Volume 9, No 2 | March 2011
CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
EDITOR’S LETTER
US Employee Benefits Industry Players Head to Chicago
I
am very excited at this year’s upcoming Employer Healthcare Congress, October 26-28th, 2011 in Chicago. This will be our 3rd year, and each year we have focused on making improvements. Last year, only in our second year, we became one of the largest employee benefits conferences in the country beating out almost all other benefits conferences, some of which have been around for over 23 years. We have moved to Chicago this year because of it’s central location which will draw a much larger audience. Our attendance this year is already almost at 200% higher than at this same time last year, and I believe this is because of our location and that Chicago is home to a high concentration of mid-size and large employers. This year we have reinvested in the congress significantly to make this the biggest and best year yet. We have two great keynote speakers, Bill Rancic, the winner of Donald Trump’s 1st “Apprentice” TV Show, and Cecil Wilson, the President of the American Medical Association. We have changed the format of the congress to have more cross-overs as to bring our symbiotic conferences closer together, and we will have more advanced educational sessions and workshops. We have also expanded our VIP program and will be including not just employers but agents and consultants also this year. What I am most excited about is our new networking software which has been newly built and is more of a social networking tool on top of meeting scheduler. It will make it easier for attendees to view who is coming to the conference, through photos, bios and allow for attendees to synch to twitter, LinkedIn and Facebook to see who in their network is attending the conference. Tomorrow I am headed to New York City for an interview with FoxNews. See you soon.
Jonathan Edelheit
EDITORIAL STAFF EDITOR Jonathan Edelheit jon@employerhealth� carecongress.com
ASSISTANT EDITOR Sarah Hunt ADVERTISING SALES info@CorporateWell� nessMagazine.com
GRAPGHIC DESIGNER Tercy U. Toussaint For any questions regarding advertising, permissions/ reprints, or other general inquiries, please contact:
Sarah Hunt ASSISTANT EDITOR
561.204.3676 PHONE
866.536.7041 FAX
Sarah@CorporateWell� nessmagazine.com E-MAIL Copyright © 2011Corporate Wellness Magazine. All rights reserved. Corporate Wellness Magazine is published monthly by Global Health Insurance Publications. Material in this publication may not be reproduced in any way without express permission from Corporate Wellness Magazine. Requests for permission may be directed to info@ CorporateWellnessMagazine. com. Corporate Wellness Magazine is in no way responsible for the content of our advertisers or authors.
FEATURES
CONTENTS Issue 22 • May 2011
13 21
ASSERTIVENESS REDUCES STRESS PUTTING YOU IN THE DRIVER’S SEAT OF YOUR OWN LIFE by Jacquelyn Ferguson
THE COST OF COLLEGE
4
EMPLOYEES ARE WHAT THEY EAT ~ THE IMPORTANCE OF INTEGRATING NUTRITION IN CORPORATE WELLNESS
8
GENDER STRESS RESPONSE... IT’S ALL IN YOUR HEAD
by Amanda Carlson-Phillips
by Jason Krausert and Donna Tosky
18
ARE YOU LEADINGLIKE A DICTATOR? SIX SIGNS YOUR MANAGEMENT STYLE IS TOXIC
by Keith Ayers
26
5 STEPS TO GOOD DECISION MAKING
30
BOOST YOUR EMPLOYEES’ ENERGY AND FOCUS IN 2011
by Kescia D. Gray
by Tom Jordan and Courtney Day
by Kay Kimball Gruder
35
MEANINGFUL THOUGHTS BEYOND “MEANINGFUL USE” by Kevin Shrake
44
CONNECTING EMPLOYEE HEALTH TO VOLUNTARY DISCOUNT DENTAL PLANS by Nicole Ropiza
47
PHARMACEUTICAL IMPORTATION ~ LOGICAL, LEGAL, SAFE by J.J Summerell
52
39
UNIONS CHEAT MEMBERS OUT OF HEALTH AND WEALTH by Lisa Holland
REDUCING NARCOTICS ABUSE IN WORKERS’ COMPENSATION by Tron Emptage
FOLLOW US ON:
Employees Are What They Eat The Importance of Integrating Nutrition in Corporate Wellness
by Amanda Carlson-Phillips
F
WORKSITE WELLNESS
or many years, corporate wellness programs focused almost entirely on movement programming, ranging from on-site fitness centers to group classes to online modules around general fitness. All of these options deliver significant value to the employee, but for too many years, optimal nutrition integration has been a missing part of the puzzle. Here we have outlined five reasons why employees are what they eat, and why on-site nutrition programming should be top of mind for employers in evaluating wellness solutions. Rising Medical Costs: Simply put, employers can’t afford to ignore the impact of heart disease and diabetes on their healthcare premiums—the American Heart Association estimates heart disease costs alone will triple by 2030. Lowering the risk factors for diabetes and heart disease alike requires more than just fitness programming: employers must provide integrated, dynamic and engaging nutrition education content and support so that employees think differently about how they eat each day. To quantify potential impact, we recently did a program with Intel that included both on-site fitness and personalized nutrition. Over just fourteen weeks, the average percentage decrease in cholesterol was 5.03%, average fat loss was 14 pounds, and V02 scores increased by an average of 19%. There was a 30% change in participants characterized as “at risk” based on their lipid profile—a staggering number when you consider the potential impact on claims data.
5 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
Meeting People Where They Are: For many employees, the notion of working out is simply too big of a jump given their current health state. Nutrition is a great way to reach non-movers with simple, actionable programming they can incorporate slowly into their lives. For many years, nutrition has become synonymous with weight loss. While trying to lose weight, people often lose sight of why we really eat. Bringing in dynamic and supportive nutrition programming can help guide people to choose foods that nourish the body, provide sustainable energy, and improve the way they feel as opposed to short-term fixes to lose five pounds. Every employee has to eat, so finding a way to meet them where they are and make small upgrades to their daily rituals can lead to the sustainable change employees and employers are looking for. Nutrition is a Family Affair: Employers have offered a wide range of on-site solutions for corporate wellness, but continue to
many people sabotage even their best efforts at fitness with poor nutrition. At C&S Wholesale Grocers, based in Keene, NH, we watched as many of their employees worked eight hour shifts with significant physical exertion without consuming a single ounce of water throughout the day. As little as 2% weight loss due to sweating can lead to up to a 25% decrease in productivity, so even educating employees about small changes in hydration can lead to significant improve in how an employee feels throughout the day at work. To address this issue, we provided simple education tools at warehouse sites, along with urine charts for their bathrooms so that employees could monitor their own hydration levels. These simple reminders and changes can lead to noteworthy results for employees and employers alike.
struggle with ways to engage the employees’ families in a meaningful way. The result? Often poor nutrition habits are fostered at home, leading to higher claims for the entire family. Finding ways to meaningfully engage with employees around nutrition can have a positive impact at home. By way of example, one of our wellness clients at Intel said he always knew he should eat breakfast, but didn’t know how to create a quick, convenient, and healthy option. After figuring out what worked best for him, he purchased healthy breakfast options, including whole-grain, high-protein cereal, for his entire family, the start of what we call “an upward spiral” in their home toward healthier habits. The Results Speak for Themselves: Simply put,
6 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
Now that we’ve addressed the importance of nutrition in wellness programming, I’ve outlined a few key considerations for employers when considering nutrition programs at their corporation: • Integrate Nutrition into Fitness Programming: Nutrition programming often lives in the medical and clinical side of corporate wellness programs. This creates an association of nutrition with disease management or a reactive solution that needs to be addressed when something is wrong. A new avenue for the delivery of nutrition content and programming should be in parallel with the fitness programs. Fitness programs focus on having more energy, stamina, and strength. Linking nutrition to these goals allows for employees to see nutrition as fuel for their performance and a way to expedite the process of reaching their goals.
WORKSITE WELLNESS one another and have fun while learning more are all great options to keep employees excited rather than tired by nutrition programming.
• Re-frame the Approach: Everyone can benefit from a nutrition tune-up. The foods we choose to eat are linked to the energy we have to be productive in our careers, present with our families, and enjoy the activities that make us who we are. Learning to choose the right foods, in the right amounts, at the right time is the key to feeling and performing the best you can in whatever you choose to do. Nutrition programming should focus on food as the fuel for our lives and provide the education and simple strategies to take advantage and get the most out of every time we eat. • Keep it Simple: Employees need simple strategies that they can incorporate in their daily lives, so focus on key priorities like hydration, increasing fruit and vegetable intake, or upgrading healthy snack options on your campus, and create simple ways for your employees to learn more and take part. • Make it Fun: Nobody wants to be lectured on what they are doing wrong, so making nutrition programming fun and relatable is imperative to its success with your teams. Creating nutrition challenges, remake a recipe contests, or lunch and learns where employees can have interact with
7 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
• Build Community: Invite employees and their families to participate in a healthier barbeque or picnic lunch on campus and work with a local grocery store to provide a coupon for employees to try out healthier breakfast fare for a week. Engaging a broader audience in the conversation with lead to broader engagements and results for everyone involved. Whether your employees are unloading pallets every day, manning a service center, or traveling non-stop, nutrition has the ability to transform their lives, increasing energy levels, improving performance, and advancing their health state. To date, most employee nutrition programs have been stand-alone online modules or education seminars without the personalization, ongoing support, and integration necessary to make them a sustainable success. To create impactful nutrition programming, it’s imperative that companies consider integrating nutrition education and support with fitness, maximizing each individual’s ability to make sustainable changes to their overall health.
Bio Amanda Carlson-Phillips is the Vice President of Nutrition and Research at Core Performance. Core Performance combines innovation, coaching, and technology to deliver unmatched, sustainable results for employees and companies alike. Amanda has designed leading-edge nutrition protocols for wellness programming at Intel and C&S. To learn more about Core Performance, please visit www.coreperformance.com/corporate-wellness.
Gender Stress Response... It’s All In Your Head by Jason Krausert and Donna Tosky
S
tress is a part of life and work. It doesn’t matter if you are a man or a woman. Similar things create stress for both men and women. Job demands, career moves, not getting along with colleagues and supervisors, having children, not to mention relationship or marital problems at home are all leading causes of stress for both genders. That’s where the similarities end however. Recent studies prove men and women respond to stress very differently. As we’ll explain below, those differences can directly impact job performance.
8 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
Therefore, it is important for managers as well as those responsible for implementing corporate wellness and employee assistance programs to be aware of these gender differences and to respond accordingly.
The Stress Response - It’s All in Your Head In 2007, researchers at the University of Pennsylvania’s School of Medicine conducted functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging scans on 32 healthy subjects – 16 men and 16 women – before, during and after they were asked to do a
WORKSITE WELLNESS complex mathematical task under pressure. The researchers measured the subjects’ heart rate, cortisol levels (a stress hormone), their perceived stress levels throughout the experiments, as well as regional cerebral blood flow (CBF), which is an indication of regional brain function.
