The Creature
The Creature
Minnari Lee
The North Sea
Sea of Eternal Darkness: Tales of
North Sea before 1850
Revealing the unknown surface: Offshore
Industrial activities from 1850 until now
Territorial Expansion of Technology from now into the future
North Sea as an Energy Factory
Dichotomously complicit: Radical simplification of a complex living system
Creating a Technological Mediator
The Creature - Year 2200
Ijmuiden, The Netherlands
The body
History of IJmuiden
An Interview with hypothetical residents in 2200
Environmental Management and Planning with The Creature Chambers of Resources
The North Sea
Sea of Eternal Darkness: Tales of North Sea Before 1850
The North Sea has long been regarded as ‘something from the other side’ by people living along its shorelines. It was a zone between heaven and earth, between the familiar coastline and whatever lies beneath the water. It has been a place of the unknown, waiting to be explored. Numerous stories have been created and passed down through generations among the people living around the coast. Civilisation developed, trade flourished, and tales were written. Due to its geological location and fluctuations in barometric pressure, the North Sea is cold, rough, and experiences frequent changes in weather conditions. In the past, its notorious strong winds challenged sailors attempting to navigate its waters. For example, in 16 AD, the Roman military commander Drusus Germanicus tried to sail his fleet across the North Sea, but they were pushed back by a storm. Albinovanus Pedo, a poet who was part of the fleet, wrote that God was calling them back from the unaccepted visit to their quiet home.1 Norwegian maps of the North Sea from the 15th century depict it as a space inhabited by imaginary sea creatures and giant monsters, making it a dangerous and mythical place. Huge and terrifying beings of evil, such as the Kraken and the Leviathan, were said to reside there, governed by different laws of life than those on the mainland. The North Sea was the edge of the world, and no one could imagine going any further. It was a place where the sea collided, where water swept into a fathomless void, and where it flowed into the primordial substance that existed at the dawn of time—a place known as ‘the abyss.’2
This map depicted the unknown expanse of the North Sea’s offshore areas, populated by imaginary sea monsters. It was created during a time when sea exploration was still in its infancy, and much speculation surrounded what lay beyond the known territories.
The Kraken is a legendary sea monster often depicted in Scandinavian folklore and mythology. It’s commonly portrayed as a massive, tentacled creature resembling a giant squid or octopus. It dwells deep in the ocean and can drag ships and sailors to their doom.
Revealing the Unknown Surface: O shore Industrial Activities from 1850 until Now
This North Sea’s notoriety largely faded away after the 19th century. Since the industrial use of coal became the norm, the way the North Sea was perceived began to shift, and the tales of the sea were gradually erased from our collective memory. Most notably, the invention of steamships —driven primarily by advancements in steam engine technology— exponentially increased human activities in the offshore region. Since then, the discovery of oil fields in the North Sea and subsequent commercial oil extraction began as early as 1851 in the Midland Valley of Scotland. 3 Its abundant fishing grounds, where its sandbanks provide a breeding ground for flatfish, sand eels, whitefish, scallops, and other local marine animals, became hubs of the commercial fishing industry. Or take the Port of Rotterdam in the Netherlands, the largest port in Europe, which opened in 1888 and made the North Sea one of the highest ship traffic density regions in the world. Fast forward to today, the grounds of Dogger Bank have provided ample space for corporations and governments of the surrounding countries to install numerous wind power generators, leading to the world’s largest offshore wind farm. This new development phase simultaneously brought second chances to declining industrial cities around the North Sea coast, such as Hull (England) and Bergen (Norway), which have now become the forefront of a new ecological era. These cities are experiencing new economic growth by producing wind turbines and providing related offshore industrial services. Especially, IJmuiden (The Netherlands), home to an early industrial steel factory, is receiving a lot of attention for its future trajectory. The multinational steel factory situated on the dunes of IJmuiden recently announced its commitment to reducing its carbon footprint in production. The North Sea is thus bound to play an important role in the future
3 Glennie K. W. Petroleum Geology of the North Sea: Basic Concepts and Recent Advances, 12. 4th ed. John Wiley & Sons, 1998.
of energy provision in Western Europe. Most recently, the Netherlands plans to insert cameras and radar systems to secure intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance capabilities, protecting pipelines and wind turbine cables in the area.4 With the intense configuration of all these activities, the North Sea is no longer an unknown space. Instead, it is a playground for testing cutting-edge engineering technologies and innovations. Now, it is fair to say that humanity has the ability to perceive the North Sea without mythical beings, sea monsters, and our imaginations of bottomless voids. Rather, we have witnessed this place transform into a human-centered space at an exceptionally rapid pace.
4 ‘This capability helps deter potential perpetrators of sabotage and espionage,’ Ollongren and Van der Maat wrote. ‘Improving the protection of the vital infrastructure on the North Sea has the full attention of the cabinet.’ Ruitenberg, Rudy. “Netherlands to Boost North Sea Surveillance to Deter Seabed Threats.” Defense News, 20 Dec. 2023, www.defensenews.com/naval/2023/12/20/netherlands-to-boostnorth-sea-surveillance-to-deter-seabed-threats/. Accessed 10 Jan. 2024.
Territorial Expansion of Technology from Now into the Future
We can see this transformation of the North Sea into such an anthropocentric space in the way journalists, scientists, and policymakers talk and write about it. Yet it is hard to comprehend what the actual significance of it is or on what scale it plays out, due to its considerable geographical and physical distance from our own living environment. In fact, this anthropocentric system is barely visible to us, while the insertion of these technologies into the landscape of the North Sea is deeply connected to our lives in the surrounding cities. It is a smoothly functioning background 5 that offers people the necessary resources: to have lights in their homes at any time, to keep the indoor temperature always comfortable, to receive our (so-called) sustainably made clothing shipped from across the continent at any time, or to consume exotic fruits and fresh fish at nearby supermarkets. As Paul N. Edwards stated, ‘Mature technological systems such as cars, roads, municipal water supplies, sewers, telephones, railroads, weather forecasting, buildings, and even computers, in the majority of their uses, reside in a naturalised background, appearing as ordinary and unremarkable to us as trees, daylight, and dirt. Our civilisations fundamentally depend on them, yet we notice them mainly when they fail, which is a rare occurrence.’6 Due to their inaccessibility, the offshore structures in the North Sea, towering over 300 meters above the surface of the sea, are barely visible as small dots from the coast. Moreover, most of their supplementary facilities and sub-structures are completely invisible.
