Some questions on two Lectures L:36 and L:148. In Lecture 36 "Ali Mirza says that there are eight books . In his lecture he states that there Bukha:ri and Muslim are the only books in which each and every Muttas:il 'Al 'Asna:d Tradition [Rava:yah] is Correct [ S:ah:i:h:] . In other eight books he says their traditions are 80 % correct and 20 % not. He is so stunch that he refuses to call them AS S:-H:A:H: . But he mischievely remains silent for those who believe in 'Us:u:l 'Arba"ah. Since they do not consider Bukha:ri by Imam Bukh:a:ri:[ d:256] a, Muslim261, Ibn Majah Imam Ibn Majah, T-rm-dh:i:, Imam289 'Abu Davud,N-sa:'i: d 275 , M-snad 'Ah:mad and MuvattaĘź Imam Malik by Imam [d:179]. Instead they believe in Kitab al-Kafi by Muhammad ibn Ya'qub al-Kulayni al-Razi (329 AH), Man la yahduruhu al-Faqih by Muhammad ibn Babawayh , Tahdhib al-Ahkam by Shaykh Muhammad T:usi: and Al-Is:tibs:ar by Shaykh Muhammad Tusi. Also a secondary group of Twelvers' books like like Nahj 'Al Bala:ghah by Shari:f Rad:i:, claimed to be collected by the said Author after 300 years after the death of Saiyiduna: "Ali and other books . These believers reject Bukhari and Muslim as Concoction and replace them by the five books stated above. Not to menstion the rest of six books. So does "Ali: Mirza equate the five Non Sunni books with the eight Sunni Books or not? What he says about those five Non Sunni books. When he commented a number of Sunni "A:lims for making argumentations from weak Sunni Traditions claiming them as criminals , he is absolutely silent on Non Sunni Scholars who believe in Non Sunni Books stated above , and some other books not mentioned above for sake of brievity. Did "Ali: Mirza Applied The Mudaddamah of S:ah:i:h: Muslim on these Non Sunni Books? What "Ali: Mirza: wants to do is to disgrace Sunni Scholars and to remain silent as an idol to Non
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.