According to Chaplin, “We know that women and men respond to stress differently. For example, following a stressful experience, women are more likely than men to say that they feel sad or anxious, which may lead to risk for depression and anxiety disorders. Some studies have found that men are more likely to drink alcohol following stress than The study found that men responded to stress women. If this becomes a pattern, it could lead to with increased CBF in the right prefrontal cortex, alcohol-use disorders.” an area of the brain associated with the so-called “fight or flight” response. In women, the limbic What This Means to Business system - a part of the brain primarily involved in emotion - was activated when they were under stress. Researchers noted that the stress response lasted longer in women than in men. According to a summary of the research on the Science Daily website, “These findings suggest that stress responses may be fundamentally different in each gender, sometimes characterized as ‘fight-or-flight’ in men and ‘tend-and-befriend’ in women.” According to Dr. J.J. Wang, the lead author of the study, “Women have twice the rate of depression and anxiety disorders compared to The University of Pennsylvania findings are men…Knowing that women respond to stress by simply interesting facts until you understand that: increasing activity in brain regions involved with emotion, and that these changes last longer than • the different stress response exhibited in men, may help us begin to explain the gender by each gender is just one tiny thread of an differences in the incidence of mood disorders.” intricate web of differences between men and women, the strands of which fit perfectly In an independent study, Tara M. Chaplin, together to create the personal and professional Associate Research Scientist at Yale University interactions that define life; School of Medicine, found that differences in how men and women respond to stress are not • this web of interacting gender differences limited to neurological evidence. Their reactions directly impacts people’s well-being and how have far-reaching implications for their overall they function individually and in groups both well-being. at home and in the workplace every single day.
9 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
In short, gender does make a difference in life and in business. For example, what are the real-world implications of each gender’s different stress response for businesses and for the managers who lead them?
Men Think Strategically
In our “Between Men and Women” Couples Wellness Weekend we explain that the overriding factor for men when making decisions and assessing circumstances is, “How likely am I to win or lose if I take this action?” This explains a man’s fight-or-flight response to stress. When given a task men size up a stressful situation maybe it’s an intransigent client, a tight deadline, a declining sales trend or personal problems with a spouse. Then they mentally, if not subconsciously, start doubting whether they can handle the task. A man’s doubt is like gas to a car. It fuels his mental engine’s process of assessing whether or not there is a chance of a winning outcome. Basically, he is asking himself, “Can I do this?” If the answer is “Yes” they fight. They go for it. If the answer is “No” they flight. They pull back, procrastinate or avoid the project. A man’s response to his doubt is almost always 10 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
influenced by personal confidence and knowledge. A senior executive has more experience and a better real-world understanding of his capabilities. As such, he will either use his deeper repertoire of strategies for winning and choose to fight, or he will strategically withdraw. A junior manager with fewer arrows in his quiver may be more inclined to hide, delay acting or withdraw in the face of impending failure. Alternatively, his enthusiasm may cause him to over-estimate his ability so he rushes head-long into a losing situation. That’s how he learns. There may be exceptions to how each man finally responds to his assessment of a situation, but the process is always the same stress is asserted when he receives an assignment, he starts doubting (i.e., assessing) his ability to produce a winning outcome, and depending on his answer he either goes for it or holds back.
Women Think Communally
Women, on the other hand, are naturally more communal than men. They are relationship masters. From an evolutionary standpoint, they value the safety of the “tribe” so-to-speak. They value community. As such, when stressful situations strike, they are less likely to go-it-alone than men. Women respond by tending-andbefriending. They build community around them.
that’s within your control: “To tell him I find his gum cracking distracting and request that he they force you to think before you speak. They stop;” may be clumsy at first but once you become proficient they become effortless to use. they are Is this within your control? Yes: It’s within problem-solving and goal-oriented in nature. your control to tell him it bothers you and to If it takes you two minutes to create an assertive request he stop. message using these formulas then you need to think that long before you speak. Just because you ask him to stop, though, doesn’t Use the “I” Message mean he will. You won’t always get your way because you act assertively. You’ll definitely You’ve learned before that “you” messages increase your batting average, however. encourage others’ defensiveness, which discourages cooperation. Avoiding the blaming In the political discussion example, determine “you” message is vital, so let’s take a look at if it’s worth it to you to counter with your own this lesson again. opinions by identifying your goal. Let your goal guide you. No matter how mature and sophisticated a person is, you can see them flinch when someone hurls If your objective is to present an opposing belief, a “you” message at them. then jump in. To do this assertively you must “You are so unfair. You never take my ideas into consideration.” Virtually everyone gets defensive when on the receiving end of “you” messages. Instead, use the simple, yet powerful “I” message: “I think this is unfair. I feel like my ideas aren’t taken into consideration.” The more difficult your message the more diligently you need to eliminate “you” messages and substitute with “I” messages. With criticisms: “I’d prefer you be less personal about my faults.”Too many demands: “I’m feeling overwhelmed. I need you to prioritize my tasks for me. respect the others’ rights to believe as they do. Simple Assertion ~ The Easiest Skill Listening well communicates this respect. If your intent is to convince the other person how This skill is a direct statement of what you want, wrong he is and how right you are, good luck. which right you want to defend, or which belief or opinion you want to communicate using the Assertive Skills “I” message: E.g., “Tom, I need you to get these copies made Assertive techniques, which are mostly for the meeting at 2:00. Thanks.” formulas, are great because: 11 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
They talk with family, friends, and co-workers; they seek advice; they build the social support structures and alliances that safety and security depend on. Again there are always exceptions, but this basic natural reaction is universal. The above is not to say that women won’t go for it on their own. Women, especially in business, can and do react this way. That is because of the dual nature of their logic. This sort of reaction, however, is less common and less comfortable for the majority of women. Being forced out front in a stressful situation can actually augment the stress inherent in that situation. For men, on the other hand, the stress of “leading the charge” is motivational and is far less than the stress of doing nothing or feeling restrained.
What is there for business to do? According to the lead University of Pennsylvania researcher, Dr. J.J. Wang, “In the future, when physicians treat patients - especially for depression and post-traumatic stress disorder - they need to take it into account that really, gender matters.” There is an opportunity here for wellness program coordinators. If the medical community is recognizing the need to incorporate an understanding of gender differences in their treatment practices, it’s time for the business community to do the same in their wellness programs and their management training efforts. Understanding that gender matters in business, not only in terms of how someone performs and communicates, but also in terms of how
12 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
people are managed, is a key step in creating a 21st century workplace characterized by wellbeing, reduced stress, deeper engagement and maximized productivity.
Bio Jason Krausert is CEO of Inner Sync Systems Inc., a leading-edge Canadian personal and professional wellness company specializing in workplace gender communication programs as well as in supporting employees’ personal relationships so problems at home don’t negatively impact either their quality of life or their performance in the office. Donna Tosky’s status as a leading gender-inrelationship expert evolved over almost two decades in the wellness industry. Now as a leading expert on gender, Donna educates individuals, health care professionals and managers in the natural laws of gender that are critical components of true success in life and in career. For a free consultation email Jason and Donna at contact@innersyncsystems.com. For full program details visit their website at www. InnerSyncSystems.com.
Assertiveness Reduces Stress Putting You in the Driver’s Seat of Your Own Life by Jacquelyn Ferguson
S
ince stress is the perception of insufficient control and assertiveness increases personal control, being assertive is one of the best ways to lower stress. It puts you in the driver’s seat of
CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
your own life. Conversely, being passive decreases your control and puts others in the driver’s seat of your life. While aggressive people attempt to
control too much and pay the consequences When rights collide you’re willing to negotiate later: they win the battle but ultimately lose the to ensure everyone gets their most important war. needs met and their rights respected, which is easier said than done.
Assertive Tips Pick and Choose Your Battles It’s important to pick and choose your battles since not all are worth fighting; like whether or not to speak up during political conversations. It’s certainly possible to carry on respectful political dialogue; it’s just difficult with some As a review from last month’s article, here are people. the four communication styles from which you can choose no matter the situation. They exist Start Small along a continuum with each style honoring It’s also wise for those who are especially different parties’ rights therefore producing passive to begin asserting themselves in different outcomes: situations and with people who represent the least threat. Practice using the following skills Passive: not standing up for yourself, or in less stressful situations first. Then as your attempting to so ineffectively that your rights self-confidence increases you can handle more are easily violated; others’ rights and needs are challenging situations with greater skill. Save more important than your own; the most threatening people and situations for later, after you’ve been successful in easier Aggressive: standing up for yourself in a way situations. that violates the rights of others; your focus is getting what you want without concern for Be Goal-oriented: Make Sure the Goal is others’ rights; within Your Control Do you often regret speaking before you Passive-aggressive: indirect expression of think? To avoid this, consciously identify your anger or frustration, which appears passive goal before speaking, particularly in difficult and non-hostile but you sabotage the other situations. Your goal basically outlines what person; you’re too indirect to assert yourself you want to say. Be careful, however, to state so communicate in a manipulative way, like your goal in a way that’s within your control. If gossiping; your goal requires someone else to change it’s beyond your control. Assertive: standing up for yourself in a way that respects the rights of others; you’re direct, E.g., Your co-worker cracks his gum, which honest and appropriate in expressing your drives you nuts! Rather than getting aggravated, feelings and opinions; identify your goal: “To get him to quit cracking his gum.” But he’s beyond your control; When assertive you accept that others’ rights therefore your goal is beyond your control and are as important to them as yours are to you. will only stress you. Restate the goal in a way 14 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
Feedback Statement This great three step formula helps you say almost anything to almost anyone: 1. Describe (not judge) the situation you are referring to; 2. Say how you feel about it if you want to;
2.“We enjoy your visits. We just want to protect our time and energy, too. Would keeping it to a week be too uncomfortable for you?” “Not uncomfortable, it just hurt my feelings.” 3. “That wasn’t my intent. I’d like for us all to be happy with your visits.”
3. Say what you’d like to see done about it Request Behavior Change (the problem-solving step): You can feel like you’re walking on thin ice For example, you have out-of-town-family when you ask someone to change a behavior. whose visits are too long. You’ve said nothing So it’s even more important to think before you for fear of hurting their feelings. But if it’s speak. Use this three-step formula: important enough to you, honor your right to set 1. Describe the other’s unacceptable limits rather than allow their rights to be more behavior; important than yours. You could say, 2. State the consequences of it; 1. “When your visit lasts longer than a 3. Give expectations for future behavior; week … 2. … I feel distracted and stressed. 3. We want you to continue visiting every year and would appreciate you keeping your visits to no more than one week.” Listen, Don’t Defend and Paraphrase Being assertive is more than stating what you want. You must also be respectful of the other party’s rights and needs. After you present the above request your family may feel offended. Listen carefully to their response. Then, paraphrase what you heard:
For example, you gave an employee several messages to call a customer. The customer has not yet been called and is getting upset. Explain to your employee the importance of returning customer calls. 1. “Janice, when you don’t return a customer’s call within 24 hours … 2. “… they can develop the impression that we don’t value their business and may take it elsewhere. 3. “So I need you to recommit to always returning customer calls within 24 hours.”
