!" # $ !" # $ ) +
% & *
( . # /
& " / 2
, +
0
1
1
3 $
. .
6-
3
7 (
##
6
3 #
3
4 6-
! " ) + !!! "
(
3.
3 7
5
! ) ! +
$
.
-
. 1
$ -
( $
6 2
& '
)
)
/
6
#
8
6
/ 9
3! 8 ! 7
+
:
-
63
"
6
$
6- ! / : ) ) !
3
-%
'() * +
+ . 4 0 /5 - ( 0
; -
/
- #
,
-
)
/
,1 ,
$ ) 3 #! +
0 -
-
4
.
+
-
B
3
/ : ?@@A5 1 ! + $
=> #
3 +
; <
0
- ./
<
-
!
$ 36
.
%&
+)
1
"
%
! 12 2
3
3
!43
5
2
#
!
6
43
!
" # !" # $ 7 8 3 9 #6
# ! 3 # !9 2 43
$
! 34 3
!" # $ 9
$
%
!#
#
&
# '
"
%
& ( %
&
$ *
"
+
"
' - . ,
"
!
,
'
( %
0 ' ( * 1 (
!3 5 ! 3# 35 !
)
"
, /
) )
3
0
' '
1 - "
" 2
: 5 43# ! 1 2 ; 3 ! 3# 3 !43 ! &!" # $ <; &= >! ! # 24 2 ! 5 5 24! 2 #3 !49 5 # 3 3 35 3 5 3 # 35 !4 # 3!3 5 4? 3# 6
2
3 / 1 -
43
4
$ 5$ 4 / 6 -
"
7 %
/
0 "
8 -
% $ 4/ $ 4/
1 " 4
8
12 @ ! ; &@ 3 ! 2!43A ! # 9 2!3 ! !" # $ ! ! 2!43A ! 6 2 43 9 7 4/ 1 ! 8
"43 !# $ ! # 424!
1 "
"
-
*
"
5 6 :5 !#3 2 !
B 5!
1 -
,
(
(
"
1 -
2
C2!4 8 ! 3@ (
43
!
! 3# 3
!43 ! -
-
!3 3 ! 6 !
:; $ 4/
( ,
4 3
/ 1 -
$ 8
$
'
2
4
/ 1 ( -
( ,
8
1
1 -
1
2
*
< 1 -
12 2
3
8 : # 42 1 -
43
)
!3 !
7
"
-
(
#
2? !
3 &!
,246
<
( 8 -
/
0
)
"
! /
8
" 0
% + ( %
"
'
/
@3 2 ! !" # $ 5 ! # 3 &! ,24 8 # 3 ! !6 % /
! !" # $ ! 8 # 2 43
2 !
! # 2
! !# $ 3 !9 !3 5 43 3A ! D
0
-
!
%
/
"
"
>
!
%
1 #
+
/
0
7
? 1
"
0
=
! #3 !
-
-
1
<
-
%
)
/
0
0
%
-
&
3
-
8
1
%
/
" -
0
-
-
1 -
-
2 <
-
-
"
8
0
2
8
1
,
2
@
C2!3 9
43
-
5 3 # 35 !3
1
!@3
%
!
6
? 0
/ 1
8
,
@
-
1
-
* 1
7 (
% "
0 '
-
./
*
0
%
/
0
./ & '()
3 !# +
'
/ " -
/(
" -
!
E
-
/ 8
(8 ! &2!A A 443 0
1
##
( . !"
C ) *+,-*+.-/ + 0 ( ?@@DE F ( !, C =7
1 2 1 ! = AHHH!
# $ %& 13
>+
/ !2!
. $ ' #*456 *446! G !
-
, (
+ ("
$ =" !
,1 1
/(
+
1
##
(
) $
? J K ? 5! )
3 7 (%
=
1
.
,1
,
-
$
C2!3 ! !" # $ ! 34 3 ! 43 4 3 2 !6 (8 ! &2!A A 443 $ " 1 "
3@ ! ! 2 !6 ,
!
!@ !2
!# !
'
8
!! !" # $
!" # $ ! 3 2 8 2 F 2 F 1 2 @!A !
. $
A +
A
A
A
A 7 !
-
A
" A
-
A
C: DE A" " A CFE ;
A
B 7
-
- A
" 0
" 1
A
,
B A
A A<
' 1
C: CC
) I I 4? J ? ?
(
8!
F "
" " A
A
- A
A
@
-
"
8
* >
7
$
(
&
F 8
5> 0
/ G 6 B A
6 %
A
H
" !
- A
&
! A
)
C
!
0
7 -
!
&
2
0 %
A
$
1
& II
= J -
! )
A A "
% /
A A J
-
A
, 1"
/ >
H 1 '
8
1
A
I 2I < "
A @ 7
"
- A = 57 ! > 6 / G A A A ) % / 0
A
> ) %
A
"
A
%
8 0 5@ A
"
B
7 ! > A 1 A #
)
4 0
D; 8
#
%
, L
H
= /
0
" 4 8
$K <
$
Sobre Simões Lopes Neto, conferir a edição número 73 de IHU On-Line, de 1º de setembro de 2003, matéria de capa.
, ! ! G! 25 34$ !9 @3# 3!43A ! !9 ;343 ! 9 8 2 ! ! 5 3 # 35 !3 @ ! 3@ 2 ! + ! 346 (8 ! &2!A 443 0 > H M; A A ) 3
!
