(,1( $1=(,*(1Ó621'(59(5 ))(17/,&+81* '(5
:,576&+$)7
',(167$* 129(0%(5
1(7=:(5.( LQ :LUWVFKDIW :LVVHQVFKDIW XQG LQ GHQ .RPPXQHQ VLQG GDV 7KHPD GLHVHU %HLODJH 6LH LVW HLQ *HPHLQVFKDIWVSURMHNW GHU RVWGHXWVFKHQ 7DJHV]HLWXQJHQ
(GLWRULDO 4®÷Ů è®®÷ŮƓ® "®Ŵ®Ůāę Ŵ®÷Ů è®®÷ŮƓ®Ů "®Ŵ®Ů DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲĀ DzţƆé ɓţÇŗȓţŅ ţƆ éĀǪ uţǪȓDzÇŗ ģȓǎ 0Ɔ ĀţƆĀŽ éƘƼƼĀŴȓĀƆ ȲƆé éǪĀţģ ÇŗĀƆ `ţƆƆǎ uĀƆƆ DzţÇŗ éţĀ BĀƆDzÇŗĀƆ Ę éţĀ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀǪ ȲƆé éţĀ ĀDzÇŗ ģȓţŅȓĀƆ Ę ţƆ éĀƆ ƟDzȓŴţÇŗĀƆ ȲƆéĀDzŝ Ŵ ƆéĀǪƆ éţĀDzĀǪ ]ĀƼȲ¥ŴţŲ ƆţÇŗȓ ĀƆŅ ɡȲDz Žŝ ŽĀƆDzÇŗŴţĀňĀƆá DzţÇŗ ŴDzƘ ɑĀǪƆĀȓɡĀƆá ȲŽ ƆĀȲĀ YǪƘéȲŲȓĀ ɡȲ ĀƆȓɓţÇŲĀŴƆá ɓĀǪéĀƆ DzţĀ ŲĀţƆĀƆ ǪģƘŴŅ ŗ ¥ĀƆǎ .ţƆȓĀǪ ŰĀéĀǪ ƼƘDzţȓţɑĀƆ iƆȓĀǪŝ ƆĀŗŽĀƆDzŅĀDzÇŗţÇŗȓĀ éĀǪ ɑĀǪŅ ƆŅĀƆĀƆ : ŗǪĀ DzȓĀŗȓ ȲÇŗ ĀţƆ `ȓȸÇŲ ,ĀŽĀţƆDzţƆƆǎ Dz ŗ ¥ĀƆ ɑţĀŴĀ ĀǪŲ ƆƆȓǎ ¥ĀǪ ĀDz ŅĀŗȓ ȲÇŗ ȲŽ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲĀ ɡɓţDzÇŗĀƆ éĀƆ *ţǪŽĀƆ ȲƆé éĀƆ ĀȓǪţĀ¥ĀƆǎ Dz ɡĀţŅȓ DzţÇŗ ǪĀŅţƘƆ Ŵ ȲƆé ţƆȓĀǪƆ ȓţƘƆ Ŵǎ ]ĀŅţƘƆ Ŵ ɡȲŽ Āţŝ DzƼţĀŴ ţƆ éĀǪ ǪɡĀȲŅĀǪŅĀŽĀţƆDzÇŗ ģȓ ǣ ţƘģǪţDzÇŗǤá éţĀ ţŽ DƘǪéĀƆ éĀDz > ƆéĀDz ȲĀǪƆŗƟģĀƆ ȲƆé ţƘŝ. ƆéŴĀǪƆ ĀţƆĀ ŅĀŽĀţƆDz ŽĀ >ƘŅţDzȓţŲ ɡȲǪ sĀǪģȸŅȲƆŅ DzȓĀŴŴȓǎ iƆé é Dz DzÇŗƘƆ DzĀţȓ ƨĭ : ŗǪĀƆ Žţȓ ɓ ÇŗDzĀƆéĀŽ iŽDz ȓɡá Ȳģ éĀǪ `ĀţȓĀ Ȃ éţĀDzĀǪ ĀţŴ ŅĀ ŲƟƆƆĀƆ `ţĀ éţĀDzĀ ǪģƘŴŅDzŅĀDzÇŗţÇŗȓĀ Ɔ ÇŗŴĀDzĀƆǎ 0ƆȓĀǪƆ ȓţƘƆ Ŵ ƼǪƘĨȓţĀǪȓ ɓţĀéĀǪȲŽ é Dz BuŝuĀǪŲ ţƆ >ĀţƼɡţŅ ɑƘƆ ĀţƆĀǪ ŲƘƆɡĀǪƆŝ ɓĀţȓĀƆ ȲDz ŽŽĀƆ Ǫ¥Āţȓ ȸ¥ĀǪ ŴŴĀ ,ǪĀƆɡĀƆ ŗţƆɓĀŅǎ BuŝBţȓ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀǪ ŅĀŗĀƆ ȲDz ` ÇŗDzĀƆ ţƆ éţĀ uĀŴȓá ȲƆé ȲDz éĀǪ uĀŴȓá ɡȲŽ ĀţDzƼţĀŴ ȲDz BĀɕţŲƘá ŲƘŽŽĀƆ ȲȓƘ¥ ȲĀǪ Ɔ Çŗ HDzȓéĀȲȓDzÇŗŝ Ŵ Ɔéǎ `ţĀ ŴĀDzĀƆ éţĀDzĀ ,ĀDzÇŗţÇŗȓĀ Ȳģ éĀǪ ɡɓĀţŝ ȓĀƆ `ĀţȓĀ ȲƆDzĀǪĀǪ ĀţŴ ŅĀǎ ƘÇŗ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲĀ ŽȲDzDz Ž Ɔ Ű ȲÇŗ Ņ Ɔɡ ɓƟǪȓŴţÇŗ ƆĀŗŽĀƆ ŲƟƆƆĀƆǎ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ţƆ éĀƆ ƆĀȲĀƆ ȲƆéĀDzŴ ƆéĀǪƆ DzţƆé Ȳģ DzÇŗƆĀŴŴĀ <ƘŽŽȲƆţŲ ȓţƘƆDzɓĀŅĀá ŲƘƆŲǪĀȓ Ȳģ ĀţƆ DzÇŗƆĀŴŝ ŴĀDz 0ƆȓĀǪƆĀȓ ƆŅĀɓţĀDzĀƆǎ iƆé Ŵ ƆŅDzȓ ƆţÇŗȓ ȸ¥ĀǪ ŴŴ ţDzȓ é Dz éĀǪ * ŴŴǎ uţĀ Ž Ɔ ĀDz ¥ĀDzDzĀǪ Ž ŝ ÇŗĀƆ Ų ƆƆá é ģȸǪ ŅĀ¥ĀƆ éţĀ `ȓ éȓɓĀǪŲĀ BĀǪDzĀŝ ¥ȲǪŅ ĀţƆ ĀţDzƼţĀŴǎ `Āţȓ ɡɓĀţĀţƆŗ Ŵ¥ : ŗǪĀƆ ŲȸŽŽĀǪȓ DzţÇŗ é Dz iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ȲŽ ĀţƆĀ ¥ĀDzŝ DzĀǪĀ o¥ĀǪȓǪ ŅȲƆŅDzǪ ȓĀ ţŽ DĀȓɡá ŗ ȓ é ģȸǪ ¥Āŝ ǪĀţȓDz ģȸƆģ BţŴŴţƘƆĀƆ ȲǪƘ ţƆɑĀDzȓţĀǪȓ ȲƆé ɓţŴŴ DzƘ éţĀ ¥ɓ ƆéĀǪȲƆŅ ȲDz éĀǪ ]ĀŅţƘƆ DzȓƘƼƼĀƆǎ ţƆ ŅȲȓĀǪ YŴ Ɔ Ę ȲƆé ĀţƆĀǪá éĀǪ ŗƘĥĀƆȓŴţÇŗ ȲģŅĀŗȓ ȲƆé ɡȲ ƆĀȲĀƆ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲĀƆ ţƆ éĀǪ ]ĀŅţƘƆ ģȸŗǪȓǎ 0Çŗ ɓȸƆDzÇŗĀ 0ŗƆĀƆ Žţȓ éţĀDzĀǪ ĀţŴ ŅĀ ţƆȓĀǪŝ ĀDzDz ƆȓĀ ţƆ¥ŴţÇŲĀ ţƆ éĀƆ ɑĀǪƆĀȓɡȓĀƆ uţǪȓŝ DzÇŗ ģȓDzDzȓ ƆéƘǪȓ HDzȓéĀȲȓDzÇŗŴ Ɔéá ŗĀǪɡŴţÇŗá 0ŗǪ :ƘÇŗĀƆ ǪƆȓɡ
-RFKHQ $UQW] &KHIUHGDNWHXU GHU %HUOLQHU =HLWXQJ
% (LQH $Q]HLJHQÓ6RQGHUYHU¶IIHQWOLFKXQJ GHU %HUOLQHU =HLWXQJ w 1RYHPEHU ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
:LUWVFKDIW
,PSXOVH DXV DOOHU :HOW
)ULVFKHU :LQG I¼U EUDFKOLHJHQGH ,PPRELOLHQ
,Q 1HW]ZHUNHQ DXI GHU 6XFKH QDFK 9RUWHLOHQ
%0: VHW]W DXI LQWHUQDWLRQDOH 1HW]ZHUNH XQG NRQ]HUQZHLWH =XVDPPHQDUEHLW ¼EHU DOOH *UHQ]HQ
:LH 1HXEUDQGHQEXUJ GLH 9HUPDUNWXQJ NRRUGLQLHUW
8PIUDJH GHV 8QLTPD ,QVWLWXWV /HLS]LJ
'% 40 %% 4!7
'% % . ) # .
s
:
ĀǪŲƘŗŴȓĀ Çŗ¥ ŴŲĀƆ Ǫ ŅĀƆ Ɔŝ ŲŴ ŅĀƆé ŅĀƆ .ţŽŽĀŴá é ǪȲƆȓĀǪ ĀǪDzȓǪĀÇŲȓ DzţÇŗ ĀţƆ dǪȸŽŽĀǪģĀŴéǎ ţƆŝ ŅĀDzÇŗŴ ŅĀƆĀ `ÇŗĀţ¥ĀƆá ¥¥Ŵ ȓȓĀǪƆéĀ * Ǫ¥DzÇŗţÇŗȓĀƆá o¥ĀǪǪĀDzȓĀ ɡĀǪDzȓƟǪȓĀƆ BƘ¥ţŴţ ǪDzǎ ǣ.ţĀǪ ŲƟƆƆȓĀ Ž Ɔ ĀţƆĀƆ ,ǪȲDzĀŴĨŴŽ éǪĀŗĀƆǤá Dz Ņȓ uţǪȓDzÇŗ ģȓDzŝ ģƟǪéĀǪĀǪ BţÇŗ ĀŴ DƟȓɡĀŴǎ ¥ĀǪ ĀǪ ŗ ȓ Āȓɓ Dz Ņ Ɔɡ ƆéĀǪĀDz Žţȓ éĀŽ ǪĀ Ŵ ɑƘǪǎ ĀǪ ,Ā¥ ȲéĀŲƘŽƼŴĀɕ DzƘŴŴ ɓţĀŝ éĀǪ ɡȲ ĀţƆĀǪ ŅȲȓĀƆ éǪĀDzDzĀ ɓĀǪéĀƆá Ā¥ĀƆDzƘ ɓţĀ ƆéĀǪĀ ¥Ǫ ÇŗŴţĀŅĀƆéĀ 0ŽŽƘ¥ţŴţĀƆ ţŽ ŅǪƟňȓĀƆ ,ĀɓĀǪ¥ĀŅĀŝ ¥ţĀȓ ɑƘƆ DĀȲ¥Ǫ ƆéĀƆ¥ȲǪŅǎ
Ƙ¥ŝ ƟǪDzĀá `ȲÇŗĀ Ɔ Çŗ ţĀƆDzȓŴĀţŝ DzȓĀǪƆ ȲƆé ŲǛȲţDzĀ ɑƘƆ ƆĀȲĀƆ Ȳģŝ ȓǪ ŅĀƆÜ HDzȓéĀȲȓDzÇŗĀ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀǪ ɑĀǪ¥ţƆéĀƆ Žţȓ ¥ĀǪȲĩţÇŗĀƆ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŝ ŲĀƆ ɑƘǪ ŴŴĀŽ Ņ Ɔɡ ŲƘƆŲǪĀȓĀ ţĀŴĀǎ BĀŗǪ ŴDz ŰĀéĀǪ ɡɓĀţȓĀ *ţǪŽĀƆŴĀƆŲĀǪ ţƆ éĀƆ HDzȓŝ ȲƆéĀDzŴ ƆéĀǪƆ ¥ĀɓĀǪȓĀȓ éţĀ ǪĀŅĀŴŽ ňţŅĀ <ƘƆȓ ŲȓƼĩĀŅĀ ŴDz ɓţÇŗŝ ȓţŅá ȲŽ ŅĀDzÇŗ ģȓŴţÇŗ ĀǪģƘŴŅǪĀţÇŗ ɡȲ DzĀţƆǎ Dz ţDzȓ é Dz ǪŅĀ¥ƆţDz ĀţƆĀǪ iŽŝ ģǪ ŅĀá éţĀ é Dz >ĀţƼɡţŅĀǪ 0ƆDzȓţȓȲȓ iƆţǛŝ Ž ţŽ ȲģȓǪ Ņ éĀǪ ƘDzȓéĀȲȓDzÇŗĀƆ d ŝ ŅĀDzɡĀţȓȲƆŅĀƆ éȲǪÇŗŅĀģȸŗǪȓ ŗ ȓǎ ţĀ Dz ÇŗDzţDzÇŗĀƆ BĀţƆȲƆŅDzģƘǪDzÇŗĀǪ ŗ ȓȓĀƆ ĭɥȘ ,ĀDzÇŗ ģȓDzģȸŗǪĀǪ ȲƆé ŴĀţȓĀƆéĀ Ɔŝ ŅĀDzȓĀŴŴȓĀ ¥ĀģǪ Ņȓǎ
$2 -$ " $ 63/ "" $ - $ $ Dz ɡȲ DzÇŗ ĥĀƆá ţDzȓ ȲģŅ ¥Ā ĀţƆĀDz ,Āŝ ɓĀǪ¥ĀŅĀ¥ţĀȓDzŽ Ɔ ŅĀŽĀƆȓDzá é Dz ŅĀǪ ŝ éĀ Žţȓ .ţŴģĀ ĀȲǪƘƼ ţDzÇŗĀǪ BţȓȓĀŴ ţƆDz >Ā¥ĀƆ ŅĀǪȲģĀƆ ɓȲǪéĀǎ DƟȓɡĀŴDz ]ƘŴŴĀ ŴDz <ƘƘǪéţƆ ȓƘǪ éĀDz ,ĀɓĀǪ¥ĀŅĀ¥ţĀȓDzŝ Ž Ɔ ŅĀŽĀƆȓDz ¥ĀDzȓĀŗȓ é ǪţƆá éţĀ ¥Āŝ Ɔ Çŗ¥ ǪȓĀ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀǪDzÇŗ ģȓ ¥ĀDzDzĀǪ ɡȲ ɑĀǪƆĀȓɡĀƆá ¥ĀǪ ȲÇŗ Žţȓ éĀƆ ţŝ ŅĀƆȓȸŽĀǪƆ ǪȲƆȓĀǪŅĀŲƘŽŽĀƆĀǪ 0Žŝ ŽƘ¥ţŴţĀƆ Ɔ Çŗ YĀǪDzƼĀŲȓţɑĀƆ ɡȲ DzȲŝ ÇŗĀƆǎ ţĀŴ ţDzȓ ĀDzá ĀţƆ ŅȲȓ ĀǪDzÇŗŴƘDzDzĀƆĀDz ,Ā¥ţĀȓ ȲģɡȲɓĀǪȓĀƆǎ ĀǪ ¥Ǫ ƆéŅĀŝ DzÇŗ éţŅȓĀ dƘǪDzƘ éĀDz ĀţƆDzȓţŅĀƆ BĀŴţƘŝ Ǫ ȓţƘƆDzŲƘŽ¥ţƆ ȓDz ţDzȓ é ¥Āţ éţĀ ĀǪDzȓĀ ŅǪƘňĀ .ĀǪ ȲDzģƘǪéĀǪȲƆŅ ȲƆé DzƘŴŴ ɡĀţŝ ŅĀƆá ɓ Dz ŽƟŅŴţÇŗ ţDzȓǎ ŴŴĀǪéţƆŅDz ŅŴĀţÇŗ ŴDz ǪţÇŗȓţŅ éţÇŲĀǪ ǪƘÇŲĀƆá éĀƆƆ é Dz . ȲƼȓŅĀ¥ ȲéĀ DzȓĀŗȓ ȲƆȓĀǪ ĀƆŲŽ Ŵŝ DzÇŗȲȓɡǎ ǣuĀţŴ ĀDz ĀɕĀŽƼŴ ǪţDzÇŗ ţDzȓ ģȸǪ ĀţƆĀ ¥ĀDzȓţŽŽȓĀ ƼƘÇŗĀ Ɔ Çŗ éĀŽ <ǪţĀŅá ɓƘ Ž Ɔ DzţÇŗ ȓǪƘȓɡ ŅĀǪţƆŅĀǪ ]ĀDzŝ DzƘȲǪÇĀƆ BȸŗĀ Ņ ¥ ¥Āţ éĀǪ ǪÇŗţȓĀŲŝ ȓȲǪǤá ɓĀţň DƟȓɡĀŴǎ ƘÇŗ sĀǪģ ŴŴ ȲƆé s Ɔé ŴĀƆ ŗ ¥ĀƆ ȲƆȸ¥ĀǪDzĀŗ¥ ǪĀ `ƼȲŝ ǪĀƆ ŗţƆȓĀǪŴ DzDzĀƆá ŗţĀǪ ɓţĀ ȲÇŗ ţƆ éĀǪ Ɔ ŗĀǪĀƆ iŽŅĀ¥ȲƆŅǎ 5 -" $2 $6 $326 $ iŽ é Dz ,Ā¥ţĀȓ ĀǪģƘŴŅǪĀţÇŗ ɡȲ ĀƆȓɓţŲŝ ŲĀŴƆá DzĀȓɡȓ éĀǪ uţǪȓDzÇŗ ģȓDzģƟǪéĀǪĀǪ Ȳģ éţĀ ǣ`Çŗɓ ǪŽţƆȓĀŴŴţŅĀƆɡǤ éĀǪ ¥ĀǪĀţȓDz ƆDz DzDzţŅĀƆ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀǪÜ ǣ Dz ţDzȓ ĀţƆĀ ȲģŅ ¥Āá éţĀ ŲĀţƆĀǪ ŴŴĀţƆ ŴĀţDzȓĀƆ Ų ƆƆǎ ¥ĀǪ ɓĀƆƆ ŅĀƆȸŅĀƆé >ĀȲȓĀ é Ǫȸ¥ĀǪ Ɔ ÇŗéĀƆŲĀƆá DzƘŴŴȓĀ ĀDz Ɔ 0éĀŝ ĀƆ ƆţÇŗȓ ģĀŗŴĀƆǎǤ `ÇŗŴţĀňŴţÇŗ DzĀţ ĀDz ȲÇŗ ţŽ 0ƆȓĀǪĀDzDzĀ éĀǪ ¥ĀƆ Çŗ¥ ǪȓĀƆ *ţǪŽĀƆá ɓĀƆƆ éţĀ `Çŗ ƆéĩĀÇŲĀƆ ɑĀǪŝ DzÇŗɓţƆéĀƆǎ Dz ,ĀɓĀǪ¥ĀŅĀ¥ţĀȓDzŽ ŝ Ɔ ŅĀŽĀƆȓ DzÇŗǪĀţ¥Ā DzţÇŗ é ¥Āţ ȲÇŗ éţĀ ŲǛȲţDzĀ ɑƘƆ *ƟǪéĀǪŽƟŅŴţÇŗŲĀţȓĀƆ Ȳģ éţĀ * ŗƆĀǎ uĀƆƆ éţĀDzĀDz YǪƘŰĀŲȓ ŅĀŝ Ŵ ƆŅĀá ţDzȓ DƟȓɡĀŴ ȸ¥ĀǪɡĀȲŅȓá ɓȸǪéĀƆ éţĀ >ĀȲȓĀ BȲȓ ģȸǪ ɓĀţȓĀǪĀ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŝ ŽȲƆŅĀƆ ģ DzDzĀƆǎ
- & " 3/ "" $/ 3//
'HU &KHI GHV %0: :HUNHV LQ /HLS]LJ +DQV 3HWHU .HPVHU YRUQH UHFKWV PLW $XWREDXHUQ DXV 0H[LNR
éţĀ dĀÇŗƆƘŴƘŅţĀ ȲƆé éţĀ sĀǪģ ŗǪĀƆDzŝ ȓĀÇŗƆţŲ ŅĀɓƘƆƆĀƆǤá ¥ĀǪţÇŗȓĀȓ ĀǪǎ Ǫ ŗ ¥Ā ŅĀŴĀǪƆȓá ɓţĀ ĀţƆ dĀ Ž ƘǪŅ ƆţDzţĀǪȓ ȲƆé ɓţĀ Ǫ¥Āţȓ DzȓǪȲŲȓȲǪţĀǪȓ ɓĀǪéĀǎ
>ȲţDz éȲ ǪéƘ :ƘȲ¥Ŵ ƆÇ , ǪÇţ ŗ ȓ ĀDz ŅȲȓ ŅĀȓǪƘĥĀƆǎ Ǫ ŗ ȓ ¥ĀǪĀţȓDz ŰĀȓɡȓ ĀţƆĀƆ Ǫ¥ĀţȓDzɑĀǪȓǪ Ņ ¥ĀţŽ Buŝ<ƘƆɡĀǪƆá Ƙ¥ɓƘŗŴ ţŽ ŅĀŅĀƆɓ ǪȓţŅ ģȸǪ ĀţƆĀ BţŴŴţŝ ǪéĀ i`ŝ ƘŴŴ Ǫ ĀƆȓDzȓĀŗĀƆéĀƆ ƆĀȲĀƆ uĀǪŲ ţŽ ŽĀɕţŲ ƆţDzÇŗĀƆ ` Ɔ >ȲţDz YƘŝ ȓƘDzţ ĀǪDzȓ ¥ ȧɥƨƉ éĀǪ ȘĀǪ ɑƘƆ éĀƆ Ɔŝ éĀǪƆ ǪƘŴŴĀƆ DzƘŴŴǎ ĀǪ ȲȓƘǪţĀDzĀ DzÇŗ ĥȓ éƘǪȓ ƨ ĭɥɥ :Ƙ¥Dzá ȲŽ éĀǪ ĀéĀȲȓȲƆŅ ţƆ éţĀDzĀŽ ɓţÇŗȓţŅĀƆ u ÇŗDzȓȲŽDzŽ ǪŲȓ ŅĀǪĀÇŗȓ ɡȲ ɓĀǪéĀƆǎ ĀǪ ȧƉŝŰ ŗǪţŅĀ , ǪÇţ ţDzȓ DzĀţȓ ĀţƆţŅĀƆ BƘƆ ȓĀƆ ȲƆé ƆƘÇŗ ¥ţDz : ŗǪĀDzĀƆéĀ ţŽ >ĀţƼɡţŅĀǪ BuŝuĀǪŲǎ ,ĀŽĀţƆDz Ž Žţȓ ƨĭ ƆéĀŝ ǪĀƆ <ƘŴŴĀŅĀƆ ȲDz éĀǪ ǹȘɥ ɥɥɥ ţƆɓƘŗŝ ƆĀǪ ɡ ŗŴĀƆéĀƆ `ȓ éȓ ţŽ ƆƟǪéŴţÇŗĀƆ ĀƆȓǪ ŴŽĀɕţŲƘ ɓţǪé ĀǪ Ĩȓ ŅĀŽ Çŗȓ ģȸǪ éţĀ ŲȸƆģȓţŅĀ d ȓţŅŲĀţȓ ţƆ éĀǪ .ĀţŽ ȓǎ ǣ0Çŗ ŗ ¥Ā ŗţĀǪ ɓĀǪȓɑƘŴŴĀ ţƆ¥ŴţÇŲĀ ţƆ
Ȳ Bu ŅĀŗƟǪȓ éĀǪ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲŅĀé Ɔŝ ŲĀ ɓţĀ ĀƆɡţƆ ţƆ éĀƆ sĀǪ¥ǪĀƆƆȲƆŅDzŝ ŽƘȓƘǪǎ ǣuţǪ ƼǪƘĨȓţĀǪĀƆ ɑƘŽ DĀȓɡŝ ɓĀǪŲ ȲƆé ȲŽŅĀŲĀŗǪȓ ţDzȓ ĀDz ŅĀƆ ȲDzƘǤá Dz Ņȓ uĀǪŲŴĀţȓĀǪ . ƆDzŝYĀȓĀǪ <ĀŽDzĀǪ ƿĭȧDžǎ ǣ ţƆ ĀŗƆȓĀŴ ȲƆDzĀǪĀǪ ŅȲȓ ĭ Șɥɥ ĀDzÇŗ ģȓţŅȓĀƆ ţDzȓ ţŽŽĀǪ ţǪŅĀƆéɓƘ Ȳģ éĀǪ uĀŴȓ ȲƆȓĀǪɓĀŅDzǤá ĀǪŅ Ɔɡȓ HŴţŝ ɑĀǪ : ŗƆ ƿĭƉDžá ¥ȓĀţŴȲƆŅDzŴĀţȓĀǪ Ɔŝ Ŵ ȲģĀǎ ǣ ȲǪÇŗ é Dz ,Ā¥ĀƆ ȲƆé DĀŗŝ ŽĀƆ ƘƼȓţŽţĀǪĀƆ ɓţǪ ȲƆDzĀǪ YǪƘéȲŲȓţŝ ƘƆDzƆĀȓɡɓĀǪŲǎǤ ţĀ ŗŴ éĀǪ >ĀţƼɡţŅĀǪá éţĀ ɑƘƆ éĀƆ ƆéĀǪĀƆ uĀǪŲĀƆ ȲŽ ] ȓ ȲƆé d ȓ ŅĀģǪ Ņȓ ɓĀǪéĀƆá ţDzȓ ǪĀŴ ȓţɑ ŗƘÇŗǎ ǣ Dz ŴţĀŅȓ é Ǫ Ɔá é DzDz Bu ŗţĀǪ ţƆ >ĀţƼɡţŅ Žţȓ éĀǪ ŴĀŲȓǪƘŽƘ¥ţŴţŝ ȓ ȓ ¥ĀŅƘƆƆĀƆ ŗ ȓǤá ¥ĀŅǪȸƆéĀȓ <ĀŽŝ DzĀǪǎ iƆé é ƆȲƆ Ɔ Çŗ ȲƆé Ɔ Çŗ ȲÇŗ éţĀ ƆéĀǪĀƆ * ¥ǪţŲĀƆ ŗţĀǪ <ƘŽƼĀŝ ȓĀƆɡ ĀǪŗ ŴȓĀƆ DzƘŴŴĀƆá ţDzȓ é Dz >ĀţƼɡţŅĀǪ uţDzDzĀƆ Ā¥ĀƆ ŅĀģǪ Ņȓǎ ¥ĀǪ ȲÇŗ >ĀţƼɡţŅ ƼǪƘĨȓţĀǪĀ é ŝ ɑƘƆǎ ǣuĀǪ ĀţƆţŅĀ BƘƆ ȓĀ ţƆ ĀţƆĀŽ ƆéĀǪĀƆ uĀǪŲ ŅĀŗƘŴģĀƆ ŗ ȓá ¥ǪţƆŅȓ
'% !. !
