OCTOBER 17, 2017
R
THE INDEPENDENT STUDENT NEWSPAPER OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO SINCE 1892
ESULTS OF POST–COLUMBIA GRAD
VOL. 129, ISSUE 7
Grad Students Head to Polls for Union Vote
UNIONIZATION ELECTIONS
THE NEW SCHOOL (~100% FOR)
Polls will be open from 9 a.m. to 9 p.m. on Tuesday and Wednesday, October 17–18
Jul. 13, 2017. 56% (504) counted. AMERICAN UNIVERSITY (84% FOR) Apr. 10, 2017. 34% (252) counted. BRANDEIS (72% FOR) May 2, 2016. 78% (122) counted. COLUMBIA (72% FOR) Jan. 27, 2016. 67% (2,225) counted. YALE (69% FOR, COMBINED*) Feb. 23, 2017. 88% (228) counted. LOYOLA CHICAGO (59% FOR) Dec. 9, 2016. 57% (210) counted. TUFTS (61% FOR) May 18, 2017. 79% (213) counted. BOSTON COLLEGE (55% FOR) Sep. 13, 2017. 66% (494) counted.
Feng Ye
Gathering outside Levi Hall on October 16, a rally crowd shouts yes to GSU.
CORNELL (48% FOR) Mar. 29, 2016. 80% (1,775) counted. HARVARD** (47% FOR)
This article is by TYRONE LOMAX, DEEPTI SAILAPPAN, and SPENCER DEMBNER.
Dec. 22, 2016. 86% (2,728) counted. DUKE (37% FOR) Feb. 24, 2017. 69% (1,089) counted. SAMPLE UNIVERSITY FOR UNION
AGAINST UNION
Date of tallying. Percent (num.) of eligible voters casting unchallenged ballots. Unionization effort successful. On appeal / result disputed. Unionization effort failed. Numbers from NLRB tallies except for Cornell, which conducted an election by agreement through the American Arbitration Association. In each of these elections, a substantial number of ballots cast were challenged by the employer or the prospective union. In some of these elections (Duke, Cornell, Harvard, and the East Asian Languages and Political Sciences department at Yale) the number of uncounted ballots under challenge could have swung the election. At schools marked in green, university administrations have agreed to begin contract negotiations with unions; At schools marked in yellow, the administration has filed an objection with the NLRB or otherwise signaled they intend to continue a legal challenge. In schools in red, the prospective union has withdrawn its initial bid. * Yale voted to unionize on a department by department basis across nine academic departments. Pro-union majorities of unchallenged ballots were secured in all but the physics department. ** The Massachusetts regional director of the NLRB invalidated the result of the election recorded here and ordered a new election after the result was challenged by the prospective union. Harvard has appealed the decision.
Starting this morning, about 2,500 graduate students can cast votes in an election to determine if they will be represented for collective bargaining by Graduate Students United (GSU). GSU members are fired up after rallying on the quad yesterday and receiving endorsements from a number of high-profile progressives in the last several days, including Senator Bernie Sanders (I-VT) (A.B. ’64). The administration continued to mount its opposition in the lead up to the vote, attempting to make the case to graduate students that unionizing would be against their best interests and contesting their right to unionize through its attorneys. Though GSU has had a significantly more organized and vocal presence in the weeks before the vote, an anti-union group called Stop and Think maintains a website with anti-unionization information. (Stop and Think could not be reached for comment Monday.) Unionization supporters say that graduate students would be able to negotiate better pay and working
conditions in a union, while the arguments against GSU generally focus on the burden of union dues. University e-mails in the days before the vote discouraged graduate students from voting to be represented by GSU, cautioning that a union would introduce a “third party” into the relationships between graduate students and the University. Administrators also stressed that the proposed bargaining unit includes students in the sciences, which administrators say would lack precedent at a peer institution—though GSU notes that some unions at public universities include students in the sciences. Organizations of graduate students at schools across the country have been pushing to unionize since the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) ruled last year in a Columbia University case that graduate
students can unionize and are workers under federal labor law. Just last week, Graduate Workers of Columbia filed a motion in the University of Chicago NLRB case requesting to file a motion to ask for the recusal of Marvin Kaplan, a Trump-appointed NLRB member whose wife is employed at Columbia.
The pro-union group at Columbia wants Kaplan to be recused from the University of Chicago case because the UChicago administration has a pending request for review that argues the Columbia decision should be overturned. The administration filed a motion yesterday opposing the Columbia students’ request to intervene in the UChicago NLRB case. Eleven universities have seen similar unionization votes since the NLRB opened the possibility last year, with mixed results: at four schools, the administration accepted a vote in favor of unionization and advanced to contract negotiations; at two schools, prospective unions withdrew their bids in face of indifferent results. The other cases are stalled by legal challenges, some of which question the legality of graduate students unionizing. With a new Republican majority on the NLRB, a reconsideration of that issue could be in the offing. Continued on page 2
Recent GSU Endorsements • Bernie Sanders (A.B. ‘64) • Chelsea Manning • Noam Chomsky • Alice Walker • Glenn Greenwald • IL Rep.Christian Mitchell (A.B. ‘08)
Kay Yang Polling locations are circled in red above: The Regenstein Library (last names A-E), Hinds (F-K), Kent (L-R), and Stuart (S-Z).
Sounding Off on Unionization Page 4 THE MAROON Editorial Board argues that the University shouldn’t challenge a pro-union outcome; meanwhile, a BSD grad student explains why she’s voting “no.”
Win Some, Lose Some Page 8 The women’s volleyball team emerged from last weekend’s UAA tournament with a 2–2 split.
“Nuclear Thresholds” Pushes Boundaries Page 6 A new installation complementing Henry Moore’s Nuclear Energy melds art with entropy.
ADVERTISE IN THE MAROON IN PRINT AND ONLINE REACH OUR READERS WITH DISPLAY ADS FROM $90 IN PRINT & $192 ONLINE FOR U OF C AFFILIATES. ADS@CHICAGOMAROON.COM FOR MORE INFORMATION