CASTRO VALLEY FORUM CASTRO VALLEY FORUM Two Weeks til Christmas
TIME TO RETIRE
Creek Return
Ceremony marks return of creek to indigenous Sogorea Te’ Land Trust Page 3
It’s a Wrap!
RCHS wraps gifts for Rotary’s Children’s Christmas Party Page 4
Wildcats Win Creekside defeats Canyon in Battle of the Valley fag football Page 12
Rudy’s Donuts Closing
By Michael Singer CASTRO VALLEY FORUM
After 60 years of serving donuts, coffee, and memories to Castro Valley, the family behind Rudy’s Donuts says it is time to retire.
Last week, sisters Gina Gatto Alfaro and Angela Gatto Ducato posted a notice on the doors announcing the news. The shop will be open until Sunday, December 22.
“Thank you for letting us be a part of your family,” Gina, Angela, and Staff said in the notice.
As a business, Rudy’s was able to weather several fnancial obstacles including the COVID-19 pandemic.
Still, the retirement news was a shock to some customers.
“Friday was Donut Day when I dropped the boys at school,” resident Geno Zertuche says. “It was the only time they would be in the car before me. I am truly going to miss these nice ladies...and the chocolate chip donuts!”
Fans of Rudy’s started lining up right after the news and all this week to make sure they could get their favorite sweet treats. see RUDY’S on back page
More than 300 people showed up to Castro Village Shopping Center last Friday, December 6, to see the annual Christmas Tree Lighting. The event has been a tradition in the center of town since the 1950s, and it has been a perennial favorite for families ever since. The event featured performances from the Castro Valley School of Music, the Castro Valley Performing Arts Center Dancers, the Castro Valley High School Madrigals Choir, and the CVHS Alumni Choir. The ceremony also included the infamous Grinch trying to steal Christmas away only to be stopped by Alameda County Sheriff’s Offce deputies and Santa himself. The evening was also a chance for families to take photos with Santa, his elves, and even the Grinch, who changed his ways and welcomed the holiday spirit into town.
Permit, Approval And Site
The popular Castro Valley Marketplace received an extension on its current permit, the bowling alley got approval for an extensive renovation, and the future of the Rudy’s Donuts site was discussed at this week’s meeting of the Castro Valley Municipal Advisory Council (MAC).
The MAC unanimously approved a revised conditional use permit for the continued operation of the Castro Valley Marketplace at 3295 Castro Valley Boulevard, including sales of alcoholic beverages. The MAC heard the matter as a routine fve-year update on the original permit, but the current controversy about the paseo and outdoor dining at the site was not discussed.
County staff said the ongoing ligation about the paseo and shared parking were not part of the permit review and that an update on that lawsuit would happen in the future.
The current review was regarding maintenance of the building and how their liquor license has been going and the MAC gave the owners the see MAC on page 10
CVUSD Test Scores Slipped a Bit This Year
By Mike McGuire CASTRO VALLEY FORUM
Castro Valley Unifed School District (CVUSD)
student test scores slipped a bit this year, according to the latest results from the state Department of Education California School Dashboard, designed to let parents compare school district outcomes
The scores remained, how-
ever, above state averages in most areas. In several categories, CVUSD exceeded state standards where many districts had trouble meeting them, particularly in the wake of the pandemic.
There was a drop of 4.9 points in English Language Arts, but this was still 31.5 points above the state’s subject-area standards. The average district statewide scored
13.2 points below the standard.
There was a small drop of 0.9 points in Mathematics, but this remained 12.3 points above state standards. This score put them well ahead of most other districts, who averaged 47.6 points below the state standard.
The graduation rate, already in the state’s highest group of districts, rose a further 0.9 percent to 96 percent. This
compares with a statewide rate of 86.7 percent. There were also small gains in science, by 0.2 percent and in reducing suspensions, by 0.4 percent.
Chronic absenteeism fell by 5.2 percent. This dropped it to 11 percent of students missing 10 percent or more of instructional days. It compares to an 18.6 percent statewide rate.
There was a drop of 9.2 percent in English language
learners making progress toward profciency, with 46.4 percent making progress. This is just above the statewide average of 45.7 percent.
Seniors who met state standards for college or work preparedness dropped by 13.1 percent, to a 47.3 preparation rate. This is also just above the statewide average, which is 45.3 percent.
see CVUSD on page 3
PHOTO BY MICHAEL SINGER
By Amy Sylvestri
CASTRO VALLEY FORUM
‘Tri-Chamber’ Holiday Mixer Held at Eden Medical Center
More than 100 people from the Hayward, San Leandro, and Castro Valley Chambers of Commerce gathered for an amazing evening at Eden Medical Center on December 5.
Billed as the “Tri-Chamber Mixer,” attendees spent the evening networking, celebrating holiday cheer, and creating community connections. The event hosted by Sutter Health was also a massive fundraising opportunity. Non-perishable
and canned goods were donated to the Davis Street Community Center program, which helps women and children in need. There was also a huge donation of toys for the Alameda County Sheriff’s Offce Holiday Toy Drive.
Newly elected California State Senator District 9 Tim Grayson was a special guest of honor who expressed gratitude for the jobs and services that the Chamber membership
represents in the community.
“I’m honored and humbled to represent parts of Alameda County, San Leandro, and San Lorenzo,” Grayson said.
“What an awesome experience it is to be able to come and be with you all—the backbone of California’s economy—small businesses.”
For more information, visit: www.edenareachamber.com/ www.sanleandrochamber.com/ and https://hayward.org/
Start New Year Off Right with CVACE
2025 is fast approaching— and so is the opportunity to earn your GED or high school diploma! Castro Valley Adult & Career Education will be offering GED classes beginning in January. Students have the option of traditional, in-person classes held on Wednesday and Thursday evenings from 6:30
to 9pm or a Distance Learning/Lab. These courses are taught in English by certifed instructors and are offered free of charge. Attendance during the frst week of class is crucial for a successful start, and students must maintain at least 80% attendance to remain enrolled. The Science portion
is scheduled for January 8 through February 13, 2025, Math is scheduled for February 26 through May 22, 2025 and Reasoning is scheduled for February 26 through May 22, 2025.
