FIGURATIVE EVALUATION REPORT 2010
MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
2
Table of Contents 1.
GENERAL EVALUATION REPORT 2010
3
2.
BENEFICIARIES EVALUATION REPORT 2010
5
2.1 2.2 2.3 3. 3.1. 4.
GENERAL AND LIFE-SKILLS PROGRAMME RESULTS IMPACT OF THE AMANDLA FAIR PLAY SYTSEM YOUTH LEADERSHIP PROGRAMME REPORT FACILITATORS EVALUATION REPORT 2010 GENERAL PROGRAMME FEEDBACK CONTACT
MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
6 9 12 18 19 23
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
3
1. General Evaluation Report 2010
This is the 2010 AMANDLA EduFootball Evaluation Report. AMANDLA holistically is developing children who grow up separated from their families in residential facilities and disadvantaged communities through developmental football leagues, life skill programmes, leadership training and crime prevention programmes.
Accumilative number of participants per programme per month in 2010: 0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000 Fair Play Football Leagues
January February March
Life-Skills Programme
April May June
Crime Prevention Programme
July August September October
Youth Leadership Programme
November December
Figure 1-1
MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
4
Outreach figures 2007 - 2011
2011
Number of participants on a weekly basis
2010 2009 2008 2007 0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
Figure 1-2
Local Partner Organisations 2007 - 2011
Children's Homes, Orphanages, Youth detention Centres, Drug Rehabilitation Centres , Shelters for Street Children)
Number of local implemeting partner organisations
2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Figure 1-3
Average participantion in programmes on a weekly basis in 2010: 1000
Participants
800 600 400 200 0
Crime Prevention Programme Youth Leadership Programme Life-Skills Programme Fair Play Football Leagues
Figure 1-4
MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
2. Beneficiaries Evaluation Report 2010
MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
6
2.1 General and Life-Skills Programme Results The following charts display the overall feedback received in the form of questionnaires and interviews from beneficiaries taking part in AMANDLA EduFootball’s (AMANDLA) programmes throughout 2010. In total AMANDLA reached out to approximately 2000 girls and boys on a weekly basis throughout the year. The participants were interviewed and asked to complet questionnaires evaluating the impact AMANDLA’s programmes have had on their lives at different stages throughout the year. The youth’s feedback was further supported by their coaches through frequently completed session feedback forms as well as field reports complied by AMANDLA staff members.
Assessment of AMANDLA programmes Very much enjoyed
Fairly good
Somewhat
Not
No answer
5% 2% 1% 18%
74%
Figure 2.1-1
Perceived improvement in school performance Improved
Same
Worse
No answer
6% 4%
24% 66%
Figure 2.1-2 MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
7
Number of trainings per week
Perception of personal football skills
Once per week
Improved a lot
Twice per week
Somewhat
More than twice per week
Didn't improve
No answer
No answer
0% 7%
29%
44%
5%
17% 27%
71%
Figure 2.1-3
Figure 2.1-4
Frequency of life-skills sessions implementations
Personal rating of 2010 school performance Very good Good Satisfactory Poor
More than twice per week Twice per week Once per week Twice per month Less than twice per month
2%
21%
13% 13% 30%
10% 20%
55%
36%
Figure 2.1-7
MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
Figure 2.1-8
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
8
Assessment of the AMANDLA Fair Play System
Did you enjoy playing football under the Fair Play System?
Well known Basics Not known No answer
Yes
4%
7%
No
No answer
16%
18% 51%
80%
24%
Figure 2.1-10
Percentage of participants
Figure 2.1-9
Life-skills in which the most knowledge was gained 100 90 80 70 60 50 40
77
30 20
71
64
51
50
47
44
44
38
10 0
Figure 2.1-11
MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
Life-Skills
41
37
32
29
22
17
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
9
2.2 Impact of the AMANDLA Fair Play Sytsem The AMANDLA Fair Play System was developed by EduFootball to directly incorporate its educational objectives into the football leagues, but especially in response to high levels of violent conduct within football leagues. It further aims to emphasize on a developmental and educational aspect of football rather than competition. Since its introduction a significant improvement in the youth behavioural patterns could be measured, making the system EduFootball’s most effective educational component up to date. With the system being implemented in all football leagues EduFootball recorded no violent incident in 2010.