D
HIJ9 !# 3 !43
:3
. "
3 ?# 3 ,9
E
"
" ! II
%
"
C: N E
'
2 '
I 2I 0 C: E ; "
'
-
H
"
, CFE M
50
%
/
$
-
P
"
0
"
0
' / *
-
E;
!
CF: Q 8 7 8
O
=
' 7 8 0
6 ,
%
&
0
' ! ' !
$ /
%
" %
1"
J -
&1
$
-
'
7
B
1 @
CFR;
CFQ ;
"
$
4 8
, &
9 ?
A 1 - A
?
%
>
" 3 - .
! "
"
-
"
* "
/ 1 7 A - A
%
1"
%
/
H
1
! "
% -
2
2
" # # 24 K ! 3 B !" # $ ! 1 2 4 3 3@3# ! $ > 6 (8 ! &2!A 443 " A , A ) A A " 1" ) 8 A " 1 - A "
S ) %1 G* "
2
3@
3
" # -
3@3# ! B " " T U
" -
# ! ! 8 5 # !6
" < #
@ "
"
FR
8
,
1 7
" 4
/ 1 - . A -
" *
A
, 1 -
.
"
I 2I
"
"
H
"
- - " #
. " <
,
@
*
.
H -
H
-
!
-
!
2 2 2!3 ! (8 ! &2!A 443 $ V
!" # $ 3 9
3 3@3# ! 12 #
4! 3 ! 2 A
B
, K
/
!
1 V "
QC
%
3# ! 9 5 3 # 35 !4 ! 6 A A , 0
# A
U3
4
"
8
-
!3 # ! 34 3
6
* . '
,
5 7
1 8
!
3
!
-
8 * A $
A -
H '
-
7 *
-
,
-
!
7
/
A 1 - A -
.
" G
!
A -
-
A
A
%
7
/
/
0
#
A
8
A @ !
A
5
A
6 (
"
,
( # ! !# 3A ! 3! (8 ! &2!A A 443 ( % / # A# '
!
A
- A
8 -
* 1 - W
%
A
0 "
! 2!4 1 2 A 8 > . "
,
" L 3
! " U
A
6
A 8 B
$ ? ,
<
H
( !
? A 1 - A
0
@ !
"
@
A
,
A
( ! >
%
/
.
8 -
-
8
4' 8 @
/ 4
% 5 46
'
5
8
7 @' 8 % ) A 4 6H
0
8 -
4 8
4 (
A
<
)
< -
5
=
6 .
1
0 %
4
;
" -
E;
(
3 !# # / / /,
0
,
1 1
(
,
/
7 A 1 - A
A
A-
.
A-
A
" !
M N; , &
( A?
3
,
E.
. 1
(
,
E
,;
) 1
1
5
! C
. L
89
(
+
=
?@@ME
) O
1
. -
7
)
$N
4 $ F
: 3
57 0 4 6 A A -
!2 & 43
2 $ 2 ! +
4
/ "
3 3
!
F
)
P
,D 3# ! 5 ! ! 3# 3 !43 ! !" # $ <; &=9 # ? 9 ! 2! 5 3 # 35 !3 # ? 3# ! 6 !2 & 43 !
#
( $
Q! 2 #
2
K # ? 3# ! ! 3 7 ! D C2!3
!
9
5
6
( (
#
8 -
. !
O
P
8
) !
"
" (
!
"
8
!
! 8
,
"
-
8 (
.
$ 8
!
" -
$ 8! 0 O
" -
P
" -
!
8
1"
-
"
! 3 B 3 4 3A ! ! D %3 5 4 2 5 #2 D # 24 2 ! !" # $ !D 1 2 !2 & 43 ) % /
9 ! 3 ! 9 5 L 3# ! 3 ! ! 9# 1O 9 0 ! ! 3 B !" # $ ! 8 ! 2 3 !9 !3 ! 1 2 5 ! # 3!4 9 , D # 3 3# ! ! 3 3@3# ! 12 ! 3# 3 !43 3 5P K 3 3@3# ! ! 4 #3 6 0 CFR; X "! / * / 1 II " " -
I 2I
8
( )
"
! !
"
*
0
X
" ,
8
,
# ?
$ !
!
!
! '
7
,
>
1
7 <
@ "
% *
$ $ P 8
-
" !"
<
& 1
-
O
* $ 7
!
! 2
1
- " -
- "
O
"
P 8
,
? ( # 3 # 24 2 !4 #
5
, D : 5 43# ! ! 5 R 6
3 Q # 3!
# 24
K
! 3 B
!" # $ !
#
L 3
B
!2 & 43 " ) O/ *
/ 1 -
P
I 2I
II
# 22 / ,
)
"
- " "
)
!
"
8, 8 ? >
8 1
3
$ " "
8
*
1
1
)
" #
8
,
@
"
-
, * !
3
* #
!
5
" 6 $ 8
"
8
-
?
" * , D5 8
!2 & 43
1 3! ! 2
:
-
5 4 5 L 3#
! :5! ,
$
P 3# !6 "
-
,
/ O
%
< O P
O 0 )
%
"
> / 8 *
P 0 8
P
-
-
0 O
! O " P
( O
P
*
5
6 -
8 " # !
-
"
0 !
P O $ 4/
P "
-
8 %
-
/
( '
-
"
"
"
,
G
< 8
@
1
-
" !
