Burak Celik SCI-Arc M.Arch II Portfolio

BURAK CELIK M.Arch II Portfolio |

2019-2021

Southern California Institute of Architecture

Burak Celik

Copyright © 2021 Burak Celik All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or used in any manner without written permission of the copyright owner except for the use of quotations in a book review. e-mail: burakc28@hotmail.com mobile: +1 (332) 200-7642

SCI-Arc

BURAK CELIK M.Arch II Portfolio |

2019-2021

Southern California Institute of Architecture

Burak Celik

SCI-Arc

Statement

Burak is a Los Angeles-based Architectural Designer.

After receiving his B.Arch Degree from Bilkent University with honors degree, he was honoured to receive Fulbright Scholarship for Masters Degree on Computational Design. He worked for prestigious architecture firms including Studio Libeskind in New York, Oyler Wu Collaborative in Los Angeles and Melike Altinisik Architects in Istanbul. Burak now pursues M.Arch II degree at Southern California Institute of Architecture in Los Angeles.

With a master’s degree, he desires to gain experience in academic research, cross-cultural interaction and competence, and it would open up new horizons for his career and for him to realize ambitious future plans. For Burak, architecture is a strong tool requiring a multidisciplinary approach and thinking that can transform the world into a peaceful home. His experience with computational tools taught him that the intelligence of algorithms and parameters provides many opportunities and convenience to designers in the design phases with many constraints.

Burak Celik

SCI-Arc

Content

3GAX 8

Culver City Office Tower

D S 4 0 0 0 E r i c O w e n M o s s Ve r t i c a l S t u d i o

22

Pacific Palisades House

D S 4 0 0 0 E r i c O w e n M o s s Ve r t i c a l S t u d i o

36

Design Documentation

56

Design Lab

AS3222 Design Documentation

A S 2 7 1 1 A S D e s i g n L a b A rc h i t e c t u r a l Te c h n o l o g i e s

2 G BX 66

Le Musée Imaginaire

96

Invisible

2GBX Computational Design Studio

VS4201 Visual Studies II

2GAX 112

After Images

128

Lou Ruvo Transformed

142

GO BIG! //Stadium

AS3302 Advanced Structural Systems

154

GO BIG! //Airport

AS3302 Advanced Structural Systems

168

SLICE IT!

2GAX Computational Design Studio

A S 3 2 0 0 A d v a n c e d M a t e r i a l s a n d Te c t o n i c s

VS4200 Visual Studies I

WRITINGS 180

AI & Artificial Intelligence

188

Computational Theory

196

Pharmako & AI

H T 2 2 0 0 T h e o r i e s o f C o n t e m p o r a r y A rc h i t e c t u re I

H T 2 2 0 1 T h e o r i e s o f C o n t e m p o r a r y A rc h i t e c t u re I I

H T 2 7 4 3 P h a r m a ko - A I

Burak Celik

8

SCI-Arc

Culver City

Office Tower

Course: DS4000 Eric Owen Moss Vertical Studio Instructor: Eric Owen Moss, FAIA Semester: Fall 2020, 3GAX Location: Los Angeles, CA | USA Partner: James Piccone Software: Rhinoceros, Grasshopper, V-Ray

Project site is located at the crossroads of main axis of Los Angeles and it has a big potential connecting the Downtown with the beach and Airport with the new Expo Line and two main avenues. The project site is in a commercial office area- mostly technologymedia firms and it is next to low rise residential areas from the North-West and East. It has views to Beverly Hills, Hollywood Sign, Downtown, Baldwin Hills and LA River. This is a departing point in our concept and Our strategy is to utilize these views and integrate at different heights becoming vistas in the lower area and panoramic views in the highest portion. COVID has caused us to reevaluate a world that will never be quite the same, especially when it comes to how we gather in and use large public 9

spaces like offices. Although COVID may not stay there forever, we think that’s a great possibility to explore new ways. Our approach here is to provide ventilation in communal areas that could be the hub of cross contamination and use this unconventional way of creating spaces to discover a new approach.

The building is comprised of 8 Intersected Cones.

Each cone develops and affects the previously placed cone, which makes each piece uniquely designed according to its sequence in the building.

Facade is comprised of 3 materials including solid gray GFRC panels, perforated panels and glazed light red extrusions which creates interior closed program spaces.

Burak Celik 1.Landscape

2. Circulation Concept

3. Floor Stacking

4. Development of Cones 01 and 03

5. Development of Cone 05

6. Development of Cone 06

7. Structural Frame

8. Stacking of Structural Cones

9. Stacking of Structural Cones

10

SCI-Arc

The project offers a new way of thinking about our lifestyle, considering COVID as a way for balanced isolation and productive, meaningful collaboration in an office building. One important consideration while utilizing these views is to provide as much versatility and isolation as possible both in terms of views and program spaces.

11

Burak Celik

Left: Perspective Section Right: Second Floor Plan

12

SCI-Arc

13

Burak Celik

Each cone develops and transforms the previously placed cone, which makes each piece uniquely designed according to its sequence in the building. The inner programmatic mass has Ventilated Communal Areas, Corridors and Isolated Hot Desks.

Perforated Panels Glazed Frames Floor Slabs of the Cone 08

Cone Primary Structure

Bronze Custom Panels

Cone Tertiary Structure

W Jefferson Pedestrian Entry Theater Stairs

Left: Axon Drawing Right: East Elevation

14

SCI-Arc

15

Burak Celik

Left: Chunk Elevation Right: Worms-Eye View

16

SCI-Arc

Glazing Mass

Structural Gaps Perforated Panels Bronze Custom Panels

Custom Openings

GFRC Panels

Skylight

Plaza Stairs

Framed Beams

Primary Columns Main Core Secondary Core

17

Burak Celik

18

SCI-Arc

19

Burak Celik

20

SCI-Arc

21

Burak Celik

22

SCI-Arc

Pacific Palisades Residence

Course: DS4000 Eric Owen Moss Vertical Studio Instructor: Eric Owen Moss, FAIA Semester: Fall 2020, 3GAX Location: Los Angeles, CA | USA Partner: James Piccone Software: Rhinoceros, Grasshopper, V-Ray

Pacific Palisades, being a pleasant neighborhood between the Santa Monica Mountains and the Pacific Ocean, offers an immense amount of views.

The project is intended to capture those views, by breaking the limit of “frames” and making them panoramic views all over the house. The spiral concept of the house started by using the spiral as an opportunity to capture the beautiful views of the project site. The definition of a house has changed so much that a house does not necessarily occupy only bedrooms, kitchen, or living room, but COVID, wildfires, climate change taught us, make us remember that a house can also occupy office space to its residents, a library, a bar, a school, remote learning, working and living hub. A house 23

is a significant place in society and defines who we are, how we live, and how we see the world. We should take the outside world into consideration.

The Project is a house for a musician couple. The program includes a Lounge Space and a Music Studio on the Basement Level, Dining Room, Kitchen, and a Large Living Room (Living Deck) on the Ground Level, Bedroom and Restroom on the Upper Level.

The building’s spiral stair/corridor runs all across the building program while providing views towards outside, views including Rustic Canyon, Will Rogers Beach, State Historic Park, and Santa Monica. Inner cylinders were utilized as a way to provide back of house program and structural connectivity through the inner perforated Shear Wall.

Burak Celik

Structural spiral beam with Secondary structural tubes creating a frame and Shear Plate between them in the inner wall make structural stability and help the building cantilever on the Canal.

24

SCI-Arc

Right: Second Floor Plan Left: Section AA

25

Burak Celik

33

ft.

Left: Axonometric Drawing Right: Conceptual Diagram

26

SCI-Arc

1. Landscape

2. Structural Beams

3. Secondary Beams

4. Floor System

27

Burak Celik

Skylight Perforated Panels Secondary Structural Pipes

28

SCI-Arc

Right: Worms Eye View Left: South Partial Elevation

29

Burak Celik

30

SCI-Arc

Top: Model Photo from East View

31

Burak Celik

Left: Model Photo from East Elevation Right: Model Photo from Rustic Canyon View

32

SCI-Arc

33

Burak Celik

34

SCI-Arc

35

Burak Celik

36

SCI-Arc

Design

Documentation

Course: AS3222 Design Documentation Instructors: Herwig Baumgartner, Brian Zamora Structural Consultant: Matthew Melnyk Environmental Consultant: Jamey Lyzun AI Consultant: Casey Rehm Semester: Fall 2020, 3GAX Location: Los Angeles, CA | USA Team: Burak Celik, Peter Kluzak, Abdullah Tahseen, David Seo, Hannah Mann, Ilaria Lu, Jasper Gregory, Kovarthini Sekar, Melody Chu, Ivan Chen, Yixuan Cai, Wenxi Zhang For the Design Documentation, one selected project from 2GBX Computational Design Studio from Spring 2020 has been studied and developed further for the Design Documentation Phase.

During the course, my team worked with multiple consultants and made studies in different scales of our building. Environmental systems studies included environmental analysis, building envelope details, solar radiation, natural ventilation, natural daylighting of the project. In order to get the most detailed results, selected floor plans, sections and chunks from the building were analyzed to be developed for the rest of the building. Construction cost control was another study material that included readings from AIA Standard Form 37

Agreements. The analysis called ProForma was studied where the project costs are also liked into a construction loan and either analyzed in a rental or sales focus. Some other topics and terms including Hard Construction Costs, Soft Construction Costs, Construction Contingency, Project life cycle, and financial considerations of the buildings were both studied and applied to our selected project.

There was also advanced software used for Egress simulation-Mass Motion- and Fire SimulationPyroSim. These studies helped the project to get further developed from the Construction Systems including foundation systems and advanced diagrid systems to more Advanced Systems including HVAC, Fire control, and AI-controlled facade system.

Burak Celik

The project locates at the place where LACMA is located in Los Angeles. Selected project from 2GBX Computational Design Studio has been studied and further developed for the Design Documentation Phase.