Dz BuŝuĀǪŲ ţƆ >ĀţƼɡţŅ DzĀȓɡȓ Ȳģ éĀƆ Dzȓ ƆéţŅĀƆ Ǫģ ŗǪȲƆŅDz ȲDzŝ ȓ ȲDzÇŗ Žţȓ <ƘƆɡĀǪƆŝBţȓ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀǪƆ Ɔ ɑţĀŴĀƆ ŅŴƘ¥ ŴĀƆ YǪƘéȲŲȓţƘƆDzDzȓ ƆéƘǪŝ ȓĀƆǎ ȲŅŴĀţÇŗ ŅĀ¥ĀƆ éţĀ >ĀţƼɡţŅĀǪ ɓĀţŝ ȓĀǪá ɓ Dz DzţĀ ¥Āţ éĀǪ YǪƘéȲŲȓţƘƆ ɑƘƆ ŴĀŲȓǪƘ ȲȓƘDz ¥ĀǪĀţȓDz ŅĀŴĀǪƆȓ ŗ ¥ĀƆ * 88 $ 3 & /
+6 +-& 2 -2
ƆĀȲĀ ƆDzţÇŗȓĀƆ ȲƆé 0éĀĀƆ Žţȓá éţĀ ȲƆDz ŗĀŴģĀƆ ŲƟƆƆĀƆǤá ŽĀţƆȓ <ĀŽDzĀǪǎ Dz ŗ ŴȓĀ éĀƆ `ȓ ƆéƘǪȓ ŰȲƆŅǎ ǣ ţĀ >ĀǪƆ¥ĀǪĀţȓDzÇŗ ģȓ ţDzȓ ţŽŽĀǪ é Dz ȲƆé HǎǤ ,ĀŅĀƆɓ ǪȓţŅ DzĀţĀƆ ɡɓƟŴģ Bţȓ Ǫŝ ¥ĀţȓĀǪ ȲDz >ĀţƼɡţŅ ţŽ i`ŝuĀǪŲ `Ƽ Ǫŝ ȓ Ɔ¥ȲǪŅá ¥ĀǪţÇŗȓĀȓ : ŗƆǎ ǣ`ţĀ DzĀŗĀƆ éƘǪȓ Žţȓ ŴţÇŲ Ȳģ éţĀ [Ȳ Ŵţȓ ȓ Žţȓ `ţÇŗĀǪŗĀţȓ YȲƆŲȓĀá éţĀ ȲƆDz ŗţĀǪ DzƼ ŝ ȓĀǪ ɓĀţȓĀǪ¥ǪţƆŅĀƆ ɓĀǪéĀƆǎǤ
+DQV 3HWHU .HPVHU &KHI GHV %0: :HUNV /HLS]LJ
ŗƆŴţÇŗ ɓţĀ ŰĀȓɡȓ éĀƆ ŽĀɕţŲ Ɔţŝ DzÇŗĀƆ , DzȓĀƆ ĀǪŅţƆŅ ĀDz ɑţĀŴĀƆ >ĀţƼɡţŝ ŅĀǪƆǎ sƘǪ éĀǪ uĀǪŲDzĀǪƟĥƆȲƆŅ ȧɥɥĭ ɓȲǪéĀƆ ɑţĀŴĀ ĀDzÇŗ ģȓţŅȓĀ Ɔ éĀƆ `ȓ ƆéƘǪȓĀƆ ţƆŅƘŴĨƆŅá ]ĀŅĀƆDz¥ȲǪŅ ȲƆé BȸƆÇŗĀƆ Ȳģ éţĀ ƆDzȓĀŗĀƆéĀ Ǫ¥Āţȓ ţƆ ` ÇŗDzĀƆ ɑƘǪ¥ĀǪĀţȓĀȓǎ ţƆ
0]< <DH*
`ÇŗɓĀǪƼȲƆŲȓ éĀDz YĀǪDzƘƆ Ŵ ȲDzȓ Ȳŝ DzÇŗĀDz ŴţĀŅȓ Ɔ ȓȲǪŅĀŽ ň ɑƘǪ éĀŽ Ɔŝ Ŵ Ȳģ ƆĀȲĀǪ * ŗǪɡĀȲŅĀǎ ŴDz ȧɥƨɥ ţƆ ]ĀŅĀƆDz¥ȲǪŅ éĀǪ ƆĀȲĀ ƨĀǪ Dzȓ ǪȓĀȓĀá ɓ ǪĀƆ ɑţĀŴĀ >ĀţƼɡţŅĀǪ ɑƘǪ HǪȓǎ ǣ]Āŝ ŅĀƆDz¥ȲǪŅ ŗ ȓ ȲƆDz ǛȲ ŴţĨɡţĀǪȓǤá Dz Ņȓ : ŗƆǎ ĀƆƆ DzƼ ȓĀǪ Ų Ž é Dz BƘéĀŴŴ ȲÇŗ ţƆ éţĀ BĀDzDzĀDzȓ éȓǎ
`i` DD ` .i>
0LFKDHO 1·W]HO N½PPHUW VLFK XP EUDFKOLHJHQGH ,PPRELOLHQǎ
¥Āţ éĀǪ u ŗŴ éĀDz ŴƘȲéŝ Ɔ¥ţĀȓĀǪDz Ɔŝ éĀǪĀ <ǪţȓĀǪţĀƆ ĀƆȓDzÇŗĀţéĀƆéǎ ǣ*ȸǪ é Dz ǪĀţƆĀ `ƼĀţÇŗĀǪƆ ţƆ éĀǪ ŴƘȲé ţDzȓ ĀDz ɓţÇŗȓţŅá é DzDz éţĀ *ƘȓƘDz ţŽ HǪţŅţŝ Ɔ ŴɡȲDzȓ Ɔé ¥ŅĀŴĀŅȓ ɓĀǪéĀƆá ȲŽ ŲĀţŝ ƆĀ [Ȳ Ŵţȓ ȓDzɑĀǪŴȲDzȓĀ éȲǪÇŗ <ƘŽƼǪţŝ ŽţĀǪȲƆŅ ƘéĀǪ iŽɓ ƆéŴȲƆŅ ţƆ ĀţƆ ƆéĀǪĀDz *ƘǪŽ ȓ ɡȲ ĀǪŴĀţéĀƆǤá Dz Ņȓ fƘŽ Dz BţÇŗŴ ɑƘƆ ǣdĀŴȓ ǪţģǎéĀǤǎ `ƘŴŴĀƆ DzţÇŗ ƆéĀǪĀ éţĀ *ƘȓƘDz ȲÇŗ ƆDzÇŗ ȲĀƆá ŽȸDzDzĀƆ éţĀ ţŴéĀǪ ƆţÇŗȓ ȲƆ¥ĀéţƆŅȓ ƘéĀǪ ȲDzDzÇŗŴţĀňŴţÇŗ ţƆ HǪţŝ ŅţƆ Ŵ ȲĩƟDzȲƆŅ ¥ŅĀŴĀŅȓ ɓĀǪéĀƆǎ ǣ Āţ ĀţƆɡĀŴƆĀƆ ţŴéĀǪƆ ţDzȓ 0ƆDzȓ ŅǪ Ž ĀţƆĀ ŅȲȓĀ u ŗŴá ģȸǪ Ņ ƆɡĀ Ŵ¥ĀƆ ĀţŅƆĀƆ DzţÇŗ ɓţĀéĀǪȲŽ ţĀƆDzȓĀ ɓţĀ *ŴţÇŲǪ ¥ĀDzŝ DzĀǪǤá ĨƆéĀȓ BţÇŗŴǎ
ţĀ * ÇŗɡĀţȓDzÇŗǪţģȓ ǣ ŗţƼ *ƘȓƘŝsţŝ éĀƘǤ ŗ ȓ ŽĀŗǪĀǪĀ ŴƘȲéŝ`ƼĀţÇŗĀǪ ŅĀŝ ȓĀDzȓĀȓ ȲƆé ĀŽƼĨĀŗŴȓá Āȓɓ Ȳģ iƆȓĀǪŝ DzȓȸȓɡȲƆŅ éĀDz ]Ƙŗé ȓĀƆģƘǪŽ ȓDz ] u ɡȲ ÇŗȓĀƆǎ *ȸǪ *ƘȓƘDz ţŽ ] uŝ*ƘǪŽ ȓ ŅţŴȓÜ ǣB ƆÇŗŽ Ŵ ɓĀǪéĀƆ DzţĀ ɡɓ Ǫ ŅĀŝ DzƼĀţÇŗĀǪȓá ¥ĀǪ éţĀ `ȲÇŗĀ ɓţǪé ƆţÇŗȓ ȲƆȓĀǪDzȓȸȓɡȓǎǤ iƆéÜ ,ţ¥ȓ ĀDz Ž `Ž Ǫȓŝ ƼŗƘƆĀ éţĀ BƟŅŴţÇŗŲĀţȓá *ƘȓƘDz ȲȓƘŽ ŝ ȓţDzÇŗ ɡȲŽ ŰĀɓĀţŴţŅĀƆ ŴƘȲéŝ ţĀƆDzȓ ŗƘÇŗɡȲŴ éĀƆá Ų ƆƆ é Dz DzĀŗǪ ƼǪ ŲȓţDzÇŗ DzĀţƆǎ .ţŴģǪĀţÇŗ ţDzȓ ĀDzŲȓƘƼŝ`Ƙģȓɓ ǪĀÜ ǣH¥ɓƘŗŴ ŴŴĀ ţĀƆDzȓĀ ƘƆŴţƆĀ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀƆá Ņţ¥ȓ ĀDz ĀDzŲȓƘƼŝdƘƘŴDzá ȸ¥ĀǪ éţĀ DzţÇŗ HƼȓţƘƆĀƆ ȲƆé `ƼĀţÇŗĀǪ ƆƼ DzDzĀƆ Ŵ Dzŝ DzĀƆǎǤ `ţĀ ¥ĀDzÇŗŴĀȲƆţŅĀƆ ŽĀţDzȓ é Dz ȲǪÇŗDzȲÇŗĀƆ ŅǪƘňĀǪ ` ŽŽŴȲƆŅĀƆǎ
lÌŵ čŽƛ ]Ìčę ¼ÌŽ +ćŵÌŽ >ÌƛǡǓÌŵėŽũ śóĬƬ Ìåŵ{úƛÌ aĨƛÌŵĨÌćġÌŵŜ
ƇƟ ŝ
čÌĨŽƛęÌčŽƛÌŵ =čƛ{ŵ ÌčƛÌŵ {ƴŽ lÌƛƛ ÌǓÌŵ ÌŵČaĨƛÌŵĨÌćġÌĨ
óƟ ŝ ƟĿ ŝ
kÌŵ {Ĩ¼ŽǒÌŵƛŵÌƛÌŵ
o¥ĀǪŗ ȲƼȓ ŴĀŅȓ Bu Ȳģ é Dz ƼĀǪDzƟƆŝ ŴţÇŗĀ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲ DzĀţƆĀǪ Bţȓ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀǪ ŅǪƘňĀƆ uĀǪȓǎ ǣ0Ɔ ĀţƆĀŽ ŅŴƘ¥ ŴĀƆ iƆŝ ȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ţDzȓ éţĀ <ƘŽŽȲƆţŲ ȓţƘƆ ȲƆé ȲDz ŽŽĀƆ Ǫ¥Āţȓ ɡɓţDzÇŗĀƆ Ƙģȓ ɓĀŴȓɓĀţȓ ɑĀǪDzȓǪĀȲȓĀƆ BĀƆDzÇŗĀƆ ƆţÇŗȓ ţŽŽĀǪ ĀţƆģ ÇŗǤá ŗĀţňȓ ĀDz ŴDz ,ǪȲƆéŝ Dz ȓɡ ţƆ éĀǪ BȸƆÇŗƆĀǪ ĀƆȓǪ ŴĀǎ ĀDzŗ Ŵ¥ Ņţ¥ȓ ĀDz ĀţƆ DzƘɡţ ŴĀDz DĀȓɡŝ ɓĀǪŲ ģȸǪ Bţȓ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀǪá ȲŽ éţĀ ȲDz Žŝ ŽĀƆ Ǫ¥Āţȓ ȲƆé Ǫ¥ĀţȓDz ¥Ŵ ȲģĀ ǪȲƆé ȲŽ éĀƆ ,ŴƘ¥ȲDz ƆƘÇŗ DzÇŗƆĀŴŴĀǪá ȲƆŝ ŲƘŽƼŴţɡţĀǪȓĀǪ ȲƆé ĀĦɡţĀƆȓĀǪ ɡȲ ŅĀDzȓ ŴȓĀƆǎ ĀȲȓDzÇŗŴ Ɔé ŅĀģ ŴŴĀ ţŗŽ ŅȲȓá Dz Ņȓ *Ǫ ƆÇţDzÇƘ :ţŽĀƆĀɡá éĀǪ Ā¥ĀƆŝ ģ ŴŴDz ţŽ >ĀţƼɡţŅĀǪ uĀǪŲ ģȸǪ éţĀ YǪƘéȲŲŝ ȓţƘƆ ţƆ BĀɕţŲƘ ŅĀDzÇŗȲŴȓ ɓţǪéǎ ĀǪ ļȧŝ: ŗǪţŅĀ Ǫ ȲŽȓ ¥ĀǪ ĀţƆá é DzDz ĀǪ DzĀţŝ ƆĀ * ŽţŴţĀ ȲƆé é Dz ŽĀɕţŲ ƆţDzÇŗĀ DzDzĀƆ ɑĀǪŽţDzDzĀǎ
&ORXG 6\VWHPH VLQG WHFKQLVFK HLQH EHTXHPH 0¶JOLFKNHLW LP +LQEOLFN DXI GHQ 'DWHQVFKXW] DEHU NULWLVFK
'% '# 0 ).% .
