Property-related taxes
Contents
Liability for taxation – a brief introduction 1 Tax on private property 2 Tax types 3 Taxable events for private property 4–7 Tabular overview – fiscal sovereignty vs tax type 8 Private person as a commercial property handler 9 Property as a business asset 10 Glossary 11 Engel & Völkers in Switzerland and the Principality of Liechtenstein 12
The main points in brief ■ ■
■
■ ■ ■
The purchase, sale and holding of property all have different implications in terms of taxation. The profit from the sale of a private property results in the cantonal capital gains tax, which is based on the effective profit realised and the length of time that the property was held. There are no federal taxes. The capital gains on property held as business assets are taxed on a cantonal basis either through the cantonal capital gains tax or through income tax or tax on profits and, at a national level, through the direct federal tax. When property changes hands, this generally results in the cantonal property transfer tax or property transfer fee becoming payable, which is usually paid by the buyer or split equally between the both parties. Anyone owning private property must declare the property as an asset and is then liable to pay the cantonal wealth tax. If you are entered in the land register as a property owner or beneficiary, you must pay a cantonal property tax for the individual canton where the property is based. If you live in your own property (including as a second home), you must pay income tax on what is known as the imputed rental value.
1 Liability to pay taxes A brief introduction
Property ownership can result in a variety of taxes. These are generally determined by the location of the property, – namely, in the canton where the property is located. This means that one person owning property in various cantons may be liable to pay taxes to different cantons. In such cases, different cantonal taxation systems come into effect, with the result that the taxation of property can easily become a rather complicated issue. The tax rates applied vary widely between the cantons (sometimes even from municipality to municipality), so that the appropriate clarifications should be sought prior to any purchase. For example, if you live in the canton of Zug and own a holiday property in the canton of Grisons, you will have full tax liability to the canton of Zug due to your personal primary residence, while the holiday home in the canton of Grisons will result in limited tax liability. This results in an intercantonal allocation of taxes, which means that the property-relevant taxable income and deductions have to be allocated to both cantons. This is not always straightforward and is worth planning carefully, particularly with regard to avoiding double taxation. This guide aims to provide an overview of the tax implications of property ownership and property transactions. The main focus is on private property. Since the tax regimes can vary widely from canton to canton, it is essential to get customised, in-depth advice for each case. Your Engel & VÜlkers real estate agent would be happy to help you or to recommend a specialist lawyer or tax consultant.
2 Taxes on private property
Properties held as private assets may result in the following types of tax: ■
Income tax: Income from privately held property is subject to income tax, which is levied by the Swiss government, the cantons and the municipalities. Income includes rental income, in particular – or, if you live in the property yourself, the imputed rental value. In return, all maintenance costs and financing costs (in particular, mortgage interest and early repayment costs incurred) can be deducted; what cannot be deducted are any expenses increasing the value of the property that were only declared as capital expenses at the time of a sale that was subject to capital gains tax.
■
Wealth tax: Private property is subject to wealth tax. Debts owed on the property may be deducted from wealth tax. The wealth tax is levied at the cantonal and municipal level. The government itself does not levy any wealth tax.
■
Capital gains tax: This is a cantonal (sometimes municipal) tax that is due whenever a profit is made on the sale of a property. The amount that is taxable is the actual profit made at the time of the sale. Possible profits from any sale are not taxable at a national level. Private property is thus subject exclusively to capital gains tax. Capital gains tax also recognises various tax deferral mechanisms (such as inheritance, division of matrimonial property, replacement purchase). These can mean that the property is only taxed upon a future change of hands.
3 Tax types
â–
Property transfer tax: Property transfer tax is a purely cantonal or municipal tax. As its name implies, it is paid when a property changes hands from a previous to a new owner. All cantons recognise different property transfer scenarios that are either exempt from tax or subject to a privileged rate (such as inheritance, division of matrimonial property, replacement purchase). In some cantons, there is no property transfer tax. Some cantons only charge a fee according to a fixed tariff (compensation for expenses not subject to taxes) or they charge this in addition to the property transfer tax.