Your relative says, “So we’re too much trouble? Fogging Maybe we should just find a hotel.” 1. Your response: “It seems you feel I’m rejecting you.” - “Yes! That’s what it feels like.” 15 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
Do you react defensively to others who trigger your hot buttons? For this reason, fogging is my favorite skill. The intent of Fogging is to take the wind out of someone’s sails. Use
it when someone is unjustifiably criticizing responsibility that will require an you or attempting to emotionally hook you. additional five hours of work each week. Fogging means agreeing with everything they 4. “Jill Johnston’s interested, though. say (although you’re not really agreeing). You could ask her to join.” - E.g., Your nemesis approaches your messy desk and says, “How can you get anything done After saying “no” if the person requesting tries with a mess like this?” to talk you into a “yes,” … 1. Your response: “Yeah, it is messy.” 2. Or, “I don’t get much done.” Obviously, if your boss said, “Your report was lousy,” you shouldn’t Fog by responding, “Yes, it really was bad.” Fogging is useful only to take the wind out of someone’s sails who deserves it. Say “No” Saying “no” is especially difficult for passive people who want to please others, avoid hurting their feelings, appear to be cooperative, etc. If saying “no” is very difficult for you, revisit last month’s article on seeing your own rights as important to you as others’ are to them. Use this four-step approach to set appropriate limits:
Make the “No” Stick Paraphrase each attempt to get you to say “yes” then say “no” again: Requester: “We really need you; you’re so creative.” Your response: “Thanks, I’m really flattered and I’m going to say “no.” - “But there will be important people on this committee who’d be good for your career.” - “I’m sure there will be interesting people. I’ll be too busy to serve.” Expose Manipulation Successful manipulation requires:
1. Paraphrase the request; 2. Say “no;” 3. Give a reason or two (but not too many) why you are saying “no;” 4. Offer an alternative if you have one;
1. Your cooperation; 2. Remaining hidden; Exposing manipulation to the light of day decreases the likelihood the manipulative person will use it again with you. Shine the light with these ideas:
- E.g., You’ve served on a committee for three years and you no longer wish to do so. The When your mother pulls the, “I carried you for chair has just asked you to serve again: nine months” manipulation: 1. “Keisha, I’m flattered you’ve asked me to join the committee again. 2. “I’m going to say “no” … 3. “because I was just assigned another 16 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
- “I get the feeling I’m being manipulated. What’s going on?” You told a colleague you won’t work this
weekend and she attempts to manipulate you by him know you heard and understood before labeling you negatively. Use this great formula: responding assertively back. Assertive formulas help you think before you 1. “Whether or not __________ is not the speak. At first they require a minute or more issue. to think through but the results of successfully The issue is _________.” asserting yourself are definitely worth the 2. Your co-worker says, “You’re not a team learning and risking. Consistent assertive player.” behavior puts you in the driver’s seat of your 3. Your response: “Whether or not I’m a own life while improving your relationships. team player is not the issue. The issue is will I work this weekend and the answer is “no.” Your co-worker rolled his eyes over an idea you gave. Without judging him as, for example, arrogant you could surface his indirect, manipulative gesture (behavior) by using these three steps: 1. Describe what you perceive as his manipulative behavior; 2. State your interpretation of it; 3. Ask if you’re correct; “Stan, when I stated my ideas for the XYZ project I noticed you rolled your eyes. This makes me think you have a problem with my idea. Is that right? Do you have a problem with it?” Once you expose his manipulation be prepared for his response. Use the listening skills to let 17 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
Bio Jaquelyn Ferguson is the founder of InterAction Associates, her speaking and coaching firm. For over 25 years Jackie has designed and presented keynotes and workshops on stress management, diversity, workplace harassment, motivation, and communication skills Jackie is also a Stress & Wellness Coach helping people achieve more success with less stress. Jackie is the author of “Let Your Body Win: Stress Management Plain & Simple” and a weekly column “Stress for Success” in Gannett Newspaper, at www.letyourbodywin.com.
Are You Leading Like A Dictator?
Six Signs Your Management Style is Toxic by Keith Ayers
18 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
I
t doesn’t matter if someone is managing are unhappy. And make no mistake; leading a nation or a four-person professional like a dictator is one of the fastest ways to foster service firm; leading like a dictator leads workplace discontent. straight to the gutter. The good news is that managers no longer need Dating as far back as anyone can remember, to wait until they get a pink slip to find out that history has provided us with countless examples they’ve been leading like dictators. Instead, of dictators being overturned by “the people.” they can just review the list below of the “Six Most recently, we’ve watched the upheaval in Signs You’re a Dictator.” If three or more signs the Middle East, spurred on by the not-so-early apply, then it’s time for some serious changes in exit of Egypt’s former leader Hosni Mubarak. leadership style. After thirty years of rule and pocket full of cash about a third as big as Egypt’s entire GDP, there Six Signs You’re a Dictator were riots in the street and the dethroning of a ruler. While this is an extreme example, on 1. The Company Revolves Around You a large scale, with tons of publicity, it doesn’t — mean that the lessons seen here don’t apply to Employees are able to describe you in business management. one word: self-centered. Without your brilliant guidance, they all would be lost. Take for example Jack Griffin, the former Chief Your inferiors are merely there to carry out Executive of Time Inc. The NY Times reported orders that further your personal objectives. that employees described his leadership style as When success comes your way, you gladly “brusque” and that he created an unworkable take all of the credit and reward yourself office culture for the Time Inc. team. He with a little extra cash in your pocket, just implemented “swift and sweeping” changes like Mubarak did. without communicating his purpose well and undermined his team’s confidence in their 2. You Obsessively Control Employees — abilities. Although it would be a stretch to You enjoy wasting time by micromanaging classify Griffin and Mubarak in the same every employee task; you make people category, it is reasonable to assume that Griffin work precisely when, where, and how you was an inflexible leader. Consequently, in want them to. You think of your office as February, Griffin was forced out of Time Inc. an elementary school classroom where you after less than six months in office. need to monitor every movement, action, and breathe your students make. These examples are more common in business than most people think. In fact, from 2000 to 3. You “Inspire” with Fear —You like 2006, one in four CEO tenures ended in forced people to know that any mistake can be dismissal, a rate of almost four percent annually punishable by unemployment. You think according to Fortune magazine. While not all the best way to motivate people is to make of these dismissals resulted from the boss being them feel like their job is something they overly inflexible or too demanding, the fact must do to survive rather than something remains that these dismissals do happen, and they want to do. All the emails you send they happen when employees and coworkers out are typed in ALL CAPS and flagged as 19 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
urgent to maximize employee panic.
with. However, by recognizing and actively addressing leadership deficiencies before 4. Priorities Start and End with Work — disaster happens, employees are usually There is no room for excuses like “my kid receptive to leaders who make a genuine change. is in the hospital” or “I’m not feeling well” when there’s work to do. To you, having Trust and respect are the most essential a “work/life balance” and “personal time” ingredients to develop healthy leader-follower don’t exist. You feel entitled to employees relationships. An effective boss needs to value weekend time just as much as their work positive social relationships in the office and time and expect them to cater to your needs nurture his or her employees to become self24/7. directed individuals who will produce their best work, not because their boss threatens them, but because they want to. Employees need to be treated with respect, shown appreciation, and given recognition from their leaders to maintain engagement in their work. Just remember, idle threats and paychecks may be enough to get one task done, but in the long run they don’t come 5. Respect Doesn’t Matter—Your ideal close to motivating employees the same way image of a leader-follower relationship is trust and respect do. to give as little as possible and get a lot back. Whenever you’re stressed or an employee has done something wrong, you don’t hesitate to “chew-out” a person in Keith E. Ayers is classic Jack Griffin style. After all, why President of Integro waste the chance to make an example of Leadership Institute, one person and motivate the others to do a global business, their job right? management, and leadership consultancy 6. You are Never Wrong — Why would firm with offices in Australia and associates you ever admit to being wrong when you located around the world. He is the author have a line of scapegoats outside your office of Engagement is Not Enough (Elevate just waiting to take the blame? You’re the 2008) which show leaders how to create leader of the company, your image is its an organization of passionate workers in most important asset, and being wrong is pursuit of a common purpose. For more not an option. You take credit for all the information visit www.integroleadership. company successes and pass off failures on com. to your employees.
Bio
By running a business like a dictator, leaders create toxic jobs, stressful workplace environments and begin to carve out a legacy that even suppliers are ashamed to be involved 20 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
11
|
May 2011
The Cost of College By Kay Kimball Gruder What does a family with a newborn have often additionally experience a sense of loss and in common with a family who has a son or anxious feelings around the shifting locus of daughter entering college? their control. So let me ask, “What percentage of your work/life initiatives provide a range This sounds like the beginning of a joke, but both of offerings and programs to employees who have far more in common than most work/life have a child either entering college or currently balance programs have considered. Employees enrolled in college?� with young children and employees with a son or daughter embarking on the college years Societal Factors and Trends share high levels of stress, uncertainty, financial changes, a long list of new expenditures, Our society provides many more offerings and constant transitions, heightened worry, and resources to parents who have young children changing family relationships. The employees than to parents of older children. This pattern with the pre-college or college-enrolled child is also reflected in many work/life wellness 21 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
programs, yet the teen through college years are high stake and high transition. Maybe as a society we hope that parents have figured out how to successfully parent by the time children have entered their mid-teens, but parenting has one stepping into new or unknown territory at a steady pace. As a Parent Coaching InstituteTM Certified Parent Coach®, with over 22 years in higher education as an advisor to students and families, I can share that my clients are your employees. They are men and women from all job levels. Some went to college decades ago and some have never set foot on a college campus. Some clients have had one child already attend college, but most have not. Some families are financially secure, but most are just getting by. What they all have in common is that they share varying degrees of stress, worry, confusion, and distraction by virtue of parenting either a precollege or college enrolled student. Their list of parenting concerns spans from the college application process through to having their recent college graduate move back home. In between they are parenting children who have lots of opportunities to make mistakes. While it has always been true that college environment is fertile ground for errors in judgment, today the impacts are greater due to the cost of a college education. When in history: • •
•
•
What We Already Know Family-to-work interference makes concentration at work difficult, and we know that when people are preoccupied they are less focused – though there is ongoing debate and research about whether there is a systematic relationship between work/life balance and productivity. We know that too much stress is bad for one’s psychosocial well-being and that stress-related illnesses raise medical costs, and that absenteeism comes at a price too. We know that not everyone seeks or solely needs counseling to improve family-to-work interference, so to assume that employees will have their needs met by accessing mental health services is a narrow view. In the wellness industry we recognize the value of preventative measures. As with other physical and emotional life occurrences, families that are better prepared for the stressors associated with parenting a precollege and college enrolled student, and who can anticipate the range of parenting challenges that they will likely encounter, have the greatest opportunity to more effectively handle stress and transitions with expanded skills and knowledge. What are businesses providing to parents of pre-college and college enrolled students?
