September 13, 2023

CASTRO VALLEY FORUM CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

What Will be Fate Of Rudy’s Donuts?

By Amy Sylvestri CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

Rudy’s Donuts—long-time staple of eastern Castro Valley Boulevard—might be on its way out, the Castro Valley Municipal Advisory Council (MAC) heard at its Monday meeting.

HUGE TURNOUT FOR FALL FESTIVAL: The annual Castro Valley Fall Festival wrapped up this past weekend. Somewhere between 35,000 to 40,000 people attended the two-day event. The Castro Valley and Eden Area Chamber of Commerce, which produced the event, say it was the largest number of local vendors and businesses in its 51-year history. See page 5

PERIOD POVERTY

Locals Show Support for Lebanese Women’s Health

By Madison Glock SPECIAL TO THE FORUM

More than 3.1 million women and girls in Lebanon currently lack the proper resources to manage their reproductive health, particularly during their menstrual cycles and one local community is reaching out for help.

Lebanon is currently grappling with a severe economic crisis that has left many vulnerable, exacerbating problems such as “period poverty.” Period poverty refers to the inability to access proper menstrual hygiene products due to limited resources. This crisis has dire consequences for affected populations, impacting their health, dignity, and overall well-being. see HEALTH on back page

1987. The business is owned by Shirley Ducato along with daughters Angela Ducato and Gina Alfaro, who manage operations. The building was sold a year ago to local dentist Dr. Jennifer Young.

The vote on the item was deferred to a future meeting, but the MAC has received a pre-application for a site development review of the site at 3692 Castro Valley Boulevard to convert the space from a donut shop to a dental office. Originally a drive-in dairy, the 2,800-square-foot space has been home to Rudy’s since

Dr. Young plans to convert the site into a 2,035-square-foot dental office with an additional 770-square-feet of rentable space. The parking along the Castro Valley Boulevard frontage would be removed, according to the filing.

In her pre-application, Dr. Young stated that Rudy’s owner is planning to retire and she would like to move her dentistry into the space from see MAC on page 10

Public Comment Closed on Report

By Michael Singer CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

A study about the potential incorporation of Castro Valley and its Eden Area neighbors is back in the hands of the Alameda Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO) following the close of public comment this past Monday.

Earlier this Spring, LAFCO commissioned a report to investigate three hybrid models for incorporation. The first is Castro Valley by itself. The second is Castro Valley, plus the unincorporated Eden areas (Ashland, Cherryland, San Lorenzo, Hayward Acres), and Fairview. The third is Eden and Fairview without Castro Valley.

The public was given 30 days to comment on the

preliminary report and an additional two weeks following requests for additional time.

The LAFCO Board will now review the preliminary report for adoption at its November 9 meeting.

“We have received a lot of public comments already and the number of comments submitted among the three proposals is pretty well balanced,” LAFCO executive director, Rachel Jones told the Forum.

Some public comments are like those submitted by Hayward Area Recreation and Park District (H.A.R.D.) Board member Peter Rosen. He poses 11 questions about the feasibility study including the viability of adding the Canyonlands (Crow Canyon, Eden Canyon, and Palomares Canyon) to the see LAFCO on page 10

PHOTO CREDIT: CATHY BRESLOW / BRESLOW IMAGING

PHOTO COURTESY OF PHOENICIA FINESSES

Phoenicia Finesses, a Bay Area-based non-profit, is playing a pivotal role in helping millions of girls in Lebanon who currently lack the proper resources to manage their reproductive health.

CV Special Ed Instructor to Receive ‘Teacher of the Year’

By Michael Singer CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

This past week, Castro Valley High School’s Claire Heppner was named as one of 18 of the 2023 Alameda County Teachers of the Year, which honors teachers throughout Alameda County.

A ceremony and reception for the annual award will be held at the Castro Valley Center for the Arts on October 5, between 6:00 and 9:00 p.m.

Heppner is a Special Education teacher at CVHS. In her classroom, she focuses solely on her students’ specific individual needs. Her program, Functional Life Skills, readies her students for the next steps in life. They learn everything from safety skills in the kitchen, to how to take care of laundry.

“I want to make sure they are contributing members of society when they leave my program,” Heppner said.

Heppner says she didn’t take the orthodox path to teaching.

Instead of finishing college right after high school, she had her family first. She returned to school in her mid-30s to finish her degree. After organizing events at her own children’s schools, she knew she wanted to become a teacher. She started as a substitute teacher, where she immediately gravitated toward special education.

“I found my passion,” she adds.

“A well-deserved recognition! Ms. Heppner works hard to create the best learning environment for students. She is able to individualize instruction to meet the needs of every student in her Special Day Class. We are very fortunate to have Ms. Heppner,” Castro Valley Unified School District Superintendent, Parvin Ahmadi told the Forum.

The Alameda County Office of Education (ACOE), which presents the Teacher of the Year awards, serves as liaison between the California Department of Education and the 18 Alameda County public school districts that serve more than 215,000 students.

This year’s 18 honorees are among the more than 12,000 educators across Alameda County, which the ACOE says, “light the future for every child, in every school, every day.”

For tickets and more information about the 2023 Alameda County Teachers of the Year award, visit the ACOE website (acoe.org)

Kintsugi - There’s Power in Your Pain

By Kevin Koo SPECIAL TO THE FORUM

Last time I shared a story about a cracked pot. The focus of the story was about how even though we may feel broken, there is still good that we put out into the world. We just need to see it and under-

stand that we still have value. I received a lot of nice feedback from others and wanted to share a related idea called kintsugi.

Kintsugi comes from Japan, and what they do is take broken pottery, and mend it with lacquer and gold dust. What’s so fascinating about

this is how the broken bits are actually highlighted with gold. Typically, we try to hide our imperfections due to shame or embarrassment, but this brings those blemishes and imperfections to the forefront. Here’s a better explanation. It’s a short excerpt from Christy Bartlett’s Flickwerk: The Aesthetics of Mended Japanese Ceramics describing the concept:

“Not only is there no attempt to hide the damage, but the repair is literally illuminated... a kind of physical expression of the spirit of mushin.... Mushin is often literally translated as “no mind,” but carries connotations of fully existing within the moment, of non-attachment, of equanimity amid changing conditions.

