äžæ£ç«¶äºé²æ¢æ³ ïŒå¹³æäºå¹Žäºæåä¹æ¥æ³åŸç¬¬ååäžå·ïŒ
ïŒç®çïŒ ç¬¬äžæ¡ ãã®æ³åŸã¯ãäºæ¥è éã®å ¬æ£ãªç«¶äºåã³ããã«é¢ããåœéçŽæã®ç確ãªå®æœã 確ä¿ãããããäžæ£ç«¶äºã®é²æ¢åã³äžæ£ç«¶äºã«ä¿ãæå®³è³ åã«é¢ããæªçœ®çãè¬ãã ãã£ãŠåœæ°çµæžã®å¥å šãªçºå±ã«å¯äžããããšãç®çãšããã ïŒå®çŸ©ïŒ 第äºæ¡ ãã®æ³åŸã«ãããŠãäžæ£ç«¶äºããšã¯ã次ã«æ²ãããã®ãããã äž ä»äººã®ååç衚瀺ïŒäººã®æ¥åã«ä¿ãæ°åãåå·ãåæšãæšç« ãååã®å®¹åšè¥ãã ã¯å è£ ãã®ä»ã®åååã¯å¶æ¥ã衚瀺ãããã®ãããã以äžåããïŒãšããŠéèŠè ã® éã«åºãèªèãããŠãããã®ãšåäžè¥ããã¯é¡äŒŒã®ååç衚瀺ã䜿çšããåã¯ãã® ååç衚瀺ã䜿çšããååãè²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€º ãã茞åºããèŒžå ¥ããè¥ããã¯é»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæäŸããŠãä»äººã®åååã¯å¶ æ¥ãšæ··åãçããããè¡çº äº èªå·±ã®ååç衚瀺ãšããŠä»äººã®èåãªååç衚瀺ãšåäžè¥ããã¯é¡äŒŒã®ãã®ã䜿 çšããåã¯ãã®ååç衚瀺ã䜿çšããååãè²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããèŒžå ¥ããè¥ããã¯é»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæäŸããè¡çº äž ä»äººã®ååã®åœ¢æ ïŒåœè©²ååã®æ©èœã確ä¿ããããã«äžå¯æ¬ ãªåœ¢æ ãé€ããïŒã æš¡å£ããååãè²æž¡ãã貞ãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯è²žæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºãã åã¯èŒžå ¥ããè¡çº å çªåãè©æ¬ºã匷迫ãã®ä»ã®äžæ£ã®æ段ã«ããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ãååŸããè¡çºïŒä»¥äžãäž æ£ååŸè¡çºããšãããïŒåã¯äžæ£ååŸè¡çºã«ããååŸããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ã䜿çšããè¥ã ãã¯é瀺ããè¡çºïŒç§å¯ãä¿æãã€ã€ç¹å®ã®è ã«ç€ºãããšãå«ãã以äžåããïŒ äº ãã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã«ã€ããŠäžæ£ååŸè¡çºãä»åšããããšãç¥ã£ãŠãè¥ããã¯é倧ãªé 倱ã«ããç¥ããªãã§å¶æ¥ç§å¯ãååŸããåã¯ãã®ååŸããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ã䜿çšããè¥ã ãã¯é瀺ããè¡çº å ãã®ååŸããåŸã«ãã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã«ã€ããŠäžæ£ååŸè¡çºãä»åšããããšãç¥ã£ãŠã åã¯é倧ãªé倱ã«ããç¥ããªãã§ãã®ååŸããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ã䜿çšããåã¯é瀺ããè¡ çº äž å¶æ¥ç§å¯ãä¿æããäºæ¥è ïŒä»¥äžãä¿æè ããšãããïŒãããã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã瀺ã ããå Žåã«ãããŠãäžæ£ã®ç«¶æ¥ãã®ä»ã®äžæ£ã®å©çãåŸãç®çã§ãåã¯ãã®ä¿æè ã«æ害ãå ããç®çã§ããã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã䜿çšããåã¯é瀺ããè¡çº å « ãã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã«ã€ããŠäžæ£é瀺è¡çºïŒåå·ã«èŠå®ããå Žåã«ãããŠåå·ã«èŠå®ã ãç®çã§ãã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ãé瀺ããè¡çºåã¯ç§å¯ãå®ãæ³åŸäžã®çŸ©åã«éåããŠãã® å¶æ¥ç§å¯ãé瀺ããè¡çºãããã以äžåããïŒã§ããããšè¥ããã¯ãã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã« ã€ããŠäžæ£é瀺è¡çºãä»åšããããšãç¥ã£ãŠãè¥ããã¯é倧ãªé倱ã«ããç¥ããªã 1
ã§å¶æ¥ç§å¯ãååŸããåã¯ãã®ååŸããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ã䜿çšããè¥ããã¯é瀺ããè¡çº ä¹ ãã®ååŸããåŸã«ãã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã«ã€ããŠäžæ£é瀺è¡çºããã£ãããšè¥ããã¯ãã® å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã«ã€ããŠäžæ£é瀺è¡çºãä»åšããããšãç¥ã£ãŠãåã¯é倧ãªé倱ã«ããç¥ ããªãã§ãã®ååŸããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ã䜿çšããåã¯é瀺ããè¡çº å å¶æ¥äžçšããããŠããæè¡çå¶éæ段ïŒä»äººãç¹å®ã®è 以å€ã®è ã«åœ±åè¥ãã㯠é³ã®èŠèŽè¥ããã¯ããã°ã©ã ã®å®è¡åã¯åœ±åãé³è¥ããã¯ããã°ã©ã ã®èšé²ããã ãªãããã«çšããŠãããã®ãé€ããïŒã«ããå¶éãããŠãã圱åè¥ããã¯é³ã®èŠèŽ è¥ããã¯ããã°ã©ã ã®å®è¡åã¯åœ±åãé³è¥ããã¯ããã°ã©ã ã®èšé²ãåœè©²æè¡çå¶ éæ段ã®å¹æã劚ããããšã«ããå¯èœãšããæ©èœã®ã¿ãæããè£ çœ®ïŒåœè©²è£ 眮ãçµ ã¿èŸŒãã æ©åšãå«ããïŒè¥ããã¯åœè©²æ©èœã®ã¿ãæããããã°ã©ã ïŒåœè©²ããã°ã© ã ãä»ã®ããã°ã©ã ãšçµã¿åãããããã®ãå«ããïŒãèšé²ããèšé²åªäœè¥ãã㯠èšæ¶ããæ©åšãè²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºãã è¥ããã¯èŒžå ¥ããåã¯åœè©²æ©èœã®ã¿ãæããããã°ã©ã ãé»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæ äŸããè¡çº åäž ä»äººãç¹å®ã®è 以å€ã®è ã«åœ±åè¥ããã¯é³ã®èŠèŽè¥ããã¯ããã°ã©ã ã®å®è¡å ã¯åœ±åãé³è¥ããã¯ããã°ã©ã ã®èšé²ããããªãããã«å¶æ¥äžçšããŠããæè¡çå¶ éæ段ã«ããå¶éãããŠãã圱åè¥ããã¯é³ã®èŠèŽè¥ããã¯ããã°ã©ã ã®å®è¡å㯠圱åãé³è¥ããã¯ããã°ã©ã ã®èšé²ãåœè©²æè¡çå¶éæ段ã®å¹æã劚ããããšã«ã ãå¯èœãšããæ©èœã®ã¿ãæããè£ çœ®ïŒåœè©²è£ 眮ãçµã¿èŸŒãã æ©åšãå«ããïŒè¥ãã ã¯åœè©²æ©èœã®ã¿ãæããããã°ã©ã ïŒåœè©²ããã°ã©ã ãä»ã®ããã°ã©ã ãšçµã¿åã ããããã®ãå«ããïŒãèšé²ããèšé²åªäœè¥ããã¯èšæ¶ããæ©åšãåœè©²ç¹å®ã®è 以 å€ã®è ã«è²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããè¥ãã ã¯èŒžå ¥ããåã¯åœè©²æ©èœã®ã¿ãæããããã°ã©ã ãé»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæäŸãã è¡çº åäº äžæ£ã®å©çãåŸãç®çã§ãåã¯ä»äººã«æ害ãå ããç®çã§ãä»äººã®ç¹å®ååç 衚瀺ïŒäººã®æ¥åã«ä¿ãæ°åãåå·ãåæšãæšç« ãã®ä»ã®åååã¯åœ¹åã衚瀺ããã ã®ããããïŒãšåäžè¥ããã¯é¡äŒŒã®ãã¡ã€ã³åã䜿çšããæš©å©ãååŸããè¥ãã㯠ä¿æããåã¯ãã®ãã¡ã€ã³åã䜿çšããè¡çº åäž ååè¥ããã¯åœ¹åè¥ããã¯ãã®åºåè¥ããã¯ååŒã«çšããæžé¡è¥ããã¯éä¿¡ã« ãã®ååã®åç£å°ãå質ãå 容ã補é æ¹æ³ãçšéè¥ããã¯æ°éè¥ããã¯ãã®åœ¹å㮠質ãå 容ãçšéè¥ããã¯æ°éã«ã€ããŠèª€èªããããããªè¡šç€ºãããåã¯ãã®è¡šç€ºã ããååãè²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããèŒžå ¥ ããè¥ããã¯é»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæäŸããè¥ããã¯ãã®è¡šç€ºãããŠåœ¹åãæäŸã ãè¡çº åå 競äºé¢ä¿ã«ããä»äººã®å¶æ¥äžã®ä¿¡çšã害ããèåœã®äºå®ãåç¥ããåã¯æµåžã ãè¡çº åäº ããªæ¡çŽïŒåæšæ³ïŒæåäžåå幎æ³åŸç¬¬çŸäºåäžå·ïŒç¬¬åæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äºå·ã«èŠ å®ããããªæ¡çŽããããïŒã®åçåœãäžç貿ææ©é¢ã®å çåœåã¯åæšæ³æ¡çŽã®ç· çŽ åœã«ãããŠåæšã«é¢ããæš©å©ïŒåæšæš©ã«çžåœããæš©å©ã«éãã以äžãã®å·ã«ãã㊠åã«ãæš©å©ããšãããïŒãæããè ã®ä»£ç人è¥ããã¯ä»£è¡šè åã¯ãã®è¡çºã®æ¥åäž 2
