INDICE EDITORIAL ......................................................................................................................... 2 MATÉRIA DE CAPA .......................................................................................................... 3 "A educação não é mercadoria, é um elemento absolutamente estratégico" ................ 3 Entrevista com Ronaldo Mota ................................................................................ 3 "O projeto é um primor de formalismo, de um lado, e de populismo, de outro" ........... 7 Entrevista com Roberto Romano............................................................................ 7 "É o ensino brasileiro e não só a universidade que precisa de reforma" .................... 10 Entrevista com Pedro Gomes ............................................................................... 10 "Romper com o elitismo social da educação superior brasileira"............................... 13 Entrevista com Hélgio Trindade........................................................................... 13 "Ao pedir mais tempo para a discussão, a sociedade sinaliza o seu desconforto"...... 15 Entrevista com Ione Bentz.................................................................................... 15 Universidades: a quem pertence a autonomia? ........................................................... 16 Entrevista com Renato Janine Ribeiro.................................................................. 16 “É fundamental preservar a autonomia universitária” ............................................... 18 Entrevista com Maria Isabel Cunha...................................................................... 18 DESTAQUES DA SEMANA............................................................................................. 21 LIVRO DA SEMANA ............................................................................................................ 21 SMOLIN, Lee. A Vida do Cosmos. São Leopoldo: Editora Unisinos, 2004, 405 p. 21 A vingança de Leibnitz ................................................................................................. 21 Por Prof. Dr. Ney Lemke...................................................................................... 21 MEMÓRIA .......................................................................................................................... 23 Jacques Dupuis – 1923 – 2004 ................................................................................. 23
Jacques Dupuis – Teólogo fiel e corajoso.................................................................... 23 Por Rosino Gibellini ............................................................................................. 23 ANÁLISE DE CONJUNTURA................................................................................................. 26 País está sem blindagem contra crises ...................................................................... 26 ARTIGO DA SEMANA .......................................................................................................... 30 Anotações de Porto Alegre ....................................................................................... 31 ENTREVISTA DA SEMANA .................................................................................................. 33 As monoculturas produzem ausência. As ecologias produzem existência............... 33 DEU NOS JORNAIS .............................................................................................................. 36 FRASES DA SEMANA ........................................................................................................... 40 EVENTOS IHU................................................................................................................... 41 PÁSCOA: PASSAGEM PARA A LIBERDADE ........................................................................... 41 A Santa Ceia: obra-prima de uma artista cristã .......................................................... 43 Entrevista com Maristela Winck .......................................................................... 43 SIMPÓSIO INTERNACIONAL TERRA HABITÁVEL. UM DESAFIO PARA A HUMANIDADE ........ 44 IHU IDÉIAS ....................................................................................................................... 44 ENCONTROS DE ÉTICA PARA ALUNOS................................................................................ 45 Estresse, trauma e resiliência.................................................................................... 45 Por Christian Haag Kristensen ............................................................................. 45 QUARTA COM CULTURA UNISINOS .................................................................................... 46 CICLO DE ESTUDOS REPENSANDO OS CLÁSSICOS DA ECONOMIA ...................................... 46 ENTREVISTA DO IHU ON-LINE É PUBLICADA NO EXTERIOR ............................................... 47 IHU REPÓRTER ............................................................................................................... 47 EDELBERTO BEHS .............................................................................................................. 47 SALA DE LEITURA .............................................................................................................. 50 CARTAS DO LEITOR ............................................................................................................ 50
!"# ! *
"
#
+ )
$ -
( % 5 .)
0 3 -
4 5
$ &
2
;
.) - (/ ' ( % 6 / 8 ' 24 3
% '
& $
( )
&
1%
, $ 2
7
3 )
3 %
' ()
9 $
:
% <
$
) % 8
'
8
5
)
8
# =
223
6
% ( 2
.0
1 86 % ,
<
< 0 9 ? 0
4 2
>
5
0 '
5
=
/
' ?
(
+ : )
A$
5 2 % ) @$ 0
A
7
5
& ;
4
,
B
$#!%"# &#'# ! ' $ (
(') * +
& C )
"
,
D>
)
%
#
%#
' %
E
%
# G 0 (2 (+ + +
7 %7 6 (
%
C
4 %
( & 0
0 ' ( -
'
$ 0 A ) (0 '
0 ' 2 A3 , ( = H II? #
' $ E 9 % A% D0' F F $%
0 ) ), )
.)' ( .
)
+) /
( '0 ) ) 1) '
3 ! # $
"
# &
.) - (/ ( 2 %
D
!" #
7 9 G
) ' 1 2 ' ), ')
(
D>
' & C <
$% " #
9
D C
! % 9 ) ) 0 ' ) & ' D + !$ (0 $ J
#
')
' + : 0
) D #
),
'
" %" # & (
' (()( * ' ./ 4 5 (! ),6/+)( (7 +/ ' * 8' *)(9 :/) ( ) ), ) ; / (7 ( 1 ' ( +) ( )* ( / +) ( * ' *) ( ) 1 1 (') 3 ), ') ) * " # $ + ( (, ' (, " " .
#
( -
(
/
" 0
&
" # "
"
" (
0
1
34
2
(
0 (
(
& "
(
"
"
"
%
0
$
(
5 ( ( " (
: (
%
$
"
" $ (+ "
" +
7
"
6
(
(
#
8 (
(
(
"
'
"
2
0
#
0
#
0
0 ( %
"
"
;<=
> % '
!
#
" "
# -
9
-
"
(
2
( (
? @4 4 "
A 0 + 7 $ (
(
! (
$
" (
" +
0 D
'
"
B .
2
B #(
0
"
" #
C "
"
:
( 2
#
# #
"
2
#
'
#(
<0 /+) )*/()4 7 ;/ 1 2 ' = )(( (' * ), (')! * + ( > ;/ !1 ? +1, ! /+ ( ; / 1 () (( ( ' = ' ) %@ ! /+) (/ ( ) ( @)8(3 ') % " - # " ( 0 /: ' # & ! " /: ' /: ' # ( ( # /: ' $ ( $ : " /: ' " $ %2 $ ( %2 ' ( 2 ( E # ( " ' (( ! ( )( +) ),
3
5
8 )
/: ' !
- .
#
(
!
3;
?4 4 @ %
-
2
'
" "
-
'
" .
+ #
(
! " 7$
( /
#
7 : A
#
-
(
(
+
F 5
"
'
%2 1
-
$ ( '
:
/: ' 3<
# ( 0 -
:" '
#
+
'
.
9
:
"
"
+ G+
: :" ' #
-
'
2
!
/: '
/: ' )
-
34 = 65. : ( " . 2 "
# #
1 #
+
65. : # 8
"
#
(
/
-
" /: ' 5
-
"
"
9
5
" "
8
$
7
/ 3@ 34 = # ' /: '
#
# E
-
(
/: ' & #
7 #
+
-
'
7 "
+
" +
# / " #
* /
+ ,)4 7 ( '0 )3 ), ') 5
( 7 A * )4 7 "
2 7
" " ( + 2
1
( 8
" % ( 0 C
( ' ! 1 1) ' )( / * ( ,- * +/ '0 " 9
:
& '
C
( E
"
#
"
!
7
(
:
. #
)(! ) )(! /+ (* ), ')
( ) ( 1 ) )(! ; / -0 /+ 3 , 7 ) ') ) )/' +)
"
: 7
"
#
2$ "
:
&
(
$ .
# ( 7 6) ; / ' + -) ' + ,)4 7 ) (( 3
! (1 * ),+ '
)( /
"
( ) ( #
"
" ( + #
# +
' #
(
&
"
"
! ' #
+
-
#
"
( # $ ( 0
" " "
E
" +
' (
$
( + +
"
#
2
(
+ 7
#
"
&
" #)+.=+ / / ( ; / ) 1 1 (') ('0 ,-) 1) ) ( ( ,) )+ ' ! ( + , ) + * ') ) /*)4 7 $0( *)9 ; / ( - )*-)3 ') * ( $ ( C . " 7 " 1 C C # " # : ( $ " " # # %2 ( " 5% ' 5 7 7 1 ' -
(/1 ), B
" 2
:/) ( ( 1 ., +)( ; / * ')(3 ), # 8
')
7
9
(
-
(
') ) * +
,)4 7
A ; / ('7
(
-
)(
( "
" -
HD
I
"
( (
0
)1
B 2
: 6
( "
'
( -
# )
" #
&
#
6
5-
"
/ #
( & #
2
#
/ (
+
2
6
-
(( 1)(( ; / ) * + )( + )( ' +) )( 1 , & ), ') * $ " ( ( %
#
# !
% "
( '
#
-
*
(
('= ) /*)4 7 ('0 ) "/,) )'= + + ' 3 ( D ( " ( (
('0 +
$
(
%
*-) ; / "/,)3 ), (
') 7 (
"
"
' ;/
7
/' ( 1 2 ' (
.