Learned to respect others and their opinions
Gained better selfdiscipline Very much Somewhat No answer
Fairly good Not really
Very much Somewhat No answer
Fairly good Not really
3% 2%
5% 35%
40%
55%
60%
Figure 2.2-1
Figure 2.2-2
I learned to take responsibility
I found my team performs better if we work together
Very much Somewhat No answer 6%
Fairly good Not really
Very much Somewhat No answer 3%
2% 5%
Fairly good Not really
1% 5% 15%
30%
57%
Figure 2.2-3 MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
76%
Figure 2.2-4
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
10
I made friends from outside my community
I became more engaged in my community through the community outreach projects
Very much Fairly good Somewhat Not really No answer
Very much Fairly good Somewhat Not really No answer
7%
5%
5%
9%
16%
18%
61%
50%
9%
20%
Figure 2.2-6
Figure 2.2-5
I found out it is very important to believe in myself Very much Fairly good Somewhat Not really No answer
Playing fair and respecting each other is more fun for everyone
Very much Fairly good
Somewhat
Not really No answer
3% 3% 3%
17%
1%
5% 5%
19%
74%
70%
Figure 2.2-7 MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
Figure 2.2-8
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
11
I learned to make considerate decisions with regards to my health and safety
I was able to help others in my community and show gratitude for what they do for me
Very much Fairly good Somewhat Not really No answer 5%
Very much
Fairly good
Somewhat
Not really
No answer
3% 3%
5% 16%
22%
45%
11%
67%
23%
Figure 2.2-9
Figure 2.2-10
I realised I can control my anger Very much
I agree that attending school regularly is very important for my personal future
Fairly good
Very much Fairly good Somewhat Not really No answer
Somewhat Not really No answer
5%
3%
6%
15%
11% 56%
22%
1% 4%
Figure 2.2-11
MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
77%
Figure 2.2-12
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
12
Â
2.3 Youth Leadership Programme Report The main objective of EduFootball’s Youth Leadership Programme is to equip young people with leadership and facilitation skills in order to create positive role models and leaders for other youth and in their communities. In partnership with its coaches and local partner organisations (40 Childcare Facilities) EduFootball identifies young people who show exceptional leadership potential. Every two years 15 girls and boys are selected to go through a four year training phase. Throughout the four years the young leaders receive a certified coaching license, career guidance, internship opportunities with companies from various sectors as well as mentoring of their academic career.
How do you feel interacting with certain social groups? 100%
90%
Comfortable Comfortable 88,24%
Indifferent
Don't feel comfortable
Comfortable 87,50%
80%
Comfortable 71,43%
Percentage of Participants
70%
Comfortable 69,23%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
Don't feel comfortable 21,43% Don't feel comfortable 11,76%
Don't feel comfortable 12,50%
10%
0%
Indifferent, 7,14% Indifferent, 0,00%
Indifferent, 0,00%
Peer Groups
Younger Groups
Figure 2.3-1 MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
Adults
Indifferent, 23,08%
Don't feel comfortable 7,69%
Opposite Gender
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
13
Â
Do you see any improvement in your way of social interaction due to the AMANDLA Leadership Programme? Yes
Indifferent
Did your expectations in reaching your personal goals change during the programme? Yes
No No 0%
Indifferent
No
5% 17%
Yes 100%
78%
Figure 2.3-2
Figure 2.3-3
Do you think your selfesteem improved during the last years being in the Leadership Programme?
I am a role model in making fellow students aware of the importance of education
Yes
Indifferent
No
Very much
Somewhat
Undecided
Not really
Not at all 0% 6%
94%
Figure 2.3-4 MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
6%
6% 0%
29%
59%
Figure 2.3-5
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
Â
Which Leadership Skills could you improve through the programme?