38

SCI-Arc

39

Burak Celik

Decorative Formed Metal W Section Metal Panel Frame Tension Cable Steel Channel

Left: Facade Chunk Right: Facade Chunk Close-up

40

SCI-Arc

41

Burak Celik

42

SCI-Arc

43

Burak Celik

Metal Suspension System Decorative Formed Metal Non-structural Metal Study Framing

Gypsum Board Interior Painting Terrazzo Floor Tile

Left: Facade Chunk Right: Structural Diagram

44

SCI-Arc

45

Burak Celik

46

SCI-Arc

Wood Roofing Weather Barrier Board Insulation

Right: Facade Chunk Left: Panel Detail

47

Burak Celik

Metal Suspension Systems Composite Metal Decking Interior Painting Fireproof Gypsum Plastering Non-structural Metal Stud Framing

Glass-Fiber Reinforced Cementious Panels Weather Barrier Gypsum Sheathing Loose-Fill Insulation Structural Steel Framing Terrazzo Floor Tile

Left: Outline Specification Typ. Ext. Wall Right: Facade Chunk

48

SCI-Arc

49

Burak Celik

[ENVIRONMENTAL ANALYSIS] The analysis helped develop many different aspects of the design including the facade system, Air Circulation through the building, Climate Control and HVAC. 1. Solar Radiation Analysis

2. Weather Data

50

SCI-Arc

3. Weather Infographs

4. Sunlight Analysis

Sunlight Analysis 05:00 - 20:00 Summer- Jun. 21 Winter- Dec. 21

79.32° 32.49°

51

Burak Celik

[FIRE SIMULATION] The building was broken up into 5 fire zones which makes each zone separate from each other in case of a fire.

Exterior Walls: 3 Hr. Diagrid Structure: 3 Hr. Nonbearing Walls: 2 Hr. Floor/ Ceiling Assembly: 2 Hr. Roof: 1.5 Hr.

Zone 5 Museum Space Group A-3

Zone 4 Museum Space Group A-3

Zone 3 Museum Space Group A-3 Zone 2 Museum Space Group A-3 Zone 1 Museum Space Group A-3

Left: Building Zones Right: Fire Simulation

52

SCI-Arc

53

Burak Celik

[EGRESS SIMULATION] The simulation was executed through using Mass Motion software. It optimized the core dimensions to evacuate building under 12 mins.

Max Occupancy Floor x 0.3 = Minimum Stair Width

2 per Exit Occupancy Calculation Stair 01 Max. Load: 100 Min. Width Required: 30” Width Provided: 6’-0”

Stair 02 Max. Load: 100 Min. Width Required: 30” Width Provided: 6’-0”

Level 22 Occupancy Type: A2 Museum Space - 15,274 sq ft Occupancy Load: 386 386 people x 0.3/ 2 = 58 inches Width Provided = 6’-0”

Level 22 Area: 15,274 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 386

Level 20 Area: 9,551 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 318

Level 19 Area: 9,318 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 310

Level 17 Area: 3,924 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 130

Level 16 Area: 9,099 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 303

Level 15 Area: 10,173 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 339

Level 14 Area: 3,514 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 117

Level 13 Area: 2,166 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 72

Level 12 Area: 11,436 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 381

Level 10 Area: 6,941 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 231

Level 09 Area: 10,081 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 336

Level 08 Area: 6,662 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 220

Level 07 Area: 7,534 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 251

Level 06 Area: 2,448 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 81

Level 05 Area: 7,592 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 253

Level 04 Area: 4,893 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 163

Level 01 Area: 2,340 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 78

Level 03 Area: 4,890 sq ft Occupancy Type: A2 Occupancy Load: 163

Left: Occupancy Load Right: Egress Simulation

54

SCI-Arc

Occupancy Type F2

Occupancy Type A1

55

Burak Celik

56

SCI-Arc

Design Lab

Platforms

Course: AS2711 Design Lab, MSc Architectural Technologies Program Course

Instructor: Damjan Jovanovic Semester: Fall 2020, 3GAX Software: Unreal Engine, Unity

In this class, there was mainly two software we utilized. By using Unreal Engine and Unity Developer, the purpose was to make a “Platform” which will be an interactive game at the end. The App is designed as a component-based system builder, where the user can select a component from a menu and place it in the game world. For this purpose, 6 modular units were optimized for

57

game purposes. The components are sourced from the design studio material and used in a modular fashion within the simulation environment. The design lab focuses heavily on the construction of a unified modeling/rendering game space, putting special focus on simulation as an aesthetic and functional methodology for design.

Burak Celik

58

SCI-Arc

Right: Units Left: Game View

59

Burak Celik

Left: Game View Right: Blueprint View

60

SCI-Arc

61

Burak Celik

62

SCI-Arc

63

Burak Celik

64

SCI-Arc

65

Burak Celik

66

SCI-Arc

Le Musée Imaginaire the Museum for the Postdigital Age

Course: DS1201 Complex Morphologies Instructor: Jackiling Hah Bloom Semester: Spring 2020, 2GBX Location: Los Angeles, CA | USA Partner: Hannah Mann Software: Maya, Rhinoceros, Unreal Engine, Z-Brush Our project aims to challenge the way that art viewers experience the museum in a new digital age. Our project reimagines William Pereira’s Los Angeles County Museum of Art (LACMA), where Peter Zumthor’s design will be constructed until 2022. Interactive, digitalized art can have the ability to disorient and transpose its viewer through collected data. Digital art pieces break the conventional art-making process and work as a catalyst to the space-making process by using more complex and higher performing data collection systems than it used to be. Projected in rooms and spaces that are designed to be dynamic allows the art pieces to take on new forms resulting in a unique experience. Encrypted artwork is a new technology, 67

allowing art pieces to be displayed in a more secure way through projection and holograms. In a digital age where technology continues to take over the conventional art-making process, encrypted art pieces are secured through databases collected in museum storage spaces and can be displayed through projections, holograms, Augmented Reality (AR), Virtual Reality (VR) or Mixed Reality (MR).

The tectonics of our project works with the data collected from the art viewers. This data can inform the building of new spacial qualities, and allow the tectonics of the structure itself to adapt to the artwork in each second. The concept here lies in the creation of dynamic architectural space, telling a unique story every time.

Burak Celik

68

SCI-Arc

Right: Field, Vector Studies Left: Initial Collage Studies

69

Burak Celik

Left: Site Plan Right: Vector Study

70

SCI-Arc

The territory of museums should concern itself with the whole of the built environment. Heightened disciplinary distinctions between architecture, art, ecology, and engineering marginalize the status of the architectural project, precluding new paradigms for contemporary settings of this digital age. This is primarily a conceptual development for an architectural intervention that is interested in deriving its form from the very notion of art.

71

Burak Celik

72

SCI-Arc

73

Burak Celik

Texture generated by the imagery on the facade has relief in the scale of the building. This surface treatment technique provided porous and solid spaces as well as two dimensional depth and shadow.

74

SCI-Arc

75

Burak Celik

Left: Axonometric Chunk Right: Front View

76

SCI-Arc

Chunk models show how formal arrangement has the impact on the interior spacial quality. Forms generated by using image tracing method from the original LACMA art pieces and optimized in three dimensional space.

77

Burak Celik

Left: Chunk Views Right: Chunk Main Render

78

SCI-Arc

79

Burak Celik

The role of museums to collect, preserve and present objects and art pieces are critical. Today, museums are not only for artviewing but for art-making. This intervention asks the question of what it means to create a museum space using the techniques and mediums of art. It is a study of the atmospheric effects created through art and translated into literal spaces for viewers.

80

SCI-Arc

81

Burak Celik

82

SCI-Arc

EXHIBITION

Exhibition

GALLERY

Gallery

CIRCULATION

Circulation

PLINTH Plinth AUDITORIUM

Auditorium UNDERPASS

Underpass

GROUNDSCAPE

Groundscape

83

Burak Celik

84

SCI-Arc

The interior of our project works to accommodate the encyclopedic museum that LACMA is known for as well as provide niches and platforms for digitilized art.

This project explores the spaces between the physical and digital for transformations. A space that enables transitions and works together with art.

Right: Interior Render Left: Render from the Plinth

85

Burak Celik

86

SCI-Arc

87

Burak Celik

Video

88

SCI-Arc

89

Burak Celik

90

SCI-Arc

Digital displays of the permanent collection through holograms and augmented reality projected in dynamic architectural spaces provides interactive activity areas.

While framing pieces from the encyclopedic collection, the museum also curates views of the cityscape through the plinth.

Right: Interior Render Left: Render from the Plinth Top: Hologram Exhibits

91

Burak Celik

92

SCI-Arc

93

Burak Celik

94

SCI-Arc

95

Burak Celik

96

SCI-Arc

Invisible Course: VS4200 Visual Studies II Instructors: Elena Manferdini, Andrea Cadioli Semester: Spring 2020, 2GBX Partner: Devangi Kansagra Software: Rhinoceros, Grasshopper, Processing, Maya.

For generations, people have been seeking for an easier way of living. Developments and inventions like Industrialization, capitalism, digitization, etc... provide an uncomplicated solution to our consumerist lifestyle. These evolutions made it possible to produce limitless amounts of products and goods without considering the results like war, famine, and plague. Technology has made living in the 21st century very comfortable. It has made us create a bubble around our life making us earn and live comfortably without leaving the four walls of our room. Unlike our past, we as intelligent sapiens know what we need to do to survive the modern apocalypse of abundance in technology. Climate change, global warming, and globalization are 97

the “new” jargon in our contemporary dictionary.

With technology, we have the knowledge to reverse it using “eco-friendly” inventions. But are these inventions actually sustainable? How many sustainable solutions are actually sustainable in the long run? We reimagined how a production and transportation based future cities might affect the natural habitat and landscape we have now.

This intervention seeks to imagine what will be the side effects of solar panels or windmills after three centuries. Except for giving humans electrical energy, will it help our environment? Can windmills stand in between trees or forests or they need flatlands? How can we integrate technology both into our lives and the environment in a mutual way?

Burak Celik

Left: Digital Model Right: Render

98

SCI-Arc

Now, our planet is on the brink.