1 ( ! 3# 3 !43 !2 & 43 0
5
3! #
O O
"
!4 $ 3 7 3# 3 23 5 ! ! ! # # 8 P O
2
# 3!3 !" # $ !5 5 3! 2 ! #3 ! 5
5 4 3 !6 <
P
P
9
" 8
@
" !
1" " O
O
P
P 8
O
!
8
P 8
8
"
, !
2
!
!" 3
!,
N
, N
,
! ! E
&;
&N
# R
3
3
!9
3
=
8
7 ! AHHT!
F 3
F P " R 3 S! ? A ?J $ > ( 4 $ 5! 6 $ : $ $ ! %
( + + C % Q 1 3 ( + C % ! AHHT! R 3 ( ) ) ( !* ! ;4 ) 5! / / )
)
1 ( & 8
1 & 8 "
"
!
!
</ ) =
5 D6
7
"
/
)
1 8
Y "
X
"
"
B "" - "" 8
-
,
-
3# ! !
7 & 8
, -
! 8 3! !
1 3
<
2
3
2
-
-
& 8
! S
3 "
C; 8 CC
/ "
M;;C
>
& 8
1 3
(
,
N !5 3 3 !5 # 5 ! 5 !
2
5
)2 3 -
#
-
CFFD 2
" 2
0 3 / - #
/
B 8
&
) ,
"
, *
N .
"
* !
* 8
, *
, ?
2
, B ,
! -
E #
" (
.- Referência ao n. 12 da revista (março de 2003). Multitudes é uma revista francesa trimestral. O grupo que a edita se define como‘coletivo editorial transnacional que tem como ambição intervir de forma criativa no debate intelectual, político e filosófico numa perspectiva de transformação e libertação social’. A revista tem como assíduo colaborador Antonio Negri e intelectuais que se identificam com o seu pensamento. 3 .- Alain Joxe é especialista em estudos de guerras estratégicas e contemporânea. É presidente do Centro Interdisciplinar para a paz e estudos estratégicos (CIRPES), sediado na França. Filho de Louis Joxe, Ministro de Charles de Gaulle e irmão de Pierre Joxe, Ex-Ministro de François Mitterrand. O seu livro L'Empire du chaos (O Império do caos) foi publicado pela editora La Découverte, Paris, 2002. O livro não foi traduzido para o português.
8 # $
) ,
-
,
<
#
3 B
!
"
$
, 8 5 (
6
O
P
7 8
,
"
( ,
"
*
5
( " *
"
( 4 ) (
2 !5 # 5 #$ 12 # 3 343A ! B
5
!
.
S @@4
!
,
6
4Z 6
5
.
, ?
"
* ,
8 ?
-
0
8
( !
" ?
5
6
-
" ! (
5 6
!
. /
0
*
?
X
*
"
(
1 9
(
-
D
& "
)
-
!
5
6 <
( (
4Z
"
B O
P
"
"
"
?
?
)
[
.
?
-
5
!
-
6
# 3 !5 # 5 3! 2 34!
!43
!
3# !
$
T !# U -
"
K =
5
Y
MC
P 5 \9 % 0 0
P 6 ) 8
"
O
P
P
@ 8
" " <
" 8
" " " G
= Y
"
. 9
W
!
( )9 $ 8
C;
9
"
( )9
ME
"
CFFD 5-
6
J*
. ,
[
?
-
[
"
, " "
" !
!
8
(
(
,
"
"
,
9
3 " (
"
! 8 3! !
P
O
, " " " " 3 "
CFFD O
6
8
3# ! !
@
& 8
8 ,
<
(
"
5
6
"
*
5 6 (
" " * "
9 8
-
1
" !
"
" O 8
P
,
"
5
6 *
" "
#
!
! 1 235
+2 $ ! 3# !43A ! ! ! 5
# 5 B
!
3
& 8 ' -
,
"
* % -
] 5
T
*
8
* 0-
, 6
? "
O " 9
!2 3 N
8 4 ! ! 4
!
P
2
2 43 3 '
-
' *
"
-. 7 " 8
5 < ( " "
"
6
"
. ( .
( 8
,
!
0-
8 2
9
2
1
.
8 H
"
* "
-
! 8 3! 8
!4$ ! ! (
]
T
1
M
8
9
"
" "
<
" *
"
"
5
"
Q 5 34!
!
3# ! !
G
6 8
! 8 3! !
. 9
8
@ , ( CC
" *
>
!
9
8 "
<
" 8
,
*
7 "
7
8
#
$-
1
6
*
" " -
5
"
( 1
. !
-
8
" 8
! ! *
$
) 1 5
;
5 43A !
! !
>
2 9
*
#
$-
!
6
47 3#
>
" " "
!
9
*
8 "
N
2
3
2
! "
8
-
.
" O 0
P
"
?
& 8 " " ,
-
!
<
-
5
,
6 2 (
2
0 "
" "
*
@
9 (
"
,
2
V
G2
!3
5 @
5 3 Q # 3!
! !-
!
25! 3 P 3
(
%
* ?
RM ; " - , " >
M;;E 0
P
,
'
( 7
>
-
-
*
%^
$
6
O0 1" (
" %
-!24 @!A #
5
>
5
> M;;D
;
8 % ^ M;; " -, FF;D
*
% ^ M;; " -, " ? >
"
% ^ RM ; " - , 1
M;;EP - W J
! 1 2 ! 2 2L 3 1 2 !2 2 3# 3# 4 !
