Urban Planning

camilo lopez

Powers of Observation:

Analysis of

2

Public Spaces uRP 6101 Planning Process and Skills

1site

2site

Himmarshee St Fort Lauderdale, Florida

The Fountains Plantation, Florida

“Primary� Uses for both sites: Commercial Nightclubs Restaurants Bars Retail Shopping

1site

Parking lot

Irish Pub Dicey Riley + Latin eBar

BAR + NIGHTCLUB

Parking lot

Pizzeria

PIZZA Public House

10

17

RESTAURANT + BAR

12

Irish Pub + Lucky’s Tavern

T-Mex + Rock Burger + Bull Market

BAR + NIGHTCLUB

RESTAURANT + BAR

12 33

Original Fat Cats

BAR

Capone’s

12

12

12

Tarpoon Bend Food + Tackle

RESTAURANT + BAR

NIGHTCLUB Himmarshee St Fort Lauderdale, Florida 10 use - Vacant Commercial 12 use - Mixed-Use store + office, or store and residential 17 use - Office bldg 33 use - Nightclubs, cocktail lounge, bars + social clubs

current use

1site 9

8

# 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13

7

10 11 12 13

6 54 3 2

Name Tarpoon Bend T-mex Rock Burger Bull Market Lucky’s Tavern Irish Pub Capone’s Fat Cats Irish Pub Latin ebar Tobacoo shop Pizzeria Public house

Himmarshee St Fort Lauderdale, Florida

1

Type Food + Drink Food + Drink Food + Drink Food + Drink Nightclub +Drink Nightclub +Drink Nightclub +Drink Nightclub +Drink Nightclub +Drink Nightclub +Drink Nightclub +Drink Food Food + Drink

Hours 11am-2am 11am-2am 11am-2am 11am-2am 6pm-3am 6pm-3am 9pm-4am 5pm-4am 5pm-4am 9pm-4am 9pm-4am 11am-4am 11am-4am

1site SW 2nd Ave

Nugent Ave Himmarshee St

Himmarshee St Fort Lauderdale, Florida

Path Edge Level of activity

1site MONDAY

Nov.3.2014

Observer

Morning 8am-9am

Afternoon 1pm-2pm

Evening 9pm-10pm

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

10 7 3 8 1

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

27 3 24 15 4

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

20 5 15 9 3

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

7 2 1 0

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

15 4 6 2

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

10 6 3 1

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

0 5 3 2

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

1 8 14 4

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

2 6 10 2

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

7 3 0 0 3 0

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

0 0 17 6 0

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

5 2 0 8 7 0

3

1site WEDNESDAY

Nov.5.2014

Observer

Morning 8am-9am

Afternoon 1pm-2pm

Evening 9pm-10pm

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

8 3 5 4 2

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

30 5 23 20 5

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

300 200 100 20 40

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

5 2 1 0

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

16 4 6 4

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

150 50 60 40

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

0 5 3 0

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

2 8 14 6

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

20 200 40 40

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

1 2 0 0 5 0

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

5 0 0 20 5 0

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

30 200 (critical mass) 0 60 20 0

1site FRIDAY

Nov.7.2014

Observer

Morning 8am-9am

Afternoon 1pm-2pm

Evening 9pm-10pm

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

6 4 2 6 0

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

40 6 34 14 13

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

130 30 100 10 60

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

6 0 0 0

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

21 6 9 4

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

50 30 40 10

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

0 2 4 0

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

2 12 10 16

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

10 50 50 20

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

4 1 0 0 1 0

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

6 0 0 27 7 0

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

30 3 0 100 20 0

T-Mobile

100 Montaditos

RETAIL

2site

Parking lot

RESTAURANT + BAR

Five Guys

16

BURGER

Cheese Course

RESTAURANT + BAR

Jewelry

YogurtLand

RETAIL

DESSERT Lime Fresh Mexican

Parking lot

16

RESTAURANT Parking lot

The Fountains Plantation, Florida 16 use - Community Shopping Center

current use

2site 6 7

8

9 10 11

4

The Fountains Plantation, Florida

3 2 1

5

# 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11

Name Lime Mexican YogurtLand Sprint Jewelry Dick’s Sporting Marshalls Cheese Course T-mobile 100 montaditos KIKO Japanese Five Guys

Type Food + Drink Dessert Retail Retail Retail Retail Food +Drink Retail Food +Drink Food Food

Hours 11am-10pm 12pm-10pm 10am-6pm 10am-6pm 10am-6pm 10am-6pm 11am-10pm 10am-6pm 11am-11pm 12pm6pm 12pm-6pm

2site

The Fountains Plantation, Florida

Path Edge Level of activity

2site MONDAY

Nov.10.2014

Observer

Morning 8am-9am

Afternoon 1pm-2pm

Evening 9pm-10pm

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

10 1 7 6 2

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

25 5 20 3 11

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

15 3 12 1 7

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

8 2 0 0

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

11 6 6 2

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

5 7 3 0

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

0 3 5 2

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

2 4 15 4

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

2 8 3 2

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

1 3 0 0 6 0

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

5 0 4 11 9 0

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

3 0 0 8 4 0

2site WEDNESDAY

Nov.12.2014

Observer

Morning 8am-9am

Afternoon 1pm-2pm

Evening 9pm-10pm

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

7 1 6 7 0

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

18 3 15 6 5

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

17 2 15 3 6

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

5 2 0 0

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

6 2 10 0

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

4 7 5 1

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

0 2 5 0

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

2 6 8 2

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

4 10 3 0

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

1 0 0 0 6 0

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

3 0 6 5 5 0

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

2 0 0 10 5 0

2site FRIDAY

Nov.14.2014

Observer

Morning 8am-9am

Afternoon 1pm-2pm

Evening 9pm-10pm

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

9 0 9 9 0

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

24 4 20 8 16

People # of people: Passer-by: Static: People alone: People accompanined:

