AnalysisofTheMerchantofVenice
WilliamShakespeare'splay"TheMerchantofVenice"isbasedonasimpleenoughplot,butitgives amorecomplexviewofthecharactersinvolved.Itportrayseachcharactersattitude,opinionsand actionsandshowshowtheyaffecttheothercharacters.
ShylockisperhapsthemostnoteworthycharacterHeiscentredonmostoftheplay'sevents Throughouttheplayheisportrayedasbothavillainandavictimandisusedtoemphasiseanumber oftheplay'sthemessuchasgreed,revenge,prejudiceandracism.
TheplaybeginswithAntonio,themerchantoftheplay'stitle,being...showmorecontent...
Hewasonceevenreferredtoas"thedevil".Thefactthatalloftheplay'scharactersseeShylockasa villainmakesitdifficultforthereadertoseehimasanythingelse.Thoughtheplaydoesshowan apparentchangeinShylockfromvillaintovictimitisstilluncertainwhatheactuallyis.
TherearemanyaspectsthatportrayShylockasavillain.ThefactthathelivesinaChristiansociety, yetstillhehasadeephatredofChristiansandinparticularAntonioisthemostobviousaspect:
"Howlikeafawningpublicanhelooks/Ihate himforheisaChristian"
HishatredforAntonioisshownattheendoftheplaywhenhisintentonAntonio'slifeisshownas wellashisdesireforrevenge:
Atthebeginningoftheplayhisdeviousandcunningsideisportrayedwhenhehideshishatredfor Antoniobehindhisproposedfriendship.Hiscunningsideisagainportrayedattheendoftheplay whenheexpectstobeshownmercybytheChristiansyethehasshownnomercytothem:
"Youtakemyhousewhenyoudonottaketheprop/theydothsustainmyhouse;youtakemylife/ whenyoudonottakethemeanswherebyIlive"
FinallythetreatmenthegiveshisdaughterJessicaportrayshimasavillain.HeforceshisJewish religionuponheryetdoesnot
"Iwillhavemybond"
WhiletherearemanyfundamentalthemesinShakespeare'sTheMerchantofVenice,onlyone seemstodrivetheplaytoitsinevitableconclusion.Thereisaconstantthemeofself–interestversus loveOnthesurface,thisseemstobethedividingfactorsbetweentheChristiansandtheJew Shylockisportrayedtoonlycareaboutmoneyandprofits,whiletheChristiansareshownaspeople whovaluehumanrelationshipsmore.ExamplesofthisthemeareshownthroughShylock's behaviour,themanyweddingsoftheChristiancharacters,andtherelationshipbetweenAntonioand Bassanio.
TheChristiancharactersviewShylockassomeonewhoonlycaresaboutmoneyandbusiness. Shakespeare'sportrayalofShylockisacold–heartedman,whoshowmorecontent
ThisshowsthatsomehumanrelationshipsdoindeedmattertoShylockmorethatmoney.However, ShylockwantsrevengeforthelossofhisdaughterthroughthefulfillmentofthebondIncourt,he isdefeatedbecauseofhisselfishness.Moreover,hisinsistencethathehaveapoundoffleshrather thananyamountofmoneyshowsthatthisresentmentismuchstrongerthanthisgreed.
TheChristiancharactersalsopresentaninconsistentpictureTherearemanylovingrelationshipsin thisplaysuchastheonebetweenBassanioandPortia,JessicaandLorenzo,andGratianoand NerissaWhenonelooksdeeplyintotheserelationships,theywouldseeparallelstotheonesof today.Forinstance,thethreemarriageswillprobablynotlast.Oneofthemainreasonsforthisis becausetheyallgotmarriedtoofast,leavingnotimetorealizethattheyareprobablynotmeantfor eachotherThisisevidentintwo–andpossiblythree–oftherelationshipsGratianoandNerissa getmarriedafterknowingeachotherforonlyseveralhoursandBassanioandPortiagetmarried beforetheygettoknoweachother.JessicaandLorenzo'smarriagemightsplitforotherreasons, suchastheirdifferentreligion.TheseallshowtrueloveinTheMerchantofVenice. WhenwefirstmeetBassanio,heiswithhisgoodfriendAntonioaskingformoney.Antoniohas previouslylentmoneytoBassanioandhehas
...Getmorecontent...