Our forests are under pressure like never before and our oceans are under great stress of toxic chemicals. It is a dual scenario where we see how nature acts when humans and their activities like trains, industries, etc harm the surroundings versus how nature will heal itself as it has always been, a world in which Artifical Intelligence plays a significant role transforming our damage on Planet Earth, our one and only house.

99

Burak Celik

100

SCI-Arc

101

Burak Celik

Video

102

SCI-Arc

103

Burak Celik

104

SCI-Arc

Left: Original Image Top: Image with UV Light

105

Burak Celik

106

SCI-Arc

107

Burak Celik

108

SCI-Arc

109

Burak Celik

110

SCI-Arc

111

Burak Celik

112

SCI-Arc

After Images Course: DS1200 Complex Morphologies Instructors: Ferda Kolatan, Rachael McCall Semester: Fall 2019, 2GAX Location: Chinatown, Los Angeles, CA | USA Partner: Jonah Klinghoffer Software: Maya, Rhinoceros, Processing, Z-Brush, AgiSoft, Autodesk Recap The project begins with a process of extracting visual and physical information from a site in Downtown Los Angeles as well as several urban artifacts of diverse scales. The extracts is the point of departure for all of the studio work. We worked on producing a composite form of selected source material derived from the site context that redefines the formal relationships inherent in selected elements and shifts these toward an architectural scale. The first exercise focuses on integrating multiple forms captured through three dimensional scanning techniques and digitally modeled forms to produce composite forms with displaced scalar effects. We worked with 3D scanning portions of an urban site, identifying the inherent biases and opportunities 113

within this technology to define new perceptions of common artifacts. The outputs from these forms of perception was remodeled and composited in the form of a multi-material model comprised of 3D printed and vacuum-formed constituents.

Our project overlaps the imaginable with the unthinkable by converging highly abstract forms with rational architectural detail, through guise of the image in multiple translations. The diverse shapes that compose the building have individual formal qualities which synchronize together through materiality, texturization, and image treatment. The design is a composition of forms that have meaning when merged into one entity. (Project Description by

Burak Celik and Jonah Klinghoffer)

Burak Celik

114

SCI-Arc

Right: Photogrammetry Point Clouds Left: Chunks Produced from the Process

115

Burak Celik

116

SCI-Arc

The vacuum-formed models created a base for the next stage of the design. Texturation, physical relationships and formal aspects were used to create familiarity.

The texture was generated through using AI Algorithms. The project intertwines vertical volumes with horizontal elements, creating diverse spatial experiences between, around, over and under the masses, through subtle changes in image, texture and coloration.

Right: Model Photo Left: Model Photo from the Review Top: Plan View

117

Burak Celik

Hybridized forms project a new methodology of thinking for architectural space. Different objects come together to create hybrid forms to generate unfamiliar conditions and scenarios in unexpected ways.

Our idea was to abstract objects which are taken from their original context by using computational techniques to develop new architectural possibilities.

Left: Hybrid Formation 01 Top: Hybrid Formation 02 Right: Hybrid Formation 03

118

SCI-Arc

119

Burak Celik

120

SCI-Arc

The progression of passages that weave throughout the building eventually culminate in a concealed yet public courtyard, accessible from all sides and levels of the building. The courtyard ties the design together, as it unifies the surrounding abstract masses around a comprehensible social void; in a sense it contextualizes a former decontextualized cluster of forms.

Right: Model Photo Left: Model Photo from the Review Top: Plan View

121

Burak Celik

The texture was created by combining a blue tile pattern of a Chinese upturned roof with a matte coloration through artificial intelligence. It generated the golden particles/minerals, and the linear fenestration that adorn the facade.

Left: Ground Diagram Right: Axonometric View

122

SCI-Arc

123

Burak Celik

124

SCI-Arc

Augmented Reality was utilized to represent textures on the model, making the presentation more interactive. Digitally generated model with the right design material applied using Unity and Vuforia. With this 3D experience, our goal was to integrate the postdigital aesthetics of our design with real life.

Right: Model Photo Left: Model Photo Top: Augmented Reality Model Overlay

125

Burak Celik

126

SCI-Arc

127

Burak Celik

128

SCI-Arc

Lou Ruvo Transformed Course: AS3200 Advanced Material and Tectonics Instructors: Maxi Spina, Randy Jefferson, Brian Zamora (Gehry Partners) Semester: Fall 2019, 2GAX Location: Las Vegas, NV | USA Partners: James Piccone, Jonah Klinghoffer, Abdullah Tahseen Software: Rhinoceros, Grasshopper For the Advanced Material and Tectonics class, we selected case studies to work on and make transformations. Lou Ruvo Center is a Frank Gehry designed building located in Las Vegas. It’s primary facade is composed of stainless steel shingles with box-like punched window openings. The envelope transformation replaces these reflective stainless steel shingles with matte finish fiber reinforced plastic (FRP) panels. These fiber-reinforced plastic panels come with a framed pipe sub-structure that includes C-channels with anchors joined by L-clips. The C-channels hook onto paired joints that are attached to the structural grid-shell of the building. The matte quality of the panels, achieved by sandblasting the panels before installation, gives 129

the building a softer look while an integrated relief pattern suggests a new scalar relationship between the windows and facade panelization. The envelope is further transformed by elongating window openings into vertical and horizontal staggered strips to emphasize a stretched building skin as opposed to a building mass with repetitive punched openings. The interior window openings become tapered window wells, similar to Le Corbusier’s Ronchamp Cathedral, in which the small exterior window area becomes significantly enlarged on the interior by flaring outwards from the window mullions. As a result, natural lighting in the interior becomes diffused and indirectly bounces off these flared openings.

Burak Celik

Lou Ruvo Tectonics Study Original Design

130

SCI-Arc

Lou Ruvo Center’s primary facade is composed of stainless steel shingles with box-like punched window openings. One of the important chunks was selected due to its complexity to understand the conceptual development and detail of the building.

CHUNK LATE CLADDING

Right: Exterior Building Chunk Flat Lock Steel Plate Cladding

RE TURALLeft: SYSTEM Aerial View

131

Burak Celik

ORIGINAL DRAWINGS

SOUTH

EAST

Precedent Study: Lou Ruvo Center for Brain Health Envelope System: Grid-Shell Structural System

132

SCI-Arc

Building Chunk A

ORIGINAL BUILDING CHUNKS

Metal Clips with Integrated Waterproof Fastener Stainless Steel Window Head Flashing 1/4 inch Stainless Steel Window Box Wall 22 ga. Stainless Steel Flat Lock Panels EPDM Fully Adhered Waterproofing Membrane Galvanized Sheet Metal Plate Thermal Insulation Z-Channel Structural Steel Grid Shell

Right: Building Chunk A Detail Left: East Elevation Top: South Elevation

133

Burak Celik

Building Chunk B

Plaster Finish “Baswaphon“ Acoustical Insulation Gypsum Board Recessed Window Box

Cold Formed Steel Stud Framing Access Hole Grid Shell Column Flange Structural Steel Grid Shell

y: Lou Ruvo Center for Brain Health m: Grid-Shell Structural System

Left: Building Chunk B Detail Right: West Elevation Top: North Elevation

134

SCI-Arc

NORTH

WEST

Advanced Tectonics & Materials AS3200 Abdullah Tahseen_Burak Celik_James Piccone_Jonah Klinghoffer

135

Burak Celik

Lou Ruvo Tectonics Study Transformed Building

TRANSFORMATION: EXTERIOR CHUNK BIRDS EYE VIEW

Pre-fabricated FRP Panels

1/4 inch Stainless Steel Window Box Wall

Metal C-Channels w/ L-clips & Anchors Curved Steel Pipe Substructure Thermal Insulation

Stainless Steel Window Head Flashing EPDM Fully Adhered Waterproofing Membrane Galvanized Sheet Metal Plate Structural Steel Grid Shell Rolled Shade Curved Glazing Unit Roller Shade Enclosure

Left: Building Chunk A Detail Right: Interior Building Chunk Top: Exterior Building Chunk

Precedent Study: Lou Ruvo Center for Brain Health Transformation: Stretched Skin Facade with FRP Panel Cladding

136

SCI-Arc

TRANSFORMATION SCHEME TRANSFORMATION SCHEME

EXTERIOR BUILDING CHUNK FIBER-REINFORCED PLASTIC CLADDING PANELS EXTERIOR BUILDING CHUNK FIBER-REINFORCED PLASTIC CLADDING PANELS

INTERIOR BUILDING CHUNK DRYWALL INTERIOR WITH PLASTER FINISH INTERIOR BUILDING CHUNK DRYWALL INTERIOR WITH PLASTER FINISH

Precedent Study: Lou Ruvo Center for Brain Health Transformation: Stretched Skin Facade with FRP Panel Cladding Precedent Study: Lou Ruvo Center for Brain Health Transformation: Stretched Skin Facade with FRP Panel Cladding

137

TRANSFORMATION: INTERIOR CHUNK BIRDS EYE VIEW

Burak Celik

Building Chunk B

Plaster Finish “Baswaphon“ Acoustical Insulation Gypsum Board Recessed Window Box Curved Glazing Unit 1/4 inch Stainless Steel Window Box Wall Grid Shell Beam Flange Structural Steel Grid Shell Thermal Insulation Metal C-channels w/ L-clips & Anchors Pre-fabricated FRP Panels

Precedent Study: Lou Ruvo Center for Brain Health Transformation: Stretched Skin Facade with FRP Panel Cladding

138

SCI-Arc

Cold Formed Steel Stud Framing Grid Shell Beam Flange Access Hole Structural Steel Grid Shell Thermal Insulation Metal C-channels w/ L-clips & Anchors Pre-fabricated FRP Panels Air Space Recessed Window Box Curved Glazing Unit Rolled Shade Rolled Shade Enclosure

Right: A1 - Grid-Shell Structural Components Left: Building Chunk B Detail

139

Burak Celik

Pre-fabricated FRP Panels 1/4 inch Stainless Steel Window Box Wall Thermal Insulation EPDM Fully Adhered Waterproofing Membrane Curved Glazing Unit

Fully Adhered Flashing Tape Roller Shade Roller Shade Enclosure Recessed Window Box Structural Steel Grid Shell Folded Steel Plate Window Box “Baswaphon“ Acoustical Insulation Light Gauge Metal Studs with L-Brackers Gypsum Board Plaster

Left: B1 - Skylight Detail Right: East Elevation

140

SCI-Arc

141

Burak Celik

142

SCI-Arc

GO BIG! //STADIUM Course: AS3302 Advanced Structural Systems Instructors: Greg Otto Semester: Fall 2019, 2GAX Location: Las Angeles, LA | USA Software: Rhinoceros, Grasshopper, Maya

The design for the for project of the class was a football stadium. It has a long span concept and carries structural characteristics from the Precedent Studies which are AT&T Stadium and Lucas Oil Stadium. The first intent of the project is to create a long span structure for a structure free interior space which does not affect the atmosphere of the stadium but add to it in terms of architectural space with a flowing facade and long span structural system. The capacity of the stadium is 70,000 and can be expandable 100,000. There is

143

a big entry gate on the North and South and two smaller entry gates on the East and West side of the building. Mega-trusses are penetrating the roof and they are oriented towards the main entry points of the building. The truss system that carries the load of the roof is connected to 20 tree columns so that the roof is elevated from the concrete system and it opens up view from the windows. The design has operable parametric window panels which can be opened up during the events, and it helps getting more daylight.