...The see KOO on page 10

Claire Heppner

CV Resident Dolores Howard Celebrates Her 100th Birthday

By Mike McGuire CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

Longtime Castro Valley resident Dolores Howard turned 100 on Sunday, marking a century filled with art, people and family with a get-together at a local restaurant.

Howard, born in San Francisco in 1923, made and taught art to area adults and senior citizens for her whole adult life, until very recently.

Her son Dan said, “She worked until she was 96, and would still be teaching today if not for the COVID lockdown at the convalescent homes.”

She’d moved on to teaching art to seniors after retiring from the Hayward schools, he said.

After moving to farm country and then Oakland as a young girl, Dolores graduated from Roosevelt High School in Oakland. She attended what was then known as California State University, Hayward (Cal State East Bay today) and got her degree in Art from UC Berkeley. She went on to teach adults, mostly women as she remembers, at the Hayward Adult School for some 20 years.

“I always liked people,” she said. She added she’d always liked teaching, too.

Dolores Howard has lived in Castro Valley for 60 years, after moving with her husband John F. Howard to the town where her parents had lived since the 1940s. They raised two sons, Dan, who now lives in the Sierra foothills town of

Sheriff’s Reports

COMPILED BY MICHAEL SINGER • CASTRO VALLEY FORUM

Resisted Arrest

Saturday, September 9: at 8:38 p.m., Sheriff’s deputies arrested a 38-year-old man with no permanent residence on suspicion of illegal narcotics and resisting arrest. The man was outside a church on Grove Way near Redwood Road when deputies stopped him. The man revealed his stash but became confrontational. Deputies took the man into custody.

Assault and Battery

Saturday, September 9: at 11:41 a.m., a 911 call about a loud and aggressive-sounding argument sent deputies to an apartment on Center Street near Grove Way. There, they arrested a 53-year-old CV man on suspicion of assault and battery. Deputies took the man into custody. The victim was treated at the scene.

store on Castro Valley Boulevard near Redwood Road. The man was handcuffed and taken to Santa Rita Jail.

Driving Drunk and on Drugs

Thursday, September 7: at 11:31 a.m., deputies served a warrant to a 37-year-old woman for a previous conviction of driving under the influence of drugs and alcohol. The woman was traveling on Interstate 580 near Eden Canyon Road when deputies pulled her over and served the court-issued warrant. Deputies took the woman to Santa Rita Jail.

Drug Paraphernalia

on the warrant for a previous drug and driving without a license. Deputies took the man into custody.

Attempted Robbery

Wednesday, September 6: at 12:05 a.m., deputies arrested a 42-year-old man with no permanent residence on suspicion of attempted robbery in a grocery store parking lot on the Boulevard near Redwood Road. The man was spotted trying to wrestle away property from with another person when deputies arrived. The man was taken into custody.

Left Without Paying

Pioneer, and Greg, who lives in San Diego. John Howard passed away 13 years ago.

“My dad worked at the Naval Air Station Alameda for 36 years, as a quality control manager on aircraft,” Dan Howard said.

“My parents met at a Navy dance right around Pearl Harbor,” he continued. “He was on a ship in the Pacific scheduled to dock there the morning of the attack, but they had decided to go straight home instead. They had no idea an attack was coming.”

Dan, for one, is very glad that his dad’s ship continued toward home.

Dolores Howard remembers, “I painted a lot of pictures. Teachers always liked them and took them for display, but for some reason I never got most of them back.”

She painted at least 150 pictures, she said.

Dolores said she never did anything unusual to live a long life, except that she always kept busy and avoided paying to get others’ attention.

Dan Howard said his mother was actually a more prolific artist than she let on.

“Mom was always very modest about her art,” Dan Howard said. “She really painted almost 500 pictures.”

Drove Under the Influence

Saturday, September 9: at 3:00 a.m., deputies pulled over and arrested a 32-year-old CV woman on suspicion of driving under the influence of alcohol. The woman was traveling on Wilson Avenue near Santa Maria Avenue when deputies stopped her for a traffic violation. The woman failed her field sobriety test and was taken into custody.

Early Morning Shoplifter

Friday, September 8: at 7:30 a.m., a 22-year-old man with no permanent residence was arrested on suspicion of attempted robbery at a grocery

Wednesday, September 6: at 2:43 p.m., a 46-year-old man was arrested for possessing illegal drug paraphernalia and as part of a warrant issued for his arrest. Deputies stopped the man outside a fast-food restaurant on Redwood Road near Redwood Court. The man revealed his stash and deputies made the positive identification

Monday, September 4: at 11:18 p.m., a 27-year-old CV man was arrested on suspicion of shoplifting from a grocery store on Redwood Road near the Boulevard. Deputies responded to a call from store security that the man had left with a substantial amount of unpaid merchandise. The man was taken into custody.

PHOTO COURTESY OF HOWARD FAMILY

Castro Valley centenarian Dolores Howard.

Meet Author Emily Liebowitz

“My Boyfriend’s Back,” “Please Mr. Postman,” “Lollipop” and hundreds of other Doo-wop songs filled the airwaves during the fifties and sixties. Who were these artists that introduced us to these iconic songs? Poet and author Emily Liebowitz is visiting her Castro Valley childhood home this month promoting her new book, But Will You Love Me Tomorrow? An Oral History of the ‘60s Girl Groups. People Magazine just chose her book as one of the “MustRead Books” for Fall of 2023. Liebowitz and her co-author Laura Flam will be at the Castro Valley Library (3600 Norbridge Avenue), September 23 at 2:00 to discuss their book and talk about this special time in American musical history.

But Will You Love Me Tomorrow? features over 300 hours of new interviews, with over 100 artists. Some of the women of the many girl groups featured in this book went on to achieve stardom in their own right. Some had successful careers behind the scenes in the music industry. Most returned

to quiet lives beyond the public eye, some empowered, some broken. But all have amazing stories to tell about their experiences and insight to share about the music industry.

