”
Commissioner to Malaysia and Australia,
“Looking ahead to the future . . . the Asia-Pacific is
Considering its size, Singapore has been
where the US future is going to be. It is not to the
surprisingly active in the international community.
detriment of your relationships with Europe and
Ambassador Mirpuri is particularly proud of
the Middle East. The US is a global superpower,
Singapore’s sponsorship of the economic and
and I think that everyone expects that there is
political regional bloc ASEAN, the Association of
sufficient attention to cover all these areas, and
America’s presence in East Asia.
South-East Asian Nations. He envisions ASEAN
that is warmly welcomed.”
Singapore, a small island city-state located
could rival India and China.
One of the most controversial aspects of the
“We intend to announce the ASEAN Economic
Asia is the proposed “Trans-Pacific Partnership”
Community at the end of next year, 2015, and
(TPP). In essence, the TPP is a massive free-
that should help to pull the ASEAN countries
trade agreement between several different
together. Again, if you look at the whole Asia-
countries around the Pacific. The treaty is
Pacific geography, you have a very large growing
controversial in the United States, but Singapore
economic power in China, a very large growing
embraces and actively sponsors the treaty.
economic power in India. Southeast Asia
Ambassador Mirpuri suggested that objections
straddles these two powers…When we’ve pulled
to specific parts of the TPP must be addressed
together the ASEAN Economic Community, we’ll
through a long process of bilateral “adjustments,”
to advance their country:
have over 600 million people, a growing middle
some of them painful but necessary for economic
class, and an interest in connecting with the
growth.
“When we became independent in 1965, we
outside world.”
Mirpuri has extensive experience working with leaders around the Asia-Pacific region and in Washington. Before his talk, WUPR had the chance to sit down with Ambassador Mirpuri to discuss Singapore, Southeast Asia, and
on the southern tip of the Malay Peninsula, is one of the world’s greatest developmental success stories—since gaining independence in 1965, it has become a major business hub and an important player in regional politics. With its singular position, Singapore has also had a unique set of development challenges to overcome. Ambassador Mirpuri credited the nation’s success to the vision of the Singaporean leadership and the will of the Singaporean people
were a country without any resources. We had to buy water from Malaysia, with long-term agreements . . . We had to import all our energy; we had to import all our food . . . You speak of these circumstances and you realize how unique it is, not having water, energy or food, there’s no other country like that . . .And it has been a dramatic transformation, very dramatic, because of the leadership’s vision and the determination of the population.” Given Singapore’s status as a small country with much larger neighbors, diplomacy has always been of critical importance in ensuring the island’s independence and prosperity.
as a potential new economic power in Asia that
Obama administration’s increased outreach to
“I think that trade agreements, generally, are
Americans have been paying more attention to
very difficult to sell. Because there are always
Southeast Asia in recent years as foreign policy
adjustments… [the TPP] is going to be beneficial
observers write of the Obama administration’s
for some, many Americans, but some Americans
so-called “Pivot to Asia,” a renewal of
will have to make an adjustment. It’s how that
engagement with the Asia-Pacific region.
adjustment can take place, and I think that that’s
Ambassador Mirpuri, however, doubted whether
the way to solve it; to say [to Americans] that
the move was novel.
there will be lots of other opportunities that will
“From Singapore’s point of view, [US involvement
emerge out of this and that is important.“
in the Asia-Pacific] actually is not something
The full interview with Ambassador Mirpuri is
new… Since the Korean War and the Vietnam
available online at wupr.org.
War, the US has always been present…Whether it’s a Democratic administration or a Republican administration, they’ve always been there, and it’s something that the region has appreciated.”
Aaron Christensen is a sophomore in the College of Arts & Sciences. He can be contacted at aaronchristensen@wustl.edu.
