CMYK
The Daily Mail
Copyright 2019, Columbia-Greene Media Volume 227, No. 99
WEEKEND
The nation’s fourth-oldest newspaper • Serving Greene County since 1792
All Rights Reserved
Saturday-Sunday, May 18-19, , 2019
Price $2.50
Feud over Open Meetings Law
FORECAST WEATHER FOR HUDSON/CATSKILL TODAY TONIGHT SUN
MON
TUE
WED
By Sarah Trafton Nice with clouds and sun
Mostly cloudy
A t-storm in spots
HIGH 72
LOW 54
80 67
Columbia-Greene MediaPleasant Some sun,
Partly sunny a t-storm; CATSKILL — withThe some town atand cooler humid torney released sun a response to
85an Albany 68 attorney 72 regarding the town’s compliance with 53open meetings 47 laws 54 on Friday.
Attorney John Dowd wrote letter dated April Montreal29 to ZonHAPPY 63/48 ing Board Chairwoman Lynn Massena Zubris and Catskill Town Su62/48 Plattsburgh Bancroft 61/48 Davis about 56/43 Ogdensburg pervisor Doreen Malone 61/49 the two meetings held April 62/47 Peterborough Potsdam Kingston 11. Residents were given Burlington 58/44 60/49 54/49 63/51 one-day notice for the town Lake Placid Watertown board 57/44 meeting, classified as 59/50 an emergency meeting, held achu? at 5:30 p.m., and same-day Ryan Reynolds as Pik Rochester notice for the zoning board I 63/53
Complete weather, A2 UN
Ottawa 59/46a
- with your current ION?
FINANCIAL INSTITUT
PY UNHAP your current -
CMYK
UNHAPPY
Y UNHAPP your current -
LOCAL, - with N? FINANCIAL OWNED INSTITUTIO FINANCIALyour COOPERATIVE current MEMBER-
- with
MEMBERLOCAL, E FINANCIAL
AWESOM OWNED RATES! LOANCOOPERATIVE
AWESOME RATES! LOAN
WE UNDERSTAND.
people, We’re dedicated to TODAY!
TODAY!
Difference? What’s the Credit UNion not profit. We’re dedicated to people,
.com
beUNbanked beUNbanked.com LOCAL, MEMBERTHE SWITCH TODAY! MAKE6 FINANCIAL OWNED beUNbanked.com 518-828-521 518-828-5216 COOPERATIVE 518-828-5216
FOR s you. dMONEY: nMORE aYOUR d e r s tGET s you.
FEES n dd e rsta e r s t aFEWER dt l i n s t i tnustt ii t u tAWESOME tt h a h aUN tn a fi n a n cfii a i t i t uLOAN ti oi no RATES! UN & CHARGES nancial s UN a fi n a nac i a l i n
on that
FOR GET MORE MONEY: YOUR FEES FEWER & CHARGES
AWESOME LOAN RATES!
- with
WE UNDERSTAND.INSTITUTION? FINANCIAL SWITCH TODAY! What’s the Credit UNion not profit. MAKE THE UNion Difference? What’s the Creditto people, not profit. We’re dedicated Difference?
MAKE THE SWITCH
2019 - C1
LOCAL, MEMBEROWNED FINANCIAL COOPERATIVE
FEWER FOR CHARGES &MORE GET MONEY: YOUR FEES FEWER & CHARGES
AWESOME LOAN RATES!
Difference? . the Credit UNion not profit. What’s UNDERSTAND WE to people, We’re dedicated MAKE THE SWITCH
Saturday - Sunday, May 18-19,
FINANCIAL INSTITUTION?
FOR LOCAL, MEMBERGET MORE OWNED FINANCIAL MONEY: COOPERATIVE YOUR FEES
PY UNHAP your current -
WE UNDERSTAND.
- with
FOR GET MORE MONEY: YOUR FEES FEWER S & CHARGE
FINANCIAL INSTITUTION?
