The European Security and Defence Union Issue 31

Page 22

THE EUROPEAN – SECURITY AND DEFENCE UNION

Migration: myth and reality by Josep Borrell i Fontelles, Minister of Foreign Affairs, European Union and Cooperation, Madrid

S

ocieties are forged on the basis of major challenges. Europeans, including the Spanish, are today facing an unparalleled challenge. How we manage the phenomenon of migration will to a large extent determine the destiny of Europe, both in the future and the present. If we think about the European elections of May 2019, the truth is that it is not easy to debate with certain political representatives when their narrative on migration is not exactly defined by its intellectual rigour.

Playing with fears Such representatives have managed to establish in the collective imagination a reality that does not exist, and with not inconsiderable success: Orbán has been elected for the third time in Hungary, Zeman for the second time in the Czech Republic, Kaczyński in Poland, AfD in Germany, Salvini in Italy, the threat of Bannon with The Movement and a project for Europe which carries on from Brexit, and the success of Liga Norte in Italy, all attempting to form in this way a large anti-Europe coalition. Fortunately, this is not the case, at least for now, in countries such as Spain, where the issue of migration does not divide society, nor has it given rise to xenophobic political parties. These politicians deal in terms of perception, and not an accurate analysis of reality. They play with fears that are capable of concealing truths. On 13 April 2018, the European Commission published the results of the Special Eurobarometer 469 survey on the “Integration of immigrants in the European Union”. According to the results, only a minority (37%) of Europeans believe that they are well informed on issues related to immigration and inte-

22

photo: © UNHCR/Markel Redondo

Playing with fears can conceal truths

gration. The survey respondents also tend to overestimate the number of non-EU immigrants: in 19 of the 28 Member States, the estimated proportion of immigrants in the population is at least double the actual proportion, and in some countries the ratio is much higher. As George Orwell reminded us, our first duty in the face of threats to liberal democracies is to preserve the integrity of political language. Conversely, the first task that enemies of plural and open societies such as ours undertake is to pervert that same language. This has also happened with the issue of migration. But let us not confuse eye-catching headlines with reality. A misdiagnosis will lead us to an inappropriate response. The spikes in arrivals on Spanish, Greek and Italian coasts are not sporadic events, but form part of a recurrent and structural phenomenon.

Causes underlying migration It is a panorama of poverty (36 of the 41 countries from the group with the lowest level of human development are in Africa according to the UNDP’s Human Development Index), problems resulting from climate change (drought, which affects 22% of the population, floods, poor soil quality), lack of peace and security (the number of refugees on the continent, after having declined in 1995-2014, has doubled since 2015 and today there are 6 million African people who comprise 26% of refugees worldwide, and the majority of United Nations peacekeeping missions are in Africa) and unemployment, especially among youth and women. Naturally, the greatest of all the causes underlying migratory flows is the scarcity of economic opportunities to pursue a decent living in the countries of origin. Furthermore, as a result of being a developed economy with an ageing population, the EU has become a world destination for


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook

Articles inside

Patrick Bellouard, Paris Galileo – a European achievement A model for future strategic European projects

5min
pages 60-61

Nicole Robinson, Luxembourg Empowering governments to protect their nations with innovative satellite-based solutions Transforming people’s day-to-day experience

3min
pages 62-64

Dr Valérie Mérindol/ Dr David W. Versailles, Paris Prospective roles for the EDA in the Common Security and Defence Policy Peace demands investments

7min
pages 56-58

Interview with Martin Konertz, Brussels The crucial role of the EDA in coordinating the race for capabilities The basis for progress is mutual confidence

10min
pages 53-55

Michael Gahler MEP, Brussels/Strasbourg Making sense of the EU initiatives on defence A Copernican revolution

6min
pages 48-49

Andy Stirnal, Berlin Putting money where the mouth is The European Defence Fund

6min
pages 51-52

Dr Wolfgang Hellmich MdB, Berlin Our future is Europe New impetus for European defence

2min
page 50

Harald Kujat, Gen (ret), Berlin The end of America’s commitment to protect Europe Trump’s withdrawal from the INF Treaty

7min
pages 45-47

Interview with Ioan M. Paşcu MEP, Brussels/Strasbourg Adapting the EU’s security and defence structures Time for organisational changes

10min
pages 42-44

Andrea Quaden, Iraq How to offer a decent life to refugees From Turkey to Iraq

8min
pages 38-41

Josep Borrell i Fontelles, Madrid Migration: myth and reality How fear can conceal truths

6min
pages 22-23

Interview with Verena Papke, Berlin The Aquarius’ daily work to save people’s lives SOS MEDITERRANEE’s mission will continue

13min
pages 27-31

Documentation UNESCO 2019 Global Education Monitoring Report

3min
page 37

Dina Ionesco and Mariam Traore Chazalnoel, Geneva/New York Environmental migration and displacement A reality of our times

8min
pages 34-36

Dimitris Avramopoulos, Brussels Working together with Africa towards a more stable and prosperous shared neighbourhood A historic opportunity

6min
pages 20-21

Gerald Knaus, Berlin

7min
pages 24-25

1O th anniversary of the magazine

6min
pages 6-7
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.