?
0
* N; :N
M;;M 0 M;;D DDF Q
-, FF;D
> C F_ -,
.
M D_
DDM F
-,
!
3
.
ME Q
8
9 7
?
2
? 6
4
9
2
52
@
*
*
!
8 "
(
-
8
3#
5
! 2 3
!
3 !
O0
' -
1"
-
! -
@
!
" M;;C 0
2' /
P 2 "
@
>
)
) !
0 -T FF;D 0
" 8
2' /
) @ O
C; _ % ^ RQ;; 8
CC E _
* H
1" 1"
% ^ R: M
*
DR R_
*
) "
Q R_ P ( 1" R; _ 1" ,
O
" -
8
. " -
DM _
" -
(
,
1" P ( 1 "
$
. O( -
" 8 1"
" 8
1" 2
1"
! ,
" 8
@34 3
%
P
! !4$ ! &344 # (
40 3 5 3 ! # !
B
L
4 "
P
/
2
/
$ %
Y
-
&& -
(
@ \
P
-
8
O 8 -
`
O " FF;D
0
/
. O>
1
$ -
O "
-
P
"
"
P
(! # " M 53 3
# 3 W
2 8 5 ! 5 5 24! @! #
! 4
!43A !
! ( "
EM_ E F_ -
7
-
4 9
> -
;(9 @! 53 3
5
O
3 2!4 ! !
(
7
! X@ 3# !
,24
$
-
1 "
\ QM_
7
" 9
9
(! # "
X ( 7 $ X
! 8
* U\ 7
X( 7 $ X $ 1 * ? ` \ \ " N D_
"
8 @
$
E F;D 7 ` ` -
8
-
S
8 *S CQ
1 9
8 .` !
1
!
"
& "
"
-
8 ( 7 $ 3 ( 7 $
8
,
!
S 0 ( 7 $
. 7
( 7 $ "
3# 24 2 ! 8 2 >
! (! # "
O0
P a
0
"
-
,
9 1
"
4
"
-,
*
.:; / C; F ; D
P ( ( 7 $
8
3 2!4 5
/ " ' &3 4
0 > C; F ; D
&3
3 Q # 3! $
# 3! 5 3
*
"
&3
-,
M;; '
" 8
!3 !
?
b C; F ; D
"
)! . O( ) ! " "
5
" ( 7 $ "
6 ) "
) )
!
-
! ,
/
"
( ! S ( ! ( 7 $ $
, , "
N (
2 @!A
!
)
2 8 5 ? 4 5! !12 3 !# )
!
P
!6 ! (
-
"
1: 6 >
) 7
!( 8 S $
4
!
= $ "
4 $
;( ! YJ 34$ B
8 "
3# 24 2 ! 5 !
. &
2 3 !
,
) .O
P
-
. 1 \
$
S 3 , ' 8
< <
"
,
!
,
SP (
< !
. `( 7 $ .
S (
" +
M;;D " ! . O0
" -
8 =
!
*
3
-
(
*
"
+ : R; ! !
8 * O -
-
*
"
)
M;;D
-,
" > ( (
9 ?
!
0
CC " - ,
-
M CQ ;
" * ?
.
8
"
- "
8
<
<
-
P
! 53 3
!
2@ # ! @ !# V 8 + 8 ! ;( (
$ $
@ -, !
CFFQ )
C; F ; D " O ( 7 $ ! "
&& '
1 "
"
&
' < :;;
" : R; ,
" 0 -
!
(
*8
,
3
< ( 7 $
$
"
,!4 ! E3 !
"
)
1
"
8
G*
P
44 MN
-
CF; : X 0
CFM Q X
0 !
/
J
>
7
8 7
CFDM X > CF " CFDD X & CFDQ X 3 CFDN X CFDF X $ B CFDF CFRM X 3 7 $ CFRM X 3 CFRQ X 3 0 CFQ C X $CFQ M X 3 CFQ : X 3
!
!
`9
$-
\
8 ! ` `> ' 0 1
0
$-
\
\
$#
0
B >
`
0
$-
`>
\
" \ %
1" >
`>
$ " \ ( "
X `>
QM \X
!
& CFN C X
9 \ !
Y $-
/
`
CFN R X
< >
CFN N X R
@
*
%
1"
>
>
$ 0
"
CFE D X )
`9 ,
@ MR
DN D_
\
@
4
$ "
CC
CFE D X ( $ "
)
%
1"
CFE D X 7
CQ D
= 7 -
! L 43
#! ! ! # !# 3! # $ 34 ! ;! 2 4 &! 7 9 # 37 4 (
2 3 5 !# # $ 34
-
!
8 3# ! ! 3 !
"
CC
"
CFE D O
= PX CC F ; D
-
7 ( " 0
/
9
$O H ?
!
" B
H *
8 <
#
P
7
/
O
9
#
! 7 3! ! L 3
P
3 ! 2
#
3 !
(
! 34 3
) . O)
'
1
&
"
CC F ; D
>
M; 9
!
! 8
! 8
" *
"
'
!
, (
"
!
8
-
@ Q_
N_
M;;D %
, "
8
$ M;;D
8
8
-
-
1
" *
C: ;
,
(
5
5> 7 2
M;;C 6 !
! 8 6 5% "
* >
Y
`=
K $ " -,
Z3 # $ 5 3
"
"
\ =
)
DC
M ; ; D6 90^ M F
>7 2 P
! 3 ! !# # ! ! 7 3!9 !#
G; 8 @!