25
political review | international
A Game of Lives C Reuben Siegman
an you imagine working for hours
problem. Brahim Ould M’Bareck Ould Med
was exacerbated by drought and poor
under the hot sun of the Sahara, only
El Moctar, a government official, said, “I
environmental conditions in the 1970s and
to not be paid? This is what life is
must tell you that in Mauritania, freedom
80s that caused some of the nomadic tribes
like as a slave in the Islamic Republic of
is total: freedom of thought, equality - of
in the north to move south. Because of the
Mauritania, a West African nation south
all men and women of Mauritania. Equality
power structure the French left behind, the
of Morocco. Mauritania is a nation of
for all people.” Government refusal to
Haratin, a group of Sub-Saharan Arabized
three and a half million people, 10-20% of
acknowledge slavery has led to a lack
people, became the lowest caste and the
whom are still enslaved, according to the
prosecution against slave owners. There
slaves of the Moors. Many other black
CIA World Factbook. This is the largest
has been only one prosecuted case, when
Africans became subject to government
enslaved population by percentage of any
Oumoulmoummine Mint Bakar Vall was
pogroms. This resulted in a peak of ethnic
country in the world. Indeed, according to
sentenced to only six months in jail. She
violence in 1989, and led to a forced exodus
a UN ranking, Mauritania’s enslavement
was convicted for having two children in
of the black Africans to Mali and Sengal,
rate is almost twice that of the second
slave-like conditions, which she denied.
while the government accepted Arab-
worst offender. Slavery in Mauritania was
She claimed to have treated them like
Islamic Maur and Tuareg refugees.
only abolished in 1981, and was not made
her own children and said the most they
a crime until 2007. While slavery was
did was housecleaning. This controversy
technically abolished decades ago, it wasn’t
generated major commotion in Mauritania,
a punishable offense until 2007.
resulting in multiple anti-slavery rallies, a few of which became violent and led to
Mauritanian slaves are often employed as farm laborers, and are also usually responsible for day-to-day tasks like tending to camels, finding and retrieving
activist arrests.
water, and serving families and guests
eventually led to Abdel Aziz’s election as
Mauritania has a very ethnically diverse
understand the concept of freedom and
president in the semi-democratic system
population. A third of the nation identifies
many people in the population are not
of government. In the years since, there
as being either Moorish or Berber Arab,
literate. In Mauritanian society, slaves are
have been multiple assassination attempts,
another third identifies as Black, and the
given as gifts, sent away, and forced to have
including one last October in which Aziz
rest of the population is of mixed heritage.
children who instantly become slaves. In
was shot. Many people still believe that
This dynamic, along with multiple historical
the process, families are often separated.
his election was fraudulent, and as recently
flows of immigration and emigration, has
Mauritanian politics have undergone rapid changes since a 2008 coup that
in their homes. Many slaves do not
created
“In Mauritanian society, slaves are given as gifts, sent away, and forced to have children who instantly become slaves. In the process, families are often separated.”
tension between the different ethnic groups and has been a driver
as August there were protests at the US-
for slavery. When Mauritania was part of
Africa Summit against his election. This
French West Africa, slavery was banned
“first of its kind” summit was supposed to
and there was a halt to fighting between
help strengthen the connections between
clans, even though most of the population
the US and African nations. However, the
remained nomadic. This was largely
Mauritanian government has not allowed
because various ethnic groups were
international organizations into the country
separated geographically under French rule.
out of fear that other nations might witness
When Mauritania gained its independence
the travesty of Mauritania’s modern slavery.
in 1960, everything changed. The French
The government led by Aziz and his administration has shown it does not care about addressing the issue of slavery, as it has been essentially ignoring the
26
Focusing on education could change popular attitudes toward slavery. Increasing the literacy rate and access to books would provide the, Mauritanian people with exposure to ideas of freedom, and thus change the views of both masters and slaves with respect to the slave system. Mauritania should thus increase its spending on education. Economic growth is also paramount. With a quarter of the country unemployed and 40% below the poverty line, there needs to be an improvement in the economy to enable the country to enact any meaningful change to the educational system.
left the power in the hands of the ArabBerber aristocracy. With Mauritania’s sudden independence, competition for resources and government power led to the collision of many groups. This conflict
Reuben is a freshman in the College of Arts & Sciences. He can be reached at reuben.siegman@wustl.com.
