The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SEC RET//SI//R EL TO USA, FVEY

'i;m W *>f; iWi

‘wprÿss

you

2ÿMAN

The ART of DECEPTION TRAINING FOR A NEW GENERATION OF ONLINE COVERT OPERATIONS

”GCHQ"

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

SECRET//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY

HSOC

HUMAN SCIENCE OPERATIONS CELL

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Online HUMINT

JTRIG

Strategic Influence

Disruption and CNA

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

ANTHROPOLOGY PSYCHOLOGY

SOCIOLOGY

b V

<

/

.i>-

i

s

*

*** )

V

4

\

ECONOMICS

/

\

\

HISTORY

POLITICAL SCIENCE

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

BIOLOGY

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Cultu re

Ethnography

Deception

Influence

ANTHROPOLOGY

Ethnography

Magic

SOCIOLOGY

A.

'

Compliance

»

'ÿ

•

\

Obedience / /

t

s>

t

s

fk

/ J

Social Networks \

*

PSYCHOLOGY

f

Trust

i

x

Elicitation

t

s

ECONOMICS

/

i

HISTORY

Key Leader Engagement

Personality

/

Belief

Religion POLITICAL SCIENCE

BIOLOGY

Neuroscience

Global Trends SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Evolutionary Biology

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

SCIENCE

SIGINT

SKILLS SYSTEMS SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Online HUMINT

JTRIG

Strategic Influence

Disruption and CNA

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

t i -

'

1

v

*i

%i

>

s

We want to build Cyber Magicians.

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

ocaa Online Covert Action Accreditation

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

AC NO Key Skill Strands

Online HUMINT

Influence & Info Ops

Disruption & CNA

Magic Techniques & Experiment

Individual

Psychology

Professionalism

Deception

Elegance Group

Performance

Creativity

Media

Intuition

Global

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

l

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

ACNO Key

Influence & Info Ops

Online HUMINT

Skill Strands

Disruption & CNA

Magic Techniques & Experiment

I

not rational)

Individual BELIEF

Decisions [Emotional

Self

How to

x

apply these

|1

Deception Persu asive

Tech

10 PRINCIPLES OF SCAMS

[who I am? Motives & exploiting them]

I

Hofstede Dimensions

PERSUASION

Hofstede Dimensions

Group

Roles

Influence/Cascade

AGENTICITV

Social Proof/ Herding etc Group Reducing

PATTERN ICI

How to act

Becoming / Targeting

Optimising Deception

i

Channels Prates of Reflection to assess if we are doing op el每antly

DIFFUSION OF INNOVATION

I

Performance

Social Identity Theory

i

i i /

PRIMING

Social Penetration Theory

Motives

i

f

Brainstorming

/ behave

l

Self Presentation in Cyber context

NARRATIVE

Elegance

i

ANCHORING

Mirroring / Mimicry

across cultures

n

CONFIRMATION BIAS

Building Relationships

/ QBEDIANCE

Virtual Communities

HINDSIGHT BIAS

Influence

Interaction

CONFORMITY

CONSPIRACY STORIES

Professionalism

Trust

Trust

Personality (OCEAN) Remote Assessment in Digital Cues

Behaviour & Influence

Psychology

-Ft

;idtr alternate

Creativity Constructing experience in mind of target which should be accepted so they don't realise It

( Intel /Analysis

/

Intuition

Media Financial Ecosystem of Media

PROPAGANDA BRANDING

Thin Slicing TAA ADVERTISING Sell own - Earn

-

MARKETING

SE&

TO USA, FVEY

Design, Retenti on & Trust

How to do some of this in real time so need to

understand what you are doing in this psychology Reading from digital tells but going with performance to reduce my risk but satisfy t nqu is it ion

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

ACNO Key

Skill Strands Mental Health a Psychopathy

Influence & Info Ops

Online HUMINT

5

71-

v

US

S3

Decision Making

%*

mm

—

Rationale Choice Crime & punishment

[ÿTag Decisions [Emotional not

Individual

(

BELIEF

Self

rational!