Additionally, beyond offering basic needs such as drinking water, food, and shelter, our desire to feel secure has also come to include social connectivity through new information technologies, as well as the assurance that we can continue to do so in the future. This entails the continuous use of
5 ‘The most salient characteristic of technology in the modern (industrial and postindustrial) world is the degree to which most technology is not salient for most people, most of the time.’ Edwards Paul N. Infrastructure and Modernity: Force Time and Social Organisation in the History of Sociotechnical Systems, 185-188. The MIT Press, 2002.
6 Edwards Paul N. Infrastructure and Modernity: Force Time and Social Organisation in the History of Sociotechnical Systems, 188. The MIT Press, 2002. Today, it is fair to say that the machine is not so much in the garden as it is indistinguishable from the garden; They are inexorably intertwined. Strang Gary L “Infrastructure As Landscape [Infrastructure As Landscape As Infrastructure].”, 4. 1996.
electronic devices as much as we want, taking pictures of our daily activities, and storing them indefinitely in the internet cloud. All this has become an intrinsic part of sustaining life in modern cities. These systems, which offer people a sense of assurance and security, can be called ‘infrastructures.’ They are connective tissues, circulatory systems, and manufacturing processes that function collaboratively and synergistically, producing and distributing a continuous flow of essential goods and services.7 In fact, all infrastructures are sociotechnical in nature. This means that, to be considered infrastructure, it also needs to include organisations, social acceptance, public reliance, and accessibility to its service. 8 However, I am mainly referring to its hardware quality in this text.9
Building and maintaining any type of infrastructure requires large, long-lasting institutions; they rely on enormous political and social power, as well as great wealth.10 Particularly, offshore infrastructure demands more efficient engineering, is larger in scale, and is more costly to install than any other infrastructure on the dry land. Hence, numerous business proposals related to offshore projects in the North Sea are long overdue for financial funding and government approval. They involve a wide variety of projects, from innovating home care systems to increasing urban biodiversity, and addressing chemical emissions from offshore wind farms.11 These plans claim to promise us a better future by tackling major societal and environmental problems that threaten human territories, such as rising climate catastrophes and increasingly unpredictable resource flows. These projects declare that they can gain control over these risks by implementing hyper-efficient technologies. As anthropocentric practices take an oceanic turn, the North Sea should be included in the contemporary urban realm, where an expanding field of modernist ideas is finally arriving. Considering its significance in terms of materiality, political position, and ecological space for the future of humanity, I would like to question: What are the overlooked aspects as the North Sea transforms into a human-centered space through a technocratic approach? And how can we employ technology for the future of the North Sea?
7-8 Edwards Paul N. Infrastructure and Modernity: Force Time and Social Organisation in the History of Sociotechnical Systems, 187-188. The MIT Press, 2002.
9 Some type of infrastructure such as educational institutions or legal systems rely relatively little on technology, but these fall out of the scope of this text.
10 Edwards, Paul N. Infrastructure and Modernity: Force Time and Social Organisation in the History of Sociotechnical Systems, 200. The MIT Press, 2002.
11 Forfang, Sofie. “Go-Ahead for 14 New Projects, Interreg VB North Sea Region Programme.” Interreg VB North Sea Region Programme, 21 Sept. 2022, northsearegion.eu/about-the-programme/programmenews/go-ahead-for-14-new-projects/. Accessed 10 Jan. 2023.
All we can ‘see’ are small dots beyond the horizon. However, the scale of land required to sustain these installations is colossal.
Location West coast of Norway Dogger bank -
Type Oil and gas platform Offshore wind farm A claster of wind turbines
North Sea
North Sea
Fig 5. A list of offshore Infrastructural projects in the exclusive economic zone (EEZ) in the North Sea Currently, more than 500 offshore installations are actively extracting oil and gas from the continental shelf throughout the North Sea. Additionally, hundreds of new proposals for offshore infrastructure await governmental approval.
North Sea as an Energy Factory
To address these questions, this study examines the current proliferation of technologies in the North Sea. I outline some of the major criticisms in this chapter.
Blinded by the affective backdrop of numerous future solutions (mostly energy-related) through the implementation of offshore structures into the North Sea landscape, we may overlook that it entails further industrialisation and even imperialistic territorial expansion. As mentioned earlier, most offshore projects are carried out on a large scale, requiring vast sums of money and sophisticated technology. Several national-scale institutions are involved in carrying out the projects, from preliminary planning to eventual service distribution. Economic motivations have historically driven territorial expansion, particularly in the scramble for resources and market shares. Yet, there is an important omission here. These large projects often entail the brutal removal of local elements, such as small social groups, non-humans, and local ecosystems. Through wielding enormous political and economic power, institutions and governments have the ability to eliminate these elements, which, in most cases, occurs during the earlier phases of infrastructure development. Henry Veltmeyer has aptly described this expansionist growth as being based on a new model of ‘extractive imperialism’.12 Technology has been radically used to achieve this by embedding it into the local landscape. Take, for instance, the railway systems that were installed during colonial times. They serve as one of the clearest examples of imperialism through technology. As Margot Francis stated, ‘railways symbolised the expansionist audacity of imperialism and provided the essential technology to bring the West into its emerging dominion.’13 The physical act of transforming seemingly empty
12 Extractive imperialism means ‘a form of primitive capital cumulation that has stark similarities to the old style of Colonial Extractivism organised by the European empires in the nineteenth century.’ Nesbit Jeffrey S and Charles Waldheim. Technical Lands: A Critical Primer, 157. Jovis 2022.
13 Francis Margot. Creative Subversions: Whiteness Indigeneity and the National Imaginary. University of British Columbia Press, 2012.
territories into spaces of extraction, only beneficial to the colonial authorities has long been justified by also labelling these places as previously ‘empty’ spaces,14 which establishes, expands, and maintains the existing powers. This essentially signifies our method of territorial expansion.15 As a result, the inhabitants, such as marine animals and microorganisms that the North Sea has nurtured for hundreds of millions of years, are being sacrificed to these machines, which are producing more (green) energy for the surrounding city residents.
Second, what is often overlooked is that building infrastructure in the North Sea means that resources need to travel longer distances. Placing large machinery near urban areas often evokes reactions and dissatisfaction among city residents. To avoid political unrest and minimise economic losses, authorities (such as urban planners, property managers, and governments, etc.) usually opt for the easiest solution: placing infrastructure far away from urban populations. By perfectly arranging machinery in a row in distant offshore areas, many complex socio-political issues are solved. The key is to functionally separate residential and technological areas, maintaining a physical gap between the two. In this way, machines become inaccessible and can be aesthetically ignored, while our reliance on remotely extracted natural resources is eventually increased. This human-exclusive zone becomes a haven for machines. They are allowed to monopolise the surface and space of the North Sea, creating a new classification of terrain: ‘Technical Land.’ Peter Galison asserted that ‘The more infrastructure expands to ever-wider circles —from local to state, national to international— the more they are technical lands.’16 Hence, having technical land in a distant location also means that a larger area of our landscape, both beneath the seabed and on the mainland, needs to be engineered and exploited in order to transport resources from these distant areas into cities. This involves the installation of pipelines and cables. It is inevitable that these works disturb local landscapes, displace non-humans, and disrupt ecosystems.