RelationshipsinWilliamShakespeare'sTheMerchantofVenice
'TheMerchantofVenice'isoneofShakespeare'smostpopularplaysandAct1Scene3isakey scene.Therearethreecharactersinvolvedinthesceneandtheseare:Antonio,Bassanioand Shylock.Shakespeareportraystheircharacterseffectivelyaswellasthecontrastingrelationships betweenthemHeusesvariousthemes,hislanguageandstyleandtheplotofthebondtoachieve this.
BeforeIlookatscene3itisimportanttolookatthefirstsceneoftheplay.AtthebeginningofAct 1Scene1Antonio,themerchantofVenice,isportrayedasatroubledman,"Insooth,Iknownot whyIamsosad,"(line1)andacharacterinshowmorecontent
NotonlyhasBassaniosquanderedhisownfortune,hehasborrowedmoneyfromAntoniowhichhe isunabletorepay,"Ioweyoumuch,and,likeawilfulyouth,/ThatwhichIoweislost".This showsthatheisirresponsiblewithmoneyandmaybehedoesnotcareaboutAntonioasmuchashe careabouthim,becauseifhedidhewouldhavemadesurethathepaidhimback.Bassanioargues thatifAntoniowerepreparedtoloanhimyetmoremoney,hecoulduseittomakehisfortuneand repaybothdebtstoAntonio.Shakespeareportrayshimasbeingskilledingettingwhathewants. Bassanioillustratesthis,lines139–51,withtheideaofshootinganarrowinthesamedirectionas onethathadbeenlost,"andbyadventuringboth,Ioftfoundboth"(lines143–4)
AntonioagreestoborrowmoneyinhisnameinordertohelphisfriendBassanioclearhisdebts, "TrywhatmycreditcaninVenicedo".ThisdisplaysAntonio'sgenerouscharacterandconfirms theirclosefriendship,"Mypurse,myperson,myextremestmeans/Lieallunlockedtoyour occasions"However,Antonio'sassertsarenotsecuresoheisalsotakingariskforhisfriend
NowIwillmoveontoAct1Scene3.BassanioandShylockdiscussthetermsoftheloan–3,000 ducatsforthreemonthsIthinkAntoniosendsBassaniotodothisbeforehe
...Getmorecontent...
TheMerchantofVenice
Theplay,¡°TheMerchantofVenice¡±byWilliamShakespearehastwomainsettings.Onesettingis Venice,acitywheremanybusinessmenlive,aplace,fullofunhappyandunkindpeople.Itaworld ofcommercialandlaw.ShakespearehasportrayedVeniceasthe¡°real¡±world.Theothersettingis Belmont,acitywhichhousesarich,happysocietyofbeautifulpeopleBelmontisafairy–tale worldofmusicandlove.Inthisplay,itisevidentthat,goodthingshappeninBelmontandnotso pleasanteventshappeninVenice.
TheplaybeginswithAntonio,arichmerchantofVeniceisdepressed,whichshowsthatmoneyand wealthdidnotbringhappinesstothisman.Shylock,awealthybusinessmanwholivesinVenice isshowmorecontent
AlsothepeopleinVenicemockandlaughatShylockwhenhisdaughterranawaywithhismoney tomarryaChristianSalarinoandSalaniomakefunofhimTheyhadnosympathytowardstheman whohasjustlosthisonlyfamilyandhisvaluablemoney.Maybeheisgreedy,butitwasstillhis moneyandonewouldexpectpeopletofeelsorryforhimbuttheywereevencruelertohimby laughingathislosses.
EventhoughoneshouldfeelsorryforShylock,hehimselfisaverycruelmanHehatesAntonio andallChristiansandwhenhegottheopportunitytotakerevengehewasmorethanpreparedtodo so.HeandAntoniohadacontractwhichstatedthat,ifAntoniowasnotabletopayoffthedebtof threethousandducatsheborrowedfromShylockwithinthreemonths,hewouldhavetopaythe debtbylettingShylockcutapoundoffleshfromhisbodyclosetotheheart.WhenAntonio¡sships werelostandhewasnotabletopayoffthedebt,Shylockwasdelighted.Shylocklikessaying¡°I thankGod,IthankGod.IthanktheegoodTubal:goodnews,goodnews!ha,ha!¡±¡°I¡mamvery gladofit:I¡llplaguehim;I¡lltorturehim:I¡mgladofit¡±Thisshowsthathewasahorrible manLaterwhenhewasofferedthemoney,herefusessayingthathewouldrather
...Getmorecontent...