幎以å ã«ä»£ç人è¥ããã¯ä»£è¡šè ã§ãã£ãè ããæ£åœãªçç±ããªãã®ã«ããã®æš©å©ã æããè ã®æ¿è«ŸãåŸãªãã§ãã®æš©å©ã«ä¿ãåæšãšåäžè¥ããã¯é¡äŒŒã®åæšããã®æš© å©ã«ä¿ãååè¥ããã¯åœ¹åãšåäžè¥ããã¯é¡äŒŒã®ååè¥ããã¯åœ¹åã«äœ¿çšããå㯠åœè©²åæšã䜿çšãããã®æš©å©ã«ä¿ãååãšåäžè¥ããã¯é¡äŒŒã®ååãè²æž¡ããåŒã æž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããèŒžå ¥ããè¥ããã¯é»æ°éä¿¡å ç·ãéããŠæäŸããè¥ããã¯åœè©²åæšã䜿çšããŠãã®æš©å©ã«ä¿ã圹åãšåäžè¥ãã ã¯é¡äŒŒã®åœ¹åãæäŸããè¡çº ïŒ ãã®æ³åŸã«ãããŠãåæšããšã¯ãåæšæ³ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé ã«èŠå®ããåæšãããã ïŒ ãã®æ³åŸã«ãããŠãæšç« ããšã¯ãåæšæ³ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé ã«èŠå®ããæšç« ãããã ïŒ ãã®æ³åŸã«ãããŠãååã®åœ¢æ ããšã¯ãéèŠè ãéåžžã®çšæ³ã«åŸã£ã䜿çšã«éã㊠ç¥èŠã«ãã£ãŠèªèããããšãã§ããååã®å€éšåã³å éšã®åœ¢ç¶äžŠã³ã«ãã®åœ¢ç¶ã«çµå ããæš¡æ§ãè²åœ©ãå æ²¢åã³è³ªæãããã ïŒ ãã®æ³åŸã«ãããŠãæš¡å£ããããšã¯ãä»äººã®ååã®åœ¢æ ã«äŸæ ããŠããããšå®è³ªç ã«åäžã®åœ¢æ ã®ååãäœãåºãããšãããã ïŒ ãã®æ³åŸã«ãããŠãå¶æ¥ç§å¯ããšã¯ãç§å¯ãšããŠç®¡çãããŠããçç£æ¹æ³ãè²©å£²æ¹ æ³ãã®ä»ã®äºæ¥æŽ»åã«æçšãªæè¡äžåã¯å¶æ¥äžã®æ å ±ã§ãã£ãŠãå ¬ç¶ãšç¥ãããŠã㪠ããã®ãããã ïŒ ãã®æ³åŸã«ãããŠãæè¡çå¶éæ段ããšã¯ãé»ç£çæ¹æ³ïŒé»åçæ¹æ³ãç£æ°çæ¹æ³ ãã®ä»ã®äººã®ç¥èŠã«ãã£ãŠèªèããããšãã§ããªãæ¹æ³ããããïŒã«ãã圱åè¥ãã ã¯é³ã®èŠèŽè¥ããã¯ããã°ã©ã ã®å®è¡åã¯åœ±åãé³è¥ããã¯ããã°ã©ã ã®èšé²ãå¶é ããæ段ã§ãã£ãŠãèŠèŽçæ©åšïŒåœ±åè¥ããã¯é³ã®èŠèŽè¥ããã¯ããã°ã©ã ã®å®è¡å ã¯åœ±åãé³è¥ããã¯ããã°ã©ã ã®èšé²ã®ããã«çšããããæ©åšãããã以äžåããïŒ ãç¹å®ã®åå¿ãããä¿¡å·ã圱åãé³è¥ããã¯ããã°ã©ã ãšãšãã«èšé²åªäœã«èšé²ãã è¥ããã¯éä¿¡ããæ¹åŒåã¯èŠèŽçæ©åšãç¹å®ã®å€æãå¿ èŠãšãããã圱åãé³è¥ãã ã¯ããã°ã©ã ãå€æããŠèšé²åªäœã«èšé²ããè¥ããã¯éä¿¡ããæ¹åŒã«ãããã®ãããã ïŒ ãã®æ³åŸã«ãããŠãããã°ã©ã ããšã¯ãé»åèšç®æ©ã«å¯Ÿããæ什ã§ãã£ãŠãäžã®çµ æãåŸãããšãã§ããããã«çµã¿åãããããã®ãããã ïŒ ãã®æ³åŸã«ãããŠããã¡ã€ã³åããšã¯ãã€ã³ã¿ãŒãããã«ãããŠãåã ã®é»åèšç® æ©ãèå¥ããããã«å²ãåœãŠãããçªå·ãèšå·åã¯æåã®çµåãã«å¯Ÿå¿ããæåãçª å·ãèšå·ãã®ä»ã®ç¬Šå·åã¯ãããã®çµåãããã ïŒïŒ ãã®æ³åŸã«ãããç©ãã«ã¯ãããã°ã©ã ãå«ããã®ãšããã ïŒå·®æ¢è«æ±æš©ïŒ 第äžæ¡ äžæ£ç«¶äºã«ãã£ãŠå¶æ¥äžã®å©çã䟵害ãããåã¯äŸµå®³ãããããããããè ã¯ã ãã®å¶æ¥äžã®å©çã䟵害ããè åã¯äŸµå®³ããããããããè ã«å¯Ÿãããã®äŸµå®³ã®åæ¢ åã¯äºé²ãè«æ±ããããšãã§ããã ïŒ äžæ£ç«¶äºã«ãã£ãŠå¶æ¥äžã®å©çã䟵害ãããåã¯äŸµå®³ãããããããããè ã¯ãå é ã®èŠå®ã«ããè«æ±ãããã«éãã䟵害ã®è¡çºãçµæããç©ïŒäŸµå®³ã®è¡çºã«ããçã ãç©ãå«ãã第äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé ã«ãããŠåããïŒã®å»æ£ã䟵害ã®è¡çºã«äŸããèšåã®é€åŽ ãã®ä»ã®äŸµå®³ã®åæ¢åã¯äºé²ã«å¿ èŠãªè¡çºãè«æ±ããããšãã§ããã 3
ïŒæå®³è³ åïŒ ç¬¬åæ¡ æ æåã¯é倱ã«ããäžæ£ç«¶äºãè¡ã£ãŠä»äººã®å¶æ¥äžã®å©çã䟵害ããè ã¯ãã ãã«ãã£ãŠçããæ害ãè³ åãã責ãã«ä»»ããããã ãã第åäºæ¡ã®èŠå®ã«ããåæ¡ ã«èŠå®ããæš©å©ãæ¶æ» ããåŸã«ãã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã䜿çšããè¡çºã«ãã£ãŠçããæ害ã«ã€ ããŠã¯ããã®éãã§ãªãã ïŒæ害ã®é¡ã®æšå®çïŒ ç¬¬äºæ¡ 第äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ãã第ä¹å·ãŸã§åã¯ç¬¬åäºå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äºïŒåé 第å å·ãã第ä¹å·ãŸã§ã«æ²ãããã®ã«ãã£ãŠã¯ãæè¡äžã®ç§å¯ïŒç§å¯ãšããŠç®¡çãããŠã ãçç£æ¹æ³ãã®ä»ã®äºæ¥æŽ»åã«æçšãªæè¡äžã®æ å ±ã§ãã£ãŠå ¬ç¶ãšç¥ãããŠããªãã ã®ããããïŒã«é¢ãããã®ã«éããïŒã«ãã£ãŠå¶æ¥äžã®å©çã䟵害ãããè ïŒä»¥äžã ã®é ã«ãããŠã被䟵害è ããšãããïŒãæ æåã¯é倱ã«ããèªå·±ã®å¶æ¥äžã®å©çã䟵 害ããè ã«å¯Ÿããã®äŸµå®³ã«ããèªå·±ãåããæ害ã®è³ åãè«æ±ããå Žåã«ãããŠãã ã®è ããã®äŸµå®³ã®è¡çºãçµæããç©ãè²æž¡ãããšãã¯ããã®è²æž¡ããç©ã®æ°éïŒä»¥äž ãã®é ã«ãããŠãè²æž¡æ°éããšãããïŒã«ã被䟵害è ããã®äŸµå®³ã®è¡çºããªããã°è²© 売ããããšãã§ããç©ã®åäœæ°éåœããã®å©çã®é¡ãä¹ããŠåŸãé¡ãã被䟵害è ã®åœ 該ç©ã«ä¿ã販売ãã®ä»ã®è¡çºãè¡ãèœåã«å¿ããé¡ãè¶ ããªãé床ã«ãããŠã被䟵害 è ãåããæ害ã®é¡ãšããããšãã§ããããã ããè²æž¡æ°éã®å šéšåã¯äžéšã«çžåœã ãæ°éã被䟵害è ã販売ããããšãã§ããªããšããäºæ ããããšãã¯ãåœè©²äºæ ã«çž åœããæ°éã«å¿ããé¡ãæ§é€ãããã®ãšããã ïŒ äžæ£ç«¶äºã«ãã£ãŠå¶æ¥äžã®å©çã䟵害ãããè ãæ æåã¯é倱ã«ããèªå·±ã®å¶æ¥äž ã®å©çã䟵害ããè ã«å¯Ÿããã®äŸµå®³ã«ããèªå·±ãåããæ害ã®è³ åãè«æ±ããå Žåã« ãããŠããã®è ããã®äŸµå®³ã®è¡çºã«ããå©çãåããŠãããšãã¯ããã®å©çã®é¡ã¯ã ãã®å¶æ¥äžã®å©çã䟵害ãããè ãåããæ害ã®é¡ãšæšå®ããã ïŒ ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ãã第ä¹å·ãŸã§ã第åäºå·åã¯ç¬¬åäºå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äºã«ã ã£ãŠå¶æ¥äžã®å©çã䟵害ãããè ã¯ãæ æåã¯é倱ã«ããèªå·±ã®å¶æ¥äžã®å©çã䟵害 ããè ã«å¯Ÿãã次ã®åå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äºã®åºåã«å¿ããŠåœè©²åå·ã«å®ããè¡çºã«å¯Ÿ ãåããã¹ãééã®é¡ã«çžåœããé¡ã®ééããèªå·±ãåããæ害ã®é¡ãšããŠãã®è³ å ãè«æ±ããããšãã§ããã äž ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·åã¯ç¬¬äºå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äº åœè©²äŸµå®³ã«ä¿ãååçè¡šç€ºã® äœ¿çš äº ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äº åœè©²äŸµå®³ã«ä¿ãååã®åœ¢æ ã®äœ¿çš äž ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第åå·ãã第ä¹å·ãŸã§ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äº åœè©²äŸµå®³ã«ä¿ãå¶æ¥ç§å¯ ã®äœ¿çš å 第äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第åäºå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äº åœè©²äŸµå®³ã«ä¿ããã¡ã€ã³åã®äœ¿çš äº ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第åäºå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äº åœè©²äŸµå®³ã«ä¿ãåæšã®äœ¿çš ïŒ åé ã®èŠå®ã¯ãåé ã«èŠå®ããéé¡ãè¶ ããæ害ã®è³ åã®è«æ±ã劚ããªãããã®å Ž åã«ãããŠããã®å¶æ¥äžã®å©çã䟵害ããè ã«æ æåã¯é倧ãªé倱ããªãã£ããšãã¯ã è£å€æã¯ãæ害ã®è³ åã®é¡ãå®ããã«ã€ããŠããããåé ããããšãã§ããã 4