Ìŵƴñč¨ćÌŽ >ÌƛǡǓÌŵė ĵŽƛ¼ÌƴƛŽ¨ćÌŵ aĨƛÌŵĨÌćġÌŵ
-/($ / 265 -
:LH VLFKHU LVW GLH :RONH" ɕȓĀǪƆĀ *ĀDzȓƼŴ ȓȓĀƆ DzţƆé ģȸǪ ȓĀƆŝ DzţÇŗĀǪȲƆŅĀƆ ţŽŽĀǪ ĀţƆĀ ŅȲȓĀ 0éĀĀǎ ¥ĀǪ ȲÇŗ éţĀ s Ǫţ ƆȓĀá ȓĀƆ Ȳģ 0ƆȓĀǪƆĀȓŝ`ĀǪɑĀǪƆ ƿ ŴƘȲéDž ¥ɡȲŴĀŝ ŅĀƆá ŗ ȓ DzĀţƆĀ sƘǪȓĀţŴĀá ɑƘǪ ŴŴĀŽá ɓĀƆƆ ĀDz DzţÇŗ ȲŽ *ƘȓƘDz ŗ ƆéĀŴȓǎ ĀƆƆ DzƘ Ŵ DzDzĀƆ DzţĀ DzţÇŗ ȸ¥ĀǪ ŴŴ ȲƆé Ƙģȓ ȲÇŗ ƼĀǪ ƼƼ ȲģǪȲģĀƆá ƆDzÇŗ ȲĀƆ ȲƆé Žţȓ ɓĀƆţŅĀƆ <ŴţÇŲDz ȓĀţŴĀƆǎ iƆé ɓĀǪ éţĀ <ƘŽ¥ţƆ ȓţƘƆ *ĀDzȓƼŴ ȓȓĀ ȲƆé HƆŴţƆĀŝ `ƼĀţÇŗĀǪ ɓ ŗŴȓá ŽţƆţŽţĀǪȓ é Dz ]ţDzţŲƘ ĀţƆĀDz dƘȓ ŴɑĀǪŴȲDzȓDzǎ BƟÇŗȓĀ Ž Ɔ DzĀţƆĀ *ƘȓƘDz ƆȲǪ ţƆ éĀǪ ŴƘȲé DzţÇŗĀǪƆ ƘéĀǪ DzţĀ ȲÇŗ Ɔŝ éĀǪĀƆ ƼǪ DzĀƆȓţĀǪĀƆǝ :Ā Ɔ ÇŗéĀŽ DzţƆé
DzDz *ȸŗǪȲƆŅDzŲǪ ģȓĀ ȲƆé iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŝ ŽĀƆ ĀţƆ ¥ĀǪȲĩţÇŗĀDz DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲ ¥Ǫ Ȳŝ ÇŗĀƆá ȲŽ Ž B ǪŲȓ ĀǪģƘŴŅǪĀţÇŗ ɡȲ DzĀţƆá DzȓĀŗȓ ģȸǪ éţĀ ŽĀţDzȓĀƆ ƘDzȓéĀȲȓŝ DzÇŗĀƆ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀǪ ȲňĀǪ *Ǫ ŅĀá Ɔ ŝ ŴɗDzţĀǪȓ iƆţǛŽ ŝ,ĀDzÇŗ ģȓDzģȸŗǪĀǪ Ɔŝ éǪĀ Dz ɡ ƼŴţÇŲţ éţĀ ǪŅĀ¥ƆţDzDzĀǎ DȲǪ ɓĀƆţŅĀ HDzȓŝ ŗĀģDz ɓȸǪéĀƆ éţĀDzĀ Āŝ
ĀɑƘǪ Ž Ɔ DzĀţƆĀ *ƘȓƘDz Ȳģ éţĀ `ĀǪŝ ɑĀǪ ŗƘÇŗŴ éȓá DzƘŴŴȓĀ Ž Ɔ ŴŴĀǪéţƆŅDz Āţŝ ƆĀƆ ŴţÇŲ ţƆ éţĀ , ȲƆé ȓĀƆŝ DzÇŗȲȓɡĀǪŲŴ ǪȲƆŅĀƆ ɓĀǪģĀƆǎ ǣ Ȳ ¥Āŝ ÇŗȓĀƆ ţDzȓá é DzDz ţŴéĀǪ ¥Āţ *ƘȓƘŝ ƘŽŝ ŽȲƆţȓţĀ Dz ŅǪȲƆéDz ȓɡŴţÇŗ ƟĥĀƆȓŴţÇŗ ĀţƆŝ DzĀŗ¥ Ǫ DzţƆéǤá ĀǪŲŴ Ǫȓ BţÇŗŴǎ ɓ Ǫ ŴĀŅȓ Ž Ɔ ŽĀţDzȓ DzĀŴ¥Dzȓ ģĀDzȓá Ƙ¥ ȲƆé ɓĀŴÇŗĀ ţŴéĀǪ ƆéĀǪĀ DzĀŗĀƆ éȸǪģĀƆǎ ģȸǪ ŽȸDzDzĀ Ž Ɔ ¥ĀǪ Žţȓ éĀƆ ĀƆȓDzƼǪĀŝ ÇŗĀƆéĀƆ ţƆDzȓĀŴŴȲƆŅĀƆ ɑĀǪȓǪ Ȳȓ DzĀţƆǎ ,ǪȲƆéDz ȓɡŴţÇŗ DzĀţ DzȓĀȓDz ɡȲ ȸ¥ĀǪŴĀŅĀƆá ɓĀŴÇŗĀ ţŴéĀǪ ŗƘÇŗŅĀŴ éĀƆ ȲƆé ɓĀŴŝ ÇŗĀ ¥ĀDzDzĀǪ Ȳģ éĀŽ ĀţŅĀƆĀƆ ]ĀÇŗƆĀǪ ¥ŴĀţ¥ĀƆ DzƘŴŴȓĀƆǎ Hģȓ ɓĀǪéĀƆ ȲÇŗ éţĀ ]ĀÇŗȓĀ Ž ţŴé Žţȓ éĀǪ ƆŽĀŴéȲƆŅ Ɔ éĀƆ Ɔ¥ţĀȓĀǪ ¥ŅĀȓǪĀȓĀƆǎ ņ ńFŌ
Ŀê ŝ
l莎ÌĨŽ¨ć{åƛęÌŵ PĵęčƛčėÌŵ
7čÌåÌŵ{ĨƛÌĨ
Ĭŝ óŝ
Qa 77 µ a>+Q= %S $+5µ =w e]]> S
éĀȲȓȲƆŅ ƆţÇŗȓ DzƘ ĀţƆDzÇŗ ȓɡĀƆǎ ƆȓɓĀŝ éĀǪ ɑĀǪȓǪĀȓĀƆ DzţĀ éţĀ BĀţƆȲƆŅá é DzDz éţĀDz ţƆ ţŗǪĀǪ Ǫ ƆÇŗĀ ƆţÇŗȓ ƆƘȓɓĀƆéţŅ DzĀţ ƘéĀǪ é DzDz ĀDz ţŗǪ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ Ȳģŝ ŅǪȲƆé DzĀţƆĀǪ B ǪŲȓƼƘDzţȓţƘƆ ƆţÇŗȓ ƆƟŝ ȓţŅ ŗ ¥Āá ɑĀǪƆĀȓɡȓ ɡȲ DzĀţƆá DzƘ ɡ ƼŴţÇŲţǎ ǣiƆé Ž ƆÇŗĀŽ ŴţĀŅȓ é Dz sĀǪƆĀȓɡĀƆ ĀţƆģ Çŗ ƆţÇŗȓǎǤ & (-/ $ 3 3 $
Ȳ éĀƆ ɓţÇŗȓţŅDzȓĀƆ ǪŅĀ¥ƆţDzDzĀƆ éĀǪ `ȓȲéţĀ ɡ ŗŴȓá é DzDz éţĀ ƘDzȓéĀȲȓDzÇŗĀƆ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀǪ ŗ ƆéģĀDzȓĀ sƘǪȓĀţŴĀ ȲDz ţŗǪĀƆ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲĀƆ ɡţĀŗĀƆǎ `Ƙ ŗ ¥ĀƆ éǪĀţ sţĀǪȓĀŴ éĀǪ ĀģǪ ŅȓĀƆ DzÇŗƘƆ ţĀƆDzȓŴĀţDzȓĀǪ ȸ¥ĀǪ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲĀ ŅĀģȲƆŝ éĀƆ ȲƆé é ƆƆ ȲÇŗ ¥Ā ȲģȓǪ Ņȓǎ ɓĀţ ǪţȓȓĀŴ ŗ ¥ĀƆ ĀţƆĀƆ YǪƘŰĀŲȓƼ ǪȓƆĀǪ ŅĀģȲƆéĀƆ ƘéĀǪ ƆĀȲĀ ȲģȓǪ ŅĀ ŲǛȲţŝ ǪţĀǪȓǎ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲĀ ţƆ éĀƆ HDzȓŝ*ţǪŽĀƆ ģȲƆŅţĀǪĀƆ ţƆ ĀţȓĀƆ éĀDz ɓ ÇŗDzĀƆéĀƆ * ÇŗŲǪ ģȓĀŽ ƆŅĀŴDz ɡȲéĀŽ ŴDz :Ƙ¥ŝ ¥ƟǪDzĀƆǎ ,Ȳȓ ŰĀéĀǪ ɓĀţȓĀ ţDzȓ é Ǫȸ¥ĀǪ DzÇŗƘƆ ĀţƆŽ Ŵ Ȳģ ƆĀȲĀ Bţȓ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀǪ ŅĀDzȓƘňĀƆǎ ţĀ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲĀ éĀǪ ŽĀţDzȓĀƆ HDzȓŝ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀǪ DzţƆé ȸ¥ĀǪDzÇŗ Ȳ¥ Ǫǎ DȲǪ ¥Āţ ǪȲƆé ļɥ YǪƘɡĀƆȓ ȲŽģ DzDzĀƆ DzţĀ ŽĀŗǪ ŴDz ļɥ <ƘƆȓ ŲȓĀǎ Āţ éĀƆ ƆéĀǪĀƆá DzƘ ɡ ƼŴţÇŲţá DzĀţ é Dz DĀȓɡŝ ɓĀǪŲ ƆƘÇŗ ŲŴĀţƆĀǪǎ iƆé DzĀŴ¥Dzȓ ţƆ éţĀDzĀŽ <ǪĀţDz ɓȸǪéĀƆ éţĀ <ƘƆȓ ŲȓĀ ƆȲǪ ŴDz ƆţÇŗȓ DzƘ ĀƆŅ ĀţƆŅĀDzȓȲģȓǎ ǣ Ɔ ĀǪDzȓĀǪ `ȓĀŴŴĀ DzȓĀŗȓ éĀǪ ŲƘŴŴĀŅţ ŴĀ ȲDzŝ ȓ ȲDzÇŗ ȲƆé éţĀ <ƘƆȓ ŲȓƼĩĀŅĀ Žţȓ ,ĀDzÇŗ ģȓDzƼ ǪȓƆĀǪƆǎǤ ţƆ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲ DzƘŴŴ Ņ Ɔɡ ŲƘƆŲǪĀȓĀƆ DȲȓɡĀƆ ģȸǪ é Dz iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ŗ ¥ĀƆá Āȓɓ éţĀ Ųŝ ǛȲţDzĀ ƆĀȲĀǪ ȲģȓǪ ŅĀǎ
&5 -' -& +7 5 7>7 9" 57 4* 7>< 4* 95 (475 & "7 9- (55 -' 5 & "7 9, ( -7 4- &, (, - ;.4 ->9 4(-% -2 5 &(-7 4 57 *7 4+ 97 47 4."2 42 4,(- (++(-%, -- (-(57 4 ":4 (475 & "7 (5' 5 -5 & "7 9- (%(7 +(5( 49-% (, 514 &2
(5 8?8? *.-5 39 -7 ".472
& ( ! # !# % #! #
! # $! (++(-%, -- &579, 4 9 &7 ;.4 ++ , --.; 7(.' - - 5( 5(- 9-5 4 .&57.# 4 9*9-"72 . & - 9 4. 9*7 . 4 4" &4 - " ++ - -( &7 ;., (,, +2 &(-7 4 57 *7 & 47 4 (7 - %97 - -2 5& +
57 4* - <(4 .45 &9-% 9- -7' <( *+9-% % -> % >( +7 94 & -% 4- 7>9-% 4 -7 4- &' , - ,(7 9-5 4 - => ++ -7 . &5 &9+ - 9- .45 &9-%5' (-4( &79-% -2 (4 < 4 ( &, - (-%9-% - ":4 9-7 4- &, 4(5 & 7 7(%9-% 9-5 4 4 . &5 &9+ - 97+( & ; 4 55 4-2 9 , 5 7> - <(4 9-5 4 --.; 7(.-5' # -5(;
& ! # (++(-%, -- -> *.-*4 7 % &7 5 9, - < (7 4 - 9"' 9- 95 9 4 .45 &9-%5(-' "4 5749*794 (- &5 -' -& +72 (5 8?8? < 4 - <(4 &( 4":4 *- 11 0$? (++(.- - 94. (- ( - - &, -2 ( 5 457*+ 55(' % - .45 &9-%5 (-4( &79-% < 4 - % 4 9-5 4 - (7' 7 +57 - + 4- & +" - 5( & ,(7 - 9 - 4. 9*7 - -. & < 77 ' < 4 5" &(% 4 9">957 ++ -2 - <(4 < 4 - 95%4:- 9-% 95 - . &5 &9+ - 4+ ( &' 7 4-2 4 94. 4 (- ( 4' > &-9-% ;.- (475 & "7 9- (55 -5 & "7 (-; 57( 47 <(4 5( & 47 .&+57 - 9- 9*9-"7 9-5 4 5 - 52 4- 7>7 < &'
5 - 5 (57 9 & 9-5 4 .77. - (>(-7 &-(*' ,195 ":4 &5 -' -& +72 5.<( 4 95 9 (- 5 4 9-&." 4' -57(7975 >94 & ( (%(7 +(5( 49-% 9" 4 % - 2 ! ! $ ' ! 5 57 4*7 ( --.; 7(.-5' -' # # ( "4 5749*794 (- &5 -' -& +72 (++(-%, -- (4 5 7> - ' ( 9" 9*9-"75 4 - & - <( & $ !# $! 97.,.7(; (>(-7 &-(* $ ' ! $ ! . 4 9-5757.#; 4 4 (79-%2 #$ % ! ( - 4 -(; 45(7 7 % 94% # 5.++ 7< (- - 9 5 97.,. (+' -7<( *+9-%5> -749, -757 ' & - ,(7 .*95 9" --.; 7(' .- - ( + *74.,. (+(7 7 9- & 57.#4 9>( 49-%2 , & ,( 4 ( * (, - 55:' - 4< (7 4- <(4 (- 4 9-' &." 4' -749, - , ( 457 ++9-% - 9 4 9-5757.# 4".45 &7 <(4 2 - (- %' 94% 57 & - 4 9 9 ":4
(++(-%, -- .4 ++ , < ' % - 9-5 4 4 5 &4 *+ (-7 (+(% (475 & "72 - &5 -' -' & +7 & - <(4 ;( + -7 4' - &, - ( 5( & * (- (% ' - - .45 &9-%5 7 (+9-% + (57 - */-- -2 4 9 & ( 5 74( 4 9 & - 9% -% >9 --.; 7(.- -2 & 4 (-; 5' 7( 4 - <(4 (- ( .45 &9-%5' + - 5 & "7 9- 5 7> - >9 ,
57 4* -4 (> ":4 ( 95 ,' , - 4 (7 ;.- (475 & "7 9- (55 -5 & "72 (4 "/4 4- 92 2 % , (-5 , .45 &9-%514.' ) *7 ;.- -7 4- &, - 9- . &5 &9+ - 5.<( ( (-57 +' +9-% ;.- . &5 &9+ 5.+; -' 7 - >94 ,5 7>9-% ;.- --.' ; 7(.- - (- - 74( -2 5 <(4*7! <<<2,<25 &5 -' -& +72
%
(LQH $Q]HLJHQÓ6RQGHUYHU¶IIHQWOLFKXQJ GHU %HUOLQHU =HLWXQJ w 1RYHPEHU
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
:LUWVFKDIW
$XI GHP +RO]ZHJ 'DV %LR (FRQRP\ &OXVWHU LQ +DOOH ZLOO GDV ZLVVHQVFKDIWOLFKH 3RWHQ]LDO GHV %XQGHVODQGHV PLW *HOGJHEHUQ ]XVDPPHQEULQJHQ
9RP :DOGUDQG DXI GHQ :HOWPDUNW 5DLQHU *O¤ I¼KUW GLH *. 6RIWZDUH $* LP YRJWO¤QGLVFKHQ 6FK¶QHFN #! ! ( ( !
s
ƘŽ u ŴéǪ Ɔé Ȳģ éĀƆ uĀŴȓŽ ǪŲȓÜ ȲÇŗ ɓĀƆƆ éţĀ ,< `Ƙģȓɓ ǪĀ , ŗĀȲȓĀ ȸǪƘDz ţƆ BĀȓǪƘƼƘŴĀƆ ɓţĀ ĀǪŝ ŴţƆá . Ž¥ȲǪŅ ȲƆé BƘDzŲ Ȳ ŗ ȓ Ę ɓĀǪ ɡȲ sƘǪDzȓ ƆéDzÇŗĀģ ] ţƆĀǪ ,Ŵ ň ɓţŴŴá ŽȲDzDz ȓţĀģ ŗţƆĀţƆ ţƆDz sƘŅȓŴ Ɔé ģ ŗǪĀƆǎ 0Ɔ `ÇŗƟƆĀÇŲá ĀţƆĀǪ <ŴĀţƆDzȓ éȓ Žţȓ ŅȲȓ Ș Șɥɥ ţƆɓƘŗƆĀǪƆá ȲŽŅĀ¥ĀƆ ɑƘƆ u ŴéĀǪƆ ȲƆé Ɔ ŗĀ Ɔ éĀǪ ,ǪĀƆɡĀ ɡȲ dDzÇŗĀÇŗţĀƆá ŗ ȓ éţĀ *ţǪŽ ţŗǪĀƆ `ţȓɡǎ ,Ŵ ň ŅţŴȓ ŴDz ɑĀǪɓȲǪɡĀŴȓ Žţȓ DzĀţƆĀǪ .ĀţŽ ȓǎ 0ŽŽĀǪ ɓţĀéĀǪ ŗ ȓ ĀǪ DzţÇŗ é ɡȲ ¥ĀŲ ƆƆȓǎ ǣ0Çŗ ŅŴ Ȳ¥Āá ĀDz ţDzȓ ĀţƆ sƘǪȓĀţŴá ţƆ `ÇŗƟƆĀÇŲ ɡȲ DzĀţƆǎ uţǪ ŗ ŝ ¥ĀƆ ŗţĀǪ ŅȲȓĀ ȲƆé ĩĀţňţŅĀ Bţȓ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀǪá éţĀ ŴƘɗ Ŵ ɡȲŽ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ DzȓĀŗĀƆǎ iƆé é Žţȓ ŗ ¥ĀƆ ɓţǪ `ȓ ¥ţŴţȓ ȓǤá Dz ŅȓĀ éĀǪ ĭČŝ: ŗǪţŅĀ ȲƆŴ ƆŅDzȓ ¥Āţ éĀǪ 0Ɔ¥Āŝ ȓǪţĀ¥Ɔ ŗŽĀ éĀǪ ŰȸƆŅDzȓĀƆ 0ƆɑĀDzȓţȓţƘƆá ĀţƆĀŽ ģȸƆģ BţŴŴţƘƆĀƆ ȲǪƘ ȓĀȲǪĀŽ Ǫŝ ɓĀţȓĀǪȲƆŅDz¥ Ȳ ģȸǪ éţĀ ŅȲȓ Șĭɥ Āŝ DzÇŗ ģȓţŅȓĀƆ ţƆ `ÇŗƟƆĀÇŲǎ
0 ' ' , ', /"' -* '
