Market
Report
FCP1 ● XIAO LI ANG ● N0351471 ● MAY 2011
CONTENTS 1. Introduction 2. Methodology 3. Rational for Choosing the Brand 4. SWOT Analysis 5. PEST Analysis 6. Brand Model 7. Consumer Behaviour 8. Consumer Segmentation 9. Positioning Map 10. Flagship Store Environment 11. Communication Strategy 12. Appendix 13. Illustration 14. Reference 15. Bibliography
1
Introduction
This report aims to help Thorntons, which is a UK confectionary brand and mainly sells chocolate products, a successful move to the US market and launches of its flagship store there. The report will include a short rational for brand chosen, specify the city where the brand will move into, and provides a clear SWOT analysis of the Thorntons and one of its American competitors, PEST analysis will also be included in this report. Moreover, consumers behaviours in different market will be taken
into account and discussed in order for Thorntons to adopt to the U.S local market nicely, while its originally based in UK market. What is more, this report will focus on consumer segmentation, i d e a s f o r fl a g s h i p s t o r e environment and communication strategy for launch of the new store, and will also suggest a suitable and feasible collaboration with the brand to make more profit in the U.S market. In addition, brand model and positioning map will also available in the report.
2
Methodology Every year thousands of new products in the food and drinks industry are launched by manufacturers hoping to gain consumers interest with innovative developments (Verdict, 2009: online). In order to gain a comprehensive knowledge about the confectionary market, to give Thorntons a solid support for launch new business in the U.S market, various research methods will be used. For primary research, a questionnaire will be produced and passed on to Thorntons potential consumers via Internet, then efficiently collect
the responses to help the brand find out the demands and the direct reaction of the market, and provide a creative way that Thorntons may start collaboration in U.S market. Also, interview with Thorntons consumers and in-store investigate will be as a part of research, which could help understand exist market and strongly support translation. For secondary research, Mintel and Verdict reports will be used as a trustworthy data resources, to get exact data of global and local business and help the brand better developed in the future.
3
Rational for Choosing the Brand Thorntons is the number one ‘Chocolate and Confectionery’ brand and the number 18 overall brand in the UK according to Superbrands’ latest research (May 2009).Established by Joseph William Thornton in 1911, Thorntons is one of the UK’s oldest chocolate retailers (Thorntons, 2011: online), and well-known for its deeply British image and highly heritage. Despite the current crippling financial climate that the world faces the
US retail market is still valued at more than $150 billion (market research, 2009:online). While many American industries took a hit during the economic recession, one seemed to thrive. as retail sales increased 3% from 2008, the U.S. chocolate industry in 2009 reached a record $16.9 billion, according to Chocolate Market in the U.S.: Trends and Opportunities in Premium, Gourmet and Mass Chocolate Products by market research (2010: online). Packaged Facts forecasts the U.S.
chocolate market will exceed $19 billion in 2014. The American chocolate market is a mature, differentiated and exacting market. Therefore, Thorntons as a renowned British chocolate brand enter the US market at this time would probably boost the company’s profits rapidly, and promote the awareness of the brand, prepare for expanding market on a large scare in the future. What is more, Thorntons can use this opportunity to upgrade itself, aiming to become a global, luxury chocolate brand, not only develop in its home market. There is a tendency that the demand for premium chocolate will persist as a leading growth
trend, especially when the economy recovers (packaged facts, 2010: online). In consequence, Thorntons, at the first place, launch of new flagship store in New York City, specifically Manhattan may be the best choice. New York is a international metropolis and has a large population, Thorntons opens new store there will target more consumers basically, and being a heritage British brand, this will attract a number of American customers to discover the real British fl a v o u r . M o r e o v e r , t h e shopping environment in New York makes it a city which can afford high priced premium chocolate products to the greatest degree, as Thorntons will present there.