The work/life balance initiatives that are available to parents of pre-college and collegeenrolled students are uneven. While there has college cost so much; are now industry expectations for what great has a college education been essentially a childcare looks like or what offerings make mandatory next step for virtually every high for a generous fitness program, the same is not true for work/life initiatives targeting parents school student; of pre-college or college-enrolled students. At has parent involvement played such a one end of the spectrum you have companies significant role in the day-to-day decisions like SAS which have an on-site Teen/College and the personal organization of a child’s life; Resource Consultant as part of the Work/Life has there been a time when young people program staff. are so insulated from experiencing risk and The Work/Life Center creates and delivers an failure? annual “College Series” and invites experts in
22 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
too, to share their knowledge about topics of interest to parents of teens and adolescents. As Page Cvelich, the Teen/College Resource Consultant shares, the presentations not only address the nuts and bolts of things like saving for college, test prep, and the college selection and admission process, but offerings also consist of seminars designed “to help parents support their college-bound students as well as to parent more effectively” during this time in their child’s development. Through evaluations of services, SAS employees report “feeling a reduction in stress and cared for by the company.” In addition to a steady stream of parent education, Ms. Cvelich provides parents with resources, referrals, and parent coaching. She also offers family programs and topics for the teens. The department has a work/life lending library and two electronic lists which facilitate a flow of information to parents of teens and parents of college students and beyond. After students are at college, Ms. Cvelich is available as a point of contact to parents, providing suggestions about whom best at the college to act as a resource to their student in crisis. The average age of SAS’s world-wide employee population is forty-five, which places many in the throes of parenting a pre-college or college enrolled child. SAS presents a very comprehensive work/life program to parents of teens and college students. A more common model is one by which a company contracts for services that focus largely on guiding parents and their student through the college admission process or helping employees to address financial concerns and needs associated with sending a child to college. While these services are definitely meeting employee needs, they often lack a continuum of offerings and support that truly carry a parent through the teen and college years.
23 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
The “best fit” for your company or organization definitely test employee interest with relatively should be determined through consultation low-cost and low-risk pilot programs and with employees from all segments of your services. Consider the following: workforce. As well, take a reading on whether • If you have a work/life lending library your organization’s culture is open and ready for consider adding and featuring books that the benefits you intend to offer and whether you guide parents in their parenting of precan respond to the demand if a new program college and college enrolled students – not or initiative is a huge success. Remember too just the nuts and bolts of how to get into that parents may know that they are stressed and college, but books about experiencing frustrated about various circumstances related transitions, making the most of college, to their pre-college or college enrolled student, and parenting a college student. but they might not recognize that the bulk of the stress comes from their inability to effectively • Consider organizing a monthly parent their student through problems, crises discussion group that targets parents of and challenging situations. Parents won’t come college students or parents of high school running to you expressing a need for a parenting seniors. class, though having new knowledge and expanded parenting tools and strategies leads • Create a mentor program where parents to reduced stress and more confident parenting. with students already in college act as a It is over time and through a continuum of sounding board for parents who are just offerings that parents can reach a comfortable embarking on this stage of parenting. and effective new parenting paradigm as they • Start a lunchtime book group that reads navigate their role with their emerging adult. a range of parenting books or shorter Recommendations That Won’t Break the articles of interest to parents of teens and Bank college students. If you historically have not offered work/life balance programs tailored to parents of precollege and college enrolled students you can 24 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
•
Contract with a provider to deliver live presentations or on-demand parenting webinars.
•
•
Survey your parents and identify “hot topics” – then invite speakers in from different departments at area colleges to share information and to answer questions.
intangibles to emerge. Interestingly much of parent education revolves around improving parent communication skills which usually has a ripple effect on one’s personal and workplace interactions. My clients often share that they find themselves applying the parenting strategies Celebrate a student’s success by sending that they gained through parent education to a company note when a student is on the other situations where they are faced with Dean’s list, has graduated, or receives an challenges, transitions, decisions, and difficult athletic award, etc. people.
Create or deliver an electronic parent The cost of college to your workforce is more publication that is expressly for parents than just a financial commitment. It comes at of college students. an emotional expense, complete with parenting • Consider short-term flex time for confusion, unanticipated twists and turns, employees who need to make a round of sleepless nights, and sometimes even weeks or college visits with their child – that way more of worry. As you evaluate older initiatives they won’t call in sick or take vacation and cycle in the new, consider evaluating what time for an experience that is anything you might offer to a potentially significant segment of your workforce. Chances are that but a vacation! they will be both surprised and grateful – as There are definitely other considerations to much of one’s parenting of older children occurs factor in as you learn about employee needs and without guidance or inspiration. interests. For example, if you have employees who have children who will be the first generation to go to college you will likely want to tailor some offerings to address their questions and desire for information. Additionally, if you Kay Kimball Gruder, M.Ed. and Parent Coaching have a global workforce you will find that there Institute™ Certified are very different norms elsewhere in the world Parent Coach® founded for how involved parents are with their teen or SuccessfulCollegeParenting. college student. You might also find that some com and is also the of your global workforce desires to send their College Parent Expert for child to college in the U.S., and this too provides CollegeParenting.com. content for niche programming. Exploring the right fit for your workforce might mean offering Kay delivers on-site and webinar-based parent variations on a theme. programming on topics that guide parents in •
Bio
their evolving relationship with their student. She also provides individual and small group
As with any new initiative or program, the ROI for creating new or broadening your existing work/life offerings might be realized immediately or it might take more time for the 25 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
parent coaching. She is the author of “Successful College Parenting Strategies”, a free electronic monthly newsletter.
5 Steps to Good Decision Making by Kescia D. Gray
E
ach day we are faced with situations in life that require us to make choices. Some of these choices are easy, and at times, some of them can be difficult. Easy decisions consist of things like what clothing you should wear; most people choose what to wear based on the season of the year, the weather of the day, and where they might be going. Other easy decisions consist of things like what to eat, what movie to see, and what television programs to watch. Decisions that seem to be the most difficult are those that require a deeper level of thought. Examples of difficult decisions consist of thinks like where to attend college, what career path would be best, and/or whether or not to marry and start a family. These types of decisions are difficult because they are life changing decisions; they shape who we are, and they shape our future.
be learned. It is not something with which we are innately born, but merely a step by step process that is usually ascertained from life experience. Most adults know that experience can be a costly, ineffective teacher that teaches more bad habits than good; and because decisions can vary so obviously from one situation to the next, the experience gained from making one important decision is often times of little or no use when another decisionmaking problem arises.
Making good decisions is a method that must
One of the most effective decision making
26 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
12
|
May 2011
When making decisions, there are many steps that can be taken; but when making good decisions there are really only five steps that need to be considered. These steps are as follows:
Step 1: Identify Your Goal
strategies is to keep an eye on your goal. This simply means identifying the purpose of your decision by asking yourself what exactly is the problem that needs to be solved? And why does this problem need to be solved?
generate ideas for a possible solution.
When gathering information, it is best to make a list of every possible alternative; even ones that may initially sound silly or seem unrealistic. Always seek the opinions of Figuring out what’s most important to you people that you trust or speak to experts and will help you make good decisions. When professionals, because it will help you to come you know the reason why you have making a up with a variety of solutions when weighing particular decision; it will better serve you in all your options for a final decision. You will staying with it, and defending it. want to gather as many resources as possible in order to make the best decision.
Step 2: Gather Information for Weighing Your Options Step 3: Consider the Consequences When making good decisions it is best to gather necessary information that is directly related to the problem. Doing his will help you to better understand what needs to be done in solving the problem, and will also help to 27 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
This step can be just as important as step one because it will help you determine how your final decision will impact yourself, and/ or others involved. In this step, you will be asking yourself what is likely to be the results
of your decision. How will it affect you now? And how will it affect your future?
outcome. Recognizing that if the first decision is not working, you may have to go back to step two and choose another option. Always This is an essential step because it allows you looking for and anticipating unexpected to review the pros and cons of the different problems will help alleviate undue stress, if options that you listed in the previous step. and when a problem occurs. It is also important because you want to feel comfortable with all your options and the Although these five steps can help assist in possible outcome of whichever one you choose. simplifying the decision-making process, there are some common drawbacks that you must Step 4: Make Your Decision also take into account. Consider these: Now that you have identified your goal, gathered all necessary information, and weighed the consequences, it is time to make a choice and actually execute your final decision. Understanding that this step can cause some people a lot of anxiety is important because this is where you have to trust your instincts. Although you may still be slightly indecisive about your final decision, you have to take into account how this makes you feel. Ask yourself, does it feel right? And does this decision work best for you now, and in the future? When you answer those questions back, you should feel good about the result.
Misidentifying The Problem Many times the problem will be obvious; but there may come a time when identifying the main problem is not that easy. When this issue arises, figuring out exactly what it is, and where you need to focus your efforts will save you a lot of time and energy in the long run.
Having a Single Source
When considering the consequences, you must be open to a broad choice of alternatives in order to find the best solution. This can become a problem if you rely solely on a single source Step 5: Evaluate Your Decision of information because that one source may not b reliable, or may not be completely inline Once you have made your final decision and with the problem; thus altering your chances of put it into action, it is necessary to evaluate the making the best decision. decision and the steps you have taken to ensure that it works. This final step is probably just as Having Too Many Sources important as step one, if not more important, because it will help you to further develop your Having a variety of sources is usually not a bad decision making skills for future problems. thing; but not in every situation. Collecting This step is also fundamental because it may as much information as possible can be very require you to seek out new information and helpful at arriving to a decision, but an overload make some changes along the way. of information can leave you confused and misguided, and prevents you from following Remember, this step requires some patience your intuition. Remember, trusting your and it can also encourage perseverance. Why? gut instincts is a major key to making good Because it may take some time to see the final decisions. 28 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
Overestimating the Outcome
by Hammond, J.S., Keeney, R.L., and Raiffa, H., The Right Decision Every Time: How to When making a decision and putting your plan Reach Perfect Clarity on Tough Decisions by into action you should have taken care to weigh Kopeikina, L., or How We Decide by Lehrer, J. all your valid options. Making a decision based upon an outcome that may not be plausible will not help you solve the problem.