ţĀ ,<á ĀţƆĀ éĀǪ ɓĀƆţŅĀƆ ¥ƟǪDzĀƆƆƘŝ ȓţĀǪȓĀƆ *ţǪŽĀƆ ţƆ BţȓȓĀŴéĀȲȓDzÇŗŴ Ɔéá ŗ ȓ DzţÇŗ ŴDz ƆȓɓţÇŲŴĀǪ ɑƘƆ `Ƙģȓɓ ǪĀŝ ŴƟDzȲƆŅĀƆ ģȸǪ éĀƆ . ƆéĀŴ ĀţƆĀƆ D ŝ ŽĀƆ ŅĀŽ Çŗȓǎ <ĀȓȓĀƆ ɓţĀ Ŵéţá ƘȲŝ ŅŴ Dz ƘéĀǪ >Ƙ¥Ŵ ɓ ţƆ < Ɔ é DzȓĀŗĀƆ Ȳģ éĀǪ <ȲƆéĀƆŴţDzȓĀǎ ] ţƆĀǪ ,Ŵ ň ģȸŗǪȓ éţĀ ,< `Ƙģȓɓ ǪĀ , ţŽ ɑƘŅȓŴ Ɔéţŝ DzÇŗĀƆ `ÇŗƟƆĀÇŲǎ 0Ɔ ŽĀŗǪ ŴDz ļƨ ɥɥɥ *ţŴţ ŴĀƆ ţƆ ȸ¥ĀǪ ļɥ > ƆéĀǪƆ ţDzȓ éţĀ `Ƙģȓɓ ǪĀ ţŽ ţƆDz ȓɡǎ o¥ĀǪ Ɖɥɥ Bţȓ Ǫŝ ¥ĀţȓĀǪ Ɔ ɡɓƟŴģ `ȓ ƆéƘǪȓĀƆ ¥ĀDzÇŗ ģȓţŅȓ ,< ŗĀȲȓĀǎ ĀǪ `ȓ Ǫȓ ɓ Ǫ ¥ĀDzÇŗĀţéĀƆĀǪá ŴDz ,Ŵ ň ȲƆé DzĀţƆ Y ǪȓƆĀǪ `ȓĀƼŗ Ɔ <ǪƘƆŽȸŴŴĀǪ ţŽ : ŗǪ ƨƉƉɥ ŴDz ɓĀţŝ B ƆƆŝiƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ŴƘDzŴĀŅȓĀƆǎ ţĀ ¥ĀţéĀƆ 0ƆģƘǪŽ ȓţŲĀǪ ŗ ȓȓĀƆ ɓĀéĀǪ *ţǪŽĀƆǪ ȲŽĀ ƆƘÇŗ ,ĀŴéǎ sƘŽ uƘŗƆŝ ɡţŽŽĀǪ ȲDz ɓȲǪéĀƆ ȲÇŗŗ ŴȓȲƆŅDzŝ ƼǪƘŅǪ ŽŽĀ ģȸǪ ŽţȓȓĀŴDzȓ ƆéţDzÇŗĀ Āŝ ȓǪţĀ¥Ā ĀƆȓɓţÇŲĀŴȓǎ D ] ` `d d> ]
)UDXQKRIHU &%3 /HXQD 0RQLTXH 0HUNHO PLW GHP QDW½UOLFKHQ 5RKVWRII DXV GHP :DOG
#! %
D
ƘÇŗ éȸŽƼĀŴȓ éĀǪ YǪĀţDz ģȸǪ ĀţƆ Ǫŝ ǪĀŴ ǪéƟŴ ȲŽ éţĀ B ǪŲĀ ɑƘƆ ĭɥ ƘŴŴ Ǫǎ u Dz ¥ĀǪ Ƽ DzDzţĀǪȓá ɓĀƆƆ éţĀ DţĀéǪţŅƼǪĀţDzƼŗ DzĀ ĀƆéĀȓ ȲƆé é Dz * DzDz é Dz sţĀǪģ ÇŗĀ ŲƘDzȓĀȓǝ Ȳģ éţĀDzĀDz `ɡĀŝ Ɔ ǪţƘ ¥ĀǪĀţȓĀȓ DzţÇŗ ` ÇŗDzĀƆŝ Ɔŗ Ŵȓ ɑƘǪá ţƆ éĀŽ ĀDz DzÇŗƘƆ ŰĀȓɡȓ ĀţƆĀ ¥ţƘ¥ ŝ DzţĀǪȓĀ uţǪȓDzÇŗ ģȓ ĀƆȓɓţÇŲĀŴȓǎ ǣ ţĀ Ȳŝ ŲȲƆģȓ ¥ĀŅţƆƆȓ ţƆ BţȓȓĀŴéĀȲȓDzÇŗŴ ƆéǤá Dz Ņȓ B ȓȓŗţ Dz DzÇŗĀţŴĀá ŗĀģ éĀDz ţƘŝ ÇƘƆƘŽɗ ŴȲDzȓĀǪ ţƆ . ŴŴĀǎ uţĀ DzţÇŗ .ĀǪDzȓĀŴŴȲƆŅ ȲƆé <ƘƆDzȲŽ ţƆ éĀƆ ŲƘŽŝ ŽĀƆéĀƆ ɡĀŗƆ : ŗǪĀƆ ɑĀǪ ƆéĀǪƆ ɓĀǪŝ éĀƆá é ɑƘƆ ¥ĀDzţȓɡȓ éĀǪDĀȓɡɓĀǪŲĀǪ ĀţƆĀ ɡţĀŽŴţÇŗ ŲƘƆŲǪĀȓĀ sƘǪDzȓĀŴŴȲƆŅǎ ĀǪ 0ƆéȲDzȓǪţĀ DzȓĀŗĀ ĀţƆĀ ŅǪ ɑţĀǪĀƆéĀ ]ţÇŗȓȲƆŅDz ƆéĀǪȲƆŅ ¥ĀɑƘǪǎ ǣ ƆŅĀ¥Ƙȓ ȲƆé D ÇŗģǪ ŅĀ ɓĀǪéĀƆ DzţÇŗ éǪ Ž ŝ ȓţDzÇŗ ɓ ƆéĀŴƆǎǤ ţĀDzĀ ĀţDzƼţĀŴĀ ŅĀ¥ĀƆ ĀţƆĀƆ ȲDzŝ ¥ŴţÇŲǎ ǪDzȓĀƆDzÜ >ƟɓĀƆɡ ŗƆŝBţŴÇŗ ŲƟƆƆȓĀ ȧɥȧǹ ĀţƆĀ ɓţÇŗȓţŅĀ Ȳȓ ȓ ģȸǪ ,ȲŽŽţŽţDzÇŗȲƆŅĀƆ DzĀţƆá ȲDz éĀƆĀƆ uţƆȓĀǪǪĀţģĀƆ ŅĀŽ Çŗȓ ɓĀǪéĀƆǎ ɓĀţŝ ȓĀƆDzÜ ţƆ ,ǪȲƆéDzȓƘĥ ģȸǪ YŴ DzȓţŲĩ ŝ DzÇŗĀƆá éĀǪ DzţÇŗ ȲDz ȲÇŲĀǪǪƘŗǪ ŅĀɓţƆƆĀƆ Ŵ DzDzȓ ŝ ȲÇŗ é Dz ţDzȓ ĀţƆĀ ɓ ŗǪDzÇŗĀţƆŴţÇŗĀ YĀǪDzƼĀŲȓţɑĀǎ Ǫţȓŝ ȓĀƆDzÜ ŲȓĀǪţĀƆ ĀǪɡĀȲŅĀƆ ţƆ ]Ā ŲȓƘǪĀƆ ĀţƆ B ȓĀǪţ Ŵá é Dz éĀǪ `ƼţƆƆĀƆDzĀţéĀ ŅŴĀţÇŗȓ ȲƆé ģȸǪ ĀɕȓǪĀŽ Dzȓ ¥ţŴĀ `ĀţŴĀ ƘéĀǪ ȲŴȓǪ ŴĀţÇŗȓĀ `ÇŗȲȓɡɓĀDzȓĀƆ ŅĀĀţŅƆĀȓ ţDzȓǎ
ţƆŽ ŴţŅ ţDzȓá ɓ Dz é Dz > Ɔé DzĀŴ¥Dzȓ ɡȲŽ ɓĀŴȓɓĀţȓĀƆ u ƆéĀŴ éĀǪ .ƘŴɡƆȲȓŝ ɡȲƆŅ ¥ĀţȓǪ ŅĀƆ Ų ƆƆǎ ĭɥ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŝ ŽĀƆ DzƘɓţĀ *ƘǪDzÇŗȲƆŅDzŝ ȲƆé ƆȓɓţÇŲŝ ŴȲƆŅDzĀţƆǪţÇŗȓȲƆŅĀƆ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀƆ é Ǫ Ɔǎ ƨȂ ŅĀŽĀţƆDz ŽĀ ȲƆé ĭƨ dĀţŴƼǪƘŰĀŲȓĀ ɡţĀŴĀƆ Ȳģ ŗƘÇŗɓĀǪȓţŅĀ YǪƘéȲŲȓĀ ȲDz éĀŽ Ɔ Çŗɓ ÇŗDzĀƆéĀƆ ]ƘŗDzȓƘĥǎ uĀţŝ ȓĀǪĀ ļɥ sƘǪŗ ¥ĀƆ DzţƆé ţƆ éĀǪ YţƼĀŴţƆĀǎ 0ƆDzŅĀDz Žȓ DzţƆé ǹȂ Y ǪȓƆĀǪ ĀţƆ¥ĀɡƘŝ ŅĀƆá é ǪȲƆȓĀǪ iƆţɑĀǪDzţȓ ȓĀƆ ţƆ . ŴŴĀá ,ƟȓȓţƆŅĀƆá ǪĀDzéĀƆ DzƘɓţĀ é Dz .ĀŴŽŝ ŗƘŴȓɡŝ ĀƆȓǪȲŽ ģȸǪ iŽɓĀŴȓģƘǪDzÇŗȲƆŅ >ĀţƼɡţŅ ȲƆé éţĀ *Ǫ ȲƆŗƘģĀǪŝ,ĀDzĀŴŴŝ DzÇŗ ģȓǎ DţǪŅĀƆéɓƘ ţƆ ȲǪƘƼ Ņţ¥ȓ ĀDz ĀţƆĀƆ éţÇŗȓĀǪĀƆ sĀǪ¥ȲƆé Ɔ YţŴƘȓŝá ĀŽƘƆDzȓǪ ȓţƘƆDzŝ ȲƆé YǪƘéȲŲȓţƘƆDz Ɔŝ Ŵ ŅĀƆǎ ţĀ < DzŲ éĀ ǪĀţÇŗȓ ɑƘŽ .ƘŴɡŝ ĀţƆDzÇŗŴ Ņ ȸ¥ĀǪ éţĀ ` ŅĀɓĀǪŲDzȓĀÇŗƆţŲ ¥ţDz ɡȲ .ƘŴɡ¥ Ȳ ȲƆé ŗĀŽţĀá DzȓĀȓDz ŅĀŝ ȓǪţĀ¥ĀƆ ɑƘƆ ĀţƆŗĀţŽţDzÇŗĀǪ *ƘǪDzÇŗȲƆŅ ȲƆé ƆȓɓţÇŲŴȲƆŅǎ
0DWWKLDV =VFKHLOH &OXVWHU 0DQDJHU
, , .,1. " .) ĀDzƘƆéĀǪDz ɓĀţȓ ŅĀéţĀŗĀƆ DzţƆé éţĀ ƆȓɓţÇŲŴȲƆŅ ɡȲǪ ţƆȓĀŴŴţŅĀƆȓĀƆ DȲȓŝ ɡȲƆŅ ɑƘƆ ȲÇŗĀƆŗƘŴɡǎ ȲŽ sĀǪ¥ǪĀƆŝ ƆĀƆ ţŽ < ŽţƆ ţDzȓ ĀDz ɑţĀŴ ɡȲ DzÇŗ éĀǎ ĀǪ ţƆDz ȓɡ ŴDz ţDzĀƆ¥ ŗƆDzÇŗɓĀŴŴĀƆá BƟ¥ĀŴŗƘŴɡ ƘéĀǪ Y ǪŲĀȓȓ ŅţŴȓ ŴDz ȲDzŝ Ŵ ȲģŽƘéĀŴŴ ƘéĀǪ ɓĀƆţŅ ƼǪƘĨȓ ¥ŴĀ Dţŝ DzÇŗĀǎ ŗĀŽţDzÇŗĀ YǪƘɡĀDzDzĀ é ŅĀŅĀƆ ŲƟƆƆĀƆ é Ǫ ȲDz sĀǪ¥ȲƆéɓĀǪŲDzȓƘĥĀ ȲƆé ȲȓĀţŴĀ ĀǪɡĀȲŅĀƆá ȲÇŗ <ȲƆDzȓŝ ģ DzĀǪƆ ȲƆé ÇŗĀŽţDzÇŗĀ DzţDzDzȓƘĥĀǎ
`i` DD ` .i>
D, D
Dz Ƽ DzDzţĀǪȓ ¥ţDzŗĀǪ ɑƘǪ ŴŴĀŽ ţƆ > ŝ ¥ƘǪĀƆǎ ǣDȲƆ ŅĀŗȓ ĀDz ĀƆéŴţÇŗ é ǪȲŽá ɓţĀ ĨƆéĀƆ ɓţǪ éĀƆ uĀŅ ţƆ éţĀ ŅǪƘňŝ ȓĀÇŗƆţDzÇŗĀ YǪ ɕţDzǤá Dz Ņȓ YǪƘģǎ DzÇŗĀţŝ ŴĀǎ Dz YƘȓĀƆɡţ Ŵ ŰĀéĀƆģ ŴŴDz DzĀţ ǪţĀDzţŅ ȲƆé ŴţĀŅĀ ƼǪ ŲȓţDzÇŗ ɑƘǪ éĀǪ . ȲDzȓȸǪǎ ǣȘɥ YǪƘɡĀƆȓ éĀǪ éĀȲȓDzÇŗĀƆ ȲÇŗĀƆŝ ɓ ŴéĀǪ DzţƆé ţŽ . Ǫɡá ɑƘǪ ŴŴĀŽ ǪȲƆé ȲŽ ]ƘȓȓŴĀ¥ĀǪƘéĀǎǤ ţĀDzĀǪ ]ƘŗDzȓƘĥŝ`Çŗ ȓɡ ŗĀ¥ȓ DzţÇŗ ŴŴĀǪéţƆŅDz ƆţÇŗȓ ɑƘƆ ŴŴĀţƆǎ ȲĀǪDzȓ ŽȲDzDz ŽţƆéĀDzȓĀƆDz ĀţƆ ĨƆ ƆɡDzȓ ǪŲĀǪ 0Ɔŝ ɑĀDzȓƘǪ ŅĀɓƘƆƆĀƆ ɓĀǪéĀƆǎ Dz ɑĀǪŴ Ɔŝ ŅĀ ŗ ǪȓĀ o¥ĀǪɡĀȲŅȲƆŅDz Ǫ¥Āţȓá ģ DzDzȓ DzÇŗĀţŴĀ DzĀţƆĀ ¥ţDzŗĀǪţŅĀƆ Ǫģ ŗǪȲƆŝ ŅĀƆ ɡȲDz ŽŽĀƆǎ B ƆÇŗĀDz ,ǪƘňȲƆȓĀǪŝ ƆĀŗŽĀƆ ɑĀǪŗ ŴȓĀ DzţÇŗ ƆƘÇŗ ¥ɓ Ǫŝ ȓĀƆéǎ Dz DzĀţ ȓĀţŴɓĀţDzĀ DzƘŅ Ǫ ɑĀǪDzȓ Ɔéŝ ŴţÇŗǎ `ÇŗŴţĀňŴţÇŗ ŲƘDzȓĀȓĀƆ éţĀ ĀǪģƘǪéĀǪŝ ŴţÇŗĀƆ ƆŴ ŅĀƆ ĀţƆĀ BĀƆŅĀ Ɔ ,ĀŴéǎ ƆéĀǪĀǪDzĀţȓDz ŅĀ¥Ā ĀDz ŅĀǪ éĀ ţƆ ` Çŗŝ DzĀƆŝ Ɔŗ Ŵȓ ȲÇŗ éţĀ ¥ĀƆƟȓţŅȓĀƆ * Çŗŝ ŲǪ ģȓĀǎ iƆé éţĀ Ǫ ƆÇŗĀƆ .ƘŴɡá ŗĀŝ ŽţĀ ȲƆé <ȲƆDzȓDzȓƘĥĀ ¥ţŴéĀȓĀƆ ţƆ éĀǪ ]ĀŅţƘƆ ¥ĀǪĀţȓDz ĀţƆ DĀȓɡǎ ŴDz uţDzDzĀƆDzÇŗ ģȓŴĀǪ DzţƆé B ȓȓŗţ Dz DzÇŗĀţŴĀ éţĀ ɑƘǪŗ ƆéĀƆĀƆ ȓĀÇŗŝ ƆţDzÇŗĀƆ BƟŅŴţÇŗŲĀţȓĀƆ ŅĀŴ ȲĨŅǎ `Ƙ ţDzȓ ĀDz ţŗŽ ɡȲģƘŴŅĀ Ŵ ƆŅDzȓ ƼǪ ŲȓţŲ ¥ĀŴá Ɔ Çŗ ŗĀǪŲƟŽŽŴţÇŗĀƆ Y Ǫ ŽĀȓĀǪƆ ŽţƆéĀǪɓĀǪȓţŅĀDz <ǪƘƆĀƆŗƘŴɡ DzƘ Ȳģŝ ɡȲDzƼ ŴȓĀƆ ȲƆé ȲŽɡȲɓ ƆéĀŴƆá é DzDz Ž ƆéĀ éĀDz YǪƘɡĀDzDzĀDz ĀţƆĀ <ȲƆDzȓŝ ģ DzĀǪ Žţȓ ¥ĀDzȓĀƆ B ȓĀǪţ ŴĀţŅĀƆDzÇŗ ģŝ ȓĀƆ ŗĀǪ ȲDzŲƘŽŽȓǎ
# ( - ) 2/ ( - '
ǪDzȓĀ o¥ĀǪŴĀŅȲƆŅĀƆ é ɡȲ Dzȓ Žŝ ŽĀƆ Ɔ Çŗ éĀƆ uƘǪȓĀƆ ɑƘƆ DzÇŗĀţŴĀ ¥ĀǪĀţȓDz ȲDz éĀƆ ƨƉȘɥĀǪ : ŗǪĀƆǎ 0Ɔɡɓţŝ DzÇŗĀƆ DzĀţĀƆ éţĀ sĀǪģ ŗǪĀƆá ¥ĀţDzƼţĀŴDzŝ ɓĀţDzĀ `ƼƘǪȓ¥ĀŲŴĀţéȲƆŅ ȲDz .ƘŴɡģ ŝ DzĀǪƆ ɡȲ ģĀǪȓţŅĀƆá ɓĀţȓĀDzȓŅĀŗĀƆé ƼĀǪŝ ģĀŲȓţƘƆţĀǪȓǎ ǣ,ĀŽĀţƆDz Ž Žţȓ ĀţƆĀŽ 0ƆéȲDzȓǪţĀŝ Ƽ ǪȓƆĀǪ ţDzȓ é Dz DzȸéŴţÇŗĀ ` ÇŗDzĀƆŝ Ɔŝ ŗ Ŵȓ éĀǪ dƘƼŝ`ȓ ƆéƘǪȓ ģȸǪ ĀţƆĀƆ ŲȸƆģȓţŝ ŅĀƆ uĀŴȓŽ ǪŲȓģȸŗǪĀǪǎǤ ţĀDzĀ 0éĀĀ ȓǪ Ņȓ é Dz ŴȲDzȓĀǪŝB Ɔ ŅĀŽĀƆȓ ŗţƆ ȲDz ţƆ éţĀ uĀŴȓá ɡȲŴĀȓɡȓ Ȳģ ĀţƆĀǪ BĀDzDzĀ Ž `ţȓɡ éĀǪ ȲǪƘƼ ţDzÇŗĀƆ iƆţƘƆ ţƆ ǪȸDzŝ DzĀŴǎ `Ƙ DzȓĀŗĀ Ž Ɔ ţŽ <ƘƆȓ Ųȓ Žţȓ iƆŝ ȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ţƆ éĀƆ i` ȲƆé ţƆ `Ų Ɔéţŝ Ɔ ɑţĀƆǎ DĀȲ ţŽ ƘƘȓÜ éţĀ 0ƆɑĀDzȓţȓţƘƆDzŝ ȲƆé B ǪŲĀȓţƆŅŅĀDzĀŴŴDzÇŗ ģȓ éĀDz > ƆéĀDz ` ÇŗDzĀƆŝ Ɔŗ Ŵȓá éţĀ ģȸŗǪĀƆé ¥Āţ ţƆéȲŝ DzȓǪţĀŴŴĀƆ DĀȲ ƆDzţĀéŴȲƆŅĀƆ ţDzȓǎ
$') ) '" ' ' ,, D Çŗ ĀţƆţŅĀƆ : ŗǪĀƆ Ų ŽĀƆ éţĀ ĀǪDzȓĀƆ ,ǪƘň ȲģȓǪ ŅĀ ȲƆé ȧɥɥČ DzÇŗŴţĀňŴţÇŗ éĀǪ ƟǪDzĀƆŅ ƆŅǎ Dz DzĀţ éĀǪ ŅǪƟňȓĀ ȲƆé ĀƆȓDzÇŗĀţéĀƆéĀ ǪģƘŴŅ ŅĀɓĀDzĀƆá DzƘ ŗ ȓ ĀDz ,Ŵ ň ĀţƆŽ Ŵ ģƘǪŽȲŴţĀǪȓÜ ǣ ţƆĀ ȲDzŅĀɡĀţÇŗƆĀȓĀ ƆȓDzÇŗĀţéȲƆŅ ȲƆé éĀǪ `ȓ ǪȓƼȲƆŲȓ ĀţƆĀǪ ţƆȓĀƆDzţɑĀƆŝ u ÇŗDzȓȲŽDzƼŗ DzĀǎǤ ţĀ DzÇŗĀţƆȓ Ɔ Çŗŝ ɓţĀ ɑƘǪ ƆɡȲŗ ŴȓĀƆǎ 0Ž ɑƘǪţŅĀƆ : ŗǪ ŲƘƆƆȓĀ sƘǪDzȓ ƆéDzÇŗĀģ ,Ŵ ň ĀţƆĀƆ ]Āŝ ŲƘǪéȲŽDz ȓɡ ɑƘƆ ǹǹ BţŴŴţƘƆĀƆ ȲǪƘŝ ɑĀǪ¥ȲÇŗĀƆǎ iƆé é Dz Ɔ ÇŗDzȓĀ ,ǪƘňɑƘǪŝ ŗ ¥ĀƆ DzȓĀŗȓ ¥ĀǪĀţȓDz ţƆ éĀƆ `ȓ ǪȓŴƟŝ ÇŗĀǪƆǎ 0Ž ƆĀȲĀƆ ,< ŽƼȲDz DzƘŴŴĀƆ `ÇŗȲŴȲƆŅDzǪ ȲŽĀá ĀȓǪţĀ¥DzŲţƆéĀǪŅ Ǫŝ ȓĀƆ ȲƆé ĀţƆ ]ĀDzȓ ȲǪ Ɔȓ YŴ ȓɡ ĨƆéĀƆǎ
, ' , B ȓȓŗţ Dz DzÇŗĀţŴĀ éǪţƆŅȓ Ȳģ dĀŽƼƘÜ ǣY ŲĀȓĀ DzÇŗƆȸǪĀƆá éţĀ ţŽ uĀȓȓ¥ĀɓĀǪ¥ ȲŽ éţĀ 0ƆɑĀDzȓƘǪĀƆ ȸ¥ĀǪɡĀȲŅĀƆ ŲƟƆŝ ƆĀƆá é Dz ţDzȓ é Dz ,Ā¥Ƙȓ éĀǪ `ȓȲƆéĀǎǤ B ǪŲȓDzȓǪ ȓĀŅţĀƆá éţĀ éĀǪ ŴȲDzȓĀǪ ĀƆȓŝ ɓţÇŲĀŴȓá éȸǪģȓĀƆ ƆţÇŗȓ ţƆ `ÇŗȲ¥Ŵ éĀƆ ɑĀǪDzÇŗɓţƆéĀƆǎ `ȓƟǪĀƆéĀDzá é Dz 0ƆɑĀDzȓţŝ ȓţƘƆĀƆ ĀǪDzÇŗɓĀǪĀá ŽȸDzDzĀ ɡȲéĀŽ ɡĀţȓŝ Ɔ ŗ ¥ĀDzĀţȓţŅȓ ɓĀǪéĀƆǎ ɡȲ ŅĀŗƟǪĀ ȲÇŗ dǪĀƆƆĀƆéĀDz ɡɓţDzÇŗĀƆ . ŴŴĀ ȲƆé >ĀţƼɡţŅá Āȓɓ ȲƆȓĀǪDzÇŗţĀéŴţÇŗĀ ,Āŝ ƆĀŗŽţŅȲƆŅDz ¥Ŵ ȲģĀ ƘéĀǪ ƆţÇŗȓ Ƽ DzDzģ ŝ ŗţŅĀ *ƟǪéĀǪǪţÇŗȓŴţƆţĀƆǎ
.]0`d0 D ` .i ]d
5DLQHU *O¥ 9RUVWDQGVFKHI GHU *. 6RIWZDUH $*
) -2 #( )) ) ( -)/ ( ( - )# ( '
111& (( ( &
. & 0 ( .3"* 3 &33 " &33 ( . & 0 ( .3"* "3&33 "+&33 ( ) / -/( $ )) ( % () ! # -2 " 3 (
% (LQH $Q]HLJHQÓ6RQGHUYHU¶IIHQWOLFKXQJ GHU %HUOLQHU =HLWXQJ w 1RYHPEHU (LQH $Q]HLJHQÓ6RQGHUYHU¶IIHQWOLFKXQJ GHU %HUOLQHU =HLWXQJ w 1RYHPEHU % * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ** * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
:LUWVFKDIW
:LUWVFKDIW
EHU *UHQ]HQ KLQZHJ
*ROGZHUWH .RQWDNWH
Ú)RRG $FDGHP\Ø QHQQW VLFK HLQ 1HW]ZHUN GDV VLFK DXI GLH 6XFKH QDFK )DFKNU¤IWHQ LQ GHU /HEHQVPLWWHOLQGXVWULH PDFKW
'DV 0DJGHEXUJHU 8QWHUQHKPHQ 5HJLRFRP KDW VLFK ]X HLQHP JUR HQ 'LHQVWOHLVWHU HQWZLFNHOW XQG I¼KUW $EUHFKQXQJHQ I¼U )LUPHQ DOOHU $UW DXV ɡĀDz ģȸǪ éţĀ *ƟǪéĀǪȲƆŅ DzƘŅĀƆ ƆƆȓĀǪ <Ǫ ģȓŝu ǪŽĀŝ<ƘƼƼŴȲƆŅDzŝ ƆŴ ŅĀƆ ƿ<u<Dž ƼŴ ƆȓĀá DzÇŗţÇŲȓĀ éĀǪ B ŅéĀŝ ¥ȲǪŅĀǪ ƆĀǪŅţĀéţĀƆDzȓŴĀţDzȓĀǪ ,ĀȓĀÇ DzĀţƆĀ * ÇŗŴĀȲȓĀ ţƆ éţĀ `ƼȲǪǎ Dz ĀŴŴŝ DzȓƘĥɓĀǪŲ `ȓĀƆé Ŵ ĀǪǪ ƆŅ ¥Āţ éĀǪ DƘŝ ɑĀŴŴĀ éĀDz ǪƆĀȲĀǪ¥ ǪĀŝ ƆĀǪŅţĀƆŝ,Āŝ DzĀȓɡĀDz ƿ ,Dž ĀţƆĀ `ƘƆéĀǪǪĀŅĀŴȲƆŅá éţĀ éĀŽ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ŽĀŗǪĀǪĀ BţŴŝ ŴţƘƆĀƆ ȲǪƘ Ű ŗǪŴţÇŗ DzƼ Ǫȓǎ ]ĀŅţƘŝ ÇƘŽŝ ŗĀģ ,ȲȓŽ ƆƆ ĀǪŲŴ ǪȓÜ ǣ ĀǪŴţƆ Ŵ Ȳģȓ Ɔ Çŗ ĀţƆĀŽ ƆéĀǪĀƆ BĀÇŗ ƆţDzŝ ŽȲDz ¥ǎ sţĀŴĀ * ÇŗŴĀȲȓĀ DzţƆé Ņ Ɔɡ Ɔ ŗ Ɔ éĀƆ ƼƘŴţȓţDzÇŗĀƆ ƆȓDzÇŗĀţŝ éȲƆŅDzȓǪ ŅĀǪƆ éǪ ƆǎǤ Āţ éĀǪ Ǫ¥Āţȓ Ɔ ƆĀȲĀƆ ,ĀDzĀȓɡĀƆ ƆȲȓɡĀƆ ¥ĀǪ ȲÇŗ éţĀ Bţȓ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀǪ ţƆ éĀƆ BţƆţDzȓĀǪţĀƆ éţĀ <ƘƆȓ ŲȓĀ ɡȲ sĀǪŝ ¥Ǫ ȲÇŗĀǪŝ ȲƆé iŽɓĀŴȓDzÇŗȸȓɡĀǪƆá