14 Said Edward W. Culture and Imperialism, 9. Vintage Digital, 2014.
15 Arturo Escobbar asserted that ‘These categories are often leveraged to justify, legitimise, and sometimes even legalise environmental degradation and social exploitation in service of economic, political, and/ or social agendas.’ Henni Samia et al. Deserts Are Not Empty. “Designs for the Pluriverse, book Desert”, 82. Columbia Books on Architecture and the City an Imprint of the Graduate School of Architecture Planning and Preservation Columbia University, 2022.
16 Nesbit Jeffrey S and Charles Waldheim. Technical Lands: A Critical Primer, 23. Jovis 2022.
Lastly, integrating offshore structures into the North Sea necessitates the perpetual maintenance of these structures in optimal condition, ensuring the absence of any threats to efficient operations.17 This also means that everything intended to be permanent, and anything threatening its perfect condition (and which is not plannable or foreseeable), must be brutally removed to maintain its ‘unchanging state.’ For instance, a pipeline is a vulnerable target for terrorists. The security precautions for one in Dyce (Scotland), with a 200-kilometre length, are so rigorous that even the local rabbits along the route have sought refuge.18 The offshore infrastructures are a ‘matrix of control’ taking a physical form, controlled by authority with a convenient mixture of state ownership and private enterprise. The notion of having a final and sole purpose implies that other beings not included in the plan are unwelcome or even need to be eliminated from the territory. Spontaneous elements, with their temporary nature and unexpected outcomes, are also considered risks and do not align with the plan. These elements lose their place once the territory has been defined. For instance, there is a growing body of evidence that indicates a considerable bird collision risk with offshore wind turbines. Throughout the evolution of marine birds (those that exploit the resources of the sea), they did not have to contend with the collision risk posed by discrete objects invading their flight space above the water surface.19 Not only is the area above the surface affected, but also underwater, where sounds caused by operational wind turbines and other machinery influence the life of local fish. During operation, fish living close to, or even tens of meters away from, the turbine may detect noise generated by the particle motion of the turbines. This could lead to behavioral errors among certain fish species.20 These offshore machines are fundamentally not designed to coexist with other living beings.
17 Definition of matrix of control: ‘the ongoing joint effort of those in power (often governments and corporations) to ensure that everything is perpetually maintained in a ‘perfect state’ and that there are no threats to efficient operations.’ Boer René and Kees de Klein. Smooth City: Against Urban Perfection Towards Collective Alternatives. Valiz 2023.
18 John Kerr, “North Sea oil begins to flow – archive”. The Gardian. 1975. 3 Nov 2017. https://www. theguardian.com/business/2017/nov/03/north-sea-oil-forties-field-begins-to-flow-scotland-1975
19 Martin Graham R and Alex N Banks. “Marine Birds: Vision-Based Wind Turbine Collision Mitigation.” Global Ecology and Conservation.
20 Hawkins Anthony D and Arthur N Popper. “Effects of Anthropogenic Noise on Animals.” Effects of Man-Made Sound on Fishes, Faculty of Science Institute of Biology Leiden (IBL), Leiden University, Leiden, The Netherlands, 2018. pp. 145-New York NY : Springer.
21 ‘Expedition sets out to research restoration opportunities of the Atlantis of the North Sea’ Nature today. 27 Nov 2023. https://www.naturetoday.com/intl/en/nature-reports/message/?msg=31583.
Fig 6. Map of inhabitants of the North Sea in 2200: Future scenario
A <A Gigantic Energy Factory> In this scenario, the last seagulls and fish have left the North Sea. The sea is now becoming a gigantic efficient energy factory. As the wind blow faster, the waves become more turbulent.
In response to the recently studied facts regarding marine environments, there are various attempts to understand how far humanity can manage the selfmade destruction. These include genuine efforts to restore the seabed around Dogger Bank 21, studies on applying colors and achromatic patterns to the blades and pylons of turbines to reduce bird collisions, and advanced research on human-induced sound in the ocean to understand its impacts on migration patterns of marine animals and their habitat quality. However, these efforts, while valuable, add ‘additional’ elements to the problems. If the fundamental principle of engineered machines is ‘efficient operation as the highest value,’ the North Sea would eventually force marine life to migrate. This would be the very first step toward the North Sea becoming a giant energy factory.
(engineeredlandscape)
7. Increasing soil subsidence and sea-level rise
It is referenced from ‘Increasing soil subsidence and sea-level rise in the western peat lands in the Netherlands over the past 1000 years’ (Zagwijn, 1991), and figures of the sea level rise are sourced from the moderate scenario in the IPCC reports of 2022.
Dichotomously Complicit: Radical Simpli cation of a Complex Living System
The belief in inserting multiple technologies into the grounds of the North Sea stems from a dichotomous worldview. In philosophy, this is often referred to as ‘dualism’. 22 This dualistic perspective is about putting things in two different pockets with contrasting aspects, and assigning them either superior or inferior value. Such an understanding of the world can lead to conceptualising relationships between humans and nature, machine (or culture) and nature, heaven and hell, physicality and mentality, form and substance, ideal and reality, body and mind, sea and land, and more. This epistemological viewpoint has long shaped humans’ way of seeing the world, especially in Western cultures, 23 by focusing on categorising the world into two sets of properties. his naturally implies a simplification and generalisation of matters to fit them into two distinct categories. However, this dichotomised worldview falls short when it comes to explaining the complex and diverse values intertwined with today’s reality, especially when dealing with our damaged Earth. The dualistic worldview oversimplifies a complex, multidimensional reality, neglecting the intricate interdependencies and nuanced relationships that exist between various elements of the world. Similarly, such an attitude toward the North Sea reflects a hierarchical relationship whereby humans are considered distinct
22 e Genesis story in the Bible, where humans are given dominion over the Earth is a great example of the anthropocentric ideas in the Western culture. In Greek philosophy, thinkers emphasised the dualism between form and matter: form represents the ideal, while matter symbolises disorder and imperfection. is dualistic perspective, suggesting that nature is chaotic thereby human’s rationality and reasoning are necessary for order. e scienti c revolution of the 16th and 17th centuries, marked by Galileo, Copernicus, and Newton, advocated a mechanistic view of the universe. is perspective laid the foundation for modern science and technology. With the advent of industrialisation and capitalism in the 18th and 19th centuries, the exploitation of natural resources for economic gain intensi ed. e emphasis on progress, growth, and material wealth o en led to perceiving nature as a resource to be exploited for human development. During the era of European colonial expansion, there was a tendency to view the nature as a subject to be conquered, exploited, and controlled for the bene t of colonial powers. is mindset contributed to the exploitation of indigenous peoples and their lands and the destruction of ecosystems.