â–
Property tax: Property tax is also a cantonal or municipal tax that is payable annually in a few individual cantons or municipalities and based on the fair market value. In contrast to wealth tax, debts owed on the property cannot be deducted from property tax and the full fair market value is taxed.
â–
VAT: Provided that a property is for private use only, VAT is not due on either the sale or on letting the property. As a result, no input tax deductions can be made for investment or operating costs or for administrative costs. New builds differ in the following ways: If a property sale occurs before construction begins, this constitutes taxable real estate. If the sale or service contract is only signed once construction has begun, the supply of the property is tax-exempt. If property is used for commercial purposes and the landlord/buyer is subject to VAT, he/she may choose to subject the leasing or sale to VAT; in such cases, input tax may be claimed. If property is used by the owner for corporate purposes and the owner is subject to VAT, input tax may also be claimed. The VAT regime in relation to property is complex, and expert advice from a tax specialist may lead to significant cost optimisations in some cases.
4 Taxable events for private property
The major taxable events relating to private property are outlined below. â–
Ownership: Income from property is subject to income tax based on the location of the property. For private-use property, the imputed rental value is also taxable as hypothetical income. On the other hand, both mortgage interest and the maintenance costs can be deducted from taxable income. Investments increasing the value of the property are not eligible for deductions; however, they are used to calculate capital gains tax in the event that the property is sold. The taxable value of the property (minus the mortgage debt) is also subject to wealth tax. Moreover, individual cantons recognise a separate property tax that can be levied in place of, or in addition to, wealth tax.
â–
Sale: The sale of a private property results in a tax-free capital gain for the seller on the national level (or a loss that is not tax-deductible). However, gains are subject to cantonal capital gains tax.
â–
Purchase: People become owners of private property through the sale, exchange, bestowal, inheritance or its change of ownership between spouses. The purchase itself does not generally lead to direct tax implications (except for property transfer tax, provided that this is payable by the buyer, at least in part, by law or as a result of an agreement between the parties). However, because most cantonal laws provide for the joint liability of the buyer or a statutory lien on property for capital gains tax and property transfer tax, suitable contractual safeguards are urgently required. This actual risk of liability on the part of the buyer can be avoided for capital gains tax, for example, by the buyer paying a portion of the purchase price (amounting to the previously determined maximum capital gains tax) directly to the relevant tax administration on behalf of the capital gains tax for the seller. These rules for the sale of property logically also apply to the exchange of property (treated as a double purchase).
5
â–
Inheritance/gifts: In the instance of inheritance or a gift, the capital gains tax due is deferred. The new owner can thus speak of having a deferred tax liability, which must be paid upon the sale of the property. In addition to capital gains tax, the cantonal inheritance/gift tax must be borne in mind, although the majority of cantons do not tax the transfer of ownership to family members and spouses/registered partners. Fiscal sovereignty is governed by the property’s location.
â–
Construction/remodelling: Capital expenses only apply in the event of the sale of the property. The imputed rental value is not taxable during the construction phase. With regard to significant personal contributions during the construction of a property, possible tax and social security implications must be discussed on a case-by-case basis. For remodelling or renovation, the expenses must be categorised either as those related to maintenance or those with a value-enhancing character according to professional practice/the instructions of the relevant cantonal tax authorities; maintenance expenses can be deducted from taxable income in the relevant tax year, while value-enhancing investments can only be taken into account as capital expenses in the event of a sale that is subject to capital gains tax. Tax legislation also allows for an optional maintenance lump sum in addition to the actual and proven maintenance costs (each tax year, it is possible to choose between applying the actual maintenance costs or the maintenance lump sum). In summary, therefore, we can say that it is significant from a tax point of view whether investments are made to maintain the value of a property for occupancy, or to increase its value. It may be fiscally advantageous to stagger larger investments, or to spread them across two calendar years.