political review | National
Ice-Bucket Politicking I Xiaochang Song | Illustration by Andrew Kay
n a summer news cycle dominated by the
spent on malaria prevention efforts would
escalating conflict in the Middle East, the
provide 500 DALYs, mainly due to the
frightening Ebola epidemic in West Africa,
disproportionate impact of malaria on
and issues of race and power structures in
children. Malaria and other infectious
America, the millions of videos that graced our
diseases severely burden the economic
newsfeeds showing people pouring ice-cold
productivity of the populations that they
water on themselves proved to be a heart-
affect, thereby creating a vicious cycle
warming respite from the world’s turbulent
of poor health and poverty. Instead of
madness. And unless you were so inspired by
contributing to the vogue charity of the
your freshman year Writing 1 class reading of
day, let us all be more active in looking
“Walden,” that you hid out in a cabin as part of
for effective charities, and non-for-profits
“summer research,” then you are undoubtedly
that best do what they claim to do. Let us
familiar with the efforts to raise awareness for
fund existing infrastructures operating at
the ALS Association. The Facebook campaign
economies of scale, such as the Against
has been out-of-this-world successful,
Malaria Foundation and the Deworm the
raising over $100 million to fund research for
World Campaign, which benefit millions of
amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), a paralyzing
people worldwide.
disease that brings severe pain to those who suffer from it. Given all the goodwill that has gone into and come out of this campaign, even a slight critique of these efforts may seem crass—that is until this issue is looked at with biostatistics and through the lens of effective altruism, a social movement that seeks the best ways to exploit limited resources to better the
Even without considering this kind of opportunity cost analysis, we must realize the complacency and myopia that social media activism tends to produce. Social media campaigns promulgated through Facebook allow for multitudes of people to be involved with a cause at a superficial
world.
level. How many ice-bucket participants
Globally, ALS kills over 100,000 people
know what the acronym stands for? How
each year, while it is estimated that over
can any campaign to eradicate disease be
200 million people currently suffer from
truly successful and sustainable without its
infectious diseases such as tuberculosis
benefactors being invested in the day-to-
and malaria—77% of these cases affecting
day struggles and sufferings of the people
children under 5 years of age. Admittedly,
that it afflicts? The world of charitable
a ‘this kind of disease vs. that kind of
giving is one in which any donation leads
disease’ comparison can be convoluted
to an absolute net positive, but while every
and extremely difficult; do we make policy
human life is equal, every cause is not.
decisions simply based on the absolute
So, by all means, keep contributing to ALS
number of people affected by each disease?
research and clinical care funds. However,
Also, what kind of units could possibly
be careful of becoming myopic and
make suffering quantifiable? The DALY
sanctimonious, and instead keep looking
(Disability Adjusted Life Year), although
out for the causes that make the best use of
imperfect, is the most widely accepted
your time and goodwill.
could list a single symptom of ALS, or even
metric used by the World Bank and the World Health Organization in all major policy planning decisions, where 1 DALY is equivalent to one year of healthy life lost. According to the World Bank, Riluzole, the drug most commonly used to treat ALS, costs about $50,000 and is equal to about one DALY. This amount of money,
Xioachang Song is a junior in the College of Arts & Sciences. He can be reached at xiaochangsong@wustl.edu.
27
political review | NATIONAL
A Mile In Her Shoes Katelyn Taira | Illustration by Alicia Yang
detail the number of cases, alleged perpetrators,
the administration knew that police were
and disciplinary proceedings for each college
investigating a fraternity for reported gang rape,
campus; collect anonymous online surveys of
but allowed the organization to continue throwing
college students about their experience with
parties without informing the greater student
sexual assault and harassment each year; hire
population. At the University of California,
trained confidential advisors capable of assisting
Berkeley, several complaints allege that the
the victim with reporting the trauma; and fine
administration has discouraged victims from
institutions up to $150,000 for each violation
reporting and failed to inform them of their rights;
as well as up to 1% of its operating budget,
in the case of four particular women, a senior who
both penalties determined by the Secretary of
allegedly assaulted them was put on probation,
Education. This differs from the Clery Act, which
required to attend counseling, and was allowed to
outlined that schools in violation could lose all
graduate eight months after their report was filed.
federal aid, a punishment both unrealistic and impractical.