Burak Celik

The concept of long span structure was analyzed and developed in the first part of the class as individual projects. This stadium is an exercise to push forward long span structural concept to create an interior athmosphere without any structural obstacles. To achieve this, a long span arc and a tensile ring were utilized for load distribution.

Surface 1- Roof Surface 2- Envelope

Surface 3- Base

144

SCI-Arc

Long Span Arc

Form Finding Study

Tensile Ring Long Span Arc

Load Distribution

145

Burak Celik

Tensile Ring

Titanium Dioxide (Ti02) Roof with Operable Windows

Roof Truss System

Expandable Seating Areas on both sides

Megatrusses

Structural Ring in tension Columns Main Entries on both sides Base

146

SCI-Arc

Two Long Span arc structures are connected to each other with 4 other truss systems. The structural system is designed to create as much free space as possible, so secondary system of structural ring works in tension to direct loads of the roof to the columns. Thus, Titanium Dioxide Roof structure works with two different support systems.

Right: Axonometric Drawing Left: Exploded Drawing

147

Burak Celik

148

SCI-Arc

Long Spac Arc

Base

Titanium Dioxide (Ti02) Roof with Operable Windows

Structural Ring in tension Columns Main Entries on both sides Base Expandable Seating Areas on both sides

149

Burak Celik

150

SCI-Arc

Structural Ring in tension

Titanium Dioxide (Ti02) Roof with Operable Windows

Structural Opening for Air Circulation Columns

Long Span Arc Base Main Entries on both sides

Structural Ring in tension Primary Structural System Secondary Structural System Tertiary Structural System Tree Column System Columns

Long Span Arc

Top: South Elevation Bottom: South Section

151

Burak Celik

152

SCI-Arc

Structural Ring in tension

Titanium Dioxide (Ti02) Roof with Operable Windows Structural Opening for Air Circulation

Main Entries on both sides

Structural Ring in tension Secondary Structural System

Long Span Arc

Columns Pin Connection

Top: East Elevation Bottom: East Section

153

Burak Celik

154

SCI-Arc

GO BIG! //AIRPORT Course: AS3302 Advanced Structural Systems Instructors: Greg Otto Semester: Fall 2019, 2GAX Location: Las Angeles, LA | USA Software: Rhinoceros, Grasshopper, Maya

The project for the assignment is a an airport terminal. The design is a star-shaped building and has 4 directions. The structural system consists of 3 different unitized systems which can be repeated to create different forms. The main space “Unit A” is 145 feet high and consists of 4 mega leaning arches and a column system. Leaning arches are used to create a large volume architectural space without any structural obstacle. Secondary space “Unit B”

155

has a deformed surface to create a truss system that can transfer loads directly to the ground. Other than a space truss system, there is a structural system taking the loads and transfering it to the ground with a steel column. Main entrances belong to “Unit C” and has 2 structural systems. Concrete structure and the steel structure connects to create a stiff structural unitized system.

Burak Celik

Modularity provides many opportunities including mass production which decreases the cost of a building and easiness in the fabrication and production.

This study explores new ways of creating long span airport interior with three different modular units using parametric tools to optimize most functional structure.

Unit A

Unit B

Unit C

156

SCI-Arc

Column

Unit A

Unit B

Unit B Mirrored

Unit C

Right: Modularity Drawing Left: Site View

157

Burak Celik

UNIT A

158

SCI-Arc

Unit B Connection

Truss and Arc Connection

Mullion of the Skylight Glazing Leaning Arches Roof Truss System

Tree Column

Leaning Arches

Image: Unit A Drawing

159

Burak Celik

160

SCI-Arc

Unit B Connection

Truss and Arc Connection

Roof Truss System Mullion of the Skylight Glazing

Tree Column

Leaning Arches

Image: Unit A Worms Eye View Drawing

161

Burak Celik

UNIT B

162

SCI-Arc

Unit A Connection

Cladding

Unit C Connection

Structural Frames

Roof Truss System

Column

Glazing

Mullion

Image: Unit B Worms Eye View Drawing

163

Burak Celik

UNIT C

01. Columns

Steel Frame

02. Primary Beam System

164

SCI-Arc

03. Secondary Beam System

Connection Zone

04. System Connection

165

Burak Celik

166

SCI-Arc

Cladding

Unit B Connection

Roof Truss System Primary Beam System

Column

Eave Structure Eave Support

Glazing Mullion

Image: Unit C Worms Eye View Drawing

167

Burak Celik

168

SCI-Arc

SLICE IT! SLICE IT! Course: VS4200 Visual Studies I Instructors: Andrea Cadioli, Curime Batliner, Casey Reas Semester: Fall 2019, 2GAX Partner: Devangi Kansagra Software: Rhinoceros, Grasshopper, Processing, Maya.

In the Visual Studies class, we started developing a form and a Grasshopper script to animate a projection technique of multiple colors with different lineweights. Using the animation generated, outline of the design was fabricated in the SCIArc Shop and Robot House to attach stickers on it. Constructed pieces were attached to the Robot Arms and through a set of Grasshopper data, the

169

scene was photographed in some time intervals.

Using reflectivity, gravity and space, photographs of the design were combined in a digital way to create exhibition boards. Processing, as a medium for visual scripting, was used to generate a set of data to be applied on the pieces. With scripting, initial Grasshopper animation and Robot House images are combined to generate an algorithmic data.

Burak Celik

170

SCI-Arc

171

Burak Celik

172

SCI-Arc

173

Burak Celik

void setup() { size(1920, 1080); beginRecord(PDF, “images7.pdf ”); img = loadImage(“BaseImage.jpg”); } void draw() { int cropWidth = int(random(6, 50)); int randomx = int(random(mouseY, mouseY-300)); PImage crop = img.get(randomx, 0, cropWidth, height); image(crop, mouseX, 0); } void keyPressed() { if (key==’q’) { endRecord(); exit(); } 174

SCI-Arc

175

Burak Celik

176

SCI-Arc

177

Burak Celik

178

SCI-Arc

179

Burak Celik

180

SCI-Arc

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE & COMPUTATIONAL DESIGN

Course: HT2200 Theories of Contemporary Architecture I Instructors: Marcelyn Gow, John Cooper Semester: Fall 2019, 2GAX Related Keywords: Artificial Intelligence, Algorithmic Rituals, Machine Learning, Deep Learning, Computational Design, Refik Anadol, Frank Gehry, M Casey Rehm, Post-Digital Aesthetics.

181

Burak Celik

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE & COMPUTATIONAL DESIGN The Emergence of AI from the Computation of Space

INTRODUCTION Machine Learning and Artificial Intelligence are emergent technologies using algorithms, time, patterns, social relations, and labor. Although AI sounds “alien” or artificial to many people, it emerges from ancient rituals like the “Agnicayana ritual” as cited by Matteo Pasquinelli in his text “Three Thousand Years of Algorithmic Rituals: The Emergence of AI from the Computation of Space” and can be seen as algorithms in human history.1 Such use of algorithmic organization can be observed throughout history. Although algorithms and geometric means were used as a part of a religious ritual in Ancient Vedas, Ancient Egyptians used geometry and algebra to compute surface area and volume to build Great Pyramids. AI’s step-by-step logical procedure and multilayered input system make it possible to solve multiplex problems and it can provide solutions to many subjects like material computation, automation, simulation and so on. AI, Deep Learning and other subsets of AI have a great impact on performative art, the future of architectural design and the design in a broader sense. Starting from the evolution of algorithms and moving to a contemporary media artist Refik Anadol’s algorithmically generated compositions in space, AI plays a critical role in transforming “the memory” and it achieves certain impacts. To understand 1 Matteo Pasquinelli, “Three Thousand Years of Algorithmic Rituals: The Emergence of AI from the Computation of Space.” e-flux Journal, no.101 (Summer 2019): 1-2. https://www.e-flux.com/journal/101/273221/three-thousand-years-of-algorithmic-rituals-the-emergence-of-ai-from-the-computation-of-space/

the impact of AI on architectural design, this essay aims to provide a discussion of how AI can change the way we think about architectural design and spatial experience.

HISTORICAL BACKGROUND Artificial Intelligence is a relatively new term but not a new method of computation of space using algorithms.

An algorithm is a procedure to solve a problem and can be in the form of a sequence of instructions that involves repetition of an operation. Algorithms are widely used throughout all areas including mathematics and computation. Today, algorithms perform actions such as automated calculations, data processing, simulations and many other tasks, helping people resolve complex problems that cannot be done solely by humans.

Algorithms have always been a part of people’s daily life since the beginning of time. The history of Artificial Intelligence began in ancient times, dating back to ancient rituals and performances. Sacred Greek and Egyptian statues were believed to have senses and wisdom; they were considered memory storages and translation machines between humans and the god(s).