Looking for a different schedule or online learning?
Castro Valley Adult & Career Education has those, too! Visit: https://cvace.link/ase or call (510) 886-1000 for more information.
You’re invited!
Our Christmas Eve services are on December 24th at 5:00 and 9:00 PM
All are welcome!
Faith Lutheran Church of Castro Valley
20080 Redwood Road
Castro Valley, CA 94546
www.flccv.org
Castro Valley Weather December 11 - December 15, 2024
Past Week’s Rain: 00.00
Season To Date: 01:65
Normal To Date: 00.00
Season Average: 00.00
The California Highway Patrol partnered with the Rotary Club of Castro Valley providing gifts for children from a local battered women’s shelter and homeless shelter for their upcoming Children’s Christmas Party, chaired by Mark Poniatowski. Above are: (front row) CV Rotarian Ceta Dochterman and Offcer Natasha Ocegueda and (back row) Linda Lee Johnson, CV Rotarian Bruce D. Johnson, Offcer David Leonard and Offcer Arturo Robles.
CVUSD: Academic Standards
continued from front page Castro Valley’s preparedness rate in 2024 was lower than last year’s, but also lower than in pre-pandemic 2019.
The district met the 2024 standard for implementing the state’s latest academic standards.
CVUSD also met standards for ensuring access to a broad course of study for its students. The state evaluators did make several suggestions for increasing access for some student groups.
The state reported that Castro Valley met the standard for teachers, instructional materials, and facilities. The district reported no students lacking access to their own copies of instructional materials both for home and school, and all facilities were reported in good repair. The district said 100 percent of all complaints received were acted on quickly.
The district fully implemented the state standards for parent and family engagement but reported to the state that they wouldn’t be fully satisfed until they fully live up to their motto of “all means all.” They would like to involve any parents not currently involved, they said.
The state said CVUSD met the standards for a local climate survey given annually, with the results acted on.
istrict offcials were not able to comment on the results in instructional areas as we went to press but promised to do so in the weeks ahead.
See more at: https://www. caschooldashboard.org/
Corrina ould, co founder of the ogorea e’ Land rust and also chairwoman of the Confederated Villages of Lis an tribe, speaks on uesday, December at the return of three acres of an Loren o Creek near Ruby treet and Crescent Avenue to the land trust on behalf of the tribe. den ousing donated the land, which it had bought along with nearby land to build affordable apartments.
Ceremony Marks Return Of Creek to Lisjan People
By Mike McGuire CASTRO VALLEY FORUM
Part of San Lorenzo Creek was returned to the indigenous Sogorea Te’ Land Trust last Tuesday, December 3, and other changes are in store for the area around Crescent Avenue and Ruby Street.
People at the return ceremony saw the beginning of construction of a fve mile long Creekway for pedestrians and bicycles, beginning at Crescent Avenue and continuing to the Bay. Eden Housing donated
a quarter-acre of land to the Hayward Area Recreation and Parks District (HARD) for a trailhead and pocket park in Hayward.
The Creekway will connect the communities of Castro Valley, Hayward, San Lorenzo, Ashland, Cherryland and San Leandro.
Corrina Gould, co-founder of Sogorea Te’ and chairwoman of the Confederated Villages of Lisjan, said “I’m amazed by the miracle that has happened. We’re amazed to have this piece of our waterway.”
The Lisjan people, who Europeans called the Ohlone, were the original inhabitants of the land along the creek, which they knew as Lisjan and from which they drew their name, Gould said adding that the Lisjan creation myth is that the people arose from the sacred creek of Lisjan and the sacred mountain that European settlers renamed Mount Diablo. She thanked Dr. Ann Maris and the other members of the Grove Way Neighborhoods Association (GWNA) for their see CREEK on page 10
Sheriff’s Reports
COMPILED BY MICHAEL SINGER • CASTRO VALLEY FORUM
Spousal Assault
Sunday, December 8: At 7:32 p.m., Sheriff’s Deputies arrested a 34-year-old CV woman on suspicion of spousal assault. An anonymous call about a loud and aggressive-sounding argument sent deputies to an apartment on Grove Way near Morales Court. There, they handcuffed the woman and took her into custody. The victim was treated at the scene.
Caught Trespassing
Sunday, December 8: At 12:25 a.m., a 44-year-old woman with no permanent residence was arrested on suspicion of trespassing on private property. Deputies responded to a suspicious person report at a home on Bridge Court near Grove Way. The woman was taken into custody.
Public Intoxication
Saturday, December 7: At 8:19 a.m., deputies arrested a 36-year-old CV man on suspicion of public intoxication. The man was hanging outside a gas station on Castro Valley Boulevard near Redwood Road when deputies stopped him for questioning and smelled alcohol on his breath. The man failed his feld sobriety test and was taken into custody.
Busted for Vandalism
Friday, December 6: At 1:20 a.m., a 36-year-old man with no permanent residence was arrested on suspicion of damaging private property and violating the terms of his parole. Deputies responded to a suspicious person report
outside a church on Grove Way near Redwood Road. The man was taken to Santa Rita Jail.
Refused to Leave Hospital Wednesday, December 4: At 3:40 a.m., deputies arrested a 70-year-old Castro Valley man on suspicion of refusing to leave an establishment when repeatedly asked to by managers, possessing illegal drug paraphernalia, and resisting arrest. The man was hanging out at Eden Medical Center on Lake Chabot Road when staff repeatedly asked him to leave for unspecifed reasons. he man was taken into custody.
Assault and Battery
Tuesday, December 3: At 7:39 p.m., a 19-year-old CV man was arrested on suspicion of assault and battery as well as damaging public property outside the Castro Valley Library. Deputies were called to the scene following a report of an altercation. The man was taken into custody. The victim was treated at the scene.