(
L
4
>7 2
=
CC F ; D
>7 2 = >7 2
$
-
8 > `
"
< " 8
P
=
\
D_ -
)
M ; ; R O( > 7 2 ' " ,
!
' RMQ_
7
"
"
, !
-!4 # # 3 4 @ Z3 # $
=
`
\
! L !5 3 K @!4 ! 43 !
"
,
% " 7
" > "
=
,
2
0
>
c
!
> $-
3 ! M2
> -
"
0
7 8
Z3 # $
"
=
" = =
!
3 ! 24!
( 7 0 2 7 = " -,
8 0
*
J
c % > 8
=
" $ ? "
90^ M F
, a
9 "
4
G; # 3!
@3
O@ 7 2 MCF " -,
,
-
>
5> 7 26 9 0 ^ CM Q " - ,
90^ ! 3 '
c
)
-
7 % "
=
" P
CM F ; D 1"
O
> c
M;;Q
D_
2'
RQ_
>7 2 (
" "
G
, c
-
P 0 8 `
"
"
O
,
\
"
*
!
> !
" -
3
( 1" ]
-
" 5
+ ! 34 N !#
"
"
RQ_ M Q_ ) 1
G; 5!!
#
8
2' 6
'
!
!
P
3 !
O
'
.
>7 2 8
R_ RMQ_ 5
DEQ_ "
1
8
! "
D_
' !
>7 2 8 6 4
- P $ c
>7 2
* 8
% -
CM F ; D
>
3 ! G; N 5 3 @4 : (
( " CM F ; D .O CFF; , >7 2
>7 2 0
>7 2 !
?
3 P 9
8
! . O(
>
8
4 3
# #
-
G; @ 3
7 ,
( P
8"
3 !!
" !
' !
. O3
"
.
P
# ZS $ 4
5 0 B
' & CM F ; D O "
c Z( !
>
"
9 0 ^ F; " - , 8
c Z0
,
. `
-
8
,
-
9
)
5> 7 26
c
! >7 2
-
! \d
>
c Z8
"
)
!
P
3 !6
O( =
-
8 " ,
!
8
,
9
+ ! 34 !5 3 2 2 3 !12 [
2 -
" ,
7
2
=
c 0 >7 2 c \d 9 P
`" " .`
*
=
< "
!
' & CM F ; D
\
G; 5 3 # 2 ,!3! >2 ! 5 ! !
! 34 3
4
$ !
!
`( > 7 2
"
' & CM F ; D
\
"
> 7 2. O
* >7 2 8 * ( = -
8 )
'
)
c
"
"
D_ "
-
\ RMQ_
= 2'
c
( '
'
1 >7 2
#
(
3
-
( ' -
G*
$
> 7 2\P
O "
7
'
@
= = 9 " 5$ ? " 6 " ?
# 4! ! # # 42
! 7 3! 8 2
c
-
( " "
(
> 8 57 8 "
6
6
=
CC !
"
>7 2 2
2' 5 ! MN
!
1"
' *
@
!
W 2' P
8
( ! " 8
!
CF e
" !
W 2'
!
" O
f
!
MN
1" "
!
CM F ; D (
M;;M
>
!
6 >
CFE ; !
0
!
" ! !
3!43
5$ -
P
*
;(M # 4
=
2A ? 3 ! 2 G;
@
!
" >
?
`0
4
-
8 (
"
0 "
"
4 `
-
)
CF C;
!
<
53 3
2 !3 -
4 # 2!4 3
3! !
% K
> 0 CM F ; D ( 7 $ J 0 ! cK B " ( 8 " ! ( 7 $ 2
$ $
1
* c
Y
N;; = "
" -
c -
7
M;;D !
&&
g . "
! g -
0 O2 g
) 9
2
8
G!
g
'
( 7 $P
!,
! !
5
3
O)
? =
!
&
24! ! #
" $ 27 2 X >
" P X$
(
"
>
! -
#
2
7
7
/
X X
FF;D
( 3 3 !43A ! A -
;, , "
" -
A X7
!
B
e
&
-
(
! "
f + " X> -
0
CD F ; D G3 O3
3 12
!
2# !
6 " 0 " 4
"
( )
7
X 3 $ 3
P X $
'
' & C; F ; D
5 " 43# 5 ! ! !
OB 2 7
"
3 !
# 4! 5 " 43# ! % ^ CQ " @ 1" X >
" !
1"
P X$
'
CC F ; D
G;
O
3 >7 2
5 X
6 ' & CM F ; D
P XB
c Z-
O
-
P X)
c
-
! >7 2 F;D
*
"
X
' & CM
! !#$ N ; , * (N
,
/ ! +) 1 " > 0
6 0A ! $ ?@@H!
89 "
)
E ,
=8 -
0
V $
3
=
( AHH? )
3
3. , 2
3 8 (
8 /
8 /
!8
"
. -
+ %
3 ?@@D ,
?@JD L 3
V3
3
1 3 > ?@M@! A !2 = C ( ( F AD! % A : 7 = V =8 (
7 = ! C : !
B # E ! H @ J ! 3 :
3 3
3
3
-
&
U
& 3 AD 3 1G 1 &I =
=
$ -
"
>
#
-
AHHT!8
1
,
1
?@JA! / 0 % = 8 ?@@T! + U AHHH!