ïŒå ·äœçæ æ§ã®æ瀺矩åïŒ ç¬¬å æ¡ äžæ£ç«¶äºã«ããå¶æ¥äžã®å©çã®äŸµå®³ã«ä¿ã蚎èšã«ãããŠãäžæ£ç«¶äºã«ãã£ãŠå¶ æ¥äžã®å©çã䟵害ãããåã¯äŸµå®³ããããããããããšäž»åŒµããè ã䟵害ã®è¡çºãçµ æãããã®ãšããŠäž»åŒµããç©åã¯æ¹æ³ã®å ·äœçæ æ§ãåŠèªãããšãã¯ãçžææ¹ã¯ãèª å·±ã®è¡çºã®å ·äœçæ æ§ãæããã«ããªããã°ãªããªãããã ããçžææ¹ã«ãããŠæã ãã«ããããšãã§ããªãçžåœã®çç±ããããšãã¯ããã®éãã§ãªãã ïŒæžé¡ã®æåºçïŒ ç¬¬äžæ¡ è£å€æã¯ãäžæ£ç«¶äºã«ããå¶æ¥äžã®å©çã®äŸµå®³ã«ä¿ã蚎èšã«ãããŠã¯ãåœäºè ã®ç³ç«ãŠã«ãããåœäºè ã«å¯Ÿããåœè©²äŸµå®³è¡çºã«ã€ããŠç«èšŒãããããåã¯åœè©²äŸµå®³ ã®è¡çºã«ããæ害ã®èšç®ãããããå¿ èŠãªæžé¡ã®æåºãåœããããšãã§ããããã ãã ãã®æžé¡ã®ææè ã«ãããŠãã®æåºãæãããšã«ã€ããŠæ£åœãªçç±ããããšãã¯ãã ã®éãã§ãªãã ïŒ è£å€æã¯ãåé ãã ãæžã«èŠå®ããæ£åœãªçç±ããããã©ããã®å€æãããããå¿ èŠããããšèªãããšãã¯ãæžé¡ã®ææè ã«ãã®æ瀺ããããããšãã§ããããã®å Žå ã«ãããŠã¯ãäœäººãããã®æ瀺ãããæžé¡ã®é瀺ãæ±ããããšãã§ããªãã ïŒ è£å€æã¯ãåé ã®å Žåã«ãããŠã第äžé ãã ãæžã«èŠå®ããæ£åœãªçç±ããããã© ããã«ã€ããŠåé åŸæ®µã®æžé¡ãé瀺ããŠãã®æèŠãèŽãããšãå¿ èŠã§ãããšèªãããš ãã¯ãåœäºè çïŒåœäºè ïŒæ³äººã§ããå Žåã«ãã£ãŠã¯ããã®ä»£è¡šè ïŒåã¯åœäºè ã®ä»£ ç人ïŒèšŽèšä»£ç人åã³è£äœäººãé€ããïŒã䜿çšäººãã®ä»ã®åŸæ¥è ãããã以äžå ããïŒã蚎èšä»£ç人åã¯è£äœäººã«å¯Ÿããåœè©²æžé¡ãé瀺ããããšãã§ããã ïŒ åäžé ã®èŠå®ã¯ãäžæ£ç«¶äºã«ããå¶æ¥äžã®å©çã®äŸµå®³ã«ä¿ã蚎èšã«ãããåœè©²äŸµå®³ è¡çºã«ã€ããŠç«èšŒããããå¿ èŠãªæ€èšŒã®ç®çã®æ瀺ã«ã€ããŠæºçšããã ïŒæ害èšç®ã®ããã®éå®ïŒ ç¬¬å «æ¡ äžæ£ç«¶äºã«ããå¶æ¥äžã®å©çã®äŸµå®³ã«ä¿ã蚎èšã«ãããŠãåœäºè ã®ç³ç«ãŠã«ã ããè£å€æãåœè©²äŸµå®³ã®è¡çºã«ããæ害ã®èšç®ãããããå¿ èŠãªäºé ã«ã€ããŠéå®ã åœãããšãã¯ãåœäºè ã¯ãéå®äººã«å¯Ÿããåœè©²éå®ãããããå¿ èŠãªäºé ã«ã€ããŠèª¬ æããªããã°ãªããªãã ïŒçžåœãªæ害é¡ã®èªå®ïŒ 第ä¹æ¡ äžæ£ç«¶äºã«ããå¶æ¥äžã®å©çã®äŸµå®³ã«ä¿ã蚎èšã«ãããŠãæ害ãçããããšã èªããããå Žåã«ãããŠãæ害é¡ãç«èšŒããããã«å¿ èŠãªäºå®ãç«èšŒããããšãåœè©² äºå®ã®æ§è³ªäžæ¥µããŠå°é£ã§ãããšãã¯ãè£å€æã¯ãå£é åŒè«ã®å šè¶£æšåã³èšŒæ 調ã¹ã® çµæã«åºã¥ããçžåœãªæ害é¡ãèªå®ããããšãã§ããã ïŒç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ïŒ 第åæ¡ è£å€æã¯ãäžæ£ç«¶äºã«ããå¶æ¥äžã®å©çã®äŸµå®³ã«ä¿ã蚎èšã«ãããŠããã®åœäº è ãä¿æããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ã«ã€ããŠã次ã«æ²ããäºç±ã®ãããã«ã該åœããããšã«ã€ãç 5
æããã£ãå Žåã«ã¯ãåœäºè ã®ç³ç«ãŠã«ããã決å®ã§ãåœäºè çã蚎èšä»£ç人åã¯è£ äœäººã«å¯Ÿããåœè©²å¶æ¥ç§å¯ãåœè©²èšŽèšã®è¿œè¡ã®ç®ç以å€ã®ç®çã§äœ¿çšããåã¯åœè©²å¶ æ¥ç§å¯ã«ä¿ããã®é ã®èŠå®ã«ããåœä»€ãåããè 以å€ã®è ã«é瀺ããŠã¯ãªããªãæšã åœããããšãã§ããããã ãããã®ç³ç«ãŠã®æãŸã§ã«åœäºè çã蚎èšä»£ç人åã¯è£äœ 人ã第äžå·ã«èŠå®ããæºåæžé¢ã®é²èªåã¯åå·ã«èŠå®ãã蚌æ ã®å調ã¹è¥ããã¯é瀺 以å€ã®æ¹æ³ã«ããåœè©²å¶æ¥ç§å¯ãååŸããåã¯ä¿æããŠããå Žåã¯ããã®éãã§ãªãã äž æ¢ã«æåºããè¥ããã¯æåºãããã¹ãæºåæžé¢ã«åœäºè ã®ä¿æããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ãèš èŒãããåã¯æ¢ã«åã調ã¹ããè¥ããã¯åã調ã¹ãããã¹ã蚌æ ïŒç¬¬äžæ¡ç¬¬äžé ã® èŠå®ã«ããé瀺ãããæžé¡åã¯ç¬¬åäžæ¡ç¬¬åé ã®èŠå®ã«ããé瀺ãããæžé¢ãå« ããïŒã®å 容ã«åœäºè ã®ä¿æããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ãå«ãŸããããšã äº åå·ã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ãåœè©²èšŽèšã®è¿œè¡ã®ç®ç以å€ã®ç®çã§äœ¿çšãããåã¯åœè©²å¶æ¥ç§ å¯ãé瀺ãããããšã«ãããåœè©²å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã«åºã¥ãåœäºè ã®äºæ¥æŽ»åã«æ¯éãçã ãããããããããããé²æ¢ããããåœè©²å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã®äœ¿çšåã¯é瀺ãå¶éããå¿ èŠ ãããããšã ïŒ åé ã®èŠå®ã«ããåœä»€ïŒä»¥äžãç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ããšãããïŒã®ç³ç«ãŠã¯ã次ã«æ²ãã äºé ãèšèŒããæžé¢ã§ããªããã°ãªããªãã äž ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ãåããã¹ãè äº ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ã®å¯Ÿè±¡ãšãªãã¹ãå¶æ¥ç§å¯ãç¹å®ããã«è¶³ããäºå® äž åé åå·ã«æ²ããäºç±ã«è©²åœããäºå® ïŒ ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ãçºããããå Žåã«ã¯ããã®æ±ºå®æžãç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ãåããè ã«éé ããªããã°ãªããªãã ïŒ ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ã¯ãç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ãåããè ã«å¯Ÿãã決å®æžã®ééããããæããã å¹åãçããã ïŒ ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ã®ç³ç«ãŠãåŽäžããè£å€ã«å¯ŸããŠã¯ãå³ææåãããããšãã§ããã ïŒç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ã®åæ¶ãïŒ ç¬¬åäžæ¡ ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ã®ç³ç«ãŠãããè åã¯ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ãåããè ã¯ã蚎èšèšé²ã® åããè£å€æïŒèšŽèšèšé²ã®åããè£å€æããªãå Žåã«ãã£ãŠã¯ãç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ãçºã ãè£å€æïŒã«å¯Ÿããåæ¡ç¬¬äžé ã«èŠå®ããèŠä»¶ãæ¬ ãããšåã¯ãããæ¬ ãã«è³ã£ãã ãšãçç±ãšããŠãç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ã®åæ¶ãã®ç³ç«ãŠãããããšãã§ããã ïŒ ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ã®åæ¶ãã®ç³ç«ãŠã«ã€ããŠã®è£å€ããã£ãå Žåã«ã¯ããã®æ±ºå®æžãã ã®ç³ç«ãŠãããè åã³çžææ¹ã«ééããªããã°ãªããªãã ïŒ ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ã®åæ¶ãã®ç³ç«ãŠã«ã€ããŠã®è£å€ã«å¯ŸããŠã¯ãå³ææåãããããšã ã§ããã ïŒ ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ãåãæ¶ãè£å€ã¯ã確å®ããªããã°ãã®å¹åãçããªãã ïŒ è£å€æã¯ãç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ãåãæ¶ãè£å€ãããå Žåã«ãããŠãç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ã®åæ¶ ãã®ç³ç«ãŠãããè åã¯çžææ¹ä»¥å€ã«åœè©²ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ãçºãããã蚎èšã«ãããŠåœ 該å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã«ä¿ãç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ãåããŠããè ããããšãã¯ããã®è ã«å¯ŸããçŽã¡ã«ã ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ãåãæ¶ãè£å€ãããæšãéç¥ããªããã°ãªããªãã