Bio
Poor Timing
Time can be a futile friend. Sometimes it is good, and sometimes it is not. When making major decisions, it beneficial to take your time in order to make the best choice from your options. But understanding the timing process is crucial because sometimes it is best to delay a decision, and other times delaying a response can cause more problems. There are also times when making a quick decision is advantageous because it allows you more time to make necessary changes should problems arise. In summary we all have to make many decisions throughout our daily lives. Some of these decisions require little effort, while others require more time and deeper thought before coming to a final solution. Remember, there are five basic steps to good decision making. Why is those five the ideal number? Because a significant part of decision making skills is understanding and knowing a simple technique; and also regularly practicing that technique. When there are more steps than we can count on one hand, most people tend to either forget a step, or misconstrue the order in which the steps must be taken. If you follow these five steps, and also remember the common pitfalls previously addressed, you will be well on your way to making good decisions for yourself. For more information on decision making skills, you can read: Smart Choices: A Practical Guide to Making Better Decisions 29 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
Kescia D. Gray, RN, MS, PHN, CHES is the owner and president of GrayKo Clinical Consultants, LLC. Previously published in Corporate Wellness Magazine, she is also an international author and speaker. Some of her most recent works includes co-author of Raising Healthy Children in an Unhealthy World, The Teen Handbook for Self-Confidence, and Transformation: Reinventing the Woman Within. GrayKo Clinical Consultants, LLC is a health and wellness education company dedicated to providing quality education programs, workshops, in-services, and seminars tailored to individuals, groups, and corporate clients. Their detail-specific program plans can be customized to fit your needs in order to foster success at meeting your goals of better health, increased productivity, job satisfaction, health safety, and more. Subject content related your needs and the needs of your company may include, but is not limited to stress management, emotional wellness, personal development, diet, and exercise. To contact Kescia Gray, please call (866) 653-2570, or go to www. graykoclinicalconsultants.com.
Boost Your Employees’ Energy and Focus in 2011 by Tom Jordan and Courtney Day
We all understand that employee productivity boosts bottom line. It’s also well known how much of an impact sick days can have on production. But sick days are not the number one culprit when it comes to hampering employee output. The truth is we lose more employee man-hours from sluggish performance than from sick days. Even our executives and leadership staff suffer from fatigue or lack of focus at times—and they should be our highest functioning team members! How much more debilitating is the “mid-shift droop” when it attacks our general work force? There is good news however—it’s beatable!
Production Comes From Energy Your assembly lines or computers run because they are energized—and so do our bodies. To produce thoughts and actions we need two things: a reliable source of energy (nutrition), and an efficient system of delivery (cardiovascular function). Unlike a computer however, the human body has a third requirement—rest. 30
CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
Most Employers Sabotage Their Own Work Force Most of us wouldn’t try to power our lights, computers, and phone lines with a weak source of energy, yet we have junk food abundantly available to our most valuable assets, our employees. To further complicate matters, our employees are sedentary for the majority of the day which by itself slows circulation and impairs our nutrient delivery system (the heart). With unlimited access to poor nutrition, and no systematic programming to encourage physical activity how can we expect employees to perform well in our fast paced, over-stressed-under-rested culture? Breaks and vending machines are common to all jobs but as leaders, our responsibility lies in providing the types of breaks and access to the types of foods that will enhance health and performance rather than sabotage it. For sedentary employees this may mean incorporating active breaks to re-establish circulation and revitalize the brain, while physically active employees may need active down time to enhance overall performance.
What do your employees do on break? Let’s look at what typical employees do with that break time. They head to the vending machine or the snack drawer and grab highly refined high-fat, high-sugar junk food snacks. This concentrated source of calories provides very quick rises in blood sugar with very little inclusion of nutrients vital to cognition or energy production. The end result is a crash is blood sugar a few hours later which is quickly followed by a crash in productivity.
Kiss Your Vending Machines Goodbye
Frequent trips to the vending machine can strike your office like the plague. When your employees eat potato chips, doughnuts, candy, etc., they are depleting vital brain chemicals such as Serotonin, Dopamine and Norepinephrine which help stabilize energy and mood. Also, the saturated and trans fats found in junk food can cause fat build-up in the blood, which leads to higher blood pressure, clogged arteries and an increased risk of heart disease. And they cause blood sugar spikes that ultimately drain energy. The From an activity standpoint, they typically go from only people benefiting from the vending machines are sitting at their desk to sitting in the break room. We the vendors. all know blood flow increases with movement but there is generally little encouragement for cerebral Supply Healthy Fuel workers to take a brisk walk, do a few yoga poses or tai chi movements that would restart blood flow. Plus, The first line of defense in boosting energy and with highly processed “junk foods” the circulatory focus isn’t prescribing anti-depressants or anxiety system shunts blood from the brain and muscles to the medications, it’s nutrition! Regular doses of high stomach in an attempt to digest it. quality lean proteins, nutrient- dense fruits and veggies and healthy fats can do wonders for both emotional Given the above metabolic burden our typical well-being and job performance. So the next time employee is imposing on their body, it’s no wonder you decide to give your employees a treat, replace that our “mid-shift droop” happens like clockwork, junk food with some of the following options: only to leave a big chunk of the workday rendered useless. But the damage doesn’t stop there… • Breakfast: Instead of doughnuts, stock your company’s kitchen with yogurt, fruit, whole These lifestyle habits also happen to result in the “big wheat bagels or oatmeal. Starting the day off ticket” medical items that affect the health of employees right can give the body a sustained release of (Cardiovascular Disease, Diabetes, Hypertension, blood sugar. Encourage your employees to eat Orthopedic Disabilities, Cancer, and Depression—the a “heart healthy” breakfast. number one disabler of U.S. employees). • Lunch: Avoid ordering from fast food So what can you as employers, HR directors and restaurants for work lunches. Instead, choose managers do to help in the year ahead? Here are some low-calorie options that everyone can enjoy. simple things you can do to improve your employees’ Examples include grilled turkey burgers with focus, energy and overall mental health: fresh lettuce and tomato, grilled chicken salads 31 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
with low-fat dressing, and low-calorie sandwich options like Subway or Jimmy Johns. • Snacks: Treat your employees with snacks that are high in fiber, such as granola bars, apples, and celery. Food that is high in fiber keeps your blood glucose levels from rising too fast. This means that your employees won’t feel hungry right after eating and will prevent them from overeating.
Provide Time to do the Opposite of Their Jobs at Lunch and On Breaks Although this may seem counter-intuitive, providing your employees with an adequate, guilt-free break allows for positive reinforcement and an increase in overall productivity. It also gives them a chance to recharge their batteries and come back to work refreshed and energized. During the break can also be a good time to provide a healthy snack. This way, your employees can rejuvenate both their mind and body. If your employees have physical jobs provide restful breaks. This gives their muscles and joints time to recover and prepare to retackle the next bout of physicality. If on the other hand your employees sit at a desk or are in stagnant positions for long periods you should provide them with the opportunity to get a little physical. It restarts circulation and revitalizes their minds. The Bottom Line: A little change can go a long way. Promoting small steps towards workplace wellness can net huge gains in performance, retention, and morale of the entire employee base. 32 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
Bio Tom Jordan, M.S., R.D. Tom Jordan is the wellness director at First Health Associates family medical center in Arlington Heights, Illinois. Jordan, a Registered Dietitian and an ACE Certified Personal Trainer, oversees First Health Associates’ Corporate Wellness and Weight Management programs including the Largest Loser Fitness Challenge. He is a member of the American Dietetic Association (ADA) and the Association of Sports, Cardiovascular and Wellness Nutritionists (SCAN). For more information, Tom Jordan can be reached at 847-593-3330 or online at www.FirstHealthAssociates.com. Courtney Day, M.S. Courtney leads the Exercise Physiology Department at First Health Associates. As an Exercise Physiologist and ACSM Certified Personal Trainer, she oversees the corporate fitness programs, weight management programs, and sports performance programs in conjunction with the First Health Wellness Department. For more information, Courtney can be reached at 847-593-3330 or online at www.FHAWeightCenters.com.
Join The Corporate Health and Wellness Association www.WellnessAssociation.com
CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
Corporate Wellness Magazine
CorporateWellnessMagazine.com | May 2011 14 w w w. C o r p o r a t e We l l n e s s M a g a z i n e . c o m
FEATURES
Meaningful Thoughts Beyond “Meaningful Use” by Kevin Shrake
H
ealthcare reform issues have frequently dominated the headlines over the past year. There are many new changes yet to roll out depending on the final regulations of the bill still being debated by our legislators. One major change has been in full swing and has captured the attention of healthcare organizations across the country. The need for an electronic health record (EHR) is obvious and ties to issues of privacy, efficiency, medical errors
35 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
and duplication of tests to name a few. The healthcare industry has clearly lagged behind when you acknowledge the fact that we have had ATM cards for several decades that allow us to perform banking transactions all over the world. Although the federal government is not always the leading edge innovator of change, in the case of the electronic health record, they have actually led the pack as evidenced by the system that has existed in their Veteran’s Administration (VA) network for many years. Recognizing the value of such a system, the government developed an incentive program as
part of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) of 2009. Under this act, provisions were developed for a program known as the Health Information Technology for Economic and Clinical Health (HITECH) Act. The final rules of this program were released in July of 2010 and offers financial incentives under Medicare and Medicaid to hospitals and eligible professionals who demonstrate “meaningful use” certified EHR technology. Although clearly an important step, health care leaders must look beyond meaningful use to implement a solution that will fit seamlessly into the process of patient care and provide value rather than turmoil.
Once established, providers must demonstrate meaningful use of their installed system for 3 months prior to becoming eligible for any financial incentives. For hospitals there are a total of 24 meaningful use objectives. There are 14 core objectives that are required and a remaining 5 that may be chosen from the list of 10 menu set objectives. Facilities that are on the leading edge of this change process may become eligible for the financial incentives beginning in mid 2011.
The Real Objectives
Although the government is providing financial “Meaningful Use” objectives to incentivize providers to develop an EHR solution, the real objectives of the There has been an enormous amount of attention program are as follows: placed on these two words and information is available from a variety of sources. A prudent • To improve the quality, safety and approach is to go right to the source and gain efficiency of care while reducing information regarding rules and regulations disparities; from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). www.cms.gov • To engage patients and families in their care; Demonstrating meaningful use is the key to receiving the incentive payments but it is not • To promote public and population the driver of the key objectives of the program health; which relate to achieving health and efficiency goals. The recovery act specifies three main • To improve care coordination; and components of meaningful use: • To promote the privacy and security of • The use of a certified EHR in a EHR’s meaningful manner (e.g.: e-Prescribing); In practical terms those goals relate to such • The use of certified EHR technology for things as reducing medication errors due to electronic exchange of health information the inability to read a physician’s handwriting, to improve quality of care; and or eliminating duplication of tests because the results of previous tests do not easily follow the • The use of certified EHR technology to patient as they seek care in multiple locations. submit clinical quality and other measures. Health care leaders must meet the criteria to 36 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
qualify for the incentive payments but then for smaller hospitals to working in a support clearly focus on how an EHR can improve capacity utilizing existing resources in a larger quality and lower costs in their organizations. facility.