6
#
"
"
-
(( 1 2 ' = +) ( *
D
#
9
(
(
+
"
(
+
+
"
@
' $
B #
@
C
(') * +
. '
$
0
6 ( . ) 2' 2 2 A2 H IIH . 9
(
@ @ "%
!
#
%
0
, H II $ 00 2 O ? FM
&
!
"
+)
0 * A( % 1
!
"%
@ +)
. '
( ) ) (6 (0 0 D C 4 0 2 AK 4 FLF ( + ,! FFL ( !/0 # HM 0 2 A ( % - (0 2 FFL 0 + ! % ! 23 0 2 A2 H II $ $ #& H H IIH
;/ .
( (
)*-) ) 1 1 (')
L
. 2 A $ % 0 A0 ( N!
1 +) ( + (' 3JK? ! -
() 3
> " 9
" B
:
C %
5
6
( CM 5 7
(
( (
#
" A 2(
# !( #
. 75 ( (
%" ! # # H
$ -
F !
'
$
:/ ' 1 +) ! # " F ' A
#
H
)
I
N #
( (
.
I
(
. '
2
(
+) /
"
( '0 ) ' + * + + ')3 B
-
"
N
. -
1
"
F
#
#
% %"
-
-
( (
#(
7
!
"
#
$
"
H
$
I , #
+
(
(
+
" !
! "
1
' #( L? #
"
O
A
+
"
! @ / ( '0 / ( ) (1 . ' +) 9 )
(
; / *- 6)+ ( ) ( ) ('7 ) / ) )(3 E 3JK< ' /: '
+
/+) ( * ( )
) F E
) ; /), (D , ( ('7
"
(2 (* + +)' */,) ( + # "
$
%
$
1
&
H
!
>
/: ' (
2
!(
0
A H!
(
(
$
"
I D
/: ' (
7
$
#
(
! (
2 # 3JK@ 5 ( ( 0
. 7 5 /: ! 6B #( (
(
I
(
.
3J?J
,=
"
> "
+ "
$
E
;
1 68 B
(
-
!
#
:
-
0 5
G 7 -
( )
H
I
-
$ 0
$
-
H
H
I
$ H
-
H /
"
!
I -
I I
!
#
" 2(
(
%
(
-
( 0 # ? ;
C 2 ! (+
+ 3JK@
2 2 .
#
7
4 @ 4 J 3J3< % " . 75 /: ! (
. L
6
B "
0
/: ! 6B %
1 1 (') + * ') ) /*)4 7 .0( *)3 . ' +) : #
('0 ,-)
1) )
(
1 ( ') ' ( )( / ( ) (1 ) (1 * ),+ ' ) ? ('> * ) * ( ,- * +/ '0 ! :/), = (/) 1 7 ) (( (1 ' 3 . ' +) H I# 0 E " / P # " " & + ( - ) ), ) ) *,/(7 +1,) ')4 7 ) 1 1 (') 3 :/) ( ( )+ * ((0 ( 1) ) /+) *,/(7 ( * ), ), ) / . ' +) : H I ( # ( ( 0 " ( F 7 # D ( 4 5 # 0 :/ + 6) -) * + ) )( +) ( )4 5 ( ; / ('7 ( . ' +) E ( "
+) / ), G ) )( -
(/1
( ,)
)( '> + +) (') ; / ) ') ) )/' +) /
2$
(
# & &
+
(
( * ), ; / )' )* ' * * + ) ( *)+ - ( ; / )1 ') ) * + +) ( ( ) 3 $ ( F & " ( 1 6
8
( A7
(
( '0 )3 6 E
+
A
0 C
<
8
( 1
(
(() @#3 F
E -
+) (
; /) )
# &
"
(
% ,6/+ /' +) ! A "
)(1 *' ; / ; / (
) ).
5
# )
7
1 6/ ')
999
,
@4
2( -
#-
%
!
+
. '
1 2 ' ! ( '0 )9
"
+ 2
!( +, )
+
( 'H
/ ( 5
( D
AM
/
L '
3JJK %
" $
6
6
@A
+
H!
+
-
-
#
! "
'
# #
7 ) Q 3 <KR
/C . 9
'
$
%"
(') * + @
!2 ) 5
2
3
3
J
%
:
5
%
: '
%
) 0 10
-! +
H II
O
N IF
=
@
#
%
C
2
IH I I
;
223
(
& % % (
1 2$
4 %
) 5 /0 FFP G FFQ G
7 "
& + (
)
!
I
: -
%I
F :
" -
3;S3
+
%
"
! (
3 ?
( %02 0 ! /0 #&
% 3 C <!
# 2%)$0 ; 6789- 67:; 0 + <! 1 0 + H 0 N$ R O D
5 1
A( A( +
?II I
:/) ( (7 ( 1 * 1) ( )(1 *' ( ; / +) ( '0 )3 & + (T7 ( ( F * $ - ( & ( # & ! ( $ " ( 7 ( ( . # # (
( -
) @
(')*) )
"
) ' 1 2 '
%2
( #
- (
+
& "
(
" 5 $
# # 0
" 7
( -
" #
@
7
B
6
6
#
/ ?4 4 <
%
(
'
# "
H 6
6
A
( ( I
11 ?4 4 ? P ( +
#
=
RU V " 4 J 3? ?4 4 ; ! &1 > ?4 4 ; P <! ?
:/) ( ( & + ( *
@
)+ )( ; / ('5 ( ; /
( -
)*-) +) ( (*/'8
(3 "
# (
!(
/
7$ ! -
$
(
( #
/
#
#
0
( 6
" (
# ( KQ
#
( (
$ "
@Q (
%
$ "
(
#
"
" " A
7
"
B
! # "
5
2 6
#
"
#
" 7
.
#
(
* + /+)
" (
# %" ( -
G ) ; / ( + ('/ ) /+)
1 ,8' *)999 @ & + (
+)
" "
(
)
"
(
"
6
" ( DB 1
+)
0
$
7 " 3JJK
"
! "
( $ 1
5 (
"
"
" ( C
K
"
" > 7 "
" % ( #
) #
" 5
&
" C
*
-
"
7 ( + *)4 5 ( ) ' & + ( > " / 8 9
+ @ 5
K
.
7
"
# 6
(
D
"
2( (
) ( (1 * ' ./ 1 2 ' ! )'= +) 4 3 " ! ' / 7 : ( %" 4 3 4 3 4 ; ?U 4 3 4 < %
2
+) +) ( " "
"
" (' '/*
), 1) ) (()(
1
/
2
2 (
" #
#
%2 .
"
/
"
#
7 ' *(1 *8 *)( 6 /1 ( :/), = ) (/) 1 7 3 @ & + ( 7 %2 (
1 2 ' ;/ G K) /*)4 7 (/1 6) G )4 5 ( ( * ) (L ' + (1 ')
)' 0 +) )( *,) )4 5 ( 1 ,> + *)(9 N
/ "
.
(" "
( 6(
$ (+
-
7 ( ;4 =
:
(
(
2 .
"
# 2
0 (
;4 =
(
(
"
*
( " "
(
"
7
-
"
#
N
2 (
"
-
"
F 7
B
%
(
# -
"
" # ( " " P " 5
" ( 9 $ (
'
(
(( '
" -
$(
"
(
2
" (
2 7
-
"
#
# (
& * * 14 7 ; / ) ). ) 6 ' ! ( ) +) ( / 3 @ & + ( 7$ 7 KJK ?4 4 < )
"
' ' (' 7 5 (
-
$
# (*
?3
$ 2
" (
%2
% 1 #
& + ( -
(
( %
/
0 2
9
(
)
-
(2
#
#
N
@
2
"
(
4 ) 1) ) +/ ) ) ' 1 2 ' 3 2 5 ( # " # 0$ 7 " 5 ( # + . ( " 2 " #
# (
( ' + ) 2 @ <K@
*,/(7
( * ), (
) +/ ' +) (
3K@ )
C
#
R33 "
U R4
?4 4 <S?