23 e classical emphasis originates in Plato’s Phaedo. Plato believed that the true substances are not physical bodies, which are ephemeral, but the eternal Forms of which bodies are imperfect copies. Robinson, Howard. “Dualism.” Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, Stanford University, 11 Sept. 2020, plato. stanford.edu/entries/dualism/.
from nature and superior to it, providing justification for the exploitation of natural elements. It portrays nature (a concept extending from non-humans and organisms to ecosystems) as something to conquer and utilise.
In his book Water and Dreams, Gaston Bachelard describes ‘[t]he sea [as] both an adversary seeking to defeat us and, at the same time, an adversary we must conquer. Those waves are like punches that we must confront and fight against. A person swimming gives the impression of throwing their entire body into the fray, colliding with the limbs of the adversary’. 24 For decades, the struggles with the North Sea have been intertwined with a significant part of the history of European countries bordering its waters. This is especially true for the Netherlands, which has been fighting against water for centuries. This dualistic approach has strongly shaped how we treat and react to the sea. Take, for instance, the severe storm surge of 1953, which struck the northwestern parts of the Netherlands, Belgium, England, and Scotland, causing the collapse of coastal defenses. This led to widespread flooding of coastal areas, displacing millions of people who had to abandon their homes. In investigating the causes of such disasters and implementing measures to prevent future floods, the Delta Works —designed through engineering technology— stands as a project that vividly illustrates the Netherlands’ struggle against water. Simultaneously, it has contributed to fostering a strong belief in engineering as the sole method to triumph over water and waves in the ongoing battle with nature. What is critical to understanding this point of view is that this dualistic attitude towards the North Sea creates continuous conflicts. By stating a ‘versus’ position, conditions of losing and winning naturally emerge. Such conflicts are bound to persist until one side is destroyed or defeated. In order to ‘win’ the climate crisis, we must ‘conquer’ and ‘utilise’ it! In this ‘versus’thinking, we will ‘end’ if we do not manage to ‘win.’ This hostile relationship blinds us to the intricacies that are inherent in the present-day global landscape. In the same vein, offshore infrastructure is inherently incompatible with natural elements, making a symbiotic relationship impossible. The construction of offshore infrastructure, in most cases, leads to inevitable disruptions of existing ecosystems and the displacement of organisms. My argument is that this has been fundamentally attributed to a dualistic worldview from which technology has been developed, and because of which it is destined to confront nature. Consequently, from this situation, the cohabitation of these two entities
24
gives rise to a binary and persistent antagonistic confrontation, wherein one must eventually devour the other’s land to continue. Coexistence between these two (seemingly conflicting) entities appears impossible. The only way to overcome this ongoing and apparently eternal dualistic conflict is by technology transcending the limits imposed by such a worldview.
Fig 8. Eastern Scheldt storm surge barrier
This mega-structure is the largest of the Delta Works, designed to protect the Netherlands from flooding from the North Sea. The construction of the Delta Works was a response to the North Sea flood of 1953. Its great success is a heroic symbol of ‘man versus water’.
Extensive flooding along the coastlines of the Netherlands, Belgium, and the United Kingdom, has resulted in significant loss of life and property damage.
Creating a Technological Mediator
This project explores a new form of offshore infrastructure: a ‘living entity’ that serves as a mediator, intertwining ‘hard’ mechanical networks with ‘soft’ biophysical dynamics. By providing an ‘artificial interface,’ it aims to contribute to creating a better relationship with the landscape, non-humans, and natural elements. Ultimately, it seeks to replace the way conventional infrastructure operates within our current engineered environment. This project is with several objectives. (1) It attempts to free from our conventional belief in ‘infrastructure,’ both in conceptual and physical way. 25 Its inception resides in the realm of imagination and the expansive domain of the ocean, a historically imaginative space for humanity, serving as a catalyst for future endeavours. (2) It aims to prioritise the Earth’s metabolic exchange over the conventional emphasis on humans as the sole end users. This exercise is grounded in a new design ethos, offering an alternative to the prevailing industrial complex, which overly simplifies intricate living systems and facilitates the extraction of life to increase economic value. (3) Through this intervention, a new interaction can arise between humans and the technology that ensures their lives. In this manner, we can redefine our somewhat forgotten relationship with our resources, ultimately aiming for a renewed and more
( technological inventon)
(technological inventon)
organised and balanced manner.
conscious connection. This new interaction hopes to satisfy a longing for belief and trust in our fundamental intuition, the courage for ethical action, and sensory interaction with earthly life. As Rosalind Williams said:
‘To landscape is to work with the planet; to improve, enhance, and adorn it; to liberate its potential, as opposed to imposing structures of conquest. Landscaping brings with it an acceptance of the passage of time as something to be appreciated rather than battled. e typical verbs associated with infrastructure are age and decay. e typical verb of landscape is cultivated through long-term commitment of human labour and other resources, it is renewed and reworked. From the landscape orientation, maintenance is not a core to be resisted but the core of what it means to create a human world.’ 26
When considering the urgency of today’s environmental issues, it might seem overly romantic. Yet, many environmental measures, policies, and technological interventions will not work fully if a profound ecological consciousness is lacking. Following Donna Haraway, who proposed ‘tentacular thinking,’ referring to a way of understanding our living environments that embraces interconnectedness and complexity, the tentacle imagery suggests a form of thought that reaches out in multiple directions, making connections and engaging with a diverse range of ideas and perspectives. 27 This project represents an effort to translate these theoretical concepts, which were previously confined to the realm of abstraction, into a more concrete model with tangible architectural practices. Diverse formats, such as moving images, paintings, sculpture, and architectural drawings, are extensively used to communicate these ideas. is endeavour begins to slowly to appear on the horizon, in the form of ‘ e Creature’.
25 ‘Landscape infrastructure is a live index and indeterminate interface of hard technological systems and so biophysical processes by design.’