Liebowitz and Flam chronicle harrowing tales of young black singers touring in the Jim Crow South as well as beautiful stories of female friendship and fierce feuds. The girl groups share insider stories about some of the era’s biggest stars including Sam Cooke, Smokey Robinson, Cher and The Beatles as well as fun facts about specific girl groups like “the no-hit Supremes.”

But Will You Love Me Tomorrow is Liebowitz’s first non-fiction book. Her first two published works were poetry: National Park and a Chap Book, In Any Map. Liebowitz grew up in Castro Valley attending Strobridge Elementary School and then the Athenian School for middle school and high school in Danville. She majored in literature and creative writing at UC Santa Cruz and received her MFA with an emphasis in poetry at the Writer’s Workshop at the University of Iowa.

Liebowitz describes her childhood as “book-heavy.” Her mother, Ninh Wick of Castro Valley read to her constantly and her grandmother recited poetry.

Emily readily admits to liking poetry because the books were smaller and the stories shorter. Liebowitz says that poetry gives her a language to express what she sees in the world. “Poetry speaks to the unspeakable.” Liebowitz and Flam make a good duo as they approach writing with a different eye.

Plethos’ Pride and Prejudice

Get ready for a hilarious twist on a classic tale as Plethos Productions proudly presents Kate Hamill’s uproarious rendition of “Pride and Prejudice.” This comedic adaptation ain’t your grandmother’s Pride and Prejudice, so buckle up for an evening of laughter and charm that’s perfect for audiences of all ages.

In this zany adaptation, the timeless love story of Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy is presented in a relatable and fresh new way. Follow Elizabeth’s journey as she navigates the treacherous waters of high society, where manners, marriage prospects and her meddling mothers collide in the most hilarious ways.

Director Camille La’akea Wong has pulled out all the stops to make this a show to remember, including incorporating costumes flown in from Hawaii. The show will be performed outdoors on the meadow stage at Heirloom East Bay in Castro Valley this Friday-Sunday September, 1517. Tickets at plethos.org.

Ivan Rutherford at Arts Center

By Terry Liebowitz SPECIAL TO THE FORUM

16

16

17

17

MY BLUE SOUL THE GROOVE FOUNDATION MARK BETTENCOURT’S AFTERMATH

MY BLUE SOUL THE GROOVE FOUNDATION MARK BETTENCOURT’S AFTERMATH

Saturday, September 23 is a big night at the Castro Valley Center for the Arts when Ivan Rutherford comes to town to sing his one-man show, More Than Broadway.

REWIND - THAT 80’s BAND 3 O’CLOCK JUMP PATRÓN LATIN RHYTHMS

JUMP PATRÓN LATIN RHYTHMS

Mr. LEO RHYTHM AND SOUL

Mr. LEO RHYTHM AND SOUL

JOHNNY MAHALO / WILD COCONUTS

JOHNNY MAHALO / WILD COCONUTS

MASTERPIECE THE BAND TOUCH OF CLASS

GGBS - MIKE SKINNER

Rutherford has performed the role of Jean Valjean in Les Miserables over 2,300 times on Broadway and national tours. “Castro Valley Arts Foundation is very excited to bring an artist of this caliber to our stage,” said Vice President Mary Ann DeGrazia. He will sing theater, film and pop. In a telephone interview, Rutherford spoke about the challenges of playing the same role eight times a week, week after week. “I knew that half of my audience had seen the show before and the other half was attending Les Miserables

for the first time. My goal was to meld this complex character with my personality. I always tried to dig deep to find the nuggets of truth in the script. And for those seeing the show multiple times, I tried to continue to grow with the character.” He remarked, “Some see Jean Val Jean as saintly, but he struggles with his flaws in the anthem, “Who Am I?” Rutherford says, “Above all, an actor must be a good storyteller!”

Rutherford joined Lea Salonga on Broadway in the 20th anniversary Les Misérables revival. He was nominated for Best Actor for his portrayal of Valjean at the First Annual National Broadway Theatre Awards, held at the New York Supper Club in NYC. Rutherford has also starred in South Pacific, Titanic, and West Side Story. He played alongside Andrea McArdle at the Ogunquit Playhouse in Maine.

Rutherford currently performs with orchestras worldwide as a concert soloist and cabaret artist. He lives in Irvine, California, and has a busy online teaching schedule when not touring.

Castro Valley Center for the Arts (19501 Redwood Road) is a little over a mile from the Castro Valley BART Station. Parking is free. For tickets: cvartsfoundation.org

Advanced Math and Science Tutoring

Looking for help with some hard homework? The Castro Valley library is offering free High School and College-Level tutoring in Math, Physics, and Chemistry every

Monday running throughout the school year Mondays from 5:30 to 7:00 pm. No Registration or appointment necessary. The Castro Valley Library

is located at 3600 Norbridge Avenue, Castro Valley, and is wheelchair accessible. Please call 510-745-1401 or TTY 888-663-0660 for more information.

L-R: Katie Francis, Benjamin R. Garcia, Thomas Nguyen, Kristy Aquino, Nancy Wong, Annie Wang, Aero England, Amber H. Gee, David Patino, Nicholas Jaochico.

PHOTO CREDIT: TIM WONG

BIG SMILES AT 2023 FALL FESTIVAL

Pet Rescue Opening Saturday

Nobody’s Perfekt Dogs & Cats (NPDC) has found a new home in Castro Valley. Located at 3810 Castro Valley Boulevard, on the corner of Forest Avenue, they are officially open to the public!

At its recent ribbon-cutting ceremony hosted by the Castro Valley Chamber of Commerce, Nobody’s Perfekt has opened officially to the Castro Valley community. Their new 3,000 square foot storefront features a pet boutique showcases seasonal, holiday, and every day clothing for dogs and cats, as well as leashes and collars, crates, and so much more.

