STUDIO AIR JOURNAL
2016, SEMESTER 1, CAITLYN PARRY CHARLOTTE ANNA SUDHOLZ 699128
CONTENTS Intoduction Part A. Conceptualisation A.1. Design Futuring A.2. Design Computation A.3. Composition/Generation A.4. Conclusion A.5. Learning Outcomes A.6. Appendix - Algorithmic Sketches Part B. Critical Design B.1. Research Field B.2. Case Study 1.0 B.3. Case Study 2.0 B.4. Techniques: Development B.5. Techniques: Proposal B.6. Techniques: Proposal B.7. Learning Outcomes B.8. Appendix - Algorithmic Sketches Part C. Detailed Design C.1. Design Concept C.2. Techtonic Elements and Prototypes C.3. Final Detail Model C.4. Learning Outcomes
INTRODUCTION ABOUT ME
My name is Charlotte Sudholz. I am currently studying at the University of Melbourne where I am in my third and final year of a Bachelor of Environments, majoring in architecture. The things that I inspire me most in life are art, travel, food, jewellery, family and friends. Whilst starting this studio, I began to realise that my knowledge of digital design was reasonably slim in comparison to my understanding of other architectural influences. Despite being heavily reliant on alternate techniques such as drawing and watercolour, I am rather nervous yet excited to explore Grasshopper and gain a greater comprehension about computerised design and its potential. My first encounter with digital designing tools initiated with a variety of Adobe Suite programs, including Photoshop, Illustrator and InDesign. After completing my previous two architectural studios, my skills within such software has become more proficient due to the development and representational requirements that various final pin-ups require. Rhino was the primitive digital modelling program that I was introduced to, within which I learnt about basic panelling tools and how to approach different geometry. Since I am revisiting the program, I hope to gain a greater understanding of its possibilities in conjunction with the plug-in Grasshopper; ultimately enriching my confidence and redefining my approach to an alternative method of design.
4
CONCEPTUALISATION
CONCEPTUALISATION 5
PART A:
CONCEPTUALISATION
A.2 DESIGN FUTURING
Responsive Surface Structure II Steffen Reichert and Achim Menges, Department for Form Generation and Materialisation, HFG Offenbach, Offenbach am Main, Germany, 2008
An underlying theme of biological and ecologically embedded architecture is evident within Steffen Reichart’s structures and their interaction and reflective nature of their context. By working in a geometrical manner, the organic form can address the state of our surroundings through dynamic expression, denoting the level of moisture and humidity. This material-based way of thinking can influence our way of addressing how we live, influencing our built identity by focusing on our environment status. Despite being part of an experimental series of responsive surfaces, this group of poly-surfaces is a prototype which emulates how far this type of technology could be developed. Its initial description of the potential behind the contextual capacity of the material is so diverse and could be used to compliment various built elements, reiterating how important it is to explore new combinations within future forms. Its complex entity continuously defines an individual system, focusing on the interdisciplinary nature of the prototype rather than the outcome [1].
[1] Brad Elias, Lecture week one; Composition/Generation, The University of Melbourne (2016) [2] Achim Menges and Steffen Reichert, “Material Capacity: Embedded Responsiveness”, Architectural Design, 82 (2012), 52-59 [3] Tony Fry, “Design Futuring: Sustainability, Ethics and New Practice (Oxford: Berg), (2008), pp. 1-16 10
CONCEPTUALISATION
Experimentation with wood’s hygroscopic behaviour has never been optimised with computerised design components, and by combining the two an innovative notion of embedded responsiveness has been indicated within this material’s capacity. Therefore by engineering this organic product to become moisture-responsive in relation to humidity, a dynamic and a representation of ‘living’ architectural form has developed, instigating change in the way one perceives the possibilities of a material and its relation with computerised development. Such a self-sufficient design is timeless due to its structural and technological identity; as it has adapted its morphological features to not require a substructure, redefining the structural frame through each extension and tip [2]. Such complexity within the skin of this prototype allows the world to consider how responsive systems could be approached, inspiring various installations and the diversity of algorithmic processes. By showing constant physical feedback from a direct interaction with its surrounding environment, Reichart illustrates a type of architecture that is fluid in relation to its context, almost acting as an environmental indicator. Such intuitive technology reminisces theory within Tony Fry’s Design Futuring, through its continuous ‘dialect of sustainment’; which encourages a form of revolutionised thinking in relation to new way of design [3]. This facet allows inhabitants to comprehend what is effecting their context and the patterns behind its behaviour, giving them selfawareness of their landscape whilst giving the prototype a dual purpose in relation to its intent and future possibility within urban communities.
CONCEPTUALISATION 11
Messe Basel Architect: Herzog de Meuron Location: Basle, Switzerland Year: 2013
Fabrication was a fundamental process for the Messe Basel, as the exterior skin of the building couldn’t have been predicted without various trials, reiterating a new manner in which one can design. Limitations such as constraints of assembly and a materials durability allowed the organic skin to take on various identities, and so such a process was important to determine how ideal the 2D CNC-milled components were in relation to the building and its requirements [6].
The use of computation within Herzog de Meuron’s Messe Basel allows for the softening of form; converting dual cubic form to be deemed as organic due to an unconventional cladding. In terms of ‘sustain-ability’, a new pattern of thinking is evident within this project which merges an environmental building system with the facade, describing how design can be evolved to increase efficiency through co-design and collaboration [4]. Visualisation of the oscillating facade derives from Rhino and engages with the concept of controlling site-specific data to optimise its response to surrounding natural elements. Various sized openings and a double curvature allows for appropriate shading whilst not detracting from the architectural ideal, emulating how such innovative software can be incorporated within a practical and subtle manner [5]. Such a contextual project has influenced environmental focused facades within contemporary architecture and describes how computer-aided design can target and assist various system’s passive objectives.