Bélanger Pierre asserted that infrastructure and their designers (equally means engineers) form ‘an unbreakable bond of beliefs that transcend public consciousness across a wide societal spectrum’. ‘...engineers have secured a position in society that is not only based on common sense or on the foundations of technology as some believe, but that hinges on an entire chain of ideals, impulses, and inclinations. Together, they form an unbreakable bond of beliefs that transcend public consciousness across a wide societal spectrum: infrastructure - technology - engineering - strength - stability - security - precision - protection - permanence - public work - federalism - identity - nationalism - state - economy - growth - development.’ Bélanger Pierre. Landscape As Infrastructure: A Base Primer, 38 and 54. Routledge 2017.
26 Bélanger Pierre. Landscape As Infrastructure: A Base Primer, 7. Routledge 2017.
27 Haraway Donna Jeanne. Staying with the Trouble: Making Kin in the Chthulucene. Duke University Press 2016.
The Creature Year 2200
A Junctional Being
The Creature stands in a blurred boundary between elements that have long been dichotomous, such as sea and land, past and future, nature and human (human culture or machine), and post-industrial and environmental realms. In particular, The Creature is a mediator formulating a new dynamic relationship between the North Sea and humans (implying nature versus humans) through the following interactions:
(1) The North Sea, a natural entity and environment where The Creature thrives, provides the energy and resources for The Creature. In return, The Creature cleans up pollutants from the industrial age that are widely distributed along the coast of the North Sea.
(2) The Creature, a technological being, is a junctional existence. Its soft existence supports human coexistence as a part of the ecology. These floating entities serve as an ‘environment’ that provides energy and resources for humans; growing seaweed, providing a habitat for fish and small animals, desalinating seawater, harvesting energy from sea waves, and transporting these sea products to nearby human settlements. The Creature also functions as a ‘tool,’ carrying out maintenance of the healthy North Sea and its coastal areas.
(3) Humans, as natural beings, build The Creature and provide maintenance to it. They are dependent on The Creature for every day life by collecting and hunting resources from the interior environment of The Creature. And they are always in proximity to The Creature’s activities.
This interplay between the North Sea, The Creature, and humans is a pivotal in integrating human activity into Earth’s metabolic system. The Creature, as a mediator, is designed to improve the previously simplistic and one-dimensional relationship between the North Sea (or nature) and humans. This broader perspective enables us to grasp the issue within a larger context, fostering environmental stewardship and promoting the sustainable coexistence of all beings.
North Sea
environment for The Creature
environment for the visitors
Creature Humans
Interplay between the North Sea, The Creature, and Humans 1. Resources
2. Maintenances
Post-Industrial Being
The birth of The Creature relies on past industrial activities. Without this history, The Creature would not exist. The post-industrial cities surrounding the shores of the North Sea are its birthplace. Their abandoned factories and neglected waterfronts provide the raw materials for its creation. The very machinery and infrastructure that once drove industrial progress now serve as the building blocks for The Creature’s existence.
Industrial infrastructure: offshore windturbine, containtership, and The Creature
An Interfacial ‘Body’
The Creature has a body intertwining ‘hard technological systems’ with ‘soft biophysical processes’, making the body itself ‘a technological interface’. This body resembles a collection of spaces and functional machinery, crafted to mimic the organs of an animal. With these organs, The Creature actively cleans the North Sea through its digestive processes, including absorbing, storing, and discharging. There are countless small animals and sea organisms sustaining their lives within this body throughout this process. However, having this ‘body’ comes with limitations. For instance, the quantity of resources that it can produce in a given time is limited, and it can only handle certain natural conditions. These thresholds may sound limiting in terms of its possibilities; however, it helps to create a better relationship with both Humans and The North Sea operating within the Earth’s metabolic systems. How The Creature works is described in the following pages.
Relation between internal and external water flows
Ijmuiden, e Netherlands
The
body
Internal Reservoir
e internal reservoir is the core space of e Creature’s body, taking the biggest space of all. Its water &ows are closely connected to the surrounding environment, the North Sea. Seawater is absorbed into e Creature’s body through the entering spaces at the chamber of sh. During this process, sea organisms such as plankton and small sh are &owing into the interior spaces along with substances like sand, sh eggs, and seeds. ese organisms are transported by internal water currents and settle in suitable locations, enriching the diverse internal environment of e Creature.
Plan: on water
1. Internal reservoir
2. Chamber of freshwater
3. Chamber of fish
4. Chamber of electricity
5. Main entrances
6. Entrances for toxic materials
7. Physical work platform
8. Technical rooms and storages
9. Public toilets
10.Entrances from docks
11.Lobby
Internal Fluid Materiality
The Creature’s internal space is primarily composed of three materials: brackish water, sand, and industrial toxins. These substances move around the internal spaces and chambers over long periods of time. These flows of materials are related to the shape of the organism’s body and organs. Moreover, it is also linked to the dynamics of materials in the external environment surrounding The Creature.
Detoxing Gut
One of The Creature’s most remarkable abilities is its capacity to mitigate the impact of human-induced pollution and habitat destruction. The Creature’s lower floor is mainly composed of toxic processing system. People remove the Industrial toxic substances that have accumulated in the ground of IJmuiden and bring them to this processing facility. This digestive system is a long tube-like space where algae and bacteria capable of breaking down these toxic substances inhabit. The new city IJmuiden accommodates the laboratory of bacteriology. The industrial toxins are removed through the symbiotic process of the organisms within The Creature’s body. Eventually, the remaining substances are treated to be returned to nature. After that, the North Sea environment naturally disposes of such debris. In doing so, it creates a safer and healthier environment for all inhabitants, both human and non-human alike.
Plan : underwater floor
Entrances for Fishes, Water and Humans
The fish entrances are located under the water surface at the chamber of fish. The spaces have small openings towards the North Sea where the sea substances flowing in and out freely. The entrances for human visitors are located its tail, where it can anchor to the dock of IJmuiden city. The entrance space is located relatively higher, providing easy accesses to the dock. Human visitors can walk down the internal reservoir.
Skin Texture
The Creature’s skin is woven meticulously with synthetic byproduct of steels harvested from IJmuiden. The steel is collected from the various area around IJmuiden and Amsterdam. After its collection, the scrap steel is purified and melted down in a furnace. Once the processed is complete, it is then cast into shapes, depending on which body parts that it will become.
Born Structure
The foundational structure of The Creature’s body is constructed using reused steel. This backbone of The Creature offers stability to store the diverse functions and programs of the internal spaces and machines as well as it supports as it navigates its environment of the North Sea.