Stop by and check out their new and amazing glass-enclosed cat house where you can come in and interact with the kittens and cats during their cat adoption days every Saturday from 11 am to 2 pm. Their dog adoption fair is held every Saturday in an enclosed area where you can interact with the dogs available for adoption.

The official grand opening will be held at the rescue this Saturday, September 16. They welcome the community to stop by and visit their new store and rescue center.

COMMUNITY CALENDAR

Friday, September 15

Back to Pack Event!

Join Cub Scout Pack 765 for the 2023/2024 year as we find adventure and excitement. We have regularly scheduled den and pack meetings where we learn everything from how to tie knots, to learning about racial equity and inclusion, to making “Little Pantries’ for our community, to learning about what it means to be a Scout. If you have questions, you can email us at cubpack765@gmail.com or call the Cub Master Daniel Pak at 510-207-0709 or Asst. Cub Master Diana Torres-Schopplein at 510-501-5368.

Saturday, September 16

“Day on the Greens” Golf Tournament

The Castro Valley Sports Foundation and Rowell Ranch Rodeo will host its 6th Annual “Day on the Greens” Golf Tournament this Saturday at the Redwood Canyon Golf Course. All profits are invested back into the community supporting local and community organizations. Visit: castrovalleysportsfoundation.org/2023-day-on-the-greens

Saturday, September 16

Mister Softee Ice Cream Social

The Leslie Peterson Team will host an ice cream social this Saturday, Sept. 16 from 2 to 4 pm at Evolve Real Estate office, located at 19633 Center Street in Castro Valley.

Sunday, September 17

Collectible Toy Show

The Moose Lodge, located at 20835 Rutledge Road in Castro Valley, will be holding a collectible toy show this Sunday, Sept. 17 from 10 am to 2 pm. Admission is $2 which goes to the Moose Lodge.

Coming Soon to Smalltown Society

This Friday, Sept. 15: Kate Lamont

The “Verse & Vibes” series continues with Smalltown Society songwriter and Bay Area recording artist Kate Lamont! Come support local live music and local business! 6-8pm at Pampas Cafe: 22222 Redwood Rd. Castro Valley (adjacent to Trader Joe’s). FREE.

Friday, Sept. 22: The Long Haired Greek

Come join us for an evening of good food, drinks and music. Smalltown Society and Pampas Cafe continue their “Verse & Vibes” series with special guest The Long Haired Greek. 6-8 pm at Pampas Cafe: 22222 Redwood Rd Castro Valley. FREE.

Wednesday, Sept. 27: The LAB

The Lab is a monthly gathering that allows songwriters and poets to workshop and collaborate on new and existing

pieces through exercises and brief performances, in front of and among friends. This month’s featured artist is local

Nobody’s Perfekt Dogs & Cats is celebrating seven years of service to the East Bay this year. They have helped hundreds of special needs dogs, abandoned cats, and feral kittens, from local shelters, find loving permanent homes.

These are dogs and cats that otherwise would have been euthanized so we are proud that we are saving their lives. The adoption center relies on our local community for support while we also provide valuable services to our community.

The rescue has a robust volunteer program that allows adults and students a chance to give back either for personal gratification or community service requirements. The rescue has become a place for families to visit and help socialize kittens. The rescue has provided a great resource for the community to buy supplies, clothing, food, and merchandise for dogs and cats at cost-effective prices. The rescue goes beyond saving the lives of special needs dogs, cats, and kittens.

The store is open Tuesdays, Wednesdays, Thursdays, and Saturdays from 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. For more information about adoption events, visit: nobodysperfektdogs.org.

Tuesday, September 19

Start Smart: Teen Driver Program

The California Highway Patrol and the Castro Valley Library present Start Smart: Teen Driver Program. CHP officers will discuss traffic collision avoidance techniques, collision causing factors, driver/parent responsibilities, and seatbelt usage. The Start Smart program is a driver safety education class which targets new and future licensed teenage drivers between the age of 15 - 19 and their parents/ guardians. A parent/guardian is required to attend the class with their teen. To register, call the Library Information Desk at 510-667-7900 or register online at: aclibrary.org

Tuesday, September 19

Rotary Hosts Evolve Real Estate’s Francesca Davila Evolve Real Estate Team member Francesca Davila will share Evolve Real Estates experience and track record of over 450 homes sold in the East Bay, with a steadfast commitment to the community. A buffet lunch and the program take place at Redwood Canyon Golf Course (17007 Redwood Road, Castro Valley) at 12 to 1:30 pm. The cost of lunch is $20 and reservations must be made by 9 pm on Sunday, Sept. 17, by contacting Rotary by email at: cvrotary@iCloud.com or 510-402-5123. More information is available at: castrovalleyrotary.org.

Saturday, September 23

Coastal Cleanup Day at Castro Valley Creek Trail

Be part of the 39th annual Coastal Cleanup Day at the Castro Valley Creek Trail on Saturday, Sept. 23 from 9 am to noon! Volunteers will participate in a litter pickup along the creek trail and beautify the trail starting from the Castro Valley Library to Castro Valley Creek Blvd. Questions? Please contact Jennifer Trevis at jennifer.trevis@acrcd.org

band Poser! Starts at 7:30pm Invitation by email only: info@ smalltownsociety.com for more info and location.

Bay Area recording artists Kate Lamont will be performing at Pampas Cafe this Friday night.

PHOTOS BY: CATHY BRESLOW / BRESLOW IMAGING

Fatigued Buyers Choosing to Sit on the Bench for Now

By Carl Medford, CRS Special to the Forum

While mortgage rates dipped slightly this past week, they have remained above 7% for the past four weeks. While current rates are deemed ‘average’ by historical standards, many homeowner wannabes, accustomed to rock-bottom rates, had made purchasing plans based on much lower rates. Those rates, the result of a financial collapse followed by a global pandemic, will not be returning anytime soon. Consequently, higher percentages have scuppered many of those plans.

Unfortunately, it appears the new rates are here to stay – at least for the near future. In fact, some indicators show inflation is still on the rise, suggesting that we may see another rate hike in the near

future.