[4] Tony Fry, “Design Futuring: Sustainability, Ethics and New Practice (Oxford: Berg), (2008), pp. 1-16 [5] Brady Peters, “Realising The Architectural Idea: Computational Design At Herzog & De Meuron”,Architectural Design, 83 (2013), 56-61 [6] Brady Peters, “Realising The Architectural Idea: Computational Design At Herzog & De Meuron”,Architectural Design, 83 (2013), 56-61 [7] Brad Elias, Lecture week one; Composition/Generation, The University of Melbourne (2016)
12
CONCEPTUALISATION
The notion of simplification within this attention to detail reminisces a course of change within architecture, describing how a singular tool can be developed for a singular project, strengthening the concept and architectural ideal. By doing so, each work is fundamentally its own; detaching itself from its precedences and a stylistic stigma, facilitating for a ‘flow’ that changes how one can approach a design without the limitations of connotations to other facets [7]. As a monumental structure in terms of space and accessibility, the Messe Basel depicts how light can be modularly targeted within the structure due to the variable sized openings. This enhances the spatial experience for the inhabitants and provides an ambiguous sense that allows the building to dissolve within its environment; an effect that is thanks to the materiality and computerised, woven facade that disperses the site into architectural form.
Image sourc
ce: http://www.gruner.ch/sites/default/files/styles/default/public/thumbnails/image/messe_basel_2012_2.jpg?itok=Ptuguvby
CONCEPTUALISATION 13
A.2 .DESIGN COMPUTATI
ION
Labrys Frisae Architect: Marc Fornes/ THEVERYMANY Location: Miami, Florida Year: 2011
In relation to computation and its influence on the design process, Forne’s prototypical architecture denotes a new approach to form through experimentation. Not only is the entity controlled by the parametrical limitations within algorithmic equations, but the structural and load bearing capacity of the pavilion is completely dependant on the materiality and engineering behind each component [8]. Such a randomised approach to the design process underpins a notion of how computing is redefining the industry; not only making various stages within the realisation of the form shortened or even removed, but ultimately technology acts as the sole facet that manipulates the mathematic section of the project. This notion is reiterating a rediscovered sense of craftsmanship within architectural practice, allowing for a sense of continuity from designing to fabrication which is pivotal in terms of control and refinement [9].
[8] Patrik Schumacher, “Advancing Social Functionality Via Agent-Based Parametric Semiology”, Archit. Design, 86 (2016), 108-113 [9] Yehuda E. Kalay, Architecture’s New Media: Principles, Theories, and Methods of Computer-Aided Design (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press), (2004), pp. 5-25 [10] Brad Elias, Lecture week two; Composition/Generation, The University of Melbourne (2016) 16
CONCEPTUALISATION
Despite these ongoing changes to how design can be undertaken, I believe that they are fundamental in relation to the future of how once can form an architectural ideal. New fabrication methods are revolutionising the construction industry, as Labrys Frisae’s fabrication reminisces elements of Greg Lynn’s Blobwall; as the subtle tweaking of each block through computation allows for a complex and organic form which is structurally and aesthetically sound [10]. I really like this deconstructed approach, as it allows the project to have a sense of vulnerability yet undeniable excitement; as it is unique through its in-situ fabrication. Fluidity within the pavilion is achieved through foreign geometries that can only be optimised via computation; as each organic facet meanders in various orientations, giving the impression that pragmatic joinery isn’t evident. Yet this aspect drives a notion of performance-orientated design, as each component’s form is a result of achieving a maximum efficiency within each geometry; an aspect which is feat in relation to construction means. Overall, such a fragmented approach to architecture allows for endless opportunities in relation to innovative forms, facades and structures. unconventional methods such as this progressive prototypical fabrication could be targeted for different briefs, allowing this technology to be used within other contexts to optimise their opposing or confronting issues.
CONCEPTUALISATION 17
Galazy Soho Architect: Zaha Hadid Location: Soho, China Year: 2012
Hadid’s Galaxy Soho demonstrates how parametric design and computation has been addressed to confront a social side to architecture in relation to forming a sense of community and belonging. By creating such an organic form, a notion of centrality is emulated within the plan, allowing the three individual towers to evolve into a singular entity. The spherical form of each pivotal tower decreases the opposing nature of the form, and has been softened with the aid of computation. Algorithmic equations have formulated primitive layout of the entire design, with cantilevering pathways which oscillate and orbit around the various central points in the structure. Unlike Labrys Frisae’s bottom-up approach with prototyping, Hadid has used a top-down technique which distinguishes the targeted formal outcome, and designs around a mutual ideal [11]. By doing so, various limitations restrict the facets within the design such as the interior spaces, plans and materiality; aspects which could have been optimised.
Despite being somewhat restrictive, Hadid’s use of emphasis within computerisation and computation has redefined the architectural industry in terms of form; as prior to her presence there was a lack of emphasis on the organic and how such fluid entities could be conceptualised and realised within our society [12]. As a consequence, there are significant incoming changes within the fixation on unprecedented and natural forms within architectural works, allowing for new fundamental influences to formulate new approaches with the relevant technology to make them valid. Achievable geometries within Galaxy Soho have been realised through the assistance of the 3d software Rhino; as various spherical forms have been connected with different commands, making it apparent how the structure would look like and what type of method and construction measures would be needed for its production. This reiterates how computation is revolutionary in terms of simulation, as a sense of prediction can be manifested through the virtual model [13]. The performance of the design has been optimised due to the influence of computerised design, allowing the form and its relation to one another to derive from the targeted notion of community and belonging. Without such parameters, Galaxy Soho’s innovative entity would have never been conceptualised, reiterating how computation allows for more than structural and formal advantages within architecture; as it can be used to target social or political parameters, giving a deeper sense of identity and meaning to its targeted forms.
Image source: http://images.adsttc.com/media/images/508e/e0ab/28ba/0d7f/e400/0005/large_jpg/Galaxy _SOHO_ZHA_12-10_5230.jpg?1413941919
[11] Yehuda E. Kalay, Architecture’s New Media: Principles, Theories, and Methods of Computer-Aided Design (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press), (2004), pp. 5-25 [12] Mark Fornes, “The Art Of The Prototypical”, Archit. Design, 86 (2016), 60-67 [13] Brad Elias, Lecture week two; Composition/Generation, The University of Melbourne (2016) 18
CONCEPTUALISATION
Image source: http://maxcdn.thedesigninspiration.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/Silver-Galaxy-Soho-001.jpg
CONCEPTUALISATION 19
A.3 .COMPOSITION/GENE
ERATION
ICD/ITKE PAVILLION Architect: University of Stuggart Location: Stuggart, Germany Year: 2013/14
A generative approach to design can be emulated within ICD/ ITKE’s Research Pavillion at the University of Stuttgart; where explorations of biomimetic forms are developed and analysed due to the assistance of algorithm aided design. Encoding a natural form allows for a new line of influence, denoting how the simplest patterns can create the most complex design [14]. Ongoing research within the architectural profession denotes how computation is refining the practice of architecture, promoting an unprecedented way of thinking that is consequently redefining design in a multifactoring-orientated manner. The ICD/ITKE pavilion is a fibre-woven structure that reiterates the form of a beetle’s elytra; taking inspiration from the morphological principles that construct its biological entity [15].