Inthecomedy,TheMerchantofVenice,therolesandresponsibilitiesofwomenisasignificant socialissueproposedbyShakespeare.Thisthemeiscommunicatedbytheonlythreefemale charactersintheplay:Nerissa,PortiaandJessica.Forexample,inAct4duringthetrialbetween AntonioandShylock,PortiaandNerissadisguisethemselvesasBalthasarandBellariotofreetheir friendHowever,JessicaalsoplaysaminorroleinportrayingtheindependenceofJewishwomenin aChristianandElizabethansociety,bysuccessfullybetrayingherfather,Shylock.Thesecharacters portrayShakespeare'soverallopiniononwomen,aswellasamodernaudience'sviewon Elizabethansocietyinmanysignificantwaysbyaccentuatingthemes,ideasshowmorecontent Theaudience,aswellasBassanio,viewPortiaasabeautiful,immaculate,aristocraticand"fair" lady.HoweverafterAct5,Portiaisnothing,butprejudicialandbigoted,assheisthecauseof Shylock'sdemiseandclaimsthatsheused"my[her]body"topunishBassanioforabusinghergift oflove:thering.Thisisironic,becausePortiainfringesherrelationshipwithBassaniobyinferring shehascommittedanaffair,eventhoughsheherselfaccuseshimofabusingherloveandpowerby losingthering.ThisimpliesthatrelationshipsinElizabethansocietywerecorruptandfake,which allowedmanywomeninparticulartocommitreligiouscrimesagainsttheirhusbands.Furthermore, Shakespeareadditionallyusesthethemeofdeceptiontoconveythatwomenaresuperiortomen. ThisseenwhenPortiatellsNerissathat"I[she]haveworkinhand/Thatyouyetknowof.We'llsee ourhusbands/Beforetheythinkofus"(34),asshewantstohelpBassanioandGratianosave Antonio'slifebydisguising.Ingeneral,manyElizabethanplaywrightssuchasTwelfthNightand TheMerryWivesofWindsor,allowtheaudiencetounderstandthefactthatthepositionofwomen wassuch,sothattheycouldnotbecome"active"(34)insocietyByPortiaandNerissadressingup asBalthasarandBellario,thiswouldgivethemtemporarymasculinityandso,theabilitytodo thingsthatnormalsocialcodeswouldnot,
...Getmorecontent...
English101–210 FinalDraft
BattleoftheDirectorsTheMerchantofVenice,alsoknownas"TheJewofVenice"isadramaplay originallywrittenbyWilliamShakespearein1598.Themajorconflictoccurswhenamannamed Antonio(Venetianmerchant)failstopayoffaloantoagreedyJewishmoneyloanerknownas ShylockwhodemandsapoundoffleshfromAntonioinreturn.Antonioandhisfriendstakea journeythroughfriendship,love,andhatredinanattempttofreehimofhispoundoffleshfate inducedbyShylockImagineyourselfsittinginthemastermindsofdirectorsMichaelRadfordand JohnSichelwhiletheyaredirectingtheiradaptationsoftheplay.Imagineexperiencingtheirunique ideasfirsthandlookingthroughtheirshowmorecontent
Byhavingtheprincetravelaloneitappearsthathehasmoretoofferinthesenseofbraveryand boldnesstoPortiacomparedtowhenhecomeswithhisfriends.TheviewerscouldseethatSichel usestheprinceseekingforloveinsolitudeasasymbolofnobilityandheroicnesstosupportthe character'spersonality.TheaudiencewatchingRadford'sinterpretationmaygivethemtheopinion thathischoicelowerstheprince'sindependencebybringinginunnecessarycharacters.Thischoice doesnotpresentthecharactersverywellwhencomparedtoSichel's.