6
ïŒèšŽèšèšé²ã®é²èŠ§çã®è«æ±ã®éç¥çïŒ ç¬¬åäºæ¡ ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ãçºãããã蚎èšïŒãã¹ãŠã®ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ãåãæ¶ãããèšŽèš ãé€ããïŒã«ä¿ã蚎èšèšé²ã«ã€ããæ°äºèšŽèšæ³ïŒå¹³æå «å¹Žæ³åŸç¬¬çŸä¹å·ïŒç¬¬ä¹åäºæ¡ 第äžé ã®æ±ºå®ããã£ãå Žåã«ãããŠãåœäºè ããåé ã«èŠå®ããç§å¯èšèŒéšåã®é²èŠ§ çã®è«æ±ãããããã€ããã®è«æ±ã®æç¶ãè¡ã£ãè ãåœè©²èšŽèšã«ãããŠç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ ãåããŠããªãè ã§ãããšãã¯ãè£å€ææžèšå®ã¯ãåé ã®ç³ç«ãŠãããåœäºè ïŒãã® è«æ±ãããè ãé€ãã第äžé ã«ãããŠåããïŒã«å¯Ÿãããã®è«æ±åŸçŽã¡ã«ããã®è«æ± ããã£ãæšãéç¥ããªããã°ãªããªãã ïŒ åé ã®å Žåã«ãããŠãè£å€ææžèšå®ã¯ãåé ã®è«æ±ããã£ãæ¥ããäºé±éãçµéã ãæ¥ãŸã§ã®éïŒãã®è«æ±ã®æç¶ãè¡ã£ãè ã«å¯Ÿããç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ã®ç³ç«ãŠããã®æ¥ãŸ ã§ã«ãããå Žåã«ãã£ãŠã¯ããã®ç³ç«ãŠã«ã€ããŠã®è£å€ã確å®ãããŸã§ã®éïŒããã® è«æ±ã®æç¶ãè¡ã£ãè ã«åé ã®ç§å¯èšèŒéšåã®é²èŠ§çããããŠã¯ãªããªãã ïŒ åäºé ã®èŠå®ã¯ã第äžé ã®è«æ±ãããè ã«åé ã®ç§å¯èšèŒéšåã®é²èŠ§çããããã ãšã«ã€ããŠæ°äºèšŽèšæ³ç¬¬ä¹åäºæ¡ç¬¬äžé ã®ç³ç«ãŠãããåœäºè ã®ãã¹ãŠã®åæããã ãšãã¯ãé©çšããªãã ïŒåœäºè å°åçã®å ¬éåæ¢ïŒ 第åäžæ¡ äžæ£ç«¶äºã«ããå¶æ¥äžã®å©çã®äŸµå®³ã«ä¿ã蚎èšã«ãããåœäºè çãããã®äŸµ 害ã®æç¡ã«ã€ããŠã®å€æã®åºç€ãšãªãäºé ã§ãã£ãŠåœäºè ã®ä¿æããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ã«è©²åœ ãããã®ã«ã€ããŠãåœäºè æ¬äººè¥ããã¯æ³å®ä»£ç人åã¯èšŒäººãšããŠå°åãåããå Žå ã«ãããŠã¯ãè£å€æã¯ãè£å€å®ã®å šå¡äžèŽã«ããããã®åœäºè çãå ¬éã®æ³å»·ã§åœè©² äºé ã«ã€ããŠé³è¿°ãããããšã«ããåœè©²å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã«åºã¥ãåœäºè ã®äºæ¥æŽ»åã«èãã æ¯éãçããããšãæããã§ããããšããåœè©²äºé ã«ã€ããŠååãªé³è¿°ãããããšã ã§ããããã€ãåœè©²é³è¿°ãæ¬ ãããšã«ããä»ã®èšŒæ ã®ã¿ã«ãã£ãŠã¯åœè©²äºé ãå€æã® åºç€ãšãã¹ãäžæ£ç«¶äºã«ããå¶æ¥äžã®å©çã®äŸµå®³ã®æç¡ã«ã€ããŠã®é©æ£ãªè£å€ããã ããšãã§ããªããšèªãããšãã¯ã決å®ã§ãåœè©²äºé ã®å°åãå ¬éããªãã§è¡ãããšã ã§ããã ïŒ è£å€æã¯ãåé ã®æ±ºå®ãããã«åœãã£ãŠã¯ãããããããåœäºè çã®æèŠãèŽã㪠ããã°ãªããªãã ïŒ è£å€æã¯ãåé ã®å Žåã«ãããŠãå¿ èŠããããšèªãããšãã¯ãåœäºè çã«ãã®é³è¿° ãã¹ãäºé ã®èŠé ãèšèŒããæžé¢ã®æ瀺ããããããšãã§ããããã®å Žåã«ãããŠã¯ã äœäººãããã®æ瀺ãããæžé¢ã®é瀺ãæ±ããããšãã§ããªãã ïŒ è£å€æã¯ãåé åŸæ®µã®æžé¢ãé瀺ããŠãã®æèŠãèŽãããšãå¿ èŠã§ãããšèªãããš ãã¯ãåœäºè çã蚎èšä»£ç人åã¯è£äœäººã«å¯Ÿããåœè©²æžé¢ãé瀺ããããšãã§ããã ïŒ è£å€æã¯ã第äžé ã®èŠå®ã«ããåœè©²äºé ã®å°åãå ¬éããªãã§è¡ããšãã¯ãå ¬è¡ã éå»·ãããåã«ããã®æšãçç±ãšãšãã«èšãæž¡ããªããã°ãªããªããåœè©²äºé ã®å°å ãçµäºãããšãã¯ãåã³å ¬è¡ãå ¥å»·ãããªããã°ãªããªãã ïŒä¿¡çšå埩ã®æªçœ®ïŒ 第ååæ¡ æ æåã¯é倱ã«ããäžæ£ç«¶äºãè¡ã£ãŠä»äººã®å¶æ¥äžã®ä¿¡çšã害ããè ã«å¯Ÿã 7
ãŠã¯ãè£å€æã¯ããã®å¶æ¥äžã®ä¿¡çšã害ãããè ã®è«æ±ã«ãããæ害ã®è³ åã«ä»£ãã åã¯æ害ã®è³ åãšãšãã«ããã®è ã®å¶æ¥äžã®ä¿¡çšãå埩ããã®ã«å¿ èŠãªæªçœ®ãåœãã ããšãã§ããã ïŒæ¶æ» æå¹ïŒ 第åäºæ¡ 第äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第åå·ãã第ä¹å·ãŸã§ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äºã®ãã¡ãå¶æ¥ç§å¯ã䜿 çšããè¡çºã«å¯Ÿãã第äžæ¡ç¬¬äžé ã®èŠå®ã«ãã䟵害ã®åæ¢åã¯äºé²ãè«æ±ããæš©å©ã¯ã ãã®è¡çºãè¡ãè ããã®è¡çºãç¶ç¶ããå Žåã«ãããŠããã®è¡çºã«ããå¶æ¥äžã®å©ç ã䟵害ãããåã¯äŸµå®³ãããããããããä¿æè ããã®äºå®åã³ãã®è¡çºãè¡ãè ã ç¥ã£ãæããäžå¹Žéè¡ããªããšãã¯ãæå¹ã«ãã£ãŠæ¶æ» ããããã®è¡çºã®éå§ã®æã ãå幎ãçµéãããšãããåæ§ãšããã ïŒå€åœã®åœæçã®åæ¥äžã®äœ¿çšçŠæ¢ïŒ 第åå æ¡ äœäººããå€åœã®åœæè¥ããã¯åœã®çŽç« ãã®ä»ã®èšç« ã§ãã£ãŠçµæžç£æ¥ç什㧠å®ãããã®ïŒä»¥äžãå€åœåœæçããšãããïŒãšåäžè¥ããã¯é¡äŒŒã®ãã®ïŒä»¥äžãå€åœ åœæçé¡äŒŒèšç« ããšãããïŒãåæšãšããŠäœ¿çšããåã¯å€åœåœæçé¡äŒŒèšç« ãåæšãš ããŠäœ¿çšããååãè²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºãã èŒžå ¥ããè¥ããã¯é»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæäŸããè¥ããã¯å€åœåœæçé¡äŒŒèšç« ãåæš ãšããŠäœ¿çšããŠåœ¹åãæäŸããŠã¯ãªããªãããã ãããã®å€åœåœæçã®äœ¿çšã®èš±å¯ ïŒèš±å¯ã«é¡ããè¡æ¿åŠåãå«ãã以äžåããïŒãè¡ãæš©éãæããå€åœã®å®åºã®èš±å¯ ãåãããšãã¯ããã®éãã§ãªãã ïŒ åé ã«èŠå®ãããã®ã®ã»ããäœäººããååã®åç£å°ã誀èªããããããªæ¹æ³ã§ãå é ã®çµæžç£æ¥ç什ã§å®ããå€åœã®åœã®çŽç« ïŒä»¥äžãå€åœçŽç« ããšãããïŒã䜿çšãã åã¯å€åœçŽç« ã䜿çšããååãè²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€º ãã茞åºããèŒžå ¥ããè¥ããã¯é»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæäŸããè¥ããã¯å€åœçŽç« ã䜿 çšããŠåœ¹åãæäŸããŠã¯ãªããªãããã ãããã®å€åœçŽç« ã®äœ¿çšã®èš±å¯ãè¡ãæš©éã æããå€åœã®å®åºã®èš±å¯ãåãããšãã¯ããã®éãã§ãªãã ïŒ äœäººããå€åœã®æ¿åºè¥ããã¯å°æ¹å ¬å ±å£äœã®ç£ç£çšè¥ããã¯èšŒæçšã®å°ç« è¥ãã㯠èšå·ã§ãã£ãŠçµæžç£æ¥ç什ã§å®ãããã®ïŒä»¥äžãå€åœæ¿åºçèšå·ããšãããïŒãšåäž è¥ããã¯é¡äŒŒã®ãã®ïŒä»¥äžãå€åœæ¿åºçé¡äŒŒèšå·ããšãããïŒããã®å€åœæ¿åºçèšå· ãçšããããŠããååè¥ããã¯åœ¹åãšåäžè¥ããã¯é¡äŒŒã®ååè¥ããã¯åœ¹åã®åæšãš ããŠäœ¿çšããåã¯å€åœæ¿åºçé¡äŒŒèšå·ãåœè©²åæšãšããŠäœ¿çšããååãè²æž¡ããåŒã æž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããèŒžå ¥ããè¥ããã¯é»æ°éä¿¡åç· ãéããŠæäŸããè¥ããã¯å€åœæ¿åºçé¡äŒŒèšå·ãåœè©²åæšãšããŠäœ¿çšããŠåœ¹åãæäŸ ããŠã¯ãªããªãããã ãããã®å€åœæ¿åºçèšå·ã®äœ¿çšã®èš±å¯ãè¡ãæš©éãæããå€åœ ã®å®åºã®èš±å¯ãåãããšãã¯ããã®éãã§ãªãã ïŒåœéæ©é¢ã®æšç« ã®åæ¥äžã®äœ¿çšçŠæ¢ïŒ 第åäžæ¡ äœäººãããã®åœéæ©é¢ïŒæ¿åºéã®åœéæ©é¢åã³ããã«æºãããã®ãšããŠçµæž ç£æ¥ç什ã§å®ããåœéæ©é¢ãããã以äžãã®æ¡ã«ãããŠåããïŒãšé¢ä¿ããããšèª€èª 8