While the financial penalties may need to be
As Senator Kelly Ayotte, one of the sponsors of
right direction. Its goal to provide transparency
CASA, aptly puts it, “This bill has teeth. If schools
has garnered bipartisan support, especially in
ignore the clear guidelines, this bill lays out that
a time when universities value reputation over
there are consequences and that they will pay a
student well-being. Schools across the nation
stiff price.” The price, however, is the main point
have claimed that they are supportive of survivors
of contention with critics. The Office for Civil
through implementing Title IX offices and sexual
Rights would collect the 1% non-compliance
violence awareness events, but the dichotomy
penalty, thereby creating an incentive to find
between policy and action is palpable. While
potentially innocent universities and alleged
institutions like Columbia University have taken
he statistics are alarming. Nearly one
perpetrators guilty. Yet with nearly 80 schools
to slightly altering their sexual assault policies,
in five women on college campuses
under federal investigation for mishandling of
transparency is still vital. Emma Sulkowicz, a
nationwide will fall victim to rape or
sexual assault complaints, proactive measures
Columbia senior, said she was raped by a fellow
attempted rape over the course of their college
like those in CASA are entirely appropriate.
student and reported the crime to the school
careers; each academic year, for every 1,000
Missouri’s own Sen. Claire McCaskill, one of the
and police, but justice was never delivered. She,
women attending college, there are 35 accounts
main sponsors of CASA, recently published the
along with other survivors and supporters, have
of sexual assault. Reported cases of sexual
results of a survey about sexual violence on 236
taken to carrying her mattress around Columbia
assaults at colleges rose by 79 percent from
college campuses. According to her report, more
as a performance piece until the administration
2001 to 2012.
than 40% of schools have not conducted a single
expells and properly disciplines her rapist.
T
Findings like these have inspired waves of protest and indignation across the country. Students have organized rallies and Title IX campaigns, alumni
investigation in five years, 21% of schools provide no training to faculty and staff, and 31% provide no training for students.
slightly altered, CASA as a whole is a step in the
Of course one piece of legislation will not entirely erase sexual violence on college campuses, but it is one step closer to eradicating
have withheld donation checks, survivors have
These numbers are not merely statistics; they
victim-blaming and a lack of accountability.
come forward with their stories, and legislators
represent stories of people wronged by their
Universities should be focusing on the safety
have proposed new preventative and impactful
peers and administrations. Among the schools
and health of their students, not just on their
measures to curb sexual assault. Foremost
under investigation, the alleged crimes point to a
reputations. CASA forces schools to treat every
among proposed new legislation is the Campus
larger problem of administrative unaccountability.
case fairly and their students as people, not just
Accountability and Safety Act (CASA), aimed
At the University of Chicago, Olivia Ortiz was
PR problems. With measures like CASA, students
to make universities fully accountable for their
allegedly assaulted by her partner at the time.
will be empowered to fight this prevalent injustice
handlings of sexual violence cases. The bill is
The Dean of Students proposed an “informal
and to find safety for themselves, each other, and
progressive, featuring provisions that crack down
mediation” that brought together Ortiz and her
their schools.
on institutions to ensure that reports are not
assaulter to talk, which is not only damaging
ignored or mishandled. Among its key points,
emotionally and psychologically, but is in
CASA aims to increase cooperation between
direct violation of Title IX provisions. At Johns
academic institutions and local law enforcement;
Hopkins University, a complaint alleges that
28
Katelyn Taira is a freshman in the College of Arts& Sciences. She can be reached at ktaira@wustl.edu.