Analyzingthesamesceneabovebutinadifferentperspectiveitisapparenttotheviewerthatin Sichels'sfilmthesetupofthecasketscanbeseenassymbolictotheprince'sactionsTheprinceis standingbehindthetriangleshapeddisplayofcasketsandasksPortiahowhewillknowifhe choosestherightone,afterherresponsehesays,"someGoddirectmyjudgment..."whilelooking upattheceiling(26:42–26:45)("YouTube–TheMerchantofVenice(1973)Part4of14")The shapeofatrianglestandsformanybeliefsaccordingtomanyancientbeliefs.Thisshapeis associatedwiththenumber3fortherearethreecasketstochoosefrom.Eachcornerissaidto symbolize"TheFather,theSon,andtheHolySpirit";whilethisshapeissaidtorepresentGodthe princeofMoscowlooksuptowardstheceilingas
...Getmorecontent...
TheMerchantofVeniceEssayOutline
Introduction:
Hook:ThethemeisthemainsubjectormessageofastoryItisusedtogivedepthandenhancethe plot.ThethemesofTheMerchantofVeniceareusedthroughoutthestoryoftheplaytomakethe plotmovealongandtoencouragethecharactersintoaction.
Bridge:WhenyoureadTheMerchantofVenicebyWilliamShakespearetherearemanythemes throughouttheplayandmanylessonstobelearned.
MainIdeas:Themostimportantthemesarehatred,mercyandfriendship.Hatredisimportant becauseitcreatesrivalryamongstthecharactersFriendshipmotivatestheherosandallowsfor theretobealogicalconclusionasbothShakespeareandhischaractersworkouttheir prejudices....showmorecontent... Ifhehavetheconditionofasaint
andthecomplexionofadevil,Ihadratherheshouldshrivemethanwiveme"(Act1scene2)
Analysis:Inthisquote,sheissayingthatevenifhewereasaintshewouldnevermarryhimbecause hehasdarkskin
ParagraphConclusion:Shakespeareportrayshatredandandprejudicethroughouttheplayto establishthateveryoneisflawed,andtoshowusthattheseflawscanbeovercomebymoralityand acceptance.
Bodyparagraphtwo:
TopicSentence:Mercyplaysamajorroleinthisplayitshowsustheimportanceofhumanlifeand friendship.
Subpoint#1:ThewholeplayleadsuptothecourtroomscenewhenPortiawastryingtoconvince ShylocktobemercifultowardsAntonio.
Example:"Thequalityofmercyisnotstrained:Itdroppethasthegentlerainfromheaven.Uponthe placebeneath.Itistwiceblessed:Itblessedhimthatgives,andhimthattakes."(Act4scene1)portia
Analysis:inthisquotePortiaistalkingtoShylock,she'saskinghimtospareAntonio'slifeandshe issayingthatmercyismoreimportantthanrevengeandthatmercyisaqualityofGod
Subpoint#2:thedukeshowedmercywhenhepreventedShylock'sexecutionandlethimkeephalf ofhisestate.
Example:"Ipardontheethylifebeforethouaskit"(Act4scene1)Duke
Analysis:TheDukeallowedShylocktolivebecausehefeltsorryforhim
Paragraph
...Getmorecontent...
WilliamShakespeare'sTheMerchantofVeniceisoneofhismostcontroversialplaysforavariety ofreasons.Writteninsixteenth–centuryEngland,whereanti–Semitismwascommonandthe presenceofJewswasnot,theplayposesmanyquestionsconcerningracial,religiousandhuman difference.Theplayisespeciallytrickytoexamineintoday'ssociety,asitsanti–Semiticthemesand languagecanbeuncomfortabletofaceinaworldpost–HolocaustAdditionally,thedepictionofthe relationshipbetweenJewsandChristians,whichhasalwaysbeenanambivalentone,addsavery interestingalbeitdifficultdimensiontothisplay.Ultimately,throughdramaticplotanddistinctive characters,TheMerchantofVeniceexploreswhatitmeanstobeshowmorecontent
OnesideofShylockispreoccupiedbymoneyandcrazedbyrevenge,whiletheotherrepresentsan oldmanwhoeventuallyloseseverythingnearanddeartohim,anoutsiderwhoisspitonbyhis Christianenemiesandmustputupwithbeingcalled"misbeliever,cut–throat,[and]dog"(1.3.107).