Columbia-Greene media
Federally insured by
nds you.
beUNbanked.com 518-828-5216
NCUA
Federally insured by NCUA
Federally insured by
NCUA
erstands you. t u t i o n t h a t UNd a financial insti
. WE UNDERSTAND
Federally insured by NCUA
UNion Difference? What’s the Creditto people, not profit. We’re dedicated
MAKE THE SWITCH
TODAY!
beUNbanked.com 518-828-5216
u. derstands yo s t i t u t i o n t h a t UN a financial in Federally insured by
NCUA
WARNER BROS. PICTURES
Kathryn Newton, Pikachu
(voiced by Ryan Reynolds)
and Justice Smith star
in “Pokémon: Detective
Pikachu.”
Don’t knock it till you
see it
INSIDE TODAY! ‘POKEMON: DETECTIVE PIKACHU’
By KRISTEN PAGE-KIRBY Washington Post
3 stars out of 4 put it mildly, to read Justice Smith, Katht may be surprising, to CAST: Ryan Reynolds, Detective Pikachu” a review of “Pokémon: ryn Newton Runner.” (More that also mentions “Blade where goldfish DIRECTOR: Rob Letterman minutes world 44 on this later.) But in a RUNNING TIME: 1 hour, baby dinosaurs walk PG, for Pokémonturn into dragons and INDUSTRY RATING: rude and suggesaflame, stranger things based action, peril, some the streets with tails thematic elements tive humor and mature have been known to happen. Pokémon are mythiFor the uninitiated, can types that each have cal creatures of varying Pikachu. Though Pokémon of their your local 10-year-old known as special abilities. (Ask their normally only articulate variations and here species many — e.g., pika pika, deliveredPikato list a few of the human trainers, they own names powers.) Working with supremacy by us- by the original voice of the cartoon specimen for battle one another The chu, Ikue Otani — this particular opponents. talk. He conattack to Ryan Reynolds) can ing their powers in the 1990s with vid- (voiced by bottom of his phenomenon started a vinces Tim to try to get to the into a cartoon series, eo games, evolving the ever-present father’s death. eventually Runner” comes in. and card game Here’s where “Blade it is today. “Pokémon: created a film-noir cultural juggernaut Just as Ridley Scott the first live-action/ neon lights and Detective Pikachu,” of the future — all Letterman the canon, is only the vision Rob into director entry — streets animated fire burning — and the crowded vs. Aliens”) has rendered a dizlatest fuel to keep the (“Monsters dazzling Ryme money flowing. complex and visually takes the mostly cud- zyingly embraces other “Detective Pikachu” “Detective Pikachu” film’s snapthe ring and puts them City. as well, down to the dly creatures out of called Ryme City, noir tropes and trenchcoat-clad femme on the streets of a place in py dialogue journalpeople live together fatale: a BuzzFeed-style Pokéwhere Pokémon and story starts outside (not quite) compiles relative harmony. The Goodman (Justice ist (Kathryn Newton) who things. Tim yet aspires to bigger the city limits, with insurance adjuster mon listicles, kind of world-building. The Smith), a 22-year-old a It’s a clever dream of becoming of whom are CGI — who has given up his film’s Pokémon — all reach out and cudtrainer. real you’ll want to champion Pokémon That verisifather in a mysteri- look so especially Pikachu. After the death of his them, set to dle City to Ryme Pikachu” feel like ous accident, Tim heads only to discover an militude makes “Detective See REYNOLDS C2 his dad’s affairs in order, lurking in his father’s amnesiac Pokémon critter rodent-like office: It’s the yellow,
Batavia Buffalo 64/54 65/57 WARNER BROS. AND NEW YORK
Syracuse 64/56
TIMES
Pikachu voices the character Ryan Reynolds, right, Detective Pikachu,” in the new film “Pokemon: is in theaters now. which
LOCAL SPORTS tion: Brash, fun l Kombat 11’ lives up to its reputa ‘MortaHornell Washington Post
and terribly violentBinghamton