political review | National
Rick Perry and UT Lock Horns W Divya Walia | Illustration by Kat Bourek here I am from, no color has more
clear during the investigation of Regent
ended in 2011 when A&M moved from the Big
significance than burnt orange. It’s
Wallace Hall. Appointed to the UT Board of
12 to the SEC conference, but the remnants of
a distinct shade, one that could only
Regents by Perry in 2011, Hall is currently
this historical conflict will always remain. Many
represent the University of Texas at Austin,
under legislative investigation for violating
Austin insiders have playfully argued that
the educational and athletic pride and joy of
confidentiality laws in accessing unusually
Perry’s conflict with UT is a manifestation of
the Lone Star State. Besides the reputation of
large amounts of campus records and finding
the classic A&M inferiority complex, a way to
Longhorn athletics, the university boasts over
evidence that, under Powers’ leadership, “UT
finally level the playing field between his alma
52,000 students, 3,166 faculty members, and
knowingly and improperly counted over $215
mater and UT. Though it may seem ridiculous
over 10,000 professional staff members. Its
million in gifts.” Though lauded by Perry,
to claim Perry’s thoughts and actions regarding
research is among the most groundbreaking
Halls’ actions are seen by many powerful UT
UT were solely based on his memory of the
in the nation. Texas football is
Longhorn/Aggie competition, it is
one of the best-known college
important to remember that this is
programs and was valued at $805
Texas and the possibility of a sports
million in 2012. The school is also
rivalry bleeding into politics should
a cultural symbol of the state with
not be ruled out.
generations of families born and
Yet the story of the rocky relationship
bred under the Longhorn banner.
between Perry and UT raises some
Football games and tailgates create
larger issues. The prominence of
fanfare that lasts for days, drawing
central institutions such as UT is
crowds that rival, if not surpass,
part of what makes Texas great, and
major NFL teams. Its status as an
the research and innovation taking
elite school has given it prominent
place in Austin are also making the
alumni in every major Texas city.
state a better, more progressive
However, over the last several years,
place to live. Perry’s wish to provide
UT has been engaged in a vicious battle with Governor Rick Perry.
affordable education is not altogether
Perry, perhaps best known for
funding for UT does not come
his 2012 presidential run when
from the state; rather, it comes
he famously forgot the third
from outside research funding and
government agency he would
philanthropy, which provide $700
eliminate in a debate—don’t worry,
million per year and $300 million per
he has since redeemed himself
year, respectively. In fact, this year,
by wearing intelligence-affirming
only 13% of the university budget
glasses—has long believed that UT
came from state taxpayers. However,
should function as a trade school focused on providing affordable, efficient education rather than as a large research institution. In 2008, Perry hosted a higher education summit where he stated his wish to provide $10,000 four-year
misguided, but most of the research
supporters as part of a disturbing “witch hunt” against the existing university leadership and an attempt by the governor to project his vision for state education onto the Austin campus. In light of this controversy, Powers has announced
the actions of the governor and Regent Hall reflect Perry’s alarming desire to keep state education securely under his jurisdiction, which leads to the most important question: should state executives really be allowed to dictate the
his plans to resign next year.
purpose of educational institutions or should
teaching and research.” However, Perry’s plans
Rick Perry’s status as a graduate of Texas A&M
of the university? Perry’s less than savory
have been disputed, most prominently by Bill
only heightens these tensions. There is an
political drama suggests not, though the future
Powers, the current president of UT. Powers
age-old rivalry between A&M and UT, with
of UT’s management and direction still remains
has held firm on his stance that the extensive
A&M acting as the smaller, rural counterpart
uncertain. For now, however, Hook ‘Em.
research the university performs is what gives
to UT’s urban powerhouse. Since 1915, the
its degrees their high caliber.
football teams have faced off annually in a
degrees and create a system “rating professors based on student assessments and separating
The friction between Powers and Perry became
major statewide event, with the University of Texas leading the series 76-37. The rivalry
this be left up to the alumni and future students
Divya Walia is a freshman in the College of Arts and Sciences. She can be reached at dwalia@wustl.edu.