Structural fluidity functions in accordance to the lightweight structure to that of the beetle, reiterating the notion of the hardened forewings protecting the fragile flying wings within the interior. As a consequence, the pavilions double-layered composite shell achieves a high level of material performance through the differentiation of fibre organisation; as the glass fibres mimic the interior mould allowing the structural carbon fibres to respond to load-bearing requirements [16]. Such an efficient flow of forces not only allows for an integral relationship between the projects form, material and structure but how it has directly emerged from transferring the interdisciplinary manner of the organisms, ultimately resulting in a representative architectural form. The pivotal feature however resides in the design and fabrication process which has been realised through computation. By linking various input parameters, a fundamental set of data has progressively analysed and optimised the form to simulate the best structure for the site [17]. Not only does this allow for more responsive design, but an innovative way to consider lightweight materials within construction, which in terms to engineering and architectural demands reiterates how computation allows for such complexity to be achieved through the a few components.
Image source: http://archive-cdn.monograph.io/page/3960/53b2152dc07a80790f0001d5_icd-itkeresearch-pavilion-2015-icd-itke-university-of-stuttgart_icd-itke_rp13-14_process12-d2048.jpg
[14] Brad Elias, Lecture week three; Composition/Generation, The University of Melbourne (2016) [15] Moritz Doerstelmann and others, “ICD/ITKE Research Pavilion 2013-14: Modular Coreless Filament Winding Based On Beetle Elytra”, Archit. Design, 85 (2015), 54-59 [16] Moritz Doerstelmann and others, “ICD/ITKE Research Pavilion 2013-14: Modular Coreless Filament Winding Based On Beetle Elytra”, Archit. Design, 85 (2015), 54-59 [17] Brady Peter, ‘Computation Works: The Building of Algorithmic Thought’, Architectural Design, 83, 2, (2013) pp. 08-15 22
CONCEPTUALISATION
Image sou -pavilion-b
urce: http://www.urdesignmag.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/5-university-of-stuttgart-realized-a-carbon-fibre based-on-beetle-shells.jpg
CONCEPTUALISATION 23
WEST COAST PAVILLION Architect: Atelier Manferendini Location: Beijing, China Year: 2006 Form finding is a primitive computational method which introduced the concept of optimisation as a structural and aesthetic quality within architectural design. Manferdini’s West Coast Pavilion reappropriates this ideal of optimisation within a different type of interdisciplinary dialect, describing how a form can only be found once all the correct variables emerge within a singular environment. Such a contextual form of generative architecture appears complex due to its imposing skin and diamond like form, one which appears massive and lacking of a clear connection such as ICD/ITKE’s biometric pavillion. Yet transparency as an aesthetic is what denotes the underlying drive behind this structure, reminiscing a type of traditional motif through a behavioural three-dimensional lacework, which creates a dynamic screening and filtering effect to that of a traditional Chinese screen [18].
[18] Mario Carpo, “The Ebb And Flow Of Digital Innovation: From Form Making To Form Finding - And Beyond”, Architectural Design, 83 (2013), 56-61 [19] “West Coast Pavilion”, Atelier Manferdini, 2016 <http://www.ateliermanferdini.com/ still-1/> [accessed 17 March 2016]. [20] Mario Carpo, “The Ebb And Flow Of Digital Innovation: From Form Making To Form Finding - And Beyond”, Architectural Design, 83 (2013), 56-61 [21] Brad Elias, Lecture week three; Composition/Generation, The University of Melbourne (2016)
24
CONCEPTUALISATION
Such a recontextualised pattern once projected onto the urban landscape of Beijing subtly contrasts two antithesis’ of architectural design; displacing the known urban landscape behind an emergence in computational capacity. The sandwich of undulating layers, which coalesce and diverge around and through this cubic volume have been generated and fabricated through computation; focusing on the compositions geometry in order to be optimised structurally [19]. A notion of indeterminacy is mimicked through the CNC milled and laser cut facade, which further emphasises the pavilions revolutionary identity due to its status of being the first digitally fabricated building within China [20]. By focusing on a sense of modernity through structure and juxtaposition of the old and new, a complex generative form has targeted a range of variables within a simple set of rules. Compositional qualities similarly follow a centralised rhythm, yet the solidarity of the structural qualities and cubic nature of the pavilion obstruct the notion of transparency within the design. The duality between structure and concept indicates a new way of thinking in relation to design, describing how computation is developing architecture into an integrated art form which promotes simplification and coherence [21].
Image source: http://www.ateliermanferdini.com
Image source: http://www.ateliermanferdini.com
Image source: http://www.ateliermanferdini.com
CONCEPTUALISATION 25
CONCLUSION Exploration of architectural precedence and its scope of development in relation to computer progression and technology has been emulated in Part A. From this range of projects, it can be distinguished that the presence of algorithmic and computational processes within architectural practice has revolutionised the manner in which we think and design. This transition in cultural paradigms both social and architectural denotes how designers are adapting their mannerisms to address present solutions aimed to enable for a sustainable future. In relation to the site of Ceres Market, their is a need to understand its internal ecosystems which consists of various pockets of activity within its layout. Such versatility reiterates how it is vital to comprehend the interrelation of each system, in order to formulate an architectural intervention which emulates the complexity of the environment. This could potentially be done with an algorithmic approach, as one could begin to analyse how a system works and the patterns that emerge from a series of environmental exchanges. Therefore, I intend to design in correspondence to the relationships created within the complexity of the market. By linking the natural environment to the functionality within various spaces, differential patterns will emerge through coalescence; ultimately allowing for a greater understanding of the systems and consequential behaviour within the site. By explaining the operations behind the environmental and contextual impact on the environment, occupants and visitor will be informed about the relationships between systems and how the market could be improved, allowing for a beneficial notion through the implication of computation and algorithmic aided architectural design.