6
■
Use: Rental income or, in the event of owner occupancy, the imputed rental value (theoretical income) are subject to income tax. The actual maintenance costs or lump sum, as well as debt interest, are deductible from taxable income. The fair market value of the property is subject to wealth tax, although debts may be deducted.
■
Imputed rental value: The imputed rental value for owner-occupied properties is taxed as income in the same way as rental income from rented properties (generally speaking, the taxable imputed rental value [and the amount liable for wealth tax] is a little lower than the rental income obtained from third parties [disposal value]). The taxation of imputed rental income also applies to domestic holiday homes. The imputed rental income is calculated by the cantonal tax administrations in accordance with relevant provisions or estimated and the owners informed.
■
Debt interest: Private debt interest on mortgages is tax-deductible. However, there is an upper limit that must be borne in mind, according to which the total tax-deductible debt interest may not exceed CHF 50,000 – exclusive of the expected returns from moveable and immoveable assets. Interest on building loans may not be deducted in accordance with Swiss jurisdiction for the purposes of direct federal tax because interest on building loans are classed as capital expenses. The cantons deal with interest on building loans differently; sometimes, interest on building loans are permitted as expenses deductible from taxable income, and sometimes they are treated as capital expenses.
■
Taxable value: All net assets are covered by wealth tax. The value of a property is thus a taxable asset and taxable at a cantonal level. However, the calculation of the amount subject to wealth tax is not always done in accordance with consistency across all cantons.
7
â–
Debts: Mortgages and all debts owed on a property may be deducted from taxable assets. In comparison to debt interest for income tax purposes, there is no upper limit in terms of debts for wealth tax purposes.
â–
Maintenance costs: For private property, the maintenance costs (provided they are ascribed to maintaining the property), insurance premiums, costs for administration and repair costs (including for newly acquired properties) can be deducted. With regard to maintenance costs, it is possible to choose every year between a lump sum and the actual, proven costs. For owner-occupied property, electricity costs, water costs, caretaker costs, etc. are all categorised as living costs and are not taxable. Expenses that increase a property’s value are viewed as capital expenses and can only be recognised at the time of a sale upon which capital gains tax is due. Expenses that represent a mixture of maintenance and investment costs must be divided into maintenance and investment categories (e.g. the renovation of a 30-year-old bathroom, resulting in a significant increase in the standard of the property; simple, old bathroom is renovated into a luxurious bathroom with every conceivable convenience). The same distinction applies for repair costs for newly acquired properties.
8 Tabular overview Fiscal sovereignty vs tax type
Who collects which taxes? Income tax
Wealth tax
Capital gains tax
Property transfer tax
Property tax
Government
P
O
O
O
O
Canton
P
P
P
P
P
Municipality
P
P
P
P
P
Capital gains tax is generally only levied by the cantons; in some cantons it is also levied by the municipalities. In the cantons of Zug and ZĂźrich, it is only levied by the municipalities. The property transfer tax and property tax are treated differently in the individual cantons and municipalities. There are also cantons where these taxes are not applied.
9 Private person as a commercial property handler
If a natural person is taxed as a commercial property handler, the property is taxed as if it were a business asset. This can have a significant impact on the tax burden of the individual and significant implications for social security. There is no general definition of what constitutes a “commercial nature”, rather, it is based on criteria and indices in Swiss jurisdiction. The tax authorities apply this to specific cases and have a significant room for manoeuvre in applying the categorisation. Some indices include: ■ ■ ■ ■
Number of sales and purchases Short periods of ownership Excess third-party financing Proximity to place of business or specific expert knowledge (e.g. architects, real estate agents and property managers) ■ Necessity of making a profit from property transactions as a means of subsistence
Overall project realisation in particular can become complicated (including through joint beneficiaries) through the creation of a commonhold and the subsequent sale of the individual units, as well as the sale of several multi-dwellings units or individual property units within a short space of time.