(& -& - $ 2 4 -
<
ŴĀŽĀƆDz ,ȲȓŽ ƆƆ ţDzȓ ,ĀDzÇŗ ģȓDzŝ ģȸŗǪĀǪ ȲƆé ,ǪȸƆéĀǪ ɑƘƆ ]ĀŅţƘŝ ÇƘŽá ĀţƆĀŽ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆá é Dz ģȸǪ ƆéĀǪĀ *ţǪŽĀƆ ¥ǪĀÇŗƆȲƆŅDzéţĀƆDzȓŝ ŴĀţDzȓȲƆŅĀƆ Ɔ¥ţĀȓĀȓǎ ,ĀŽĀţƆDz Ž Žţȓ DzĀţƆĀƆ ,ĀDzÇŗ ģȓDzƼ ǪȓƆĀǪƆ ¥ĀDzȓţŽŽȓ ĀǪá ɓĀŴÇŗĀ ]ţÇŗȓȲƆŅ DzĀţƆ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŝ ŽĀƆ ĀţƆDzÇŗŴ Ņȓ ȲƆé ɓĀŴÇŗĀ ȲģȓǪ ŅĀ éţĀ ŽĀŗǪ ŴDz ĭ ɥɥɥ Bţȓ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀǪ ţƆ Ɔ Çŗŝ DzȓĀǪ Āţȓ ¥Ā Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀƆǎ ĀǪ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀǪ ţDzȓ ĀţƆ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŝ ŲĀǪǎ Ǫ Dz ŅȓÜ ǣBĀţƆ ŅǪƘňĀDz DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲ ţDzȓ éĀǪ ,ǪȲƆéDzȓĀţƆ ģȸǪ ȲƆDzĀǪ ĀǪģƘŴŅǪĀţŝ ÇŗĀDz ,ĀDzÇŗ ģȓǎǤ ĀǪ *ţǪŽĀƆDzţȓɡ ɑƘƆ ]ĀŅţƘÇƘŽ ţDzȓ éţĀ ĀŗĀŽ ŴţŅĀ ĀƆȓǪ ŴĀ éĀDz ģǪȸŗĀǪĀƆ B DzÇŗţƆĀƆ¥ Ȳŝ<ƘŽ¥ţŝ Ɔ ȓDz `ŲĀȓǎ ,ȲȓŽ ƆƆDz *ţǪŽ ŗ ȓ é Dz ,Ā¥ ȲéĀ ŴţĀ¥ĀɑƘŴŴ Dz ƆţĀǪĀƆ Ŵ DzDzĀƆǎ 0Ɔ éţĀ ĀţƆDzȓţŅĀ ]ȲţƆĀ ţDzȓ é Dz >Ā¥ĀƆ ɡȲŝ ǪȸÇŲŅĀŲĀŗǪȓǎ ]ĀŅţƘÇƘŽ ţDzȓ DzĀţȓ : ŗǪĀƆ Ȳģ u ÇŗDzȓȲŽDzŲȲǪDzǎ
,# # 1 777 . 1 1 %
B y < Y H . >
3L]]DSURGXNWLRQ EHL 'U 2HWNHU LQ :LWWHQEXUJ HLQHP GHU JU· WHP $UEHLWJHEHU LP 1RUGHQ 'DV 8QWHUQHKPHQ JHK·UW ]X GHQ *U½QGXQJVPLWJOLHGHUQ GHU 0HFNOHQEXUJHU Ü)RRG $FDGHP\Û
(& 5 ( "
Ȳģ éĀŽ ģ Dzȓ ŴĀĀǪ ŅĀģĀŅȓĀƆ Ǫ¥ĀţȓDzŝ Ž ǪŲȓ ţƆ uĀDzȓŽĀÇŲŴĀƆ¥ȲǪŅ DzţƆé DzţĀ ƆƘǪŽ ŴĀǪɓĀţDzĀ ĀǪ¥ţȓȓĀǪȓĀ <ƘƆŲȲǪŝ ǪĀƆȓĀƆǎ Āţ éĀǪ `ȲÇŗĀ Ɔ Çŗ >ĀŗǪŴţƆŅĀƆ DzƘɓţĀDzƘǎ iƆé éĀƆƆƘÇŗ DzƼǪ ƆŅĀƆ ɑƘǪ ŽĀŗǪ ŴDz éǪĀţ : ŗǪĀƆ ĀţƆţŅĀ ŅǪƘňĀ *ţǪŝ ŽĀƆ éĀǪ ǪƆ ŗǪȲƆŅDzţƆéȲDzȓǪţĀ ȸ¥ĀǪ ţŗǪĀƆ `Çŗ ȓȓĀƆ ȲƆé ŅǪȸƆéĀȓĀƆ éĀƆ sĀǪĀţƆ Žţȓ éĀŽ ţƆȓĀǪƆ ȓţƘƆ Ŵ ŲŴţƆŅĀƆŝ éĀƆ D ŽĀƆ ǣ*ƘƘé Ç éĀŽɗǤǎ Ņ Ŵ Ƙ¥ `ɓĀĀȓ dĀÇ ţƆ ƘţɡĀƆ¥ȲǪŅá ]ţŗ ŝuĀDzĀǪŅƘŴé ţƆ ƘéƘɓá DĀDzȓŴă ţƆ `ÇŗɓĀǪţƆ ƘéĀǪ Ǫǎ HĀȓŲĀǪ Žţȓ DzĀţƆĀŽ Yţɡɡ ɓĀǪŲ ţƆ uţȓȓĀƆ¥ȲǪŅá DzţĀ ŴŴĀ ŗ ¥ĀƆ ɡȲƆĀŗŽĀƆé YǪƘ¥ŴĀŽĀá * ÇŗŲǪ ģȓĀ ɡȲ ĨƆéĀƆǎ `ȓ ȓȓ ɓĀţȓĀǪ ŴŴĀţƆĀ ŅĀŅĀƆ éţĀ BţDzĀǪĀ ƆɡȲŲ ŽƼģĀƆá DzƘŴŴȓĀ ĀţƆ DĀȓɡŝ
ɓĀǪŲ ţƆ *ƘǪŽ ĀţƆĀDz sĀǪĀţƆDz ŗĀǪá éĀǪ ɑţĀŝ ŴĀDz ŲƘƘǪéţƆţĀǪȓ ȲƆé éĀƆ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ţƆ ` ÇŗĀƆ uĀǪ¥ȲƆŅá ¥ĀǪ ȲÇŗ ¥Āţ éĀǪ [Ȳ ŴţĨɡţĀǪȲƆŅ ȲƆé uĀţȓĀǪ¥ţŴéȲƆŅ éĀǪ ĀţŅĀƆĀƆ Bţȓ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀǪ ĀţƆţŅĀDz ¥ƆţŽŽȓǎ 1 , 3, 3. ## % , 1 ǣuţǪ ŽȸDzDzĀƆ ȲƆDz ţƆ éĀǪ ]ĀŅţƘƆ ƆţÇŗȓ ȲƆƆƟȓţŅ <ƘƆŲȲǪǪĀƆɡ Ž ÇŗĀƆǤ ŗ ȓ HŴţŝ ɑĀǪ `ÇŗţƆéŴĀǪá sƘǪDzȓ ƆéDzɑƘǪDzţȓɡĀƆéĀǪ éĀDz sĀǪĀţƆDz ȲƆé ŗĀģ éĀǪ ƘƆ¥ƘƆŗĀǪŝ DzȓĀŴŴĀǪ `ɓĀĀȓ dĀÇ ȲƆé dƘĥĀĀ dĀÇ ţŽŽĀǪ ɓţĀéĀǪ ¥ĀȓƘƆȓǎ *ȸƆģ ŅǪƘňĀ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŝ ŽĀƆ ŗ ȓȓĀƆ ȧɥƨļá ĩ ƆŲţĀǪȓ ɑƘƆ ĀǪȲģDzŝ DzÇŗȲŴĀƆ ȲƆé éĀǪ ĀƆŅ ŅţĀǪȓĀƆ uţǪȓŝ DzÇŗ ģȓDzģƟǪéĀǪȲƆŅ éĀDz <ǪĀţDzĀDzá Žţȓ éĀŽ sĀǪĀţƆ ĀţƆĀƆ `ÇŗǪţȓȓ Ɔ Çŗ ɑƘǪƆ ŅĀŝ Ž Çŗȓǎ Dz > Ɔé BĀÇŲŴĀƆ¥ȲǪŅŝsƘǪŝ ƼƘŽŽĀǪƆ ģ Ɔé éţĀ 0éĀĀ ŗĀǪɑƘǪǪ ŅĀƆé
ȲƆé ģƟǪéĀǪȓ éĀƆ sĀǪĀţƆ ɑƘƆ éĀǪ ,ǪȸƆŝ ɓȸǪéĀǎ ƘÇŗ éţĀ ǣ*ƘƘé Ç éĀŽɗǤ éȲƆŅ ¥ţDz ŗĀȲȓĀ ¥Āţ éĀƆ YĀǪDzƘƆ ŴŲƘDzȓĀƆǎ Ų Ž ţƆ , ƆŅǎ Āţ éĀǪ DĀȲ ƆDzţĀéŝ D Çŗ éĀǪ ȲƼŗƘǪţĀ éĀǪ ŴȲƆŅ ȲƆé éĀƆ 0ƆɑĀDzȓţŝ ,ǪȸƆéȲƆŅ ŗĀǪǪDzÇŗȓĀ éĀƆƆƘÇŗ ĀǪDzȓ ĀţƆŽ Ŵ ȓţƘƆĀƆ Ɔ Çŗ éĀǪ uĀƆéĀ ĀţƆĀ uĀţŴĀ ]ȲŗĀǎ ǣuţǪ ŗ ȓȓĀƆ ɑţĀŴĀ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŝ
ŽȲDzDzȓĀƆ ɑţĀŴ ɑƘǪ¥ĀǪĀţŝ ŽĀƆ éĀǪ Ɔ Çŗ iŽDz ȓɡ ţƆɡɓţDzÇŗĀƆ ɓţÇŗȓţŅDzȓĀƆ ȓĀƆá éţĀ Ǫ¥Āţȓ ƼǪ ɡţDzţĀŝ Ǫ ƆÇŗĀ éĀǪ ]ĀŅţƘƆ ǪĀƆ ȲƆé o¥ĀǪɡĀȲŅȲƆŅDzŝ iƆŅĀŴĀǪƆȓĀ ȲƆé [ȲĀǪŝ Ǫ¥Āţȓ ŴĀţDzȓĀƆǤá ĀǪŲŴ ǪȓĀ ĀţƆDzȓĀţŅĀǪ ĀţƆŅĀDzȓĀŴŴȓǎ < ȓŗǪţƆ iŽ¥Ŵţ á éţĀ ¥ţDz 2OLYHU 6FKLQGOHU ŗĀȲȓĀ ĀţƆɡţŅĀ *ĀDzȓ ƆŅĀŝ ţĀ ¥Ǫ ȲÇŗȓĀƆ ¥ŝ 9RUVWDQGVYRUVLW]HQGHU DzÇŗŴȸDzDzĀ ȲƆé é Žţȓ DzȓĀŴŴȓĀ éĀDz sĀǪĀţƆDzá éţĀ YĀǪDzƼĀŲȓţɑĀƆ ţƆ éĀƆ é Ž ŴţŅĀ > ŅĀǎ ĀƆƆ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆǎ iƆé DzƘ Ŵ ƆŅDzȓ ƆţÇŗȓ ŴŴĀ *ţǪŽĀƆ éĀǪ Ǫ ƆÇŗĀ ɓ ǪĀƆ ȸ¥ĀǪɡĀȲŅȓá é DzDz ŲȸŽŽĀǪȓ DzţÇŗ éţĀ Ų éĀŽţĀ ȲŽ ¥Āŝ éţĀDzĀǪ sƘǪDzȓƘňá éĀǪ ģȸǪ éţĀ BţȓŅŴţĀéĀǪ ǪȲģDz¥ĀŅŴĀţȓĀƆéĀ >ĀŗǪŅ ƆŅĀ ģȸǪ B DzÇŗţŝ DzÇŗŴţĀňŴţÇŗ Žţȓ ,ĀŴé ȲDzŅ ¥ĀƆ ɑĀǪ¥ȲƆŝ ƆĀƆŝ ȲƆé ƆŴ ŅĀƆģȸŗǪĀǪ ƘéĀǪ * ÇŗŲǪ ģŝ éĀƆ ɓ Ǫá ȸ¥ĀǪŗ ȲƼȓ Āȓɓ Dz ¥ǪţƆŅĀƆ ȓĀ ģȸǪ >Ā¥ĀƆDzŽţȓȓĀŴȓĀÇŗƆţŲǎ Dz Ņ ¥
0$&+7ʧ6 (,1)$&+
DzÇŗƘƆ <ȲǪDzĀ ģȸǪ 0ƆéȲDzȓǪţĀŽĀţDzȓĀǪá uĀţŝ ȓĀǪ¥ţŴéȲƆŅĀƆ ţŽ Y]ŝ ĀǪĀţÇŗá ĀDz Ņţ¥ȓ ]Ƙŝ ȓ ȓţƘƆDzȓ ŅĀ ģȸǪ ȲDzɡȲ¥ţŴéĀƆéĀá éţĀ éţĀ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ŲĀƆƆĀƆŴĀǪƆĀƆá ȲƆé ĀţƆţŝ ŅĀDz ŽĀŗǪǎ Dz ŴŴĀDz Žţȓ Y ǪȓƆĀǪƆá éĀǪ 0.< ƘéĀǪ ţŴéȲƆŅDzȓǪ ŅĀǪƆǎ iƆé DzƘ ŴĀŅȓĀ DzţÇŗ é Dz Ɔģ ƆŅŴţÇŗĀ BţDzDzȓǪ ȲĀƆ ȲƆȓĀǪ éĀƆ ƆĀȲĀƆ BţȓDzƼţĀŴĀǪƆǎ )/ 1 ! , % , , % D Çŗ éǪĀţ : ŗǪĀƆ ŗ ȓ é Dz DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲ ƨȂ BţȓŅŴţĀéĀǪá éţĀ Žţȓ ļƨɥɥ Bţȓ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀǪƆ ţŽŽĀǪŗţƆ Șɥ YǪƘɡĀƆȓ éĀǪ Ǫ ƆÇŗĀ ţŽ > Ɔé ǪĀƼǪ DzĀƆȓţĀǪĀƆǎ ɡȲ ŲƘŽŽĀƆ ƆƘÇŗ ĀţƆŽ Ŵ ģȸƆģ *ƟǪéĀǪŽţȓŅŴţĀéĀǪǎ 0Ɔŝ ɡɓţDzÇŗĀƆ Ņţ¥ȓ ĀDz ȲÇŗ BţȓŅŴţĀéDzĨǪŽĀƆ ȲDz sƘǪƼƘŽŽĀǪƆ ƘéĀǪ éĀŽ Ɔ ŗĀƆ Ǫ ƆéĀƆ¥ȲǪŅǎ <ƘƘƼĀǪ ȓţƘƆ ţDzȓ é ŗĀǪ ĀţƆ YȲƆŲȓ éĀǪ ȲDz ŽŽĀƆ Ǫ¥Āţȓá ¥Āţŝ
DzƼţĀŴDzɓĀţDzĀ ¥Āţ éĀǪ uĀǪ¥ȲƆŅ ģȸǪ éţĀ ţƆDzŅĀDz Žȓ ȧĭ ĀǪȲģDzģĀŴéĀǪá éţĀ ĀDz ţƆ éĀƆ BţȓŅŴţĀéDzȲƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ Ņţ¥ȓǎ ţĀ ŽĀţDzȓĀƆ :ȲŅĀƆéŴţÇŗĀƆá DzȓĀŴŴȓĀ Ž Ɔ ģĀDzȓá ŗ ¥ĀƆ Ņ Ǫ ŲĀţƆĀ ŗƆȲƆŅá ɓţĀ ɑţĀŴĀ Āŝ ǪȲģĀ ĀDz ţƆ éĀǪ Ǫ ƆÇŗĀ Ņţ¥ȓǎ ǣuĀǪ ɓĀţň éĀƆƆ DzÇŗƘƆá é DzDz Ž Ɔ ¥Āţ ȲƆDz ȲÇŗ 0ŽŲĀǪ ƘéĀǪ ŗĀŽţĀģ ÇŗŴ ¥ƘǪ Ɔȓ ɓĀǪŝ éĀƆ Ų ƆƆǎǤ ĀǪ sĀǪĀţƆ ţDzȓ Ȳģ ɡ ŗŴǪĀţÇŗĀƆ Āŝ ǪȲģDzŽĀDzDzĀƆ ƼǪ DzĀƆȓ ȲƆé ƘǪŅ ƆţDzţĀǪȓ éĀƆ Ǫģ ŗǪȲƆŅDz ȲDzȓ ȲDzÇŗ ɡɓţDzÇŗĀƆ éĀƆ *ţǪŽĀƆǎ Dz Ņţ¥ȓ Ǫ¥ĀţȓDzŲǪĀţDzĀ ģȸǪ YĀǪDzƘƆ ŴĀƆȓɓţÇŲŴȲƆŅá ģȸǪ éĀƆ Y]ŝ ȲƆé B ǪŲĀȓţƆŅ¥ĀǪĀţÇŗ ƘéĀǪ ģȸǪ ƆĀǪŅţĀá iŽɓĀŴȓ ȲƆé dĀÇŗƆţŲǎ DƘÇŗ Ų ƆƆ éţĀ ǣ Ç éĀŽɗǤ ƆţÇŗȓ Ņ Ɔɡ Ȳģ ĀţŅĀƆĀƆ ĀţƆĀƆ DzȓĀŗĀƆá é Dz DzƘŴŴ ¥ĀǪ ¥ Ŵé ŅĀŝ DzÇŗ ĥȓ ɓĀǪéĀƆǎ
+DQV 3HWHU .HPVHU &KHI GHV %0: :HUNV /HLS]LJ
i>0 >o <
.OHPHQV *XWPDQQ LVW *HVFK¥IWVI½KUHU GHU 5HJLRFRP LQ 0DJGHEXUJ
,ȲȓŽ ƆƆá éĀǪ DzĀţȓ ɑţĀǪ : ŗǪĀƆ ȲÇŗ ģȸǪ éţĀ éĀȲȓDzÇŗĀƆ ƆĀǪŅţĀŽ ǪŲȓŝ éţĀƆDzȓŴĀţDzȓĀǪ DzƼǪţÇŗȓǎ `ƘŴÇŗĀ YƘDzȓĀƆá Dz Ņȓ éĀǪ ]ĀŅţƘÇƘŽŝ ŗĀģá ŗĀŴģĀƆ é ¥Āţá ĀţƆ ţŴé ɡȲ ɡĀţÇŗƆĀƆá é Dz DzţÇŗ ŰĀéĀǪ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀǪ ɓȸƆDzÇŗȓǎ ,ȲȓŽ ƆƆÜ ǣ Dz ţDzȓ ţŽŽĀǪ ŗţŴģǪĀţÇŗá ţƆƆĀǪŗ Ŵ¥ DzĀţƆĀǪ Ǫ ƆÇŗĀ ŴDz DzĀǪţƟDzá ţƆƆƘɑ ȓţɑ ȲƆé ¥Āŝ Dzȓ ƆéţŅ ɓ ŗǪŅĀƆƘŽŽĀƆ ɡȲ ɓĀǪéĀƆǎǤ
'DV +HU] VFKO¤JW I¼U GHQ 0LWWHOVWDQG
,QQRYDWLYH 7HFKQLN YRP 5HQQVWHLJ
'LH %¼UJVFKDIWVEDQN XQWHUVW¼W]W )LUPHQ LQ %UDQGHQEXUJ
3UR]HQW GHU 8PV¤W]H NRPPHQ DXV GHU ,QGXVWULH
*ȸǪ ,ȲȓŽ ƆƆ ŅĀŗȓ ĀDz é ¥Āţ ƆţÇŗȓ ţŽŝ ŽĀǪ ȲŽ ƆĀȲĀ ȲģȓǪ ŅĀǎ Ǫ ƆȲȓɡȓ ŴŴĀ ,ĀŴĀŅĀƆŗĀţȓĀƆá ȲŽ ȲÇŗ uţDzDzĀƆŝ DzÇŗ ģȓŴĀǪƆ ȲƆé .ƘÇŗDzÇŗȲŴŴĀŗǪĀǪƆ ɡȲ DzƼĀÇŗĀƆǎ ƆƆ DzÇŗţĀ¥ȓ ĀǪ YǪƘŰĀŲȓĀ Ɔǎ Ɔ éĀƆ iƆţɑĀǪDzţȓ ȓĀƆ ȲƆé .ƘÇŗDzÇŗȲŝ ŴĀƆ ţŽ > Ɔé ƆȲȓɡȓ ,ȲȓŽ ƆƆ ģ Dzȓ ŰĀéĀ ,ĀŴĀŅĀƆŗĀţȓá ȲŽ DzĀţƆ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ɡȲ ƼǪ DzĀƆȓţĀǪĀƆǎ ]ĀŅţƘÇƘŽ DzƘŴŴ ɑƘƆ
ŰȲƆŅĀƆ Ų éĀŽţŲĀǪƆ ŴDz ȓȓǪ ŲȓţɑĀǪ Ǫ¥ĀţȓŅĀ¥ĀǪ ɓ ŗǪŅĀƆƘŽŽĀƆ ɓĀǪŝ éĀƆǎ ǣ Dz ŅĀŗȓ ȲŽ éţĀ * ÇŗŲǪ ģȓĀ ɑƘƆ ŽƘǪŅĀƆǤá ĀǪŲŴ Ǫȓ ,ȲȓŽ ƆƆǎ *ȸǪ ɑţĀŴĀ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀǪ ţDzȓ éĀǪ <ƘƆȓ Ųȓ ɡȲ uţDzŝ DzĀƆDzÇŗ ģȓŴĀǪƆ ȲÇŗ ģȸǪ é Dz ĀţŅĀƆĀ u ÇŗDzȓȲŽ ɓţÇŗȓţŅǎ 0Ɔ ` ÇŗDzĀƆŝ Ɔŗ Ŵȓ ȲƆé ƆéĀǪĀƆ ƘDzȓéĀȲȓDzÇŗĀƆ ȲƆéĀDzŴ ƆéĀǪƆ DzţƆé éţĀ *ţǪŽĀƆ
ŲŴĀţƆá ƆȲǪ ɓĀƆţŅĀ ĀȓǪţĀ¥Ā ¥ĀDzţȓɡĀƆ éţĀ < Ƽ ɡţȓ ȓĀƆá ȲŽ ƆĀȲĀ YǪƘéȲŲȓĀ ƘéĀǪ sĀǪģ ŗǪĀƆ DzĀŴ¥Dzȓ ɡȲ ĀƆȓɓţÇŲĀŴƆǎ .ţĀǪ ŲƟƆƆĀƆ *ƘǪDzÇŗȲƆŅDzĀţƆǪţÇŗȓȲƆŝ ŅĀƆ ŗĀŴģĀƆ ȲƆé DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲĀ ĀƆȓDzÇŗĀţŝ éĀƆé DzĀţƆǎ sţĀŴĀ *ţǪŽĀƆ ƆȲȓɡĀƆ ɡȲéĀŽ <ƘƆŝ ȓ ŲȓĀ Ɔ Çŗ ĀǪŴţƆÜ ŴDz éţĀ ȲƆéĀDzǪĀŝ ŅţĀǪȲƆŅ ĀţƆĀ DĀȲ Ȳĩ ŅĀ éĀDz ,ĀDzĀȓŝ
B
