NEW HAVEN, CONNECTICUT · WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY 18, 2015 · VOL. CXXXVII, NO. 91 · yaledailynews.com
INSIDE THE NEWS MORNING EVENING
PARTLY SUNNY 29 SNOW 12
CROSS CAMPUS
HORIZONS “ICARUS” DEBUTS AT UNIV. THEATER
GO PHISH
NO TAX HAVEN
Yale ITS creates training program to prevent email phishing attacks.
INT’L STUDENTS DEAL WITH AN EXTRA COST.
PAGES 10–11 CULTURE
PAGE 3 UNIVERSITY
PAGE 3 UNIVERSITY
Participants are given an hour to solve a puzzle and escape the room. PAGE 5 CITY
Key to assault adjudication, barring contact difficult in practice BY VIVIAN WANG STAFF REPORTER
Remember that you are dust.
Shifting gears from Mardi Gras yesterday, today is Ash Wednesday. Saint Mary’s on Hillhouse Avenue and Saint Thomas More on Park Street will hold Mass and distribute ashes over the course of the day.
Last May, as seniors gathered at Myrtle Beach, South Carolina for their time-honored, week-long celebration before commencement, a female student and a male student found themselves a few feet away from each other on the beach. This encounter would have been just like any other that week — except that these two students were barred by the University from interacting with one another. Several months before, in February, the female stu-
Give it up. And with Ash
Wednesday comes the beginning of Lent, for which many students on campus will be making (small) sacrifices through Easter. Still, it could be a good opportunity for the non-religious to revisit their New Year’s resolutions and see how far a little self-restraint can go.
Like Humility. Faith-practicing or otherwise, Yalies would agree that human values are fundamental, wherever they might originate. Dipesh Chakrabarty, a professor from the University of Chicago, is on campus today to offer his thoughts on “Climate Change as Epochal Consciousness,” the initial of a three-part series of “The Tanner Lectures on Human Values” this week.
ESCAPE NEW HAVEN
dent had filed a formal complaint with the University-Wide Committee on Sexual Misconduct alleging that, in the midst of an otherwise consensual sexual encounter, the male student had engaged in nonconsensual anal contact with her. After roughly two months, in which an independent factfinder investigated the claim and a UWC panel held a hearing, the five-member panel determined that the male student had not violated Yale’s sexual misconduct policies. It did not recommend any follow-up measures. Then-Yale College Dean Mary Miller upheld the panel’s
findings, according to her written decision, which — along with the fact-finder’s report, the panel’s report and the complainant’s response to the panel’s decision — was provided to the News. But at the request of the female student, Miller asked that the no-contact order between the students, which had been registered when the formal complaint was first filed, remain in place. She further recommended that the male student meet with his residential college master and pursue SEE NO-CONTACT PAGE 4
Top: Then-Yale College Dean Mary Miller provides UWC Secretary Aley Menon with her final decision in a case involving two undergraduates. The decision was rendered April 23, 2014. Bottom: Jennifer Czincz of SHARE writes to then-UWC Chair Michael Della Rocca on March 25, 2014 to relay the complainant’s concerns about the no-contact order.
Back to debauchery. Yalies
— well, mainly seniors — still let a little loose at last night’s Feb Club event, a Star Warsthemed party named “Jar Jar Drinks” held in a Jonathan Edwards suite. The creativity is strong with these ones.
Expert commentary. This week’s news about the University’s sanctions against SAE has drawn a wide range of reactions from an even wider collection of sources. Add Total Frat Move to the list, which expressed some, shall we say, surprise at the ruling. Also, recycling an old picture from the News? TFM. They’re kind of a frat. The
Whiffenpoofs managed to do Mardi Gras the right way, parading through the streets of New Orleans yesterday. By Tuesday night, however, they were on their way back from the trip, while the rest of us in New Haven tried to improvise with buckets of Cajun chicken for a little Fat Tuesday kick.
Behavioural decision making.
The Center for International and Professional Experience seems to be fully prepared for anyone with questions about the London School of Economics summer session. Having already hosted several info sessions about the study abroad program, the CIPE will hold another one today to help make the decision even easier for those considering it. Don’t forget. Applications for everything from fellowships (e.g., the Libby Rouse Fund for Peace) to Fling (i.e., this year’s Spring Fling logo) are due today. THIS DAY IN YALE HISTORY
2014 Yalies make a strong push for local businesses and public offices to advertise broccoli as a healthy, appealing option. Follow along for the News’ latest.
