THE UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN’S INDEPENDENT STUDENT NEWSPAPER SINCE 1969 Volume XLIII, Issue 132
Thursday, April 26, 2012
www.badgerherald.com
Voter ID stay stands
State, system relations tense
State Appeals Court declines to decide on law, injunction could hold in recalls Sean Kirkby State Politics Editor Voters may not have to present photo identification at the polls for the June recall elections after a court denied the state’s request to end a temporary injunction on the law Wednesday. The voter ID law faces two challenges brought in two separate appeals courts, one brought by the League of Women Voters of Wisconsin and the other by the Milwaukee Branch of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People. Judges have imposed a temporary injunction in the NAACP case and a permanent injunction in the League of Women Voters case. According to a court order in the NAACP case, since the matter is currently awaiting a decision by Judge David Flanagan, the court declined the Department of Justice request for an appeal, as well as the request to stay the temporary injunction. “We are disappointed
in this decision,” DOJ spokesperson Dana Brueck said in an email to The Badger Herald. “However, another injunction was entered in a separate action, and both injunctions would have to be stayed or overturned in order for the voter ID law to be in place for upcoming elections.” Michael Hintze, Wisconsin state coordinator for the Tea Party Patriots, said the injunctions against the voter ID law should never have been issued in the first place. He said presenting photo identification at the polls does not cause voters any hardship because the state pays for the identification. He said this is a “oneman, one-vote” society, and that allowing people to vote multiple times without presenting voter ID could cancel out another’s vote. “But it is what it is, and the election will move forward,” Hintze said. Democratic Party of Wisconsin Chair Mike Tate said in a statement
VOTER LAW, page 2
Report finds public feels more distant from universities Mike Kujak State Legislature Editor
of reinstating eligibility, nine against and four abstaining. During the session, each member voting on the eligibility decision was required to state for the record their support or denial for the move, as well as their reasoning. Much of the debate centered on the group’s fulfillment of the eligibility requirement that more than 50 percent of their programs go toward direct services for students, as well as
During the university’s celebration of the Year of the Wisconsin Idea, experts are questioning the strength of the state’s relationship with the University of Wisconsin System and whether the public feels a growing distance from the higher education system. In a report published last month, UW political science professor Kathy Walsh said while public opinion matters for the administration of public higher education, little is known about how members of the public perceive these institutions. According to the report, after having in-depth conversations with people throughout the state about UW, Walsh found people still have a respect for the university system, but they make sense of it through a “lens of distance.” To improve the public’s perception, Walsh said
MCSC, page 5
RELATIONS, page 4
Megan McCormick The Badger Herald
A member of MCSC breaks down the group’s direct services, which had been the center of debate. Members also said the ordeal has caused great strain.
Deadlocked Council deems MCSC eligible Chair Allie Gardner votes in favor to break tie, raises neutrality question Jackie Allen Campus Life Editor In the final move to end a months-long funding debate, members of the University of Wisconsin student government narrowly voted Wednesday to reinstate the Multicultural Student Coalition’s funding
eligibility for the next fiscal year. Associated Students of Madison Chair Allie Gardner broke a tie with Student Council members by voting in favor of reinstating MCSC’s eligibility to receive funding. Gardner also spoke last semester in support of MCSC at a Student Services Finance Committee meeting, which immediately sparked questions of neutrality in the deciding process. The final vote tally stood at 10 in support
Bidar-Sielaff aims for common agenda as Council President Leah Linschied City Life Editor A vocal official on city issues, Ald. Shiva BidarSielaff, District 5, recently secured the position of Madison’s City Council president by a unanimous vote. Bidar-Sielaff has
been a part of City Council since 2009 and served as the council president pro tem last year but has been actively involved in city affairs since her arrival to Madison in 1997. In an interview with The Badger Herald, BidarSielaff talked about her
guiding agenda for the council’s next session and whether she plans to run for the city’s highest leadership position. The Badger Herald: What are your personal connections to the city? Shiva Bidar-Sielaff: I actually started my work
serving on city committees. When I first moved to Madison, I had heard this was a city with a love of citizen engagement, and I wanted to make sure I was contributing in some way to the city. I served on the Public Health Commission at the time. My work has
Megan McCormick The Badger Herald file photo
Incoming City Council President Shiva Bidar-Sielaff first became involved with ALRC when she felt student voices were not heard by Madison officials, and said quality housing is at the forefront for students issues.
City will audit Chaser’s, Logan’s bars for possible license violation Kaylie Duff y Herald Contributor Despite a city committee’s decision not to take immediate action on the issue, two downtown bars may face audits into the breakdown of their business model in the coming weeks, which could carry a penalty of being forced to shut down. The Alcohol License Review Committee met Wednesday evening to discuss a request by the
Madison Police Department to have the city perform audits on Logan’s Madtown and Chaser’s Bar and Grille. The committee also voiced concerns about setting a specific deadline to complete the city’s audit process. According to Madison Assistant City Attorney Jennifer Zilavy, both establishments hold operating licenses that require them to operate primarily as restaurants. Running against the
provisions of their licenses, Logan’s and Chaser’s have operated primarily as bars. A restaurant in Wisconsin is defined as having sales of alcohol beverages accounting for 50 percent or less of an establishment’s gross receipts. MPD requested the audit to determine what percentage alcohol and food accounted for the establishments’ receipts.
AUDIT, page 6
always been around social service advocacy, and I figured that continuing to being involved in city policy-making was an important piece of that. I was also a member of the Police and Fire Commission for five years. BH: As president, what are some specific goals you want to focus on? Bidar-Sielaff: Developing a council agenda is one we’ve been talking about, coming up with two or three issues that the council wants to work toward as a whole, … like social services and issues with poverty, homelessness and housing in the city. It’s never been done before. I also think continuing to provide the council with regular updates about discussions with the mayor. That’s one of the main roles of the president, is to be the link between the legislative and executive branch. BH: As an alder for Madison’s District 5 near the University of Wisconsin campus, what student issues have you addressed, and will those
issues take priority during your time as president? Bidar-Sielaff: That was one of the reasons I ran for City Council. Having worked a lot with students, I found that oftentimes their voices weren’t being heard at the city level. I’ve served on the Alcohol License Review Committee, dealing with issues around finding a good balance between entertainment within our city for young people and finding ways to make sure we don’t have the kind of alcohol binge-drinking that leads to safety issues for our students. I’ve been also quite involved in the discussion of housing issues, whether it is the quality of housing, making sure students understand their rights and making sure that we have good policies in line for appropriate housing for students. One other issue that’s come up is this whole issue of ID requirements and what kind of IDs are required for entering alcohol
BIDAR-SIELAFF, page 3
INSIDE Many candidates bad for Democrats An abundance of Democratic candidates is not always a good thing for party health.
OPINION | 7
UW alum seeks end to global poverty
Associated Press
Still got it goin’ on
Globe Med project aims to break an international cycle of living in poverty.
There’s more to Fountains of Wayne than its biggest hit. The band performs this weekend in Madison.
NEWS | 3
ARTS | 9
© 2012 BADGER HERALD