The Change Process
Choosing the Best Option
Health care executives must realize that implementing an EHR requires understanding of the change process as well as a commitment to a “total solution” and not just software implementation. The acceptance of this major change by the end users; physicians, nurses and other clinical professionals is critical to the process. Physicians want to know, how easy will it be for me to locate information, make rounds on my patients, order medications and establish routine order sets, etc. Nurses have their own issues related to availability of computer terminals, ease of documenting nurse’s notes and accessing test results. Intimate involvement of the key stake holders in the evaluation and implementation process is a major factor in success or frustration.
There are a number of qualified companies with viable EHR solutions to pick from. When choosing a vendor it is important to consider these meaningful thoughts beyond meaningful use.
One Size Does not Fit All Clearly there are differences in capabilities and resources in a 25 bed critical access hospital and a 700 bed medical center. The former often has very little on site information technology (IT) personnel and support unless they are part of a larger health system. Larger institutions often have a full complement of IT support and have different needs when it comes to EHR implementation. For this reason, when evaluating vendors, health care executives should look for a total solution which has a menu of options to choose from that can be customized to the specific needs of the client. This could range from a total outsourced solution 37 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
• The software must be certified; • The vendor must have an efficient process of meeting meaningful use criteria; • System costs should be structured to minimize total costs while taking advantage of positive adjustments in Medicare Cost Reports (for critical access hospitals) or enhancing payments to larger facilities; • Total costs of the implementation should be calculated. Is this an all inclusive package deal for a defined period of time, or will there be ongoing maintenance and upgrade costs? Beware of a low acquisition cost followed by expensive upgrades; • Are financing options available that meet your needs? and; • How will your system be supported and maintained and how will it interface with existing systems?
Avoiding the “CEO Nightmare” As we enter the age of EHR we are moving into a scenario of dependence on technology that we have not experienced to this point. The typical issues that a CEO worries about have historically related to things such as patient safety, quality measures, financial performance, medical staff relations and employee satisfaction. The CEO did not have to be concerned about how orders would be processed or patient documentation achieved because it was accomplished via people and paper. This might be a good system based on “up time” but as described earlier it does not offer the safety, efficiencies and portability of data advantages that an EHR provides. The most critical issue that CEOs should ask is, “how will our EHR system be maintained and supported and by who?” Making sure that you have a clear, professional, cost effective answer to that question will avoid the CEO nightmare of frustrated physicians and staff complaining about not being able to care for their patients. We are entering a major era of change in the healthcare industry as it relates to implementation of EHR. It is important to meet meaningful 38 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
use criteria and qualify for financial incentives offered by the federal government as soon as possible. It is equally important however to engage in a process that takes in account the change process with the users as well as the need for a total solution that that is cost effective and meets your ongoing system support needs. Healthcare leaders that recognize these key elements will provide the best environment for serving their patients while enhancing the satisfaction of their clinicians.
Bio Kevin Shrake is an experienced Health Care CEO . He is a Fellow in the American College of Healthcare Executives as well as an accomplished author and public speaker. He currently serves as the Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer of M*D Resources, Inc. based in Fresno, California.
FEATURES
UNIONS CHEAT MEMBERS
OUT OF HEALTH AND
WEALTH by Lisa Holland
3927 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
L
et’s start by saying that we are pro-member, prohealth and pro-wealth! Now that we’ve gone on record stating that we are not bias towards Unions, let’s talk about the health of America. It’s not good. It’s getting worse and union members aren’t any healthier than the general population, yet they have some of the best health benefits in the nation! So, what’s wrong with this picture? Just look at the recent CDC stats on obesity…it’s appalling. America spends more on healthcare and is one of the sickest nations in the world. You can draw your own conclusion on that fact but it’s now obvious that the amount of money in terms of benefits that are available to an individual or union member makes no difference in their health status. It’s the member that makes the difference in their personal health. If we accept these facts as correct then union members are paying huge amounts of cash to doctors, hospitals and administrators. Why not pay union members to be healthy? Yes, that’s right. It’s the concept inherent in a Consumer Directed Health Plan with an HSA. But Unions have been loath to listen to the facts. We say it’s time for the Unions to stop cheating their members out of health and wealth. Here’s how: The facts speak for themselves that CDHP changes an individual’s healthcare behavior. McKinsey’s research and recent findings continue to show that 25% or more of members in a CDHP change their actual health behavior for the better. They stop smoking and lose weight. First year medical trend reduction is in the range of 14-17%. Health spend continues to decline as members maintain their better health status year after year. This demonstrates how improved health behaviors and lifestyle changes can impact healthcare affordability. Where does the saved money go? In a CDHP model it goes to the member’s HSA account. Cash, tax free… accumulating tax free for the use of members and their families for future medical care and retirement. Who can argue with a plan that makes members healthier and wealthier? The transfer of wealth to union members might possibly be the largest transfer in history and will eclipse any rate of pay increase that most Americans may see in the next 20 years.
CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
Union leaders continue to perceive CDHP as a “take away” rather then a benefit and continue to ignore the hard facts that members on a CDHP are not only getting healthier but wealthier.
dollar “shifted” from a member’s paycheck to their own HSA account they will save about 42 cents in taxes while management saves about 8 cents in taxes. For example, a contribution from management of $2,000 a year saves enough taxes Unions have special leverage with their ($840) to pay for 80% of all workers’ healthcare management and are in a position to seek this in any one year. Re-routing tax dollars for the wealth transfer to their members. This is not a benefit of union members seems to be a good wealth transfer from management but from the idea too. medical establishment as a reward for just being healthy. We think it’s a no-brainer for Unions to New point-of-service adjudication and payment go to management and seek a CDHP/HSA plan technology now makes the implemention of a that pay first dollar for preventive care, then ask CDHP with HSA a hassle free experience for management to fund the first two year deductibles members, since members no longer get reams essentially giving members a “ZERO” deductible of bills at home nor have to deal with a debit plan. Stay healthy and get wealthy! It’s a win/ card. Just walk in, get treated and walk out. win/win situation for members, union leaders It’s Simple. Imagine a system that enriches and management. the union member with tax savings, tax free dollars, a “zero” deductible plan, paid preventive Here are the facts: 80% of members in any health healthcare, additional money for retirement, no plan never spend on average more than $800 a more bills at home and that actually can make year on healthcare and that includes families. the member more healthy while at the same time Most members will have their deductible saving management money that makes the Union accumulated within a year or two. For every leaders look like heroes. The time has come for 41 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
Unions to take a real close look into the world of CDHP.
About Simplicity Health Plans Cleveland, Ohio - Simplicity Health Plans is the best implementation of a CDHP/HSA. It aligns the interests of the Employer, Employee and the Provider to provide a turn-key, fully integrated Consumer Directed Health Plan. It also delivers a low cost, scalable solution to control claim costs. The Plan fuses unparalleled technology, point of service adjudication, real-time data, and first of its kind anti-fraud controls. Services include an ERISA compliant health plan, HSA administration and banking, medical claims administration, TPA functions, pharmacy, dental & vision, COBRA, stop loss reinsurance, realtime Utilization Review and Case Management, Health Coaching, Comparison Shopper, Health & Wellness programs, and a host of on-line tools for Providers, Employers and Members.
42 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
Bio Lisa M. Holland, RN, MBA has been in the healthcare care industry for over 18 years and held senior level positions within major healthcare organization in the US. Lisa is an accomplished business development professional. Lisa’s professional objective is to promote appropriate utilization of healthcare services/solutions that empower healthcare consumerism. Gregory J. Hummer, M.D., has spent the last 18 years developing and perfecting Simplicity Health Plans to solve the vexing complexities, out-of-control costs, burdens and inefficiencies that are associated with healthcare coverage in America today. Dr. Hummer is chairman and CEO of Simplicity Health Plans.
Give your employees something to smile about. They will thank you.
Offer affordable discount plans to help them save on their wellness and family needs. With Careington discount wellness and lifestyle plans, you can offer affordable plans that will help your employees save on health care. They no longer miss check-ups or forgo filling prescriptions because of cost. Plus, our lifestyle discount plans can help them simplify their busy life - and reduce their overall stress. Careington Discount Plans can be customized to meet your organization's needs. We also offer discounts on a variety of lifestyle and wellness products, including, mental health services, child and elder care, a 24-hour nurseline, financial counseling, pet care, pet medicine, and more.
Some of the premier products we offer:
Discount plans can be ...
Added to your current benefits package anytime Bundled with voluntary insurance plans or flex plans Available to full-time or part-time employees Employee or employer can pay for plan membership Can be customized to your organization's needs ®
To learn more about Careington and our discount plans, call (800) 400-8789 or visit www.careington.com
Connecting Employee Health to Voluntary Discount Dental Plans by Nicole Ropiza Studies and word-of-mouth in recent years have dental hygiene ; brushing twice daily, flossing brought much needed attention to the connection daily and scheduling semi-annual dental between dental care and a person’s overall health. checkups, the preventive care and daily dental hygiene habits can help them avoid some major According to the Academy of General Dentistry, out-of-pocket dental expenses tomorrow. more than 90 percent of all systematic diseases have oral health symptoms. Poor or lacking Proper dental care can also help keep employees dental health may have negative effects on a at work. Considering that lost work due to range of diseases and conditions, including dental problems equates to 164 million hours of diabetes, osteoporosis, heart attack, stroke, employee productivity each year, according to pregnancy and pre-term birth weights. the U.S. Department of Labor’s Bureau of Labor Statistics. In addition, a report in Dental Health Magazine from February 2011 goes on to read, “People But sometimes, dental health is not as simple as with gum disease are almost twice as likely to just brushing, flossing, chewing sugarless gum suffer from coronary artery disease as those and so on. You might need a cavity filling or root without gum disease, according to the American canal and our children might need braces. And, Academy of Periodontology.” sometimes our mouth For those who religiously keep up with their 44
is a major investment not covered by employersponsored insurance plans. Meanwhile, the cost of dental care procedures is rising faster than you can say “commission.” According to a 2010 report from Pew Center on the States, the total annual spending for dental care is expected to increase 58 percent, from $101.9 billion to $161.4 billion, through 2018. Coincidentally, a 2009 poll by Harris Interactive and Health Day found that 50 percent of uninsured Americans skipped necessary dental care visits due to financial burdens. The fast increase in dental costs and lack of dental coverage has prompted some workers to get creative with their dental care budgets. A few money saving dental care solutions that have hit the newscycle in recent years include: visiting local university dental schools for dental care at a fraction of the cost; heading overseas for a dental vacation and discount dental work in countries like Costa Rica and Tijuana; and negotiating with dentists to find a discount wherever possible.