PHOTOS BY MIKE McGUIRE
COMMUNITY CALENDAR
TONIGHT • Wednesday, December 11
Smalltown Society The LAB: Featuring Casket Ring onight at he Lab, Smalltown Society is e cited to feature Casket ing, whose uni ue artistry will inspire and connect with the Smalltown community. he Lab welcomes songwriters and poets to workshop, collaborate, and share their creations in a warm, welcoming space. oin us, invitation is by email only: info smalltownsociety.com for more information and location.
TOMORROW • Thursday, December 12
CV Library’s Homework Center Volunteer Orientation he Castro Valley Library is looking for dedicated and enthusiastic igh School student volunteers, ust a few hours a week, for its after school omework ssistance Center. Orientation takes place tomorrow, hursday, ec. at pm at the Castro Valley Library. re you looking for community service hours or need some ob e perience for your resume Sign up for hours and help students tackle their homework, gain valuable e perience, and have fun. Contact the Library at for more information.
TOMORROW • Thursday, December 12
Chabot College Holiday Big Band Concert
Chabot College is e cited to present their oliday ig and Concert tomorrow, hursday, ecember at pm at the eed L. uffngton Visual erforming rts Center, uilding , at esperian oulevard in ayward. he performance features Chabot College a Ensemble, directed by on alacio r., and will include ilipino born merican singer guest artist Ellona Santiago and actress, singer songwriter, and recording artist pril bsynth. he Chabot College a Ensemble is Chabot’s top multi award winning student a group that consists primarily of music ma ors. icket prices vary and can be purchased online at urple ass.com. oors open at : . or additional uestions, email on alacio at palacio chabotcollege.edu.
Friday - Sunday, December 13 - 15
On Thursday, December 5, thirty fve edwood Christian igh School students dedicated their lunch hour to wrapping packages for the otary Club of Castro Valley Children’s Christmas arty, which took place yesterday, for children from uby’s lace and ESCO anyon ouse and Les ar uis ouse .
he packages were collected by the California ighway atrol and selected to match the children who will be attending. he students wrapped the packages and labeled them.
r. Evan arnhart, irector of CS lobal, coordinated the event and Castro Valley otarian Ceta was present to set up and assist the students.
C S students will also attend the Children’s Christmas arty for face painting, balloon animals, coloring and simply to be friends.
he party brought together many community organi ations and schools including otary Club of Castro Valley, California ighway atrol, lameda County ire epart-
ment, Castro Valley nifed School istrict, edwood Christian Schools, Castro Valley Sanitary istrict, obert offman of Club nywhere as well as members from the community. Castro Valley otarian ark oniatowski chairs the party each year. See many more photos online at: mycvforum.com
Adult Technology Classes Start January
Enrollment has begun for Castro Valley Library’s EE technology classes for the month of anuary oin us for these hands on, rela ed pace classes, designed for people who have never used a computer or have very little e perience and want a solid introduction. he classes are: Introduction to Computers Saturday, anuary , : am to : pm. opics covered in
this class will include the parts of a computer, the types of computers and mobile devices, how to set up a desktop or laptop, and more Learning to use a Mouse, Touch Pad & Keyboard Saturday, anuary , : pm to : pm. his hands on class is targeted at beginning computer users and will introduce students to the mouse, keyboard, and other essential skills.
Learning to Use the Internet Saturday, anuary , : am to : pm. eeling left behind on the nformation Superhighway Learn about the nternet and the orld ide eb. his hands on class is targeted at beginning computer users and will introduce students to using a web browser, getting to websites, and navigating a website. Internet Searching Saturday, anuary , : pm
to : pm. Students will learn how to fnd information on the nternet using the search engine oogle. ou’ll also learn more advanced searching techni ues and other cool oogle features.
Students will use library provided laptops during class. dvance registration is re uired. egister online at www.aclibrary.org click on Events or call .
Morrisson Theatre Chorus Holiday Concert he orrisson heatre Chorus returns for a oyous holiday concert on riday and Saturday, ecember and at pm and Sunday, ecember at pm, at the ouglas orrisson heater. his unforgettable night of uplifting music is sure to raise spirits and spark the holiday mood. Cesar Cancino directs and entertains with his informative and witty comments about the musical selections and talented solo performers. on’t miss this night of glorious music and fun. ickets can be purchased at the offces E St. ayward or online at haywardrec.org/ theater. Call for assistance if needed. ickets will not be available at the door. he ouglas orrison heater is located at hird St., ayward.
Saturday, December 14
Castro Valley School of Music’s Winter Recital oin Castro Valley School of usic for a magical day of music as their talented students take the stage. on’t miss out on this wonderful winter celebration. he event takes place on Saturday, ecember . here will be two showtimes am and pm at edwood d. Suite , Castro Valley. or tickets, please email annee very at: wannee cvsom.com or call .
Wednesday, December 18
CVACE Community Band Holiday Concert e entertained with delightful seasonal favorites during ll hings oliday by the Castro Valley dult Career Education musicians. ote the change of venue and take a nostalgic trek up the hill to the Canyon iddle School cafeteria Cull Canyon oad at : pm to en oy a family friendly evening of free music and winter cheer.
PHOTO COURTESY OF CRYSTAL BECERRA
HEYER CENTER
Corner of Heyer Ave. and Center St., Castro Valley Wishes you Happy Holidays
CAFÉ RUMI
*Present
We specialize in quality Mediterranean foods and drinks. Try our special drink.... a “Pink Cha”.... very refreshing!
STUDIO ONE SEVEN SALON AT HEYER CENTER
New guest and returning clients are always welcome in our cozy remodeled salon. Make your appointment early for the holidays.
BOY SCOUT CHRISTMAS TREE LOT AT HEYER CENTER Open Nov. 29th.; specializing in freshly cut Douglas. Noble and Grand r trees. Proceeds from sales help support Boy Scout activities.