ţŴƘǵ `ȓĀģ ƆƘɑţÇ ŗ ȓ ģ Dzȓ ȓ ŅŴţÇŗ Žţȓ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀǪƆ éĀǪ ]ĀŅţƘƆ ɡȲ ȓȲƆ ŝ ŗƟǪȓ DzţÇŗ ţŗǪĀ YŴ ƆĀ Ɔ ȲƆé DzȓĀŴŴȓ *Ǫ ŅĀƆá ȲŽ ģĀDzȓɡȲDzȓĀŴŴĀƆá Ƙ¥ DzţĀ Ɔ éĀƆ ǪģƘŴŅ ţŗǪĀǪ ,ĀDzÇŗ ģȓDzţéĀĀ ŅŴ Ȳ¥ĀƆǎ ĀǪ Ȃɥŝ: ŗǪţŅĀ ţDzȓ ,ĀDzÇŗ ģȓDzŝ ģȸŗǪĀǪ éĀǪ ȸǪŅDzÇŗ ģȓDz¥ ƆŲ Ǫ ƆéĀƆŝ ¥ȲǪŅ ,Ž¥.ǎ ţĀ ȸǪŅDzÇŗ ģȓDz¥ ƆŲ Dzţŝ ÇŗĀǪȓ ŅĀɓĀǪ¥ŴţÇŗĀ <ǪĀéţȓĀ ģȸǪ éĀƆ Bţȓŝ ȓĀŴDzȓ Ɔé Žţȓ ¥ţDz ɡȲ Čɥ YǪƘɡĀƆȓ ¥ǎ Bţȓ ţŗǪĀǪ ȲDzģ ŴŴ¥ȸǪŅDzÇŗ ģȓ ƆţŽŽȓ DzţĀ éĀǪ . ȲDz¥ ƆŲ éĀDz <ǪĀéţȓƆĀŗŽĀǪDz ĀţƆţŅĀ > Dzȓ ɑƘƆ éĀƆ `ÇŗȲŴȓĀǪƆ ȲƆé Ž Çŗȓ ţƆ éĀƆ ŽĀţDzȓĀƆ * ŴŴĀƆ éţĀ <ǪĀéţȓɑĀǪŅ ¥Ā ȸ¥ĀǪŗ ȲƼȓ ĀǪDzȓ ŽƟŅŴţÇŗǎ ɓţDzÇŗĀƆ Șɥɥ ȲƆé ļɥɥ ƆĀȲĀ sĀǪȓǪ ŝ ŅĀ DzÇŗŴţĀňȓ éţĀ Ǫ ƆéĀƆ¥ȲǪŅĀǪ ȸǪŅŝ DzÇŗ ģȓDz¥ ƆŲ ţƆ YƘȓDzé Ž ƼǪƘ : ŗǪ ¥ǎ ǹɥ YǪƘɡĀƆȓ éĀǪ * ŴŴĀ ¥ĀŲƘŽŽĀƆ ĀţƆĀ ŗĀģ¥Āŗ ƆéŴȲƆŅ éȲǪÇŗ BţŴƘǵ `ȓĀģ ŝ ƆƘɑţÇ ƘéĀǪ DzĀţƆĀ ,ĀDzÇŗ ģȓDzģȸŗǪĀǪŲƘŴŝ ŴĀŅţƆ , ¥ǪţĀŴĀ <ƟƆȓƘƼƼǎ Ȳ éĀƆ <ȲƆŝ éĀƆ éĀǪ ȸǪŅDzÇŗ ģȓDz¥ ƆŲ ɡ ŗŴĀƆ *ţǪŝ ŽĀƆ éĀǪ ȲƆȓĀǪDzÇŗţĀéŴţÇŗDzȓĀƆ Ǫ Ɔŝ ÇŗĀƆǎ `ȓĀģ ƆƘɑţÇ ĀǪţƆƆĀǪȓ DzţÇŗ ŅĀǪƆ Ɔ DzƘŴÇŗĀ ,ĀDzÇŗţÇŗȓĀƆ ɓţĀ éţĀ éĀǪ `ÇŗƆƘǪǪĀƆ¥ĀǪŅ ŗţǪȲǪŅţĀŽĀÇŗ ƆţŲ ,Ž¥. ţƆ u ƆéŴţȓɡ ƿ ǪƆţŽDžǎ Dz iƆŝ ȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆá é Dz ÇŗţǪȲǪŅţDzÇŗĀ 0ƆDzȓǪȲŝ ŽĀƆȓĀ ǪĀƼ ǪţĀǪȓá ŗ ȓ Žţȓ DzţĀ¥ĀƆ Āŝ DzÇŗ ģȓţŅȓĀƆ ƆŅĀģ ƆŅĀƆǎ ǣ.ĀȲȓĀ Ǫ¥Āţŝ
ȓĀƆ ģȸǪ `ÇŗƆƘǪǪĀƆ¥ĀǪŅ ǪȲƆé ȧɥɥ ŗƟÇŗDzȓǛȲ ŴţĨɡţĀǪȓĀ BĀƆDzÇŗĀƆǤá ¥Āŝ ǪţÇŗȓĀȓ éĀǪ ƆŲĀǪǎ ţĀ u ƆéŴţȓɡĀǪ ¥ţĀŝ ȓĀƆ ţŗǪĀƆ `ĀǪɑţÇĀ ŽţȓȓŴĀǪɓĀţŴĀ ȲÇŗ ţƆ PDzȓĀǪǪĀţÇŗ ȲƆé éĀǪ `ÇŗɓĀţɡ Ɔǎ
Ȍ(LQH WROOH ZDUPH -DFNHȊ
$EELOGXQJ ]HLJW 6RQGHUDXVVWDWWXQJ $NWLRQV]HLWUDXP ̳ ̳̲ ʣ ̵̳ ̴̳ ̴̲̳̹ { )LQDQ]LHUXQJVEHLVSLHO I¾U HLQHQ 6ZLIW ̳ ̴ '8$/-(7 &OXE .UDIWVWRIIYHUEUDXFK LQQHURUWV ̷ ̶ O ̳̲̲ NP DX¡HURUWV ̵ ̹ O ̳̲̲ NP NRPELQLHUWHU 7HVW]\NOXV ̶ ̵ O ̳̲̲ NP &2̩ $XVVWR¡ NRPELQLHUWHU 7HVW]\NOXV ̻̺ J NP 92 (* ̷̹̳ ̴̲̲̹
DXI %DVLV GHU 893 GHU 6X]XNL 'HXWVFKODQG *PE+ LQ +¸KH YRQ ̶̳ ̹̻̲ ̲̲ (XUR ]]JO EHUI¾KUXQJV XQG =XODVVXQJVNRVWHQ 1HWWRNUHGLWEHWUDJ ̳̳ ̴̻̲ ̺̲ (XUR *HVDPWEHWUDJ ̴̳ ̴̶̷ ̵̲ (XUR $Q]DKOXQJVEHWUDJ ̳ ̳̳̳ ̲̲ (XUR HIIHNWLYHU -DKUHV]LQV ̳ ̳̳ ̵̸ 5DWHQ ̵̷ [ ̳̲̻ ̲̲ (XUR ̳ [ ̺ ̶̵̲ ̵̲ (XUR ̵̸ 0RQDWH /DXI]HLW JHEXQGHQHU 6ROO]LQVVDW] ̳ ̳̲ S D %RQLW¦W YRUDXVJHVHW]W .UHGLWYHUPLWWOXQJ HUIROJW DOOHLQH ¾EHU 6X]XNL )LQDQFH ʣ HLQ 6HUYLFH &HQWHU GHU &UHGLW3OXV %DQN $* $XJXVWHQVWUD¡H ̹ ̹̲̳̹̺ 6WXWWJDUW ̴ ̵ %HLVSLHO JHP i ̸ D $EV ̶ 3$QJ9 t .I] +DIWSIOLFKW PLW 9ROO XQG 7HLONDVNRYHUVLFKHUXQJ 6% 9. ̳ ̲̲̲ ʣ (XUR 7. ̷̲̲ ʣ (XUR *¾OWLJ DE ̴̵ -DKUHQ *LOW QXU I¾U 3ULYDWNXQGHQ 5LVLNRWU¦JHU (5*2 9HUVLFKHUXQJ $* 9LFWRULDSODW] ̳ ̶̶̲̹̹ '¾VVHOGRUI EHU Q¦KHUH (LQ]HOKHLWHQ LQIRUPLHUHQ 6LH GLH MHZHLOLJHQ 9HUVLFKHUXQJVEHGLQJXQJHQ ZZZ VX]XNL YG GH HUJR 1LFKW PLW DQGHUHQ 6X]XNL $NWLRQVDQJHERWHQ NRPELQLHUEDU *LOW EHL DOOHQ WHLOQHKPHQGHQ 6X]XNL 3DUWQHUQ B
0LORV 6WHIDQRYLF &KHI GHU %½UJVFKDIWVEDQN %UDQGHQEXUJ
0LW GLHVHQ IHGHUOHLFKWHQ 6WHSSMDFNHQ JHQLH¡HQ 6LH EHKDJOLFKH :¦UPH LQ GHU NDOWHQ -DKUHVK¦OIWH 2SWLVFK EHVWLFKW GLH GH]HQWH 6WHSSXQJ PLW WUHQGLJHQ )DUE .RQWUDVWHQ 'LH ZHLFKH :DWWLHUXQJ VRUJW I¾U ΖKUHQ 5XQGXP .RPIRUW Ȃ RKQH DXI]XWUDJHQ 'DV %HVWH 'LH -DFNH LVW ¦X¡HUVW SȵHJH OHLFKW EHL r & ZDVFKEDU %HVWHOOHQ 6LH JOHLFK XQG VSDUHQ 6LH ¾EHU Ȝ Ȃ
7ROOH )DUEHQ OHLFKW DEHU VFKHOLJ ZDUP W SȵHJHOHLFKW
3. !!+3'1 ! 1 1 ,'6 %1 Dz ŅĀŗȓ ¥ĀǪ ȲÇŗ ¥ƘéĀƆDzȓ ƆéţŅĀǪá Žţȓ ĀţƆĀŽ <ŴĀȓȓĀǪɓ Ŵé ¥ĀţDzƼţĀŴDzɓĀţDzĀǎ ŴDz éţĀ YƘȓDzé ŽĀǪ ƆŲ éĀƆ ĀǪDzȓĀƆ <ǪĀéţȓ ģȸǪ ĀţƆĀƆ <ŴĀȓȓĀǪɓ Ŵé ɑĀǪ¥ȸǪŅȓĀá ŗ ¥Ā ĀDz ĀţƆţŅĀ DzƼƟȓȓţDzÇŗĀ D ÇŗģǪ ŅĀƆ ŅĀŅĀŝ ¥ĀƆÜ uƘģȸǪ ţDzȓ é Dz ,ĀŴé ƆƘÇŗ Ž Ŵǝ *ȸǪ ȲŽDzȓ ŽŽĀǝ ţDz ŗĀȲȓĀ ţDzȓ DzƘ Ž Ɔŝ ÇŗĀǪ <ŴĀȓȓĀǪɓ Ŵé é ɡȲŅĀŲƘŽŽĀƆǎ Dz ɓȲǪŽȓ ţŗƆ DzĀŗǪá ɓĀƆƆ ĀţƆ <ǪĀéţȓ ȲDzģ ŴŴȓǎ 0Ɔ ĀţƆĀǪ ƆƘǪŽ ŴĀƆ ƆŲ ¥Āŝ ȓǪ ŅĀ éţĀ ȲDzģ ŴŴǛȲƘȓĀ ¥Āţ <ǪĀéţȓĀƆ Āȓɓ ĀţƆ YǪƘɡĀƆȓǎ ţƆĀ ȸǪŅDzÇŗ ģȓDzŝ ¥ ƆŲ ŗ ȓ ŽĀŗǪ ȲDzģ ŴŴĀǎ `ţĀ ŗ ȓ Ű ȲÇŗ ǪţDzţŲƘǪĀţÇŗĀǪĀ <ǪĀéţȓĀǎ ȓɓ Çŗȓ YǪƘŝ ɡĀƆȓ éĀǪ <ǪĀéţȓĀ ƼŴ ȓɡĀƆǎ ǣBĀţƆ .ĀǪɡ DzÇŗŴȲŅ DzÇŗƘƆ ţŽŽĀǪ ģȸǪ éĀƆ BţȓȓĀŴDzȓ ƆéǤá Dz Ņȓ ĀǪǎ Žţȓ ţDzȓ ĀǪ ţƆ Ǫ ƆéĀƆ¥ȲǪŅ ŅĀƆ Ȳ ǪţÇŗȓţŅǎ sƘƆ ǪȲƆé Ɖɥ ɥɥɥ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ţŽ > Ɔé DzţƆé ƆȲǪ Ȃɥɥ DzƘ ŅǪƘňá é DzDz DzţĀ ƆţÇŗȓ ɡȲŽ BţȓȓĀŴDzȓ Ɔé ŅĀŗƟǪĀƆǎ `Āţȓ ŽĀŗǪ ŴDz ȧȂ : ŗǪĀƆ Ņţ¥ȓ ĀDz éţĀDzĀDz *ţƆ Ɔɡŗ ȲDz DzÇŗƘƆǎ 0ƆɡɓţDzÇŗĀƆ ŗţŴģȓ éţĀ ƆŲ ¥Āţ éĀǪ *ţƆ ƆɡţĀǪȲƆŅ ɑƘƆ D ÇŗģƘŴŅĀƆ ģȸǪ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆá éĀǪĀƆ ,ǪȸƆéȲƆŅ DzţĀ DzÇŗƘƆ ¥ĀŅŴĀţȓĀȓ ŗ ȓǎ
Ā¥ĀƆDzƘ ɡȲ Ǫ ƆÇŗĀƆŝ ȲƆé iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŝ ŽĀǪɑĀǪ¥ ƆéĀƆǎ ţƆţŅĀ : ŗǪĀ Ŵ ƆŅ ɓ Ǫ <ŴĀŽĀƆDz ,ȲȓŽ ƆƆ ģȸǪ DzĀţƆĀ Ǫ ƆÇŗĀ ȲDzDzÇŗȲDzDzɑƘǪDzţȓɡĀƆéĀǪ ţŽ ĀȲȓŝ DzÇŗĀƆ 0ƆéȲDzȓǪţĀŝ ȲƆé . ƆéĀŴDzŲ Žŝ ŽĀǪȓ Ņǎ ŴDz `ƼǪĀÇŗĀǪ éĀDz ȲDzDzÇŗȲDzŝ DzĀDz ȓǪȲŅ ĀǪ BĀţƆȲƆŅĀƆ éĀǪ BţȓŅŴţĀéĀǪ ɡȲDz ŽŽĀƆ ȲƆé ģƘǪŽȓĀ é ƆƆ é Ǫ ȲDz ĀţƆ ţŴéá é Dz éĀŽ ,ĀDzĀȓɡŅĀ¥ĀǪ ¥Āţ éĀƆ *ƘǪŽȲŴţĀǪȲƆŅĀƆ ƆĀȲĀǪ ]ĀŅĀŴƆ ŗĀŴģĀƆ DzƘŴŴȓĀǎ ǣ`ȓĀŴŴȓ Ž Ɔ é Dz ǪţÇŗȓţŅ Ɔá Ŵ DzDzȓ DzţÇŗ ɓţǪŲŴţÇŗ Āȓɓ Dz ¥ĀɓĀŝ ŅĀƆǤá Dz Ņȓ ĀǪǎ Ǫ ţDzȓ ȲÇŗ ţƆ éţĀDzĀƆ d ŝ ŅĀƆ ɓţĀéĀǪ Žţȓ éĀǪ YƘŴţȓţŲ ţŽ ,Āŝ DzƼǪ Çŗǎ BĀŗǪĀǪĀ ,ǪĀŽţĀƆ éĀǪ ȲǪƘŝ Ƽ ţDzÇŗĀƆ iƆţƘƆ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀƆ Ɔ ĀţƆĀŽ ȓĀƆDzÇŗȲȓɡŝ,ĀDzĀȓɡǎ <ŴĀŽĀƆDz ,Ȳȓŝ Ž ƆƆ ɓţŴŴ DzţÇŗ é ĀţƆ¥ǪţƆŅĀƆǎ
6SRUWLYHV 'HVLJQ PLW IDQWDVWLVFKHP 7UDJHNRPIRUW
RW
(& 2 ($$ -
$E ʣ (85 PRQDWOLFK{ LQNO -DKU 9HUVLFKHUXQJt VX]XNL PDFKWV HLQIDFK GH .UDIWVWRIIYHUEUDXFK NRPELQLHUWHU 7HVW]\NOXV ʣ O NP &2˄ $XVVWR¡ NRPELQLHUWHU 7HVW]\NOXV ʣ J NP 92 (*
sţĀŴĀ éĀǪ <ȲƆéĀƆ éĀDz B ŅéĀ¥ȲǪŅĀǪ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆDz ŝ ɑƘǪ ŴŴĀŽ éţĀ ŅǪƘňĀƆ ƆĀǪŅţĀɑĀǪDzƘǪŅĀǪ ɓţĀ ƘƆ ƘéĀǪ D u ŝ Ŵ ŅĀǪƆ ¥ǪĀÇŗƆȲƆŅDzéţĀƆDzȓŝ ŴĀţDzȓȲƆŅĀƆ DzĀţȓ : ŗǪĀƆ ȲDzǎ ]ĀŅţƘÇƘŽ ƼǪƘĨȓţĀǪȓ é ɑƘƆǎ 0Ɔ éĀƆ ɑĀǪŅ ƆŅĀƆĀƆ BƘƆ ȓĀƆ ȸ¥ĀǪƆ ŗŽ ,ȲȓŽ ƆƆ ţŽŽĀǪ Ž Ŵ ɓţĀéĀǪ ĀţƆ <ƘƆŲȲǪǪĀƆɡŝ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆǎ ȲDz ĀţƆĀŽ ǪĀţŝ B ƆƆŝ ĀȓǪţĀ¥ ŗ ȓ ĀǪ Žţȓ DzĀţƆĀƆ Bţȓŝ DzȓǪĀţȓĀǪƆ ĀţƆĀ *ţǪŽ Žţȓ ĭ ɥɥɥ Āŝ DzÇŗ ģȓţŅȓĀƆ ŅĀŽ Çŗȓǎ ,ȲȓŽ ƆƆ ĀǪɡ ŗŴȓá é DzDz ĀǪ ŰĀéĀDz : ŗǪ Ɔģ ƆŅ *Ā¥ǪȲ Ǫ Ɔ Çŗ DzDzĀƆ ǪĀţDzȓǎ ƘǪȓ ȓǪţĥȓ DzţÇŗ DzĀţƆĀ Ǫ ƆÇŗĀǎ Dz ɓţǪé ȸ¥ĀǪ ŲȓȲĀŴŴĀ ƆȓɓţÇŲŴȲƆŅĀƆ ŅĀDzƼǪƘŝ ÇŗĀƆá ŽţȓȲƆȓĀǪ ɓĀǪéĀƆ DzƘŅ Ǫ ƼĀǪ . ƆéDzÇŗŴ Ņ ȲģȓǪ ŅĀ ɑĀǪŅĀ¥ĀƆǎ ȓɓ ĀţƆĀ . ƆéɑƘŴŴ dǪĀĥĀƆ ŝ BĀDzDzĀƆ ȲƆé ɓţÇŗȓţŅĀ ¥ĀƆéɑĀǪ ƆDzȓ ŴȓȲƆŅĀƆ ŝ ģȸǪ éţĀ ƆĀǪŅţĀ¥Ǫ ƆÇŗĀ Ņţ¥ȓ ĀDz ţƆ ĀţƆĀŽ : ŗǪǎ *ȸǪ ]ĀŅţƘÇƘŽ ţDzȓ ĀDz ĀƆȓDzÇŗĀţŝ éĀƆéá éƘǪȓ ƼǪ DzĀƆȓ ɡȲ DzĀţƆǎ ǣ Dz Ņţ¥ȓ ȲƆDz `ţÇŗȓ¥ ǪŲĀţȓǎ uţǪ ɓĀǪéĀƆ ¥Āţ ȲDzŝ DzÇŗǪĀţ¥ȲƆŅĀƆ ƆţÇŗȓ ɑĀǪŅĀDzDzĀƆǤá ĀǪŲŴ Ǫȓ
H
ΖKUH 9RUWHLOH
6LW]W SHUIHNW GDQN JHUDGHP 6FKQLWW XQG HODVWLVFKHQ %¾QGFKHQ 8OWUDOHLFKW PLW ZHLFKHU :DWWLHUXQJ 3ȵHJHOHLFKWHV 0DWHULDO 3RO\DPLG )XWWHU 3RO\HVWHU
3UDNWLVFK PLW DQJHVFKQLWWHQHU .DSX]H XQG 5HL¡YHUVFKOXVV 7DVFKHQ
B0 . > ] 0 . >
6DVFKD =VPLVNRO LVW &KHI GHU Ü5HQQVWHLJ :HUN]HXJH *PE+Û
(& " $$
ĀţŽ ]ĀƆƆDzȓĀţŅ éĀƆŲĀƆ éţĀ ŽĀţŝ DzȓĀƆ BĀƆDzÇŗĀƆ Ɔ iǪŴ Ȳ¥ǎ ¥ĀǪ ǪȲƆé ļČ YǪƘɡĀƆȓ éĀǪ iŽDz ȓɡĀ ŲƘŽŝ ŽĀƆ ŗţĀǪ ȲDz éĀǪ 0ƆéȲDzȓǪţĀá ƆȲǪ ɡɓĀţ YǪƘɡĀƆȓ ȲDz éĀŽ , DzȓŅĀɓĀǪ¥Āǎ ţĀ ǣ]ĀƆƆDzȓĀţŅ uĀǪŲɡĀȲŅĀ ,Ž¥.Ǥ ţƆ sţĀǪƆ Ȳ ƿ<ǪĀţDz `ÇŗŽ ŴŲ ŴéĀƆŝBĀţŝ ƆţƆŅĀƆDž ŗ ȓ é Ǫ Ɔ ţŗǪĀƆ ƆȓĀţŴá éţĀ *ţǪŽ ţDzȓ ĀţƆ `ƼĀɡţ ŴţDzȓ ģȸǪ `ƼĀɡţ Ŵŝ ɡ ƆŅĀƆǎ ǣ`ţĀ ¥ĀDzȓĀŗĀƆ ȲDz ¥ţDz ɡȲ ƨǹɥ ȲȓĀţŴĀƆ ȲƆé DzţƆé ţƆɡɓţDzÇŗĀƆ ɡȲŽ dĀţŴ Žţȓ ŴĀŲȓǪƘƆţŲ ȲDzŅĀDzȓ ȓȓĀȓá éţĀ ƆɡĀţŅȓá Ƙ¥ é Dz uĀǪŲɡĀȲŅ ǪţÇŗȓţŅ ĀţƆŝ ŅĀDzĀȓɡȓ ɓţǪéǤá ĀǪŲŴ Ǫȓ ,ĀDzÇŗ ģȓDzģȸŗǪĀǪ ` DzÇŗ ŽţDzŲƘŴǎ < ¥ĀŴɑĀǪ¥ţƆéȲƆŅĀƆ Žţȓ ƆŅĀƆ DzţƆé éţĀ `ƼĀɡţ Ŵţȓ ȓ éĀDz . ȲDzĀDzá ȲÇŗ éĀǪ *ŴȲŅɡĀȲŅ¥ ȲĀǪ ţǪŝ ¥ȲDz ŅĀŗƟǪȓ ɡȲ éĀƆ <ȲƆéĀƆǎ Āţ DĀɓ yƘǪŲ ȲƆȓĀǪŗ Ŵȓ éţĀ *ţǪŽ ĀţƆĀ DţĀŝ éĀǪŴ DzDzȲƆŅ ģȸǪ éĀƆ ɓţÇŗȓţŅĀƆ ŽĀǪţŝ Ų ƆţDzÇŗĀƆ B ǪŲȓǎ BĀŗǪ ŴDz Șɥɥ Bţȓ Ǫŝ ¥ĀţȓĀǪ Ɔ ¥ĀţéĀƆ `ȓ ƆéƘǪȓĀƆ DzţƆé ģȸǪ éţĀ B ǪŲĀ ]ĀƆƆDzȓĀţŅ ȓ ȓţŅ ŝ éƘƼƼĀŴȓ DzƘ ɑţĀŴĀ ɓţĀ ƨƉƉƨá ŴDz ǣ]ĀƆƆDzȓĀţŅǤ ɑƘƆ éĀǪ uȲƼƼĀǪȓ ŴĀǪ <ƆţƼĀɕŝ,ǪȲƼƼĀ ȸ¥ĀǪƆƘŽŽĀƆ ɓȲǪéĀǎ ǣuţǪ ŴţĀģĀǪƆ Ȳģ ŴŴĀ ǪéȓĀţŴĀá ¥ĀǪ ȲƆDzĀǪĀ `ȓĀȲĀǪƆ ɡ ŗŴĀƆ ɓţǪ ŗţĀǪǤá ĀǪŲŴ Ǫȓ ŽţDzŲƘŴǎ ţƆĀ ĀţŅĀƆĀ ƆȓɓţÇŲŴȲƆŅDz ¥ȓĀţŴȲƆŅ Ņţ¥ȓ ĀDz ȲÇŗ ŝ é Dz iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ŗ Ŵȓ ŽĀŗǪ ŴDz Ȃɥ Ɔ ȓţƘƆ ŴĀ ȲƆé ţƆȓĀǪƆ ȓţƘŝ Ɔ ŴĀ Y ȓĀƆȓĀá éĀǪ ɕƼƘǪȓ ƆȓĀţŴ ŴţĀŅȓ
