DAILY LOBO new mexico
First round fiasco
monday
see page 11
November 22, 2010
The Independent Voice of UNM since 1895
INSTEELATION
Former student sues UNM
Disabled med student claims dean said, ‘get over it’ by Danielle Boudreau dbou@unm.edu
Former UNM medical student Chad Cunningham filed a civil suit against UNM’s Board of Regents and the National Board of Medical Examiners for alleged refusal of disability accommodation during his medical exams. Cunningham suffers from highblood pressure and scotopic sensitivity syndrome, a condition that is sometimes categorized as a type of dyslexia. “The students who suffer most are those who have disabilities that aren’t so obvious,” said Dennis Montoya, Cunningham’s attorney. The complaint has four counts, three of which are against UNM: deprivation of right of due process, violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and breach of contract. Montoya said that this case is not an unusual one. “There are very talented, capable Americans out there who are being prevented from succeeding,” he said. During Cunningham’s first year of medical school in 2006, he experienced intense headaches and had difficulty reading, according to his complaint. He was diagnosed soon after. After taking a medical leave of absence he returned to school in 2007. When it came time to take the Step 1 examination given to all medical students after their first two years, he requested disability accommodation during the exam and was denied based on insufficient documentation, the complaint said. “Mr. Cunningham made every effort imaginable,” Montoya said. The defendants and Cunningham disagree on the fundamentals of Cunningham’s conduct. Cunningham’s complaint stated that he had “fulfilled his duties under the written and implied agreements.” In its response to the complaint, UNM denied Cunningham’s claims that he made several requests for disability accommodation and that the Dean of Students told Cunningham to “get over it and take the test.” Montoya said he and his client could not understand why defendants UNM and NBME resisted his request. He said that accommodations could include more natural light in the testing room, more time to take the test and the opportunity for breaks. “The accommodations would be awfully simple and inexpensive,” Montoya said. In UNM’s answer to the amended complaint, it states that Cunningham “failed to exhaust his
Inside the
Daily Lobo volume 115
issue 64
Robert Maes / Daily Lobo Local artist John Davis lifts a piece of the frame for his installation outside the Greyhound bus station downtown called “A Stop on the Rio Grande” on Sunday. The federally funded public art piece is set to be completed by next month and will include 12-foot-tall steel sculptures. administrative remedies,” and that UNM’s actions were driven by state interest and business purposes. UNM filed a motion to dismiss the case Oct. 4. The University provided evidence from Gerard F. Dillon, vice president of the United States Medical Licensing Examination and an NBME employee. He outlined the process for students to apply for accommodation and explained the requirements. “In order to protect the integrity and meaning of the scores, the USMLE is administered under standard conditions,” Dillon wrote. The defense attached the 2009 Bulletin of Information for the USMLE, a document that includes information for students who wish to request testing accommodations. The motion included a second letter from Catherine Farmer, the manager of Disability Services and ADA Compliance Officer. She said Cunningham did not provide sufficient documentation for the NBME to make an informed decision. “Mr. Cunningham did not respond to NBME’s request for additional documentation, either to provide the requested documents or to confirm that no further documentation would be submitted,” Farmer wrote. She wrote that after the NBME’s request, Cunningham elected to take the exam without any accommodations on June 24, 2009, and he hasn’t reapplied for accommodation or for a retake of the test since. The two parties are still locked in pretrial, although Montoya expects to be through the pretrial cycle in around seven months.
Grads take on SUB catering by Sofia Sanchez sanchez@unm.edu
GPSA passed a resolution at Saturday’s meeting to form an adhoc committee to discuss how the SUB’s catering prices are restricting student groups from using its facilities. Graduate student Japji Hundal sponsored the resolution. He said the committee would work to create dialogue with the SUB board and the Retail and Marketing Committee about lowering catering prices and expanding food options. “This will bring revenue and also bring more recognition among
students for the SUB and be more visible among students,” Hundal said. GPSA Council Chair Megan McRobert said her organization can’t have its monthly meetings at the SUB because the prices are outrageous for groups on restricted budgets. “We have a budget of less then $100 per meeting, and so we are financially unable to meet in the SUB, and I will say that has been a hardship for us at GPSA,” she said. The SUB food policy states groups are not allowed to bring outside food or beverages for meetings. Groups have to contract the
SUB’s catering services. The council said groups want to use the SUB because it is wellknown, and it has the biggest meeting rooms. “It will bring more revenue to the SUB and also help students when they want to hold a meeting,” Hundal said. McRobert said the resolution wouldn’t just benefit GPSA but all student groups. “I think it is really important that we take a collaborative approach, and it’s about how we make the Student Union Building work for students,” she said.
DL
have a knack for design? The
Daily
Lobo
is
holding
its
first
ever
design
contest. We’re asking students to redesign the Daily Lobo’s flag, and the winning artist gets his/her design featured on our front page for a day. The deadline is Jan. 9. Visit our website and click on “Daily Lobo Design Contest” for more information.
Not large, in charge
An end to the violence?
See page 16
See page 7
TODAY
52 |29