As Matteo Pasquinelli mentions in his text, Ancient Vedas, as part of a ritual, recomposed the fragmented body of god by building a fire altar, through the use of an elaborate geometric plan. Each brick was designed independently, numbered and placed following a step-

182

SCI-Arc

by-step process of instructions. Each layer of brick was built on top of another, conforming to the same area and shape so that the entire structure eventually faces East to symbolize the “flight of the constructed god” in the direction of the rising sun. Ancient Vedas used geometric and algorithmic techniques to organize and carry on the ritual.2 In my opinion, solving the logical riddle of the ritual whilst managing the construction, and keeping the symbolic value of reincarnation is a perfect building exercise demonstrating a primordial example of algorithmic culture and material computation. Later on, Ancient Egyptians started using geometry and algebra to create surface areas and volumes to design and erect the Pyramids. It is highly crucial to understand and visualize the generative process that was made available for humanity to advance architecture through human history.

Building on from AI’s presence in today’s world, I would like to share an example of an artist who is utilizing AI to create art. Refik Anadol uses algorithms that encode and compute data according to their spatial relations. All machine-learning algorithms are emergent processes, in which the repetition of similar patterns “teach” the machine and cause the pattern to emerge as a statistical distribution. Architect and media artist Refik Anadol blends media art and neuroscience with different sets of data, algorithms, and machine intelligence techniques to create data sculptures. Since data sculptures grow from a sophisticated construction of space data, mostly architectural space or facades, the algorithms try to recognize certain photographic moments and create a spatial matrix of visual and audio data. By embedding media design into architecture, Anadol’s work focuses on a post-digital architectural future, in which there are no non-digital realities anymore but a combination of mixed realities including photographic memories.3 MATERIAL COMPUTATION To further understand the role of AI and algorithms in architectural design, material computation should be considered as a strategy instead of a formulated method.

Material computation is a design approach that uses methods to model, simulate, and fabricate functional material organizations; such organizations’ properties vary and are arranged to abide to multiple materials and environmental constraints. Such practices include data processing, modeling, analysis, and fabrication, all of which are abundantly used in architectural design, 2 Matteo Pasquinelli, “Three Thousand Years of Algorithmic Rituals: The Emergence of AI from the Computation of Space.” e-flux Journal, no.101 (Summer 2019): 1. https://www.e-flux.com/journal/101/273221/three-thousand-years-of-algorithmic-rituals-the-emergence-of-ai-from-the-computation-of-space/ 3 Refik Anadol Studio, “WDCH Dreams”, accessed November 15, 2019. http://refikanadol.com/works/wdch-dreams/

mechanical design, 3D Fabrication and all production fields.

Material has always been considered as a secondary design driver due to the practical concerns in architectural design. On the other hand, nature’s very first design driver is the relationship between material and its corresponding environmental constraints. Most of the materials utilized in architectural construction such as steel, timber, or glass are not selected as parts of environmental constraints, but rather as selections that include budget parameters, availability, constructibility, etc., although they possess different material properties and performances.4 Mass production makes it available to use the same material component in different designs unlike nature itself. I believe AI significantly changes the way we think about architectural design since a shift from mass production to customized production could only be achieved by computational design methods like CAD software, robotics, CNC and other modern fabrication techniques; in turn, these provide diversity in size, shape, variation, and material. This approach to design creates discrete forms and heterogeneity.

DISCRETENESS M. Casey Rehm, a distinguished Sci-Arc professor and founder of Studio Kinch, is currently working on projects which are great examples of discrete forms using AI. In one of his works called “Control”, Rehm integrates imagebased interaction design with material algorithms as space-defining methods. I believe the future of AI will also allow architects to expand ideas on global environmental issues while creating unique architectural spaces; the relationship between AI and material computation creates new horizons in architecture and construction. The impact of AI on architectural design is massive, and in the future, AI can only be useful if we see it as a part of the process which humanity has been advancing throughout history.

Similarly, in Refik Anadol’s work called “WDCH Dreams” in 2018, he collaborated with the Los Angeles Philharmonic. The AI component uses and processes sound, photographic memories, and architectural space to create data sculptures which represent the building’s dream. To achieve this, Anadol worked with the Machine Intelligence program at Google Arts and Culture alongside researcher Parag K. Mital. Anadol used a computerized “mind” for AI systems to dream similar to humans dreaming by processing memories and creating new combinations of tests and trials using AI intuition. All 4 Neri Oxman, “Manufacturing the Bespoke”, MIT Media: 256-259, accessed November 15, 2019, https://neri.media.mit.edu/assets/pdf/Publications_MC.pdf

183

Burak Celik

of the digital archives - nearly 587,763 image files, 1,880 videos, and 17,773 audio files - are used to generate data clouds using AI, and categorized according to their spatial matrix.5 Machine learning was thought to create unique visuals by using architectural space data and the orchestral conductor’s body movements, which were recorded by using image tracking.

The work explores the space within the mind of a machine — limitless in its dimensions and in the information it holds. While the machine is generating a data universe of architectural hallucinations in 512 dimensions, people explore the moments spatially. The “data universe” is the human-accessible material and Artificial Intelligence is the tool to create new memories and experiences in the same architectural space. Each moment represents hidden connections between instances in the Philharmonic’s history. The work is also interactive as visitors can engage with the archives through unique timelines generated live each second according to the visitor’s motions. The work challenges the conventional interpretation of architectural space as the boundless, three-dimensional extent when objects interact in different positions relative to one another. The work offers a unique experience of architectural space and a glimpse into the future of architecture itself.6 Anadol’s work is a great example of how AI changes the way people observe and experience space. The strength of such an approach is that AI is not only a canvas for an artist, but it is also a strong tool to experience architectural space through images, memories, human performance, and “dreaming”, which is key to design.

ARTIFICIAL INTUITION In contrast to the claim that AI cannot have an intuition and cannot be a part of the design process other than a CAD tool, intuition is a significant concept to differentiate between memorization and learning to learn. In 1950, British mathematician Alan Turing claimed that humans use available information as well as reasoning to solve problems and make decisions, deducting that machines could potentially do the same. Although computers advanced enough to compute a million times faster than humans, there was still a long way to go before natural language processing, abstract thinking, and intuitive decision making.7 Intuition and Logic are two methods of prediction and problem-solving. Even though intuition requires prior experiences in learning through innate abilities, logic requires knowledge that computers already have. Throughout history, people that have “wisdom” have a unique set of knowledge and intuition accumulated during their 5 Refik Anadol Studio, “WDCH Dreams”, accessed November 15, 2019. http://refikanadol.com/works/wdch-dreams/ 6 “Refik Anadol’s ‘Machine Hallucination’ Debuts at New York’s Chelsea Market.”

Designboom, accessed November 15, 2019. https://www.designboom.com/art/refik-anadol-machine-hallucination-artechouse-chelsea-09-11-2019 7 Rockwell Anyoha, “The History of Artificial Intelligence”: Science in the News Blog, Harvard University, August 28, 2017, accessed November 22, 2019. http://sitn.hms.harvard.edu/flash/2017/history-artificial-intelligence/

184

“ Nature’s way is uniquely different. In nature, forms are the result of the matching between material parameters and their corresponding environmental constraints.

Shape is then merely a byproduct, a derivative of natural behavioural formation.”

Neri Oxman, MIT Media LAB

SCI-Arc

Copyright® M Casey Rehm

185

Burak Celik

lifetimes. People become intuitive through daily problems and experiences, so why can’t AI systems also be trained to predict things that they do not know? As an example, when a person is lacking experience in a situation, using precedent case studies to predict the solution is important to guess how the current issue can be resolved.

This is a trial and error operation that AI systems can also utilize. In the long term, AI researchers will be able to train artificial intelligence systems to perform tasks requiring flexibility and common sense.

MENAGERIES / IMAGERIES Images change meaning when they are put to different contexts and one after another since our perception changes when an image is not still. Cinematic images or videos carry different meanings and more importantly, have a sense of time. As cited by Jacques Rancière in his book “The Future of the Image”, “cinematic images are primarily operations, relations between the sayable and the visible, ways of playing with the before and the after, cause and effect”. These processes include different meanings of the word ‘image’. Two cinematic images or sequences of images can thus pertain to a different “imageness”8 Anadol’s work can be seen as an example of such cinematic images. Since each image generated through AI is somehow related to each other, AI is creating a cinematic “image” that can only be experienced through time. I see this approach as a significant part of the future of architectural design, which is interactive and dynamic rather than static and still.

As Boris Groys claims in his text, an artwork that is exhibited in an international context, mostly in an exhibition or biennale, loses its aura and exhibition value if the place is not its own original place. For Groys, “the aura is understood as the artwork’s inscription in the historical context to which it originally belongs, while the loss of aura results from its removal from that world of lived experience. I would argue against this claim when Artificial Intelligence becomes the producer of the artwork. Anadol’s work is a highly powerful digital approach as it shows that machines are thought by memories of the space, the local context, although the final product has always international exhibition value.

Martin Heidegger, a renowned German philosopher, differentiates artworks between an artwork that bonds to its historical/ritual space and time, and an artwork that only exhibits at a certain place that is removable from its context. With developing technology and the digital social era, our perception of any artwork can be defined 8 Jacques Rancière, “The Future of the Image”, translated by Gregory Elliott (New York: Verso, 2007), 1-6.

through Gestell, or the ‘framing’ of an image, according to Heidegger. One can speak of two different types of gazes in an exhibition, as Groys claims.9 When we look at an image, we use the frontal gaze since there are a precision and stability of our vision, and when we visit an exhibition, we do not just perceive the space as it is but instead we look around and become very aware of our position, which is called the ‘gaze from within’. I agree with Groys, due to the fact that the frontal gaze and the gaze from within define how we understand architectural space. Since we cannot reproduce the same historical trajectory in an architectural space, Refik Anadol’s artwork achieves highly powerful moments, using memories of the space. To me, in the age of unlimited content, artificial intelligence plays a crucial role to capture moments and store them in a data universe as an artwork in the form of light and music.