.3
,V
& V3
< -
3
L
6 # !8 -
?@@D L
W # !8 L "
, XF 8 ?@@J <
1
! , 8! "
*
.
"
<
< -
" $
B
# &
'
5B
B
! B &
V
- "
-
'
6
(
*
"
"
< ,
0
&
"
8! 5
D;
6
%
-
0 - Y
) )
7 Z
-
" ,
7
C;
CF; D & > "
"
3 B
'
!
0 "
B "
(
# 3
' %
"
CFM :
" B #
"
! B
.O P
"
&
.
" P * " CFDD &
B & 5 6 B P
O
-
.O "
-
-
=
CFDQ
-
<
, " 2
CFRD
B
4
=
' -
]
7
B "
"
a
2
CFRQ
-
7 Z )
-
O
- "
` -
3
&
=
!
\ 7
CF: R &
8
@ -
8
"
-
-T *
-
"
-T
`
"
\ -
P
-
-
<
X
!
@ 9
2 -
CFQ Q
&
$ ) T 0 -
-
0
%
-
)
L
Y
1
3
. 7 "
B
-
"
#
! B
< " 5 3 # ?5 3
5
& "
! 343 !
CFE F B
"
"
<
!
-
)
&
-
.
-
X "
X
8
O
8
P5
6 &
, ,
)
. O "
" H
" #
<
! B "
!. !
B
< -
!
! "
P 0
& "
#
)
"
! B
&
"
8
?
"
"
O -
P
%" % N 3# 3
,
L 3
,
. ,N ;
8 3# ! @34
@3!
) 8 3# !
* @3!
@34
+
!4 @ 3 ! 2A 3 "
5 2 43# !
5 4!
3
"
$
3# 3 7
$
0
,
:Q
-
7
"
QD
DM D
" -
"
,
!
MQ; %
$
0
L 3 "
8 MR
CCM "
3 !
9
!4
CE Q $ ED 0
! !N 3
B
'
% h
B
& '
, 0 -
T
K !
-
"
*
@
] =
>
% 9
9 "
0
"
@ J
%
9
/
>
7
$
7 $
> "
: /
- 9 3. 3
/
9 G
+ *
, G
*; ,
3 !#
;
#
CN
N ( - N
31 2 (! 6
/ : !
7
,5 )
/
( 3. 3 $ !/ 3
>
C2!3 @ ! ! G ! !6
+
#
! 5 2 43# !
/ -
3
1
;
31 2 (!
!
,5 "
"
>
" !
" "
-
"
1 2 ! , \D 5 ! 3# 3 L 3 5 2 2Q 6 ; 31 2 (! ,5 7 ! * " " * !
; <
1 2 ! 8 3# ! ,5
31 2 (!
! 3A
2 ! 2 3
3 !
'
! 34 3 ! 5 2 43# !
3
!
4
"
" -
K
!
! # 3 343A !
*
@
6 "
, <
<
G*
"
8
12 ! 5 # ; 31 2 (!
*
!4 8 2 ! 5 !4! ! @ 4! 5 3! 2 34$ ,5 , 8 ! "
( 31 2 (!
(
-
7 8
;
@!
Q ,5
! 5 ! ! ! ! ! 2 3!46 ; 31 2 (! ,5 * ( "
2 92 ! 6 "
!
#2 !5! !
5 D
-
! 2!4 ! @34
@3!6
7
" Q ! ! N 9 1 2!3 ! !3 5
D ( 3 343 !
J
2 ! 3 5 2 43# ! 12 5 ! # # 3!43 60D 5 3! K 5 3 # 35 !3 # 3 ! ; 31 2 (! ,5 7 ! ! 1" <
"
! *
5
3 #
! 3
! ! 2 !
9
-
>
!4 ; 9 ! , \D ! $ ! ! # 3!43 !9 !# 5 ! 3 ! 6
5 3! K 5 2 !% 12 2 12 8
" -
( !
.
%
, , , - .^ , * ( , 0
]^ ,
3 !#
- D ;! # 4 3
8 !
1 23
$
! 7
+)
C! 7
+) 3
. C2!4 !# ;! # 4
3
(
3
3@3# ! 3
,
1 2 !
3!
3
/
/ :
! 3 !N 3 3 1 6 < $ -
X $
1 23
>
*
! 2A 3 5 ! ! &
5
2 2Q
2 !
9
, $
8
*
< "
7
$
-
< 0
-
>
"
"
CFFN
! D;
"
! K 12 ! 2 ! 23! 8 3# ! !46 ;! # 4 1 23 X 4
#
L 3 9 ! 3 2! ,
! 2!4 !
"
# 3 ! 9 ! : 3 Q # 3! *
,
8
,
,
4
" $
#
C2!3 ! : 5 # ! 3 ! # 2 3 ! 2 3 3 L 3!6 ;! # 4 1 23
4!
! !5
@
3! "
!
4 4 ! " "
!
/ <
9
5!
-
" / "
!5
-
%
;
;-
3 !#
;
;
(! 4
4
(! 4
(
&3! ! &3!
4
0
;
3
3! 3 0
!3
5
3
1
! "
3
"
!N 3 3
6
3
" "
9 *
9 ' "
@ "
H *
, "
M;;D
(! 4
C2!4 8 &3!
4
3
3@3# !
3 3
@! -
"
"
4
3
! !N 3
3 ! 6 " 9
J
( (! 4 8 "
5! !!