26
LEARNING OUTCOMES My understanding of architectural design as a discipline has been revolutionised due to the content of Part A. Finite possibilities in relation to structure, materiality and form are available due to algorithmic exploration and computation, as Grasshopper offers the opportunity not only to reach a notion of geometric optimisation and exploration, but it provides a new way of design thinking. By perceiving a scenario with a sense of algorithmic thinking, one can approach and obtain a unique comprehension of how to solve that problem through understanding a complex set of relationships. Prototyping and the importance of fabrication during the design progress has also been highlighted as an important measure, denoting how computation allows for virtual and physical manifestations to assist with refinement and critique. A perceived â&#x20AC;&#x2DC;modelâ&#x20AC;&#x2122; therefore is no longer a static term which implies of a simulation or representation of a design. Instead, its the description of computational algorithms acting as the basis of generative design. This process makes use of rules, parameters and boundaries to produce a set of optimal solutions to very complex scenarios. Consequently, I have learnt a great deal about the shift in design paradigms which have resulted due to scripting cultures, denoting how Grasshopperâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s influential nature has opened a new way of design thinking which will enable architects to reconsider their values in relation to the traditional design process.
The unique form-finding qualities that are intrinsic to computation are a set of tools that not only are invaluable to future design possibilities, but they could have assisted in the process of developing previous designs. A key example would have been within Studio Earth which focused on tectonics and their influence on architectural form. If a parametric approach was used, a complex series of relations could have become intertwined between notions of massing as well as frame and infill, allowing me to push the boundaries with the geometries within each tectonic; almost merging the distinctions between each form. By comparing this previous design to my new skill set, it is evident how small elements such as contouring can be fabricated more efficiently, and I am excited to see the outcomes of incorporating computation into my design approach.
27
ALGORITHMIC SKETCHES
28
29
30
PART B:
DETAILED DESIGN
31
B1
PATTERN The role of patterning and ornamentation in architecture is integral to communicating a point of transcendence between an intended ideal and the user. However, the history of ornamentation documents a vast range of discrepancies in its use and importance within social context, often being linked to religion or political agendas [1]. A more organic linage of this ideal is underpinned within Islamic ornamentation, a form of embellishment that elaborates cultural values and aspects of symbolism within mosaic. As Mark Gracia dwells on within his studies upon patterning within architecture, there appears to be a tendency within architecture’s history to associate patterns with nature [2]. Such speculation could be deducted from the similar principles that organic entities exhibit as a self-organising system of interconnected parts and functions. the structural logic behind utilising the natural analogy within traditional patterning resinates within Leon Battista Alberti, who focused on the definition of ornamentation as a necessity for beauty; a quality that he perceived as being pivotal to nature, and therefore formal qualities inspired by such distinctions could be denoted as ‘beautiful’ [3]. Yet there has been a drastic departure from such a traditional use of ornamentation within architecture, as an emphasis on symbolic motifs are being dissolved by criticisims of the of the modernist era. In the view of Adolf Loos, ornamentation has lost its social function and therefore has become an unnecessary that detracts from the transparency of the form [4]. By depriving architecture from such embellishment, it was believed that each project would become more ‘sincere’ to its context and function.
Despite such a great emphasis on purist beliefs, patterning and ornamentation can identify with an array of unprecedented values in a manner that may not reminisce the ‘monumentality’ of previous eras. A innovative and compelling approach is embedded within the work of Melbourne-based architecture firm ARM and the William Barak building; a project which resinates a distinctive cultural asset and figure within the perforated facade of a building. Not only does this form of ornamentation represent a sense of identity, but it reiterates a linage of symbology that has been reapproriated to enhance social function and awareness, parting ways for a renewal of the application of decoration within a modern times. Through the incorporation of parametric design, patterning as a tectonic can encompass a complexity that excels previous forms due to the embedded information that is present. Proportions and motifs can be manipulated to enhance or detriment a specific issue, prompting judgement and evaluation through primitive aesthetics. Due to the limitless potential and notion of depth that this field embodies, I have decided to pursue its diverse qualities due to the capability to incorporate contextually within a vast domain; ultimately intertwining information to contrast layers of individual rhythms within an entity.
[1] Farshid Moussavi and Michael Kubo, The Function Of Ornament (Barcelona: Actar, 2006). [2] Mark Garcia, Patterns Of Architecture (London: John Wiley, 2009). [3] Leon Battista Alberti, On The Art Of Building in Ten Books (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT 1988) . Press, [4] Farshid Moussavi and Michael Kubo, The Function Of Ornament (Barcelona: Actar, 2006).
32
DETAILED DESIIGN
Image source: http://assemblepapers.com.au/assemblepapers/wp-content/uploads/2015/05/SLIDER _assmbl_portrait_8158_WEB.jpg
Image sou
urce: https://www.pinterest.com/feeleykatie/islamic-culture/
DETAILED DESIGN
33
B2 CASE STUDY 1.0 HERZOG & DE MEURON DE YOUNG MUSEUM
Herzog & De Meuron is an architecture firm with an emphasis on computational technology as a pivotal design tool which can contribute a sense of individuality to each project. Their focus on patterning is due to the notion of layering various scaled geometries on surfaces that derives from the digital designing process. Such methodology can be perceived within the De Young Museum, which features three copper screens that have been perforated in different manners to encapsulate oscillating patterns along each facade. Through a sense of precision provided by computation technology, ensured for a controlled fabrication with exact details on a greater scale. The surfaces transparency manifests patterning through its presence, abstracting itself from being a form of decoration, redefining itself to become a part of the architecture instead.
34
DETAILED DESIGN Image source: http://www.archdaily.com.br/br/01-60612/fotografia-e-arquitetura-duccio-malagamba
DETAILED DESIGN
35
Image source: http://www.archdaily.com.br/br/01-60612/fotografia-e-arquitetura-duccio-malagamba
ITERATIONS RADIUS SAMPLING 1.
2.
3.
4.
11.
12.
19.
20.
27.
28.
AXIS/PLANE DIFFRENTIATION 9.
10.
HEIGHT/EXTRUSION SAMPLING 17.
18.
WEAVING/GRAPH MAPPING 25.
36
26.
DETAILED DESIGN
5.
6.
7.
8.
13.
14.
15.
16.
21.
22.
23.
24.
29.
30.
31.
32.