Anatomy of The Creature
In the body of e Creature, there are various organs such as skin, skeleton, mouth, lungs, and a gut. ese organs are closely related to each other and collaborate in its metabolic processes. While these organs serve mechanical functions, they also function as architectural spaces for the residents of the city.
Anatomy of The Creature: organs and functions of The Creature
1. Top skins - roof
2. Top ribs - main structure
3. Mouths - the chamber of fish
4. Liver - the chamber of fresh water
5. Left lung - the chamber of electricity
6. Bottom ribs - main structure
7. Right lung - the chamber of electricity
8. Gut - industrial detoxing tube
9. Bottom skins - plates
History of IJmuiden
e Creature is born from the city of IJmuiden. is city used to be situated at the entrance of the North Sea Canal. Its strategic location was a vital gateway to the industrial activities and transportation networks to Amsterdam, o ering e cient import and export operations.
IJmuiden, The Netherlands
A map of the North Sea featuring one of the birthplace of The Creature.
Coastal Nature, 1850
Previously, this area was a wetland protected by sand dunes. It was also a place where people raised livestock and established a small village called Breesaap existing from the late Middle Ages to the 19th century. The farmers in Breesaap kept sheep and grew some potatoes and grain.
The North Sea Canal, 1880 e North Sea Canal constructed between 1865 and 1876, connects Amsterdam to the North Sea at IJmuiden. is arti cial waterway was built to facilitate maritime navigation and provide seafaring vessels access to the port of Amsterdam. However, as a consequence of the North Sea Canal excavation, the groundwater level in the Breesaap decreased, resulting in the land drying out and causing a decline in the farmers’ livelihoods.
Steel Factory, 1920
Established in 1918, Royal Dutch Blast Furnaces and Steel Mills (Koninklijke Nederlandse Hoogovens en Staalfabrieken, KNHS) emerged as a pivotal entity in the landscape of the area. e factory’s genesis aligned with the advent of the canal locks, symbolising a shi towards mass-scale industrialisation. e arrival of the factory coincided with the introduction of large canal locks, marking a period of industrial steel production alongside international free trade. Due to the enlarging the North Sea Canal together with the paving the wet ground to asphalt to make the ground comfortable for the human uses, the groundwater level in the Breesaap consequently dropped, leading to land drying out.
International Steel Factory, 2020 e factory has expanded several times over the century. e layout of the steel factory is based on the conventional way of producing steel, emphasising an linear process. With its e cient operation taking land as a giant factory, it has built a successful history in producing industrial steel products and has contributed to shape the industrial era. However, in the year 2020, more than half of the factory’s facilities were no longer in use due to its decreased demand for industrial steel in the global market.
Relocation Plan, 2050
Due to continuous sea level rise over the past 80 years, large-scale &ooding and damage have persisted in low-lying areas in recent times. Flood defense systems like dams and water locks are already reaching their limits, with a sea level increase of +4.5 meters. Small towns are frequently inundated by &oods. However, the steel factory’s location remains relatively secure, being on average +8 meters above sea level. ere is a plan to relocate residents of &ood-prone areas to where the steel factory was situated. e most prominent challenge is the pollutant soils and lands spreading 13 square kilometers. is evident result of heavy steel industry activities is undergoing transformation into a new home for a population of 20,000 people, as well as becoming the birthplace of e Creature.
An Interview with Hypothetical Residents in 2200
There is the massive structures next to the shore. Did you build this?
‘Yes, I am a builder and one of the people who built The Creature. We built her all together. About a population of 20,000 people live in our city, and we all contributed to building her.’
What is The Creature?
‘Think of The Creature as a regenerative farmer of the North Sea: growing seaweed and vegetables, desalinating seawater into freshwater, and harvesting energy using waves, and bringing these sea products to our city. Plus, we live in close proximity to her activities. The Creature is essentially an artificial being. She serves a dual role for us, as “an environment” and “a tool”. As an environment, she provides us with resources. while as a tool, she has a functional role in keeping our land healthy. The relationship between these three entities: human, The Creature, and North Sea is maintained in a balance by mutually exchanging “resources” and “maintenance”.’
Sand dune, IJmuiden, 2023
What distinguishes The Creature from the previous infrastructural system, and how does it interact with the North Sea?
‘The Creature has a “body”. This sets her apart from the previous infrastructural system of the industrial era. Her body is like a collection of spaces and functional machines, designed to resemble organs of an animal. She cultivates the North Sea through digestive activities, storing, absorbing, and discharging. There are many small animals living within her body throughout this process. However, having this “body” comes with some limitations. For instance, The Creature’s body is designed for activity on shallow waters of the North Sea; therefore, she cannot be on land nor in deep water. These thresholds may sound limiting in terms of her possibilities; however, it helps to create a better relationship with both us and the North Sea.’
How do you create a relationship with ! e Creature?
‘We collect fresh water, vegetables, electricity, and hunt fish in The Creature. Her internal environment is cultivated in a way that allows those resources to grow there over time. As visitors, we find and collect as many resources as we can carry with our bodies. These visits are usually made 2-3 times a week. It’s like going to a supermarket. To get the necessary resources for our lives, we also maintain her internal environment. So she stays healthy and resilient. The relationship between us and The Creature is created through this careful exchange of “resources” and “maintenance”.’
How did you learn to build it?
‘Mostly I learn from school. We are all trained as designers, scientists, craftsman, and builders. For my case, I’ve been repairing and maintaining the small compartments of The Creature since I was a kid. I have grown up with seeing my parent and neighbors working together to keep the machines running. Building her comes naturally to me. There are several workshops in the city where I do experiments and test new findings. In the archive center, all of our published knowledge is stored in a digital format. There are plan drawings and construction details. Everyone can access them.’
Could you explain how to cultivate the land?
‘Cultivating the land is like working with the planet. We try to improve, enhance, and adorn it; We try to liberate its potential, as opposed to imposing structures of conquest. First, divide the polluted land into 70 by 800 meters. Each parcel of land is managed and cultivated by a group. Some are heavily polluted from industrial activities in the past. But it’s okay. All groups can go at their own pace. Because there is no clear result that needs to come out on time. No one owns land here. Our purpose is only to keep it healthy. We build The Creature from the harvested steel from the land. And we limitedly use crane and excavator to fulfill our role as steward of the land. These machines can only be on the “hard passage” since it easily damages the soft surface of our dune.’
Common view, IJmuiden, 2023
Could you share your favorite place in the city?
‘Everyday, I go swimming in “shallow water basin”. It is a place where I am taking care of a small water garden. Local animals like plovers and sandpiper are visiting my water garden! My friends and neighbors come there to have a small chat and we do picnics sometimes.’