Thorntons Strengths Traditional British Image On-line store Strong product and brand portfolio Mature distributing system Gift-wrapping service Well-designed website will be positive for promoting the brand • Service to customise products • • • • • •
Weaknesses • The brand awareness within the U.S market • Inefficient use of resources • Declining operating margin
Opportunities Publicity New product development Collaboration Growing organic food market Attracting younger age group Growing opportunities in ecommercial • A growing number of needs in confectionary market • • • • • •
Threats • Existing American-loving brands • Small and more specialist chocolate producers • Large manufactures • Recession
SWOT The SWOT analysis is a key tool to help determine strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats of the company, which can provide a strategical analysis of company’s businesses and operations. This part will demonstrate the SWOT analysis of Thorntons and Hershey’s which is one of its major competitors in the U.S market.
4
Analysis
Hershey’s
Strengths • An American icon for its chocolate bar • A large consumer group within the U.S market • Experienced • Strong brand portfolio and image • Diversified Products • Powerful Partnership • Cooperative with students and professors
Weaknesses • • • •
Highly leveraged Concern for the natural environment Poor International performance Inefficient on organisational design
Opportunities • Positive market outlook • Product diversification • Growing market for premium chocolate products • Increasing health consciousness • Demographic • Joint Ventures
Threats • • • •
Potential competitor like Thorntons Existing competitive environment Price conscious consumers Price increase of milk and coco beans
Political • Government restrict inport policy Pest analysis is quite important for a brand to consider its environment before starting the business process. Its aims to observe various factors within political, economical, social and technological aspects which can deeply affect the development regards to the brand.
PEST
5
Economical • Disposable income among U.S consumers has decreased in relation to the crisis • Devaluation of U.S dollars
Social • Raising social concern about obesity • Preference of taste • Seasonal demand (in particular, Easter, Christmas) • Reduction of labour • Male customers, children and teenagers lowering the overall age profile of consumers • Environmental friendly • Organic food demand • Fair trade
Technological • Investigated programme to install EPOS (electronic point of sales) • Internet and interactive television sales operation. • Hi-tech material using for flagship store
The PEST analysis has revealed the factors that can affects Thorntons launch of its new business in America both positively and negatively. Social factors, apparently, are significant for the brand to move to the new market. America has a vary high obesity rates, thus it maybe necessary for Thorntons to consider altering their brand image as healthier products. The marketing of this new healthier, organic range is likely to show how Thorntons has taken into account consumer concerns with regards
to attempting to combat obesity as well as boost sales figures. Considering American preference which might be different with UK market is also important for brand to promote. Additionally, according t o M a r k e t Re s e a r ch (2009: online) the seasonal demands of chocolate products during Easter and Christmas is far more than the average level, thus to introduce new products or present a new ad campaign which relate to holiday theme could help the brand attract more consumers in the U.S market.
Analysis
6 Brand Model
Attributes
Promise
Innovative
Premium Quality
Gift choice
Hand made
Festival
Communication
Brand Essence British Heritage chocolate art
Personality
Source of Authority
Authentic
Brand history
Traditional
Market reputation
Friendly
Public image
7
Consumer Behaviour In order to successfully translate Thorntons from UK to the US market, considering the different consumer behaviour which may caused by cultural difference and efficiently addressed the problem is crucial to the brand. The chocolate industry in America has enjoyed a
steady increase in demand since the opening of the first chocolate factory in 1765. The average American now consumes 10 pounds of chocolate annually. However, recent report indicated that “epidemic obesity among Americans coupled with the increasing health awareness threaten the future viability of the
the industry.� (market matters inc.org, 2010: online). While, the health news is not always bad when it comes to chocolate. As the news reported by Market Matters that recent studies have found chocolate may help prevent both cancer and heart disease. Dark chocolate raises level of cancer-fighting anti-oxidants in the bloody, and a study in the journal of American Medical Association fi n d s t h a t e a t i n g d a r k chocolate decreases blood pressure (2010: online). Based on these findings and facts, Thorntons may pay special attention to promote its dark chocolate products, highlighting the healthy image behind chocolate, which may stimulate purchasing, meanwhile supplying low-fat, fat-free and low calorie chocolate in
addition to normal full-fat chocolate. A tendency followed by the mass U.S chocolate market. Another key factor within consumer behaviour lies in the different seasonal demand from the UK and the U.S market. America is a highly seasonal market in terms of demand of chocolate. Fig.1 displayed consumption is highest at Halloween, followed by Easter, Christmas and Valentines’ Day over the decade. And it’s important to note that the quality of chocolate is different on different holidays. Market Matters (2010: online) indicates chocolate purchased for Halloween is likely to be cheaper but mass market, notwithstanding Valentines chocolate market
is typically tend to focus on premium quality but low quantity. Compared with the UK market, according to the Mintel Seasonal and Boxed Chocolate report (2010: online), in 2010 retail sales of chocolate confectionery is ₤264 million account for 54.1% for the year, follow by the Christmas which sales ₤163 million. Nevertheless, at Halloween and others merely sales ₤5m that only 1.1% of the y e a r s e l l i n g ( s e e fi g . 2 ) . I n addition, there is a tendency that the sales of Easter chocolate confectionery will continue growing, which increased 6.1% between 2008-10 (Mintel, 2010: online). Consequently, for a prepared and efficient launch in the U.S market of Thorntons, American consumer behaviour should be adopted to adjust the marketing and promoting strategies used by the brand.