As for those plans made when rates were low? They will need to be shelved for the foreseeable future or readjusted to meet the new reality. If they included buying a home or investment property, a purchase is still viable, but the parameters will need to change. The latest Black Knight Mortgage Monitor confirms this, stating that mortgage payments have jumped 60% in the past two years. Since wages have not increased at the same rate during the same period, this means affordability has gone down. WAY down, in most cases. Bottom line: if you were looking for a detached, single-family home with 4 bedrooms and a decent-sized yard, you may need to adjust to a much smaller home or even consider condos or townhouses.

We have definitely seen interest rates this high before. In fact, in the mid-80s, mortgages averaged over 13%. The difference then, however, was that home prices were substantially lower. Fast forward to today and we have a double whammy: while interest rates of 7% are higher than before, it is the outlandishly high home prices combining with the higher rates that are pushing many buyers out of the market.

To put this into perspective, the Mortgage Monitor report states, “it would take some combination of roughly a 27% decline in home prices, a greater than 4% reduction in 30-year rates, or a 60% growth in median household income to bring affordability back to its 25-year average.” Since it is doubtful any of those things will happen, buyers who want to buy will need

the moment you walk up to the front door you will see all the many improvements throughout! Recent upgrades include new interior and exterior painting, new roof w/warranty, luxury vinyl plank flooring, hall & primary bathrooms were remodeled with custom designer touches, additionally all new interior doors, hardware and light fixtures were installed. Features of the property include a formal living room w/fireplace and slider to covered patio and yard, kitchen family room combination w/stainless appliance, recessed lighting, solar tube and dining area w/access to garage w/laundry hookups & plenty of storage, primary bedroom and updated bath w/stall shower, remodeled hall bathroom w/shower over tub and 2 additional bedrooms. Entertain, garden or play in the well maintained backyard w/covered patio and lawn area. Centrally located to all, including freeway, transit, schools, shopping, hospital and more. Don’t miss this one!

Open Sunday 9/17, 1-4

to adapt to the new realities. The net result is a significant dip in mortgage applications, suggesting that for now, many buyers are choosing to sit on

the sidelines until something changes.

C arl Medford is a licensed Realtor with Keller

Williams Realty and a licensed general contractor. This article is sponsored by the Central County Marketing Association.

20157 Butterfield Drive, Castro Valley • $998,000

WEEKEND GARDENER

Watering

Continue to water shallow-rooted plants such as azaleas, baby’s tears, begonias, camellias, ferns, fuchsias and rhododendrons frequently while the weather is hot this month and next month. If the surrounding soil is clay, however, be sure that you’ve provided sufficient drainage. A mulch will help to moderate soil temperatures and evaporation.

Flowers

Cut back Shasta daisies now that their blooming season is winding down. Trim bearded iris foliage to fans 8 inches from the rhizomes. Sow sweet peas now for glorious spring color. Continue feeding chrysanthemums every three weeks until their buds show color. Switch to a 0-10-10 fertilizer for azaleas, camellias, gardenias and rhododendrons to encourage formation of next spring’s blossom buds.

Mortgage Rates

For the fourth consecutive week, the 30-year fixed-rate mortgage hovered above seven percent. The economy remains buoyant, which is encouraging for consumers. Though while inflation has decelerated, firmer economic data have put upward pressure on mortgage rates which, in the face of affordability challenges, are straining potential homebuyers.

RECENT HOME SALES

(CA DRE #00689931,

“Lovewell Team” is a dynamic, award-winning Real Estate team Call 510-351-5555 or visit us at www.Lovewellteam.com

— A team you can love and trust —

Advertise your Home for rent in the San Leandro Times & Castro Valley Forum

DON’T LET ANOTHER WEEK SLIPBY!

HANDYMAN & CONTRACTORS

REAAALLLY appreciate our Readers who support our Advertisers! Patrick V.

– Avacancy day is money lost forever –

To place an ad call 510-614-1558

LANDLORDS - Advertise your units! – Avacancy day is money lost forever –

to our many Readers who SUPPORT OUR ADVERTISERS!

R. Bowman

NEED - MUSIC LESSONS or PIANO TUNING?

SELL YOUR CAR TRUCK NOW!

Check the Classified Ads under “MUSICALSERVICES” for help.

Advertise your vehicle for weeks in the San Leandro Times and 3 weeks in the Valley Forum for only…

GREAT DEAL!

10 words maximum.

$1.00 for each additional word.

is for private party ads only (no

Items must be priced and only may be listed for sale. You may the asking price at anytime (no changes are allowed). You may canat anytime (there are no refunds on this $25 special). Other restricapply. For more information call 614-1558.

HOPE YOU FIND just the job you are looking for!

Rent it FAST with a TIMES WANT AD ... 614-1558

You can run a classified ad for a little as $35 a week. Your ad runs in both of our newspapers, the Castro Valley Forum on Wednesday and the San Leandro Times on Thursday. You can also save by placing your ad on our website at castrovalleyforum.com or sanleandrotimes.com. We’ll call you for your credit or debit card info for payment.

HOME SERVICES GUIDE

Help for the homeowner means business for you!

To Place an Ad ... Call 614-1558

To Place an Ad call 614-1558

To place an ad by phone call Patrick Vadnais at 510-614-1560, Mon-Fri 9 a.m. - 1 p.m.

To Place a Garage Sale Ad 614-1558

To Place a Garage Sale Ad call 614-1558

IF YOUR GARAGE SALE IS RAINED OUT, WE'LL RUN YOUR AD AGAIN FOR NO EXTRA CHARGE. SLTimes

NEED REMODELING?

How about a new kitchen or bath? Check the TIMES "Classified Ads" & The TIMES "Home Service" ads for help!

Help for the homeowner means business for you! San Leandro Times HOME SERVICES GUIDE Call 614-1558

Help for the homeowner means business for you!