J4 4
(
?4 4 @S3
@
'
"#%
%
"
(') * + <=,6 #
)
% @
$
!
%"
& ) 5 C
6
2 > 2
%
D
;
$
%
2
4
0 )
B /? C ! /0
( (
1
0 2
& - %
2
4 2
4
AT : AT :
( .)
2 > A % D$ 3 0
1 1 ( S FF G
FFF ! H IIH
'
2
(
#& D !
%
0
6
/ 4
' () @! FLIG - %
1
A! @ ! &
:
:/ )(1 *' ( ( )+ ( +) ( (*/' ) ' 1 2 ' ) " ) /*)4 7 %/1 3 <=,6 # ) 7 ( T $ " + L " 1 B $ A 8 0 ' . $ 9
7 ; /
0
-
; A8
2
8 .2 E
%
-
6 0
3
( 1 ,
( -
+
,)4 7
) &
A
" ' 0
P
"
( A
3JKR
3J;3 # "
7
#
-
2
" " #
(
"
$
:/) ( (7 )( + ')( 1) ) ( (/1 !;/ +;/ + ) (()( + ')( (7 1 ,> + *)(3 ) (N " ( " $ (+ " + # ( $ (+ ' % 7 " ! ( ( ) ( " '%7 $ 0
" ('7
(
1 1 (')( )
+) <=,6 #
7
7
8
7
"
:
/
?4 4 <
"
# # ! !
( '
%
1 ( ') ' ( )( / ( ) ( 1 ) )( '> + +) (') ; / 1 2 ' ! (1 * ),+ ' ) ? ('> * ) * ( ,- * +/ '0 ! ) ') ) )/' +) / ( '0 )9 :/), = (/) 1 7 ) (( (1 ' 3 :/), = (/) * * 14 7 * +1, + ') ) ' ( 1M ., * 1 ) 3 <=,6 # ) E 8 /C 8 9 : 5 6 ( " / : " ( % ' 9 " ( " B 0 ) 2 /C 8 9 : ( " 7 # " 1 2 ' = ')+.=+ )*/() ' + , / ( ) ;/ ' + ( , (1 )+ ( ,)* ) 3 <=,6 # ) M (
)(( (' * ), (')9 <0 /+ (') * )+ ' ( 1 ., +)( (() ( * ) 3 + " #
B (
!
"
+
# "
52 <=,6
#
0 / ( U4= ! "
2 (" #
2
"
7
:/), ( ) )(1 *' ; / +) ( ) M 1 33= U @= " 0 " " $ " # 8
"
#
(')*) ) 1 1 (') 3R ?@ * %
/
5-
( 8
-
(
!
$ (
,6/+ /' #
)(1 *' ; / ; /
) ).
)
7
1 6/ ') "
"
) (
%
! (
;4 =
<=,6
3 - ( "
0
8 (+
"
-
! ?4 4 4
7 "
# 5
3 :
-
5
-
(( 0
#
" 7
" "
#
2
@
'
%#
@ @
(') * +
+ %
'
3 9 + 2 2%)$0 8T .2 0
3 U>
+ 2
! /0 * 1
!
%%
%
%
"N
%
%
C
#
$ 'G
M8 %
%
A!
:
% 5 @8
5 +
/
U> D
2
;
24 3 9
D :
4
(
!! /0 2
! FIM
5 % %02
D
: 2
A(
4
?
A T : H III + H IIH 8 H II
' V
9
: #& N!
> O :/) ( (7 ( '0 )
+) $ 'G
( 1 3 #
* 1) ( 1 ., +)( )1 ( ') $
%
&
$
-
'
-
"
-
"
#
B
7 '
"
( " #
-
" #
'
"
7
)
' () +
M #(
( 1 , ) ' 1 2 '
(
&
1
#(
B
(
"
" )
(
#
#
(
(
(
"
"
" + ) ), ) ) 1) ' * 1)4 7 " ( * " % P
5
$ 'G # -
)(
()( (' '/ 4 5 ( )'= + + ' 3 ( N $
( (
"
: $
"
;/ '1
+) /
8
$ 'G
!
( '0 ) (')+ ( 1 * () & ( M " " ( "
$
3 2 E
3JU 3
7
( 6
& S4 @
"
:
7
+ 8
#
( "
(
+
0 W
/
"
W '
2$
# "
*
+ ) ), ) ) *,/(7 ( * ), 1 1 (') 1 , ) ' 1 2 ' 3 :/), ( ) ( / *,/(7 ( * ), ) 1) ' ) / ( ) 3 ! 5+ 5 W ( - W # ( ( ( # ( ! " " ' $ " " P ( " #
* ' $ 'G
#
:/ + 6) -) ; / + 1 1 1 (')3 !
,) ('0 ( $ 'G
* +) "
( '0 )
)
-
(
(
N (
"
"
-
7 N
'
E
3 2 ( )
W (
%O
%
:
(') * +
$ 0 .2
<
@
0 D
#
)' B)
$ /
.)
(
(
"
J
(' + ( +;/
/
8 -
+) /
3
#
. ) %
0
/ % 2 8 D % 7
2 2
C +
0
( AW FL - D , "0 + FF? ( $ % D ' 3 FFF <! ! < ' G ' $
D -
0
1 0 &
, 1 -
! 1
:/ )(1 *' ( (7 ( '0 ) $ )( ,3 . * ( '2 9 "
5
$ 3
( ;/
< -!
: 7 6 4 !
+
E 9+ 0
0
)G + +) ( / 6 ' )
2 A) H 9 6 : H III # A) H II? * (( ) : (
A
/+) ( "
" # (
" -
8
6 9
( ! A$ $ <
" 7
2
" $
->
%
2 -$
9
+) / )' B) N
( WX
$
) 6
" #
#
-
* YYY
&
( ! /
" )
" :/ ' 1 . P
)' B)
(
$ $
+) /
( '0 ) ' + * + + ')3 ! $ 6 I #
" "
T
)
7
$
-
$
H
" # " " )
(
#
(
0 -
!
"
-
( ! 5
"
0
'
( # /
0 '2 9
%
/
0
%" -
#
)
"
?4 4 @ ?4 34 '
'
YYY
(
2
@ ; / *- 6)+ ( ) ( /+) ( * ) / ( '0 ) ('7 ) / ( ) F E ( ) ( 1 ) )(3 )' B) . ! " # ( 7 : (2 " + # " " 2 ( 1 " 7 0
) ; /), (D , ( ('7
:/ )(1 *' ( ) 1 1 (') (() ' ( ; /) ( ( ; / +) ( * ' *) )3 )' B) . B . 75 7 $ " 7 #
( -
(2 (* + +)' */,) ( + ( /
" #
"
0
)(( ),) ) * + +) ( "
5
"
M
" )
#
' $
(
-
" "
C
E
U4
-
+ -
(
1 1 (') ' + * . / )( * 8' *)( 1 ' ( 1 (( )( ') ' ( 1M ., * ; /) ' 1 ) 9 :/) ( (()( * 8' *)( )*-) ; / '> + / )+ ' ; /) ( )*-) +1 ') ' (*,) * 1) ) 7 * ) * /(7 + ,)4 7 A * +1 (7 1 2 ' 3 )' B) . C ( # # 7 " B " T ( T E & ' (
!
-
(
"
0 (
( (
"
0
( $ $
# ' J4
$
$
R3
! ! /
(
$
( 0 34 4
J4
-
(
T
(
T ( + )( ) * > * ) 1) ) ; / ' ( 6) - +3 )' B) . B ( % ( # " # - E " 0 ' ( " B -
,)4 7
'
,6/+ /'
K
C
'
# "@
( *
)
.
1
-
" "
#
" T
T
$
"
"
6
"
( '0 ) 1
(
) ), ) )
*
2/ '
" '
+
T
" 7
+ 1 6/ ')
*
(
+1 ') '
# T "
#
J
)
#
223 )
4
$ 2
2 2 &
J
) !/?
#
L
% #P
E ! H
%
;
C !2
0 C
4 ' )
, /? !!
&
(
3
2
1 5
!
(') * + ) ) (). , / -)
' 8 % % D 2 (+ %
%
)
& "
$ .