The Agnicayana Ritual is an example of an emergent algorithm as it encodes the organization of social and ritual space. The symbolic function of the ritual is the reconstruction of the god through mundane means; this practice of reconstruction also symbolizes the expression of the many within the One (or the “computation” of the One through the many). Similar to the ritual’s social function of teaching basic geometry skills to construct solid buildings, AI is thought by people to collect data and regenerate visual and vocal data through a set of algorithmic processes. Artificial Intelligence and the computational power of AI is a highly sophisticated version of the straightforward and primordial way of thinking used in ancient times. Its role as a means of designing architectural space is unlimited, yet to be elaborated, and full of potential.

9 Boris Groys, “Curating in the Post-Internet Age”, e-flux Journal, no.94 (October, 2018): 4. https://www.e-flux.com/journal/94/219462/curating-in-the-post-internet-age/

186

SCI-Arc

BIBLIOGRAPHY Anyoha, Rockwell. “The History of Artificial Intelligence”. Science in the News Blog, Harvard University (August, 2017). Accessed November 22, 2019. http://sitn.hms.harvard.edu/flash/2017/history-artificial-intelligence/ Designboom. “Refik Anadol’s ‘Machine Hallucination’ Debuts at New York’s Chelsea Market.” Accessed November 15, 2019. https://www.designboom. com/art/refik-anadol-machine-hallucination-artechouse-chelsea-09-11-2019/ Groys, Boris. “Curating in the Post-Internet Age.” e-flux Journal, no.94 (October, 2018): 1-8. https://www.e-flux.com/journal/94/219462/curating-inthe-post-internet-age/ Oxman, Neri. “Manufacturing the Bespoke”. MIT Media: 256-265. Accessed November 15, 2019. https://neri.media.mit.edu/assets/pdf/Publications_ MC.pdf Pasquinelli, Matteo. “Three Thousand Years of Algorithmic Rituals: The Emergence of AI from the Computation of Space.” e-flux Journal, no.101 (Summer 2019): 1-12. https://www.e-flux.com/journal/101/273221/three-thousand-years-of-algorithmic-rituals-the-emergence-of-ai-fromthe-computation-of-space/ Rancière, Jacques. “The Future of the Image”. Translated by Gregory Elliott. New York: Verso, 2007.

Refik Anadol Studio. “WDCH Dreams”. Accessed November 15, 2019. http://refikanadol.com/works/wdch-dreams/.

187

Burak Celik

188

SCI-Arc

COMPUTATIONAL THEORY IN A POSTDIGITAL AGE

Course: HT2201 Theories of Contemporary Architecture II Instructors: Marcelyn Gow, Erik Ghenoiu, John Cooper Semester: Spring 2020, 2GBX Related Keywords: Post-Digital Aesthetics, Architectural Theory, Artificial Intelligence, Algorithmic Rituals, Machine Learning, Deep Learning, Computational Design, Mark Foster Gage, Mario Carpo.

189

Burak Celik

COMPUTATIONAL THEORY IN A POSTDIGITAL AGE Postdigital Approaches in Architecture

“Ars longa, vita brevis” We can only perform a given number of experiments in a lifetime, and we can only record and transmit a chosen few of them.1

One of the main drivers of architecture, art, design and other design fields has always been Science.

Computational tools including Architectural software, Building Information Modeling (BIM), Artificial Intelligence, Machine Learning and Deep Learning base their strength on Science that revolutionized with radical ideas. New advanced tools are involved in our daily lives mostly in the last 20 years and affected all fields of life including architectural design. Big data environment we are living in today started to be represented in architecture with different architectural styles and aesthetics. Architectural aesthetics, which also refers to architectural theory and practice, is one the major changes in a postdigital age in which the “post” does not imply a time after or beyond the digital but a call for examination and evolution of what we have known as “the digital”. 2 This paper aims to examine how computational tools greatly impacted the way architecture is practiced and the way architectural theory responded to it in a postdigital age.

been a part of our daily lives since the father of modern science, Galileo. Although AI sounds “alien” or artificial to many people, it emerges from ancient rituals like the “Agnicayana ritual” as cited by Matteo Pasquinelli in his text “Three Thousand Years of Algorithmic Rituals: The Emergence of AI from the Computation of Space” and can be seen as algorithms in human history.3 Science has always been using algorithms to collect and utilize data. Algorithms help computational tools perform actions such as automated calculations, data processing, simulations and many other tasks, helping people resolve complex problems that cannot be done solely by humans.

The reason AI outperforms us in plenty of cases is the way it works with datasets. AI does not work the way our mind does but follows a logic of simulation and optimization to test all options on earth to find the best option, still does not run out of time. People use shortcuts and theories, which condense the acquired knowledge, to optimize their time, this is where shortcuts and theories are coming from so that it does not start from scratch every time.

The name Artificial Intelligence does not represent an artificiality but it is a new kind of science that has already

Ars Longa, vita brevis. The Greek aphorism means ‘art lasts forever, but artists die and are forgotten’. This can

1 Gary Martin, “‘Ars Longa, Vita Brevis’ - the Meaning and Origin of This Phrase.” Phrasefinder. Accessed April 24, 2020. https://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/ ars-longa-vita-brevis.html 2 Mark Foster Gage, “Aesthetics Equals Politics: New Discourses across Art, Architecture, and Philosophy” Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 2019: 103.

3 Matteo Pasquinelli, “Three Thousand Years of Algorithmic Rituals: The Emergence of AI from the Computation of Space.” e-flux Journal, no.101 (Summer 2019): 1-2. https://www.e-flux.com/journal/101/273221/three-thousand-years-of-algorithmic-rituals-the-emergence-of-ai-from-the-computation-of-space/

1

190

SCI-Arc

be translated into English as ‘life is short, the art (craft/ skill) long, opportunity fleeting, experiment treacherous, judgement difficult’. Computational design is now progressing daily and basic mathematical knowledge can open up new ways in programming languages like Java, Python or C++ to develop a new tool or plugin in the sea of computational design. New computational tools enabled architects to do simulation and optimization at no cost, requiring basic scientific knowledge. These tools are not just tools for making but tools for thinking, experiencing and advancing the theory, education and practice. Modern science is based on the observation of factual evidence through a process of comparison, selection, formalization, and abstraction. This is where theories of science and architecture are coming from.4 Formulas and theories are used to calculate and predict the lifespan of a building or endless variations of a structure, making it much easier than traditional trial and error which gives practical limits and problems. Big Data environment today we are experiencing play a crucial role in the development of computational tools used today. Data sets which are ever expanding by human data (user data for the Internet) can be collected and processed using computational tools. In the sea of vast data sets, it’s undeniable to accept that it is the future for architecture too. Integrating computational tools with Big Data in design phases will inform architects about up-to-date information and inevitable problems architecture and built environments might face. In the near future, it’s likely to see unlimited data storage and access to the user-generated data. Google’s self-driving car brand Waymo adapted user-generated data to predict the traffic and environmental activity based on Artificial Intelligence and computational techniques. Self-driving cars are capable of sensing their environment and navigating without any human input. In order to work without human input, each car is outfitted with a GPS unit and a range of sensors around them including laser rangefinders, radar, and video. Positional information from the GPS and sensors are used to refine its position estimate as well as to build a three-dimensional image of its environment. Three-dimensional environment is then generated and used to make the system work. For me, Big Data will be the future to inform architects in all design phases too. It is a strong tool and very common in the Architectural practice to use environmental data software and plugins such as ARCGIS, Grasshopper, Dynamo and others currently in use today. It makes environmental data more integrated with the design using simulation and optimization.

4 Mario Carpo, “The Alternative Science of Computation” e-flux Journal, (2020): 3. https://www.e-flux.com/architecture/artificial-labor/142274/the-alternative-science-of-computation/

Architecture is highly influenced by technology. In 2011, Japanese fashion designer Junya Watanabe’s Indigo Dyed 5 Pocket Sweat Pant, designed for denim brand Levi’s, printed with a high resolution digital scan of a pair of Levi’s pants. Although the look was perfectly the same, the pants were not denim at all. James Bridle, a British artist, posted to his Tumblr account named “The New Aesthetics’’. Bridle was claiming something spectacular, His thesis claims that the world is undergoing fundamental visual change due to the rapid spread of computation, and this will result in a new aesthetics in every field of our lives. The subtle change in Watanabe’s denim was something we used to see in digital media today. It requires close inspection to even notice, and most of the time, it’s not noticeable. Given today’s digital media, namely Pinterest, Instagram, Behance, Tumblr, Youtube and countless others, the line between digital and nondigital is increasingly blurry. MVRDV’ Glass Farm is also another example in which architectural pieces of a farm building are imitated using glass. MVRDV clad the building in fritted glass printed with an image of a typical farm building.5 Vagueness is particularly instrumental in today’s architectural image-making since the way architects are dealing with form, space-making and drawings rely on digital mediums.6 When architectural production shifted towards Photoshop, V-Ray and other raster imaging programs, vagueness became a design tool, consequently a new aesthetics. The New Aesthetics is largely associated with “postdigital”, a term used to manifest the progression of digital technology from something uncommon and novel to something pervasive and usual. Architecture has entered a postdigital time where the postdigital highlights the ways in which computation shows up in digital things by patterns and qualities that arise from pervasive yet often unintelligible computational processes.7 A quick surf of architectural websites and contents show a drastic change in aesthetics. This shows a loss of architectural theory and thought behind projects. Architecture evolves by processing technological and aesthetic shifts disciplinarily yet the speed of digital media makes the process difficult for implementing a theory.8 Architects with strong theories behind using computational tools were called “pioneers” and others with no theoretical background ended up being followers.

5 Mark Foster Gage, “Aesthetics Equals Politics: New Discourses across Art, Architecture, and Philosophy” Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 2019: 117.

6 Michelle Chang, “Something Vague” Log44: 106.

7 Mark Foster Gage, “Aesthetics Equals Politics: New Discourses across Art, Architecture, and Philosophy” Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 2019: 103.

8 Mark Foster Gage, “Aesthetics Equals Politics: New Discourses across Art, Architecture, and Philosophy” Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 2019: 106.