MOXIE WOMEN’S FITNESS
We specialize in providing individual tness programs for women Let us customize a tness program for you.
HEYER HOUSE LIQUOR
We carry a wide selection of beers, wine and liquor to meet your holiday needs.
HEYER
Make Wise Lighting Decisions for the Holidays
By Carl Medford, CRS Special to
With the Holiday Season upon us, lights are appearing everywhere. Not only are numerous strings outlining homes across the county, but they are also hung inside as well, especially on the Christmas trees that are a central part of many Bay Area family’s holiday celebrations. Additionally, it seems that every year more front yards are decorated with
no end of festive items ranging from Nativity scenes to blow-up Santas, reindeer, snowmen and more.
All of this can add up to a serious surge in electrical consumption at this time of year and even potential overloads to older electrical systems. We have two suggestions to keep you safe this Holiday Season. Do not overload your electrical system. Overloaded electrical circuits can heat up the
Experience Matters!
Thinking of Buying or Selling a Home? Call for a no-cost, no-obligation consultation.
Ken Kremer, Broker, CRS, ABR, SRES 510-301-1957 KrEmerTeam@aol.com
Corner of Heyer Ave. and Center Wishes you Happy
Corner of Heyer Ave. and Center Wishes you Happy CAFÉ RUMI
REAL ESTATE GALLERY REAL ESTATE GALLERY
wiring, increasing the potential of a fre. his can be especially true in older homes with signifcantly outdated electrical systems. A sign that a system is overloading is a frequent tripping of an electrical breaker or blowing a fuse. The correct response should circuits continue to shut off is to reduce the load by either unplugging things or only allowing a limited number of items to be on at the same time.
The second approach would be to hire a licensed electrician to analyze your electrical system and make upgrades as necessary. Some homeowners, attempting to solve ongoing issues without the cost of upgrades swap out breakers or fuses that constantly trip with those with a higher capacity. This can be EXTREMELY dangerous and is not recommended under any circumstances.
Go with LED lighting.
The relatively recent advent of LED lighting and subsequent decreases in pricing has been a complete game changer. As an example, an 8-bulb chandelier with 60W bulbs
Mortgage Rates Continue to Decrease
This week, mortgage rates decreased to their lowest level in over a month. Despite just a modest drop in rates, consumers clearly have responded as purchase demand has noticeably improved. The responsiveness of prospective homebuyers to even small changes in rates illustrates that affordability headwinds persist.
We specialize in quality Mediterranean and drinks. Try our special drink.... very refreshing! STUDIO ONE SEVEN SALON AT New guest and returning clients welcome in our cozy remodeled your appointment early for the BOY SCOUT CHRISTMAS TREE LOT Open Nov. 29th.; specializing in freshly Noble and Grand r trees. Proceeds support Boy Scout activities. MOXIE WOMEN’S FITNESS We specialize in providing individual programs for women Let us customize program for you.
HEYER CENTER
HEYER CENTER
Corner of Heyer Ave. and Center St., Castro Valley Wishes you Happy Holidays
CAFÉ RUMI
Corner of Heyer Ave. and Center St., Castro Valley Wishes you Happy Holidays
The Cathy Brent Team would like to wish all a Wonderful Holiday Season flled with everything good that life can bring!
We specialize in quality Mediterranean foods and drinks. Try our special drink.... a “Pink Cha”.... very refreshing!
STUDIO ONE SEVEN SALON AT HEYER CENTER
CENTER
New guest and returning clients are always welcome in our cozy remodeled salon. Make your appointment early for the holidays.
BOY SCOUT CHRISTMAS TREE LOT AT HEYER CENTER Open Nov. 29th.; specializing in freshly cut Douglas. Noble and Grand r trees. Proceeds from sales help support Boy Scout activities.
MOXIE WOMEN’S FITNESS
Thank You to all our clients past, present & future for entrusting us with your business and contributing to our status as Berkshire Hathaway’s #1 Team. We could not have done it without you! We look forward to helping you all in the New Year.
Cathy, Kathi, Wayne, Linda & Kelly
We specialize in providing individual tness programs for women Let us customize a tness program for you.
HEYER HOUSE LIQUOR
We carry a wide selection of beers, wine and liquor to meet your holiday needs.
consumes a total of 480 watts. In contrast, comparable LED replacement lights draw 5.5W each, for a total of only 44 watts – less than 10%! Since a typical 15A circuit should only handle a maximum of 1,440W, reducing the wattage required to light your home can result in signifcant savings and increased safety.
Keep this in mind as well when hanging those strings of holiday lights. The new LED strings use dramatically less power than the old incandescent bulbs and also last a lot longer. Although it may cost a bit to replace older strings, the change will pay for itself in short order and mean you can actually add more lights if desired.
Carl Medford is a licensed Realtor with Keller Williams Realty and a licensed general contractor. This article is sponsored by the Central County Marketing Association.
the Forum
Winter Is the Best Time to Transplant Roses
By Buzz Bertolero The Dirt
QIs this a good time to transplant several mature roses from one garden area to another? Should it be done before or after they have been pruned, or does it matter? Also, can I plant new roses in the same spot?
AMost gardening books recommend transplanting roses while they are dormant; however, with our mild temperatures, roses never go entirely dormant; it is also not unusual for them to have buds and blooms, although the foliage looks crummy. The ideal window to relocate or transplant roses along with other landscape shrubs and conifers is from Thanksgiving through mid-March. Typically, most
gardeners wait until after the holidays to transplant. You prune before or after, as it doesn’t matter. I prefer to prune them back frst so there are fewer branches and thorns to get in the way by reducing the height and sides. Roses have an extensive spreading root system, so you’ll leave some behind. You may bareroot the plants. The lack of soil now is not a problem because of the cool conditions. You can also spread this task over several days or weekends. Once out of the ground, you can store them above the ground by covering them with a tarp or plant them in temporary containers. Roses survive beautifully after being mistreated. When you’re ready to replant, avoid a common mistake and plant them too deep. The top of the frst root should be at or near the soil surface. All too often,
the bushes are planted up to the bud union. The bud union is where the desirable rose variety is budded to the rootstock and should be above ground. The distance between the roots and the bud union varies signifcantly with each bush. Problems develop from the poor drainage of our clay soils and the constant moisture from frequent watering. I’m unaware of any issues preventing you from planting a new rose in the old location(s). The new roses for 2025, along with many of your old favorites, will arrive at your favorite garden center later this month.