workers have access to employer-offered dental plans, compared to the 74 percent of workers with access to similar medical coverage. As many companies do not offer dental coverage and are considering insurance cuts in response to a questionable economy and newfound financial strategies, dental benefits are beginning to play a major role in employers attracting and retaining workers. Dental is the third most requested benefit after major medical insurance and retirement benefits, according to a report by LIMRA. And nearly 80 percent of workers participate in benefit programs if dental care is part of the program. Giving employees an option and resources for dental plans is an investment for companies. Employees with dental benefits are more likely to take part in preventive dental care, contributing to their overall health and wellbeing. According to a recent survey by The Long Group, 83 percent of employees with an employer contributory dental plan visited the dentist twice or more a year. Brush Up On Voluntary Discount Dental Plans
Employees More Conscious of Employer Dental Benefits Some companies find employer-paid dental programs too expensive and not necessary to Other media reports in recent years, including their employees overall health and well-being. the New York Times, “How to manage dental costs, with or without insurance” and BankRate. And while employers discuss how best to com, “Dental insurance or discount plan,” have respond to cost challenges and the anticipated brought attention to the struggle against high effects of health care reform, voluntary dental dental expenses and the growing gap between plans are becoming an alternative for companies employers and dental benefits. to share with their employees and save on health care costs. But, let’s say for instance “Company These days, the reality is that many employer- A” offers a mom of three a full-time job with offered health care plans do not include dental a healthy base salary, halfway decent medical coverage or offer it as a supplementary benefit. insurance, a 401k program to participate in According to the U.S. Department of Labor’s and no dental insurance. The mom considers Bureau of Labor Statistics, only 48 percent of the offer and reviews another opportunity with 45 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
“Company B,” which will provide everything drugs. that “Company A” will, as well as voluntary discount dental plans. As a solution for employees and employers, voluntary discount dental plans can help The mom weighs her options while considering one companies cut costs while providing workers of her sons is going to need braces soon and she’s with an option to manage necessary dental anticipating a cavity filling or two this year. expenses. It also gives brokers an alternative to She decides to go with “Company B,” knowing provide clients who want to cut dental benefits that she will take advantage of the voluntary as a whole. discount dental plans for her family and save money in the long-run versus paying out more And the next time the sensitive topic of no of her salary. She also knows that she’ll be help with employee dental care comes up for more productive at work without having to your client, they could say, “We do not provide worry about how she is going to afford her son’s employer-paid dental plans, however, you orthodontist bill, which can cost up to $7,000 can join a voluntary discount dental plan with without any benefits. access to significant savings on dental care With voluntary discount dental plans, procedures for you and your family. And you employees and families typically pay an annual have the flexibility of choosing an affordable membership fee that gives them access to plan without annual limits.” discount dental dentists have agreed to offer at dental care services at discounted rates. Major providers, such as Aetna and Cigna, offer plans where savings can range from 10 to 60 percent Nicole Ropiza is the broker/affiliate and group on routine exams, x-rays and costly dental manager at DentalPlans.com. The leading online procedures. source for discount dental plans, DentalPlans. com connects individual, family and group Voluntary discount dental plans are not dental members to significant savings on dental care insurance. Employees and families typically procedures such as cleanings, braces, root canals pay an annual membership fee starting at $79.95 and crowns. The company offers more than 30 of per year for individual employee and $129.95 the leading regional and national discount dental per year for families. Plans also activate within plans with more than 100,000 participating three business days, without paperwork hassles dentist listings in combined networks across or health restrictions. the country. For more information and to find a discount dental plan that fits your family’s needs, Plans do not have annual limits and can be used visit www.DentalPlans.com. as often as needed, which offers employees a choice and affordable alternative to dental For more information about a turnkey sales insurance while they choose the plan that best solution for insurance brokers to fill the growing fits their needs. Some plans can also be used for need for affordable dental care, visit www. procedures such as cosmetic dentistry, and may DentalPlans.com or call 1-888-632-5353 choose include discounts on vision and prescription option 5 for brokers and 6 for groups or email DPBrokers@DentalPlans.com.
Bio
46 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
Pharmaceutical Importation ~
Logical, Legal, Safe by J.J Summerell
P
harmaceutical costs, especially those for brand name, maintenance drugs, have been a primary driver of health costs and, in turn, health insurance costs, for well over a decade. Interestingly, the costs for these drugs vary widely around the world and are on average 44% higher in the United States than elsewhere. That’s 44%! Countries with centralized, single-payer health systems are able to negotiate lower prices for drugs than are the myriad of insurance companies in the US. However, the lost revenue from lower prices paid by the single-payer countries is simply shifted to payers in the US. Effectively, the US is subsidizing the research and development ventures of the drug companies more than their single-payer counterparts. Given free markets, this is not a sustainable business model. As pharmaceutical costs have risen, more and more Americans have begun sourcing their brand name, maintenance medications from countries enjoying the lower price structures. As Americans, we have the right to source legitimate prescriptions, for personal use only, from whatever country we choose. Over the past decade a small industry of importation management companies has evolved. One of the more interesting developments in this industry applies to self-funded, ASO 47 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
health plans. Because the FDA stipulates that pharmaceutical importation must be voluntary and for personal consumption only, ASO plans can give employees the option of participating in these plans. The advantages of such an arrangement accrue to both employer and employee: • The employer pays the lowest price available in Tier 1* countries, usually a savings of 35% to 55%. • The employee no longer is responsible for the co-pay. This can be a significant savings for a family with multiple co-pays on brand name maintenance meds. The remainder of this article will discuss what is involved in implementing one of these plans, including Prospective Accounts, Products and Pricing, PIM Company Analysis, Projected Savings, Future Implications and Legal Substantiation.
Prospective Accounts
Only self-funded, ASO (administrative service only) groups are allowed to participate and employees can only participate on a voluntary basis. Fully insured groups are ineligible. The reason ASO groups are eligible is because they are acting as individuals. That is, with no underlying true insurance on the group and participation only on a voluntary basis participants are legally acting as individuals. This is discussed in more detail within the links under “legal substantiation.” Generally, group size should be 100+ employees. Older employees consume more maintenance drugs, thus increasing
participation. Ideally, an older employee population is better. Employee communication is paramount to the success of the program. Employees need to be assured that the imported drugs are authentic and will be delivered reliably. Most groups experience about 30% participation initially, growing to 60%+ within a few years.
Products and Pricing
the IPP not give employees access to: • Narcotics. Scripts such as Valium, etc may be prone to theft. • Illegal drugs. • Drugs not specifically approved by the FDA for use in the US. Many drugs are approved for use in other countries but not the US. Such drugs may be available for importation but their availability ‘muddies the water’ for both the FDA and the IPP.
The formulary of the IPP is quite important, both what is provided in the formulary as well • Immediate needs drugs. If a patient needs as what is not provided. It is important for antibiotics, they do not want to wait 5 employees to have the widest possible range days for delivery. These meds should be of drugs available that may be prescribed by a sourced through the traditional PBM. doctor. However, it is equally important that 48 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
Pricing is at the crux of the matter. Consider the top ten medications shipped by a leading IPP:
These are the same products, from the same manufacturers, as those available via the traditional PBM. The only difference is with Nexium, whose US advertising firm had the color changed to purple for promotional reasons. In the rest of the world the ‘purple pill’ is pink! Otherwise, they are the exact same drugs.
Company Analysis There are no long-established players in this market because it is so new. There are a number of firms which have targeted the individual market for over a decade, but the ASO market is just beginning to develop. No doubt, these plans are ‘pushing the envelope’ with the pharmaceutical manufacturers and regulatory bodies, but their objections appear to be negated by various pieces of legislation; points of law and precedent (see ‘Legal Substantiation’). Look for an IPP’s ability to source meds from the top 4 Tier 1 countries: Canada, United Kingdom, New Zealand and Australia. Prices vary from country to country and you need to provide the lowest possible cost. As noted above, it is not advisable to contract with companies who also provide narcotics via overseas sources, even if 49 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
these narcotics are legal and legitimate. They are a target of criminals which you need to avoid. Another critical need is top notch customer service. Although the importation of scripts is legal for personal consumption, occasionally US Customs will intercept a 90 day supply and deem it not for personal consumption since it is for more than 30 days. In this case, the IPP should be willing to overnight a replacement script to the employee. US Customs interceptions occur in less than 1% of shipments but it is a situation which needs to be addressed. Managerial and financial capacities are important but difficult to determine, again because of this being an ‘infant industry.’ IPP’s which have addressed the individual market have the most experience at sourcing and distributing the meds, but very few have long
term experience list-billing the client company the savings. A utilization report from the current and providing superior customer service in the plan administrator will give the most accurate HR arena. projections. The best bet is to look for an IPP which has been Future Implications in business the longest, has the widest possible formulary of non-narcotic maintenance meds and the administrative resources to make the program simple and successful.
Projecting Savings Savings to an employer will depend upon the number of employees, the use of brand name maintenance medications and participation in the program. For example, Schnectady County (NY) projects an annual savings of $1.3 million + for their 2,300 employees in 2010 after 6 years of offering the program, an average savings of $565 per employee .
This may well be a temporary industry. That is, once a significant amount of meds are purchased overseas, the pharmaceutical manufacturers will adjust prices globally to address the imbalances, rendering IPPs unnecessary. However, for the next several years this is an excellent option to show prospects which other brokers may not even be aware of.