¥Āţ ŽĀŗǪ ŴDz ĭɥ YǪƘɡĀƆȓǎ ţĀ <ĀŗǪDzĀţŝ ȓĀ éĀDz ǪģƘŴŅĀDzá éĀƆ éţĀ ȧ ĭɥɥ 0ƆéȲŝ DzȓǪţĀ¥ĀȓǪţĀ¥Ā fȸǪţƆŅĀƆDz ɑĀǪ¥ȲÇŗĀƆÜ Ų ȲŽ * ÇŗŲǪ ģȓĀ ɓĀţȓ ȲƆé ¥ǪĀţȓǎ Āţ ǣ]ĀƆƆDzȓĀţŅ uĀǪŲɡĀȲŅĀǤ ŗ ȓ Ž Ɔ ĀDz DzƘŅ Ǫ DzÇŗƘƆ Žţȓ .Ā éŗȲƆȓĀǪƆ ɑĀǪŝ DzȲÇŗȓǎ Dz ]ĀDzȲŴȓ ȓ ɓ Ǫ ¥ĀDzÇŗĀţéĀƆǎ sĀǪŴ DzDzŴţÇŗĀǪ DzţƆé éţĀ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲĀá éţĀ éţĀ ŅĀDz ŽȓĀ ]ĀŅţƘƆ éȲǪÇŗɡţĀŗĀƆ ȲƆé ¥ţDz ţƆ éĀƆ *ǪĀţɡĀţȓ¥ĀǪĀţÇŗ ǪĀţÇŗĀƆǎ `Ƙ ɓȲǪéĀ éĀǪ ǣ*ţǪŽĀƆŴ Ȳģ fȸǪţƆŅĀǪ u ŴéǤá Ɔ éĀŽ ɑţĀŴĀ Ɔŝ ŅĀƆŝ ɕƼĀǪȓĀƆ ȓĀţŴƆ ŗŽĀƆá ŅĀƆȲȓɡȓá ȲŽ Ȳģ DzţÇŗ ȲģŽĀǪŲDz Ž ɡȲ Ž ÇŗĀƆǎ sĀǪ ƆDzȓ ŴȓĀǪ éĀDz *ţǪŽĀƆŴ ȲģDz ţDzȓ éĀǪ ǣsĀǪĀţƆ *ƘǪȲŽ fȸǪţƆŅĀǪ u ŴéǤá éĀǪ ɑƘƆ 0.< ȲƆé . ƆéɓĀǪŲDzŲ ŽŽĀǪ ŅĀȓǪ ŅĀƆ ɓţǪéǎ Ɔģ ƆŅ DƘɑĀŽ¥ĀǪ éţĀDzĀDz : ŗǪĀDz ɑĀǪ ƆDzȓ ŴȓĀȓĀ ǣ]ĀƆƆDzȓĀţŅ uĀǪŲɡĀȲŅĀǤ ĀǪDzȓŽ ŴDz ĀţƆĀƆ ǪŴĀ¥ƆţDzȓ Ņ ţƆ éĀǪ *ţǪŝ Ž ǎ Șļ ɓĀţȓĀǪĀ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ¥ĀȓĀţŝ ŴţŅȓĀƆ DzţÇŗ é Ǫ Ɔá é ǪȲƆȓĀǪ éţĀ D Çŗŝ ¥ ǪĨǪŽ .ĀŗƆŲĀá ĀţƆ <ȲƆDzȓDzȓƘĥɑĀǪŝ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀǪ ȲƆé ȲȓƘŽƘ¥ţŴɡȲŴţĀģĀǪĀǪǎ ĀţéĀ ĀȓǪţĀ¥Ā ¥ĀȓǪĀţ¥ĀƆ DzƘŅĀƆ ƆƆŝ ȓĀ :ȲŅĀƆéŝiƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆDzɓĀǪŲDzȓ ȓŝ ȓĀƆǎ <ţƆéĀǪ éĀǪ ļǎ ¥ţDz ɡȲǪ Ȃǎ <Ŵ DzDzĀ ŲƟƆƆĀƆ ţƆ éĀƆ uĀǪŲDzȓ ȓȓĀƆ ¥ DzȓĀŴƆ ȲƆé ȲƆȓĀǪ ƆŴĀţȓȲƆŅ ƼǪƘģĀDzDzţƘƆĀŴŴĀ B DzÇŗţƆĀƆ ƆȲȓɡĀƆǎ `ţĀ¥ĀƆ DzƘŴÇŗĀ uĀǪŲDzȓ ȓȓĀƆ Ņţ¥ȓ ĀDzá ɓĀţȓĀǪĀ DzƘŴŴĀƆ ţƆ ȲŲȲģȓ ģƘŴŅĀƆ ȲƆé ĀţƆ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲ éĀǪ ¥ĀDzƘƆéĀǪĀƆ Ǫȓ ¥ţŴéĀƆǎ
1RUGFDS Ȃ GHU ([SHUWH I¾U KRFKZHU WLJH 6SRUW XQG )UHL]HLW %HNOHLGXQJ )XQNWLRQHOOH 0DWHULDOLHQ GXUFKGDFKWH 'HWDLOV VRZLH DXVJH]HLFKQHWH 9HUDU EHLWXQJ VRUJHQ I¾U ODQJOHELJHQ XQG DXVJH]HLFKQHWHQ 7UDJHNRPIRUW ZZZ QRUGFDS VSRUW FRP 0
%LWWH JHEHQ 6LH LP 2QOLQH 6KRS ΖKUHQ VWHOOLJHQ *XWVFKHLQ &RGH HLQ XP YRQ ΖKUHP 9RUWHLO ]X SURȴWLHUHQ
'LUHNW ]XP 2QOLQH 6KRS
/
;/
; /
;/
ΖKU %HVWHOOVFKHLQ
-HW]W EHVWHOOHQ
6(+5 *87
*'
9HUVDQGNRVWHQIUHL EHVWHOOHQ EHL 9RUWHLOVKRS
1RUGFDS -DFNH VFKZDU] RUDQJH
Ȝ Ȃ
Ȝ
*'
1RUGFDS -DFNH EODX RUDQJH
Ȝ Ȃ
Ȝ
*'
1RUGFDS -DFNH JU¾Q EODX
Ȝ Ȃ
Ȝ
*'
1RUGFDS -DFNH URW VFKZDU]
Ȝ Ȃ
Ȝ
-D LFK EHVWHOOH PLW *XWVFKHLQ &RGH $EVHQGHU %LWWH GHXWOLFK DXVI¾OOHQ
)UDX
+HUU
1DPH 9RUQDPH :LGHUUXIVUHFKW 6LH KDEHQ GDV 5HFKW 7DJH ODQJ RKQH $QJDEH YRQ *U¾QGHQ GLHVHQ 9HUWUDJ JHJHQ¾EHU GHU JUHQ]HQORV GLUHNW +DQGHOV *PE+ VFKULIWOLFK WHOHIRQLVFK SHU )D[ RGHU SHU ( 0DLO DQ $ ΖQQVEUXFN *¦UEHUEDFK 7HO RɝFH#YRUWHLOVKRS FRP ]X ZLGHUUXIHQ 'LH :LGHUUXIVIULVW EHJLQQW DE GHP 7DJ DQ GHP 6LH GLH :DUHQ LQ %HVLW] JHQRPPHQ KDEHQ 6HQGHQ 6LH XQV GLH :DUH VS¦WHVWHQV 7DJH QDFK ΖKUHP :LGHUUXI ]XU¾FN :LU JHZ¦KUHQ ΖKQHQ QHEHQ GHP JHVHW]OLFKHQ :LGHUUXIVUHFKW HLQH IUHLZLOOLJH 5¾FNJDEHJDUDQWLH YRQ 7DJHQ DE (UKDOW GHU :DUH VRIHUQ GLH :DUH VLFK LQ XQJHEUDXFKWHP XQG XQEHVFK¦GLJWHP =XVWDQG EHȴQGHW ΖPSUHVVXP 9RUWHLOVKRS Ȃ HLQH 0DUNH GHU JUHQ]HQORV GLUHNW +DQ GHOV *PE+ *¦UEHUEDFK $ ΖQQVEUXFN
6WDWWSUHLVH EH]LHKHQ VLFK DXI +HUVWHOOHU /LVWHQSUHLVH RGHU XQYHUELQGOLFKH 3UHLVHPSIHKOXQJ GHV +HUVWHOOHUV 893
'HWDLOOLHUWH $QJDEHQ ]XP 5¾FNWULWWVUHFKW ȴQGHQ 6LH DXI ZZZ YRUWHLOVKRS FRP
6WUD¡H 1U 3/= 2UW
*HEXUWVGDWXP
( 0DLO
/LHIHUXQJ HUIROJW JHJHQ 5HFKQXQJ LQ 5HLKHQIROJH GHV %HVWHOOHLQJDQJV %LWWH NHLQH =DKOXQJVPLWWHO EHLOHJHQ $QJHERWH JHOWHQ QXU LQ 'HXWVFKODQG XQG VRODQJH GHU 9RUUDW UHLFKW
% (LQH $Q]HLJHQÓ6RQGHUYHU¶IIHQWOLFKXQJ GHU %HUOLQHU =HLWXQJ w 1RYHPEHU ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
:LUWVFKDIW
$OOHV %LR LP 1HW]ZHUN
$EZDQGHUXQJ GXUFK VWDELOHV 1HW] VWRSSHQ
'LH (U]HXJHUJHPHLQVFKDIW Ú%LRIULVFKØ ¼EHUQLPPW GLH 9HUPDUNWXQJ YRQ %LR 3URGXNWHQ
6WDGWZHUNH &KHI *XLGR /DQJHU EHWRQW GLH 5ROOH GHV ,QWHUQHWDXVEDXV *( ! ( /
ȸǪŅĀǪ ȲƆé iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ éĀǪ ]Āŝ ŅţƘƆ DzÇŗƆĀŴŴ ȲƆé DzȓƟǪȲƆŅDzģǪĀţ Žţȓ ƆĀǪŅţĀ ɡȲ ɑĀǪDzƘǪŅĀƆ Ę é Dz ţDzȓ é Dz ţĀŴ éĀǪ `ȓ éȓɓĀǪŲĀ BĀǪDzĀ¥ȲǪŅǎ Dz iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ DzȓĀŴŴȓ ɡȲéĀŽ éţĀ 0ƆģǪ ŝ DzȓǪȲŲȓȲǪ ɡȲǪ `ȓǪƘŽƆȲȓɡȲƆŅ ¥ĀţŽ BĀǪDzĀ¥ȲǪŅĀǪ <ŴţƆţŲȲŽá ţŽ ` ŴĀŲǪĀţDz ȲƆé éĀǪ BĀǪDzĀ¥ȲǪŅĀǪ `ȓ éȓɑĀǪɓ Ŵŝ ȓȲƆŅǎ BĀŗǪ ŴDz ȧǹ ĭɥɥ DȲȓɡĀǪ ɡ ŗŴĀƆ éţĀ `ȓ éȓɓĀǪŲĀ ŲȓȲĀŴŴ ƿȓĀţŴɓĀţDzĀ BĀŗǪģ ÇŗƆȲȓɡȲƆŅDžá é ɡȲ ŅĀŗƟǪĀƆ éţĀ sĀǪDzƘǪŅȲƆŅDz¥ĀǪĀţÇŗĀ , Dzá `ȓǪƘŽá *ĀǪƆɓ ǪŽĀá 0ƆȓĀǪƆĀȓ ȲƆé dĀŴĀģƘƆţĀ DzƘɓţĀ dsǎ `Āţȓ `ĀƼȓĀŽ¥ĀǪ ȧɥƨļ ģȸŗǪȓ ,ȲţéƘ > ƆŅĀǪ éţĀ ,ĀDzÇŗ ģȓĀǎ ĀǪ ĭȧŝ: ŗǪţŅĀ ţDzȓ ŅĀ¥ȸǪȓţŅĀǪ BĀǪDzĀ¥ȲǪŝ ŅĀǪ ȲƆé DzĀţȓ ƨƉƉȘ ţŽ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ȓ ȓţŅá ɡȲƆ ÇŗDzȓ ŴDz sĀǪȓǪţĀ¥DzŴĀţȓĀǪá é ƆƆ ŴDz YǪƘŲȲǪţDzȓǎ ' ).% 2 )'0 400 #0 ' ",4'"2
ȲŽ fĀŽ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲĀ Dz Ņȓ > ƆŅĀǪ ģƘŴŅĀƆéĀDzÜ ǣ0Ɔ ĀţƆĀǪ DzÇŗƆĀŴŴŴĀ¥ţŅĀƆ Āţȓ ţDzȓ ĀDz DzÇŗɓţĀǪţŅá 0ƆģƘǪŽ ȓţƘƆĀƆ ţƆDz . ȲDz ɡȲ ¥ĀŲƘŽŽĀƆǎ ģȸǪ ¥ţĀȓĀȓ DzţÇŗ éĀǪ ȲDzȓ ȲDzÇŗ ţƆ ĀţƆĀŽ DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲ ƆǎǤ 0Ž ƆĀǪŅţĀĀĦɡţĀƆɡƆĀȓɡɓĀǪŲ éĀǪ ŽţȓȓĀŴéĀȲȓDzÇŗĀƆ 0ƆéȲDzȓǪţĀ DzţƆé Çŗȓ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ Ųȓţɑá ƆĀ¥ĀƆ éĀƆ `ȓ éȓŝ ɓĀǪŲĀƆ ȲDz DzÇŗĀǪDzŴĀ¥ĀƆá ţȓȓĀǪģĀŴéŝ uƘŴģĀƆá ţDzŴĀ¥ĀƆ ȲƆé [ȲĀéŴţƆ¥ȲǪŅ ȲÇŗ sĀǪDzƘǪŅĀǪ ȲDz ` ÇŗDzĀƆá fȸǪţƆŝ ŅĀƆ ȲƆé Ǫ ƆéĀƆ¥ȲǪŅǎ ţƆ `ÇŗɓĀǪƼȲƆŲȓ éĀDz BĀǪDzĀ¥ȲǪŅĀǪ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆDzÜ 0ƆȓĀǪƆĀȓƆȲȓɡȲƆŅ Žţȓ ŗƘŗĀǪ o¥ĀǪȓǪ ŅȲƆŅDzǪ ȓĀ ĀǪŽƟŅŴţÇŗĀƆǎ `Āţȓ ŅȲȓ ɡɓĀţĀţƆŗ Ŵ¥ : ŗǪĀƆ ɓĀǪéĀ é Dz ƆŅĀ¥Ƙȓ ȲDzŅĀ¥ Ȳȓǎ *ȸƆģ BţŴŴţƘƆĀƆ ȲǪƘ ɓȲǪéĀƆ ţƆɑĀDzȓţĀǪȓǎ ĀǪɡĀţȓ ŅĀŝ ŴţƆŅĀ ĀDz ȲÇŗ ƘŗƆĀ *ƟǪéĀǪŽţȓȓĀŴá é Dz ,ĀŴé ȲģɡȲ¥ǪţƆŅĀƆǎ ĀţŽ 0ƆȓĀǪƆĀȓ Ɔŝ ŅĀ¥Ƙȓ DzţĀŗȓ ĀǪ BĀǪDzĀ¥ȲǪŅ é ¥Āţ ɑƘǪƆǎ ǣ0Ɔ éĀǪ ]ĀŅţƘƆ ŗĀ¥ĀƆ ɓţǪ ȲƆDz é Žţȓ éĀȲȓŴţÇŗ ¥Ǥá Dz Ņȓ > ƆŅĀǪ Žţȓ ŴţÇŲ Ȳģ
.]0`d0 D ]P >
*DE\ )LHELJ XQG 7XUH *XVWDYV VWHKHQ DXI GHU :HLGH QHEHQ HLQLJHQ LKUHU 0LOFKN½KH *( /( / &! 3 5 /
`d ** D ]iD<
*XLGR /DQJHU &KHI GHU 6WDGWZHUNH 0HUVHEXUJ éĀƆ ǪĀţȓ¥ Ɔé ȓŴ Dzá éĀǪ ģȸǪ ŰĀéĀ ]ĀŅţŝ ƘƆ ɑƘƆ éĀǪ ȲƆéĀDzǪĀŅţĀǪȲƆŅ ɑƘǪ ŽĀŗǪ ŴDz ɡĀŗƆ : ŗǪĀƆ ɑĀǪƟĥĀƆȓŴţÇŗȓ ɓȲǪéĀǎ Dz DzĀţ ŗţŴģǪĀţÇŗ ŅĀɓĀDzĀƆá ȲŽ ĀţƆĀ ¥ŝ ɓ ƆéĀǪȲƆŅ ȲDz éĀǪ `ȓ éȓ ɡȲ ɑĀǪŗţƆŝ éĀǪƆǎ ĀƆƆ DzĀţĀƆ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ Ȳģ ĀţƆĀ ƼǪƘģĀDzDzţƘƆĀŴŴĀ 0ƆģǪ DzȓǪȲŲȓȲǪ Ɔŝ ŅĀɓţĀDzĀƆá DzĀţ éţĀ ƆDzţĀéŴȲƆŅ ģȸǪ éţĀDzĀ ţƆ éĀǪ ]ĀŅţƘƆ ƘŗƆĀ é Dz sƘǪŗ ƆéĀƆŝ DzĀţƆ ĀţƆĀDz ŅȲȓ ȲDz¥ ȲȓĀƆ 0ƆȓĀǪƆĀȓ Ɔŝ DzÇŗŴȲDzDzĀDz ƆţÇŗȓ ȓȓǪ Ųȓţɑǎ YǪţɑ ȓ ţDzȓ ,ȲţéƘ > ƆŅĀǪ ţŽ ǣ>ţƘƆDz ŴȲ¥ BĀǪDzĀ¥ȲǪŅǤá ɓĀŴÇŗĀǪ ţƆ éţĀDzĀŽ : ŗǪ ȧĭŝŰ ŗǪţŅĀDz ĀDzȓĀŗĀƆ ģĀţĀǪȓá Ųȓţɑǎ *ǪĀţĀ BţȓŅŴţĀéĀǪ ŗĀŴģĀƆ ţƆ éţĀDzĀǪ sĀǪĀţŝ ƆţŅȲƆŅ Ɔ Çŗ ĀţŅĀƆĀƆ ƆŅ ¥ĀƆ éƘǪȓá ǣɓƘ é Dz DzƘɡţ ŴĀ DĀȓɡ ĀţƆ >ƘÇŗ ŗ ȓǤǎ ģȸǪ ŗ ȓ éĀǪ ɡɓĀţģ ÇŗĀ * ŽţŴţĀƆɑ ȓĀǪ > ƆŅĀǪ ȲÇŗ DzĀţƆĀ Bţȓ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀǪ ¥ĀŅĀţŝ DzȓĀǪƆ ŲƟƆƆĀƆǎ ,035(6680 %HUOLQHU 9HUODJ *PE+ *HVFK¥IWVI½KUHU 0LFKDHO %UDXQ -HQV .DXHUDXI 9 L 6 G 3UHVVHJHVHW]HV -RFKHQ $UQW] 9HUPDUNWXQJ %9= %0 9HUPDUNWXQJ *PE+ %HUOLQ 0HGLHQ
$OWH -DNREVWUD H %HUOLQ *HVFK¥IWVI½KUHU $QGUHH )ULWVFKH $OWH -DNREVWD H %HUOLQ EHUOLQ DQ]HLJHQ#GXPRQW GH 'UXFN %9= %HUOLQHU =HLWXQJVGUXFN *PE+ $P :DVVHUZHUN %HUOLQ /D\RXW 0GV&UHDWLYH *PE+ $OWH -DNREVWU %HUOLQ *HVFK¥IWVI½KUHU .ODXV %DUWHOV 7LWHOELOG 6LJPDU )UHQ]HO Ü:LUWVFKDIW Ú LVW HLQ *HPHLQVFKDIWVSURMHNW GHU RVWGHXWVFKHQ 7DJHV]HLWXQJHQ
Dz ĨƆéĀƆ 0ǪŽ ȲƆé 0ƆŅĀ ţƆȓĀǪĀDzŝ Dz Ɔȓǎ Bţȓ Ŵ ƆŅDz ŽĀƆ `ÇŗǪţȓȓĀƆ ŲƘŽŽĀƆ BȲȓȓĀǪ ȲƆé dƘÇŗȓĀǪ ŗĀǪ Ɔǎ 0ŽŽĀǪ ƘĥĀƆDzţÇŗȓŴţÇŗĀǪ ɡĀţŅĀƆ DzţĀ ţŗǪĀ DĀȲŅţĀǪǎ ţĀ ¥ĀţéĀƆ DzĀŗĀƆ ţŽƼƘDz Ɔȓ ȲDzá Žţȓ ţŗǪĀƆ Ŵ ƆŅ Ɔ Çŗ Ƙ¥ĀƆ ŅĀ¥ƘŅĀŝ ƆĀƆ DzƼţȓɡĀƆ .ƟǪƆĀǪƆǎ ţĀ ¥ĀţéĀƆ ŝ ŽĀƆ ŅĀŗƟǪĀƆ ɡȲǪ BţŴÇŗɑţĀŗŗĀǪéĀ ɑƘƆ , ¥ɗ *ţĀ¥ţŅ ƿĭǹDž ȲƆé dȲǪĀ ,ȲDzȓ ɑDz ƿļƉDžǎ Dz Y Ǫ ¥ĀȓǪĀţ¥ȓ éĀƆ .Ƙģ Ɔŝ éĀǪDzŗ ŅĀƆá é Dz ƟǪģÇŗĀƆ ŅĀŗƟǪȓ ɡȲ ]ţÇŗȓĀƆ¥ĀǪŅ ƿsƘǪƼƘŽŽĀǪƆŝ]ȸŅĀƆDžǎ `ţĀ Ž ÇŗĀƆ ģ Dzȓ ŴŴĀDz ŴŴĀţƆá ƆȲǪ ĀţƆĀ DzƘŅĀƆ ƆƆȓĀ ǪţȓȓĀŴŝ<Ǫ ģȓ Ƽ ÇŲȓ ƆƘÇŗ Žţȓ Ɔǎ ĀǪ ŲŴĀţƆĀ PŲƘŝ ĀȓǪţĀ¥ ŗ ȓ ŰĀŝ éƘÇŗ ĀţƆĀƆ Dzȓ ǪŲĀƆ Y ǪȓƆĀǪ Ɔ éĀǪ `Āţŝ ȓĀÜ Ǫ ŅĀŗƟǪȓ ɡȲŽ Ŵ ƆéĀDzɓĀţȓĀƆ ǪɡĀȲŝ ŅĀǪƆĀȓɡɓĀǪŲ ǣ ţƘģǪţDzÇŗǤ DƘǪéƘDzȓ ţƆ BĀÇŲŴĀƆ¥ȲǪŅŝsƘǪƼƘŽŽĀǪƆǎ ") # 2 % . ' ǣiƆDzĀǪĀ <ȸŗĀ DzţƆé ĀţƆĀ BţDzÇŗȲƆŅ ȲDz éĀƆ ] DzDzĀƆ HǪţŅţƆ Ŵ ŴŴŅ ȲĀǪ Ǫ ȲƆŝ ɑţĀŗ ȲƆé :ĀǪDzĀɗǤá ĀǪŲŴ Ǫȓ dȲǪĀ ,ȲDzȓ ɑDzá éĀǪ ȲƆȓĀǪ ƆéĀǪĀŽ éţĀ *ȲȓȓĀǪƼǪƘéȲŲȓţŝ ƘƆ ȲƆȓĀǪ DzţÇŗ ŗ ȓǎ Bţȓ :ȲƆŅȓţĀǪĀƆ ȲƆé < Ŵ¥ÇŗĀƆ ¥ĀDzȓĀŗȓ éţĀ .ĀǪéĀ ȲDz ţƆDzŅĀŝ