QThis summer, I planted three large Coleus plants in pots in partial shade. Will they
survive the winter or should I take them inside?
AColeus is a plant that adapts to indoor and outdoor conditions. They will survive the winter outside as long as the temperatures stay above forty degrees. However, they grow nicely indoors in a room with lots of direct or indirect light. To be safe, I’d move them indoors now and then back outdoors in early March after the danger of frost has passed. At that time, I’d prune off fifty percent of the growth and fertilize with Osmocote or other similar time-release fertilizer to encourage the lateral growth.
Buzz Bertolero is an Advanced California Certified Nursery Professional. The Dirt Gardener’s website is www.dirtgardener.com
WEEKEND GARDENER
Dormant Spray
f you missed the frst dormant spray period in late ovember, do it now! It’s better to spray late than not at all.
Holiday Plants
eep those owering gift plants, like poinsettias, in a cool spot with bright, indirect sunlight. It’s important that they do not sit in water, so peel away the decorative foil from the bottom of the pot and set the pot in a saucer.
Bulb Bargains
Look for specials on Dutch bulbs, such as daffodils, hyacinths and tulips at your local garden center. When you buy, choose those that are still frm and plant them as soon as possible. ulips will beneft from chilling in your refrigerator for si weeks prior to planting.)
Vegetables
Although sunlight and warmth are at their ebb right now, some seeds will germinate. Sow chard, kale, romaine lettuce, onions, peas, radishes and spinach, but expect the plants to grow very slowly.
Prune and Decorate
Prune conifers, holly and broadleaf evergreens to shape them. Then, use the trimmings for holiday decorations.
Gardener
ANNOUNCEMENTS
You can run a classified ad for a little as $35 a week. Your ad runs in both of our newspapers, the Castro Valley Forum on Wednesday and the San Leandro Times on Thursday. You can also save by placing your ad on our website at castrovalleyforum.com or sanleandrotimes.com. We’ll call you for your credit or debit card info for payment. To place an ad by phone call Patrick Vadnais at 510-614-1560, Mon-Fri 9 a.m. - 1 p.m.
To Place a Garage Sale Ad call 614-1558
CONCRETE SERVICE
S.L. CONCRETE SERVICE Driveways, Sidewalks, Stamped Concrete, Retaining Walls, Tree and Drain Service. Lic.#982202. 510856-8937.
CONTRACTOR SERVICE
NOTICETO READERS
California law requires that contractors taking jobs that total $500 or more (labor or materials) be licensed by the Contractors State License Board. State Law also requires that contractors include their license number on all advertising. Advertisers appearing on this page without a license number indicate that the contractor is not licensed. You can check the status of your licensed contractor at www.cslb.ca.gov or (800) 321-2752. Unlicensed contractors taking jobs that total less than $500 must state in their advertisements that they are not licensed by the Contractors State License Board.
FENCES/DECKS
Fence wobbly? Call Randy's Fence Reinforcement and save thousands! 510-706-6189.
FENCES/DECKS
*SPECIALIZING IN WOOD FENCES, DECKS & RETAINING WALLS. Replace or repair, paved walkways, yard cleaning, tree work, brush removal (fire prevention), garage cleaning/ debris removal. Insured & Bonded #8189. Jerry 510-410-2427.
GARDENING
JAIME’S GARDENING
Maintenance, Trimming, Cleanups, Hauling, Sprinkler Repair/ Timers. FREE Estimates. Insured. 510-299-9583
*BEAUTYGARDEN LANDSCAPING
Design - Construction - Maintenance. Cleanups, New Lawn, Artificial Grass, Irrigation, Patios, Pathways, Brick, Stone, Concrete Fence/ Decks. Free Estimates! Lic.#925130. 510-691-8852. www.beautygardenlandscaping.com
NAVA'SCOMPLETE LANDSCAPING: Mowing, trees, cleanup, hauling, FREE estimates. 510 512-5857.
GIVEAWAYS
FREE 30 gal nice fish tank with all accessories including walnut cabinet stand, also free kitchen sink hookup washing machine. Both in very good condition. Call 510-909-4409.
HAULING SERVICE
HAULING: Small and Big Jobs. Furniture, Concrete, Wood, Trash, Metal, Demolition. Also house inside/ outside cleanups. 510-715-1578.
Advertise your Home for rent in the San Leandro Times & Castro Valley Forum DON’T LET ANOTHER WEEK SLIPBY!
– Avacancy day is money lost forever –To place an ad call 510-614-1558
The City of San Leandro is now accepting online applications for Management Analyst I/II8,974 - $12,040/month
For more detailed information, please visit www.sanleandro.org. EOE
HOME SERVICES GUIDE
Help for the homeowner means business for you!
To Place an Ad ... Call 614-1558
Please BOYCE ELLIS be advised and put on notice that a small claims lawsuit in the amount of $3,852. 58 for move out charges has been filed on March 1, 2024 in the county of Alameda against Boyce Ellis for his contract of renting at the premises of 1555 164th Ave. apartment number 35 by the Plaintiff, San Leandro Ashland LLC, with the defendant being Boyce Ellis case number 24SC66034. This notice is to serve as publication of service as per the order granted and dated October 21, 2024 to run in this newspaper for four consecutive weeks.Contact plaintiff at Ashland Office located at 1555 164th Ave San Leandro, CA94578, 510-278-3920, Ashlandmanor@jleproperties.com
NEED - MUSIC LESSONS or PIANO TUNING?
