4HE¬#HRONICLE T H E I N D E P E N D E N T D A I LY AT D U K E U N I V E R S I T Y
MONDAY, APRIL 4, 2011
ONE HUNDRED AND SIXTH YEAR, ISSUE 126
WWW.DUKECHRONICLE.COM
Judge lets lacrosse suits proceed Brodhead, Nifong, Dzau among Duke and Durham officials named in claims by Zachary Tracer THE CHRONICLE
Richard Brodhead John Burness
Robert Steel
Tallman Trask
Victor Dzau
Sue Wasiolek
A federal judge will allow three lawsuits filed by most of the members of the 2006 men’s lacrosse team to move forward against Duke and Durham. The judge rejected many of the claims made in the two suits against Duke and specific employees, but claims still stand against President Richard Brodhead, Dean of Students Sue Wasiolek, Robert Steel, Trinity ’73 and former chair of the Board of Trustees, and Dr. Victor Dzau, chancellor for health affairs and president and CEO of the Duke University Health System. A substantial number of the claims in all three suits against Durham and its employees were allowed to proceed. The judge’s decision to allow specific claims to proceed does not mean that those claims are true. Lawyers for the players involved in the suits will now be allowed to collect evidence and conduct interviews as they attempt to prove allegations including fabrication of evidence, wrongful searches, fraud and negligence. Two of the three suits were brought against Duke and the City of Durham as well as individuals for their roles in the 2006 lacrosse case, in which exotic dancer
Crystal Mangum falsely accused three Duke men’s lacrosse players of rape. Mangum is not named as a defendant in the cases. The individuals bringing these suits were never charged with any crimes. “We are heartened by the judge’s carefully considered decision permitting the lacrosse players’ primary claims to move forward,” attorney Charles Cooper, who represents 38 of the unindicted players, said in a statement. “We will immediately begin taking extensive discovery and preparing the case for trial.” Robert Ekstrand, an attorney for three other unindicted players, did not respond to requests for comment. The third suit, brought by the three players who were wrongly charged with rape and other crimes, is directed at the City of Durham and related individuals. The players—David Evans, Collin Finnerty and Reade Seligmann—were ultimately declared innocent and Mike Nifong, the district attorney who bungled the case, was disbarred and jailed for a day. The three have already settled with the University, so Duke is not a defendant in their suit. Robert Cary, an attorney for the three SEE LACROSSE ON PAGE 5
DUKE STUDENT GOVERNMENT PRESIDENT
Mizrahi emphasizes student perspective by Maggie Spini THE CHRONICLE
MELISSA YEO/THE CHRONICLE
Junior Isaac Mizrahi served as a DSG student affairs senator in 2007 and president pro-tempore in 2008.
Junior Isaac Mizrahi’s high school principal told him he would know a meeting went well if everyone in attendance left equally unhappy. This is an adage Mizrahi hopes to follow as Duke Student Government president. If elected, Mizrahi said he will keep this advice in mind while promoting open conversation and remaining attuned to the concerns of the student body. He plans to do this by including members of different student groups in his cabinet and establishing “out-of-office hours” for DSG senators, which would require senators to visit various student forums, meetings and events to gain perspective—something Mizrahi said he possesses. “I speak from the heart of the students,” he said. “I associate myself with a diverse collection of social groups and
cultural groups and get to really understand what Duke students feel with their experience.” Mizrahi served on DSG as a student affairs senator in 2007 and as president protempore of the Senate in 2008. In Spring 2009, Mizrahi, a then-sophomore, left the University voluntarily to return home to Miami, Fla. for personal reasons. Mizrahi returned in Fall 2009. In March, Mizrahi was confirmed as a senator on the newly formed Residence Life and Dining committee. Despite his DSG experience, Mizrahi said he sees himself as immune to the organization’s internal politics. “I’m a very vocal, impassioned outsider,” he said. “That kind of culture shock into student government will shake things up.” SEE MIZRAHI ON PAGE 8
ONTHERECORD
“He liked to experience the natural world, to be in it and record it.”
—Wendy Moses on the late Timothy Oliver. See obituary page 3
See what you missed this weekend, Page 4
Mike Nifong
Steve Chalmers
Benjamin Himan
Ronald Hodge
Patrick Baker
Linwood Wilson
International ambassadors promote Duke by Joanna Lichter THE CHRONICLE
Every year, students from across the globe leave their homes to study at Duke and immerse themselves in an American lifestyle. But for many international students, committing to Duke was not an easy decision. Unfamiliar with the various distinctions among U.S. universities, many students rely on national rankings and word-of-mouth when applying to American colleges. “When I was admitted to Duke, there were not too many ways to know about SEE AMBASSADORS ON PAGE 6
Orphans require additional mental health services, Page 3