fig.1
fig.2
Traditionally, Thorntons customers are somewhat conservative and typically in a age group of over 50 years, they were aware of Throntons when they were young, not completely loyal to the brand but used to buy it, particularly if they were to receive a box of Thorntons chocolate they would quite happily enjoy it. At current they choose the product as a gift for others. A Thorntons’ Easter egg is the best at Easter for their
grandchildren. They don’t particularly like change, and they go to Thorntons looking for the same kind of chocolate gifts as they did thirty years ago. In the article Thorntons in the Future as posted on Chocablog, Dom said “As much as Thorntons might want to develop innovative and exotic new products, it has to be done at a pace that won’t alienate their most valuable customers.” (2009: online)
Consumer Segmentation
8
With the change of consumers lifestyle, while Throntons are still keeping a strong British heritage image, its now trying to attract a younger more m o d e r n a n d a f fl u e n t consumer ( Thorntons PLC preliminary result, 2008: online). According to the primary research, the questionnaire (see the Appendix) shows 72.5% aged 16-25 young people out of 39 aware the brand Thorntons, and 65.9% of them have purchased Thorntons products, which revealed that Thorntons is now to target more younger generation. When asked about the words they would like to link to the Thorntons Brand image, over half of respondents chose British,
however nearly the same proportion of answer revealed a playful, tasteful a n d d e licio u s im a ge o f Thorntons. This is a important part that Thorntons should develop, make the brand image more various, playful, creative in order to target more customers.
pen-portrait Keith is a 17-year-old guy and studies at a high school in west New York. He usually gets up around 7: 30 in the morning for his first class at 9. After a quick shower, while waiting for school bus takes him to school he sitting has breakfast prepared by his mom, which always have a cup of full-fat milk, couple of toast with butter and eggs, cereal some times. He likes sweets, especially chocolate. He often takes couple of bars of chocolate to school eats them and shares with his friends on the way to school while he chatting with his friend on the bus. This is the last year for his high school
and he will become a fresher at the college next year. He is a people-person, and always friendly to all his peers. He is really into photography, always take his Canon G12 with him and he got an professional DSLR as well. He is a fan of Apple products, he got a white ipod classic, but now he is using ipod touch to listen to music, and using his iphone to keep him up-todate with anything new posted on facebook and twitter. He is expecting his mom can buy him a latest iPad 2 as Christmas gift, but actually he is saving money for that.
Positioning
Map
9
Innovative
Mid-Low Market
Premium Market
Heritage
10
Flagship Store Environment To successful launch the new business in the U.S market, opening a flagship store is necessary and essential for the brand to promote itself and attract more new consumers at a very beginning point. A s f o r fl a g s h i p s t o r e environment, basically, it should convey the idea of British
Heritage, hence Thorntons will keep its traditional colour, which is orange. On the one hand, orange is representative colour of the brand that can gives American customers a feeling of heritage. Conversely, on the other hand, orange is not conservative as the stereotype of British image. It is a quite fun, playful and energetic colour that
can makes people excited about it, and attract younger generation customers. At the same time, as the flagship store, it will target wider customer group and more tends to focus on promoting its premium range products, tells potential customers Thorntons is a premium chocolate expert. Therefore, the logo at the exterior of the store should be vary eye-catching. It will have a whole dark black background and the label “THORNTONS” will be bright white, as well as showing the manifesto “the Art of the Chocolatier” of the brand. The logo should have a light inside and display a strong
contrast between the colour black and white. In addition, in order to keep a integrative deco of in-store environment, an orange line will cross the exterior logo, to interpret brand colour. To celebrate its 100 years birthday, Thorntons has created a series of illustrations, which includes three core sections in different colours, its quite fun, creative and highlighted 100 years of Thorntons history, its indicates Thorntons is a heritage brand but interesting enough, this can be widely used in in-store decoration and window display, definitely will attract more consumers.