Check the Classified Ads under “MUSICALSERVICES” for help.
Please JOSE AVILA be advised and put on notice that a small claims lawsuit in the amount of $3,099.84 for move out charges has been filed on March 1st, 2024 in the county of Alameda against Jose Avila for his contract of renting at the premises of 1570 164th Ave. apartment number
56 by the Plaintiff, San Leandro Shamor LLC, with the defendant being Jose Avila case number 24SC66032. This notice is to serve as publication of service as per the order granted and dated October 21, 2024 to run in this newspaper for four consecutive weeks.Contact plaintiff at Shamor Office located at 1570 164th Ave San Leandro, CA94578, 510-278-1889 Shamor apartments@jleproperties.com
MISC. FOR SALE
Model Airplane $50. Call at 510-8258412.
RENTALS/RV SPACES
RV/ Trailer space in San Leandro and Oakland& Hayward. $950/ month. Call 510-481-9901.
TREE SERVICE
*ACAREFULTREE SERVICE. Certified. Arborist. Lic.#694067. Trimming, Removals. FREE Estimates Bonded. Call 510-581-7377.
CLASSIFIED AD DEADLINE: Monday 5:00 p.m.
AC Proposal to Turn Rudy’s Site Into A Kids Konnect Infant Care, Preschool
continued from front page thumbs-up to continue as-is.
Speaker and Castro Valley Chamber of Commerce President & CEO Gary Slate told the MAC that the Marketplace was a major asset to the community
“They’ve been good Chamber members,” said Slate. “They are good to work with for events and we’ve had a ton of positive feedback from the community.”
However, when the initial permit was issued, a crosswalk for easier pedestrian access to the Marketplace was in the plans. That never materialized in the subse uent fve years and the MAC wanted to know why. The marketplace owners said that the county did not really seem enthusiastic about the crosswalk and it kind of just fell by the wayside. The MAC instructed the owners and county to address the crosswalk or at least some other pedestrian-friendly options before bringing the matter back before the MAC for a follow-up discussion in June 2025.
The MAC also gave unanimous approval for plans to allow an exterior renovation of the existing Castro Village
Bowl building in the Village. There will be a new outdoor dining and the construction of a new commercial building as well as the demolition of two current buildings.
The bowling alley has been in business since 1959 and the owners have proposed a retro vibe for the remodeled façade. Following this week’s approval, the county anticipates it will take six months to a year to pull permits, then another 12 to 18 months for construction.
Two tenants are currently in the building that will be demolished, but they will be offered alternative locations in the Village, though one has indicated that they will leave.
MAC Chair Chuck Moore thanks the owners for being willing to take on major improvements to a landmark in town.
“Thank you for presenting upgrades to the center,” said Moore. “It would be wonderful to see more applications like this.”
Finally, the MAC was not so positive about a proposal to turn the current Rudy’s donuts site at 3692 Castro Valley Boulevard into a Kids Konnect Infant Care and Preschool.
The location has been home
Homework Volunteers
The Castro Valley Library is looking for dedicated and enthusiastic High School student volunteers, just a few hours a week, for its after-school Homework Assistance Center.
Are you looking for community service hours or need some job experience for your resume? Sign up for hours and help students tackle their homework, gain valuable experience, and have fun. Contact the Castro Valley Library at 510-667-7900 for more information or visit their website at: https://aclibrary.org/ locations/csv/
to Rudy’s Donuts for more than 60 years, but the owners have announced plans to retire and the beloved shop will close for good just before Christmas.
Property owner Dr. Jennifer Yang previously attempted to get approval to put her own dental practice in the spot but she withdrew that application after community feedback overwhelmingly demanded a café, donut spot, or similar use for the space.’ Said yang.
“I am acutely aware how important this place is to the community,
Yang returned with the proposal for the day for up to 55 kids, but once again the MAC rebuffed her, saying retail or even mixed-use retail/ housing use was more appropriate for the location in the business corridor.
Everyone acknowledged that affordable childcare is necessary, but they simply don’t like it in a busy thoroughfare right off the Boulevard. Other concerns were the lack of parking and defned pick up and drop off areas for the kids, as well as space and noise issues.
“This isn’t a NIMBY (Not in My Backyard) thing, this is a ‘not in this location’ thing,” said MAC Vice-Chair Bill Mulgrew. The need is there, I just have a hard time with that location.”
Yang can resubmit another proposal for her property or go around the MAC to appeal to the Board of Supervisors to approve her current proposal.
Note: The upcoming MAC Land Use scheduled for Monday, December 23 is likely to be cancelled due to lack of agenda items.
Offcials from ogorea e’ Land
Creek Crescent Grove Apartments
continued from page 3 efforts to save Ruby Meadow and instead have affordable housing built on other abandoned Caltrans sites nearby.
aris said, once that fght was lost, the GWNA tried to have some good come out of the effort. They wanted the creek itself returned to its original owners, the Lisjan. They also wanted to wisely reuse the 100 large oak trees cut down to build the apartments.
Meanwhile, the Crescent Grove apartments, built on the former Ruby Meadows natural area after considerable community opposition, will be welcoming their frst residents soon, perhaps by the end of the year, according to an Eden Housing spokesperson.
There were 6800 applicants for 71 spaces in the apartments, according to Darian Williams of the nonproft group.
Some 60 percent of the apartment site has been preserved as open space, with some of that open to the public, he said. None of that space had been available to the public previously, Williams added.
In addition to preserving the land, a spokesperson for Bay Area Redwoods, a Livermore-based company that makes furniture and other useful items from perished trees, said it will repurpose the 330 cubic yards of logs cut to create the housing for tables and other items in common areas of the new apartments.
rust, the Lis an tribe, den ousing, Caltrans and the rove ay Neighborhood Association gathered on uesday, December to celebrate the return of three acres of an Loren o Creek near Ruby treet and Crescent Avenue to the land trust. den ousing donated the land, which it had bought along with nearby land to build affordable apartments.
he new Crescent rove apartments, almost ready for occupancy, rise over early construction from a fve mile long Creekway bicycle pedestrian path from Castro Valley to the Bay along an Loren o Creek.