191

Burak Celik

Computational design is the application of computational strategies to the design process in order to solve many complications. Although design problems were used to be solved by intuition and experience traditionally, computational design relies on the process of encoding design decisions using scientific methods, statistics, simulation and optimization.

This process usually produces endless variations and provides many opportunities and convenience to designers in the design phases with many constraints. Since the early 1990s, the pioneers of digitally intelligent architecture have asserted that computational tools can mass produce endless variations at no cost with a postdigital aesthetics even when all individual pieces are different.9 Marikka Trotter, a distinguished SCIArc professor, claims that architects taking discreteness as a philosophical or computational method used data to create autonomous components to be fabricated at a lower-cost, still considering economic viability. Standardization and serial production, the emphasis on housing as a social program, the concern for a mass clientele were all examples of the modern architect’s attempt to redefine architecture’s economic and social role in 1990s. When Le Corbusier was claiming his famous idea “Architecture or Revolution. Revolution can be avoided”, he was arguing the expansion of the architect’s role to address social and economic problems.10 This role can further affect new aesthetic categories. New aesthetics of discreteness and patchiness, for instance, can be seen as an economic reflection of the heterogeneous nature of it. Sharples Holden Pasquarelli, owners of the New York-based design firm SHoP, calls for a new “intelligence of fabrication”, based on creating a common language between design and execution.

For SHoP, the computer has enabled architects to rethink the design process in terms of a procedure that conventional design methodologies cannot conceive of. This is due to “versioning” that makes the design process accelerated and adaptive.11 Aesthetics of the digital age is still under the impact of economical issues, yet to be solved again by computational techniques in the future.

In the age of digital turn, architecture was outweighed by a tool for many years: spline modelers. The scientific approach to spline modelers dates back to the 1950’s. When two French engineers, Pierre Bezier and Paul de Casteljau, were working for Renault and Citroen, they found a mathematical way to join a set of nonaligned geometrical points with a continuous curve.12 This made spline modelers available in computer-aided modeling software. The Spline-dominated 9 Artforum International, “Breaking the Curve: Big Data and Design”, 2014: 2. https://www.artforum.com/print/201402/breaking-the-curve-big-data-and-design-45013 10 Mary McLeod “Architecture and Politics in the Reagan Era: From Postmodernism to Deconstructivism”, Assemblage 8 (February 1989): 682.

11 Mario Carpo, “The Digital Turn in Architecture: 1992-2012”, Hoboken, Wiley: 131.

12 Artforum International, “Breaking the Curve: Big Data and Design”, 2014: 2. https://www.artforum.com/print/201402/breaking-the-curve-big-data-and-design-45013

192

“ The electronic paradigm directs a powerful challenge to architecture because it defines reality in terms of media and simulation; it values appearance over existence, what can be seen over what is. Not the seen as we formerly knew it, but rather a seeing that can no longer interpret..”

Peter Eisenman

SCI-Arc

Fig 1. Google’s Self-Driving Vehicles. Accessed April 20, 2020.

193

Burak Celik

environment of the 1990s in the architectural environment progressed modeling software including Maya, AutoCAD and Rhino. The power of digital design is one can mass-produce boxes and the other can design folded amorph buildings. Greg Lynn’s theory of folding, Peter Eisenman’s singularity, Stan Allen’s field conditions and Patrik Schumacher’s theory of parametricism represent different techniques and applications. By using computational tools including fabrication techniques, simulation and optimization, many visionary architectural proposals could be built in the 1990s, namely Zaha Hadid, Frank Gehry and Peter Eisenman. Three buildings made a difference with nonlinear geometries in the 1990s: Frank Gehry’s Guggenheim Museum in Bilbao, Peter Eisenman’s Aronoff Center in Cincinnati and Daniel Libeskind’s Jewish Museum Berlin. These buildings used nonlinear forms with linears using computer aided design and layout. Each of the buildings raised a critical question of the language which is inherent in its use. They questioned if architecture does not only reflect a different paradigm of thought but itself becomes a discipline of unfolding knowledge.

unlimited, yet to be elaborated, and full of potential. There is a strong connection between technological change in culture at large and architecture reflects these changes through aesthetic agendas. New aesthetic categories today architecture is having are due to the power of computational tools. Today, computational thinking in architecture resulted in a predisposition to experiment more than thinking, yet architectural practice is powerful with all the aesthetic categories more than ever when computational design is combined with architectural theory.

An advanced version of spline modelers are using a spline modeling technique now called “subdivision modeling” and it uses discrete fragments of a model like Face, Edges and Vertices to represent perfectly smooth 3D Geometries. Greg Lynn, in his essay “Architectural Curvilinearity”, heralds the age of round and smooth shapes. He claims that the reason we see perfectly smooth and multifaceted forms is because it is the most visible expression of digital making in architecture.

Lynn calls these forms “blobs” and most of the iconic buildings in the 1990’s have the same tendency.13 Frank Gehry’s Guggenheim Bilbao is often related to this tendency although Gehry uses a completely different set of software and design techniques. Similarly, Peter Eisenman argues that “folding” may provide a new strategy by subverting the hierarchy of interior and exterior and by weakening the notational correspondence between drawing and building. This shows a continuity between Deconstructivism and the new age of digital design because both ideas claim to challenge “the space of classical vision” and break “the gridded space of the Cartesian order”.14 We are now experiencing a digital age in which computational tools are an integral part of our daily lives. The use of computational design in architecture has become a prevailing technique in the architectural practice too. It affects many aspects of the design including aesthetics, practice, economy and theory.

Its role as a means of designing architectural space is 13 Wiley: 26.

14 Wiley: 15.

Mario Carpo, “The Digital Turn in Architecture: 1992-2012”, Hoboken, Mario Carpo, “The Digital Turn in Architecture: 1992-2012”, Hoboken,

194

SCI-Arc

Fig. 2. Digital Drawings of Peter Eisenman’s Aronoff Center in Cincinnati.

BIBLIOGRAPHY Artforum International. “Breaking the Curve: Big Data and Design”. 2014: 1-9. https://www.artforum.com/print/201402/breaking-the-curve-big-data-and-design-45013 Carpo, Mario. “The Alternative Science of Computation”. e-flux Journal, (2020): 1-8. https://www.e-flux.com/architecture/artificial-labor/142274/the-alternative-science-of-computation/ Carpo, Mario. The Digital Turn in Architecture: 1992-2012. Hoboken: Wiley, 2013.

Chang, Michelle. “Something Vague” Log44: 106.

Gage, Mark Foster. Aesthetics Equals Politics: New Discourses across Art, Architecture, and Philosophy. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press, 2019.

Martin, Gary. “‘Ars Longa, Vita Brevis’ - the Meaning and Origin of This Phrase.” Phrasefinder. Accessed April 24, 2020. https://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/ars-longa-vita-brevis.html.

McLeod, Mary. “Architecture and Politics in the Reagan Era: From Postmodernism to Deconstructivism”. Assemblage 8 (February 1989): 679-697.

Pasquinelli, Matteo. “Three Thousand Years of Algorithmic Rituals: The Emergence of AI from the Computation of Space.” e-flux Journal, no.101 (Summer 2019):

1-12. https://www.e-flux.com/journal/101/273221/three-thousand-years-of-algorithmic-rituals-the-emergence-of-ai-from-the-computation-of-space/

195

Burak Celik

196

SCI-Arc

AI MUSEUM AUDIENCE ENGAGEMENT

Course: HT2743 Pharmako-AI Instructors: Kenric McDowell Guest Lecturers: Holly Grimm, Refik Anadol Semester: Fall 2020, 3GAX Related Keywords: Pharmakon, Feedback Loop, Artificial Intelligence, Synesthesia, Umwelt, Museum Engagement, Augmented Reality, Unity.

197

Burak Celik

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE USED IN MUSEUM AUDIENCE ENGAGEMENT The relationship of Pharmakon wih Museum Audience Engagement

INTRODUCTION The concept of this paper started with a metaphor that reads “Ars Longa, Vita Brevis.”1 The Greek aphorism means ‘art lasts forever, but artists die and are forgotten’.

This can be translated into English as ‘life is short, the art (craft/skill) long, opportunity fleeting, experiment treacherous, judgment difficult’. Human lifespan is just as tiny as a piece of sand in the ocean and in the big picture, Artificial Intelligence can be seen not only as a big step towards the digital age but also as a way for homo sapiens to understand their own capacities, capabilities, and roots. AI, when the feedback loop is taken into consideration, can open up entirely new horizons for humanity. This paper aims to discover AI and Machine Learning which would be a Pharmakon- that is as poison, cure and scapegoat- and rethink the Museum experience using Machine Learning with an application using the Cybernetic Feedback Loop.

ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE Artificial Intelligence, since the last century, has been a subject that exponentially grows in importance due to its existence in daily life and change of lifestyle. Although the name suggests, it does not describe an artificiality but it is a new kind of science that has already been a part of 1 Gary Martin, “‘Ars Longa, Vita Brevis’ - the Meaning and Origin of This Phrase.” Phrasefinder. Accessed September 30, 2020. https://www.phrases.org.uk/ meanings/ars-longa-vita-brevis.html

our daily lives since the father of modern science, Galileo.

Artificial Intelligence is a relatively new term, but it is not a new method of computation using “algorithms” which are procedures to solve a problem and can be in the form of a sequence of instructions that involves repetition of an operation. These operations help people resolve complex problems that cannot be done solely by humans.

The history of Artificial Intelligence began in ancient times, dating back to ancient rituals and performances.

For instance, sacred Greek and Egyptian statues were believed to have senses and wisdom. They were considered memory storages and translation machines between humans and the god(s). Moreover, Ancient Vedas, for instance, used geometric and algorithmic techniques to organize and carry on the ritual.2 Later on, Ancient Egyptians started using geometry and algebra to create surface areas and volumes to design and erect the Pyramids. It is important to understand the transformative process that was made available for humanity to advance architecture through human history.