UnlikeotherantagonistssuchasDonJohninMuchAdoAboutNothingorAaroninTitus Andronicus,Shylockdoesnotexplicitlynamehimselfasavillainnordoesherelishinhisevil behaviour.Hedoesindeeddisplayvillainouscharacteristics;veryearlyonheadmitsinanasidethat hehatesAntonio"forheisaChristian"(1.3.37),andhisobsessionwithrevengequicklygrowsout ofcontrol.ButwhatiscomplicatedaboutShylock's"evil"isthatitallseemstostemfromthe malevolenceoftheChristians.OnecannotreallyblamehimaboutbeingbitterforthetimesAntonio kickedhimandspit"upon[his]beard"(13113),orthathismoneylendingbusinessisdamagedby Antonio'stendencytolendout"moneygratis"(1.3.39).EventhoughtheChristiansintheplay considerusuryanevilpractice,itistheonlywaythatShylockknowshowtomakealiving,anditis understandablethathewouldbeprotectiveofhisbusinessHeshowshismoretendersideinscenes withdaughter,especiallyin2.4asheleaveshomeandtellshertoshutthedoorafterher,because somethingfirmlysecuredwillremainsafe;"Fastbind,fastfind /Aproverbneverstaleinthrifty mind"
...Getmorecontent...
TheMerchantofVeniceisshowsthedynamicsofloveandtowhatextenthumanswillgotoshow love,theywillusetheirwealthandevenbepreparedtogiveuptheirlifeforthepeopletheylove. BothAntonioandPortialoveBassaniodifferently.PortiaperceivesAntonio'sphileoincompetition withhereros,(bothformsoflovewillbedefinedlater)andthroughouttheplaysheisseentryingto defeatAntonio'sphileoandshedoesthisbysubjugatingAntonio,firstlywithherwealth,sheoffers topayofhisdebttoShylockthreetimesmoretheamounthehadboundhimself,thenshesaveshis lifeandfinallyteachingBassaniothatshecanuseherwomanlypowerstorefusehimthe consummatingpowerinmarriage,throughtheringsagashowmorecontent
Theothertypeofloveisknownaseros,itiswhatmostpeoplerefertowhentheyannouncewitha smile,I'minlove.Thistypeoflovecoverseverythingfromqueasystomachsandwarmfuzzy feelingstostrongsensualpassion"(AShortHandbookonLove)orinotherwordsintimateromantic love.ErosisthelovebetweenPortiaandBassanio.Thewordloveinthispaperwillbesubstituted bythewordsphileoanderostoemphasizethedistinctionswhenaddressingAntonioandBassanio's loveandthelovebetweenPortiaandAntonio.EventhoughthelovebetweenAntonioandBassanio andBassanioarePortiaarecompletelydifferent,howevertheyareincompetitionwitheachother. BassanioisawareofthedepthofAntonio'sphileoforhim,andthereforeexploitsAntonio'slovein exchangeformoney.ThedepthofAntonio'sphileoisnotsuperficial,itrunsdeep,whichsurface whenhetellsBassanio"ifstandasyouyourselfstilldo/Withintheeyeofhonour,beassur'd/My purse,myperson.Myextrememeans/Lieallunlock'dtoyouroccasion"(I.i.136–39).Itisbecauseof thisphileothatAntoniogoesintoabondwithhisJewishenemyShylockwhoreturnforthisfavor ShylockdemandsapoundoffleshshouldhedefaulttheloanagreementInLoveandLikeness WalterFEggersJr.writesthat..."AntoniohastoenlistShylockshelptomakehisgenerosityto Bassaniopossible.Forthefirsttimeintheplay,friendshipisseen
...Getmorecontent...