’m ama ed by the mir acle that has happened. e’re ama ed to have this piece of our water way. Corrina ould
FROM THE BOULEVARD
Christmas and Johnny Mathis
By Thomas Lorentzen SPECIAL TO THE FORUM
Writers can be lonely hunters in their pursuit of stories. As I searched for one for this column it was imperative that it reference with relevance the Christmas season upon us. We know the story – it is spiritual and about the birth of Christ. Proper elements are gratitude, appreciation, and love. As I searched for a topic, one was found while attending the annual Christmas tree lighting ceremony in the Village.
Although it is 2024, memories returned from attending the same event in 1954. It was like yesterday, yet it was today. I was eight years old in 1954. Now I’m approaching 80 years old. Memories marched through my mind.
As I appreciate the present and re ect on the past, a story comes to mind that is perhaps worthy of sharing. It is about a famed and favorite singer from the Bay Area. His name is Johnny Mathis. His voice and music have owed melli uously throughout my life. Love songs and Christmas music have been a special focus for him. From everything I had learned of him as a person, he was known as a sensitive and kind man. From interviews, he credited his mom and dad for enabling him to fnd true meaning in his life.
n ecember of was living in Reno. An invitation was extended by friends to go
As holiday celebrations continue into ecember, the American Red Cross encourages donors to keep the blood supply top of mind by giving blood or platelets this month. Type O negative blood donors and those giving platelets are especially urged to give now to help ensure patients can continue to receive the care they need in the coming weeks.
Record-breaking travel since November is expected to carry into the new year, which could cause some potential donors to put off blood donation until after the holiday season. In addition to millions of Americans traveling to spend holidays with loved ones, extended vacations are also surging in popularity at a time when fewer people may be available to give lifesaving blood products. Bring joy to someone
to Lake Tahoe to have dinner and see a show. Our dinner was to be at the North Shore Club. It was a place of elegance with coat and tie required. Afterward, we were going to see a performance by Johnny Mathis and the Henry Mancini Orchestra. A heavy snowstorm fell that afternoon on t. ose. espite the impediment, we proceeded ahead.
After dinner we went to the showroom. The storm had signifcantly reduced the si e of the audience. espite that, Johnny Mathis and the Mancini Orchestra put on a spirited performance. The audience was appreciative. The performers were proud.
Twenty years later I was invited to attend a private dinner party at a famed restaurant in Beverly Hills (Chasen’s). There would be 279 of us there to have dinner with Ronald and Nancy Reagan. It was a tuxedo and gown event. Hollywood celebrities were abundant among us.
As a surprise, Johnny Mathis showed up with a couple of musicians. Unknown to me, he was a close friend of the Reagans. After dinner he informally performed for us. It was a special evening. As the evening was ending, I decided to have a glass of wine at the bar. As I approached the bar, I noticed that Mathis was sitting there alone. I said hello and
introduced myself and asked if I could join him. He welcomed me to do so.
For the next 15 minutes we sat alone and engaged in conversation. I had read that he was a shy man. He was. Although our conversation was sweet, it was also awkward. His shyness dominated our discussion. His personality and talent came alive only on the stage.
A few years later I was visiting with President Reagan’s Chief of Staff in his offce in Century City. Reagan had already entered the domain of Alzheimer’s. She stressed the importance of routine for the President as the disease matured. Once a week he would be brought into his offce to sit and read. She showed me what he read. It was the Bible. She then shared that Johnny Mathis would often come with him and read from the Bible with him.
With these stories shared, I realize that I must go see Johnny Mathis perform once more. espite approaching ninety years of age, he still periodically performs. He’s a bit slower, just as I am as I approach eighty years of age. His next performance in our region is May 10th in Santa Rosa. My ticket is purchased and a hotel room reserved. As I sit in the audience and watch him perform, I will appreciate his amazing grace. I will also appreciate my life here in Castro Valley and the goodness it has gifted me with.
the Gift of Life, Get Gift in Return
facing a medical emergency; give something that means something with a blood or platelet donation. Schedule an appointment this ecember by visiting RedCrossBlood.org or calling E C OSS (1-800-733-2767).
For a limited time, those who come to give ec. , 2024, will receive a $15 e-gift card to a merchant of choice.
CV Remembers Pearl Harbor
On a beautiful Castro Valley morning on Saturday, ecember 7, members of the Armed Forces, active and veterans, and their survivors as well as members of the community gathered at the Castro Valley Veterans Memorial to remember those killed in the attack on earl arbor on ecember , 1941. The Sea Cadets as well as Young Marines Master Sergeant Ryan Wryder (18) were present. Owen Smith’s widow, Irma Smith was also present. Owen survived the attack on Pearl Harbor.
Master of Ceremonies was VFW Post 9601 Commander Chris Bokamper. American Legion Post Commander Bernard Remoaldo was also present.
The speaker was Vietnam Veteran Bruce Bennett who shared the story of the USS Utah, the “Forgotten Battleship.” Bennett is the VFW Post Chaplain and opened with an Invocation and closed with the Benediction. US Army First Sergeant Kathy Vargas (retired) read a Proclamation from President Joe Biden. The remembrance also included the “Reading of the Watch” by on S uires S avy , i e Salute and “Amazing Grace” by bagpiper HMC Graham P. A focused remembrance on a beautiful day in Castro Valley.
hose who come to give ec. 16, 2024 to Jan. 3, 2025, will receive an exclusive Red Cross long-sleeved T-shirt, while supplies last. For details, visit RedCrossBlood.org/Gifts.
The blood donation opportunity in Castro Valley takes place on uesday, ecember 31 from 9am to 3pm at Castro Valley Church of the Nazarene, 19230 Lake Chabot Road.