1
6
)(1 *' ; /
'
.
1M ., *
(
(') 1 1 (') +) / /' )( 1 1 (')( & "/,)3 )' B) . T' # $ " ' $ " * + ') 9 )' B) . 75 $
(
9 % ) ' A 2 ! /0 2 P ) A< ' (
( A 8
2
( %
5
( FF? # 1 ) A2 A % D 2 (+ FFQ # A2 H II? H II?
2
D ( 0
&
)
D
4 -
(
>
(
0 FFQ # + 1
A! ' $
'
. . +
@ ? '
F
/0
:/), = (/) (7 ) 1 1 (') ( )(1 *' ( +) ( 1 ( ' ( ( +) ( 6)' ) ) (). , ) / -) 5
+) /
( '0 )3 :/) ( (7
(3 "
(
+ #
"
#
"
7
$(
"
"
1
$"
! # " D
B
1
#
"
" (
"
- 2 +
(
0
(
# "
5
%
( ?3
-
+ (
$
"
"
( ! $
#
" +
-
3JU 4 (2 (
" "
"
! # - ( #
67 :
"
B
-
%
(
# "
# %
( $ (+
-
S
(
$ +
" 2
67 : + "
(
"
2 %"
:" . 75
*
) (
"
0
7
"
+ 1 1 (')3 ) ) (). ,
)
)( /
( ) ( 1
# "
(
)' 6 )( 1
D '
67 :
" "
+ (
"
/ -)
!
. 75 7 7 *
) )( 1
$
+
"
(
+
"
M " #
0 -
0 N
67 : "
-
( 5
(')
@ ; / *- 6)+ ( ) ( /+) ( * ) ) ; /), (D / ( '0 ) ('7 ) / ( ) F E , ( ('7 / ( ) ( 1 ) )(3 :/ ' 1 +) 1 +/ ) (( ; /) ) ) (). , ) / -) ! & " 1 " - 2 " ( ' # %" # " 5 " ( ( 7 " 7 $ " % 1 ( 7 # &
E
(2 (* + +)' */,) ( + 3
)
"
" + "
" +
-
:"
.
"
"
+) 1 1 (') 1 , = )(( (' * ), (')3 @ 0, 6 ), ' ) ( * ) ! * + ( /( 1 ., +)(! ) / ( ) / ( ) 1 ) )3 ) ) (). , ) / -) % " . 75 $ & ( " 7 " $ ( " #( ' . # . # # ( # 0 5 " 7 0 7 " # ( E 0 ( " " 0 ! 7 # ( + 5 " '
1)(() ) /+ 1M ., *) )
+ ) ), ) ) )'/), 1 1 (') ; / ('7 ( ), G ) ( 6 "/,)3 ) ) (). , ) / -) 5 7 7 7 6 ( " (
' (1 2 ' (
) ) (). ,
:/), = ) +) / ) / -) * 2
+
,)4 7
! # N
& (
"
# -
"
( '0 ) ; / ) 1 D1 )
( (
$ #
( 7$
) (
#
# (
(
"
! ( "
( ('0
* (( ') ! #
3
#
"
" (
"
+ ! / -
! "
"
-
2
#
+
7 "
" "
2
#
0
,6/+ /' )(1 *' ; / 7 ) ) (). , ) / -) 9 ( " "
!#(
1 6/ ')
) % +) )
%
" ! " 9 - 3 .- .
(
%
($ (9 %
"
O
@ "
#
-3 % ) 5 (%
R
(,
7
)
>
M
+
4
.% D $ 3 0 / #
+
4 Q
? !
Z Q FM !
"
J &
9
9
>
> H II
H II 5 !G &F ! @ 3 Y D X )
& %
Z9 H H II?
@9
0
0
! X
+
+
! A7 & H II !
; #&
0
8
%
D
B ' 87 2 H IM A
1 & H III 0 HP
$
3
- E = # =
[
> $ #N
H " +R N#
9 : &
X
%
2
D>
-
@
Q! Q
- E + %
C
(G
@
%!
%
;
; R ) 0
( 2 )* (* ') 9 +
# $#)#
"
% 2
$(
"
( -
(
6
7
X
;
: 0
B
H II
(
- E +
X
2
>
#
#
>
: )R 5
-
I B
D
D % Y
O
H5N
D 2
;
H7
#
' ( I B
-
( #
7
C
-
" 5
"
&
.
"
" C
#
-
(
(
D
ZZ6 '
2
Z 666 -
5
( 2
-
" C
1 ! C
*81 ) ' D1 * # + $ (
C
5
( 7
8 "
$ 9
7$
" /
" (
"
"
'
O
1 2
0
"
"
7 $
/ #
+
(
(
"
( +
$
( (
!
(
+
2
A
2 "
!
" -
"
'
(
(
-
"
"
C (2
.
A (/
# "
2
H
I
# (
#
( ( :
+ #
$ 2
2
7
-
(
# ( "
( -
'
N
# 2
7
B
( ! ( -
(
(
0 H
2$
B
" &
2 (
( (
#I
(
"
$
. 2$
F : $
XC #
%
0
+
X
(
0
0
" #
(
(
+ .
+
+ +
+
#
H
5
#
I "
$
+
"
"
(
+D ) B
:
<
%
S
@ %
;
4
:
H II
Q #
2
> >
4 %
(
; 4
*
H
$
4 ! (
&
3
9
)
$
8&
P
.Y Y Y ,
3
#
H IIP
=
H
D / P
H IIP $ $
B @
3 7 Z2 :
3 7
%
(
\ IH HQM
@ %
#
H
H II Q
:
K H II
# ]Z
I" & C "
B %
& . ,, 7
8
0 ?4 4 < . 3J?;
' >
B (
2 ( 3J<J 3JR< 3JR< C ?R
/
9
(
3K
" [ )
(
/
1 ( ( ( B 9 (
3JRJ ( # $
# ( A
! (
3 -
^ ) -
" "
7
"
" +
F
__
B
5 3JJ?
" )
(
B
2
(
"
"
"
(
(
# (
'
%
(
(
(
(
(
-
A-
2
,
-
(
N
33I
"
T
3JJU
(
( " A
J@
' B ( B
$ #
' B
% I
H1
2 ) -
& N
%
" H
I
5
"
# (
7
"
5 "
"
(
(
=
=
"
" 5
7
( &
"
"
!
( #
( # !
5 ( ( " ? ' B 7 E
"
H
-
3JJR 6
"
' B -
3JJJ
8
"
$
&
"
5 B
9
> B /' /6: E H " ( A34 " ( A ,!
# B
N
# 5
! " (
C
? ! A5 % ! 22 : " ' AD L 0 !
J
"
-
-
R
5
"
3?
(
3?
3JJR (
(
A H% 2
)
" " 5 ( ( " # I
# H
34
3;
33
"
" I #
"
9
(
( (
( 1
E
\5
3JJ3 % 3JJR % :" '
2( 7
-
6 6
%
8
A' 7
)
3JJJ % E
%
A B
9 9 9
(
: - : 1
M
(-
9
3;
B
] L I 7
(
: :
B \5 ^_ (
!
L .
7
8
#
(
.
'
(
>
8
" (
34 4
(
2
$ 2 (
'
C ) $ (
#
7
3<
2
7
P
4
B 8
(
`
B
;3 ?4 4 3 < 7
" 5 ( ( " ?4 4 4 > " "
N
?4 4 4 !
! + # H%
B
" I
B
"
@
<
T ?U
?4 4 3
7
B 5
( ( '/)+ ( 1 ., +)(3 %
(
(
(
(
+ -
( (
"
5
P
"
#
(
$
(
P
%
2(
"
$
( ( (
3;
!
) 2 ( : C
>
C
3@
8
2 ( 2 (
2 (
L
P > ^G (
#
B 2
# $
/( : " '
B (/(! (8+. , $ 8 ( M (-
A'
*
?4 4 ; ( " #
% ''9 C
)
5+
8
(
* I $! :" ' A' 3JJ3 % B ' . ! : > # 6 57 6M / D 34 ;V " ;3 ?4 4 < ) # + : 2 6 D ( ) ( 6 M / . ! ) ( L L 5 ( )(L % B# ( ( ( 7 6 ! C# ( ( 6 # " ! )- ( % Y B ( ' 7 ( ! C ( " ` 7 " A! A9 : - L ' O 3K
M
:# ) $ % 2(
" 9
3U
" 3<
" A5
7 " PM
-
"
(
" .