10 Property as a business asset
If properties are held by a legal person (or a natural person as a business asset), they are generally subject to normal taxation on profits (income) and capital (wealth). In several cantons, property ownership requires intercantonal tax allocation. The taxation of the sales profit is applied by some cantons as part of the normal cantonal taxation on profits (income), which is known as the monistic system (LU, OW, GL, ZG, FR, SO, SH, AR, AI, SG, GR, AG, TG, VD, VS and NE), while the remaining cantons remove capital gains from taxation on profits (income) and register them under capital gains tax (the recontributed depreciation is also recorded under taxation on profits [income tax] in these cantons). For property held as a business asset, depreciation is permitted in the scope of the actual loss of value of the rates of depreciation recognised under tax law. What must be taken into account is that all transactions between the company and its owner or persons closely associated with the owner must take place at fair market conditions. Tax-optimising acts, such as renting your own property at reduced rent, or transferring it to become a private asset for a low price, are thus only possible in very limited circumstances. The distribution of profits of a legal person to the owner in the form of dividends is also subject to income tax, transferring the property from being a business asset to a natural person as a private asset represents a realisation of revenue under tax law and therefore is taxable. Due to the concrete owner strategy, individual cases must be carefully checked to see whether it would be more advantageous for the property to be held by a legal person instead of as a private asset.
11 Glossary ■ Land: According to the law, land includes property, individual and permanent rights listed in the land
registry, mines and co-ownership shares of land. ■ Property: If a plot of land is meant, a property can also be called land. ■ Tax deferral: Taxation takes place at a later date. Tax is not exempt but deferred to a later date. ■ Deferred taxes: A potential tax liability that the new owner assumes with tax deferral mechanisms in
conjunction with capital gains tax (e.g. inheritance). ■ Monistic vs dualistic system: The cantons are exempt from applying the monistic or dualistic system
for profits made from land. In the monistic system, every sale is subject to capital gains tax, regardless of whether the land is held as a private or business asset or belongs to a legal person. However, recontributed depreciation is taxed as a business asset, or as profits or income tax for legal persons. In the dualistic system, gains made from land are subject to different taxation strategies. Land held privately is subject to capital gains tax, while land held as a business asset or by a legal person is taxed with profit or income.
Property and tax are a very complex area of Swiss tax law. This guide aims to answer the major questions but cannot replace expert assessments of specific situations. If you have any questions, please ask for a consultation. Your Engel & Völkers real estate agent will be happy to advise you.
Sources: ■ Admin.ch: DBG [Swiss Federal Law on Direct Taxes] ■ Admin.ch: StHG [Swiss Federal Act on Harmonisation of Direct Taxes] ■ Fabian Petrus: tax and property ■ immobilien-besteuerung.ch/ ■ ch.ch/de/besteuerung-immobilien/
All information is correct as of May 2016 and subject to correction.