Could you briefly introduce the history of your city?
‘Before we have this clean and safe land that everyone wants to visit, our city was well-known for its industrialised steel production and for being a part of the North Sea Canal. At some moment in the past, industrialisation was the norm in many societies. The earth, land, ocean, and dunes were targeted for exploitation. And our land, the wet land with the dune was hugely damaged. Before, this area used to be a swamp; a wet land protected by sand dunes. You can still see the old dune mostly on the north of our city. In the past, the larger and deeper dunes once guided us to the North Sea. The old steel industry has heavily polluted the land before our settlement in the area. We had to create a better relationship with the land. That is also for our survival. The Creature emerged from there.’
Common view, IJmuiden, 2023
Common view, IJmuiden, 2023
Environmental Management and Planning with The Creature
Dividing Land
e land division process commences with the implementation of allotment layout and an excavation grid. It is to facilitate collective cultivation, ensuring the involvement of all parties. e division aims at creating equitable and manageable sections, each assigned to speci c groups such as families, relatives, and friends, typically consisting of 100 to 150 individuals. Despite variations in pollutant levels and soil quality across di erent plots, the collective responsibility is assumed to rejuvenate the entire expanse. In certain regions, the restoration e orts spanned two or three generations, dedicated to clearing old contaminants and restoring the land healthy.
The Planning of the New City
Total population of 20,000.
Total area approximately 13.000.000 m2 (13km 2). Average size of a parcel 70 x 800 m (105.600 m 2). Average population of 100 to 150 in a parcel.
Harvesting Steel for building The Creature e residents excavate the industrial toxins that remained on the ground. Meanwhile, they also harvest the steel, which KNHS and Tata Steel have been producing for more than a century. is local steel had become a fundamental material of the land, shaping the region’s identity over decades. is is also where e Creature was born from. People built e Creature by using the steel harvested from this area. e industrial steel plants and the North Sea Canal, which once divided the sand dunes in half, are now the materials for building e Creature.
Target Objects in Details
Excavating Ground Toxic Clays
Each group has its own pace, employing various methods and skills for land cleaning, toxic excavation, and steel collection, creating di erent results. On average, digging about 3 meters is necessary to reach the healthy sand. e Toxic materials were transported to e Creature through the strong paved hard passage from the previous industrial city.
1. Excavation of industrial toxic materials.
2. Working together with the machines like excavator.
Physical relation with baskets and jars.
Invention of The Creature.
New
Patterns of the Landscape is city doesn’t have a traditional centre. Instead, it has e Creature’s decks where everything converges. In each ‘parceled block’, there is an area hosting a collective community, laboratory, market, and workshops. Residential blocks encircle the communal block on both sides of the street, strolling to the next block in about 5 minutes. It’s a city where traditional hierarchical systems and political power are minimised.
Detail of the landscape quality
Water Moves Freely is city is meticulously woven, blurring the boundary between land and water. Having water around brings e Creature closer, making resources more accessible. e depth of the excavation, the &ows of sand through winds, and the tides of the North Sea determine how much water gets into this land.
* e plant list referenced by A.P. Grootjans, R.M. Bekker ‘Why Young Coastal Dune Slacks Sustain a High Biodiversity.’
Sand Dune Protection is city depends on the sand dunes to protect it from storm surges. Consequently, the e orts of the city residents are focused on cultivating and nurturing these healthy sand dunes. e more people invest in cultivating the land in this manner, the safer they become from natural disasters.
* The image is re-created based on a painting from L.A. Ring, ‘The
Chambers of Resources
Chamber of Fish
e largest area around the central reservoir consists of the chambers of sh where sh, seaweed and other marine life thrive. e entire hydro dynamic system is related to the internal reservoir and the North Sea beneath the water’s surface. People visit these chambers to sh and collect shells, seaweeds, and other items they may nd in the environments. ere are a total of eight di erent chambers in total, each with unique conditions shaped by internal currents, the depth of the sand bed, and the organisms that have settled there.
Principle section and mechanism of the chamber of fish
1. Small animals, planktons and fish eggs can enter and exit from this entrance.
2. Fishing platform.
3. Jetty and walkway for visitors from the seaside.
4. Releasing freshwater. It is slowly helping the North Sea to be less saline.
Principle plan of the chamber of sh
Chamber of Electricity
Life has become increasingly automated with digital devices. e Creature provides a space where people can charge their devices and batteries for home machines. e layout of this area is organised like an self-studying room or co-working space, with rooms designed for a set number of people to sit around tables. Here, people can work with their devices using electricity generated by wave power from directly beneath the rooms.
Principle section and mechanism of the chamber of electricity
1. Enclosed space has an opening beneath sea level which allow water to flow to this space and back. Water level in the chamber rises and falls with the rhythm of the waves.
2. Electric generator. The wave action alternately compresses and decompresses the trapped air forcing an air flow moving back and forth through a wells turbine that drives a generator and produces electricity. [Well Turbine]
3. The winds once passed through the electric generator move cross the wind corridor.
Work rooms are where people gather to charge their digital devices and machines.
Principle plan of the chamber of electricity
Chamber of Freshwater
People can bring their water jars to the chamber of freshwater and ll them up with drinking water. It might be heavy, but fear not- you may have a carrying robot to help! e enclosed dorm structure is designed so that the process of producing freshwater uses simple physics, such as condensation and evaporation, creating internal rain within the chamber. Additionally, rainwater is collected through the skin structure of e Creature.
Principle section and mechanism of the chamber of electricity
1. Fresh water in this chamber is cultivated in the following order: (a) Strong heat from the sun enters to the enclosed space. (b) Evaporation occurs on the surface of the water on the internal reservoir. (c) Condensation occurs on the internal surface of the ceiling. (d) The water drops. (e) Fresh water is saved in the freshwater tank. And the clean water filtered by local sand is being ready to be distributed to visitors at the collecting point.
2. Freshwater tank is consisting of two parts: an upper hanging tank and an underground storage. Freshwater is clean, safe, and drinkable. In the water laboratory next to the underground storage, a quality control system and a remote research lab are located.
3. Internal rain gives enough water for the plants to grow and flourish in the communal garden.
4. This cycle allows the internal reservoir to be brackish water.
Principle plan of the chamber of freshwater
Living with Creatures
The Three Post-Industrial Cities
The Creature takes its birthplace in the three post-industrial cities situated around the North Sea: Ijmuiden, Bergen, and Hull. As a mediator between humanity and the natural world, The Creature plays a crucial role in fostering harmony and coexistence among the diverse array of life forms inhabiting the North Sea. The birth of The Creature represents a transformative moment in the relationship between humans and the environment. During the industrial time, the human activities around the North Sea have often led to ecological degradation and the disruption of fragile marine ecosystems. However, The Creature’s emergence signals a shift towards a more balanced and sustainable approach to cohabitating with all other beings. The core idea of its shift is based on new ideas employing technology not as an efficient tool but as a mediating device.