ããããããªæ¹æ³ã§ãåœéæ©é¢ã衚瀺ããæšç« ã§ãã£ãŠçµæžç£æ¥ç什ã§å®ãããã®ãš åäžè¥ããã¯é¡äŒŒã®ãã®ïŒä»¥äžãåœéæ©é¢é¡äŒŒæšç« ããšãããïŒãåæšãšããŠäœ¿çšãã åã¯åœéæ©é¢é¡äŒŒæšç« ãåæšãšããŠäœ¿çšããååãè²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ãã㯠åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããèŒžå ¥ããè¥ããã¯é»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæäŸããè¥ ããã¯åœéæ©é¢é¡äŒŒæšç« ãåæšãšããŠäœ¿çšããŠåœ¹åãæäŸããŠã¯ãªããªãããã ãã ãã®åœéæ©é¢ã®èš±å¯ãåãããšãã¯ããã®éãã§ãªãã ïŒå€åœå ¬åå¡çã«å¯Ÿããäžæ£ã®å©çã®äŸäžçã®çŠæ¢ïŒ 第åå «æ¡ äœäººããå€åœå ¬åå¡çã«å¯ŸããåœéçãªåååŒã«é¢ããŠå¶æ¥äžã®äžæ£ã®å©ç ãåŸãããã«ããã®å€åœå ¬åå¡çã«ããã®è·åã«é¢ããè¡çºãããè¥ããã¯ãããªã ããšãåã¯ãã®å°äœãå©çšããŠä»ã®å€åœå ¬åå¡çã«ãã®è·åã«é¢ããè¡çºãããè¥ã ãã¯ãããªãããã«ãã£ããããããããšãç®çãšããŠãééãã®ä»ã®å©çãäŸäžãã åã¯ãã®ç³èŸŒã¿è¥ããã¯çŽæãããŠã¯ãªããªãã ïŒ åé ã«ãããŠãå€åœå ¬åå¡çããšã¯ã次ã«æ²ããè ãããã äž å€åœã®æ¿åºåã¯å°æ¹å ¬å ±å£äœã®å ¬åã«åŸäºããè äº å ¬å ±ã®å©çã«é¢ããç¹å®ã®äºåãè¡ãããã«å€åœã®ç¹å¥ã®æ³ä»€ã«ããèšç«ããã ãã®ã®äºåã«åŸäºããè äž äžåã¯äºä»¥äžã®å€åœã®æ¿åºåã¯å°æ¹å ¬å ±å£äœã«ãããçºè¡æžæ ªåŒã®ãã¡è°æ±ºæš©ã® ããæ ªåŒã®ç·æ°è¥ããã¯åºè³ã®éé¡ã®ç·é¡ã®çŸåã®äºåãè¶ ããåœè©²æ ªåŒã®æ°è¥ã ãã¯åºè³ã®éé¡ãçŽæ¥ã«ææãããåã¯åœ¹å¡ïŒåç· åœ¹ãç£æ»åœ¹ãçäºãç£äºåã³æž ç®äººäžŠã³ã«ããã以å€ã®è ã§äºæ¥ã®çµå¶ã«åŸäºããŠãããã®ããããïŒã®éåæ°ã ä»»åœããè¥ããã¯æåãããŠããäºæ¥è ã§ãã£ãŠããã®äºæ¥ã®éè¡ã«åœãããå€åœ ã®æ¿åºåã¯å°æ¹å ¬å ±å£äœããç¹ã«æš©çãä»äžãããŠãããã®ã®äºåã«åŸäºããè ã ã®ä»ããã«æºããè ãšããŠæ¿ä»€ã§å®ããè å åœéæ©é¢ïŒæ¿åºåã¯æ¿åºéã®åœéæ©é¢ã«ãã£ãŠæ§æãããåœéæ©é¢ããããæ¬¡å· ã«ãããŠåããïŒã®å ¬åã«åŸäºããè äº å€åœã®æ¿åºè¥ããã¯å°æ¹å ¬å ±å£äœåã¯åœéæ©é¢ã®æš©éã«å±ããäºåã§ãã£ãŠãã ããã®æ©é¢ããå§ä»»ããããã®ã«åŸäºããè ïŒé©çšé€å€çïŒ ç¬¬åä¹æ¡ 第äžæ¡ãã第åäºæ¡ãŸã§ã第äºåäžæ¡ïŒç¬¬äºé 第å å·ã«ä¿ãéšåãé€ããïŒ åã³ç¬¬äºåäºæ¡ã®èŠå®ã¯ã次ã®åå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äºã®åºåã«å¿ããŠåœè©²åå·ã«å®ã ãè¡çºã«ã€ããŠã¯ãé©çšããªãã äž ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ã第äºå·ã第åäžå·åã³ç¬¬åäºå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äº ååè¥ ããã¯å¶æ¥ã®æ®éå称ïŒã¶ã©ããåæåã¯ææãšããç©ã®åç£å°ã®å称ã§ãã£ãŠã æ®éå称ãšãªã£ããã®ãé€ããïŒè¥ããã¯åäžè¥ããã¯é¡äŒŒã®ååè¥ããã¯å¶æ¥ã« ã€ããŠæ £çšãããŠããååç衚瀺ïŒä»¥äžãæ®éå称çããšç·ç§°ãããïŒãæ®éã«çš ããããæ¹æ³ã§äœ¿çšããè¥ããã¯è¡šç€ºãããåã¯æ®éå称çãæ®éã«çšããããæ¹ æ³ã§äœ¿çšããè¥ããã¯è¡šç€ºãããååãè²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã® ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããèŒžå ¥ããè¥ããã¯é»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæäŸããè¡çºïŒå 9
é 第åäžå·åã³ç¬¬åäºå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äºã®å Žåã«ãã£ãŠã¯ãæ®éå称çãæ®éã« çšããããæ¹æ³ã§è¡šç€ºãããåã¯äœ¿çšããŠåœ¹åãæäŸããè¡çºãå«ããïŒ äº ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ã第äºå·åã³ç¬¬åäºå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äº èªå·±ã®æ°åãäžæ£ ã®ç®çïŒäžæ£ã®å©çãåŸãç®çãä»äººã«æ害ãå ããç®çãã®ä»ã®äžæ£ã®ç®çãã ãã以äžåããïŒã§ãªã䜿çšããåã¯èªå·±ã®æ°åãäžæ£ã®ç®çã§ãªã䜿çšããåå ãè²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããèŒžå ¥ããè¥ã ãã¯é»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæäŸããè¡çºïŒåå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äºã®å Žåã«ãã£ãŠã¯ã èªå·±ã®æ°åãäžæ£ã®ç®çã§ãªã䜿çšããŠåœ¹åãæäŸããè¡çºãå«ããïŒ äž ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äº ä»äººã®ååç衚瀺ãéèŠè ã®éã«åºãèª èãããåãããã®ååç衚瀺ãšåäžè¥ããã¯é¡äŒŒã®ååç衚瀺ã䜿çšããè å㯠ãã®ååç衚瀺ã«ä¿ãæ¥åãæ¿ç¶ããè ããã®ååç衚瀺ãäžæ£ã®ç®çã§ãªãäœ¿çš ããåã¯ãã®ååç衚瀺ãäžæ£ã®ç®çã§ãªã䜿çšããååãè²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè² æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããèŒžå ¥ããè¥ããã¯é»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéã ãŠæäŸããè¡çº å 第äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äºå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äº ä»äººã®ååç衚瀺ãèåã«ãªãåããã ã®ååç衚瀺ãšåäžè¥ããã¯é¡äŒŒã®ååç衚瀺ã䜿çšããè åã¯ãã®ååç衚瀺㫠ä¿ãæ¥åãæ¿ç¶ããè ããã®ååç衚瀺ãäžæ£ã®ç®çã§ãªã䜿çšããåã¯ãã®åå ç衚瀺ãäžæ£ã®ç®çã§ãªã䜿çšããååãè²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ã ã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããèŒžå ¥ããè¥ããã¯é»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæäŸããè¡çº äº ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äº 次ã®ããããã«æ²ããè¡çº 〠æ¥æ¬åœå ã«ãããŠæåã«è²©å£²ãããæ¥ããèµ·ç®ããŠäžå¹Žãçµéããååã«ã€ã ãŠããã®ååã®åœ¢æ ãæš¡å£ããååãè²æž¡ãã貞ãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯è²žæž¡ãã® ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããåã¯èŒžå ¥ããè¡çºã ã ä»äººã®ååã®åœ¢æ ãæš¡å£ããååãè²ãåããè ïŒãã®è²ãåããæã«ãã®å åãä»äººã®ååã®åœ¢æ ãæš¡å£ããååã§ããããšãç¥ããããã€ãç¥ããªãããš ã«ã€ãé倧ãªé倱ããªãè ã«éããïŒããã®ååãè²æž¡ãã貞ãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ã ãã¯è²žæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããåã¯èŒžå ¥ããè¡çº å 第äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第åå·ãã第ä¹å·ãŸã§ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äº