@yaledailynews
ONLINE y MORE goydn.com/xcampus
Students call for Af-Am House dean’s removal BY STAPHANY HOU AND AMAKA UCHEGBU STAFF REPORTERS Members of the Afro-American Cultural Center presented a petition calling for the removal of Assistant Dean of Yale College and Director of the Af-Am House Rodney Cohen at an external review meeting on Tuesday evening. During the meeting — which was chaired by Yale College Dean Jonathan Holloway and University Secretary and Vice President for Student Life Kimberly Goff-Crews — Elisia Ceballo-Countryman ’18, a member of the Af-Am House and freshman liaison for the Black Student Alliance at Yale, presented a 60-page petition signed by 147 students, outlining the students’ grievances about Cohen’s leadership. Students who spoke during the meeting, which drew roughly 40 attendees, and who wrote letters that were included in
the petition shared complaints about Cohen’s lack of accessibility, his character and financial management of the cultural center. They also unanimously expressed the view that Cohen should be relieved of his directorship. “We demand widespread change that begins with the termination of Rodney Cohen’s term as director of the AfroAmerican Cultural Center,” the petition reads. The petition, which includes letters from current students and alumni, lists steps taken by house members to improve Cohen’s leadership of the house since he stepped into the position in 2010. Complaints were already lobbied against Cohen after his first semester, and two internal reviews were conducted regarding his leadership between 2010 and 2014, petition organizer Micah Jones ’16 said in an interview with the SEE AF-AM PAGE 6
CT senators propose replacing Metro-North BY DANIELA BRIGHENTI AND NOAH DAPONTE-SMITH STAFF REPORTERS As Metro-North Railroad comes under scrutiny for a series of fatal accidents in the last two years, two Connecticut lawmakers are calling for the state to reconsider its deal with the beleaguered commuter rail operator. The proposed legislation — submitted to the General Assembly’s Transportation Committee by State Senators Toni Boucher, R-Wilton, and Tony Hwang, R-Fairfield — would force the state to put the contract for the operation of rail lines up for bid-
ding. Such a change could result in the replacement of Metro-North as the line’s operator. The state’s current contract with Metro-North, signed three decades ago, lasts 60 years, with amendments possible every five years. Boucher and Hwang, however, want the General Assembly to authorize an immediate renegotiation of the contract. “Reliability and a safe working infrastructure are a state’s core function,” Boucher said in a statement. “We are in desperate need of better service, replacements, repairs SEE METRO-NORTH PAGE 6
Study questions divestment’s costs BY JED FINLEY AND LARRY MILSTEIN STAFF REPORTERS The cost of divestment may be too high for institutions to bear, according to a study published last week by researchers from Compass Lexecon, an economic consulting firm. The study found a “highly likely and substantial” potential for lower investment returns on divested institutional portfolios. Critics, though, have argued that the study’s results merely reflect the interests of the pro-energy group that financed the report, the Independent Petroleum Association of America. The report — which analyzed the effect of divestment over a 50-year period — cited higher trading costs, diversification costs and compliance costs as among the potential consequences of divestment. “The economic evidence demonstrates that fossil fuel divestment is a bad idea,” former dean of the University of Chicago Law School and lead author Daniel Fischel wrote in the study. “These costs have real financial impacts on the returns generated by an investment portfolio, and therefore, real impacts on the ability of an educational institution to achieve its goals.”
The conclusion of the report was based on a study comparing two portfolios — one “optimal equity portfolio” without divested assets and one divested non-energy stock portfolio. After analyzing the investment returns over the timeframe from 1965 to 2014, the study found a gross reduction in returns of 0.7 percent per year due to divestment. Over the past decade, Yale has earned an average 11 percent annual return that has brought the endowment total to $24 billion as of June 30, 2014. Senior vice president at Compass Lexecon Alexander Rinaudo, who was part of Fischel’s three-person team of researchers for the study, said divested portfolios may have lower returns due to decreased diversification of assets. Rinaudo said that compared to other industrial sectors in the market, the energy industry is the “least correlated” sector. He added that because energy stocks are not closely tied to the performance of other stocks, they have provided a stable source of investment for years — despite the recent fall in oil prices. The School of Management finance professor Roger Ibbotson said that though SEE DIVESTMENT PAGE 6
MEN’S LACROSSE
Looking to rebound
The men’s lacrosse team tries for the NCAA Tournament. PAGE 12