The flagship store will be a 2story structure and the first floor will be a half-build open area which will able to see the ground floor. On the ground floor, there will be a chocolate fountain right at the centre which can be seen immediately when customers step into the store, and it will be free for customers to try it when they hold special event or give special offer. A independent section will be separate only for display the making of Thorntons’ chocolate, and consumer can look how the chocolate been made, and everyone are able to try freshly made chocolate. The show box will be on the wall and show all the range of Thorntons confectionary products in it with lighting detail around the edge of the box. There also will be a cafe
on the first floor, providing a variety of delicate cakes, sweets and ice cream. This area aims to give customers a direct feeling of Thorntons products, brand culture, high quality service which may have a impact on them result in loyal to the brand, and basically a place for resting.
11
Communication Strategy It is imperative to come up with a straight forward communication strategy to make sure a successful and productive launch of the brand in U.S market. Based on the questionnaire (see the Appendix) which conducted as primary research, 95% people think if Thorntons collaborate with a celebrity chef it will be positive for the brand firmly translate to the U.S market. Thorntons is a traditional British confectionary brand and now moving to America, in order to create a link between the collaboration and the brand
background, the chef is better to be an English and has to be well-know in America at the same time. Therefore, Gordon Ramsay would be the best candidate. He is one of four chefs in the UK maintain three Michelin Stars for his restaurant, there’s nothing the US respects more than a selfmade man, and few have taken control of their own destiny as emphatically as Gordon Ramsay. The Times described him “is a bona fide celebrity” in America (2008: online), because his reality show Hell’s Kitchen, and Chef Ramsay
which display on the FOX. Additionally, the result of the questionnaire (see the Appendix) also demonstrated that 65% respondents believe Gordon is more suitable for Thorntons, and his dynamic and creative character is potentially matching the growing U.S confectionary market. Thorntons will collaborate with Gordon Ramsay to promote a special product line, which the flavour will be special prepared by Gordon and delicately decorated. Also, the special edition will have a different packaging with Thorntons’ other products. The collaboration line will be exclusive for the U.S market, customers will have chance to taste this special chocolate in the flagship store. Moreover, on the day Thorntons launch of the new flagship store in New York, Gordon Ramsay will also be invited to attend. He will make three different desserts which using Thorntons chocolate as main ingredient at launching party. Thorntons will create a special page on Facebook and Twitter for launching of flagship store, by liking and following the page,
five customers will be randomly chose and be invited to the launching party, they will have a great opportunity to try the dessert that freshly made by Gordon Ramsay and a small package of Ramsay’s collaboration chocolate will be a gift as they attending the party. Finally, the new ad campaign of Thorntons for the U.S market will be released. As for special product line collaborate with Gordon, his image will be cast and appear in the new campaign. This campaign will then print on lifestyle magazines, post outside the flagship store and on the hundreds of billboard all over the New York City.