12
Engel & Völkers in Schwitzerland and Principality of Liechtenstein
Engel & Völkers Wohnen Schweiz Poststrasse 26 · 6300 Zug Phone +41-41-500 06 06 Fax +41-41-500 06 07 schweiz@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch
Flims Promenada 37 · 7018 Flims-Waldhaus Phone +41-81-911 33 82 Fax +41-81-911 33 85 flims@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/flims
Pfäffikon SZ Rebstockstrasse 4 · 8808 Pfäffikon SZ Phone +41-43-888 11 11 Fax +41-43-888 11 12 schwyz@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/zuerichseefreienbach
Thun Obere Hauptgasse 40 · 3600 Thun Phone +41-33-227 30 00 Fax +41-33-227 30 09 thun@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/thun
Aarau Kronengasse 2 · 5000 Aarau Phone +41-62-825 27 90 Fax +41-62-825 27 91 aarau@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/aarau
Frauenfeld Freiestrasse 17 · 8500 Frauenfeld Phone +41-52-723 30 40 Fax +41-52-723 30 41 frauenfeld@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/frauenfeld
Rapperswil Fischmarktstrasse 12 · 8640 Rapperswil Phone +41-43-210 92 20 Fax +41-43-210 92 21 rapperswil@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.com/zuerichgoldkueste
Urschweiz Seestrasse 60 · 6052 Hergiswil Phone +41-41-611 10 00 Fax +41-41-711 10 00 urschweiz@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.com/urschweiz
Affoltern am Albis Im Winkel 1 · 8910 Affoltern am Albis Phone +41-44-723 12 12 affoltern@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/zuerichseethalwil
Gstaad Lauenenstrasse 19 · 3780 Gstaad Phone +41-33-655 65 05 Fax +41-33-655 65 06 gstaad@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/gstaad
Rheinfelden Marktgasse 43 · 4310 Rheinfelden Phone +41-61-813 37 33 Fax +41-61-813 37 34 rheinfelden@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/nordwestschweiz
Vaduz Herrengasse 7 · LI-9490 Vaduz Phone +423- 231- 30 03 Fax +423- 231- 30 04 vaduz@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.li
Interlaken Höheweg 72 · 3800 Interlaken Phone +41-33-822 70 70 Fax +41-33-821 03 19 interlaken@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/interlaken
Rheintal/Glarus Bahnhofplatz 2 · 9470 Buchs SG Phone +41-81-523 70 70 Fax +41-81-523 70 71 rheintal@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/rheintal
Visp Kaufplatz 1A · 3930 Visp Phone +41-27-205 77 00 Fax +41-27-205 77 09 valais@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/valais
Küsnacht Oberwachtstrasse 6 · 8700 Küsnacht Phone +41-43-210 92 30 Fax +41-43-210 92 31 kuesnacht@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.com/zuerichgoldkueste
Rolle Grand-Rue 21 · 1180 Rolle Phone +41-22-343 12 12 Fax +41-22-343 12 15 rolle@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/suisseromande
Wallisellen Opfikonerstrasse 1 · 8304 Wallisellen Phone +41-43-500 68 68 Fax +41-43-500 68 69 wallisellen@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/zuerichnord
Kreuzlingen Hauptstr. 43 · 8280 Kreuzlingen Phone +41-71-677 18 18 Fax +41-71-677 18 19 kreuzlingen@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/kreuzlingen
Rorschach Hauptstr. 53 · 9400 Rorschach Phone +41-71-845 65 50 Fax +41-71-845 65 51 rorschach@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/rorschach
Weinfelden Pestalozzistrasse 4 · 8570 Weinfelden Phone +41-71-663 30 00 Fax +41-71-663 30 01 weinfelden@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/weinfelden
Liestal Kanonengasse 57 · 4410 Liestal Phone +41-61-666 62 06 Fax +41-61-666 62 07 liestal@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/nordwestschweiz
Rüti Rapperswilerstrasse 7 · 8630 Rüti Phone +41-55-533 04 50 Fax +41-55-533 04 59 zuerichoberland@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/zuerichoberland
Wil SG Toggenburgerstrasse 47 · 9500 Wil SG Phone +41-71-911 30 33 Fax +41-71-911 30 34 wil@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/wil
Lugano-Paradiso Via della Posta 2 · 6900 Lugano Phone +41-91-980 42 60 Fax +41-91-980 42 59 lugano@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/lugano