Dz Žȓ Ȃɥ dţĀǪĀƆǎ ŴŴĀ ȓǪ ŅĀƆ D ŽĀƆǎ ţĀ ]ţƆéĀǪ ɓȸǪéĀƆ ȲDzDzÇŗŴţĀňŴţÇŗ ,Ǫ Dzá <ŴĀĀ ȲƆé ƆéĀǪĀDz ,ǪȸƆģȲȓȓĀǪ ɑƘƆ éĀǪ uĀţéĀ ģǪĀDzDzĀƆá ţŽ uţƆȓĀǪ .ĀȲ ȲƆé Āȓŝ ɓ Dz ,ĀȓǪĀţéĀá é Dz DzĀţ Ž ŅĀDzȸƆéĀDzȓĀƆǎ <Ǫ ģȓģȲȓȓĀǪ ŲƘŽŽĀ ƆţÇŗȓ ţƆ éţĀ dǪƟŅĀǎ ȓɓ Ɖɥ .ĀŲȓ Ǫ ,ǪȸƆŴ Ɔé ɓĀǪéĀƆ ¥ţƘŝ ŴƘŅţDzÇŗ ¥ĀɓţǪȓDzÇŗ ģȓĀȓá ƘŗƆĀ ÇŗĀŽţŝ DzÇŗĀƆ ȸƆŅĀǪá iƆŲǪ Ȳȓŝ DzƘɓţĀ `Çŗ éŝ ŴţƆŅDz¥ĀŲ ŽƼģȲƆŅDzŽţȓȓĀŴ ĀţƆɡȲDzĀȓɡĀƆǎ 0ŗǪ BƘȓȓƘ ţDzȓÜ ǣ ţĀ <Ȳŗ ŽĀŴŲȓ éȲǪÇŗDz B ȲŴǎǤ 0Ɔ éţĀDzĀǪ ŴȓĀƆ ȲĀǪƆɓĀţDzŗĀţȓ DzȓĀÇŲĀ ŗĀȲȓĀ ƆƘÇŗ ɑţĀŴ u ŗǪŗĀţȓ ȲƆé ɑţĀŴ Ǫ¥Āţȓǎ ¥ĀǪ ĀDz ŅĀŗĀ ţŗƆĀƆ ŅȲȓá ɓĀţŴ DzţĀ DzţÇŗ ǣŽţȓ Ņ ƆɡĀŽ .ĀǪɡĀƆ ĀƆŅ ŝ ŅţĀǪĀƆǤá ĀǪŲŴ Ǫȓ , ¥ɗ *ţĀ¥ţŅǎ ǣiƆé ɓĀţŴ ɓţǪ ȲƆDzĀǪĀ YǪƘéȲŲȓĀ ɡȲ ĀţƆĀŽ ŅǪƘňĀƆ dĀţŴ DzĀŴ¥Dzȓ ɑĀǪĀéĀŴƆ ȲƆé éţǪĀŲȓ ɑĀǪŝ Ž ǪŲȓĀƆǎǤ `Ƙ ¥ĀŴţĀģĀǪƆ DzţĀ ţƘŴ éĀƆ ȲƆé ]ĀDzȓ ȲǪ ƆȓDz ţƆ éĀǪ ]ĀŅţƘƆ ɡɓţŝ DzÇŗĀƆ ,ǪĀţģDzɓ Ŵéá `ȓǪ ŴDzȲƆé ȲƆé DĀȲŝ ¥Ǫ ƆéĀƆ¥ȲǪŅǎ ǣ ţƆĀ . ŴģȓĀ éĀǪ BţŴÇŗ ɑĀǪŽ ǪŲȓĀƆ ɓţǪ DzĀŴ¥DzȓǤá ¥ĀǪţÇŗȓĀȓ , ¥ɗ *ţĀ¥ţŅá éţĀ DzţÇŗ ţƆ éĀŽ > ƆéɓţǪȓŝ DzÇŗ ģȓDz¥ĀȓǪţĀ¥ ȲƆȓĀǪ ƆéĀǪĀŽ ȲŽ éţĀ < DzĀǪĀţ ŲȸŽŽĀǪȓǎ BţŴÇŗƼǪƘéȲŲȓĀ ŲƟƆŝ ƆĀƆ <ȲƆéĀƆ ɡȲŽ ĀţƆĀƆ ţŽ ŲŴĀţƆĀƆ ƆéĀǪDzŗ ŅĀǪ .Ƙĩ éĀƆ ĀǪɓĀǪ¥ĀƆá ģǪĀţȓ ŅDz ȲƆé DzƘƆƆ ¥ĀƆéDz ţDzȓ ŅĀƟĥƆĀȓǎ
ȲŽ ȲŽģ ƆŅǪĀţÇŗĀƆ `ƘǪȓţŽĀƆȓ ŅĀŗƟŝ ǪĀƆ Ā¥ĀƆDzƘ *ŴĀţDzÇŗ ȲƆé uȲǪDzȓ ɑƘƆ ]ţƆŝ éĀǪƆ ȲƆé `ÇŗɓĀţƆĀƆ éĀDz .ƘģĀDzǎ 0Ž .Ƙĩ éĀƆ Ņţ¥ȓ ĀDz ȲňĀǪéĀŽ DzĀŴ¥DzȓŅĀŝ Ž ÇŗȓĀDz ţDz DzƘɓţĀ ģǪţDzÇŗĀDz ,ĀŽȸDzĀ ȲDz éĀǪ ]ĀŅţƘƆá ǪƘȓá ` ģȓá ţĀǪá uĀţƆ ȲƆé ƟŲƘŴƘŅţDzÇŗĀ ]ĀţƆţŅȲƆŅDzŽţȓȓĀŴǎ
7XUH *XVWDYV %LREDXHU
ţƘŝ>Ā¥ĀƆDzŽţȓȓĀŴ ȲDz ƆéĀǪDzŗ ŝ ŅĀƆ DzţƆé ȲÇŗ Ŵ ƆéĀDzɓĀţȓ ĀǪŗ ŴȓŴţÇŗǎ iƆé é ŲƘŽŽȓ éţĀ ǪɡĀȲŅĀǪŅĀŽĀţƆŝ DzÇŗ ģȓ ǣ ţƘģǪţDzÇŗ DƘǪéƘDzȓǤ ţƆDz `ƼţĀŴǎ ǣ,Ȳȓá é DzDz ĀDz éţĀDzĀDz DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲ Ņţ¥ȓǤá Dz Ņȓ dȲǪĀ ,ȲDzȓ ɑDzǎ Dz uţÇŗȓţŅDzȓĀ DzĀţ éţĀ ɑĀǪȓǪ ȲĀƆDzɑƘŴŴĀ ȲDz ŽŽĀƆ Ǫ¥Āţȓ Žţȓ éĀŽ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ţƆ dĀDzÇŗĀƆŝ
éƘǪģǎ iƆé é DzDz DzţĀ éţĀ >ƘŅţDzȓţŲ éĀDz iƆŝ ȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆDz ƆȲȓɡĀƆ ŲƟƆƆĀƆá DzĀţ ģȸǪ ţŗǪĀƆ ŲŴĀţƆĀƆ ĀȓǪţĀ¥ ȸ¥ĀǪŴĀ¥ĀƆDzŝ ɓţÇŗȓţŅá ŽĀţƆȓ ,ȲDzȓ ɑDzǎ ǣuţǪ ¥ ȲĀƆ Ȳģ ȲŴţĀģĀǪĀǪ ɓţĀ , ¥ɗ *ţĀ¥ţŅ ȲƆé dȲǪĀ ,ȲDzȓ ɑDzǤá Dz Ņȓ B ǪȓţƆ > ŽƼ ƿĭɥDžǎ Ǫ ȲƆé sƘŴŲĀǪ ǪţƆŲŽ ƆƆ ƿĭɥDž DzţƆé éţĀ ,ĀDzÇŗ ģȓDzģȸŗǪĀǪ éĀǪ ǣ ţƘģǪţDzÇŗ DƘǪéƘDzȓǤ ,¥]ǎ ĀƆ . ƆéĀŴ Žţȓ ţƘŝ>Ā¥ĀƆDzŽţȓȓĀŴƆ ¥ĀȓǪĀţ¥ĀƆ DzţĀ ȲƆé ɡȲǪɡĀţȓ ļĭ Bţȓ Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀǪ ɑƘƆ ĀţƆĀǪ ŴȓĀƆ ÇŲDzȓĀţƆDzÇŗĀȲƆĀ ţƆ dĀDzÇŗĀƆŝ éƘǪģ ƿ> ƆéŲǪĀţDz ]ƘDzȓƘÇŲDž ȲDzǎ .0+'# )'2 "2 6 # ' ĭɥ ĀȓǪţĀ¥Ā ŴţĀģĀǪƆ ţŗǪĀ YǪƘéȲŲȓĀ ŅĀŝ ŅĀƆɓ ǪȓţŅ Ɔ éţĀ ǪɡĀȲŅĀǪŅĀŽĀţƆŝ DzÇŗ ģȓá ȘȂ é ɑƘƆ ŲƘŽŽĀƆ ȲDz BĀÇŲŝ ŴĀƆ¥ȲǪŅŝsƘǪƼƘŽŽĀǪƆá éĀǪ ]ĀDzȓ ȲDz éĀƆ ȲƆéĀDzŴ ƆéĀǪƆ `ÇŗŴĀDzɓţŅŝ.ƘŴŝ DzȓĀţƆá DţĀéĀǪDz ÇŗDzĀƆ ȲƆé DƘǪéǪŗĀţƆŝ uĀDzȓģ ŴĀƆǎ 0Ž : ŗǪ ȧɥɥƨ ɓ Ǫ é Dz iƆŝ ȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ Žţȓ ɡɓƟŴģ >ţĀģĀǪ ƆȓĀƆ ŅĀŝ Dzȓ ǪȓĀȓǎ ŲȓȲĀŴŴ DzĀţĀƆ éţĀ ŽĀţDzȓĀƆ éĀǪ >ţĀģĀǪ ƆȓĀƆ ¥ ȲĀǪŴţÇŗĀ * ŽţŴţĀƆ¥Āŝ ȓǪţĀ¥Āá Dz Ņȓ ǪţƆŲŽ ƆƆǎ ŴŴĀ sĀǪ Ǫ¥Āţŝ ȓĀǪ ȲƆé ǪɡĀȲŅĀǪ ɓȸǪéĀƆ Ɔ Çŗ éĀƆ DzȓǪĀƆŅĀƆ ]ţÇŗȓŴţƆţĀƆ éĀDz PŲƘŴƘŅţŝ DzÇŗĀƆ > Ɔé¥ ȲDz Ǫ¥ĀţȓĀƆ ȲƆé DzĀţĀƆ ţƆ
ţƘŝ Ɔ¥ ȲɑĀǪ¥ ƆéĀƆá ɓţĀ ţƘŴ Ɔé ƘéĀǪ ĀŽĀȓĀǪá ƘǪŅ ƆţDzţĀǪȓǎ Ȳģ ƼĀǪŝ DzƟƆŴţÇŗĀ <ƘƆȓ ŲȓĀ ɡȲ éĀƆ >ţĀģĀǪ ƆȓĀƆ ɡȲ DzĀȓɡĀƆá é Dz ģȲƆŲȓţƘƆţĀǪȓǎ ĀǪ iŽŝ Dz ȓɡ ¥ĀȓǪȲŅ ţŽ ,ĀDzÇŗ ģȓDzŰ ŗǪ ȧɥƨȂ Āȓɓ Șáĭ BţŴŴţƘƆĀƆ ȲǪƘǎ Dz DĀȓɡɓĀǪŲá DzƘ > ŽƼá DzĀţ ƆţÇŗȓ ĨɕţĀǪȓ Ȳģ ĀţƆĀ Dzȓ ƆéţŅ DzȓĀţŅĀƆéĀ Ɔŝ ɡ ŗŴ ɑƘƆ ȲŴţĀģĀǪĀǪƆǎ ǣ Dzá ɓ Dz ɓţǪ Ž ÇŗĀƆá é Dz ɓƘŴŴĀƆ ɓţǪ ŅȲȓ Ž ÇŗĀƆǤá ¥ĀȓƘƆȓ ǪţƆŲŽ ƆƆǎ ɡȲ ŅĀŗƟǪȓ ȲÇŗ éţĀ ĀţŅĀƆĀ `ȓǪƘŽĀǪɡĀȲŅȲƆŅǎ 0Ɔ éĀǪ sĀǪ¥ǪĀţȓȲƆŅ ɑƘƆ ǪĀŅţƘƆ ŴĀƆ YǪƘéȲŲŝ ȓĀƆ ǣŗ ¥ĀƆ ɓţǪ ĀţƆĀ ŅĀɓţDzDzĀ YǪƘģĀDzDzţƘŝ Ɔ Ŵţȓ ȓ ĀǪǪĀţÇŗȓǤá ǪĀDzȸŽţĀǪȓ > ŽƼǎ Dz iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ DzȓĀŗĀ DzţÇŗĀǪ Ȳģ DzĀţƆĀƆ `ȓ Ɔé¥ĀţƆĀƆ B ǪŲȓŗ ƆéĀŴá HƆŴţƆĀŝ`ŗƘƼá ,ǪƘňŗ ƆéĀŴ ȲƆé .Ƙĩ ŝ éĀƆǎ .ţĀǪ DzÇŗŴţĀňȓ DzţÇŗ éĀǪ <ǪĀţDzǎ ĀǪ dĀDzÇŗĀƆéƘǪģĀǪ > éĀƆ ŗ ȓ ȲÇŗ YǪƘŝ éȲŲȓĀ ȲDz ƆéĀǪDzŗ ŅĀƆ ţŽ `ƘǪȓţŝ ŽĀƆȓǎ iƆé ǣ ţƘģǪţDzÇŗǤ ŴţĀģĀǪȓ éĀǪĀƆ >Ā¥ĀƆDzŽţȓȓĀŴ Ŵ ƆéĀDzɓĀţȓ ȲDzǎ Ȳģ DzţÇŗ ŴŴĀţƆ ŅĀDzȓĀŴŴȓ ŲƟƆƆȓĀƆ , ¥ɗ *ţĀ¥ţŅ ȲƆé dȲǪĀ ,ȲDzȓ ɑDz é Dz ƆţĀŽ ŴDz ŴĀţDzȓĀƆǎ Dz ǪɡĀȲŅĀǪƆĀȓɡɓĀǪŲ Ž Çŗȓ ĀDz ŽƟŅŝ ŴţÇŗ Ę ȲƆé ĀǪƟĥƆĀȓ BƟŅŴţÇŗŲĀţȓĀƆá éţĀ ɑƘǪ ĀţƆţŅĀƆ : ŗǪĀƆ ƆƘÇŗ ţƆ ɓĀţȓĀǪ *ĀǪŝ ƆĀ Ŵ ŅĀƆǎ
/HLS]LJHU /HXFKWHQ I¼U &KLQDV 7UDQVUDSLG 3URGXNWH GHU )LUPD 6%) 6SH]LDOOHXFKWHQ *PE+ NRPPHQ ZHOWZHLW ]XP (LQVDW] *( $/! ( /
B
ţȓ ¥ţDz ɡȲ ļȘƨ <ţŴƘŽĀȓĀǪƆ ƼǪƘ `ȓȲƆéĀ Ǫ Dzȓ éţĀ ŗƘÇŗŽƘéĀǪƆĀ B ŅƆĀȓDzÇŗɓĀ¥Ā¥ ŗƆ ȸ¥ĀǪ Șɥ <ţŴƘŝ ŽĀȓĀǪ ɑƘŽ *ŴȲŅŗ ģĀƆ `ŗ ƆŅŗ ţ ţƆ ŲƆ ƼƼ DzţĀ¥ĀƆ BţƆȲȓĀƆ ¥ţDz ţƆ éĀƆ `ȓ éȓ¥ĀɡţǪŲ YȲéƘƆŅǎ Bţȓ é ¥Āţ ţDzȓ ŰĀŝ éĀƆ d Ņ ĀţƆ ȲȓĀţŴ éĀǪ >ĀţƼɡţŅĀǪ *ţǪŝ Ž ` * `ƼĀɡţ ŴŴĀȲÇŗȓĀƆ ,Ž¥.ǎ Dz éĀȲȓDzÇŗĀ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ŗ ȓ éţĀ Āŝ ŴĀȲÇŗȓȲƆŅ ģȸǪ éţĀ ,ĀƼ ÇŲȓǪ ŅĀǪŲŴ Ƽŝ ƼĀƆ ŅĀ¥ Ȳȓǎ 0 ' .2 +04' '
ǣiƆDzĀǪĀ YǪƘéȲŲȓĀ DzţƆé ȸ¥ĀǪ ŴŴ ţƆ éĀǪ uĀŴȓá Ȳģ ŴŴĀƆ <ƘƆȓţƆĀƆȓĀƆ ƆɡȲȓǪĀģŝ ģĀƆǤá Dz Ņȓ éĀƆƆ ȲÇŗ ]ȲéƘŴģ uţȓȓ DzȓƘŴɡá Ų ȲģŽ ƆƆţDzÇŗĀǪ ,ĀDzÇŗ ģȓDzģȸŗŝ ǪĀǪ éĀDz iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆDzǎ ţĀ >ƟDzȲƆŝ ŅĀƆ éĀǪ *ţǪŽ DzţƆé ɡȲ ƨɥɥ YǪƘɡĀƆȓ Ȳģ éţĀ uȸƆDzÇŗĀ éĀǪ <ȲƆéĀƆ ɡȲŅĀŝ DzÇŗƆţȓȓĀƆǎ iŽ éĀƆ ĀéȸǪģƆţDzDzĀƆ éĀǪ `ÇŗţĀƆĀƆģ ŗǪɡĀȲŅŗĀǪDzȓĀŴŴĀǪ Žţȓ ŗƘŝ ŗĀǪ <ƘŽƼĀȓĀƆɡ ŅĀǪĀÇŗȓ ɡȲ ɓĀǪéĀƆá ǣ¥Āé Ǫģ ĀDz ĀţƆĀDz ǪĀŅĀƆ ȲƆé ţƆȓĀƆDzţŝ ɑĀƆ <ƘƆȓ ŲȓDzǤá ɓĀţň uţȓȓǎ ɡȲ ǣƆȲȓŝ
ɡĀƆ ɓţǪ Žţȓ ȲƆDzĀǪĀƆ Y ǪȓƆĀǪƆ `ȲƼƼŝ ŴɗŝƘƆ Ę ĀţƆĀ ¥ĀDzƘƆéĀǪĀ sŝYŴ ȓȓŝ ģƘǪŽǤá Dz Ņȓ éĀǪ ]ĀŅĀƆDz¥ȲǪŅĀǪ uţȓȓá éĀǪ ƨƉƉɥ ɡȲƆ ÇŗDzȓ ŴDz ƆŲĀǪ ţƆDz ȲƆéĀDzŴ Ɔé ` ÇŗDzĀƆ Ų Žǎ 0Ɔ éĀŽ `ɗDzȓĀŽ ɓȸǪéĀƆ éţĀ ƆƟȓţŅĀƆ 0ƆģƘǪŽ ŝ ȓţƘƆĀƆ ĀŴĀŲȓǪƘƆţDzÇŗ Ȳģ ŲȸǪɡĀDzȓĀŽ uĀŅĀ ȲDzŅĀȓ ȲDzÇŗȓǎ ŴDz ĀţDzƼţĀŴ ģȸǪ éĀƆ ŗƘŗĀƆ ,Ǫ é éĀǪ sĀǪƆĀȓɡȲƆŅ ƆĀƆƆȓ éĀǪ *ţǪŽĀƆŝ ÇŗĀģ éĀƆ dǪ ƆDzƼƘǪȓ éĀǪ ĀÇŲĀƆĀŴĀŝ ŽĀƆȓĀǎ ǣ ţĀDzĀ ȲȓĀţŴĀ ŲƟƆƆĀƆ ƆţÇŗȓ ĀţƆģ Çŗ ¥ĀŴţĀ¥ţŅ Ȳģ ĀţƆĀƆ > DzȓŲǪ ģȓŝ ɓ ŅĀƆ ɑĀǪŴ éĀƆ ɓĀǪéĀƆǎ sţĀŴŽĀŗǪ DzţƆé Ņ Ɔɡ DzƼĀɡţĀŴŴĀá DzĀŗǪ Ƙģȓ ɑƘƆ éĀƆ <ȲƆéĀƆ DzĀŴ¥Dzȓ ĀƆȓɓţÇŲĀŴȓĀ > éȲƆŅDzŝ ȓǪ ŅĀǪ ȲƆé ,ĀDzȓĀŴŴĀ ɑƘƆƆƟȓĀƆǎǤ ţĀDz Ž ÇŗĀ éţĀ ŅĀƆ ȲĀ <ƘƘǪéţƆ ȓţƘƆ Žţȓ éĀƆ ŰĀɓĀţŴţŅĀƆ `ƼĀéţȓţƘƆĀƆ ȲƆ ¥ŝ éţƆŅ¥ Ǫǎ ǣHŗƆĀ ĀĦɡţĀƆȓĀ sĀǪƆĀȓɡȲƆŅ Ŵ Ȳģȓ ŗţĀǪ ǪĀţƆ Ņ Ǫ ƆţÇŗȓDzǤá ţDzȓ éĀǪ B ŝ Ɔ ŅĀǪ ģĀDzȓ ȸ¥ĀǪɡĀȲŅȓǎ ţƆĀ ɓţÇŗȓţŅĀ `ĀţȓĀ éţĀDzĀǪ DĀȓɡŝ ɓĀǪŲĀ ţDzȓ éţĀ ,ĀDzȓ ŴȓȲƆŅ éĀǪ *ţƆ Ɔɡŝ ¥ĀɡţĀŗȲƆŅĀƆǎ ǣo¥ĀǪ ĀţƆ DzƘŅĀƆ ƆƆȓĀDz ]ĀɑĀǪDzĀŝ* ÇȓƘǪţƆŅ ɓĀǪéĀƆ éţĀ ŗŝ ŴȲƆŅDzģǪţDzȓĀƆ ɑĀǪŲȸǪɡȓǎ ǣ Dz ŗĀţňȓǤá
ĀǪŲŴ Ǫȓ éĀǪ B Ɔ ŅĀǪá ǣ ȲDz ¥Ǫ ƆÇŗĀƆŝ ȸ¥ŴţÇŗĀƆ Ȃɥ ¥ţDz Ɖɥ d ŅĀƆ ŗŴȲƆŅDzŝ ɡţĀŴ ɓĀǪéĀƆ ɓĀƆţŅĀ d ŅĀ ŝ ŅĀŅĀƆ ŗŴȲƆŅ ĀţƆĀDz ŅĀǪţƆŅĀƆ ¥DzÇŗŴ ŅDzǎǤ Dz ɑĀǪ¥ĀDzDzĀǪĀ ¥Āţ ` * éĀǪ ,Ž¥. éţĀ >ţǛȲţéţȓ ȓDzDzţȓȲ ȓţƘƆ DzƘɓţĀ éţĀ YŴ ƆȲƆŅDzDzţÇŗĀǪŗĀţȓǎ ' % 0 . ' 4' ' # ' éţĀ éĀȓ ţŴŴţĀǪȓĀƆ ¥DzƼǪ ÇŗĀƆ ɑƘƆ ȲģȓǪ Ņ ɡȲ ȲģȓǪ Ņ ţŽŽĀǪ ɓţĀéĀǪ ƆĀȲ ɡȲ ɑĀǪŗ ƆéĀŴƆ DzţƆéá ŲƘŽŽĀƆ éţĀ Y ǪȓƆĀǪ ƘŗƆĀ ĀƆŅŽ DzÇŗţŅĀá ŽƟŅŝ ŴţÇŗDzȓ ȲƆŲƘŽƼŴţɡţĀǪȓĀ sĀǪ¥ţƆéȲƆŅĀƆ ȲÇŗ ¥Āţ éĀƆ *ţƆ Ɔɡ¥ĀɡţĀŗȲƆŅĀƆ ƆţÇŗȓ ȲDzǎ ȲǪȸÇŲŗ ŴȓĀƆéĀǪ ţDzȓ uţȓȓ ŗţƆŅĀŅĀƆ ¥ĀţŽ fĀŽ <ƆƘɓŗƘɓŝ dǪ ƆDzģĀǪǎ ǣ.ţĀǪ Ų ƆƆ ĀţƆĀ ȸ¥ĀǪɡƘŅĀƆĀ PĥƆȲƆŅ éĀǪ iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ȲÇŗ ŅǪƘŝ ňĀ ]ţDzţŲĀƆ ¥ĀǪŅĀƆǤá ŽĀţƆȓ éĀǪ *ţǪŝ ŽĀƆÇŗĀģǎ D Çŗ sĀǪŴȲDzȓŰ ŗǪĀƆ DzÇŗǪĀţ¥ȓ é Dz iƆȓĀǪƆĀŗŽĀƆ ǣƆȲƆ DzĀţȓ ȧɥƨȂ DzÇŗɓ ǪɡĀ ŗŴĀƆǤá ģǪĀȲȓ DzţÇŗ uţȓȓá éĀǪ ɡȲDz ŽŽĀƆ Žţȓ DzĀţƆĀŽ ,Āŝ DzÇŗ ģȓDzģȸŗǪĀǪŲƘŴŴĀŅĀƆ ]Ƙ¥ĀǪȓ `ȓƟÇŲŝ ŴţƆŅĀǪ Ɔ éĀǪ *ţǪŽĀƆDzƼţȓɡĀ éĀDz iƆȓĀǪŝ ƆĀŗŽĀƆDz DzȓĀŗȓŕ
0]< <DH*
5XGROI :LWW LVW GHU NDXIP¥QQLVFKH *HVFK¥IWVI½KUHU GHV 8QWHUQHKPHQV
!
,0
(
' % * ' # + ##+ / $ &) *#"%! % + * * ## * 3 2! 2 (( 9:@ .@95 2(%* (1 @9@6 5 @5$@
' % * ' # + ##+ / $ &) *#"%! '% * #3 * )) :@ .@ :+ 2(%* (1 @9@6 5 @ $@
( (
(
(
' % * ' # + ##+ / $ &) '% # - *#"% ) ,* (( . .: :+ #-* ( (1 @9@694 $@:
%1% +2 "/ %
,1 1 .@ :@ #2 >>>1#, * 21 >>>1 ,,'1 ,)6 , (1 , * 2
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