DETAILED DESIGN
37
SUCCESSFUL SPECIES An array of variation has been formulated through alterations and additions of this script, reiterating the limitless potential behind algorithmic design. Perhaps the most interesting aspect of this process is the multifactorial manner and mindset that a designer must obtain in order to consider future obstacles and consequently how they must adapt their script. This in itself is a testament to how one can manipulate endless sets of data to push the boundaries of a specific geometry or parametric composition, as I found that by adding components and new relationships, more complex relationships beca to occur, leading to a variety of embedded pattern. Such advantages permit for variance between geometries and forms through simple modifications. Through the development of the multiple species types from the original script of the De Young Museum project, one can perceive how the adaption of the patterning facade technique and the manipulation of parameters has allowed for architectural realisation. An example would be depicted within comparing the species of radius sampling with that of the extrusion species; as the only difference is whether the image sampling component affects the radius of the height of the geometries within the bounding surface. As a consequent, a whole new typology is discovered which is greatly evolved from its antecedent form.
38
DETAILED DESIGN
When developing and testing the potentials of the definition, I was considering how to produce new forms of patterning which could be applicable for an architectural design within Ceres. This aim translated into the exploration of patterns which exhibited strong repetitious elements that underpin a notion of depth; a characteristic that has limitless potential due to the individual systems and relations that thrive within the geometry. In relation to the design brief addressing Ceres, this task has allowed me to start consdiering what form the architectural screen could possess to enhance its contextual placement. As such, the various patterned geometries which exhibit architectural qualities that bespoke ideals towards various functionalities and programs were considered as better suited due to relevancy. Even more so, if they could be created into fabricatable and liveable spaces. Four of the most successful iterations produced were founded on this set of selection criteria. They are no.10, no.19, no.20 and no.4.
10. FLOATING PLATFORMS Despite being highly impractical, this iteration resinates a form of weightlessness that appeals to the aesthetics within my selection criteria. Transparency is pivotal within layered patterning, as it allows for complexity within a minimal manner. These scattered circles denote the potential to be developed into a perforated screen; perhaps dissolving an unpleasant view through soft segregation.
19. WOVEN PANELS Intersection of planar forms is the main aesthetic within this iteration, permitting for a complex yet achievable form. Despite not having any functional properties, this composition encapsulates how linear qualities can produce a sense of transcendence through careful consideration of placement. It is for that reason that I have deemed it as successful, as the geometry is pushed into taking on a new presence.
20. INDENTED EXTUSIONS The notion of repetition within this iteration is a persuasive device in relation to creating a formal pattern that undulates due to the massing of single devices. Its composition mimics a potential approach to an installation or confronting screen, and is why I thought it was deemed successful in relation to addressing the brief. It would be interesting to visualise what kind of effect this iteration may have if fabricated with a specific object; as a literal motif may transform the presence of this composition within the context of Ceres.
24. UNDULATING TRUSS SYSTEMS The textual qualities denoted within the layered composition of this iteration is what I found quite compelling, as it looks like some type of creature due to its undeniable rhythm. Despite not being desirable in reference to fabrication, the nodes within this iteration do possess a sense of functionality, which indicate an opportunity to give the structure a programmatic purpose. Its intimate nature is also appealing, as it seems to emerge from the landscape which has a organic effect.
DETAILED DESIGN
39
B3 I/O PAPER CLOUD ARCHITECTECT: IWAMOTOSCOTT LOCATION: SAN FRANSISCO, USA YEAR: 2014 Paper Clouds is a transformative structure by IwamotoScott, developed through parametric principles based on repetitive tectonics for fabrication. Taking inspiration from Quantum Paper, Googleâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s code name for their new Material Design Ui, IwamotoScott has developed an installation that derives from a heavy emphasis on fabrication and weightlessness. From the primitive stages in the design process, a combined effort between digital scripting and analogue prototyping was distinguished, highlighting how the form of the installation was to derive from the manipulation of accessible materials such as paper and staples. Through this factor of limitation, a greater sense of appreciation could be placed to the behaviour of the paper in relation to aggregation and connection logics; facilitating for such detail to decipher the overall geometrical form of the oblique array.
Such consideration of relationships between the material, form and connection detailing dictates how a sense of simplicity can produce a patterned/tessellation effect that allows the geometries to obtain a characteristic of transcendence and elegance. By attempting to reverse-engineer the Paper Clouds project, I have been able to comprehend the project as a system through the distinction of the interrelation of individual components. As a result, I have been enabled to explore how the massing of an array of geometries can lead to a visual and spatial pattern that is enticing towards the user, but also how basic methods of fabrication can assist in producing a complexity that canâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t be always achieved in advanced forms.
Image source: http://www.iwamotoscott.com/I-O-Paper-Cloud
40
DETAILED DESIGN
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
DETAILED DESIGN
41
REVERSE-ENGINEER FLIP MATRIX
SQUARE GRID
DIVIDE GRID
CULL
INTERPOLATE
INTERPOLATE
FIND CENTROID OF POINTS
MERGE
MERGE
DEFINE OFFSET GEOMETRY CONSTRUCT DOMAIN
1.
2.
3.
INTERPOLATION OF GRID DATA To create a boundary for the surface geometry, all of the u points are connected with individual curves. The data is also flattened to ensure that the curves do not wrap around each other.
FLIP MATRIX In order to interpolate the opposing values to create the basis of the adapted grid, the matrix must be flipped in order to swap the input of data.
CENTROID GEOMETRY After the basic grid is produced, cubic performations are dictated within the centre of each square to mimick the structural grid.
42
DETAILED DESIGN
GEOMETRY
PLANAR SURFACE
DIVIDE SURFACE
BOX MORPH
SURFACE BOX
ROTATE
MOVE
SERIES
SERIES
MOVE
DECONSTRUCT DOMAIN
4.
PLANAR SURFACE For the second half of the script to work, a boundary surface must be defined. This is done by taking the edge parameters of the grid and using that data to make a identical surface.
5.
BOX MORPH Once a surface is created, an intended geometry is referenced and replicated to the parameters of the grid. This gives the project its form through an efficient method of visual representation.
6.
ROTATIONAL SERIES As the geometry of the oblique paper forms fluctuates its orientation at every level, it was necessary to ensure that the Box Morph oscillated between true and false values at various stages.