Koo: ‘Your Mess is Your Message’

continued from page 2 vicissitudes of existence over time, to which all humans are susceptible, could not be clearer than in the breaks, the knocks, and the shattering to which ceramic ware too is subject.”

Reading that excerpt reminds me of something I heard years ago from a coach/ mentor of mine. She often said, “your mess is your message.”

Up until that point, I assumed perfection was the only “right” answer, but when she said that, something clicked in my head. When we connect with people, we can connect in a lot of ways. Usually through things we like, such as hobbies, sports teams, or even being in the same line of work. The other way to connect though, is through shared challenges and troubles. I’ve seen deep connections develop through single parents who have been through divorce, or blended families, or even those who have lost a loved one. If you know someone who has gone through a recovery group, you see how strong those relationships can be. There’s something powerful that lies in sharing

your hardships with others who have gone through something similar.

So, what if we decided to share our

hardships rather than trying to hide them?

This is where things get interesting. What if those things you considered shameful, or embarrassing were your source of strength? Who would benefit from hearing your story? Who would feel less alone to know that you went through that as well? What if by sharing your story, you could prevent someone from having that same experience?

Now, I will say that if it feels too scary to share, you’re probably not ready to share it. Take the time to get those wounds healed up a bit. Getting some therapy, coaching, or counseling would be helpful. However, keep in mind that the first time sharing will always be scary. You’ll know you might be ready when you’re able to articulate your learnings rather than playing the victim.

MAC: Rudy’s in ‘A State of Limbo’

What’s an experience you’ve had that you’ve been hiding? It’s ok, you don’t have to share it with me. Just think about it. What were your learnings from that experience? What strengths and skills did you develop because of that hurtful experience? Can you think of anyone who might be going through something similar?

I really hope you take to heart when I say that you are a person of value. I don’t have to know you to tell you that it’s true. Your strengths and triumphs, as well as your hurts and weaknesses, make you valuable.

The life you have lived to this point has turned into wisdom that others can benefit from. Learn to embrace the bad along with the good, and you’ll have a greater impact in your community than you ever could have imagined.

Coach Kev helps people find calm, clarity, and confidence in their life while mending the cracks that come along in life. Contact him at kevinkoocoaching@gmail.com, or follow on IG and YouTube @ kevinkoocoaching

continued from front page her current leased location at 3603 Jamison Way. Young said the business sees about 70 patients per week and she has a 2,000 plus and growing patient base ranging in age from 2 to 100 years old.

Under the Castro Valley Central Business District Plan, medical and dental offices are allowed around the Rudy’s site, but it will likely require re-zoning, and formally applying the project with Alameda County Public Works Agency and even the county Board of Supervisors, possibly a two-year process, according to MAC member Ken Carbone.

Meanwhile, Rudy’s continues to operate and serve donuts in “a state of limbo,” Angela Ducato told the Forum. She’s hoping her landlord will have a change of heart and allow the donut shop to continue for many years to come.

Also at Monday’s meeting, the MAC also heard an update “state of the parks” from the Hayward Area Recreation and Park District (HARD).

Recent improvements to Castro Valley-based HARD property include the replacement of the roof at the Chanticleers Theatre and upgrades to six picnic areas at Castro Valley Community Park, both on Quail Avenue.

In the next five years, there are also plans to replace the tennis courts at that park, according to HARD. There have also been improvements to the Kenneth C. Aitken Senior and Community Center at 17800 Redwood Road including new signage and landscaping.

And HARD said that perhaps the largest upgrade in Castro Valley has taken place at Canyon Middle School where four synthetic turf fields for sports have been installed. The $18 million project is a joint effort between the Castro Valley Unified School District and HARD.

LAFCO: Adopt or Dismiss Draft Report

continued from front page Castro Valley map. Jones noted that the draft study will now include a table that includes the easternmost parts of Castro Valley.

Other public comments like those submitted by Castro Valley resident David Livingston point out that incorporation would be “financially infeasible” without transfer of Property Tax in lieu of Vehicle License Fees from the State.

Incorporation has long been a topic of conversation in Castro Valley and the possibility of cityhood has been on ballots in 1956 and 2002 only to be shot down by voters.

With public comment in

hand, LAFCO’s Jones notes that the state agency’s next step includes adopting or dismissing the draft report. It does not trigger any sort of automatic inclusion on a future ballot.

“Alameda LAFCO has not received an incorporation application. We cannot submit an incorporation application. And there is currently no vote on incorporation regarding these affected territories,” Jones said.

“Please note that if LAFCO received any potential incorporation proposal, it would be placed on the ballot for voter approval at the next available general election unless 50 percent of registered voters residing in the incorporation

area submit written protest to LAFCO,” Jones added. “This was also stated at the Castro Valley Municipal Advisory Committee meeting held on August 28.”

More information can be found at the Alameda LAFCO website: alamedalafco.org

CORRECTION:

In our story about the 103-year-old bocce bowler, the company providing the group’s tournament lunch was Big Apple Bagels, not Red Apple Bagels. The Forum regrets the error.

Rudy’s Donuts—long-time staple of eastern Castro Valley Boulevard—might be on its way out

LETTERS to the EDITOR

Clarification on LAFCO Letter by Frank Mellon

In a letter to the editor in last week’s Castro Valley Forum, citizen Frank Mellon suggested that during the recent CV MAC meeting it was stated by the LAFCO Executive Director that, lacking a protest by at least 25% of registered Castro Valley voters, incorporation could be implemented without an election. I am unable to locate either the meeting minutes or any contact information for Mr. Mellon in order to verify his allegation, but if I am reading the LAFCO report correctly, page 35 states that an election would be held should the LAFCO report be approved. Can you confirm my belief that Mr. Mellon’s allegation in the Forum is indeed incorrect? Perhaps a clarification to his comment in the Forum would be appropriate as well, in an effort to keep citizens properly informed. I personally do not have an opinion, pro or con, on incorporation at this time, but only seek to have Castro Valley voters properly informed as the process develops.