29
political review | NATIONAL
Who’s Gaining from Capital Gains? D Benjamin Compall | Illustration by Andrew Catanese uring the 2012 presidential election,
varies depending on the amount of annual
some. The average American does not
issues revolving around capital gains
income you make. The more money you
have the economic means necessary to
tax rates suddenly entered into public
make, the higher the percentage of your
capitalize on capital gains. In a recent
discourse. One event sparked this: then-
income is taxed. The logic behind this
study, the Tax Policy Center found that
presidential nominee Mitt Romney’s release of
formula is that if you have more money,
an astonishing 47% of profits derived
his tax forms, which showed that he only paid
you can afford to pay a little bit more of
from capital gains went to the top .01%
a tax rate of 14% on his income of nearly $14
that money in taxes. Despite the fact that
of American earners. How much goes to
million. For weeks this issue became ingrained
profiting off of capital gains is one of the
the bottom 80% of American earners? A
in many Americans’ political lexicons. However,
many ways that some Americans make a
miniscule 6%. Furthermore, for the top
when Romney lost the election and faded away
living, the tax rate for capital gains is not
1%, approximately 60% of their income
from public scrutiny, the debate over capital
taxed progressively. All capital gains are
is in capital form (including capital gains,
gains went with him. While the discussion
taxed at a 15-20% rate.
dividends, etc). What does this mean? Well,
seems to have ceased about as rapidly as it started, the issues at the heart of capital gains tax rates are no less pertinent to American life today. So what are these “capital gains” and what is it about the tax code that makes them
So let’s look at this closer. Say you’re a businesswoman who worked strenuously throughout your life to earn a living. As a result, you now make over $500,000 per
it seems that, by taxing capital gains at a far lower, comparatively un-progressive rate, the US government is selectively providing some Americans (the economic elites) with an enormous economic reward. I would
so contentious?
year. Your income now falls into the highest
Forbes defines capital gains as the process
as a result, you are taxed at a 39.6% rate
in which someone purchases a stock (or
(along with anyone else who makes over
makes an investment), and then later sells
$400,000 annually). Now that may sound
that stock for a different price; the money
like a big percentage. However, keep in
they gain or lose from this is a “capital
mind that the percentage you actually
gain.” This type of transaction is one way
pay will almost certainly lower. According
that many Americans, particularly those
to the New York Times, people whose
in the financial world, generate income.
income is placed in the highest quintile
Obviously there are myriad other ways
bracket usually pay an effective rate of
that people earn a living in this country.
20%, instead of the 39.6% rate for which
Whether you’re a waiter or a business
their income qualifies them. How do they
executive, a construction worker or a real
manage this? Tax deductibles (and the fact
estate mogul, a teacher or a sales rep,
that tax brackets operate on margins) allow
chances are you’re working very hard to
everyone to pay a lower effective tax rate.
The real reason that this debate is at all
earn a living. All of these people should pay
Tax loopholes and offshore sheltering play
relevant is that there is an ever-widening
their fair share of taxes to the government,
a role here, too. Now just imagine if you
gulf separating the elite Americans from the
regardless of their career, right? That seems
made a sizeable portion of your income via
rest. According to CNN Money, studies show
to be a fairly uncontroversial statement. So
investments. In that case, your initial tax
that the top 1% of American earners control
why is it, then, that in the current US tax
rate would be 20%. And those deductibles
approximately half of the nation’s wealth,
code, capital gains are taxed significantly
and loopholes we just talked about? Well
an enormous increase from the 1950s when
less than traditional “income”? Are people
those can help you to make that rate even
the bottom 90% of Americans accounted
who profit off of capital gains paying their
lower, too.
for 68% of the wealth. Income inequality is
fair share?
tax bracket on the progressive scale, and
So who are all these suckers not making
First, we should properly establish what
money from capital gains, and why don’t
“fair share” even means- for this in and
they start doing so already? Well, as it turns
of itself is often a point of contention. As
out, those profiting from capital gains are,
it relates to the income of nearly every
almost exclusively, the economic elites.
