NEW HAVEN, CONNECTICUT · MONDAY, APRIL 13, 2015 · VOL. CXXXVII, NO. 119 · yaledailynews.com
INSIDE THE NEWS MORNING EVENING
SUNNY RAINY
63 49
CROSS CAMPUS 14,400 minutes. That is, more or less, how much class time remains in the school year. Make ‘em count. Thanks, Obama. As excited
as much of Yale was to have United States Vice President Joe Biden as this year’s Class Day speaker, we all just got one-upped by our neighbors at the Coast Guard Academy. On Friday, it was announced that Biden’s boss, President Barack Obama, will be delivering a commencement speech at the New London, Conn., academy on May 20. Breaking news. Hillary Clinton
LAW ’73 did, in fact, officially declare her plans to join the hunt for Obama’s current position as part of the 2016 presidential election. But something — perhaps the very quick appearance of official Yale for Hillary social media campaigns — tells us that this wasn’t exactly unexpected.
SOFTBALL SLUMP YALE SWEPT BY DARTMOUTH
SPEAKING OF GREEK
HOUSE OF WORSHIP
But not in Phelps Hall. Two sororities vie to expand to Yale.
BYX SECURES A HOUSE ON CROWN STREET.
PAGE B1 SPORTS
PAGE 3 UNIVERSITY
PAGE 3 UNIVERSITY
A
s the nation focuses its attention on campus sexual misconduct, students, administrators and activists alike turn to data for answers. But low reporting rates mean most stories go untold — leaving universities largely unguided in their efforts to address a widespread yet simultaneously highly particular problem. VIVIAN WANG reports.
UPCLOSE
BY VIVIAN WANG STAFF REPORTER On Dec. 2, 2014, thousands of students, faculty and staff in Woolsey Hall burst into applause as former United States President Jimmy Carter confronted University President Peter Salovey about Yale’s sexual misconduct policies.
“I read one article on the way up here ... and it pointed out that Yale has in previous years … [students who] had been guilty or admitted that they committed sexual assault, and they had not been expelled,” Carter said. Carter was citing an August 2013 Huffington Post article
about Yale’s controversial July 2013 Report of Complaints of Sexual Misconduct. While the report concluded that four students were found responsible for engaging in nonconsensual sexual acts, none of them had been expelled, and only one was suspended. Carter’s remark soon spread across the Internet, from Twitter to Inside HigherEd and back to the Huffington Post. But Yale was quick to distance itself from the criticism. Karen Peart, the University deputy press secretary, told the News later that day that the original Huffington Post article had not correctly stated the facts. Indeed, the article states that Yale “found six students guilty of ‘nonconsensual sex,’” but the language of the report itself points to “certain nonconsensual acts during otherwise consensual sexual activ-
Almost. This weekend, many freshmen dressed in odd garb and yelled nonsensical things throughout Old Campus. No, there’s no such thing as Freshman Tap (yet): Saturday’s festivities were part of Freshman Olympics, which Saybrook won. About time they had something go right. Do better. Over the weekend,
The New York Observer wrote about a WYBCX interview with Robert Storr, dean of the School of Art, who took aim at art critics everywhere for not being “interesting enough.”
THIS DAY IN YALE HISTORY
2013 The men’s hockey team beats Quinnipiac 4–0 for the NCAA national championship. Follow along for the News’ latest.
Twitter | @yaledailynews
ONLINE y MORE goydn.com/xcampus
PAGE 5 CITY
ity” in several of the cases. The cases in question involved violations of Yale’s more “stringent” definition of consent as positive, voluntary and unambiguous, Peart said. But the conflicting explanations reached by Yale administrators and Carter indicate a problem beyond punishment or definition. They illustrate how even experts in sexual misconduct policy can be confused by the limited data on campus sexual misconduct. Indeed, as Yale — and campuses across the country — races to address a burgeoning nationwide conversation about sexual assault, policymakers, politicians, university counselors and students alike are faced with a lack of quantitative information. Instead, vague reports and anecdotes dominate the conversation about a problem that, more often than not,
Kissinger examines “world order”
last two items, it would only be fair if we gave an update on a fourth major player during the 2008 election, Mitt Romney. The two-time Republican nominee visited Harvard, his old stomping grounds (for both law and business), on Friday to speak about paths from the private sector to the public sector. “If you get the chance to run for president, do it. It’s great,” Romney told students gathered, according to The Harvard Crimson.
FOMO. Some members of the class of 2017 who just could not wait another year for *actual* tap season participated in Junior Tap Night yesterday. If you were serenaded by students dressed as cowboys or Spongebob or lions, now you know why.
Crepes Choupette to open shop on Whitney Avenue.
In sexual misconduct, data offer limited guidance
Remember him? Given the
“Pay attention to me!” All this talk about the actual presidency makes it easy to forget that campus just recently elected a new Yale College Council president. But, so as to make sure that we don’t actually forget about him, President-elect Joe English ’17 sent out a college-wide email Sunday night to solicit interest for his Executive Board.