Schaffhausen Bachstrasse 13 · 8200 Schaffhausen Phone +41-52-630 70 10 Fax +41-52-630 70 11 schaffhausen@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/schaffhausen
Winterthur Obertor 2 · 8400 Winterthur Phone +41-43-500 64 64 Fax +41-43-500 64 65 winterthur@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/zuerichnord
Lugano-Paradiso Riva Paradiso 10 · 6900 Lugano-Paradiso Phone +41-91-980 42 60 Fax +41-91-980 42 59 lugano@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/lugano
Scuol Porta 7 · 7550 Scuol Phone +41-81-860 37 42 scuol@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/scuol
Zug Neugasse 15 · 6301 Zug Phone +41-41-728 77 11 Fax +41-41-728 77 10 zug@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/zug
Ascona Piazza G. Motta 57 · 6612 Ascona Phone +41-91-785 14 80 Fax +41-91-785 14 85 ascona@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/ascona Baden Vordere Metzggasse 6 · 5402 Baden Phone +41-56-200 88 77 Fax +41-56-200 88 70 baden@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/baden Basel Grenzacherstrasse 4 · 4058 Basel Phone +41-61-666 62 00 Fax +41-61-666 62 01 basel@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/nordwestschweiz Bern Mettlengässli 2 · 3074 Muri b. Bern Phone +41-31-950 22 11 Fax +41-31-950 22 12 bern@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/bern Biel Hauptstrasse 59 · 2560 Nidau Phone +41-32-333 20 66 Fax +41-32-333 20 67 biel@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/biel Bülach Poststrasse 1 · 8180 Bülach Phone +41-43-500 38 38 Fax +41-43-500 38 39 zuerichnord@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/zuerichnord Burgdorf Kirchbühl 5 · 3400 Burgdorf Phone +41-34-423 05 06 Fax +41-34 423 05 07 burgdorf@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/burgdorf
Luzern Pilatusstrasse 41 · 6003 Luzern Phone +41-41-410 66 91 Fax +41-41-410 66 92 luzern@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/luzern
Solothurn Friedhofplatz 5 · 4500 Solothurn Phone +41-32-322 13 13 Fax +41-32-322 37 37 solothurn@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/solothurn
Chur Masanserstrasse 21 · 7000 Chur Phone +41-81-250 55 85 Fax +41-81-250 55 87 chur@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/chur
Luzern-Land Unterstadt 22 · 6210 Sursee Phone +41-41-910 58 58 luzern-land@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/luzern-land
St. Gallen Spisergasse 23 · 9000 St. Gallen Phone +41-71-730 09 20 Fax +41-71-730 09 24 stgallen@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/stgallen
Davos Promenade 83 · 7270 Davos Platz Phone +41-81-410 00 30 Fax +41-81-410 00 39 davos@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/davos
Montreux Grand-Rue 82 · 1820 Montreux Phone +41-21-533 13 33 Fax +41-21-533 13 34 montreux@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/montreux
St. Moritz Via Maistra 39 · 7500 St. Moritz Phone +41-81-837 51 51 Fax +41-81-837 51 50 stmoritz@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/stmoritz
Dietikon Bremgartnerstrasse 11 · 8953 Dietikon Phone +41-43-500 25 25 Fax +41-43-500 25 26 dietikon@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/dietikon
Nyon Rue de Rive 32 · 1260 Nyon Phone +41-22-343 12 12 Fax +41-22-343 12 15 nyon@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/suisseromande
Thalwil Gotthardstrasse 26 · 8800 Thalwil Phone +41-44-533 12 12 Fax +41-44-533 12 13 zuerichseethalwil@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/zuerichseethalwil
Zürichberg Gemeindestrasse 51 · 8032 Zürich Phone +41-43-210 92 40 Fax +41-43-210 92 41 zuerichberg@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.com/zuerichgoldkueste Zürich Paradeplatz Claridenstrasse 43 · 8002 Zürich Phone +41-43-888 11 22 Fax +41-43-888 11 23 zuerichparadeplatz@engelvoelkers.com www.engelvoelkers.ch/zuerichparadeplatz
Engel & Völkers Wohnen Schweiz AG Poststrasse 26 · CH-6300 Zug Phone +41-41-500 06 06 · Fax +41-41-500 06 07 www.engelvoelkers.ch · Schweiz@engelvoelkers.com