DETAILED DESIGN
43
FINAL OUTCOME
The overall outcome of this reverse-engineering exercise was extremely beneficial in allowing me to think algorithmically. When contemplating how to approach the task of redesigning Paper Clouds, I was surprised to find myself considering the logic that constructs various data flow and explicit geometries, almost deconstructing the project to visualise how it was initially formulated. Despite the final outcome being very similar to its precedented twin, I found it very hard to achieve the intimate detailing that is evident within the edge connections for the oblique geometry which resulted in some discrepancies. It must also be noted that the Box Morph technique that derives from grasshopper is inaccurate to an extent, as its programmed to divide a singular geometry along a surfaceâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s domain. Due to this factor, the distribution of geometry is sometimes wrapped to match fluctuating surface divisions, allowing the components within some areas to be slightly bigger or stretched in a certain direction, differentiating themselves from the uniform grid. Despite this, I found it interesting to use Box Morph due to the compelling aesthetics that it can produce, in spite of its inaccuracy which is not desirable with fabrication. Another pivotal difference between the digital representation of Paper Clouds and its actually embodiment is that of the actual process from which its fabrication is realised. Other than the materiality of the geometry, there are several factors to the installations appearance that result from the construction process. For example, the staples which attach the array of folded sheets of paper are a significant structural feature, which consequentially adds to the overall impression and tactile presence of the design; a factor which cannot be illustrated in Grasshopper. Personally, I am intrigued by the complex pattern and conceptualisation of Paper Clouds. The emphasis on simple materials being refined within parametric and digital means to assist on the development of prototyping is not only pivotal to fabricating an architectural intervention within Ceres, but also places a sense of recognition on how patterning can be realised through the massing of singular forms. Hopefully by pushing the duality of the underlying structural grid and the occupying geometries within this definition, I will be able to formulate a series of unique and engaging algorithmic entities that embody a complex domain of patterning through a layered composition.
44
DETAILED DESIGN
DETAILED DESIGN
45
B4 TECHNIQUE DEVELOPMENT The technique which has been developed from the fundamental values of Paper Clouds has the limitless potential to formulate an array of irregular forms and geometries which rebel against the conformity of the original design, due to the flexible nature of the algorithm. The two major components within my developed script; the data manipulation of the grid and the box morphing technique. Through the relationship of these two elements, there are numerous directions to take in order to produce unique surfaces that can vary in scale, function and form. By adjusting various initial parameters such as the geometry input for the box morph, the entity of the form can be completely transformed, making it seem unrelated to the original reference. Alternatives addressing the data manipulation of the grid include creating a new domain or boundary for the input data of the grid allows for distance-based transformations due to the placement of attractor points. By doing so the uniformed base is dissolved into a more organic grid, creating a dynamic sense and rhythm within the linear structure. From these potentials I am certain that I would like to continue with the development of this definition, as its duality could drive a successful architectural intervention within the Ceres community. I am intrigued with the ideal of a double skin per say, to exploit an underlying structure from which a variety of patterned geometries could sprawl giving the design a sense of function and purpose within the site.
46
DETAILED DESIGN
CONCEPTUALISATION 47
ITERATIONS 1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
10.
11.
12.
17.
18.
19.
20.
25.
26.
27.
28.
48
DETAILED DESIGN
5.
6.
7.
8.
13.
14.
15.
16.
21.
22.
29.
30.
23.
31.
24.
32.
DETAILED DESIGN
49
33.
34.
35.
36.
41.
42.
43.
44.
49.
50.
50
DETAILED DESIGN
37.
38.
39.
40.
45.
46.
47.
48.
SELECTION CRITERIA Fabrication Capacity
How easily can the iteration be physically manifested within a prototype? is it realistic or confined to digital parameters?
Functional Engagement
Does the iteration possess the ability to take on a sense of program? If so, is it multifunctional or there for perhaps an artistic purpose?
Contextual Adaption
Can the iteration be retrofitted or adapted to various locations throughout Ceres?
Complexity of Patterning
Does the iteration allow for possible variation within its geometry that is sufficient in embedding characteristics of Ceres?
Spatial Transcendence
Does the iteration possess the potential of being aesthetically appealing? How could this compelling nature resinate within Ceres and for what cause?
DETAILED DESIGN
51
TECHNIQUE DEVELOPMENT From the selection criteria, four iterations were perceived as the most successful against the rest of the matrix due to their potential to be development as a design proposal. Some of the key aspects within my design focus are the fluid and underlying complexity of patterned geometries which are enhanced through the interelation of various levels of details. This makes geometric articulation and its relation to connection and structural details a dire factor, as the effects created from this multifactorial entity can allow for embedded contextually and functionality through its overall formal qualities. In addition, a notion of program and functionality is vital, reiterating how the geometries themselves when fabricated need to have the capacity to contain some feature or allow for a certain requirement, without detracting from the surrounding context or comprising the structural integrity of the form. Adaption to the context is also pivotal in order to respond to the brief, as there are several slight bends in the intersecting footpaths of my chosen site and therefore a flexible curvature is required. From all of the iteration produced from this stage, i have found the most relevant and successful in terms of potential development to be ………..
52
DETAILED DESIGN
25. LAYERED GEOMETRY The duality of the systems and their interrelated nature is extremely successful in meeting the selection criteria, as it references both sides of the spectrum with its refined aesthetics and distinct set of program. Much like the reverse-engineer project of Iwamoto Scott, this iteration dictates a systematic approach to the ideal of having two screens acting within one entity; yet an inverse approach is undertaken due to the circular geometries taking on a structural intent unlike the undulating decorative screen. In relation to adhering to contextual references, I believe that this iteration has the potential to be developed to perhaps frame an image like the William Barak building or to incorporate neglected objects within the site.
Fabrication Capacity Functional Engagement Contextual Adaption Complexity of Patterning Spatial Transcendence
34. INTERSECTING TRIANGULATED GRIDS The sense of rhythm produced by this iterationâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s linear presence has allowed of an asymmetrical form that denotes a great amount of potential in relation to addressing the brief. Its geometric composition encapsulates how the form could act as an occupational screen; may it be with shelves or just as a decorative feature. However despite the intersecting patterns between two grid origins, there is still a lacking capability to resinate with the desired aesthetic of layering and transcendence, and it is for this reason that I do not think that there will be any further development of this form.