Similarly, if we look at modern science, the findings of how quantum mechanics work by Lov Grover can also be interpreted as a new beginning of how we perceive nature 2 Matteo Pasquinelli, “Three Thousand Years of Algorithmic Rituals: The Emergence of AI from the Computation of Space.” e-flux Journal, no.101 (Summer 2019): 1. https://www.e-flux.com/journal/101/273221/three-thousand-years-of-algorithmic-rituals-the-emergence-of-ai-from-the-computation-of-space/

198

SCI-Arc

and the origin of life. Although science has proven that every creature on Earth is using the same genetic codesDNA’s- there is no proven fact that creatures including plants, organisms, animals, and humans have strong emotional-physical or intelligence-related connections.

This brings up the question if AI can also be a part of this discussion since there seems to be an intelligence underlying it. What we have to ask then is whether such an intellect can be integrated in such a way where AI becomes the guiding mechanism that helps us discover the answer which would mean that quantum mechanics would start to play an important role in shaping nature and the origin of life.

SYNESTHESIA To understand the importance of Artificial Intelligence in today’s science, there are other substantial issues in which AI can help us discover a whole different vision. For instance, Synesthesia is a condition where stimulation of one form evokes sensation in another form.3 Sensation and perception are related terms and one of the best ways to understand how people perceive language, consciousness and how the brain processes sense. In order to understand Artificial Intelligence and develop it further, the link between sensation and perception might be the best strategy humanity ever has since the brain is the most complex system with the intelligence, interpretation of the senses, controlling the body movement, and behavior. Natural language processing systems with AI involve semantics which is not the only way for the brain to learn. GPT-3 is the most recent and relevant example taking patterns into consideration which made a revolution in language analysis. If a system can understand metaphors, make connections between forms of sensations and categorize different subjects, it makes the process even faster and more efficient than the human brain. This idea is similar to Neuro-symbolic AI. The way Neural Networks can help symbolic AI is that it can break the world into symbols which will allow for AI to perform multiplex tasks with a lot less data.

The Human species is not the only one dealing multiplex tasks at the same time but it’s the most complex one.

Expanding Human-Centered Design: An Ecological Approach by Google AI Strategy and Research Team help bring up the concept of human-centered design thinking with its emphasis on an individual perspective as a means to defining and solving a design problem which aims to meet the challenges we face in the era of climate change

3 Jun Wu, “Synesthesia, An Inspiring Condition For AI Researchers,” Medium (Towards Data Science, January 27, 2020), https://towardsdatascience.com/ synesthesia-an-inspiring-condition-for-ai-researchers-10cd57708855

and human-caused mass extinction.4 The tendency towards anthropocentrism- the centering of humansprecipitates our current climate and environmental crises we are facing right now, although the ecological approach to design prioritizes relationships between individuals, species and landscape. The text “Follow the Sounds of the Axe” points out hyperobjects and it signifies a shift in our thinking of objects and their meanings-relationships.

Such an object would be an axe. The skill of inventing and making it is more complicated than many people realise.

The invention of such a tool is no different from the more sophisticated ones now and people who believe in action against climate change should realise that we are the only species in history that has the ability to think about the future consequences of our actions because we are the only ones who evolved to create representations of the world in its various aspects and dimensions.

UMWELT & PHARMAKON Synesthesia relates to what is called “Umwelt”. In “The Theory of Meaning”, the author mentions all living beings becoming machines, with their capacity of perceptual tools and effector tools. So, an animal is nothing but a series of perceptual and effector tools connected by an organism that carries on life functions.5 Considering this as a machine, sense organs serve the perception and motor organs function like an operator, which refers to a notion called Umwelt, formation of a closed unit.

Uexküell’s Funktionkreis shows how this mechanism works using Meaning-Receiver and Meaning-Carrier as part of the system which can be called a functional circle that connects the meaning carrier with the subject.

Relating to the circle, poisons emerge as a method by which one living being resists tolerance of another’s meaning in form. Poison here is not a protection from other animals but rather protection from the meanings of other organisms and the poison can be considered as a remedy, according to the pharmakon principle. According to what Indigenous people say “Ultimately everything interconnects”, most customs and practices clearly show that humans as well are inextricably tied to the earth and one another, which shows a clear similarity with the Umwelt circle.

MUSEUM ENGAGEMENT Technology took away some of the aspects of how people appreciate the artwork. Through digital platforms, people are bombarded by enormous amounts of artworks in 4 Google AI Strategy & Research Team, “Expanding Human-Centered Design: An Ecological Approach”, (Google SPAN Design Conference, October 10, 2019.)

5 Donald Favareau, Essential Readings In Biosemiotics: Anthology and Commentary (Place of publication not identified: SPRINGER, 2016).

199

Burak Celik

seconds and this makes people lazy to wait, observe, think about it and create connections between them since they are not experiencing it through physical environments - like a museum, biennial, or art galleries but social platforms. AI is a powerful tool to rethink our conventional way of thinking about Museum Experience and it can give this thinking-interactingappreciating process back to life. Museums-galleries and art exhibits are not only public spaces but are also educational informative domains. The relationship between artworks, their dates, artists, how artists influenced each other, how the eratime changed their perception are key concepts. Google’s X Degrees of Separation creates this kind of a platform where you see visually related artwork.

DISTRICT ARt District ARt is an Augmented Reality museum application using user input and Geolocation Data and designed for local artists and designers to present/sell/buy artwork in a hybrid digital/ physical environment and city users to engage with the digital art environment of the App. Application has multiple interactive buttons including contacting the artist, checking current prices, and the Art Coin Collection System which helps users to collect points and get artwork. The App encourages people to interact with more artwork and learn more about related ones using the Machine Learning model. This machine learning model provides the relationship between artworks, their dates, artists, how artists influenced each other, how the era-time changed their perception. In this App, the goal is to include people as much as possible in this dynamic environment and provide them space to both present their artwork in a local context and interact with the local artists and their artworks. Multiple Interactive buttons and point collection systems working with the Feedback Loop.

FEEDBACK LOOP The Feedback loop can be defined as a system that keeps the dialogue between the system’s subjects. For instance, Generative Adversarial Networks (GAN’s) use feedback loops to generate new data with the training sets. This provides a generative model for unsupervised learning, meaning the model starts to dynamically learn in an unsupervised manner after it starts and learns from its mistakes. This technique provides a constant dialogue in the system and output is used as input. In the App, the feedback loop between human and AI makes this system more generative and open to transformation.

The AR App introduces Geolocation and User Input and creates a semantic map which ends up being a personalized data set.

In my opinion, this is the part where the museum experience becomes more valuable. Appreciating artwork through the App which provides people the best fit for them. Mori Art Museum and Aby Warburg Bilderatlas Mnemosyne Virtual Exhibition are some of the examples of such technology being used in a

200

We can imagine a world where our language is not commercialised... where our autonomy is supported by a network rather than threatened by our relationship to it. Looking to nature, we can discover many patterns that are not manmade... In what ways do the undulations of... sound waves in the air form a new type of ‘hidden order’ that cybernetics can explore?

Kenric McDowell & GPT-3, Pharmako-AI

SCI-Arc

Fig. 1. AR App View on the Street.

201

Burak Celik

museum, using a virtual world for visitors to engage in a more dynamic museum experience.

User input and Geolocation Data are critical aspects of the design. The App is located in the Triangle Park in the Arts District and has a starting point. Throughout the path, users pick their combination of artwork and add to their AI list which will eventually become an artwork and be presented on the screen using Machine Learning algorithms. This dialogue technique between input and output will determine the best way to curate a personalized AR Museum experience with the Feedback Loop.

Most of the time, the audience cannot relate some artwork to another. AI system will help visualize and categorize by using similarities of the artwork and this will help the audience discover an unlimited amount of related artwork.

This system will also help museum archives to reformat and show the connection between artworks. By using the connections between different sensations and memories, AI interprets these datasets of images and text to produce and speculate artwork. The Cybernetic feedback loop here will be an interaction between visitors and the AI system which is producing artwork according to the response it’s getting from the AR visitors. Since everybody’s response will be different, there will be customization for each individual which will show the mindmap of the visitor. For instance, if the visitor tends to see more contemporary/ pop art, the result will be different from a visitor who wants to see impressionist paintings and artwork. The Feedback loop will show if AI works as a poison, cure, or scapegoat. In history, all customs had a different way of interpreting knowledge. According to what Indigenous people say “Ultimately everything interconnects”, most customs and practices clearly show that humans are inextricably tied to the earth and one another, which shows a clear similarity with the Umwelt circle. Now we are living in an age where engagement with Artificial Intelligence is key. Artificial Intelligence is the continuation of the knowledge humanity has been developing, and we are just at the beginning of a search.

NOTES Fig. 1. Pharmako-AI Mindmap. Using app.ayoa.com Fig. 2. Google X Degrees of Separation.

Fig. 3. Augmented Reality App. Fig. 4. Augmented Reality App. Fig. 5. Augmented Reality App Site. Unity viewport.

Fig. 6. Feedback Loop Diagram.

Fig. 7. Semantic map of the Machine Learning model. Using artbreeder.com

202

SCI-Arc

Fig. 2. AR App.

BIBLIOGRAPHY Favareau, Donald. Essential Readings In Biosemiotics: Anthology and Commentary. Place of publication not identified: SPRINGER, 2016.

Google AI Strategy & Research Team. “Expanding Human-Centered Design: An Ecological Approach”. Google SPAN Design Conference, October 10, 2019.

Martin, Gary. “‘Ars Longa, Vita Brevis’ - the Meaning and Origin of This Phrase.” Phrasefinder. Accessed September 30, 2020. https://www.phrases.org. uk/meanings/ars-longa-vita-brevis.html.

Pasquinelli, Matteo. “Three Thousand Years of Algorithmic Rituals: The Emergence of AI from the Computation of Space.” e-flux Journal, no.101 (Summer 2019): 1-12. https://www.e-flux.com/journal/101/273221/three-thousand-years-of-algorithmic-rituals-the-emergence-of-ai- from-the-computation-of-space/ Wu, Jun. “Synesthesia, An Inspiring Condition For AI Researchers.” Medium. Towards Data Science, January 27, 2020. https://towardsdatascience.com/ synesthesia-an-inspiring-condition-for-ai-researchers-10cd57708855

203

Burak Celik

204