"
"
-
Q
A
-
(" 1
/
C
M
. 9
%
^G (
' [
B ( Q 34 ? ?< ! (
"
5 (
/
:#
# '- B [ ! AC - 5 % Y B - 6 3JJ4 ]
8 ( ?4 4 <
)
6 :
O () ( -
(
ZZ6 ( : 8
# (
6 B ( )- '
B ( 3JR@P . O ( 6
$ ( %
"
# (
0
' > ?4 4 <
-
-
( "
B
(
3K (
$
)
" ( +
9
& 5 (
-
-
5-
3R
,
>
9
(
#
\5
) $ 5
"
(
7
E
( 5
-
-
(
" ' ' ?4 4 3 (
2
$
9 (
(
( $
"
B $
)
#
A
-
-
H
2
&
(
+
0, (
2/ '/ )
% %# %
$"
&
( % D$ < (
#
% %
3
# 8 %
H IIP / !
$ + 5 ( ( " A< )
I $
(
@
A 3JRJ 3JJU
"
# 2$
-
-
# 0
& 5
J (
#
H > % D$ < C
# &
H IIP
< <
: ;U
0
0
"
"
R
ZZ .9
A(
'
> ( $ $
!
D -
N
#
+ , (
7
" -
8 ( B ( 5 ! ( ( ! A9 : - L ' O - 3JJ? ) ( + ' 7 :" ' A' 3JJ@P . O ( M L D ( ' ] B - A 6: ' 5^ ?4 4 ; P ) - B (5 ! ] L M L B - A 6: ' 5^ ?4 4 ; % < " 18 Cientista jesuíta, autor do livro O Fenômeno Humano, publicado há 50 anos. A UNISINOS celebrará o 50º aniversário da morte de Teilhard de Chardin no Simpósio Internacional Terra Habitável: Um desafio para a humanidade, a ser realizado de 16 a 19 de maio de 2005.(Nota do IHU On-Line).
((
1
5
"
$
! "
"
-
' 7 (
# "
;= !
, A
( 8 a @4
N :
-
' 61 #
-
-
7 -
9
. (
( ( ! . L
B ^ L
W (
W % 1 # W W 2 O L
:
W
0 W% .
W
B
-
WF
6
#
2 O L /C 8 > "
7
" # 3RR; 3J<K 3J 6 5 L D # . $ ! , ^ L . & 3JJ4 # 2 O L $ W W 2 " $ # 3JR4
N
> "
6
7
(+ > N 7 ^ L
^ L 2 1
"
W
W .
$ + 7 - )- -
( /C 8 >
!
(
N
/
G (
N
$
"
J), O $ )( , ' )+ ' + ,- / + Q3 B 7 % *(M O , $ @= # ?4 4 < ?4 4 ; 4 @= 5 # ' 61 ?U= ( D ?4 4 ; < # # C M 5 3JJ@ ?4 4 ? ? ;= B ( CM 5 # A 3JJ@ 3JJU 3JJR 3JJJ ?4 4 3 ?4 4 ? S $ # W (" W ?4 4 3 J), O $ 1 2 ') 1) ) /+) ?1) (7 1) ) * (* +) ( ; / (( 3 % *(M O % " ?4 4 < " $ ?4 4 @ . - ( # 3J
M
7
65 /
@
7
@$
QE 9 "
!
! E 9 7
( @=
# #
H8
"
7 '
+ *)
B
C
C
I C -
6 /C 8 9 : S8 : %
0
W $
#
@= W
2$
!
D
! 5
.
'
A W'
"
W + ( ) (! 6 ' ) * (* / E 9 $ )( ,O ! E 9 J), O ; / ! 1) ) ' ( * (* + ' ! = += ' )1 )( ' /+) * 2/ '/ ) ?' ) . = *)3 % *(M O 1 # @= ?4 4 < & N 1 $ " $ 5[ 6 + $ # # - ! ( - 7 ! ( ) # $ J), O * (* + ' 20 1 % *(M O ( "
(
*
(
) "
4 ) ' "/,) T *) 1 ,8' *) * U + *) ;/ =
*
# -
@= $ ?4 4 ;
P ?4 4 < @ @=
J= J= 3R= 1 D ^ -
#
(/(' '0 ,3 ! W
W
( ?4 4 <
0 #
CM 5
4 @=
' 61
?4 4 ;
4 <=
(
$
7
(
'
$
H
(
I
+$ $
&
" (
$
N
N
$
(
2 15 "
$
%"
-
H
(
I
6
N
2 6)' ) ) J), O )* % *(M O (
)4 7 * + C C. 6
)* * + C ., ; / ) ) +/,)4 7
/+) /' ) 1 ,8' *) * (
"
( ?4 4 <
(
J), O ; / 1 * () ( % *(M O 5 $ % 0 34
C. 6 ' 1) ) .,
)
(
* ?4 4 @
(
@)8(3 CM 5D
! #
( -
55@ -
U + *)3
) 68
)
+
6
8
M
" ) W ,
(
$
"
2
- W
7 -
(
"
S
(
(
. "
#
# 7
"
"
' "
$
"
$
( -
#
"
#
(
(
C. 6
(
J), O ( 2/ ( )' )1),-)+ * (* + ' % *(M O ! " 2 5 ! $ " " ' " "
6 / * (* + ' $
1
2/ 3 2
)
" 2
# 7
" #
"
$
" (
(
$#
"
( ' (
+ (
#
"
(
$
(
# " (
-
*
# "
"
"
#
( "
#
!
$
#
(
# "
6' 5!
1
3JJJ # K3= # A
$ "
1 " 0
!
#
( (
#
" A(
3@<= P
#
$
JK= P
" ?3U = 0 " 3<@= P
!
"
W $
" J;=
1 # " 5 , ! (
" "
1 ,8' *) * U + *) J), O + ( -
@=
W $ $
W R=
;= '
"
W ! K=
#
$
" "/,) @), ** = /+ + , '81 * V' ) ( ) ) 1 ,8' *) * U + *) 1 ' (')3
> *)
)W
,
% *(M O W + 7
: 0 (
# ( 8a @
(
# P
' +
8 a 3<@ ' ?4 4 < 0
S -
D
W # " #
. -
8 a ?U "
7 ?4 4 ; ( -
-
P 7
8 a 334 8 a K @ ?4 4 < $
"
:2 8 a 3< #
(
J), O +) ),' )4 7 % *(M O # 34 =
1 ,8' *) * ,
U + *) ( #
) +/ '
8* , '/+/,'/) )3 %" ( ( 5 1
( $ "
$
(
( G
(
1 (
$
( 1 N
5
2
!
"
(
W
W
0 0
1
(
-
-
-
" 8 a @4
$ "
7 0
J), O 6 .)( 1) ) ) % *(M A ( : (
* , . ) (/1 0 ' (*), 6 *) * + ) (' /'/ )9 7 = /+ ) ) 4 3 " ! W ( " ( W (
"
C
(, *)+ '
-
(
"
"
#
#
" (
' " 1 (
5 ,
'
$
(
( ;= (
$
$ 0
'6
) % +) )
(
$ ( # " $
*
$ ( 8 a @4 ' 61 % ( ' 61 $
R= 7
" "
( "
# 2 7 0
@
X %
#
" & )
.) (2 7 / 2 < 6
'
0
)
; ) 5
)
2
2
A( T
H II? /
;
$! L
0
[ E .0
@,) ') @ '
) % D2$ ;
0
I M
T D4 ! H II
#
, 6 @V
"
C2
:
9 - (
.
'
B
)
( + ()6 ( C2 # "
CD /+
/ #
(
( H
0
(
&
(
! #
2
2
( I /
!
#
#
+ $
& #
"
" 2
( -
$
*
-
(
$
(
+
" (
:
A
-
7 -
H C2
.
(
-
.
:
! ( 0
(
2
(
#
2
"
)
I
2
2
0 A
-
C )6+ ') 1) ) / % C2
(
B
(
( 5
-
-
6
!
( C2
"
C ( (
A '
" $
.
!
(
C2 -
) )(
$
K L3 "
-
7
( ! !))!5 - 9 -
" # .
-
[
( -
(
(
(
8 (
X
( ( "
( 5
C2
+$
(
7 H (; /
I
) (' '/*
),
!