&3!
@ 3 5 3
# M;;;
! 2 * @
"
5 2 43# ! >
7
!
!6 2
! 8
,
-
M;;;
" *
)
)
3 7
7
*
* 9
*
@
8 0
%
" 1
> @
"
-
) " "
*
(
0 -
" $
"
* CF
*
9 ($ (! 4
4 +
2!5 &3! 3 8 *
! 12
3 3! ! # -
6 >
*
(
"
!
( 8
2
" B
!
-
8
>
"
" " 9
( (! 4
4 "
1 2! 3
&3! "
4
L 5
3
4! !
9 "
RFi >
=
/ "
< CE -
6
0
0
>
CD
$
&" ((
, N @
+
,, +
CC
,
" 7
(
$
-
@ > 1 89
9
& %
L1 C/ CCF
" 8
F /
Mi 0 59 > % / 0 6 ( F $ > 2B 9 8
@ (
,
# O
-
$
8 '
-
-
!
( "
/
"
'
0
0
"
8
O( > "
-
=
-
(M
@
P
L1
"
"
>
$
" ) "
-
$
-
8
"
P 7 O
-
8
(
1H
=
*
$
>
8
" $
>
@
P =
3
0
' A ' " &
O -
8 " -
> -
?
'
8 "
$
MF $
2
! !
'1 =
(
@3 ! ! 5
! ! @ B = =
@ B = 4
. CN " .M;- < MM. $ . @ >
@ B = 4
)N
(M
(3# 4 5 ! !
@
L1
M
.;F " . CR- < CE .0 C/ CCF . ! 89 & A @ $ a ) 6
5>
-
P
>
F
> >
0
-
!
-
(
90
.MD " . CE - D; < CF.0 C/ CCF .+ $ @ @ 0 -G
$ 9 >% / 0
* , )
1 =+
3 3 % 9$%0 ( ,
!
0 * P
CC
" C
M;;D
0 &
7
?? -
8 7
-
O
' )
"
" &
@
Q
1
' .0
9
!
'
E
M;;D
CCi ' 8
2
=
-
%
&
# O$ &
"
'
8
?
8 CC " -,
`
\S >
8
"
" *
P
N>1
O>
H
> !
=
@ 89 > ) $'>/
$ '
8
&
"
8
" -
&
&
-
P $
G
, G
(
+
9
.%
_D
) (
)
X
3
6 $
?J 2
(
3
(
$ +
1
3Y! 8 Y! 7 6 3 3
+ 3
-
7 6
,( ;
?HH /,
3
A 8= ! A
!
+
1 U #! 7 6
+ ,1 Z !+ ( ?@@K!/
3 2 !+ 3 =" 8 / ,
6
O
2
!+ ( - (" 3 -
C2!3 ! 5 3 # 35 !3 3 8 3! 1 2 3 L !5 ! @34 @3! 5 3 2 # $ ` 3 AF6 8 ( " 7 8 B Y22 / 2 1 $ " 2 0 CQ 8 (
!
! :5
3
$ ;L # 3! 3 2 3
"
3 2 8 ( $ $ 9 3. F
( - = 3 " 1 3 = #
!
CFRE 7 "
)
" "
c 5 - (
CFN N 6 CFRE
"
8
" "
( 5B "
8 "
"
-
O
!
P "
(
"
8
!
"
6 -
"
-
"
-
.
8 .
-
8 7
7 !
"
O
P -
" ! 5
-
-
8 " 4
$ !
6 -
,
.
2
4 8
"
-
"
5
"
!
6
-
" 0 2
! CFN F
1 ! < "
" (
"
1
-
! ) '
-
!
G* !
"
!
"
"
!
"
8 <
" ! C2!4 8 3 5
5 ! 6 ;L # 3! 3 2 3 9 < "
R # 3!
! @34
@3!
1 2!4 ! ! 2!43 !
2
CFN F "
" " -
(
" .
-
-
1
"
! "
**N
#
"
&
7
8
8
&
8 !
!
1
#
G* "
!
O)
!
-T
P .
! "
*
S
-
!
8! ) "
9
@
!
-
8
#
8
)
! 5
6 5
7
7
6
*
" ]
! '
8
5
!
*
8
CFR;
6
8
" 8
-
12 8
;L # 3! 3 2 3 B " " T ' -T
2 #$` 3A *
2
2
#2
! @34
@3!6 II
< " "
$
-
*
!
"
,
S 2
G*
" -
-T ) " -
8
-
!
!
3
CC " -
+
7 +
+ 8
" "
U #
"
CF; D
-
-
"
C2!4 8 ! # ? 3# ! 1 2 G ! U @2 6 ;L # 3! 3 2 3 9
$ > 5 B
] Y-
!
-
9
6 "
$
@ 3! ! '
K
7
8 "
/
O4
!
.
( * -
(
3 M
@3 ! ! 5 7 : 3 ! a Ha
X P+
$
%.
QX
i @ i
# 4!
8
@
!
.
$
9
$ !
P
(
) N;
C/ CCF . -
3 2B 9
CE - D;
< CF-
8
" "
, ( (
1 " "
CE
-
8
0 M;;D
0
$' "
C
"
8
9 "
N
!
