THE DAILY ATHENAEUM
“Little good is accomplished without controversy, and no civic evil is ever defeated without publicity.”
da
Friday February 24, 2012
Volume 125, Issue 109
www.THEDAONLINE.com
Law Center examines medical research by bryan bumgardner staff writer
What if your genes, the stuff that makes up DNA, could be patented by pharmaceutical companies? What if the process could save your life? The West Virginia University Law Center will be hosting Professor Michael Risch to discuss the issues presented by patent law in innovative medical research. Risch will present his keynote address “Rethinking
Patent Quality” at noon today in the Marlyn E. Lugar Courtroom at the WVU College of Law. A debate panel of representatives from the School of Medicine, Villanova University School of Law, and Mylan Pharmaceuticals will discuss the topic of “Patentability of Human Genetic Material” following the address. The debate will be moderated by WVU associate professor of law Shine Tu.
Tu said the event is inspired by recent legal cases. In 2009, a lawsuit was filed against Myriad Genetics, a molecular diagnostic company that has discovered a way to isolate genes that reveal a person’s likelihood to contract breast cancer. The plaintiffs, represented by the American Civil Liberties Union, argued that Myriad’s patents on isolated genes are invalid, and several appeals later, the Supreme Court is currently considering whether to
accept or reject the case. Tu said it is not clear if a human gene that has been removed, isolated and then purified from the cell can be considered intellectual property or a natural product. “The broader question is whether genes in general should be considered patentable subject matter,” Tu said. Placing a patent on a raw material occurring in nature is currently prohibited. If the natural material is manipulated
by man, Tu said, it can be patented: a purified form of human adrenaline was patented in 1906. Defenders of patent laws argue the patents protect the company’s investment in developing the technology, which was difficult and expensive to create. Challengers of the patents also argue the human body is pure and cannot be patented. They may agree with patents on the methods used to find
by lacey palmer staff writer
wvu today
Left to right: WVU students Taylor Richmond, B. Jay Hatfield, Daniel Carlson and Jonathan Kimble are finalists in the competition to become the next Mountaineer Mascot.
Four students compete to become the next WVU mascot CITY EDITOR
THE MOUNTAINEER CHEER-OFF
WHAT: Finalists will participate in a cheer-off to get the crowd going & impress the selection committee. For Daniel Carlson, it’s his duty. For WHERE: Men’s home basketball game vs. Marquette. Jonathon Kimble, it “just comes natu- WHEN: Tonight at 9. rally.” For B. Jay Hatfield, it’s a chance to be a positive role model. And for Tay- and will replace Mountaineer Brock lor Richmond, it’s a dedication to the Burwell, who has held the position for University. the past two years. The four West Virginia University stuCarlson, a senior business adminisdents will don buckskins tonight at the tration and international management men’s basketball game against Mar- student from Winchester, Va., is a memquette to compete for the position of ber of the West Virginia Air National the next Mountaineer mascot. Guard and said being the Mountaineer Each finalist will compete in a cheer- means having the chance to serve the off to see who can get the crowd going people of the state in a special way. and impress the selection committee. “The state of West Virginia has done The winner will be announced during so much for me. When I swore with the the second half of the WVU men’s bas- Guard, I swore my life to the state, and ketball game against DePaul Tuesday being the Mountaineer will help me
continue that,” he said. “I went from being an uneducated driller to a senior with so many opportunities. I’m indebted to the state and the University, and I want to give back – especially to the youth of West Virginia. I want to tell middle school and high school students how great it is to set a goal and achieve it.” Carlson, who struggled in the past and dropped out of college, said the compassion and unity of the people of West Virginia helped him get to where he is today. “When the UBB tragedy happened, we gathered together and mourned for the miners during a candlelight vigil, and when we have a major accomplishment,
see mountaineer on PAGE 2
Storytelling inspires professor’s career in photography by lydia nuzum
associate city editor
For photographer Abby Robinson, the “storytelling of art” has both fascinated and inspired a level of intimacy throughout her career. “You have to ask yourself, ‘How do I make a whole out of all of these little parts?’ and you have to ask yourself ‘What is going on here?’ That’s what is consciously going on in my head as I shoot,” Robinson said. Robinson, a professor at the
School of Visual Arts in New York City, gave a presentation on her work as a photographer Thursday for students in the Perley Issac Reed School of Journalism at West Virginia University and discussed the ideas that influenced her work and career. “One of the things that all of her projects have in common is that there is a really interesting dialogue that both provokes and invites,” said Lois Raimondo, sssistant professor of Journalism at WVU. “She cre-
ates what I think of as ‘cultural texts,’ because when you look at them on one level, you can be intrigued by them, excited by them, but when you read her words there is a whole other set of doors that start opening.” Robinson, who has been a featured contributor in Newsweek, The New York Times, People Magazine and The Village Voice, said she stumbled into photography as a passion during her undergraduate and graduate college career. “Someone gave me a cam-
era between my junior and senior year of college, and I took pictures, but I was so disgusted that I couldn’t figure out how to get the camera to work that I threw the film out without ever developing it,” Robinson said. Her photo projects include “The Perdue Project,” a collection of photographs depicting various body parts of both strangers and friends, and “In Camera,” a series of panoramic color photos of
52° / 31°
SWEET SOUNDS
CHECK OUT OUR MOBILE SITE
INSIDE
The WVU Symphony Orchestra played at the CAC Thursday. A&E PAGE 8
Get the same stories, features and columns quicker and easier on your smartphone at www.thedaonline.com/mobile.
