Harvard Law Review

VOLUME 127

DECEMBER

2013

NUMBER2

HARVARD LAW REVIEW IN MEMORIAM: RONALD DWORKIN Richard H. Fallon, Jr. Frances Kamm

J ohn C. P. Goldberg M artha M inow

Charles Fried Frank I. Michelman Laurence H. Tribe

ARTICLE THE LEAKY LEVIATHAN: WHY THE GOVERNMENT CONDEMNS AND CONDONES UNLAWFUL DISCLOSURES OF INFORMATION

David E. Pozen

ESSAYS NOT T AKEN: A. HART'S HARVARD

THE PATH H. L.

ESSAY ON DISCRETION

H. L. A. Hart

DISCRETION H. L.

A.

Nicola Lacey

HART'S LOST ESSAY:

DISCRETION

Geoffrey C. Shaw

AND THE LEGAL PROCESS SCHOOL

NOTES Danger Lurking in the Shadows: Why Regulators Lack the Authority to Effectively Fight Contagion in the Shadow Banking System The Vagaries of Vagueness: Rethinking Private Nondelegatíon

the CF AA as a Problem of

Toward a General Good Faith Exception

~.

RECENTCASES RECENT LEGISLATION RECENT LEGISLATIVE DEBATE RECENT PUBLICA'FlONS

Copyright ©

THE

HARVARD

LAW

REVIEW

ASSOCIATION

2013

by

VOLUME 127

DECEMBER 2013

HARVARD

LAW ©

NUMBER 2

REVIEW 2013

by The Harvard Law Review Association

CONTENTS IN MEMORIAM: RONALD DWORKIN

489

Richard H. Fallon, Jr.

489

Charles Fried

491

John C. P Goldberg

494

Frances Kamm

498

Frank I. Michelman

499

M artha M inow

504

Laurence H. Tribe

507

ARTICLE

The Leaky Leviathan: Why the Government Condemns and Condones Unlawful Disclosures of Information

David E. Pozen

5 12

The Path N ot Taken: H. L. A. Hart's Harvard Essay on Discretion

Nicola Lacey

636

Discretion

H. L. A. Hart

ESSAYS

H. L. A. Hart's Lost Essay: Discretion and the Legal Process School

~\,

652

9•••.........

666

~OIREI,O

Geoffrey C. ~aw a~.;: ~ ~,

~

, I

'" ~

íO.tIGR.201/f

• qflJ~'01tC-""

-----2::1

COTA N?EX..

.

.~

COMPRA

CONTENTS

NOTES

Danger Lurking in the Shadows: Why Regulators Lack the Authority to Effectively Fight Contagion in the Shadow Banking System

729

The Vagaries of Vagueness: Rethinking the CFAA as a Problem of Private N ondelegation

75 I

Toward a General Good Faith Exception

773

RECENT CASES

First Amendment Commercial SpeechSecond Circuit Holds that Prohibiting Truthful Off-Label Promotion of FDAApproved Drugs by Pharmaceutical Representatives Violates First Amendment.

-

United States v. Caronia, 703 F.3d I49 (zd Cir. 2012)

795

Education Law School Finance Colorado Supreme Court Upholds State's School Finance System as Rationally Related to the "Thorough and Uniform" Mandate of the Colorado Constitution 's Education Clause. -

Lobato v. State, 304 P.3d I I32 (Colo. 20I3)

803

Fourteenth AmendmentDuty to Protect Third Circuit Holds that State Has No Duty to Protect Schoolchildren from Bullying Under the Special Relationship or State-Created Danger Exceptions. -

Morrow v. Balaski, 7I9 F.3d I60 (3d Cir. 20I3) (en bane)

11

8Il

CONTENTS

Constitutional Law Fourth AmendmentFirst Circuit Holds that the Search-Incident-to-Arrest Exception Does N ot Authorize the Warrantless Search of Cell Phone Data. -

United States v. Wurie, 728 F.3d I (1St Cir. 2013), reh'g en bane denied, No. 11-1792, 2013 WL 4080123 (rst Cir. July 29,2013)

819

Habeas Corpus Federal Statute of Limitations Eleventh Circuit Holds that Postconviction Counsel 's Misconduct Does N ot Excuse Untimely Petition. -

Smith v. Commissioner, Alabama Department of Correetions, 703 F.3d I266 (r r th Cir. 2012) (per curiam),

reh'g en bane denied, No. II-I3802 (r r th Cir. Feb. 19, 2013)

827

RECENT LEGISLATION WarPowersDetention of Prisoners Congress Renews Restrictions on President's Power to Transfer Guantanamo Detainees to Foreign Countries. National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2013, Pub. L. No. II2-239, ยง I028, I26 Stat. 1632, 1914-17 (codified at 10 V.S.c. ยง 801 note (2012))

835

RECENT LEGISLATIVE DEBATE Parliamentary ProcedureFilibusters Texas State Senator Wendy Davis ..~~ Filibusters Abortion Bill. Senate Session, TEX. STATE SENATE (June 25, 2013), http://www.senate.state.tx.us/avarchive /ramav. ph p ?ram =00006 278 RECENT PUBLICATIONS

:

iii

~';

843 851