world 5 through 10, and the last I has changed since old go‘MORTAL KOMBAT 11’ caught up with my SubDEVELOPED BY: Netherto characters Kitana, of Realm Studios Zero, and Kabal. (Some have PUBLISHED BY: Warner the other characters the in Bros. Interactive Entertainhad children that are ment able to new game.) But I was flow AVAILABLE ON: Nintendo the 4, quickly get back into Switch, PC, PlayStation thanks, in part, to “Mortal Xbox One tutorial Kombat 11’s” robust of system, and my memory which we used to memorize halfand fa- all those quarter-circle, long combo-strings of our circle, and back-to-forward are talities. At the height for us button patterns that in mania, MK became staples of fighting games an almost-purely cerebral try general. experience where we’d start I was off to a decent other’s to guess each other and I up the the first night Milton strategy, then switch the fly. played a few online matches is shown. tempo of a game on Mortal Kombat 11” A fight scene from “ It was our chess. See ‘MORTAL’ C2 I skipped Mortal Kombats
63/56
69/59
By CHRISTOPHER BYRD
that “Can you believe we’re playing a ‘Mortal friend Kombat’ game?” my dove Milton asked as we Kominto the new “Mortal bat 11.” since It has been 20 years tohe and I went to college played gether. Back then we “Mora serious amount of tal Kombat 3” and “Mortal Super Kombat 4” on the reNintendo and the N64,into got spectively. Though I “Street fighting games via game Fighter 2,” my fighting those skills plateaued with friends two MK games. My with and I used to play them laps a guidebook on our
Utica 62/52
WARNER BROS. INTERACTIVE
meeting, held at 5 p.m. Dowd cited Section 104 of the Public Officers Law to defend his argument that the public was not adequately notified of the meetings. “[The law] requires public notice of the time and place of a meeting scheduled at least one week prior thereto to be given or electronically submitted to the news media and to be conspicuously posted in one or more designated public locations at least 72 hours before such meeting,” according to Section 104. Dowd alleges that the town intentionally withheld in-
formation from the public because the meetings had to do with controversial negotiations with Sheepdog Warrior Shooting Range on Haines Road. The Zoning Board determined that law enforcement training was not a recreational use in March, leaving owner Ed Rivenburg the option to seek a use variance for the property. Town attorney Michael Smith opposes Dowd’s claim. “Your letter to Town Supervisor Davis and Zoning Board of Appeals Chair Zubris iterates a sequence of meetings,
unfounded assumptions, and inferences as a basis to spin a false narrative to conclude that the Town of Catskill intentionally violated the Open Meetings Law,” Smith wrote. “The truth lies elsewhere. Indeed, as I describe below, the timeline connected with the very meetings detailed in your letter actually demonstrate that the town engaged in performing its duties not only in full compliance with the technical requirements of the Open Meetings Law but also in compliance with the spirit of the Open Meetings Law.” At the meetings in question,
both boards passed resolutions to authorize a tolling agreement with Sheepdog, which extends the statute of limitations for Rivenburg to make an appeal to the zoning board another 60 days. This option would have expired on April 14 but will now expire June 13, according to Smith’s letter. Dowd argued in his letter that the meetings in question could have been rescheduled for a later date and proper notice could have been given to the public. See FEUD A2
Albany 71/56
Trustees: Wheelabrator dumps plan Catskill 72/54
Hudson 72/55
ENTERTAINMENT
Shown is today’s weather. Temperatures are today’s highs and tonight’s lows.
ALMANAC
SUN AND MOON
Statistics through 3 p.m. yesterday
Temperature
Precipitation
Yesterday as of 3 p.m. 24 hrs. through 3 p.m. yest.
High
0.09”
Low
Today 5:32 a.m. 8:12 p.m. 8:04 p.m. 5:39 a.m.
Sunrise Sunset Moonrise Moonset
Moon Phases
71
Full
52 YEAR TO DATE NORMAL
Last
May 18 May 26
14.77 13.03
Panthers hold off Spartans CONDITIONS TODAY
Sun. 5:31 a.m. 8:13 p.m. 9:11 p.m. 6:16 a.m.