–Rich Cooper, Castro Valley

Incorrect Information On LAFCO Report

The draft report on the Castro Valley and surrounding unincorporated communities Initial Feasibility Analysis is a preliminary report. Alameda LAFCO cannot initiate an incorporation proposal, we have not received an incorporation application and there is currently no vote on incorporation regarding these affected territories. Please note that any potential incorporation proposal is placed on the ballot for voter approval at the next available general election if less than 50% of registered voters residing in the incorporation area submit written protest to LAFCO. This was also stated at the Castro Valley Municipal Advisory Committee meeting held on August 28th.

–Rachel Jones, LAFCO

Something More Attune with Current and Future Economy

Mr. Brian Foster (Letters September 6, 2023) writes with authority supporting the recent proposals to convert the unincorporated area of Castro Valley into a self-governing municipality. One suggestion he puts forward to generate tax revenues is that “if we had one or two auto dealerships … we would be flush with tax revenues.” Unfortunately, from what I understand from the business model for auto dealerships is that profit margins are extremely tight, and presuming that buyers will flock to our town in a rush to purchase a new car is unlikely. There are many other auto dealerships in the East Bay and the possible land available near the freeway ramps is rather small, given that dealerships need space for inventory.

I would propose something more attune with the current and future economy – a high-tech/biotech hub where start-ups and research units can base themselves. We are at the geographical center of the East Bay, served by the aforementioned freeways and public transport (BART, buses to SFO, etc.); we have potential tracts on the boulevard such as the Rite Aid site and the closed trailer park just east of KFC, both of which may be available in due time. Both sites are only a short walk from the BART/AC Transit station.

Such organizations could generate tax revenue from property taxes, employees eating out locally, bring a younger generation back to work in Castro Valley, and may have a knock-on effect of generating new businesses, such as perhaps a micro-brewery and other restaurants.

Many of the current residents of Castro Valley work in Silicon Valley and the associated high-tech/biotech hubs in Pleasanton, etc., so we already have local expertise in the industry.

All we need now is someone with the foresight and vision to propose and fund such a development.

–Matthew Kaser, Castro Valley

FROM THE BOULEVARD

In

Absolute

Opposition to Redevelopment of Rudy’s

I am writing in absolute opposition to the matter of the redevelopment of Rudy’s Donuts in Castro Valley to a Medical/Dental Office. Rudy’s has been a cornerstone of the Castro Valley Community for the past three decades. They are a total success story of building a thriving business from scratch and winning over past competitors, namely Winchells Donuts. Rudy’s Donuts is a unique landmark to Castro Valley and the people that live here. It existence is always indicated on the Town maps as a fun place to go. It serves a multitude of functions (listed below) as it is not just a Donut Shop. It is a special/ safe destination for people to meet and socialize. They provide good food at an affordable price and a well secure atmosphere. The Business Owners have been part of the Community for the past thirty + years and know most of their customers by name. It is enjoyed by many patrons in a multitude of occupations. To name a few; Law Enforcement, Teachers, Students and many assorted clubs. The thought of taking away an established thriving business in a portion of our town not for a singular use business is incomprehensible. I strongly urge that this redevelopment application be denied. Castro Valley needs its history and its social identity. Let them put a Medical/Dental office in an area more suited for that type of business. Don’t destroy a business land mark and a unique pillar to the town of Castro Valley.

–Matt Poulos, Castro Valley

To All Who Serve, Thank You

I have not run into anyone who does not remember when Our Great Country was attacked on September 11, 2001. When each of us found out it happened, we were shocked and enraged. The loss of truly innocent lives followed by the loss of our First Responders who ran into danger to rescue and serve others, and the continued loss of so many First Responders 22 years later due to the lingering effects physically and mentally by the attack continues to be a bleak reminder of that day when I found out about it while having breakfast at Denny’s with a close friend.

As we remember those we lost then and since then, let’s not forget to pray for and support the First Responders all around us, encourage them and thank them when we see them, and be thankful that each one made the decision to serve each of us.

Thank you to all of the First Responders as well as our Military, home and overseas, who serve us to do their absolute best to prevent another 9-11 attack from happening.

Our prayers are with each of you.

–Bruce D. and Linda Lee Johnson, Castro Valley

Is Compensation Justified?

The Castro Valley Sanitary District (CVSan) spends our money like it grows on trees. At the Board Meeting on September 5, the Board approved the General Manager’s new yearly employment contract for $272,960.10. This does not include benefits for health, dental, retirement, auto allowance, etc. The General Manager’s total compensation would be approaching $400,000 per year, to manage around 25 employees. There are no state officials making that kind of money. There are only a few federal officials that make that kind of money. At the same Board Meeting, the Board approved a Security System contract for the new Operations and Engineering Building at Center Street for $236,665.21. In the several months of constructing the Operations and Engineering Building, there have already been seven change orders totaling over $200,000. What started out as a $6,000,000 Corporation Yard to be funded from cash reserves, is now a $27,000,000 Operations and Engineering Building funded from a $14,000,000 recently Board approved 30-year Revenue Bond with debt service of over $700,000 per year, with the balance coming from cash reserves. I’m sure the change orders will keep coming. CVSan needs to be investigated for its handling of the ratepayer’s money that ratepayers unwillingly are forced to pay as Sewer Service Charges.

–Ken Owen, Castro Valley

Reflecting with Class Reunion

By Thomas Lorentzen SPECIAL TO THE FORUM

In my last column I referenced the upcoming reunion of the Class of 1963 from Castro Valley High School. It is the class that I was part of.

Although I prefer to not write about a subject a second time, an exception has been made. Compared to other reunions of my class, this one was different. There was a consensus among the 55 or so people that attended that it was our most meaningful. With that, the question is why? We are all now in our late 70’s. It is worth exploring.

We all know that aging does things to us – to our bodies, hearts, and minds. Nearly all of it is challenging. The bad competes with the good. We get more health problems. We have lost classmates - and continue to do so at an unsafe speed. We know the clock is ticking for us.