< CE E : F " :- < MM-
" M;;D
CQ - < CF-
8
$-
(
N
=
CC
=
/
7
8
,
, @
"
1
=
-
-
"
@
"
8
* <
1
*
8
"
+
-
+
E @
MF &
9 9 B
"
@ i @ i 0 ( 0
H
M;;D 1 M1 A CF- RQ
c
@ 1
0
" ]
" $ 0
< MM-
$ * ' ! ! ! > . 9
=
<
! =
c >
,
& 3
$ * 0
$
" ' $
M
' "
9 0 H#1
8P
1 0A
M;;D
N ) B ( 9
8
D;
"
2
9 >
" 2B 9 "
9 M;;D
(
"
(
" -
)
" @
8 %
0
Y
D;
CE - D; /
< CF-
C/ CCF 9
@ J
M;;D (
$
1
.
! ) > " !
( 7 = M ; ; DH 1 A
7
89
, M: @
E
"
$
0
.
"
$
'
%
0
=
.
9
M;;D
&
% $ " '( ( 5 ! 3 ! )! 3 !# 3 !3 ) : " B " $ @ 0 @ & 4 " - 0 ( 4
5 "
? 2 1
$ (
0 -
3 !
4 a $
$ *
E3 3 ! ) F 9 $ > 4
"
M;;R % 7 = ! ) ' & !
& -
% = ! > 2 0 -
%
2
a
' .'
-
1"
9
" 8 2B 9
"
1"
"
DRM E
"
" 3
% 0 0 MC
"
&
' 4
" 59 $ @ ' 6
i 7 0 J 1" % 7
)N 2B 9
@
: 0
(
4
CM ) TTT -
2B 9 '
@
$ *
!
J
1"
$
$
7 0
$ 0 0 1
7 0 @
>
$
>
$
>
/
2B 9
-L 3 !
J * 1 2B 9 "
J
(! 5 ! $ ! ! G ! $ > $
"
: 2B 9
(
2B 9 - 7 0 0 "
(
$)#$ $ ,
;
,
+ , (] Z
7
,
#V
/
N]
#
- $
AHH?!9
(
2
!
,
#
$ #
)X
-
)
(
3
:
-
"
! -
!
-
!> 7 3!
7
" -
" +
- CE
$ 0
4 -
-
9
" -
" -
)
CF M;
G! ?43! - $
-
9
! CD
" -
C;
-
=
4
0 ! $
@
! 43
-
" -
$
3
H
2
! J
=1
7
Y
=1 $
7
Y
1 !3 @ 43A (
-
-
9 "
-
4
(
/ - "
8
" ;
$
7
+ ]
.
-
G34 ]
=
-
J
Q
0
-
" =
>
@
<
" -
N 3 3
@
!
" -
-
9
0
(
"
"
9
)N " N
*
!
(
$
3
-
@ -
-
7
4
-
'
*
,
! %* % + / "
3
9F
7
,
6 3
$
(
/
$
)
/
/, /
/ :
/ : $
$ 3 :
< . C2!4 8 ) -
:
!2
!+
12
!
)
=
!3 3 @42 # 3 2 ! 2! @
!
3
4 # 2!46
"
*
-
$
"
W
"
-
A
A 8 8
9
B
"
H
"
H
8
= $-
0
7
.
& "
'
* "
C2!4 !2 1 "
12
!3 , -
5
K
U
2! 3 1 23 ! B
! 2!3 6
*
/
, -
7
-
"
" .)
J
!3 ! 7 -
7
"
2
4
-
7
0
% C2!4 !2 4 !
#
5
R /
1 2 4Q # =
YK
6 ) 8
"
, '
X
-
"
"
*
"$ & ,!4!
32! O) 0 "
. "
3
' 1 CFE F Q DQ
$
V
>
R
'
" "
!
-
8
-
8
!
-
)
G
1
"
P >@ 1 89 A
1 O( 1
O
=
" 6
L
8
( ! !1
$
-
(M
@
=1 K
7 CFN N &
&
(
T
(
T
5$
6. )
9
0
=
1
5 $ $ M;;M NQN
'
0
!
!
"
6
L1
0A
5 M;;M 0
" 9 ! #
!
(
1
1 !
1
=
1
=1
7
J
$
3 .
1 & CFFQ DC; (
' " 8
4
P
1H 89 H
R% O 7
!
7
-
& "
Esta obra foi tema do IHU Idéias de 15 de agosto de 2002, com o título O mundo do trabalho a partir do ´Germinal´, de Émile Zola, com o Prof. Dr. Lauro João Dick, do Centro de Ciências da Comunicação
" !
@
"
8
P 1$
(! !
=
1
0 =
(
(M
(1
89
3 " "
2B 9
"
0
8 C
" 8 Q; '
8
"* -
1
1
0
Q;
!
-
8 ( " /
$
-
=
/
H 7
$ 0 "
bM 2B 9 ( = J 5 j " 5 j ( i 7 * = <
2 0
>
B
9
$
" 6 $ " 6 % j " - > " 5
5
.2
) /
" 6 j
Mi 9
%0 $
FD; M M ; ; ; 2B 9 . -
B
9
7
" %
"
2
. j
j "
%
9
X 2B 9 X 9 2B 9 . @ 2 . i 7 0 J % 0 7 k 5 j ] 5 j " 6 " 6 . 8$ ! - .WWT T T . 9 FQ ; X 0 = " > . Q C Q F; DDDD X % RCM C . CCE D CCFQ
) 0 " 6 % . 2B 9 ( " W 0 RCM :