®
The activist vision for western Wyoming: Few cattle, free-ranging elk, human restrictions Environmental advocates commenting on a U.S. Forest Service (USFS) proposal to reauthorize the Wyoming Game and Fish Department’s (WGFD) continued use of two elk feedgrounds located on National Forest lands are using the opportunity to propose systematic change in western Wyoming. Their vision eliminates all elk feedgrounds in favor of elk free ranging in the winter across broad swathes of Sublette, Lincoln and Teton counties; with elkproof fences erected around small winter feedlots for cattle which remain in the region and restrictions on human use of public lands during the winter. The federal land management agency would declare its authority to protect predators on federal land and would rely on wolves to control disease in wildlife populations. Public land cattle grazing would be reduced or eliminated, and the USFS would consider having livestock producers switch from running cow/calf operations to steers, or ship livestock out of the region for the winter and spring seasons. Background The Bridger-Teton National Forest (BTNF) is preparing a draft environmental impact statement for reauthorizing use of two elk feedgrounds in western Wyoming’s Sublette and Lincoln counties. The analysis will consider the impacts
“Lacking the ability to maintain these feedgrounds, WGFD would have been forced to drastically reduce the elk populations in this area. Should they have failed to do so, there would no longer be a viable cattle industry in northwestern Wyoming.” – Jim Magagna, Wyoming Stock Growers Association
South Park – Elk congregate along the Snake River on the South Park Feedground located near Jackson Hole. Cat Urbigkit photo
of the WGFD’s application to continue feeding elk at the Dell Creek Feedground near Bondurant and the Forest Park Feedground east of Alpine. Although the BTNF’s stated purpose of the analysis is to analyze the proposal to assure WGFD is “managing elk in a manner allowing the health of the land to be sustained and to meet the goals and objectives” of the forest plan, environmental activists want to stretch the scope of the analysis to encompass a much broader vision. Many of the comment letters submitted by environmental groups cited concerns for the spread of chronic wasting disease as
justification for closing the feedgrounds, while promoting the presence of wolves for disease control. The letters also cited other disease transmission risks, but respondents expressed little concern for the transmission of brucellosis to area cattle herds should the closures result in elk commingling with wintering cattle herds. Advocating closures A joint letter submitted by Wyoming Sierra Club, Wyoming Wildlife Advocates, Western Watersheds Project, Gallatin Wildlife Association, Jackson Hole Conservation Alliance, Yellowstone to Uintas Connection and Buffalo Roam Tours proposed immediate
closure of the Forest Park Feedground, phasing out feeding at Dell Creek within three years and starting the process of phasing out all feedgrounds on USFS lands. This “Sierra Club” letter took note of the high percentage of federal lands in western Wyoming, combined with its sparse human population to suggest the agency “allow elk to naturally free-range among their natural, healthier seasonal habitats throughout the region.” To maintain separation between brucellosisinfected elk and area cattle, the Sierra Club proposed alternatives such as “fence in the livestock with elk proof fences or con-
struct elk-proof fences to prevent elk from entering into private land where vulnerable livestock are pastured and allow elk to free range.” The letter advised, “Another way to separate elk from livestock is to ship the livestock to winter elsewhere.” A comment letter penned by John Carter of Bondurant of the Yellowstone to Uintas Connection, jointly with the Alliance for the Wild Rockies and Native Ecosystems Council, advocated the closure of all feedgrounds in western Wyoming. Carter, who also serves on the advisory board for the anti-grazing group Western Watersheds Project, took aim at livestock grazing in Sublette County, asking, “Why should the public have to lose its wildlife so a handful of livestock permittees can graze their cattle at great public cost? … There is a 100-year history of taxpayer subsidized feeding of elk to essentially protect livestock producers’ stored hay and reduce mixing of elk and cattle.” Carter also suggested
area landowners weren’t leaving enough forage for wildlife on their private lands, stating, “This comes down to an ethical issue in our mind. Not everything must be for profit.” He suggested the BTNF eliminate hunting and trapping of predators and scavengers within the national forest boundaries, writing, “We remind the USFS it has primacy over management on public lands and is a cooperating agency with the state of Wyoming, not its servant.” In addition, Carter said national forest officials should “get engaged with the state, Bureau of Land Management and private landowners to provide forage and migration for these animals on lands managed by other entities.” A joint letter from the Greater Yellowstone Coalition and the National Wildlife Federation suggested WGFD take action to reduce the number of elk in the Dell Creek area, noting, “Simply reauthorizing the feedground to allow more elk which are above objectives is not a Please see ELK on page B2
SitzAngus.com
20th Annual Jim Sitz (406) 683-5277 SitzAngus@gmail.com
Bob Sitz (406) 581-6448
SitzAngusRanch@gmail.com
Joe Jones (208) 670-2364 JoeJones@SitzAngus.com
SITZ Judicial 401H Reg: 19841993
S: SITZ Accomplishment 720F MGS: SITZ Upward 10559 CED 7 BW 2.4 WW 75 YW 133 SC 1.58 Claw 0.46 Angle 0.34 HP 13.0 Milk 30 CW 74 Marb 0.81 REA 0.89 $M 61 $B 186 $C 302
SITZ Angus Spring Bull Sale 12:30 pm, March 9, 2022 At the Ranch —Dillon, MT
Call for a sale book!
260 Yearling, PAP-Tested Angus Bulls, 78 PAP-Tested, 2-Year-Old Bulls 80 Open Commercial Replacement Females Selling sons of SITZ Resilient 10208, SITZ Accomplishment 720F, SITZ Stellar 726D, SITZ Barricade 632F, SITZ Profound 680G, Square B True North 8052, Connealy National 390C, Connealy Dry Valley
SITZ Impulse 732J Reg: 20010981
S: SITZ Resilient 10208 MGS: Woodhill Blueprint CED 12 BW 0.1 WW 86 YW 144 SC 1.32 Claw 0.55 Angle 0.54 HP 13.0 Milk 31 CW 67 Marb 0.68 REA 1.03 $M 75 $B 161 $C 284
SITZ True North 709J Reg: 20014255
S: Square B True North 8052 MGS: SITZ Stellar 726D CED 14 BW -1.7 WW 76 YW 136 SC 1.50 Claw 0.34 Angle 0.33 HP 11.9 Milk 31 CW 46 Marb 0.59 REA .73 $M 101 $B 130 $C 265
SITZ Accomplishment 713J
Reg: 20003659 S: SITZ Accomplishment 720F MGS: SITZ High Country 10011 CED 7 BW 0.9 WW 74 YW 131 SC 0.76 Claw 0.45 Angle 0.32 HP 21.3 Milk 30 CW 70 Marb 0.39 REA 0.64 $M 93 $B 150 $C 288