New
First
Jun 3
Jun 10
Forecasts and graphics provided by AccuWeather, Inc. ©2019
AccuWeather.com UV Index™ & AccuWeather.com RealFeel Temperature® The Chatham Panthers defeated the Greenville 9 9 9 7 7 4 4 Spartans, 7-6 3 3 2 2 PAGE B1 56
60
64
69
73
76
78
78
77
74
72
8 a.m. 9 a.m. 10 a.m. 11 a.m. Noon 1 p.m. 2 p.m. 3 p.m. 4 p.m. 5 p.m. 6 p.m. The higher the AccuWeather.com UV Index number, the greater the need for eye and skin protection. 0-2 Low; 3-5 Moderate; 6-7 High; 8-10 Very High; 11+ Extreme. The patented AccuWeather.com RealFeel Temperature is an exclusive index of effective temperature based on eight weather factors.
OBITUARY NATIONAL WEATHER TODAY Winnipeg 52/33
Seattle 72/54 Billings 42/34
Minneapolis 55/44
Denver 60/36
San Francisco 62/54
Montreal 63/48
Detroit 74/62
Toronto 57/47
New York 75/58 Washington 82/65
Chicago 81/63 Kansas City 77/56
Los Angeles 71/57
El Paso 83/59 Houston 87/73 Chihuahua 90/53
ALASKA
Miami 87/77
Monterrey 97/68
Grumpy Cat dies at 7
Atlanta 88/69
HAWAII
Anchorage 57/45
Honolulu 86/75
Fairbanks 66/45
Hilo 85/69
Juneau 64/41
Shown are noon positions of weather systems and precipitation. Temperature bands are highs for the day.
Grumpy Cat, the internet -10s -0s 0s 10s 20s 30s 40s 50s 60s 70s 80s 90s 100s 110s By Sarah Trafton celebrity whose scowl Columbia-Greene Media showers t-storms rain flurries snow ice cold front warm front stationary front spoke for all of us in dark CATSKILL — A New HampNATIONAL times, dead atCITIES 7 Today Sun. Today Sun. shire-based municipal waste City Hi/Lo PAGE W Hi/Lo A5 W City Hi/Lo W Hi/Lo W combustion company is dropAlbuquerque Anchorage Atlanta Atlantic City Baltimore Billings Birmingham Boise Boston Charleston, SC Charleston, WV Charlotte Cheyenne Chicago Cincinnati Cleveland Columbus, OH Dallas Denver Des Moines Detroit Hartford Honolulu Houston Indianapolis Kansas City Knoxville Region Las Vegas
70/46 57/45 88/69 67/58 79/63 42/34 88/67 64/48 68/55 92/68 87/64 91/67 55/31 81/63 86/64 79/66 87/65 81/64 60/36 79/51 74/62 76/54 86/75 87/73 86/68 77/56 87/63 83/62
NATION
s pc s pc pc r s c pc s pc s t t s pc pc t t t pc pc s t pc t s pc
73/53 c 59/46 pc 88/67 c 72/62 pc 87/68 pc 47/37 c 86/69 pc 55/45 r 72/64 s 86/68 s 88/63 pc 88/66 s 50/34 pc 72/47 t 81/60 pc 86/60 pc 85/62 pc 88/71 s 61/40 pc 59/41 r 82/54 t 79/65 pc 87/74 pc 89/73 t 74/53 t 67/46 pc 87/63 pc A3 72/54 pc
No action on misconduct
Ohio State failed to act on reports of sexual misconduct, according to a 232-page report PAGE A5
INDEX
Opinion State/Nation Obituaries Sports Classified Comics/Advice
A4 A5 A5 B1 B4-B5 B7-B8
Little Rock 83/69 pc 87/64 pc Los Angeles sh an ash ping its 71/57 planpcto66/54 build Miami 87/77 t 88/76 pc landfill in68/52 ther town, village Milwaukee 65/46 two t Minneapolis 55/44 r 48/41 r offi cials confi rmed Friday. Nashville 89/67 s 83/63 c New Orleans 86/75 pc 87/74 c New York City 75/58 pc 77/67 pc Norfolk 79/65 pc 88/69 s Oklahoma City 70/52 t 78/57 s Omaha 79/53 t 61/44 pc Orlando 88/67 pc 90/69 pc Philadelphia 78/62 pc 87/68 pc Phoenix 87/68 s 83/58 c Pittsburgh 82/64 pc 86/65 pc Portland 66/49 pc 64/56 pc By Melanie71/53 Lekocevic Portland r 64/51 c Providence 72/53 Columbia-Greene Mediapc 69/61 s Raleigh 92/67 s 90/67 s —s Two canRichmond TANNERSVILLE 88/67 pc 92/70 Sacramento 59/51 r 62/47 r didates are running to fill one St. Louis 87/66 pc 76/54 pc Salt Lake City seat 61/50 r open oncthe63/43 Hunter-TanSan Francisco r 62/53 r nersville 62/54 Board of Education. Savannah 92/67 s 88/70 s SeattlePolls will be 72/54 c 65/52 c open Tuesday. Tampa 90/71 pc 91/75 pc Washington, DC 82/65 pc 91/72 pc Name: Barbara Bates
CONTRIBUTED PHOTO
Wheelabrator Technologies was proposing to lease 158 acres on Route 9W in Smith’s Landing, including a former quarry owned by Peckham Materials, Inc. The project involved hauling 445,000 tons of ash annually from Wheelabrator’s