American, we as a country have decided
This makes sense, for in order to profit off
that “fair share” means a progressive tax
of capital gains one must, by definition,
rate. This means that the rate you are taxed
possess capital, or the means of acquiring
30
like to make it clear that I am not indicting wealthy Americans for having wealth, nor am I claiming that it is a negative thing to be wealthy. The capitalist way should encourage people to be successful and make money. Furthermore, I am not saying that the wealthy should be required to carry the entire country by paying an unreasonably high tax rate. I am suggesting, however, that the elite class of Americans that benefits from capital gains pay the tax rate that they already would be paying if they made that money through other means.
no myth, and it is affecting the lives of the vast majority of American citizens. Lower tax rates on capital gains are a catalyst for such inequality. Allowing the already tremendously economically advantaged to pay a smaller tax percentage on their capital-gains-earned-income consolidates their control over the nation’s wealth, and in turn, obstructs social mobility. While
political review | National
many Americans see this country as “the land of opportunity,” the supposedly fluid river of social mobility is slowly drying up. Today, America is less economicallymobile than Canada and much of Western Europe, and is roughly tied with Britain. We would be wrong to assume that capital gains are the only factor at play in creating these problems. However, capital gains do selectively provide the already economically advantaged with economic rewards and are a contributing factor to inequality and decreased social mobility. That should not be the American way. In an ostensibly egalitarian society the government has a responsibility to ensure equal opportunity. Therefore, the government must tax capital gains at the same rate as federal income tax. So why have we not done anything about this yet? Many pundits argue that raising taxes on capital gains, or taxing them more progressively, would negatively impact the economy and stifle economic growth. The Wall Street Journal echoed this in a recent article, stating: “Almost all economists agree… that keeping taxes low on investment is critical to economic growth, rising wages and job creation.” This is the single most pervasive argument against raising capital gains taxes. Though the argument seems economically logical (Econ 101 will tell you that taxing an activity disincentivizes people from doing that activity); in practice, the picture is less clear. According to a study conducted by the Congressional Research Service, a nonpartisan group run by the Library of Congress, “the reduction in the top tax rates appears to be uncorrelated with saving, investment and productivity growth.” Lowering the rate of capital gains tax does not negatively affect investment, nor does it benefit the lower or even middle classes. The beneficiaries are exclusively the wealthy elite. This does not have to be a partisan issue. In fact, looking closely at the actions of
recent administrations, you will see that
share of taxes on all of their income. It is
both sides are responsible for not acting
not that radical of a proposal. It is, also,
on capital gains taxes. Oddly enough, the
only the beginning. Americans must ask the
last time that capital gains tax rates were
question of how we can make investment
raised was in the 1980s during the Reagan
markets more readily available to the
administration. This policy placed capital
American middle class. How can we get
gains tax rates at the same rate as federal
more people involved in investing? Until we
income for top earners for the first time in
get there though, making sure the wealthy
decades. Since President Reagan left office,
investors who profit from capital gains are
tax rates for capital gains and income have
paying their fair share of taxes is a crucial
diverged. Income tax rates have increased,
first step in the right direction.
and capital gains tax rates have decreased (during both the Bush and the Clinton administration). It is clear that this is not a partisan issue; both Republicans and Democrats have raised and lowered capital gains tax rates at various times. Both parties can come together to help solve this problem. We can tax capital gains more progressively so that the elites whom benefit from them are paying a fairer
Benjamin Compall is a freshman in the College of Arts & Sciences. He can be reached at bcompall@yahoo.com.
31
political review | NATIONAL
Missouri’s Apathetic Approach to Gun Violence T Brady Schaer | Infographic by Simin Lim, Illustration by Alex Chiu his past year, Missouri Governor Jay
root. While it is not unreasonable to make
present in Missouri. Also, new laws passed
Nixon vetoed a bill that would have
schools ready to handle these emergencies,
have given more power to California’s
subjected federal officers to state
steps should also be taken to prevent
Department of Justice in order to lower the
criminal charges if they tried to enforce federal
them altogether. Such steps are noticeably
risk of gun violence. The Department of
gun control laws. Over the past few months, a
absent in the new legislation.