(
"
"
H
" "
I
C2
#
5
"
?V
(
C:. ! # #
( ' T') '5 1 ':)/ % , 5
"
2
( ( 0
( H
(
': D T + ') ( D
C2 " %" '
( ':)/ (
' "
" ! (
B
') "
': D C2
I A /
B !
-
' ).),- ! )/( ' 7 ( " ( 2
"
( # 2
-
.)' ( N
( H "
"
%
+ +/ )
+/
2
C2
3
)
$
C2
-
(
"
5
/ -
2 $( !
2
(
; / ('7
1 2
"
"
Y LA #
(
F 7 (
(
" ! (
F B I
H
T % M
"
- I
"
"
"
. :)
! "
+
I
#
#
$
# 7
" -
%
" "
" H
!
( -
" #
"
-
"
8
-
$ 7 ( +
?4
)
.
C2 -
: .
+ .
$
"
-
! "
8
#
0 "
(
(
$
( B
M
"
"
8
) "
C%
(1)4 "
!
/+
+ ' 3 C2
" C:. #
0 (
"
"
/
(
"
( I
+
' !
+
C:.
H3?
2 +
" *
"
% ,' 1 ) % "
( -
(
C2
,
B
&
(
(
9
(
#
#
"
.
'
"
:
T
T H $ (
&
C2
I
!
( "
' (
C:.
'
(') ) % +) )
%
"#
%@
0 5 9 .D ' 7 + /
+
N
9
%
%
% 0 2%)$0
0 :
5
" & %@
% H
HP
& 0
0
D4 !
#
: 4
#
5
; 5
4
7 ;
?4
5
%
1
@ #
+)
7 $%
7 ( .
333V
) 7
' 4
(
& 0
Y %#
a ;
;
N
KJS?4 4 3 T / # " 3K (
# ?4 4 < %
!
'
! ( A! 6 " @Q
5
"
#&
PHM
'
H
H II?
>
4 :/), ) +1 'Z * ) ) ), G )4 7 (( CD /+ # , 6) * ' ?' 6, .), - 2 3 $ ) '/ ) % /() %) ' ( b * ) ( D " " 3JK4 " " $ ! # D 7 ' ! # D ) ( D " ( ( & + ! # ) ( D " " " " " ' ) ( D " " " M ( ( # " ' # # ( $ 2 ( ) ( D " V 1 (' + *8
W [ ( (( ; / ) , 6 7 / (), (+ ( )( + */,'/ )(9 ;/ * ' ./ ) * (' /4 7 )( * , 6 )(3 $ ) '/ ) % /() %) ' ( b ! $ " ! # " " " " ( ( ( C ( ( -
-) ) * ' ./8 ')+.=+ 1) ) ( ),( ( +) ) (( )* ' * / * + 1 # +
%
#
Z 6
A -
.
# /
:
"
2
N
$ (G +
2
!
" & $
1
"
'
$
" + (
( (
(
7 D (
"
#
' , 6 ) ) ' ) /4 7
#
(
(
#
(
$ $
(
!
2
!
#
D
+
" (
(
(
(
[ 1 ((8 ,3 $ ) '/ ) M $ + )
+ )(
,65 ( 1
)+ )'/)
% /() %) ' ( b ! ( (
%
" $ )
'/ ) ) ), ()
" 6
(
"
' " (
-
) *
(' /4 7
((
(" ( " #
/'
+/ (
$ #
#
7
( &
-
< ,, \ )H
[ ( (( / ) ' (/) 1), (' ) ; / (+ ' ) ' )( )( ' ( ( ' 6 9 ( ( + + ' ( ) ' 6, .), G )4 7 7 (7 +) (')4 5 ( ( (/2 ' ( ( * ) (! / K+/,' 7 L! ( ' + ( 6 3 , ( 7 * +)+ ) = ) B - < ,, \ )H K+/ ) +/ ( + ' +) 1 L3 + ( > (( 3 $ ) '/ ) % /() %) ' ( b ! ( ( ( 5 ) % ( ( # ( + $ 7 " ` ! # D 7 " ( & + 7 ( ( " 2( 2 : # # ] . :) " # # 2( % ( " # # # # " F B . M " # " # ( 6 B # " # ! ( # # ( ( ; 5 " # + " : # - # ( # " " ( E M Y L # + # " $ +$ ( C ( ( " ( * M Y L 2 " % " "
"
$
"
)
"
"
+
> - M - A
#
7
( Y L -
#
#
"
@ ; / ( - ' + )' G ) ) = ) ; / (/ 6 + +/ ' ( + ( *)(1 , ( ' ( -/+) ( ; / 7 ( ' ) ( +)+ + ' ( -/+) (3 $ ) '/ ) % /() %) ' ( M " " > ( 6 # F ! ( # 1 " " ( % + E F % ( # X% % ` $ <? * " " + M6 F '
"
%
"
+
:
+ ' ( " . / + ;@ "
" + " F 6
-
F '
+ ) # , 6) 1 )2/ ) 1) ) )+1, ) ( * * ' ( ) ' ( -/+) (3 $ ) '/ ) % /() %) ' ( 7 ( " ( : ( " A 2 ! ) ( ( 0 %" $ & " & " 2
/ +7
(2 '-H !
)( )(()(( ) ) 1 ] B -L :
+, (
33
$
1
8 a @4 .
1 (
-" ! (
2 8 a @4 4 4 ?; ? 4 @ 7
E '
( ! " 5
C (
B
-L 1 "
! - (
'B: -
7
$ #
5
! ;4
1
7 /
-
5
( '
7
?3
( (
" 'B: 7
(
% "
B (
'C
33 0
$ c
@@
1
d
'B: -
+)
9 +7 W1
1
8 L
W
'-H
+ ') ) , )( . + ) '/ ) 4 )( + " W 5 B -L : ( -" 3? # # ( ! ?; ? 4 @ 7 7 ( ( . K ; W1 # # W JA W1 " B W B -L ( . D ' 5 ! '! % : C ( 2 7 E C ( 2 B -L W 0 W D + C ( 2 & # AB 'B: ' B : ! M " ! " 'B: / 5 7 C ( 2 "
" !
8 L
7 1 &
W7 8 L
$
"/,)O (' /+ ' 5 - 6 (
( , ') ( + 6 ( ( .
(1 5
(
86 )(! ( 6/ W (
D
1 ! @
-L 5
$
( ( W !
#
(
!
?@ ? 4 @ !
E
(
( ( ( -
"
! :" 5
( D (
" K; ;3 @ 5-
# " ?4 4 @ ( -
" >
%"
2
(
-
"
. )
(
W
#
W:
(2
(
.
# " . !
1
2
W
( .) * ( ; / ), ) ?4 4 < $
?4 4 K (
(
W
( ( ( ' +)
9
$
"/*
+
(
+
$
# W $
( C
(
( 2 W W
W
5 W
W 4 )+ '
@ 1
2 1 E"
" ( ?4 4 < - ( ' 1 ?< ? 4 @ 5
( 0 8 a 3@ (
! '
?4 4 <
8 a 3? R
3U = (
# 0
( :2
1
6 0
(
-
-
'
8
(
"
?;
8 a ;R
2
B
?4 4 ;
3JJ<
" # 3444= @K4 =
% )
(
"
> !1. 5
(
) (* + )4 7 6 =' *) :
(
-
:
7 /!
" 0
"
8
( #
& (
(
3J ? 4 @
! (
!
:
5N
#
(
-
JR
4 7 /! ! (
& $( "
" 6(
( # (
#
-
"
( # -
2
" ( #
#
VR ' +)(()* W H (
WO W
G
W( \
#
!
( :
') ! ?; ? 4 @ '
!
:
I
A
(
+
'
W
$ eO
2
"
# fO f
6 ' $ ' (
e
-L
"
( 3@
f#
D
0 (
?4 G+
-
B fO f # (
$
> N
2
"/,) = /+ )*'D ! : (" , " & ! : 7 6
" fO
( (
'
0 (
W P
( ( " B
( K1)* ' L
" #
A H! (
#
%
f
" W
( &
I 7 &
( H A H fO
P
+
W
(
+
P -
(
( ( %
( P
W
(
(
"
\I
! ) +) @,8 H f g ( ( 5A I'
f
/ ) %)+1) f f#
" R
XI I' " -
2
" (
O ? FI T ( "
" B 7 E
-L 1 :" ' (+
#
?@
'
'
34 = ( " B X & '
8 a 3444
A !