12. Appendix
13.Illustration 1.http://bpando.files.wordpress.com/2011/03/thorntons-07.jpg? w=600&h=381
2.http://investors.thorntons.co.uk/download/pdf/ interim_report_Final_2011.pdf
4.http://www.towercentre.com/offers/a-taste-journey-through-europewith-thorntons-new-continental-boxes/
http://cdn.benzinga.com/files/Hershey%27s%20Kisses %20Chocolate_0.jpg
6.http://www.towercentre.com/offers/a-taste-journey-through-europewith-thorntons-new-continental-boxes/
7.http://www.towercentre.com/offers/a-taste-journey-through-europewith-thorntons-new-continental-boxes/
http://investors.thorntons.co.uk/download/pdf/ar09.pdf
8.https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-k_UyHW0v8dU/TY3Y3NtG-iI/ AAAAAAAAAZs/deYRoqQBaoY/s1600/blog1_NED6040.jpg
http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/images/episode/p0094b04_640_360.jpg
10.http://www.archsystems.com/uploadedImages/Projects/Retail/ ASI_Flooring/Godiva229(1).jpg
http://www.chocolatefountainsrus.com/sitebuildercontent/ sitebuilderpictures/chocolate_fountain_3.jpg http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_l0to0aXpF71qbc1d5o2_500.jpg
http://www.wayfaring.info/wp-content/uploads/ 2009/01/6a00d83451e44269e200e5538beaaa8834-800wi.jpg http://www.johannabasford.com/blog-article/253
11.http://www.marieclaire.co.uk/imageBank/cache/g/GordonRamsay-LP.jpg_e_b531446b815d841fa57ff7ac29559923.jpg http://media-cdn.tripadvisor.com/media/photo-s/01/28/0d/f4/thepyramid-chocolate.jpg https://lh4.googleusercontent.com/-S4wBbZ2dByQ/TXrwtbXUHQI/ AAAAAAAAAhA/8lQ5-UYVYMo/flourless-choc-cake.jpg http://www.purplecircle.co.uk/our-work/thorntons-centenarybranding.html http://www.purplecircle.co.uk/our-work/thorntons-centenarybranding.html
14.Reference Verdict, 2009: online Super brand, May 2009 market research, 2009:online market research, 2010:online packaged facts, 2010: online market research, 2009:online market matters, 2010: online market matters, 2010: online market matters, 2010: online Mintel, 2010: online Mintel, 2010: online Chocolate blog, 2009: online Thorntons PLC preliminary result, 2008: online
15. Bibliography Reports: Lewis, H. (2009), ‘Growth Opportunities in Confectionary’, Verdic. Chocolate Confectionary -UK (2011), Mintel online, http:// academic.mintel.com/sinatra/oxygen_academic//display/ &id=545241 , accessed 20/5/2011 Chocolate Confectionary in the US (2010), GMID online, https:// ntuanywhere.ntu.ac.uk/Portal/Pages/ Search/,DanaInfo=.awxyCttx0iuJp6421440A8AVzA. +SearchResultsList.aspx, accessed 20/5/2011 Chocolate Market in the U.S.: Trends and Opportunities in Premium, Gourmet and Mass Chocolate Products (2010), Packaged facts online, http://www.packagedfacts.com/Chocolate-2505082/, accessed 20/5/2011 Seasonal and Boxed Chocolates-UK (2010), Mintel online, http:// academic.mintel.com/sinatra/oxygen_academic/search_results/ show&/display/id=479796/display/id=540667, accessed 20/5/2011 Thorntons PLC interim report (2011), online, http:// investors.thorntons.co.uk/download/pdf/ interim_report_Final_2011.pdf, accessed 20/5/2011 Thorntons PLC annual report and accounts (2009), online, http:// investors.thorntons.co.uk/download/pdf/ar09.pdf, accessed 20/5/2011
Thorntons PLC - finical and strategical SWOT analysis review (2011), Market Research online, http://www.marketresearch.com/ product/print/default.asp?productid=6263267, accessed 20/5/2011 Websites: Ayres, C. (2008), ‘Gordon’s American Dream’, the Times, http:// www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/life_and_style/food_and_drink/ gordon_ramsay/article4654260.ece, accessed 20/5/2011 Noormohammad, M. (2011), ‘New US Chocolate Maker Trying to Break Into World Market’, VOA news, http://www.voanews.com/ english/news/usa/New-US-Chocolate-Maker-Trying-to-Break-IntoWorld-Market-112894294.html, accessed 20/5/2011 ‘Gordon Ramsay Biography’, Gordon Ramsay (2011), http:// www.gordonramsay.com/corporate/theman/biography/, accessed 20/5/2011 ‘The Future of Thorntons’, choca blog (2009), http:// www.chocablog.com/features/the-future-of-thorntons/, accessed 20/5/2011 ‘Thorntons Value’, Thorntons (2011), http:// www.thorntonsjobs.co.uk/Page.aspx/2/Thorntons_Values, accessed 20/5/2011