Justice has received more funding in order
new bill was introduced, which also received a veto from Nixon, but the veto was overridden this past September. The new bill, which will take effect in October, deals mainly with Missouri’s laws on concealed carry and the
The rest of Missouri’s new law turns in the other direction. First, the law changes the status of all issued concealed carry permits to qualify as open carrying permits;
open carry of firearms.
if someone is allowed to carry a gun in
First, the new law provides a new set of
walk down the street, even in crowded
training guidelines in order to instruct
areas. Additionally, the new law lowers the
teachers and other school workers on
minimum age to apply for a concealed carry
becoming “school protection officers.” Each
permit from 21 to 19, giving more people
“officer” will be trained to carry concealed
the opportunity to possess guns. Also, the
firearms and defense spray in school. The
law prohibits all local governments from
system will prepare schools for shooting
banning open carry, a law that had been in
incidents while also ensuring that faculty
place in Kansas City and parts of St. Louis.
members who can carry weapons are
So now local governments have no control
his bag, he can carry it in his hand as they
on the ubiquity of guns in their cities, even
safely trained. Had this law been in
though they are ultimately the ones who
place prior to tragedies such as
have to control their gun violence.
Columbine High School and Sandy Hook
Currently, Missouri holds the
Elementary
second highest gun homicide rate
School, far
per population of all states; between
less
2001 and 2010, more people died in Missouri as a result of gun violence than did US soldiers in both Iraq and Afghanistan. Gun homicide is a pervasive damage may have occurred. Still, the method of making schools more prepared to deal with shootings is largely similar to cutting a weed at its stem and not its
32
issue for Missouri, but the state has yet to implement a clear plan to combat it. Meanwhile, there have been other states that also struggle from high rates of gun homicide that have successfully combated it with stricter gun control: specifically, California struggles with the same type of gun violence as Missouri. California, since Sandy Hook alone, has passed ten laws that
to more efficiently keep track of the Armed Prohibited Person System, which tracks those who should not be allowed to possess firearms in a statewide manner. The Department of Justice can also increase the time of background checks to 30 days if the original ten-day span is not enough and extend the time someone is prohibited if they make a threat to a psychotherapist from six months to five years. These new laws are part of a widespread California effort spanning over the past 20 years to lower California’s gun homicide rate. Over 25 gun control laws have been passed in that period, including those that ban large capacity magazines, bans on assault-type weapons, and more effective ways to remove guns from felons and perpetrators of domestic violence. In the 20-year period, California gun deaths have decreased by over 50% and now California has a significantly lower gun homicide rate than Missouri. While there are other causes that could have also played a part in California’s drastic decrease in gun homicide, there is a strong correlation between the laws passed and the dropped rate. So Missouri has a fairly clear role model they could follow: California did something about their abnormally high gun homicide rate, and the gun homicide rate lowered. But it is up to Missouri’s legislators to decide if they want to try to fix it.
strengthen gun control. This includes laws that extend the requirement for firearm safety certificates to all gun purchases and not just handguns, something not
Brady is a freshman in the College of Arts & Sciences. He can be reached at bradyschaer@wustl.edu
GUN SAFETY IN CALIFORNIA NUMBER OF FIREARMSRELATED DEATHS IN CALIFORNIA
1993 POPULATION: 30 MILLION
political review | National
2010 POPULATION: 37 MILLION
5,500
2,935
deaths
deaths
WHAT CAUSED THIS DRAMATIC CHANGE?
BAN
Requirements of
SAFETY
on military-style weapons
in handgun design
ARMED AND PROHIBITED PERSONS SYSTEM (APPS) In response to “high profile murder cases involving people prohibited from owning firearms”.
California has passed over
300 ordinances since the mid-1990s including...
1,001 APPS cases in 2011
1,209 firearms seized
SOURCES:
firearms seized from
723 individuals
155,731 rounds of ammo seized
http://smartgunlaws.org/the-california-model-twenty-years-of-putting-safety-first/ https://oag.ca.gov/system/files/attachments/press_releases/n2521_apps_fact_sheet.pdf
99
Dept of Justice agents involved
2
grenades seized
33