( "/ 6 & /(() ! / ) . ( D " > - 8 ( ?; ? 4 @ ( '
+
( " -L C
( >
2 FI
+ ' +/ -7 ?? ? 4 @ D ( 9
" . ')4 7 2 . "
'
!
-"
#(
h (
5
( 2 ("
(
:
2 ( (
%
1
. $ )( ,
' +) +) *) */1/)4 / ! / " 7 #
( !
- C
! 7
(
6 9
! !
# !
(
W
#
( D
9
2
$ !
# >
( "
- C ?4 4 4
" (
3
W "
-
>
"
J 1
$ / " 7 /
7
#
(
2
e
) ?3 H%
^
.
$
2
" I7 1 ! "
\ +
F !1
( ( )6
2 -
,
#
W
0 -
( ?3 ? 4 @ W 1 $ W
W
6D* 5
7 = 7 (
/'/
?@
N $
!
/C 8 >
/ (
H +F H
" % (
U 34@
$ )( , (
i
( )
(
(2
!
(
(2
" #
#
$
1 (2 : (
(
7
D ?4 ? 4 @ 1 (
! #
X'
A A
(
(2 ! A
) 5 8
:"
"
#I % 2
(2
*
6
(
"
' (2
(
I ' ( F
.
$ I
D
" H (
%" -
#
'), )
$ )( , ) *) * H
1
$
C
0 6 " B
B ' ! ?4 ? 4 @ : (
I
> H 1
#
:
.
# &
+
(
9
:
-L (
2 ( +
5N
B
- (- (-
9
( -
I
C )( ( ) ( +) ) )
' P Ib .
N'
;
c
`/ &
;
R
0 0
; ,
5
&
( 7$
% . , ?4 4 < 4@
!
"
;
` O T B= U +
c
B :
;?4
N6 &
;
:
.
B (
: T
>
>
&
?3 ?
&
;
> ;
,
;
2
;
0
-
;
! ;?4
"
B
4
O T B= U + % . ,
B (
:
E
&
7$
?4 4 < T
; ITF $
:
:
# : .
:
N0
"
>
O
?3 ? 4 @
, 2)
H.
+ 0.)
?? ? 4 @
N
O
, 2)
H.
+ 0.)
IT
??
?4@
6
6D* 9 4
N!
@)(() /C 8 >
' N0
$ )( , 9
( /
O T ), (
9 D
(
/) ^ / 6 ! ?4 ? 4 @
) "
C ) 4 ( '' ) $ . I 8 9 # (
4 TF $
+ ?4 ? 4 @
O T
& #
H
5-
+) ' ).),- (') N)
4 C
27
;
')
5N
' 1 ,)
+
#
N%
9 Z T @)/,
: ! ?; ? 4 @
(
> ; , O T ,D ( %# 6 ' 07 ;
N0 4
*-)
((
#
! ?; ? 4 @
(
"/,) O TB 7
,
. :)
@
%'= , D T
"
" ?K ?
E
4@
(/* ((
T *-
N% ;
=
(
> ;
= O (
+) / #
N! # A
; >
"/ G
) , ( $ (( ( T
"
@ #
) (
5
C9 ! ?R ? 4 @
$
( '0 ) & ;
&
;
#
7
'
;
# &
O T "/8( )((
#
! ?@ ? 4 @
(
*)! @0(* )O @)(()6 + 1) ) ) , . ! /
8
) :
6
& & ' "
6M / "
7
. : 8 "
2(
+ 5
'
@ 6 )+)4 7 O
/ (
(
( 7 ( " 57 58 7 6 D ( 6M / 3?JV
M
&
"
:
!
( " VB V5 ! ' ( 9 . : 1 ?4 4 @
) 57 5!
B
( 6
(
7:)
5 # ( ' ( 8 ( 6
5
7
+
7
5
8
: )
( '0
6M /
7
9 M
/
?1 ( 4 7 ) ' (') %) ) A H8 " I ) A H7 : @ 8 O ; ;3 < 0 O 33- & ?3" *),O 7 5 6
. '
)
( 5
"I
M
/
?1 ( 4 7 ) ) ' (') ) (' ,) %) ' @ ) A H! : 5 I ) A H! : 5 I @ 8 O 4 ; ;3 < 0 O R- & ??" *),O 9 5 1 < = )( KB (/( * @), (' ) ' O ' 5 7 )O 34 < 0 O 3U - ;4 & 3J" *),O : 39 33J
5
< = )( K @0(* ) /( *), +) ) 0, ( )/ ' )L @), (' ) ' O ' VB Vi 1 ( )O 3U < 0 O 3U - ;4 & 3J" *),O : 39 33J
B
*R
/% 6C 6D
(' L!
) ' %* ( (
$)*- ) ) ')') $_ J Q! - (' ,)6 5
#
B -)
% .)(' )
$)*-
3?- ;4 ) 6 ,- ( 6/
*) )4 7 D 5 & 3J-
/
((/ :
( $)
9
O /% 7 : '
)O K (() + % + L! )L Vi 1 ( 5 O /% 7 : '
?.47 C ,+ O K )O ?; < 0 O 3K- & 3R- ;4 " *),O : 39 33J < = )( K @), (' ) ' O ' )O ;3 < 0 O 3U - ;4
)_
+)L
?.47 C ,+ O K M ,' +) ' ')4 7 )O 3K < 0 O 3K- & 3R- ;4 " *),O : 39 33J
/ 47 + ') * , . )4 7 1 * 1' @), (' ) ' O ' VB )O 3R < 0 O R- ;4 & " *),O : 39 33J
G
%7
)' /(L!
4 7 O /+ * ' /5S8 :
@8
'
@) , @)( , 9
) ' 1 , 6 )(L
K +)
" *),O :
O
39 33J
%
#
'
(') * + ) (' ,) _ '
$
Y
@
# %#
X
,
# 4
=
3
D
G
3 D > .H II? /G ) , ( S 6 G( + . FF / , = 3 S 2 2 D G V0 3 " < D 2 G ' Y X 6 T R
+
(
d
( 2 0 0 <& %
%#
*R
*R
'
Y
X R
8
>
) (' ,) _
%
T ,
D
= A) R ' .H IIH /G ( ) 3 + . FFF/G ( )
2
)
9
0 A
G _ _ 8T 0 6
H II? ) R $
G
H II 9 T G( 8 3 : 3
0 H III G(
+ (/ 6 / ) (/) '
))
C
T
(
G 2
2 +
G
G
G( FFF 88 (,
) ' (')3 2
-
. # -
"
2 2
(
H IIH
' 0
9
7
-
G 2
G)R
)
E
2(
2 D +
*)4 7 7
(
' > G< $
9
( )$7
H
2
(
I C
'j 1
(
!
+ *) )*' ) (' ,) _ *R ! 0 ) '2 ( " 2 ! ( k 5 " 0 ( " ( # :/ ' 1 *R 7 #
) (' ,) _
G) )) . )( # T 1d
3 7
;/ ), ( 3 D
5 2
) ( -
D
B
"
2 "
,6 ( ) (
(
, '
) (/) . )3 "
6
( )
"
#
/ ) (() * )4 7 3 ) 5 " 8 # ( " ' " ( " $ : !
!
@ ; / )*-) +1 ') ' + ' +1 ( * + ) @0(* )3
6( ( ' )G
5 2
# ((
5 '1
. ) 1) )
'
)
) (' ,) _
! -
*R
'
-
2
"
#
E k
!
'
5
#
F 5
$"
(
"
HC
+ )) ' *R ! ( #
) (' ,) _ !
)
2 ,6 ( )
IF
( / + )*
' +1 )
) 3
6
-
M
2
! $
!(
:
E
" F
"
@V
"
$
"
$ (
(
"
2
"
N
% +1D( -/+) )
'
)*
), #
) <). '0 ,9
2
6
+ 3K 3J % ) -
"
0
4
"
8
1
(
1) ) )
7
6
& 2 (
G
5! #
()
/ )
/ !
7
(
8
+
2
" "
5
3@ 8 a 3<4 4 4 " # AY Y Y S A l 6M /A @3 @J4 R<U <
<
M
?4 4 @
! / 8 a K4 4 4 3@ ! (
+
#
YYY 8 a R4 4 4
"
S
S
!