Psychology

How to

apply these

1

PERSUASION

10 PRINCIPLES OF SCAMS

Hofstede Dimensions

Group

Morality & Ethics

Cyber Cultures across

AGENTICITV

Organisations

PATTERN 1C|-p|

How to act

Group

Effect iveness

Dynamics

Becoming / Targeting

Channels P races of Reflection to assess if we are doing op eiÿantly

i

!

i

DIFFUSION OF INNOVATION

/ j

Performance

Social Identity Theory Social Proof/ Herding etc Group Reducing

PRIMING

Roles

Influence/Cascade

Optimising Deception

/

Social Penetration Theory

Motives

Virtual Communities

r

! i

ANCHORING

Mirroring / Mimicry

/ QBEDIANCE

Elegance

CONFIRMATION BIAS

Building Relationships

across cultures

CONFORMITY

HINDSIGHT BIAS

Influence

Interaction

CONSPIRACY STORIES

FLAMMED INTERVENTION

Persu asive

exploiting them]

Hofstede Dimensions

s

Deception

[who I am? Motives &

I

r*iriTi4

Trust

K

[•]

[ÿXI

Personality (OCEAN) Remote Assessment in Digital Cues

Behaviour & Influence

4

Disruption & Comp Net Attack

/ behave

l

Self Presentation in Cyber context

Creativity NARRATIVE

Brainstorming !

1

CCJ/RE

idtr alternate

P

!S

:>

Constructing experience in mind of target which should be accepted so they don't realise it

Intel /Analysis j

Global

Legitimisation of Violence SOCIAL NETWORKS

Con structing News System

)

Financial Ecosystem of Media

r±iifias Management & Legend Building (decided not to include in training)

Intuition

Media PROPAGANDA BRANDING

Thin Slicing TAA ADVERTISING Sell own - Earn

-

MARKETING

SE&

Howto do some of this in real time so need to

TO USA, FVEY

Design, Retenti on & Trust

*

understand what you are doing In this psychology Reading from digital tells but going with performance to reduce my risk but satisfy Target's Inquisition

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Human Science Learning Path i

A

A

A i

A

A Scams

A

And

i

JHk

\

Strategic Influence (1day)

f

r

r

Wj

it ! I I

f

r

uence

i

Psychology And Cyber -

*i

Core

“

psychology

A

i

Tells

Online HUMINT Disruption {1hour)

1

u

Engineering Fur CNA

(e-learning)

r

CNA and Disruption

•I ocoo

HSOC m

i* IVW( Vitwifinwlnuftlllt

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

SECRET//SI// REL TO USA, FVEY

*ÿ

V I

f

I

II

V

1

I

*

* C,

1

- .

-

& W* I

* i

1

V *

>*

w*

*

L

*

*

«

•1*

I

E

41

r:

B*v *

.

4

r *<

JCK SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

k,

j

_

. v*T. Md/

•Ifli

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

•If? *

V .

1

« #

i

-4

*

’I

i

A SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Magicians, the military and intelligence 3

fe

rl

r

4*

I

#

*

*r

// Hr 4

f

•

1

*ÿ

1

Hi**

w V (gJt1 w

4

Iff

L

r

f.

r A/

-c

&

u

V * a

f

4.

ri

§

*

ji y

ms

Jean Robert-Houdin

Jasper Maskelyne

John Mulholland

1856 mission on behalf of Napoleon III to help quell the

1 940s Camouflage work during the Second World War.

1 950s CIA work on the application of conjuring to

‘clandestine activities' .

Marabout-led uprising in Algeria.

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

X

P— -1-

Jjn

.

X X r-. ps

.

p

**’

rt

Dissimulation - Hide the real Dazzling

Repackaging

Masking ~

t

tv _-

-

PH

-

r

H

.i

IP™”

SE*

r-n

BX-

1 1

j

i*

, j

ipi

Jm

i

-~

u

w] d

J W

&

i|f

f**

,iflV|jl

V

t . V*

.

*

*

.m

L/Vij

*

j

ivÿ >B

/'

x-

J

\

LKP IJ

.»

»

.

t

l

it.

i1

y:

Lt* /

w.

J ™

. _-

(V

i..*'

V * jiWrS!H* 7i -‘

_

£ J

Mimicking

Simulation

T

h

“ SWr"'

,1

,

'i

|ÿ

' 'ÿ

_!

’ Lÿf

.

»

-

r

pJ

Jt

A

r

t

._.

#

IV--

rp

Pu

"

,fc

Inventing

Show the false SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

- laW

Decoying

“

'3

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

The psychological building blocks of deception Ex

net /

Attention

Sensemaking

Perception

1

/ /

Affect

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

*

Behaviour

V