Furthermore, The Creature serves as a symbol of resilience in the face of adversity. Its existence underscores the potential for positive change and the possibility of forging a more harmonious relationship with the natural world. By embracing The Creature’s role as a mediator and steward of the environment, humanity can work towards a future where coexistence and sustainability are prioritised, ensuring the continued well-being of the North Sea and its inhabitants for generations to come.
Scale Comparison
e Creature from the di erent cities have di erent sizes. is stems from factors such as their natural habitat, available resources for its materials and structure, and population density. ese elements intricately shape the physical dimensions of each creature, re&ecting adaptations to their speci c environments.
13. Scale comparison of the three creatures in relation to the modern offshore infrastructure, wind turbine, container-ship.
Bergen, Norway
Location
A map of the North Sea featuring one of the birthplace of The Creature.
Locality
Bergen used to be the Scandinavia’s biggest traiding hub from 11th century to the 18th century.
Bergen served as Scandinavia’s largest trading hub from the 11th to the 18th century.
Structural Materials
r a r i il mai l i or i ia m r ram from the nearby Forestry. The forest and the biological diversity in the forest is of great value as an ecological resource of the i aro m
The Creature is predominantly constructed using Norwegian timber frames sourced from nearby forests. These forests, with their rich biological diversity, are invaluable ecological resources for the surrounding cities.
Main Structural Principle
The main structure is woven like a jigsaw puzzle to prevent it from spreading and expanding into the deeper levels of the Norwegian Trench.
Currents
A quiet inlet from the Norwegian Trench: r i i a i a la r i o o a rr o la O a a a a i l r morpology of the landscape and terrain.
A quiet inlet from the Norwegian Trench: Bergen is situated in a place where the inflow of the fast current of the Atlantic Ocean and the Baltic Sea is filtered by the morphology of the landscape and terrain. altc current tlantc water
The depth of the Norwegian Trench can be reached to 300m. The Creature from Bergen is evolved as an underwater entity.
1
2
8
3
4
7
5
ll mo ai Bergen was described as 'the green meadow among the mountains'.
Lyderhorn Damsgardsll Lovstakken Ulriken Floyen Rundemanen Sandviksll Mountains
The seven mountains (de syv fjell) are surrounding the city, Bergen. It used to be an area described as ‘the green meadow among the mountains’.
yde ho n Damsga d s ellet ovsta en Ulriken loyen Rundemanen andvi sellet
Principle Plan
Functional rooms are interconnected each other.
Hull, England
Location
A map of the North Sea featuring one of the birthplace of The Creature.
Riverbank
The city is situated along the Humber River. The 14 km length of the river bank is suitable for the large number of the creature (B) claster to be anchored.
0 km 10
The city is situated along the Humber River. The 14 km length of the riverbank is suitable for the large number of The Creature cluster to be anchored. This river is characterised by dynamic tidal movements and varying depths along its course. m 10
Depth of Riverbank
Closer to the river’s mouth to the North Sea and along its banks, depths may be shallower, especially in areas where sedimentation occurs. The small scale of The Creature from Hull is perfectly adapted for such natural condition.
Post-Industrial City
The city had become a major hub for offshore wind energy since 2020, with companies like Siemens Gamesa and Ørsted establishing manufacturing facilities and offshore wind farms in the area.
25 years life span
Structural Materials
The Creature is built from the byproducts of the offshore wind farm construction. The unwanted materials and its trash for one wind turbine will be managed to create 5 small creatures (b).
Cluster (behavior)
The behavior of The Creature is being and working as a cluster. This cluster cultivates the fresh water, food, and energy as a group to bring them to the city Hull.
r a r i il rom ro o o or i arm o r o a ma rial a i r for one wind turbine will be manage to create 5 small creatures (b).
Spread (behavior) The Creature spreads along the Humber riverbank in the city Hull.
Principle Plan
Schematic plan.
Principle Section Schematic section.
Storage l Rooms of machines
resource chamber (a)
Storage
‘Twelve-thousand-year structure, structure that seems so real we call it nature.’
Master’s degree in Architecture
Academy of Architecture Amsterdam
Mentor
Jeroen van Mechelen
Committee member
Jandirk Hoekstra
Committee member
Marten Kuijpers
Extra graduation committee
Geurt Holdijk
Extra graduation committee
Susana Constantino
Colophon
Texts. Drawings, and Images
Minnari Lee
Proofread (Chapter: The North Sea)
Kobe De Keere
Editing
Minnari Lee
Publication Design
Hyeonjeong Joo
- Timothy Morton
Acknowledgments
Many people have contributed invaluable things to this project. First and foremost, I would like to express my gratitude to my mentor, Jeroen van Mechelen, for his sincere guidance and patience throughout this journey. Without his consistent advice regarding ecological aspects of the project, the result would not have been completed in a satisfactory manner. I also extend my deepest gratitude to my committee member, Jandirk Hoekstra. His powerful presence at every meeting was such a gift to me over the last two years. His sharing of invaluable knowledge in landscape architecture will forever be my foundation for upcoming projects. And, I am grateful to my last committee member, Marten Kuijpers for his extensive remarks beyond the scope of architecture. His curiosity and accurate perception were invaluable in the process. Furthermore, a heartfelt thank you goes out to my dear Kobe De Keere for his unconditional supports and intellectual generosity, particularly from a theoretical and sociological aspects. The simple fact that having him by side significantly boosted my perseverance and dedication throughout this endeavor. I also wish to express my gratitude to Christoph Seyferth for his encouragement and life-long unfailing support. Additionally, a big thanks to Hyeonjeong Joo for her contributions to this publication and her availability for the very last request. And thank you to De Architekten Cie. for their flexibility in planning and materialistic supports. Lastly, thanks to my cat, Namu, who sat always by me while I was struggling with the texts and the drawings. I would like to thank the many friends, collaborators, and colleagues with whom I discussed the project in last two years. This project would not have been completed without all your support.
© 2024 by Minnari Lee
T: +31 (0)6 24 35 96 14
W: http://minnarilee.com
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be used or reproduced in a context of reviews. Several reference images in the book were sourced from Google search engine. This can be adjusted if there are any issues. Any errors or omissions will be rectified in future editions.