Fabrication Capacity Functional Engagement Contextual Adaption Complexity of Patterning Spatial Transcendence
40. DIVERGING SCREEN This iteration has addressed all of the selection criteria in a manner that identifies the formal qualities and patterning typology that I would like to pursue within later design developments. through the inclusion of attractor points, the structural grid has undulated it a manner that oscillates to contextual information within Ceres, embedding that notion of transcendence between spatial entities. The circular geometry that occupies the screen denotes a sense of functionality; allowing for this interdisciplinary identity. This cohesive relationship ultimately strengthens the design in terms of meeting an array of criteria, which will help manipulate this typology into a fully resolved design.
Fabrication Capacity Functional Engagement Contextual Adaption Complexity of Patterning Spatial Transcendence
46. MORPHED PARABOLAS In relation to attempting to create a modular iteration thats overall form boasts an individual capability to address aesthetic, structural and contextual criteria, this geometric wall of solid objects has derived. taking inspiration for greg Lynn, I attempted to revolve this iteration around his principles, which could be refined to become suitable for the application of a screen wall within Ceres. Despite the concept being compelling, the fabrication of massive geometry may be impractical, limiting the design through connection details and depriving any sense of transparency. It is for these reasons that despite further exploring morphed geometries, I will not be pursuing it as a sole design resolution.
Fabrication Capacity Functional Engagement Contextual Adaption Complexity of Patterning Spatial Transcendence
DETAILED DESIGN
53
B5 PROTOTYPES Material processes and fabrication techniques have become integral to the computational design process. In relation to the duality within the formal qualities of my design, the initial consideration in terms of performance requirements derives to the materiality of the structure. Since I required a sense of rigidity within the structural grid as well as a capability to fold and bend for the unrolled geometries, I thought it would be suitable to use a composite material which can achieve both requirements: mount board. A reasonable cheap and durable product, mount board can be laser cut at the FabLab through the submission of a Rhino file; a factor which is desirable when fabricating baked geometry from Grasshopper. Referring back to the Paper Clouds project by IwamotoScott, I began to consider how the connection details within the prototypes could become integral to the design itself; leading to the variety of exposed and hidden notch joints which compliment the mount board once again due to its properties. In relation to the process that was undertook to fabricate the series of prototypes, it must be understood that each element that is intended to be laser cut must be planar. In relation to organic geometries such as the box morphed cylinders, I had to unroll the form and add tabs to the sides in order for the connections to sustain themselves. Due to my interest in exposed connections, I decided to have all the decorative forms which could occupy the skin of the structure to have tabs, allowing for a variety of outcomes from a single technique. After sending of the line work to the FabLab, the laser cut elements will be returned within a singular sheet of mount board; taped down to the foundation in relation to maintaining all of the parts within their dictated place. Despite being helpful, laser cutting can lead to some undesirable outcomes such as burn marks and damaged surfaces due to the tape, however due to the intent of the task I wasnâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;t too concerned with these factors. Instead the benefits of this method are much more significant, as the precision and rapid construction are invaluable when fabricating prototypes.
54
DETAILED DESIGN
1. Bending the mountboard to place one side in compression.
2. Replicating the motion to strain the material in tension.
3. Placing the mountboard under lateral stress.
4. Rolling the mountboard as tightly as possible before warping.
5. Folding the mountboard on itself to judge resistance.
6. Repeating folding action to achieve a curved surface.
7. Angled folds describes the language of a paneled effect within the surface.
8. Wrapping the surface till its finite point, which creates a paneled spiral.
9. Pulling the mountboard to attempt to break its structural integrity. DETAILED DESIGN
55
WAFFLE GRID The waffle grid form is a conventional approach to fabricating a reasonably durable and resistant structure. The notches within the intersection of joints allow each panel to securely fasten itself within its perpendicular twin; allowing for an efficient and self-supporting form due to the bracing from lateral forces. The flexibility of the mount board allows for such unconventional curvature and yet still is able to stand up despite its organic and thin materiality. In terms of a structural component, this grid would be sufficient is sustaining the occupied geometries, however the detailing of the connections between the two would have to be further considered.
HEXAGONAL GEOMETRY This framed hexagonal geometry derives from the attempt to include a sense of functionality within my design intent, potentially further embedding contextuality though occupying plant life. Its formal quality derived from folding each side towards it centre, and then oscillating between gluing the tabs on the outside and inside of the prototype. The intent behind the fluctuating connections was to display the joint detailing, reiterating how the structural program works and may importantly, how it can contribute to the overall patterning of the design. It would be interesting to produce several more of these prototypes in order to visualise how they present themselves en mass, as they could create a new identity of the geometry.
UNROLLED CYLINDER By unrolling the surface of a single cylinder, the planarity behind the fabrication of this prototype was made achievable. Its smooth finish it a testament to the consideration behind the process used to realise this organic form, and is beneficial for future opportunities in regards to fabricating curvaceous forms. The exposed and contrasting linear tabs intersect with the geometry to allow for a self-supporting structure that remains in tact due to the sheer friction created by the bend mount board. However the flush exterior may be problematic in creating an array of these prototypes, as the connection between forms would have to derive from pinned or glued joints.
WIRED CONNECTION Resulting as a by-product from the hexagonal geometry, I decided to explore an additional connection that could be simply fabricated from household products. By utilising the wire ties that generally seal bread, a flexible yet steady joint was facilitated for, allowing the panels to rotate between directions to increase structural stability. Despite not being an intended prototype, the invaluable knowledge produced by this experiment has reiterated how a sense of simplicity within fabrication still allows for complexity; much like the details within IwamotoScottâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s paper Clouds.
56
DETAILED DESIGN
CONCEPTUALISATION 57
B6 PROPOSAL Ceres is a dynamic and fluid environment which is an entity of fragmented functions which all contribute to its welcoming identity. Despite this appearence, when at the site I found that there was a disjionted notion within exploring the area, as every pocket seemed alienated from one another. Since there is such an emphasis on the ideal of community within Ceres, I found it bizarre that there was no form of connection and a void within the relationship between sections, ultimately prompting me to question how these naural, technical and cultural systems interact. In response I decided to address an area that acts as one of the main connection points within the versatile and complex structure of Ceres, and would like to develop a screen which further emphasises each node within the rich fabric of the site. These aims will be confronted in terms of: - incorporating materiality and structure with the ideal of continuity - reflecting elements of Ceres within the self-commissioned architecture to reiterate the ethos of the environement - giving users a greater appretiation of the landscape and the complexity of Ceres.