" 7 (
'
S
-
. ( 8 a 3?4 4 4 #
6M /A Y Y Y A @3 @J4 33??
/
= )( <
6 39 33J
= )(
(
M
/
6M / (
0
3U - ;4
& 3J- !
( !
" >
9 : * /
A . 9
L
9
# ( C
?4 4 @ , 5 ''9 5+ / ' 8 9
2$
;
:
! 8
: #
D '
& / : ' ( /C 8 9 : .
#
B 8
*
( D / ! ( : " ^ O $ A / 7
D
5 H .
/ I
5
!
6 (
9
#
"
<
?4 4 ; C * D
1
A
$
9
% 1
?4 4 < ?4 4 < : 3K (
E& &
@. %),)
(
! 0
"
2
/ @
= #! A! 1 ?4 4 ?P ( 7 AC .
:" ' 8
$! :# ( 7 A/ ?4 4 ?
D :
! % 5
.
1 " '/ ) ( 9
L
:
:"
= )( ?4 R<V " 3U ( # ( Q 34 ?4 4 ; ' ! ( A) 6M / 3U 333V "
?4 4 ; B # 7 (
?4 4 <
* ' (
' *) 1) ) ,/ ( (
&
+
3@
&
6M /
* ' ( ' *) 1) ) ,/ ( 3U - ;4 & 3J39 33J " # / (
(
" & (
" !
#
-
$ M
6
+
"
"
( "
'
: 0 / M ( ^ % + :
# /
?4 4 @ M (^ ( ' (
. : 5-
2$
U
/
5+ 5%0 /C 8 9 :
5 /
(
* (
'
(
( ( A
%#
@
%%
!#
%"
- (' ) <))6 T (' ( 7
(
H "
G
I
(+
"
( #
%
:#
Z 66
C -
( 7
" + M #
(
#
$
%
Z6
" (
2( 2( : L
Z 6Z
3J;K (
-
5
1
]
(
5
,
(
"
+ ( C
: L
-
$ $
A
"
-
(
"
"
(
(
( 2(
2(
5
"
2
!
"
2(
+
& ( 2(
(
2
(
(
+ "
8
2(
2( #
!
: L 2(
"
(
7
&
2
"
+ "
!
" +
!
(
2 *
7 D
+
G+ !
2
%
$ +
$
" "
( 2
!
+
'
$
"
+
#
" 2 $
:/) ') * + /,'/ ) 6
(
(
M
(
/
2 (
5
2 A :
" '
#
# D
! (
) +
"
'
5
7
7
5
5 # ! ( 7
6M /
(
1 :(5 :/) ') * + /,'/ ) ( ( 5 A5 7 8 . # 7 ( . 5
D
L
1 -
&
'
*,
( /
(
('/ ( / ('/
(
1 ()
"
1 ()
(
3J- ;4 YYY -
& ?3- ;4
( ,0(( * ( ) *
( 6 ( ,0(( * ( ) *
M +)
/
+) ?4 4 @ #
*, "
$
+
,
& P ( -
P
&
(
P
+
/
" (
"
.
7
/
34 ?4 4 @ ;@ *, ('/ ( 1 () ( ,0(( * ( ) * +)# 6 M / ( " 7 ! " ''9 5+ 5 / 7 ! " 5+ 5 : 5 # 7$ B 7 M 2 : : : 3?JV " ?4 4 @ ! # C m ( ! / 5+ ! / 5 34 + R ) D T ' B ): T /C C 8 > ! 2 / 5+ > 3J- <@ & ??( 3U 3< & 3U 0 S ( ' VB V! . 1 - T /: ' : ' ! ( " ( YYY -
?4 4 @
#
34
'
(')
= 1/., *) ) #
< -
"
"
!
%
6 7 B !
"
I ! 7 2(
E
M
/
E D
5+ 7
,
:
5 39 33J
6M / 6
-
# "
+ ?4 4 <
n 3?< ?? " 6( #
# A H!
/ ''9
?'
<4 Q
!
"
3
#
!
AY Y Y
"'+"!" ,. ' $ -( -
+ #
( 9
! #
) ;U
0 <
+
# (
4 &
,
5
9
-
'
,
5
#
:
>
)
:
'
8
#
:
# 4
;
;
# )
6 ( . 7
0
-
"
-
-
(
# "
.
2
"
) D
5
C +)4 7 C 5 " 7 2 (
"
' /5S8 :
(
" ) "
-
7
: -
!
5 )
"
# (
A) :"
0
)
7 -
(
( 7
N
#
+ "
-
$ (
7
# - (
"
$
7 "
"
(
M 0
$
#
1 A H1
0
I # )2 'D ) 7 5 " D (
# 3JJ@ 2
-
B ! : 7
5 (
B
'
> ! ! (
7
(# )
( ( #
# !
)
7
/
" ( C :
6(
1
-
'
6 3JJU
! ( 9
5
C .
9 8
.
-" :
0 (#
C >
5 -
2
" : /C : 5 %
)
( -
!
# ! D
+/ *)4 7 ),' 5 ! ( 5 5 + ! " "
)' ) % - . 6( 6( 5 - % 2 S " ! D5 ! D5 D ' . # "
( 5. 6 %9
( C 6( 5 0
( " D -
$
+ .
! (+ (
5 D
! !
" "
#
D $
(
-
6(
+ ' ( +) *) ' ( ! 3JJR m
%
.
!
#
5 -
2
$#
+
-
` 0
: .
. 5. 6
7 :
-
Y -
.
5 3JJR
7
(
`
-
5. 6
C
-
"
M
# `
:
-
(
%
C
(
! ^
$
+
!
# C)+8, ) : # 7 7 " ( /
) > 7
+6) "
.
(
(
! " -
(#
A! 0
.
C ,+ (
-
. -
P 0
-
A! >
- . ]
-
]
%"
(
+
$ 7
(
?V ( - % -
$
0
/(
2
=0
( )4 7
7 >
9
( D
&
/
2 ( " 1 O PM E!
P
& (
) 7
/0 ) 8
+1 ( ' % "
"
(
' 7 /! P F )
-
:" D -
1
)( - )( ,
> B
?3
( !
7
?K
'
-
)/'
2
#
-
/
(
(
!
(
"
#
' "
#
!
#
F '
F :"
7 5 (
" : ( 5- (
/
" # "
" ! /
+
"
5
#
> -
#
?4 4 ; #
6M /
<
"
"
%),)
#( 6M /
-
/
%2
" '/ ) W6 D
7
-. ! ?4 4 ? @4 U ( " $
9
:"
(
'
A5
"
(
B !6 @ ( "
' (
-
-
3JK<
( (
-
(
-
-
N
"
-
" ( &
1
E
(!
=
=
!
&
! /0 ( C
+
W7
. (
:
:"
!
0 $"
= '
A 5 : #
"
(
:
A
(
(
. " &
&
& 3JU U /
) ')(
(
= !
$" " ! = - A! ! = !
% (
( &
(
( &$( - B -
$
f /0
! $
D ?4 4 ; 34 K ( 3J;; ?4 4 < ) ( . ( " $ #
fW -
3 ! =
.
, ' ' :
"
= 6
M
/ (2 (
57 > 5
B ?4 4 @
! ' B 8
> " C ( 2 5 #( 7 >
( "
33
>0
5 ?4 4 @
-
&
5 ) M
-
0
/
'
+
#
6
6M / 5
&
N (
8
8
58 1 %
$" 8
(
:
(
-
B
(
5 6 . '
(
1
"
-
:B: 5
+
8
(
1
58 1 %
X :
0
&
( .
6M /
' ! D 5
Y@
#
5
"
5
5
:
% 6
$ / $
D / 86 % ! +
.
e e
TC
6M / 7 "
7 ( -
X '
O
e D
: ( "
T' 8
0 e .
C2
.
#
+ M
! (
9
)- ( ) Bf
86 % ! $ 2 M .# ! 4 ' 5 . ,) 0 ( A
'
$
8 6 % 1 86 % 1 86 % A 2 8 & : . e . e / 3 A 8 & : 0 ' f . e / ' P LF 3 : Y . : [e e / ) A 5 (, HM % ( A % FP I 1 0 + D A P PF HH 1 $ H A L? FP
%
T / A
#
< / 2 / $
>
A
0 + : 0 A 2 M
) [[[ $ 0 ) (2 F? IH H III H ( 86 % A