ååŒã«ãã£ãŠå¶æ¥ç§å¯ ãååŸããè ïŒãã®ååŸããæã«ãã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã«ã€ããŠäžæ£é瀺è¡çºã§ããããš åã¯ãã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã«ã€ããŠäžæ£ååŸè¡çºè¥ããã¯äžæ£é瀺è¡çºãä»åšããããšã ç¥ããããã€ãç¥ããªãããšã«ã€ãé倧ãªé倱ããªãè ã«éããïŒããã®ååŒã« ãã£ãŠååŸããæš©åã®ç¯å²å ã«ãããŠãã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã䜿çšããåã¯é瀺ããè¡çº äž ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第åå·åã³ç¬¬åäžå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äº æè¡çå¶éæ段ã®è©Šéšå㯠ç 究ã®ããã«çšãããã第äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第åå·åã³ç¬¬åäžå·ã«èŠå®ããè£ çœ®è¥ãã㯠ãããã®å·ã«èŠå®ããããã°ã©ã ãèšé²ããèšé²åªäœè¥ããã¯èšæ¶ããæ©åšãè²æž¡ ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããè¥ããã¯èŒžå ¥ããå ã¯åœè©²ããã°ã©ã ãé»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæäŸããè¡çº ïŒ åé 第äºå·åã¯ç¬¬äžå·ã«æ²ããè¡çºã«ãã£ãŠå¶æ¥äžã®å©çã䟵害ãããåã¯äŸµå®³ã ããããããããè ã¯ã次ã®åå·ã«æ²ããè¡çºã®åºåã«å¿ããŠåœè©²åå·ã«å®ããè 㫠察ããèªå·±ã®åååã¯å¶æ¥ãšã®æ··åãé²ãã®ã«é©åœãªè¡šç€ºãä»ãã¹ãããšãè«æ±ãã 10
ããšãã§ããã äž åé 第äºå·ã«æ²ããè¡çº èªå·±ã®æ°åã䜿çšããè ïŒèªå·±ã®æ°åã䜿çšããåå ãèªãè²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããèŒžå ¥ãã åã¯é»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæäŸããè ãå«ããïŒ äº åé 第äžå·ã«æ²ããè¡çº ä»äººã®ååç衚瀺ãšåäžåã¯é¡äŒŒã®ååç衚瀺ãäœ¿çš ããè åã³ãã®ååç衚瀺ã«ä¿ãæ¥åãæ¿ç¶ããè ïŒãã®ååç衚瀺ã䜿çšããå åãèªãè²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞åºããèŒžå ¥ãã åã¯é»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæäŸããè ãå«ããïŒ ïŒçµéæªçœ®ïŒ 第äºåæ¡ ãã®æ³åŸã®èŠå®ã«åºã¥ãæ¿ä»€åã¯çµæžç£æ¥ç什ãå¶å®ããåã¯æ¹å»ããå Žå ã«ãããŠã¯ããã®æ¿ä»€åã¯çµæžç£æ¥ç什ã§ããã®å¶å®åã¯æ¹å»ã«äŒŽãåççã«å¿ èŠãš å€æãããç¯å²å ã«ãããŠãæèŠã®çµéæªçœ®ïŒçœ°åã«é¢ããçµéæªçœ®ãå«ããïŒãå® ããããšãã§ããã ïŒçœ°åïŒ ç¬¬äºåäžæ¡ 次ã®åå·ã®ããããã«è©²åœããè ã¯ãå幎以äžã®æ²åœ¹è¥ããã¯åäžåä»¥äž ã®çœ°éã«åŠããåã¯ããã䜵ç§ããã äž è©æ¬ºçè¡çºïŒäººã欺ãã人ã«æŽè¡ãå ããåã¯äººãè è¿«ããè¡çºãããã以äžå ããïŒã«ãããåã¯ç®¡ç䟵害è¡çºïŒå¶æ¥ç§å¯ãèšèŒãããåã¯èšé²ãããæžé¢å㯠èšé²åªäœïŒä»¥äžãå¶æ¥ç§å¯èšé²åªäœçããšãããïŒã®çªåãå¶æ¥ç§å¯ã管çãã㊠ããæœèšãžã®äŸµå ¥ãäžæ£ã¢ã¯ã»ã¹è¡çºïŒäžæ£ã¢ã¯ã»ã¹è¡çºã®çŠæ¢çã«é¢ããæ³åŸ ïŒå¹³æåäžå¹Žæ³åŸç¬¬çŸäºåå «å·ïŒç¬¬äžæ¡ã«èŠå®ããäžæ£ã¢ã¯ã»ã¹è¡çºããããïŒã ã®ä»ã®ä¿æè ã®ç®¡çã害ããè¡çºãããã以äžåããïŒã«ããååŸããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ãã äžæ£ã®ç«¶äºã®ç®çã§ã䜿çšããåã¯é瀺ããè äº åå·ã®äœ¿çšåã¯é瀺ã®çšã«äŸããç®çã§ãè©æ¬ºçè¡çºåã¯ç®¡ç䟵害è¡çºã«ããã å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã次ã®ããããã«æ²ããæ¹æ³ã§ååŸããè 〠ä¿æè ã®ç®¡çã«ä¿ãå¶æ¥ç§å¯èšé²åªäœçãååŸããããšã ã ä¿æè ã®ç®¡çã«ä¿ãå¶æ¥ç§å¯èšé²åªäœçã®èšèŒåã¯èšé²ã«ã€ããŠããã®è€è£œã äœæããããšã äž å¶æ¥ç§å¯ãä¿æè ãã瀺ãããè ã§ãã£ãŠãäžæ£ã®ç«¶äºã®ç®çã§ãè©æ¬ºçè¡çºè¥ ããã¯ç®¡ç䟵害è¡çºã«ãããåã¯æšªé ãã®ä»ã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯èšé²åªäœçã®ç®¡çã«ä¿ãä»» åã«èãè¡çºã«ããã次ã®ããããã«æ²ããæ¹æ³ã§å¶æ¥ç§å¯ãèšèŒãããåã¯èšé² ãããæžé¢åã¯èšé²åªäœãé åŸããåã¯äœæããŠããã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã䜿çšããåã¯é 瀺ããè 〠ä¿æè ã®ç®¡çã«ä¿ãå¶æ¥ç§å¯èšé²åªäœçãé åŸããããšã ã ä¿æè ã®ç®¡çã«ä¿ãå¶æ¥ç§å¯èšé²åªäœçã®èšèŒåã¯èšé²ã«ã€ããŠããã®è€è£œã äœæããããšã å å¶æ¥ç§å¯ãä¿æè ãã瀺ããããã®åœ¹å¡ïŒçäºãåç· åœ¹ãå·è¡åœ¹ãæ¥åãå·è¡ã ã瀟å¡ãç£äºè¥ããã¯ç£æ»åœ¹åã¯ãããã«æºããè ãããã次å·ã«ãããŠåããïŒ 11
åã¯åŸæ¥è ã§ãã£ãŠãäžæ£ã®ç«¶äºã®ç®çã§ããã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã®ç®¡çã«ä¿ãä»»åã«èãã ãã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã䜿çšããåã¯é瀺ããè ïŒåå·ã«æ²ããè ãé€ããïŒ äº å¶æ¥ç§å¯ãä¿æè ãã瀺ããããã®åœ¹å¡åã¯åŸæ¥è ã§ãã£ãè ã§ãã£ãŠãäžæ£ã® 競äºã®ç®çã§ããã®åšè·äžã«ããã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã®ç®¡çã«ä¿ãä»»åã«èããŠãã®å¶æ¥ç§ å¯ã®é瀺ã®ç³èŸŒã¿ãããåã¯ãã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã®äœ¿çšè¥ããã¯é瀺ã«ã€ããŠè«èšãåã ãŠããã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ããã®è·ãéããåŸã«äœ¿çšããåã¯é瀺ããè ïŒç¬¬äžå·ã«æ²ãã è ãé€ããïŒ å äžæ£ã®ç«¶äºã®ç®çã§ã第äžå·åã¯ç¬¬äžå·ããåå·ãŸã§ã®çœªã«åœããé瀺ã«ãã£ãŠ å¶æ¥ç§å¯ãååŸããŠããã®å¶æ¥ç§å¯ã䜿çšããåã¯é瀺ããè ïŒ æ¬¡ã®åå·ã®ããããã«è©²åœããè ã¯ãäºå¹Žä»¥äžã®æ²åœ¹è¥ããã¯äºçŸäžå以äžã®çœ°é ã«åŠããåã¯ããã䜵ç§ããã äž äžæ£ã®ç®çããã£ãŠç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·åã¯ç¬¬åäžå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äºãè¡ã£ã è äº ä»äººã®èåãªååç衚瀺ã«ä¿ãä¿¡çšè¥ããã¯å声ãå©çšããŠäžæ£ã®å©çãåŸãç® çã§ãåã¯åœè©²ä¿¡çšè¥ããã¯å声ã害ããç®çã§ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äºå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ 競äºãè¡ã£ãè äž äžæ£ã®å©çãåŸãç®çã§ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ã«æ²ããäžæ£ç«¶äºãè¡ã£ãè å ååè¥ããã¯åœ¹åè¥ããã¯ãã®åºåè¥ããã¯ååŒã«çšããæžé¡è¥ããã¯éä¿¡ã«ã ã®ååã®åç£å°ãå質ãå 容ã補é æ¹æ³ãçšéè¥ããã¯æ°éåã¯ãã®åœ¹åã®è³ªãå 容ãçšéè¥ããã¯æ°éã«ã€ããŠèª€èªããããããªèåœã®è¡šç€ºãããè ïŒç¬¬äžå·ã«æ² ããè ãé€ããïŒ äº ç§å¯ä¿æåœä»€ã«éåããè å 第åå æ¡ã第åäžæ¡åã¯ç¬¬åå «æ¡ç¬¬äžé ã®èŠå®ã«éåããè ïŒ ç¬¬äžé åã³åé 第äºå·ã®çœªã¯ãå蚎ããªããã°å ¬èšŽãæèµ·ããããšãã§ããªãã ïŒ ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·åã¯ç¬¬äžå·ãã第å