Legal Substantiation
Muncie (IN) is saving $586K per year on their 750 employees, an average of $780 per Is this legal? The regulators and legislators employee. have been intentionally vague on the subject. I am not an attorney and will simply use links to How much can any individual employer expect give readers an overview of legislation, points to save? It depends, but contact me and I will of law and precedents. Seniors living in the share an Excel spreadsheet which will estimate United States along the Canadian border have 50 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
their scripts from Canada for years. Brokers and legality has been questioned, the regulators and human resource managers should consult their legislators have opted not to pursue the matter attorneys regarding their individual situations. and there is a ‘deafening silence’ from the courts on the issue. Until conclusive decisions Joe Morris is the attorney for a leading PIM. are handed down from DC, these programs are Mr. Morris was Assistant Attorney General a terrific way of opening doors to new accounts under President Reagan and a lead negotiator and allowing employer’s immediate savings on for the United States with NAFTA, the their pharmaceutical utilization. North American Free Trade Agreement. His opinion is that pharmaceutical importation, on an individual basis and with a legitimate prescription, is protected by NAFTA. The FDA has not disagreed. Mr. Morris, interestingly, J.J Summerell manages has recently served as Hearing Officer in Rham Worksite Insight, a Emmanuel’s residency hearing regarding his benefits communications eligibility to run for mayor of Chicago. and enrollment firm in Greensboro, NC. An An April 2004 statement by William Hubbard, independent general Associate Commissioner for Policy and agency, Worksite Planning for the FDA is here. These statements Insight markets exclusively through brokers were prepared for the Senate Committee on and agents. Worksite Insight also owns Easy Finance, subcommittee on Health Care and Benefit Statements, LLC, a software product International Trade. sold to benefits brokers and human resource departments. Past President of the Greensboro The Council of State Governments issued a Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors, report, Prescription Drug Importation, in 2004, Summerell currently serves on the Board of in response to inquiries from state and local Directors of the Greensboro Society of Financial governments. Service Professionals. Mr. Summerell earned his Masters in Business Administration from Wake WebMD researched the subject in an article Forest University and has industry awards include The Letter (and Spirit) of Drug Import Laws. the Frederick W. Joyner Distinguished Service Award, the W.H. Andrews Member of the Year Pharmaceutical importation can be a powerful award, qualification for the Leading Producers tool in the effort to reduce health care costs in Round Table and Golden Eagle awards. self-funded, ASO health plans. Though the
Bio
51 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
Reducing Narcotics Abuse in Workers’ Compensation by Tron Emptage
Best practices a PBM can implement to reduce cases related to abuse of opioid analgesics. In addition, another study co-released by CDC abuse and cost and SAMHSA found that emergency room On-the-job injuries often involve chronic pain visits linked to non-medical use of narcotics for injured workers and long-term liability for rose 111 percent between 2004 and 2008. workers’ compensation self-insured payors. Many times, pain from a chronic injury is Risks Associated With Narcotics Abuse treated with narcotics. According to the 2010 Progressive Medical Drug Spend Analysis, While narcotics are considered safe and narcotic spending accounts for 34 percent of effective if used properly, they have the workers’ compensation medication expenses. potential for leading to addiction and abuse And while narcotics can be beneficial in the if their use is not monitored and controlled. treatment plan for a patient in pain, there are Misuse and abuse of narcotics represent serious risks involved when they are not used three areas of particular concern for workers’ compensation self insurers including: properly. ▪ Potential for serious health risks The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) and the ▪ Higher percentage of medical expenses Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services as claims age Administration (SAMHSA) both indicate ▪ Risk of litigation increasing misuse and abuse of narcotics over the past decade. SAMHSA data shows that As the cost of prescriptions ─ including there was a significant increase from 2000 narcotic medications ─ directly impacts to 2006 in the treatment of substance abuse the cost of a workers’ compensation claim, 52 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
insurers are looking for ways to quickly get control of cases of misuse and abuse. One of the most efficient ways to manage narcotic use in a claimant population is to partner with a pharmacy benefit manager (PBM). A PBM can clearly define a strategy for proactively and effectively monitoring narcotics. These plans and strategies help payors ensure injured worker safety and reduce expenses. Best Practices to Reduce Narcotics Abuse and Manage Expenses Forming a partnership with a PBM can provide workers’ compensation self insurers a valuable resource in controlling narcotics use and thereby reducing risk for all stakeholders. There are several key best practices that can be deployed by PBMs to assist self-insured payors. Best Practice #1: Defining a strategy Getting control of narcotics usage requires a well-defined strategy. Once the PBM reviews the prescription history, it should be used to develop a customized narcotics strategy for each medication plan to identify which medications are appropriate for the injury type and body part. They also account for proper duration of use and quantity limits. Best Practice #2: Capturing prescriptions at first fill When new claims are filed, it is important to capture when and what type of medication is filled at the onset of injury. PBMs should have in place a mechanism to capture this prescription information. Often these early prescriptions begin telling the story of the medication history and medication therapy to come. One method to capturing this data is through First Fill cards. These cards are typically distributed by the employer to the injured worker at the point of accident or injury. To ensure that both employers 53 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
and injured workers use the program, PBMs should offer training programs on their use. Best Practice #3: Offering home delivery programs and retail drug cards Both retail and home delivery programs provide the workers’ compensation self insurer an effective means to monitor and control an injured worker’s medication utilization. They also provide self-insured payors an opportunity to fully leverage pharmacy network participation and discounts, thereby reducing medication expenses. Retail drug cards. When an injured worker requires additional medications, a retail drug card program will give the self-insured payor control over what, when and where the prescriptions can be filled. Home delivery programs. A home delivery program offers the injured worker the convenience of ordering prescriptions online or on the phone while providing the workers’ compensation self-insured payor the ability to engage in proactive utilization review programs. They also give the self insurer a mechanism to educate injured workers on the risks associated with narcotics through direct interaction with the pharmacist dispensing the injured worker’s prescriptions. Best Practice #4: Managing prospective and concurrent narcotics utilization review programs The PBM should have a clinical management process to govern narcotics utilization that is managed by clinical pharmacists. The clinical drug utilization review (DUR) program should use a combination of evidence-based guidelines, peer review journals and recommendations provided by government organizations. Both
prospective and concurrent review processes are essential to a successful program: Prospective utilization reviews. A prospective program allows all involved parties to plan for future outcomes with up-front information. Historical data and practices guide future decisions at the establishment of the PBM relationship. This prospective process allows for the achievement of cost control and utilization control. Concurrent utilization reviews. The PBM triggers concurrent alerts to inform the dispensing pharmacist about possible reasons a prescription should be questioned further prior to filling. These point-of-sale alerts may establish behaviors that could indicate abuse involving the use of multiple pharmacies and physicians for different narcotics or excessive early refill attempts. The messaging from the PBM ensures that prescriptions for narcotics will not be fulfilled at the point-of-sale unless the medication is allowed or the PBM receives authorization from the self-insured payor.
These types of utilization review programs are essential to maximize the effectiveness of a narcotics usage strategy and are most effective when leveraged in conjunction with prospective and concurrent drug utilization reviews. PBM programs should be flexible enough to allow for customization of review requirements for clients, as client goals and objectives often vary even within organizations.
Best Practice #5: Conducting retrospective drug utilization reviews and clinical intervention programs Retrospective reviews. After a prescription is fulfilled, a PBM’s clinical pharmacist team should audit these prescriptions for indicators of inappropriate use. Indicators often include: ▪
Sole use of narcotics as treatment
▪
Multiple physicians
▪
Use of multiple short or long acting narcotics
▪
Excessive duration and use
54 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
Physician monitoring. A PBM should continually monitor the use of multiple physicians by one injured worker. The physician monitoring program should be based on established best practices and contain multiple components including: ▪
Monitoring for appropriate medication utilization using evidence-based published therapeutic guidelines
▪
Overseeing prescribing patterns at the physician level to establish appropriate/ inappropriate use of brand name medications when an FDA-approved generic equivalent exists
▪
Participating in mandatory and voluntary state reporting programs that monitor for excessive prescribing patterns Clinical intervention programs. The PBM should have a range of clinical intervention programs to assist a client with evaluation needs. The range of programs should consist of registered pharmacists, nurses and other health professionals available for consultation on medication questions to more detailed evaluations including peer reviews and direct consultation with prescribing physicians. The PBM’s clinical intervention team should provide recommendations for specific claims that require further evaluation through the use of the information gathered in prospective, concurrent and retrospective review processes.
Best Practice consultation
#6:
Providing
ongoing
A quality narcotics utilization program is an essential component of controlling narcotics use. To ensure the utilization program is effective, the pharmacists managing the programs should take proactive measures to continually expand utilization review programs as the workers’ compensation industry evolves. As changes occur, they should also be available to consult with clients on how to adapt their DUR programs accordingly. Best Practice #7: Validating narcotics use through reporting If a DUR program is successful, there will be 55 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
| May 2011
a reduction in unnecessary medication usage, including narcotic use. A PBM should easily be able to validate those reductions through a wide range of real-time and ad-hoc reports. User-run reports. The PBM should offer a tool that gives a client an option to run a wide range of reports to gain an in-depth understanding of all activity. To maximize the effectiveness and ease of use of the reports, the PBM should ensure the reports are categorized into varying levels depending on how the reports will be used. Management level users should be able to run reports to assist with managing the claims professional, such as a report that provides exception or override information as well as a report that provides details on actions sent to the PBM.
Other available reports should include: savings reports that can be sorted by a range of time periods, jurisdictions, groups and/ or branches, pharmacy network utilization and savings reports, generic efficiency and opportunity, as well as a wide range of trending reports including top prescribing physicians, top therapeutic classifications, top pharmacy medications, top ICD-9, top injury type and reports detailing prescribing physician habits.
However, the best method for controlling outof-network bills is to make it easier for the injured worker to go in-network as early in the life of the claim as possible by utilizing First Fill cards, which are distributed by the employer at the onset of the injury. Two other strategies for reducing out-of-network bills are home delivery and retail drug card programs. Drug utilization review report. To provide information on savings achieved as a result of the program, the PBM should have a detailed DUR report. This report should provide information on savings achieved as a result of the program and should document savings in distinct areas rather than broad categories in order to provide the complete picture of DUR activity.
Summary It is expected that narcotics will continue to play a role in treating pain in workers’ compensation, so self insurers must take proactive measures to reduce misuse and abuse. By doing so, they decrease risk for litigation, improve injured worker safety and obtain more control over medication expenses.
By partnering with a PBM, workers’ Ad-hoc reporting. The PBM should have compensation self-insured payors can put an the ability to supply ad-hoc reports to assist effective narcotics utilization strategy into with narcotic utilization management. If place. A relationship with a strong PBM partner the PBM captures the data, then the PBM experienced in workers’ compensation will should be able to provide reports based on enable the self insurer to not only monitor utilization but stop point-of-sale fulfillment of those data elements. unnecessary narcotics. Best Practice #8: Reduce Out-of-Network Bills A high number of out-of-network bills can lead to issues with managing utilization of narcotics. Not only are individual out-of-network bills typically higher than those in-network, they are often not included in the utilization process. It is vital for payors to have a process in place for properly driving those bills back into the network. This can be done by working with a PBM that offers both paper and electronic out-of-network bill solutions. This will ensure that critical injured worker data on number of prescriptions, duration of therapy, doctor information and other related factors are captured to better monitor utilization. 56 CorporateWellnessMagazine.com
|
May 2011
Bio Tron Emptage is Chief Clinical and Compliance Officer for Progressive Medical, a leading provider of cost management solutions for the workers’ compensation and auto no-fault industries. Emptage can be reached at tron.emptage@ progressive-medical.com.