21 2 19 3 9

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

5 2 1 1

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

10 4 6 4

Demographics White: Black: Hispanic: Other:

10 5 4 0

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

0 0 6 3

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

4 8 8 4

Age 0-18: 19-30: 31-50: 51+:

2 12 5 4

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

0 2 0 0 7 0

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

4 0 12 4 4 0

Activity Walking: Exercising: Shopping: Eating: Working: Playing:

2 0 0 12 7 0

MONDAY morning

2site

1site 9

8

8

7

7

6

6

5

5

4

4

People

3

People

3 2

2

1

1

0

0 Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

Passer-by:

People accompanined:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

White:

White:

Black:

Black:

Hispanic:

19-30:

19-30:

31-50:

31-50:

51+:

51+:

7

8

6

7 6

5

5

4 Activity

3

4

Activity

3

2

2

1

1

0 Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

0 Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

MONDAY afternoon

2site

1site 30

25

25

20

20

15

15

People

People 10

10

5

5 0

0 Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

White:

White:

Black:

Black:

Hispanic:

Hispanic:

Other:

Other:

0-18:

0-18:

19-30:

19-30:

31-50:

31-50:

51+:

51+:

12

18 16

10

14

8

12 10 Activity

8 6

6

Activity

4

4

2

2 0 Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

0 Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

MONDAY evening

2site

1site 16

14

14

12

12

10

10

8

8

6

People

6

People

4

4

2

2 0 Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

0

People accompanined:

Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

White:

White:

Black:

Black:

Hispanic:

Hispanic:

Other:

0-18:

0-18:

19-30:

19-30:

31-50:

31-50:

51+:

51+:

9

9

8

8

7

7

6

6

5

5 Activity

4

3

2

2

1

1

0

Activity

4

3

0 Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

WEDNESDAY morning

2site

1site 6

8 7

5

6

4

5

3

4

Series1 2

Series1

3 2

1

1

0

0

Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

White:

White:

Black:

Black:

Hispanic:

19-30:

19-30:

31-50:

31-50:

7

6

6

5

5 4

4 3

Activity

Activity

3

2

2

1

1 0

0 Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

WEDNESDAY afternoon

2site

1site

16

25

14 20

12 10

15

8 People

10

People

6 4

5

2 0

0 Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

White:

White:

Black:

Black:

Hispanic:

Hispanic:

Other:

0-18:

0-18:

19-30:

19-30:

31-50:

31-50:

51+:

51+:

25

7 6

20

5

15

4

Activity

10

Activity

3 2

5

1 0

0 Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

WEDNESDAY evening

2site

1site

16

250

14

200

12 10

150

8

People

100

People

6 4

50

2 0

0 Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

Passer-by:

People accompanined:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

White:

White:

Black:

Black:

Hispanic:

Hispanic:

Other:

Other:

0-18:

0-18:

19-30:

19-30:

31-50:

31-50:

51+:

250

12 10

200

8

150 Activity

100

6

Activity

4

50

2

0

0 Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

FRIDAY morning

2site

1site 7

10 9

6

8

5

7

4

6 5

3

People

People

4 3

2

2

1

1

0

0 Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

White: Black:

1

Hispanic: Other:

19-30:

31-50:

31-50:

51+:

4.5

8

4

7

3.5

6

3

5

2.5 Activity

2

4

Activity

3

1.5 1

2

0.5

1

0

0 Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

FRIDAY afternoon

2site

1site 40

25

35 20

30 25

15

20 People

15 10

People

10 5

5 0

0 Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

White:

White:

Black:

Black:

Hispanic:

Hispanic:

Other:

Other:

0-18:

0-18:

19-30:

19-30:

31-50:

31-50:

51+:

51+:

30

14

25

12 10

20

8 15

Activity

10

Activity

6 4

5

2

0

0 Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

FRIDAY evening

2site

1site 120

20 18

100

16 14

80

12

60

10 People

40

People

8 6 4

20

2

0

0 Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

Passer-by:

Static:

People alone:

People accompanined:

White:

White:

Black:

Black:

Hispanic:

Hispanic:

Other:

0-18:

0-18:

19-30:

19-30:

31-50:

31-50:

51+:

51+:

120

14

100

12 10

80

8 60

Activity

40

Activity

6 4

20

2 0

0 Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

Walking: Exercising: Shopping:

Eating:

Working:

Playing:

The Fountains Plantation, Florida

1site

2site 360’-0”

194’-0” 87’-0”

73’-0”

Himmarshee St Fort Lauderdale, Florida

2 stories

Jane Jacobs Review Characteristic Mixed-use Primary Uses Short blocks Concentration of People Aged Buildings

1 story

Himmarshee St x x x x

The Fountains x

Himmarshee St Fort Lauderdale, Florida

1site

NightTIME Success!

Daytime

-

nighttime

+

morning

evening

The Fountains Plantation, Florida

2site

DayTIME Success!

Daytime

+

nighttime

-

morning

evening

*Recommendation

1site proposed

MORE daytime uses

b

existing a

existing

existing

2 stories

a

Infill development ground floor retail + daycare + laundry second floor office space/studio third floor living units addition of living Units increase density + “eyes on the street”

b

*Recommendation b

2site pro

proposed

MORE nighttime uses

existing

Infill development ground floor bar+ grocery store + laundry second floor office space/studio third floor living units

a

existing

1 story

addition of living Units increase density + “eyes on the street”

a

b

Thank You camilo lopez

Fall 2014