Nonetheless, we continue to gather. The planners of the reunion decided to create three separate events – all informal. The first was at a classmate’s home for a pizza party. Special guests were two teachers from the early days of Castro Valley High. One was Norm Guest – a teacher and track coach liked by everyone. The other was Dale Berven – also a teacher and coach (wrestling and football). He was also there as a teacher when CV High opened in 1956. We were privileged to have them join us. They were great teachers and role models.

Of added value was that the President of the Castro Valley School District Board - Lavender Whitaker, joined us. When invited to make remarks she thoughtfully emphasized the roles that we played in growing up in CV and going through our schools. We have been a part of history. That history has not only been local, but on a much broader basis. Upon graduation, President Kennedy was assassinated. The next year we went to war in Vietnam. The next year riots broke out in major cities over the issue of race. Radical politics was born on the left and took hold on college campuses throughout the country. There was talk about revolution and overthrowing our government. Five years later Martin Luther King and Robert Kennedy

were both assassinated. Historians often view the 1960’s as the most troubled decade since the Civil War.

Two more events over the next couple of days took place for our reunion. One was for dinner and wine at Twining Vine Winery in Cull Canyon. It was an ideal setting for us to gather. The third and final event was to gather for coffee and donuts at Rudy’s Donut Shop. It, like us, is a part of our local history.

The talk among everyone was that this was the best reunion we ever had. Most of our lives are behind us. We are wiser and more paced in how we view life. We appreciate time more than ever, particularly with family, friends, and classmates. A consensus emerged from within the gathered to have our next reunion sooner, rather than later.

The question was to do it every two years or perhaps even annually. Keep it small and simple. Just get together. Time is of the essence. As aging classmates greet one another, we do so with a spirit of appreciation and gratitude.

As I conclude these thoughts a maxim comes to mind. It is that as we age can make new friends, but we can’t make old friends. And – old friends are the best friends.

ATHLETE OF THE WEEK

Corrine Arakawa

Our Athlete of the Week is Corinne Arakawa, who swims for the Chabot Marlins Swim Club. At the club’s season ending banquet Corinne was recognized for scoring the most team points through the dual meet season. At the league championship meet on July 21. Corinne swam three events and a relay. Her first swim was the 50-yard freestyle stroke where she did a personal best and finished second. Next, she swam 50-yard breaststroke, where she set a new club record. Her final individual swim was

the 50-yard butterfly stroke where she again had a personal best and placed second. The meet’s last event was the 200-yard freestyle relay. Here Corinne led off and got the team a good lead. Her three relay teammates finished it off with another win and gold medal. Corinne also swims and plays water polo for Castro Valley High School. She has varsity lettered in her freshman and sophomore years in both sports. She is enthusiastically looking forward to her two remaining years at Chabot and CVHS.

The Matt Wilhite Team is proud to sponsor Athlete of the Week

Corinne Arakawa

Health: Kits For Women In Lebanon

continued from front page

The Bay Area’s engagement with global issues makes this concern important for residents as well. There is a growing Lebanese population in the Bay Area community, particularly in San Francisco, which holds the third-highest Lebanese population in California.

In response to these challenges, Phoenicia Finesses, a Bay Area-based 501(c)(3) and non-governmental organization (NGO), is playing a pivotal role. Not only does the organization ensure proper hygiene, but it also generates employment opportunities for women.

Phoenicia Finesses employs a sustainable approach by providing reusable menstrual kits to women and girls in need. These kits not only address hygiene but also contribute to reducing waste, aligning with the Bay Area’s commitment to environmental sustainability. Phoenicia Finesses has already distributed kits to over 2,000 women in Lebanon, making an incredible impact on the ground.

REMEMBERING OUR HEROES

There are various ways for the local community to get involved and support Phoenicia Finesses’ mission. The company suggests people volunteer their time, participate in fundraisers, or make donations to contribute to their efforts. By supporting this cause, Phoenicia Finesses president, Nara Mataafa says people can help break the cycle of poverty in Lebanon and create lasting change.

“Our organization has the power of collective action,” Mataafa said. “Our journey began with a personal commitment to address the unmet needs of women and girls in Lebanon. Our team’s diverse backgrounds, and our work in the Bay Area, have driven us to create sustainable solutions that empower women while championing environmental responsibility. We believe that by standing together, we can pave the way for a brighter future.”

Veda and Veera (students of Stanton Elementary) caught a 6 lb catfish at Racoon point on a hot summer afternoon recently. It was their first catfish catch fishing as a team! Congratulations on your ‘Great Catch’ Veda and Veera! Have a ‘Great Catch’ you’d like to share? Send a photo and info by email to: filesforforum@gmail.com

Redwood Christian Schools Patriots Day Assembly was held on Friday, September 8. “Remembering Our Heroes” is an annual program dedicated to remembering the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks on our Great Country. 9-11 changed all of our lives forever. Pictured above are Supt. Al Hearne and teacher Laura Vanegas with ACSO Canine Officer and K-9. Remembering and recognizing the sacrifice First Responders and their families paid on 9-11, in addition to those lives lost since then, are critical for people of all ages. On the 22nd Anniversary of 9-11, the Redwood Christian Schools community (RCS) once again gathered to recognize and thank our First Responders who serve our community, as well as active duty and veterans of our military, who continue to protect all of us today, at home and overseas. This is just a portion of the article. Read it in full: mycvforum.com

Phoenicia Finesses is asking for help in several ways, including participating in local fundraisers, volunteering, or making donations.

“Together, we can create positive change and empower vulnerable communities, “ Mataafa said.  To find out more about their initiatives and ways to get involved, visit their website (phoeniciafinesse.org).

Madison Glock attends Bishop O’Dowd High School.

Raya is a 6 moth old all black bunny. Raya came to the shelter with her brother Reggie. Raya is bonded with her brother it would be good for each other. To adopt Raya, please contact Hayward Animal shelter at: 510-293-7200.

REGGIE is a 6-monthold back and white rabbit. Reggie came to the shelter with partner. He is bonded with Raya.and is playful too. To adopt Reggie, please contact the Hayward Animal shelter at: 510-293-7200.