WITH NUTELLA
occurs behind closed doors. Administrators acknowledge their inability to know either the true incidence or reporting rates of campus sexual misconduct. Left out of every SemiAnnual Report of Complaints of Misconduct — which lays out all the complaints that come to the University’s attention in a period of six months, as well as their outcomes — are the students who do not tell their stories, at least not to administrators or police. “[Sexual assault] goes on at all the universities,” Carter said. “But I think the main thing is to let the students know what is going on and teach them if they want to know what can be done in case there is a case of sexual assault.” The question, then, is this: What exactly is going on? SEE UP CLOSE PAGE 4
English ’17 elected YCC president BY JOEY YE STAFF REPORTER
versity President Peter Salovey, Ferguson and Kissinger discussed how historical peace treaties, such as the Treaty of Westphalia or the Congress of Vienna, could be used to understand present circumstances more clearly. “There’s never been a world order before. What used to be considered world order was a regional
With 68.25 percent of the student vote, Joe English ’17 cruised to victory in this year’s Yale College Council presidential election. While English received 1,225 votes, his opponents — Ben Martin ’17 and Andy Hill ’17 — garnered 316 and 254 votes, respectively. Maddie Bauer ’17 was elected YCC vice president in an uncontested race. “I’m so excited to be serving Yale as president of the YCC next year,” English said upon learning thathe had won. “I’m excited to bring the YCC to students and work with different student organizations, as well as the administration, on a whole host of issues.” This year’s race saw a dramatic drop in turnout, with 825 fewer votes cast this year compared to last. During his campaign, English ran on a platform of pursuing five policy areas. These included continuing current YCC initiatives such as reforming mental health policies while also pursuing new projects, such as the creation of a task force on campus dining and a comprehensive evaluation of distributional requirements. English said his first order of business will be to meet with members of the Yale Corporation on Friday. During the meeting, he plans to address a variety of issues ranging from reforming financial aid to improving the cultural houses. The YCC also began its search for candidates to
SEE KISSINGER PAGE 6
SEE YCC RACE PAGE 6
FINNEGAN SCHICK/CONTRIBUTING PHOTOGRAPHER
Former Secretary of State Henry Kissinger spoke about the need for a re-examination of the 21st century world order. BY FINNEGAN SCHICK STAFF REPORTER Nobel laureate and two-time Secretary of State Henry A. Kissinger spoke on Friday to a full Levinson auditorium, calling for a re-examination of the 21st century world order. Hosted by the Yale Johnson Center for the Study of American Diplomacy, Kissinger was joined
by Harvard history professor Niall Ferguson to discuss possibilities of what the world order will look like in 2025, using diplomatic history as a tool for predicting the future. Kissinger drew on his extensive diplomatic experience in China and the Middle East, explaining the complexity of establishing order in a world with diverging conceptions of international norms. After opening remarks from Uni-
Athletic donations charge set to increase BY GREG CAMERON AND LARRY MILSTEIN STAFF REPORTERS Beginning next fiscal year, should a Yale donor give $1,000 to one of the 18 alumni sports associations, just $880 of that sum will directly fund the team that the association supports. On July 1, 2012, the Provost’s Office began to extend its indirect cost recovery policy, which charges a 12 percent administrative fee to all gifts not restricted for capital projects or endowment funds, to all departments, including athletics. Officials planned to implement the change using a three-year transitional period in which there was no fee in
2012–13, a 6 percent charge in 2013–14 and the full 12 percent assessment in 2014–15. But according to Jim Millar, a member of the Yale Crew Association and president of the Yale Sports Federation, the University is now applying the 6 percent charge for two years, concluding this July, when the charge will increase to the 12 percent target. Millar, however, did not know the exact timing of the implementation, and University administrators declined to comment on the specific timeline of Yale’s gift giving policy. “About four years ago, [University officials] reaffirmed that the long-standing policy regarding an assessment for indirect costs for expend-
able gifts should be applied in a fair and consistent way,” Deputy Provost for Academic Resources Lloyd Suttle wrote in an email. “Other than [assuring] that this policy is being applied across all schools and departments of the University, there is little I could or would wish to add.” Annual giving from these associations is one of three methods by which teams receive funds for their operating expenses. Endowment returns, which are not charged an assessment, and institutional support from the University are the other two elements of team funding, according to Millar. According to a letter that Director of Athletics Tom
Beckett sent to athletics alumni in October of 2013, the rationale for implementing this 12 percent assessment on athletic donations was to ensure that the administrative costs necessary to sustain the full functioning of the University, such as support services, facilities maintenance and business operations, could be met. Beckett’s letter noted that in the past, most gifts to athletics and a few other departments had been exempted from this “cost recovery policy.” As a result, the University planned to phase in the assessment over three years, which would allow departments sufficient time to adjust their long-range financial plans and ensure the policy is understood by donors, he stated.
Despite this explanation, an alumnus of the University, who wished to remain anonymous, expressed confusion about the reasoning for the charge. He noted that a smaller fee might be reasonable, but that 12 percent is excessive. “This whole thing has a bizarre feel to it,” the alumnus said. “How do you get to 12 percent? No one has presented any justification for it.” The increasing assessment comes at a time in which, according to Millar, alumni associations are currently looking to ramp up fundraising to wean their associated teams off their reliance on institutional support. This resilience SEE DONATIONS PAGE 6