What'sinaWordPaperTheMerchantofVenus,isaplaywrittenbyWilliamShakespeareandisa majorityofthetimerememberedforitsscenewithShylockandAntonio.Asintricateastheplay woveitself,thewordthatseemedtooccuramajorityofthetime"bonds",hadmultiplemeanings occurringthroughouttheplay.OxfordEnglishDictionary(OED)tellsusthatBondscanmeanthe bondageofamarriage,thewaysofwhichathingisboundortieddown,agreementorengagement bindingtohimofwhichwhomakesit,andadeed,bywhichbindshimself,hisheirs,executors,or assignstopayacertainsumofmoney.Inthisplay,weseeastrongconnectionbetweenbondsand goodsreoccurringfromstarttofinishTheterm"bond",isshowmorecontent
Themanis,notwithstanding,sufficient.Threethousandducats;IthinkImaytakehisbond. Interestedly,insteadofShakespeareusingthewordbondasawaytotiePortiaandBassanioand theirundyingloveandpromises.WefindBassaniodiscoveringoutaboutAntonio'ssituationina lettertellingBassanioabouthislostshipsandShylocksintentionsoftakinghispoundofflesh.The newsincitesasinceofguiltfromBassaniowhichprodsPortiatoofferandpaytwentytimesthe originalsum.AfterreadingtheletteraloudtoPortiashesuggestsBassaniogotohisfriendsaidand gobacktoVenicebyhisside.(3.2.314)
SweetBassanio,myshipshaveallmiscarried,mycreditorsgrowcruel,myestateisverylow,my bondtotheJewisforfeit;andsinceinpayingit,itisimpossibleIshouldlive,alldebtsarecleared betweenyouandI,ifImightbutseeyouatmydeathNotwithstanding,useyourpleasure:ifyour lovedonotpersuadeyoutocome,letnotmyletter.Payhimsixthousand,anddefacethebond (3.2.298)ThissectionisaninstancewerethewordbondastheagreementbetweenShylockis confrontedbyanotherstrongcharacterinthisplayPortiaplayingastrongmasculineroleforher householdandnewhusbandBassanio.Sheshowsherpowerandauthoritybywantingtodefacethe bondandpaymorethantheoriginalsum,tofreeAntonioandhelpoutBassanio.Thisshowsthat eventhoughtheagreementbetweenAntonioand
...Getmorecontent...
ComparisonandContrastofShylockandClaudius
Introduction
ThisessaylooksintothelivesofShylockandAntonio.ThesearetwoofShakespeareanantagonists ofalltime.Theyarealikeinmorewaysthanone.ShylockinMerchantofVeniceisaJewish moneylenderbasedinVeniceHehasbeentormentedandrepressedmainlybytheChristian population.Onefindsiteasytosympathizewithhimmainlybecausehehashisownreasonstobe loathing,greedy,andmiserly.Thisendsupmakingtheentire'MerchantofVenice'bittersweet.This waswhenShylockwasforcedtogiveupallthatheownedandfurtherconvertedittoChristianity ThismeantthatthatJewishcommunitywouldnolongeraccepthim.Italsomeantthathewouldbe shunnedbyshowmorecontent
TheobjectofaffectionasseenisBassaniowhogoesaheadtotakefulladvantageofthismerchant's feelingsforhim(Wright45).
ThemainprinciplesofAntoniodonotsupportborrowingorlendingmoneyforprofitHepurely reflectsamedievalattitudeformoneythatneedstobelentforChristiancharity.Whenhelendsto Bassanio,thismadehimtocastasidehisprinciplesandtakealoanfromShylock.Hethenpledges hisfleshasbond.WhenAntonio'sshipsarelostatsea,thismeantthathecouldnotrepaytheloan andthereforeheacceptstopayShylockwithapoundofhisflesh(Shakespeare61).
ShylockontheotherpointisafocalpointoftheentireplayThereisatraditionalstereotypeofJews foundintheElizabethantimes.Heiscomicallyputoutasagreedyministerwhowearsatraditional Jewishgabardine.Asamiddle–agedman,Shylockhasakeennessofobservation,amemoryof severaldetailsaswellasastrongenergyamountUnlikeAntonio,heisportrayedassomeonewitha strongamountofenergywhoiswellversedwiththeBible.Heoftendrawsanalogiesfromseveral Biblicalstoriesandsources.Thesearerelevanttosituationswherebyhefindshimselfin. WhenShylockspeaks,hespeaksinamannerthatrevealsauthoritativeness.Hemakesfrequent referencestoancientandgreatnamesfromthescriptures.Hethenusesthesewhenjustifyinghis ownbadpracticesHisspeechfurtherrevealsa
...Getmorecontent...