THE INDEPENDENT STUDENT NEWSPAPER OF THE UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA | WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 12, 2014
HIGHONPIE
2014-2015 Men's
basketball Supplement
Last night, Alpha Delta Pi hosted Pie-a-President, where students paid $3 to pie leaders of the Penn community in the face. The proceeds from the charity event will benefit Ronald McDonald House Charities. 51 leaders of organizations across campus participated in the event.
>>CHECK INSIDE
SEE MORE PHOTOS ON PAGE 6
$1,250 raised TOP 5
373
Presidents
pies thrown
Capozzi 25 Louis GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS ASSOCIATION
Want tenure at Penn? Be innovative
Culliver 17 Taylor THE DAILY PENNSYLVANIAN
Manning 17 Bryan CROWS Goldman 17 Brian GOVERNMENT AND POLITICS
With Penn’s increasing commercialization, the U. is placing a higher emphasis on innovation
ASSOCIATION
Dwyer 14 Maggie WOMEN’S ROWING
KRISTEN GRABARZ Deputy News Editor
PHOTO BY TIFFANY PHAM, GRAPHIC BY ANALYN DELOS SANTOS
While the concept of innovation might evoke images of computers, startups and engineers, it increasingly impacts faculty in all disciplines at Penn. At the groundbreaking of the new Pennovation Center at the end of October, Penn President Amy Gutmann said innovation could come to play a role in faculty tenure decisions — a sentiment that Provost Vincent Price echoed. “Innovation and impact are centrally implicated in faculty hiring, promotion and tenure,” Price said in an email. “Primary responsibility for developing and maintaining a high-quality faculty rests with the individual disciplines. But, across the diverse forms of scholarly activity at Penn, the schools share clear expectations that our researchers will both push forward the frontiers of knowledge and maximize the impact of that work.” Some areas of academia — the hard sciences, health sciences, engineering and computer science — come to mind more readily when mentioning commercialization. For professors in the liberal arts, innovation is defined more loosely. “Our deans want to take into account all the ways in which faculty’s research is impactful in the world. Some of that research, like my own, is totally uncommercializable,” Gutmann — a political theorist — said. “But it’s the impact that research has and potentially has that is something that we take into account.” Classics professor Peter Struck said that in his field, innovation takes the form of reinterpretation of past ma-
Equality of Penn admissions called into question
INSIDE NEWS PERELMAN UPGRADES
The college app process is unfair to minorities, speakers said Tuesday night HUIZHONG WU Staff Writer
PAGE 2
FEELING SAFE
What makes Penn valuable is that it doesn’t admit anyone, Sean Vereen said. The school was proud to announce in spring 2014 that the admissions rate had dipped below
DPS tops national rankings for the eighth year in a row PAGE 6
10 percent for the first time, to a record low of 9.9 percent. It was a mark of the exclusive meritocracy at work. But a meritocracy is not fair, said Vereen, president of Steppingstone Scholars, an organization that helps minority students overcome inequalities in education to get to college. It’s not fair, he said at a United Minorities Council talk on Nov. 11, because it’s a system that rewards achievements that
those with privilege can accomplish and those without — such as those part of the black, Latino, Native American and other underrepresented minorities — will find much more difficult to do. Vereen and the other speaker at the UMC talk, English professor Herman Beavers, also said that Penn students can push more to address some of this inequality. SEE UMC PAGE 2
OPINION
Sean Vareen, President of Steppingstone Scholars, Inc., (pictured) and Professor Herman Beavers held a discussion yesterday about diversity at Penn. The event was organized by the United Minorities Council.
ADOPTING A NEW POINT OF VIEW
Rethinking our attitudes toward adoption challenges us to think differently PAGE 4
SPORTS SOPHOMORE SOCCER STUD Alec Neumann had a breakout season for the Quakers BACK PAGE
PRIMED FOR LEAP Sophomore Caleb Richardson is hungry for some major results BACK PAGE
CONNIE KANG/PHOTO MANAGER
SEE INNOVATION PAGE 5
Wharton places second in Businessweek MBA rankings Wharton moved up from its third-place ranking last cycle COREY STERN Staff Writer
Bloomberg Businessweek’s biennial MBA program ranking for 2014 was released Tuesday. And while Wharton triumphed over its usual competitors, it still took home second place. For the first time since Businessweek began publishing MBA rankings in 1988, Duke’s Fuqua School of Business was given the top spot. Harvard Business School fell to eighth place, leaving it out of the top five for the first time. That leaves Wharton as the only school to have been consistently ranked in the top five, including a first place ranking from 1994 to 2000. Wharton jumped from third to second — the school’s highest ranking since 2006. The University of Chicago’s Booth School of
3
TOP 10 FULL-TIME MBA PROGRAMS IN THE COUNTRY
7
NORTHWESTERN UNIVERSITY
9 4
UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO
CARNEGIE MELLON UNIVERSITY
8
UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN
2
STANFORD UNIVERSITY
10
UNIVERSITY OF PENNSYLVANIA
1
5
COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY
SEND STORY IDEAS TO NEWSTIP@THEDP.COM
6
YALE UNIVERSITY
DUKE UNIVERSITY EMILY CHENG/DESIGN ASSISTANT
SOURCE: BUSINESSWEEK
Business, which has held the number one spot since 2006, fell to number three. Businessweek’s methodology included student and employer surveys, which each comprised 45 percent of schools’ scores. The remaining 10 percent was calculated based on each
HARVARD UNIVERSITY
school’s intellectual capital, which was measured by counting the articles published by faculty in 20 top business journals over the past five years and dividing that by the number of full-time faculty members. Wharton took first place in the employer survey, which sig-
nificantly boosted the school’s score. Wharton’s performance varies across business school rankings. Some rankings consider postMBA salaries, while others survey deans and MBA directors. Wharton has had a strong showing in many MBA rankings
ONLINE AT THEDP.COM
this year, including a tie for first in U.S. News and World Report’s list and a fourth-place ranking from Forbes. Internationally, the Financial Times ranked Wharton in fourth place, while The Economist gave the school 11th place. Wharton Dean Geoffrey Garrett is satisfied with Whar-
ton’s showing in the many rankings this year. “It doesn’t matter which rankings you choose — and they all use very different methodologies — Wharton is always at or very near the top,” Garrett said via email. “We must be doing a lot of things right.”
CONTACT US: 215-422-4640