www.HudsonValley360.com Twitter Follow: @CatskillDailyMail Facebook www.facebook.com/ CatskillDailyMail/
mental Conservation but its status is currently considered incomplete. Village Trustee Joseph Kozloski said he learned Thursday at a meeting with Wheelabrator representatives that the project was dead. “I thought it was going to be
a regular meeting,” Kozloski said. As the department head of village water, sewer and roads, Kozloski had to work with Wheelabrator because the project required the village See PLAN A2
Two running for one seat on HTC board “
A few concerns and priorities I do have are to get funding for our preK program so that there is no limit to how many children can receive the benefits of our amazing program and to make sure this funding is in place for years to come. — Barbara Bates
Weather(W): s-sunny, pc-partly cloudy, c-cloudy, sh-showers, t-thunderstorms, r-rain, sf-snow flurries, sn-snow, i-ice.
On the web
incinerators in Peekskill, Hudson Falls and Poughkeepsie, to the Catskill site, and separating the metals from the ash. The anticipated life of the project was 48 years. The application, first submitted in 2017, was under review by the state Department of Environ-
Age: 47 Occupation: Co-owns propane and trucking/excavating businesses with her husband Education: Catskill High School Barbara Bates has two children attending HunterTannersville schools, and her husband is an alumnus of the district. She lives in Elka Park and is a volunteer at several organizations in the community, including the Hunter Elementary Safety Committee and the Nutrition and Wellness Committee for the district, among others. She said she is not running for the board of education based on a specific agenda, but there are issues she wants to see addressed.
“
”
After speaking with some district residents, they feel like there are possible transparency issues with the administration,” Pascucci said. “I would like to work with the board and the administration to help take away the feeling that not everything is being forthcoming to the district residents on issues at hand by working on the comnmunication between both sides of the table. — Michael Pascucci
“A few concerns and priorities I do have are to get funding for our pre-K program so that there is no limit to how many children can receive the benefits of our amazing program and to make sure this funding is in place for years to come,” Bates said. She also wants to make sure “qualified educators” are hired
and retained in the district, and that members of the school community have a voice in the process. Ensuring that extracurricular activities, such as drama club and sports, receive financial support from the district and remain available to the children, is another priority. “It is also important to keep
”
encouraging the educational trips that many of the children may never experience otherwise,” Bates said. “As a property owner (taxpayer), I believe we can do this and still be fiscally responsible with the taxpayers’ money.” Name: Michael Pascucci Age: 49
Occupation: Assistant chief operator/supervisor Education: ColumbiaGreene Community College Michael Pascucci lives in Tannersville with his wife and daughter. He is an alumnus of Hunter-Tannersville High School. He volunteers with the Tannersville Fire Department and holds the rank of assistant fire chief. He said he wants to bring more transparency to the district. “After speaking with some district residents, they feel like there are possible transparency issues with the administration,” Pascucci said. “I would like to work with the board and the administration to help take away the feeling that not everything is being forthcoming to the district residents on issues at hand by working on the comnmunication between both sides of the table.” He added that if elected, he looks forward to being a “positive voice for the children.”