58
DETAILED DESIGN
Patterning is an aesthetic that can be conceptually responsive to not only the breif and the site, but the ideas behind connection and a cohesive structure. As a consequence, I aim for my screen to be based of the pivotal areas within Ceres, allowing them to act as a foundation from which my structure can oscillate and develop from. In relation to computation, Grasshopper allows for such contextual data to create paramteric forms which potray a related identity of an issue but with a different approach. I am to link the components used to push my design to be more resposive with embedded information which allows users to understand its placement within the site and how it can illude to the fundamental morals that construct Ceres.
DETAILED DESIGN
59
60
DETAILED DESIGN
The structural system within the proposed design relies on an underlying waffle grid that allows for the occupational geometry to fix themselves within the array of openings. Such distinction between structure and function is merged through the elief of patterning; allowing the design to become an entity through the underlating form. The curvature within the plan of the screen is dependant on the meandering pathways within Ceres, especially at the intented site due to the convergence of five various corridors. By manipulating the screen to lean away from the most extreme points within the curve, a sense of integration is achieved, making the design appear for tangible and dynamic.
DETAILED DESIGN
61
62
DETAILED DESIGN
DETAILED DESIGN
63
B.6.1 GROUP DESIGN INTENT In reference to the next stage of design development, a collaborative shift in design intent is required in order to work cohesively within a group. By morphing all of our ideals and criteria together, a mutual emphasis on a site-responsive architectural form was deciphered, as we all felt as though it was integral to focus on a factor that seemed to be lacking within the site. At the moment, there is a strong consideration on the composition of Ceres in relation to its segregated nature as well as how it has been oppressed by various external factors such as the power lines, both which are detrimental to the site and its overall intent. It is for this reason that we want to explore an ideal that serves Ceres in a certain manner, almost giving back to the community or spreading awareness through our architectural intervention. By continuing developing and merging our individual definitions together, we are intending to create a simple yet refined form that has a greater emphasis on simplicity and detail between connections, as we feel as though it is pivotal to focus on the fabrication of our design. Our group is also intrigued to use external Grasshopper plug-ins such as Kangaroo and Ladybird to assist in the embedding of contextual data from the site, as we feels as though it will not only permit for a more complex application of forces in addition to attractor points, but also will refine our design to becoming more functional. Overall I am extremely interested to commence working within my group, as I believe that through the collaboration of our various scripts and selection criteria that we ill be able to produce a refined and beautifully detailed model that will improve the current conditions within Ceres.
64
DETAILED DESIGN
B.7 LEARNING OUTCOMES The learning objectives of Studio Air encourage for the comprehension behind the influence that computation can have on architectural design, simultaneously in methodology and formally. By focusing on a specific parametric language throughout Part B, I have been able to develop an understanding of algorithmic aided design as well as the vast range of architectural applications that can be based off parametric modelling and visual programming. In terms of conceptually meeting the brief, the theory behind interrelatedness of systems and their applications within an individual context has allowed me to embed my knowledge behind various components to strengthen the idea behind my design, which is extremely exciting and satisfying. Developing an understanding of computation has also assisted in a personal aspect of emergence as a designer, by allowing me to break down forms into a parametric values, almost reevaluating objects through an algorithmic mind set. Despite there being a significant amount of time before I may become more proficient in scripting, I feel as though this studio has given me the confidence to venture into other computation programs. My design proposal intends to interrogate the sense of discontinuity within Ceres compositional layout, whilst utilising various computation and patterning techniques to link and patch this void within the site identity. In order to do so, I am focusing on various functionalities and layers created by my parametric design, and how atmospheres produced by contrasting geometric patterns and articulation can enhance the users knowledge about the various pockets within the site. Such awareness would not have been achieved without computation methods, as several components such as attractor points are pivotal in dictating the scenes form as well as a key technique to employ the conceptual ideal. To conclude, I have demonstrated a decent grasp on the logistics behind data stature and flow, through my ability to understand and develop a detailed script which references both aesthetic components as well as structural mechanisms and user participation.
DETAILED DESIGN
65
B.8 ALGORITHMIC SKETCHES
66
DETAILED DESIGN
DETAILED DESIGN
67
BIBLIOGRAPHY - Alberti, Leon Battista, On The Art Of Building in Ten Books (Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press, 1988) - Carpo, Mario, “The Ebb And Flow Of Digital Innovation: From Form Making To Form Finding And Beyond”, Architectural Design, 83 (2013), 56-61 - Doerstelmann, Moritz, Jan Knippers, Achim Menges, Stefana Parascho, Marshall Prado, and Tobias Schwinn, “ICD/ITKE Research Pavilion 2013-14: Modular Coreless Filament Winding Based On Beetle Elytra”, Archit. Design, 85 (2015), 54-59 - Elias, Brad. Lecture week one; Composition/Generation, The University of Melbourne (2016) - Elias, Brad. Lecture week two; Composition/Generation, The University of Melbourne (2016) - Elias, Brad. Lecture week three; Composition/Generation, The University of Melbourne (2016) - Fornes, Mark, “The Art Of The Prototypical”, Archit. Design, 86 (2016), 60-67 - Fry, Tony (2008). Design Futuring: Sustainability, Ethics and New Practice (Oxford: Berg), pp. 1–16 - Garcia, Mark, Patterns of Architecture (London: John Wiley, 2009) - Kalay, Yehuda E. (2004). Architecture’s New Media: Principles, Theories, and Methods of Computer-Aided Design (Cambridge, MA: MIT Press), pp. 5-25 - Menges, Achim, and Steffen Reichert, “Material Capacity: EmbeddedResponsiveness”, Architectural Design, 82 (2012), 52-59 - Moussavi, Farshid and Michael Kubo, The Function Of Ornament (Barcelona: Acar, 2006) - Peters, Brady. (2013) ‘Computation Works: The Building of Algorithmic Thought’, Architectural Design, 83, 2, pp. 08-15 - Peters, Brady, “Realising The Architectural Idea: Computational Design At Herzog & De Meuron”, Architectural Design, 83 (2013), 56-61 - Schumacher, Patrik, “Advancing Social Functionality Via Agent-Based Parametric Semiology”, Archit. Design, 86 (2016), 108-113 - “West Coast Pavilion”, Atelier Manferdini, 2016 <http://www.ateliermanferdini.com/still-1/> [accessed 17 March 2016]
68
DETAILED DESIGN