Our beloved Karin L. Bercovitz née Reed, 76 years old, of Castro Valley, died at home on the 4th of
Karin was the daughter of Marsille P Reed and Gloria E Reed of Los Angeles. He was a Tuskegee airman in WWII and she was an RN. Karin obtained a bachelor’s and a master’s in speech pathology from USC. She married John in June of 1971. Her last and longest employment was with ayward nifed School istrict. She was lively and had a great number of good friends. She was in several women’s groups. She loved owers and jewelry-making, particularly if it involved beads.
She is survived by her husband of nearly 53 years, John, and daughter Kimberly of Castro Valley, and son Brian of Marin County, and her last dog, Jag. She is also survived by her younger brother, M. Gregory Reed and his son, M. Ian Reed. Further, her grandchildren Brodie and Liliana of Castro Valley, and her grandson Otto of Marin County. She is also survived by her sister-in-law, Lynn, of Berkeley. She was preceded in death by her father and mother who lived to 77 and 84.
Karin is interred at Lone Tree in Hayward. She would appreciate some owers.
Karin L. Bercovitz
Creekside Defeats Canyon Condors
or the frst time in eight years, Creekside iddle chool ildcats won its Battle of the Valley in lag ootball over crosstown rival Canyon iddle chool Condors by . he two middle schools met at ro an tadium last riday for their annual contest. Creekside’s points were from two touchdown runs by JoJo night ( ) and one touchdown run by ibson Anaya ( ). he pirit uads from both schools performed at halftime, and even the school mascots got into the spirit of the game, helping to cheer with the crowds. he Battle of the Valley ame is a fundraiser for both middle schools. ach school benefts from the event through ticket, snack bar, and raf e sales.
Rudy’s Retiring
continued from front page
“There will never be anyone that can make Apple Fritters like you,” says resident Kathi Townsend. “I remember when you were in your frst location, and we would stop by a couple of times a week with the “littles,” starting with donut holes and then Maple Bars, and then I discovered the fritters! I’m so sad but happy for you. You will sorely be missed!”
The company was founded by Rudy Gatto, who worked at Winchell’s Donuts in town and eventually decided to branch out. In 1987, Gatto moved his operation to the current Castro Valley Boulevard and Yeandle Avenue site, which was initially a drive-in dairy in the early 60s. Gatto passed away in 2006. His wife, Shirley Ducato, and daughters, Angela and Gina, manage the business.
“Congratulations on a wellearned retirement,” says resident Laurie Devine. “You will be missed tremendously! Not only are Rudy’s the best donuts in town but also Gina and Angela are the best! I’ve been going to Rudy’s since I was a kid and have been bringing my own kids!! Sunday’s won’t be the same without you!! Thank you so much for also helping us host so many coffee and donut days over the years for the amazing teachers at our kids schools! You’ve been such a blessing to the community.”
Other residents remember Rudy’s for the job opportunity it provided.
“I worked for Rudy’s from 1995 to 2022,” says CV resident Kim Walton. “This was the longest place I’ve ever worked at in all my working years. I retired in 2022 after 26 and a half years at Rudy’s. I enjoyed working here until my body and feet told me it was time to retire. I miss working there but the body was saying it’s time to give it up. Rudy’s will always be the best donuts around in my book. Gina and Angela, enjoy your retirement. Just not having to get up at 2:00 a.m. is going to feel sooo good. Rudy’s will be missed by all.”
ATHLETES OF THE WEEK
CVI Lions Flag Football
Our Athletes of the Week are the CVI Lions who are the 2024 Flag Football C-Division Champions. The team took home the “W” with a record of 11-0. This group of 8- and 9-year-olds played hard during games and practices - with dedicated and encouraging coaches that truly brought the out best in each of them.
is proud to sponsor Athletes of the Week CVI Flag Football
Local Baseball Travel Team, Coach Headed to Nationals
The coach and several players from a Castro Valley-based youth traveling baseball team are packing their gear and taking their award-winning play across the country starting this weekend.
Chaz Lagaret, who coaches NorCal CGE Baseball, has assembled an All-Star roster that is designed to compete with other traveling teams from Southern California, Nevada, Texas, and Georgia. The new team, called 463 National, includes players from Northern California’s most promising young athletes in the San Francisco Bay Area and Sacramento. heir frst competition is the PG Super Regional NIT (National Invitational Tournament) on December 14 and 15 in Huntington Beach, California.
“We’re a Top 10 contending team with the players we have and we’re about to fnd out
how we do against other regions,” Lagaret told the Forum.
In Northern California, the best players come from Sunnyvale, the East Bay, and around the Sacramento suburbs, Lagaret noted. Players wishing to compete on a national level typically ew to Southern California to play in their leagues. The 463
National team would be the frst competitive travel team based solely out of Northern California. Five of the players are from CGE, including a few from Canyon Middle School. The rest are from the other teams in the area.
After Huntington Beach, the 463 National team travels to Las Vegas for a tournament on January 25 followed by a PG Super Regional NIT NorCal in Sunnyvale, and a PG Super Regional NIT in Houston, Texas on March 1. The season culminates in the PG World Series in Atlanta, Georgia on June 19.
Additionally, Lagaret said the team is looking for a business, organization, or individual who would be interested and honored to sponsor this elite team of the best and most talented boys. Follow their journey on Instagram at @463national.
The Matt Wilhite Team
Pictured are: Coaches: Justin Allen, Luke Allen (Assistant Jr. Coach), Joseph Neal, and Hollie Pope; Players front row (l-r): Maddox Foxworthy, Zain Coleman, Kayson Word, Karson Word, and David Canady; Players back row (l-r): Josiah Neal, Xavier Sanders, Colby Allen, Dominic Marquez, Aarav Khatri, and Owen Pope.
Chaz Lagaret
PHOTO COURTESY OF KAREN CANADY
PHOTOS COURTESY OF DARRELL LAVIN/ LAVINPHOTOS.COM