RAIN/SNOW
News: 1, 2, 3 Opinion: 4 A&E: 6, 7, 8 Sports: 9, 10, 12 Campus Calendar: 5 Puzzles: 5 Classifieds: 11
CONTACT US Newsroom 304-293-5092 or DAnewsroom@mail.wvu.edu Advertising 304-293-4141 or DA-Ads@mail.wvu.edu Fax 304-293-6857
see research on PAGE 2
Zimride offers students safe transportation
WHO WANTS TO BE A MOUNTAINEER?
BY MACKENZIE MAYS
the genes, Tu said, but they argue that patents on the genes themselves violate the law. “The analogy was, ‘identifying a mutated gene is like trying to spot a penny on the ground from the top of the Empire State Building,’” Tu said. Tu said if a company can’t get a patent to protect their investment, it simply won’t spend resources to make the potentially lifesaving technology.
see career on PAGE 2
INSIDE THIS EDITION The West Virginia baseball team is traveling south for a tournament in Myrtle Beach, S.C. SPORTS PAGE 9
One program is celebrating three years of helping students and faculty at West Virginia University find safe transportation while at the same time protecting the environment. Zimride, an online service that allows users to find and post rides through its University networks, currently serves more than 450 users, according to Hugh Kierig, Director of Transportation and Parking at WVU. “Zimride is our online carpool matching program where you can put in your destination and origin for your trip and how frequently you need it, and it matches you with other people who have got similar trips and similar times,” Kierig said. Zimride is a San Francisco-based company that services a variety of college campuses, and is integrated through social networking sites like Facebook to make it easier for people to connect. Kierig said students use the service to find rides home for holiday breaks or to and from campus if they
don’t live downtown. The Zimride program is perfect for the WVU community, because it’s dedicated to providing safe rides and allows users to contact fellow riders beforehand, Kierig said. “It’s strictly for people with WVU email addresses, so that’s another safeguard,” he said. “It’s not like the general public can go online and use the site.” Kierig said it’s also a quick and easy way for students to make money. The driver can have passengers pay Zimride, and Zimride pays the driver to avoid the exchange of money, or passengers riding together can decide amongst themselves how to arrange the payment. The site also works with the Zipcar program at WVU, which allows students to rent a car and use it around campus if they meet certain eligibility requirements. Students and faculty can visit http://zimride.wvu.edu to sign up through Facebook and start finding rides for the upcoming spring break. danewsroom@mail.wvu.edu
Multicultural film series honors black WWII pilots by bryan bumgardner staff writer
During World War II, a group of African American pilots overcame racial prejudice to become one of the best U.S. fighter squadrons in the entire war. On Thursday, the West Virginia University Gluck Theatre presented a documentary featuring the true story of the pilots known as the Tuskegee Airmen. The film, titled “The Tuskegee Airmen,” was presented by Marjorie Fuller, director of the WVU Center for Black Culture and Research, in celebration of Black History Month. “I’m really happy to see that the African-American heroes of World War II are finally being recognized for their sacrifices and achievements,” Fuller said. “The Tuskegee Airmen” is the popular name of the 332nd Fighter Group of the U.S. Army Air Corps. They were the first African-American military aviators to ever serve in the U.S. armed forces and faced racial discrimination both within and outside the Army, Fuller said.
The Tuskegee Airmen served with distinction, and 450 of the airmen earned more than 850 medals in Europe and North Africa. Ed Hargro, a retired pharmaceutical salesman whose father was a Tuskegee Airman, said he felt the film captured the true attitude of the pilots. “They didn’t think that they were part of history, you know? They just thought this was something they had to do as Americans,” he said. The film was hosted as part of the Multicultural Brown Bag Lunch Film Series, and each week a different culture is profiled by a short film and discussion. James R. Johnson from the Office of Multicultural Programs said students should take the opportunity to immerse themselves in culture through events like the Brown Bag Lunches. “Anyone can come for free. At the end, I can ask you about your culture, and you can ask me about mine. We could both learn something and become friends,” he said. Johnson said cultural
see tuskegee on PAGE 2
ON THE BUBBLE The WVU men’s basketball team will host No. 10 Marquette tonight in hopes of improving its NCAA tournament resume. SPORTS PAGE 9