å·ãŸã§ã®çœªã¯ãè©æ¬ºçè¡çºè¥ããã¯ç®¡ç䟵害è¡çº ããã£ãæåã¯ä¿æè ãã瀺ãããæã«æ¥æ¬åœå ã«ãããŠç®¡çãããŠããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ã« ã€ããŠãæ¥æ¬åœå€ã«ãããŠãããã®çœªãç¯ããè ã«ãé©çšããã ïŒ ç¬¬äºé 第äºå·ã®çœªã¯ãæ¥æ¬åœå€ã«ãããŠåå·ã®çœªãç¯ããè ã«ãé©çšããã ïŒ ç¬¬äºé 第å å·ïŒç¬¬åå «æ¡ç¬¬äžé ã«ä¿ãéšåã«éããïŒã®çœªã¯ãåæ³ïŒææ²»ååå¹Žæ³ åŸç¬¬ååäºå·ïŒç¬¬äžæ¡ã®äŸã«åŸãã ïŒ ç¬¬äžé åã³ç¬¬äºé ã®èŠå®ã¯ãåæ³ãã®ä»ã®çœ°åã®é©çšã劚ããªãã 第äºåäºæ¡ æ³äººã®ä»£è¡šè åã¯æ³äººè¥ããã¯äººã®ä»£ç人ã䜿çšäººãã®ä»ã®åŸæ¥è ããã ã®æ³äººåã¯äººã®æ¥åã«é¢ããåæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ã第äºå·è¥ããã¯ç¬¬å å·åã¯ç¬¬äºé ã« æ²ããèŠå®ã®éåè¡çºããããšãã¯ãè¡çºè ã眰ããã»ãããã®æ³äººã«å¯ŸããŠäžåå 以äžã®çœ°éåãããã®äººã«å¯ŸããŠæ¬æ¡ã®çœ°éåãç§ããã ïŒ åé ã®å Žåã«ãããŠãåœè©²è¡çºè ã«å¯ŸããŠããåæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ã第äºå·åã³ç¬¬å å·äžŠã³ã«ç¬¬äºé 第äºå·ã®çœªã«ä¿ãåæ¡ç¬¬äžé ã®å蚎ã¯ããã®æ³äººåã¯äººã«å¯ŸããŠãå¹ åãçãããã®æ³äººåã¯äººã«å¯ŸããŠããå蚎ã¯ãåœè©²è¡çºè ã«å¯ŸããŠãå¹åãçãã ãã®ãšããã 12
ïŒ ç¬¬äžé ã®èŠå®ã«ããåæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ã第äºå·è¥ããã¯ç¬¬å å·åã¯ç¬¬äºé ã®éåè¡ çºã«ã€ãæ³äººåã¯äººã«çœ°éåãç§ããå Žåã«ãããæå¹ã®æéã¯ããããã®èŠå®ã®çœª ã«ã€ããŠã®æå¹ã®æéã«ããã é å æ ïŒæœè¡ææ¥ïŒ 第äžæ¡ ãã®æ³åŸã¯ãå ¬åžã®æ¥ããèµ·ç®ããŠäžå¹Žãè¶ ããªãç¯å²å ã«ãããŠæ¿ä»€ã§å®ã ãæ¥ããæœè¡ãããïŒå¹³æå 幎æ¿ä»€ç¬¬ååå·ã§å¹³æå 幎äºæäžæ¥ããæœè¡ïŒ ïŒçµéæªçœ®ïŒ 第äºæ¡ æ¹æ£åŸã®äžæ£ç«¶äºé²æ¢æ³ïŒä»¥äžãæ°æ³ããšãããïŒã®èŠå®ã¯ãç¹å¥ã®å®ããã ãå Žåãé€ããŠã¯ããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡åã«çããäºé ã«ãé©çšããããã ããæ¹æ£åã® äžæ£ç«¶äºé²æ¢æ³ïŒä»¥äžãæ§æ³ããšãããïŒã«ãã£ãŠçããå¹åã劚ããªãã 第äžæ¡ æ°æ³ç¬¬äžæ¡ã第åæ¡æ¬æåã³ç¬¬äºæ¡ã®èŠå®ã¯ããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡åã«éå§ãã次 ã«æ²ããè¡çºãç¶ç¶ããè¡çºã«ã€ããŠã¯ãé©çšããªãã äž æ°æ³ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äºå·ã«æ²ããè¡çºã«è©²åœãããã®ïŒåé 第äžå·ã«æ²ããè¡çº ã«è©²åœãããã®ãé€ããïŒ äº æ°æ³ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第åäžå·ã«æ²ããè¡çºã®ãã¡ã圹åè¥ããã¯ãã®åºåè¥ãã㯠ååŒã«çšããæžé¡è¥ããã¯éä¿¡ã«ãã®åœ¹åã®è³ªãå 容ãçšéè¥ããã¯æ°éã«ã€ã㊠誀èªããããããªè¡šç€ºãããåã¯ãã®è¡šç€ºãããŠåœ¹åãæäŸããè¡çºã«è©²åœããã 㮠第åæ¡ æ°æ³ç¬¬äžæ¡ãã第äºæ¡ãŸã§ã第ååæ¡åã³ç¬¬åäºæ¡ã®èŠå®ã¯ãå¹³æäžå¹Žå æå äºæ¥åã«è¡ãããæ°æ³ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第åå·ã«èŠå®ããäžæ£ååŸè¡çºåã¯åé ç¬¬å «å·ã« èŠå®ããäžæ£é瀺è¡çºã«ä¿ãåé 第åå·ãã第å å·ãŸã§ãç¬¬å «å·åã¯ç¬¬ä¹å·ã«æ²ãã äžæ£ç«¶äºã§ãã£ãŠåæ¥ä»¥åŸã«è¡ããããã®ïŒæ¬¡ã®åå·ã«æ²ããè¡çºã«è©²åœãããã®ã é€ããïŒåã³åæ¥åã«éå§ããåé 第äžå·ã«èŠå®ããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ã䜿çšããè¡çºãç¶ç¶ ããè¡çºã«ã€ããŠã¯ãé©çšããªãã äž æ°æ³ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第åå·ãã第å å·ãŸã§ãç¬¬å «å·åã³ç¬¬ä¹å·ã«èŠå®ããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ ãé瀺ããè¡çº äº æ°æ³ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äºå·åã³ç¬¬å «å·ã«èŠå®ããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ãååŸããè¡çºäžŠã³ã«ã ããã®è¡çºã«ããååŸããå¶æ¥ç§å¯ã䜿çšããè¡çº 第äºæ¡ æ°æ³ç¬¬äžæ¡ã®èŠå®ã¯ããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡åŸã«æèµ·ããã蚎ãã«ã€ããŠé©çšããã ã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡åã«æèµ·ããã蚎ãã«ã€ããŠã¯ããªãåŸåã®äŸã«ããã 第å æ¡ æ°æ³ç¬¬ååæ¡ã®èŠå®ã¯ããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡åã«éå§ããæ°æ³ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äºå· åã¯ç¬¬åäžå·ã«æ²ããè¡çºã«è©²åœãããã®ïŒåé 第äžå·ã«æ²ããè¡çºã«è©²åœãããã® 13
ãé€ããïŒãç¶ç¶ããè¡çºã«ã€ããŠã¯ãé©çšããªãã 第äžæ¡ ãã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡ã®éçŸã«æ§æ³ç¬¬åæ¡ç¬¬äžé ãã第äžé ãŸã§åã¯ç¬¬åæ¡ãäºã«èŠ å®ããèš±å¯ãåããŠããè ã¯ããããããæ°æ³ç¬¬åå æ¡ç¬¬äžé ãã ãæžã第äºé ãã ãæžè¥ããã¯ç¬¬äžé ãã ãæžåã¯ç¬¬åäžæ¡ãã ãæžã«èŠå®ããèš±å¯ãåããè ãšã¿ãª ãã ç¬¬å «æ¡ æ°æ³ç¬¬åå æ¡ã®èŠå®ã¯ããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡ã®éçŸã«æ§æ³ç¬¬åæ¡ç¬¬åé ã«èŠå®ãã èš±å¯ãåããŠããè ã«ã€ããŠã¯ãé©çšããªãã 第ä¹æ¡ æ°æ³ç¬¬åäžæ¡ã®èŠå®ã¯ããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡åã«éå§ããåæ¡ã«èŠå®ããåœéæ©é¢ é¡äŒŒæšç« ïŒæ§æ³ç¬¬åæ¡ãäºã«èŠå®ããæ¿åºéåœéæ©é¢ãçŽç« ãæç« å ¶ãä»ãåŸœç« ãç¥ ç§°åãå称ãã·ãäž»å倧è£ãæå®ã¹ã«ã¢ããåäžåãé¡äŒŒãã¢ããé€ãã以äžãæ°é åœéæ©é¢é¡äŒŒæšç« ããšãããïŒãåæšãšããŠäœ¿çšããåã¯æ°éåœéæ©é¢é¡äŒŒæšç« ãå æšãšããŠäœ¿çšããååãè²æž¡ããåŒãæž¡ããè²æž¡è¥ããã¯åŒæž¡ãã®ããã«å±ç€ºãã茞 åºããèŒžå ¥ããè¥ããã¯é»æ°éä¿¡åç·ãéããŠæäŸããè¥ããã¯æ°éåœéæ©é¢é¡äŒŒæš ç« ãåæšãšããŠäœ¿çšããŠåœ¹åãæäŸããè¡çºã«è©²åœãããã®ãç¶ç¶ããè¡çºã«ã€ã㊠ã¯ãé©çšããªãã 第åæ¡ æ°æ³ç¬¬äºåäžæ¡ïŒç¬¬äžé 第åäžå·ã«ä¿ãéšåãé€ããïŒåã³ç¬¬äºåäºæ¡ã®èŠå® ã¯ããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡åã«éå§ããéå第äžæ¡ç¬¬äºå·ã«æ²ããè¡çºã«è©²åœãããã®ãç¶ ç¶ããè¡çºã«ã€ããŠã¯ãé©çšããªãã 第åäžæ¡ ãã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡åã«ããè¡çºã«é¢ããæ§æ³ç¬¬äžæ¡ã«èŠå®ããå€åœäººãè¡ãå æ¡ã«èŠå®ããè«æ±ã«ã€ããŠã¯ããªãåŸåã®äŸã«ããã ïŒçœ°åã®é©çšã«é¢ããçµéæªçœ®ïŒ 第åäžæ¡ ãã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡åã«ããè¡çºã«å¯Ÿãã眰åã®é©çšã«ã€ããŠã¯ããªãåŸåã®äŸ ã«ããã ïŒæ¿ä»€ãžã®å§ä»»ïŒ 第ååæ¡ éå第äºæ¡ãã第åäžæ¡ãŸã§åã³åæ¡ã«å®ãããã®ã®ã»ãããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡ ã«é¢ãå¿ èŠãªçµéæªçœ®ã¯ãæ¿ä»€ã§å®ããã é å ïŒå¹³æå 幎äžäºæäžåæ¥æ³åŸç¬¬äžäžå å·ïŒ æ ïŒæœè¡ææ¥ïŒ 第äžæ¡ ãã®æ³åŸã¯ãå¹³æäžå¹Žäžæäžæ¥ããæœè¡ããããã ãã次ã®åå·ã«æ²ããèŠå® ã¯ãåœè©²åå·ã«å®ããæ¥ããæœè¡ããã äž ç¬¬äžæ¡äžç¹èš±æ³ç¬¬äžåæ¡ç¬¬äžé ã®æ¹æ£èŠå®ã第äºæ¡ã®èŠå®ïŒåæšæ³ç¬¬åæ¡ç¬¬äžé ã 14