5 4,5
5 = Very much
4 3,5 3 4,50
4,18
4,12
4,06
4,00
-
2,5
4,00
4,00
3,94
3,94
3,88
3,80
3,75
1 = Not at all
2 1,5 1
Leadership Skills
Figure 2.3-6 MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
3,65
3,65
3,63
3,63
3,59
3,56
3,56
3,47
14
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
Which life-skills could you improve through the AMANDLA EduFootball Youth Leadership Programme 5,00
4,00 3,50
4,40
4,47
Willing to learn
3,94
4,18
Know my strengths & weaknesses
3,93
Self-esteem
3,79
Sense of gratitude
3,38
3,69
Reading
2,00
3,56
Sense of belonging
2,50
Polite & Respectful
3,00
1,00
LIFE-SKILLS MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
Figure 2.3-7
Communication
1,50
Writing
1 = Not at all
-
5 = very much
4,50
15
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
16
The programme sometimes distracts me from my studying
I engage more in discussions in the classroom since I joined the Leadership Programme
Very much
Somewhat
Very much
Somewhat
Undecided
Not really
Undecided
Not really
Not at all
Not at all
6%
7%
6%
38%
7% 13%
12%
13% 60%
38%
Figure 2.3-8
Figure 2.3-9
I feel more focused since I joined the Leadership Programme
I feel more motivated since I joined the Leadership Programme
Very much
Somewhat
Very much
Somewhat
Undecided
Not really
Undecided
Not really
Not at all
Not at all 0%
5%
12% 29%
6%
0%
11% 59%
Figure 2.3-10 MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
78%
Figure 2.3-11
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
17
How did you deal with players that did not play for the team? 60%
Percentage of Participants
50%
40%
30% 50,00%
20% 31,82%
10% 13,64% 4,55%
0%
0,00%
I tried to exclude them from the team...
0,00%
I start swearing...
I walk off the field...
I did not care...
SOLUTIONS
Figure 2.3-12 MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
I asked them I told them to why they felt play for the unable to play team... for the team...
3. Facilitators Evaluation Report 2010
MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
19
3.1.
General Programme Feedback
The following charts display the overall feedback received in the form of questionnaires and interviews conducted with football and life-skills facilitatiors responsible for implementing sessions for AMANDLA EduFootball (AMANDLA) throughout 2010. In total AMANDLA’s 30 football and life -skills facilitators were able to reach approximately 2000 girls and boys on a weekly basis. A randomly selected group of facilitators (approx. 50%)were interviewed and asked to complete a detailed questionnaire evaluating the impact that AMANDLA’s programmes have on children in their care throughout the year. The facilitator’s feedback is supported by feedback form beneficiaries gained through interviews and questionnaires as well as the field reports of AMANDLA staff members.
Life-skills sessions per week Once
Twice
More than twice
25%
31%
44%
Figure 3.1-1
Duration of life-skills sessions Less than 60 minutes
31%
60 minutes
More than 60 minutes
19%
50%
Figure 3.1-2 MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
20
Percentage of facilitators
What are the most apparent changes in youth's behaviour who participate in the Youth Leaderhip Programme? 60 50
50
50
50
50
50
50
40
44
44
30
31
20 10 0
Figure 3.1-3
Percentage of facilitatiors
The AMANDLA Fair Play System helps to raise awareness most about:
100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 20 10 0
88 75
69 56
Figure 3.1-4
MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
56
56
56
50
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
21
Coaches' opinions on the life-skills training workshop
Perceived effectiveness of AMANDLA's life-skills education Very effective Effective Neutral Ineffective Very ineffective
Helpful Unnescessary No answer
0% 6%
6%
13% 6%
50%
94%
25%
Figure 3.1-5
Figure 3.1-6
Level of interest in receiving more life-skills facilitation training Very
Maybe
No
I can see a positive difference/change in children participating in AMANDLA programmes Yes
No
No answer
0% 0%
25% 75%
Figure 3.1-7 MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
13%
87%
Figure 3.1-8
AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Figurative Evaluation Report 2010
Â
Percentage of facilitators agreeing on the following statements: AMANDLA programmes... 100 90
Percentage of facilitators
80 70
88 81 75
60
69
69 63
63 56
50
56
40 38
30
31
20 10 0
Figure 3.1-9 MONITORING & EVALUATION DEPARTMENT AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Cape Town, February 2011
38
22
4. Contact
CONTACT German Office: AMANDLA EduFootball e.V. Staufenstr. 4 83209 Prien am Chiemsee Federal Republic of Germany phone: +49 (0)8051 939 0476
South African Office: AMANDLA EduFootball- Project AMANDLA KuLutsha 20 Durham Ave Salt River 7925 Republic of South Africa phone/fax: +27 (0)21 447 8261 info@edufootball.org www.edufootball.org