第åäžæ¡ç¬¬äžé ã第åååæ¡ç¬¬äºé åã³ç¬¬å åäžæ¡ã®äºã®æ¹æ£èŠå®ãé€ããïŒå㳠第ä¹æ¡ã®èŠå® å¹³æäžå¹Žäžæäžæ¥åã¯äžç貿ææ©é¢ãèšç«ãããã©ã±ã·ã¥åå®ãæ¥ æ¬åœã«ã€ããŠå¹åãçããæ¥ïŒä»¥äžãçºå¹æ¥ããšãããïŒã®ããããé ãæ¥ ïŒçœ°åã®é©çšã«é¢ããçµéæªçœ®ïŒ 第åäžæ¡ ãã®æ³åŸã®åæ¹æ£èŠå®ã®æœè¡åã«ããè¡çºåã³ãã®éåã®èŠå®ã«ãããªãåŸ åã®äŸã«ããããšãšãããäºé ã«ä¿ããã®æ³åŸã®åæ¹æ£èŠå®ã®æœè¡åŸã«ããè¡çºã«å¯Ÿ ãã眰åã®é©çšã«ã€ããŠã¯ããããããªãåŸåã®äŸã«ããã ïŒæ¿ä»€ãžã®å§ä»»ïŒ 第ååæ¡ éå第äºæ¡ããåæ¡ãŸã§ã«å®ãããã®ã®ã»ãããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡ã«é¢ãå¿ èŠãª çµéæªçœ®ã¯ãæ¿ä»€ã§å®ããã é å ïŒå¹³æå «å¹Žå æäžäºæ¥æ³åŸç¬¬å å «å·ïŒ æ ïŒæœè¡ææ¥ïŒ 第äžæ¡ ãã®æ³åŸã¯ãå¹³æä¹å¹Žåæäžæ¥ããæœè¡ããããã ãã次ã®åå·ã«æ²ããèŠå® ã¯ãåœè©²åå·ã«å®ããæ¥ããæœè¡ããã äž ç¬¬äžæ¡äžåæšæ³ç¬¬åæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äºå·åã³ç¬¬äºå·ã®æ¹æ£èŠå®ãåæ³ç¬¬ä¹æ¡ç¬¬äžé ã® æ¹æ£èŠå®ãåæ³ç¬¬ä¹æ¡ã®äºã®åã«èŠåºããä»ãæ¹æ£èŠå®ãåæ³ç¬¬ä¹æ¡ã®äºã®æ¬¡ã«äž æ¡ãå ããæ¹æ£èŠå®ãåæ³ç¬¬åäžæ¡ç¬¬äžé ã®æ¹æ£èŠå®äžŠã³ã«åæ³ç¬¬äºåäžæ¡ã®äºã® æ¹æ£èŠå®äžŠã³ã«ç¬¬å æ¡ã®èŠå® åæšæ³æ¡çŽãæ¥æ¬åœã«ã€ããŠå¹åãçããæ¥ ïŒæ¿ä»€ãžã®å§ä»»ïŒ 第äºåäžæ¡ éå第äºæ¡ããåæ¡ãŸã§ã«å®ãããã®ã®ã»ãããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡ã«é¢ãå¿ èŠ ãªçµéæªçœ®ã¯ãæ¿ä»€ã§å®ããã é å ïŒå¹³æäžã幎ä¹æäºå «æ¥æ³åŸç¬¬äžäžäžå·ïŒ ãã®æ³åŸã¯ãåœéåååŒã«ãããå€åœå ¬åå¡ã«å¯ŸããèŽè³ã®é²æ¢ã«é¢ããæ¡çŽãæ¥æ¬åœ ã«ã€ããŠå¹åãçããæ¥ããæœè¡ããã é å ïŒå¹³æäžäžå¹Žåæäºäžæ¥æ³åŸç¬¬äžäžå·ïŒ æ ãã®æ³åŸã¯ãå¹³æåäžå¹Žåæäžæ¥ããæœè¡ããã é å ïŒå¹³æäžå 幎äºæäºå æ¥æ³åŸç¬¬äºäžå·ïŒ ãã®æ³åŸã¯ãå¹³æåäžå¹Žäžæäžæ¥ããæœè¡ããã
15
é å ïŒå¹³æäžå 幎å æäžå «æ¥æ³åŸäžäºãå·ïŒ æ ïŒæœè¡ææ¥ïŒ 第äžæ¡ ãã®æ³åŸã¯ãå¹³æåäžå¹Žåæäžæ¥ããæœè¡ããã ïŒçµéæªçœ®ã®ååïŒ ç¬¬äºæ¡ ãã®æ³åŸã«ããæ¹æ£åŸã®è£å€ææ³ãæ°äºèšŽèšæ³ãæ°äºèšŽèšè²»çšçã«é¢ããæ³åŸã ç¹èš±æ³ãå®çšæ°æ¡æ³ãæå æ³ãåæšæ³ãäžæ£ç«¶äºé²æ¢æ³åã³èäœæš©æ³ã®èŠå®ïŒçœ°åã é€ããïŒã¯ããã®éåã«ç¹å¥ã®å®ããããå Žåãé€ãããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡åã«çããäº é ã«ãé©çšããããã ãããã®æ³åŸã«ããæ¹æ£åã®ãããã®æ³åŸã®èŠå®ã«ããçãã å¹åã劚ããªãã é å ïŒå¹³æäžäžå¹Žå æäºä¹æ¥æ³åŸäžäºå·ïŒ æ ïŒæœè¡ææ¥ïŒ 第äžæ¡ ãã®æ³åŸã¯ãå ¬åžã®æ¥ããèµ·ç®ããŠäžå¹Žãè¶ ããªãç¯å²å ã«ãããŠæ¿ä»€ã§å®ã ãæ¥ããæœè¡ããããã ããéå第äžæ¡ã第åäžæ¡åã³ç¬¬ååæ¡ã®èŠå®ã¯ãç¯çœªã®åœ éååã³çµç¹å䞊ã³ã«æ å ±åŠçã®é«åºŠåã«å¯ŸåŠããããã®åæ³çã®äžéšãæ¹æ£ããæ³ åŸïŒå¹³æåäžå¹Žæ³åŸç¬¬ å·ïŒã®æœè¡ã®æ¥åã¯ãã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡ã®æ¥ã®ããããé ãæ¥ã ãæœè¡ããã ïŒçµéæªçœ®ïŒ 第äºæ¡ 第äžæ¡ã®èŠå®ã«ããæ¹æ£åŸã®äžæ£ç«¶äºé²æ¢æ³ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ã®èŠå®ã¯ãã ã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡åŸã«ããåå·ã«æ²ããè¡çºã«ã€ããŠé©çšãããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡åã«ãã第 äžæ¡ã®èŠå®ã«ããæ¹æ£åã®äžæ£ç«¶äºé²æ¢æ³ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ã«æ²ããè¡çºã«ã€ã㊠ã¯ããªãåŸåã®äŸã«ããã 第äžæ¡ çµç¹çãªç¯çœªã®åŠçœ°åã³ç¯çœªåçã®èŠå¶çã«é¢ããæ³åŸïŒå¹³æåäžå¹Žæ³åŸç¬¬çŸ äžåå å·ã以äžãçµç¹çç¯çœªåŠçœ°æ³ããšãããïŒç¬¬ä¹æ¡ç¬¬äžé ãã第äžé ãŸã§ã第å æ¡åã³ç¬¬åäžæ¡ã®èŠå®ã¯ããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡åã«è²¡ç£äžã®äžæ£ãªå©çãåŸãç®çã§ç¯ã ã第äžæ¡ã®èŠå®ã«ããæ¹æ£åã®äžæ£ç«¶äºé²æ¢æ³ç¬¬ååæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ãã第å å·ã®äº ãŸã§è¥ããã¯ç¬¬äžå·ïŒåæ³ç¬¬åäžæ¡ç¬¬äžé ã«ä¿ãéšåãé€ããïŒã第äºæ¡ã®èŠå®ã«ã ãæ¹æ£åã®ç¹èš±æ³ç¬¬äºçŸæ¡ã®äºç¬¬äžé ã第äžæ¡ã®èŠå®ã«ããæ¹æ£åã®å®çšæ°æ¡æ³ç¬¬å åæ¡ã®äºç¬¬äžé ã第åæ¡ã®èŠå®ã«ããæ¹æ£åã®æå æ³ç¬¬äžåäžæ¡ã®äºç¬¬äžé ã第äºæ¡ ã®èŠå®ã«ããæ¹æ£åã®åæšæ³ç¬¬å «åäžæ¡ã®äºç¬¬äžé ã第å æ¡ã®èŠå®ã«ããæ¹æ£åã®è äœæš©æ³ç¬¬çŸäºåäºæ¡ã®äºåã¯éå第å æ¡ã®èŠå®ã«ããæ¹æ£åã®ç¹èš±æ³çã®äžéšãæ¹æ£ ããæ³åŸïŒå¹³æäºå¹Žæ³åŸç¬¬äºåå å·ïŒéå第åæ¡ç¬¬äžé ã®èŠå®ã«ãããªããã®å¹åã æãããã®ãšãããåæ³ç¬¬äžæ¡ã®èŠå®ã«ããæ¹æ£åã®å®çšæ°æ¡æ³ïŒéå第å æ¡ã«ãã ãŠãå¹³æäºå¹Žæ§å®çšæ°æ¡æ³ããšãããïŒç¬¬å åæ¡ã®äºç¬¬äžé ã«æ²ãã眪ã®ç¯çœªè¡çº ïŒæ¥æ¬åœå€ã§ããè¡çºã§ãã£ãŠãåœè©²è¡çºãæ¥æ¬åœå ã«ãããŠè¡ããããšãããªãã° 16
ãããã®çœªã«åœããããã€ãåœè©²è¡çºå°ã®æ³ä»€ã«ãã眪ã«åœãããã®ãå«ããïŒã«ã ãçããè¥ããã¯åœè©²ç¯çœªè¡çºã«ããåŸã財ç£åã¯åœè©²ç¯çœªè¡çºã®å ±é ¬ãšããŠåŸã財 ç£ã«é¢ããŠãã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡åŸã«ããè¡çºã«å¯ŸããŠããé©çšããããã®å Žåã«ãããŠã ãããã®è²¡ç£ã¯ãçµç¹çç¯çœªåŠçœ°æ³ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äºé 第äžå·ã®ç¯çœªåçãšã¿ãªãã 第åæ¡ ç¯çœªã®åœéååã³çµç¹å䞊ã³ã«æ å ±åŠçã®é«åºŠåã«å¯ŸåŠããããã®åæ³çã®äž éšãæ¹æ£ããæ³åŸã®æœè¡ã®æ¥ããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡ã®æ¥åŸã§ããå Žåã«ããããã®æ³åŸã® æœè¡ã®æ¥ããç¯çœªã®åœéååã³çµç¹å䞊ã³ã«æ å ±åŠçã®é«åºŠåã«å¯ŸåŠããããã®åæ³ çã®äžéšãæ¹æ£ããæ³åŸã®æœè¡ã®æ¥ã®åæ¥ãŸã§ã®éã®çµç¹çç¯çœªåŠçœ°æ³ç¬¬äºæ¡ç¬¬äºé 第äžå·ã®èŠå®ã®é©çšã«ã€ããŠã¯ãåå·äžã第åäžæ¡ç¬¬äžé ããšããã®ã¯ã第åå «æ¡ç¬¬ äžé ããšãã第ååæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第äžå·ããšããã®ã¯ã第äºåäžæ¡ç¬¬äžé 第åäžå·ããšã ãã ïŒæ¿ä»€ãžã®å§ä»»ïŒ 第äºæ¡ åäžæ¡ã«å®ãããã®ã®ã»ãããã®æ³åŸã®æœè¡ã«é¢ãå¿ èŠãªçµéæªçœ®ã¯ãæ¿ä»€ã§ å®ããã
17