email: editor@ independent.com
VOL 11 No. 24
Phone: 281-980-6745 50 cents
www.fbindependent.com ww .fbindependent.com
FORT BEND FAIR. BALANCED. INFORMATIVE. WEDNESDAY, JUNE 13, 2018
P. O.BOX 623, SUGAR LAND, TX 77487-0623
Official newspaper of Fort Bend County & Missouri City
Sugar Land appoints 9-member CAD fends off charges for violating Texas Public Information Act Redistricting Committee Outside legal counsel will prepare several redistricting plans based on state and federal law as well as guidelines adopted by City Council. City Council also approved resolution 18-19 that establishes criteria for use in the 2018 redistricting process, creates a framework to guide redistricting plans and assists city efforts to comply with all applicable federal and state laws. The city will adhere to the following criteria: • Where possible, easily identifiable geographic boundaries should be followed. • Communities of interest should be maintained in a single district, where possible and attempts should be made to avoid splitting districts. • To the extent possible, dis-
Sugar Land City Council last week appointed a Redistricting Advisory Committee. The annexation of Greatwood and New Territory increased the city’s population, requiring the city’s four single-member City Council districts to be adjusted. Single-member Council districts must be of substantially equal population with a maximum deviation no greater than 10 percent between the most populated and least populated council member district. Sugar Land’s citizen redistricting committee includes Chairman Randy Garbs, Councilmember Himesh Gandhi, Tina Gibson, Dr. Mary Harrell, Russell Jones, Louis Manuel, Apurva Parikh, Sapana Patel and Councilmember Bridget Yeung. Committee meetings will be held from June 25 to Aug. 10.
tricts should be composed of whole voting precincts. Where this is not possible or practicable, districts should be drawn in a way that permits the creation of practical voting precincts and that ensures that adequate facilities for polling places exists in each voting precinct. • Although it is recognized that existing districts will have to be altered to reflect new population distribution, any districting plan should, to the extent poSee RE-DISTRICT, Page 4
Sugar Land’s Land Use Plan, Page 3; Commentary, Page 4
Eric Robins named SLPD Police Chief Assistant Police Chief Eric Robins has been elevated to the position of police chief of Sugar Land. “During the past several years, we’ve focused on developing leaders within our department,” said Assistant City Manager Doug Brinkley. “Throughout this rigorous and extensive selection process, Eric excelled at demonstrating leadership, strategic foresight and a visionary approach to building on the recent achievements of our department and charting a path for future sustained success.” A native Houstonian who has spent almost his entire career with SLPD, Robins most recent assignment as assistant chief
TIP OF THE SPEAR If you have ever wondered what our deployed troops do to honor the “fallen” on Memorial Day, this email from
Robins included direct supervision and leadership of patrol, criminal investigations, traffic, special impact teams, crime analysis, SWAT and crime scene investi-
one of Tip of the Spear.org adopted troops will make you feel proud as the Captain explains the “Murph.” “This is what some of us on
Moving Up or Scaling Down? We Have Buyers Realtor Fees are negotiable Call me today for a quote Residential-AcreageCommercial Wayne Russell Broker Associate Re/Max Southwest 14905 Southwest Freeway Email: wayne@swfreeway.com Off: 281-207-5054 Cell: 281-814-6397 Fax: 281-242-6754 Licensed since 1968; Member of the Houston Association of Realtors; Access to MLS; Disregard if your home is currently in the market.
Southwest
gations. His many accomplishments have included strategies and programs that directly contributed to Sugar Land achieving a crime rate for 2017 that was the lowest on record after hitting a 20-year low in 2016. Industry experts recently credited SLPD as one of the best run agencies they’ve evaluated in the nation. Robins has implemented initiatives to increase police visibility and expand crime analysis to identify resources necessary to address criminal trends. He also managed and created special enforcement teams to target and handle specific high-crime patterns throughout the city, efforts that directly contributed to See CHIEF, Page 4
By SESHADRI KUMAR An ex-employee of the Fort Bend County Central Appraisal District, who turned into a “whistle blower” has helped uncover violations of the Texas Public Information Act by the CAD. The CAD denied the existence of certain documents to several people who made Open Records Requests two years ago. The crux of the matter is the so called “black list” of arbitrators which the CAD used until 2016. Chief Appraiser Glen Whitehead at that time denied the existence of a “black list” but confirmed that there was a “Not to use” list. Whitehead in 2016 responded to an Open Records Request thus: “The list of arbitrators, the FBCAD did not agree to use, was known as the “Not Quali-
fied” list. Recently, as the result of an Open Records Request, a letter mailed or emailed by a local property owner contained a copy of this list. Even though the FBCAD did not agree with the individual taxpayer’s choice of arbitrator, this list is not a “Black List,” nor does it mean the individual arbitrator is not qualified or prohibited from serving as an arbitrator– it simply means the FBCAD did not agree with the selection. “This incident caused turmoil among both the arbitrators on the list and the taxpayers of Fort Bend County; and for this, I apologize. “I have taken the following steps to refocus the District’s operations. (1) Staff is to stop using or referring to the previous list which is currently segregated from the active records of the District and clearly marked “Do Not Use.” (2) Arbitrators
will be given full consideration in future proceedings, and (3) To insure the transparency of the arbitration process, staff is to maintain a Results Log of all arbitrations. This updated log will be made available, upon request, to members of the public. All taxpayers have ample and equal access to both the arbitration process and the administrative process as outlined in the Texas Property Tax Code.” What is new? Rose Spencer, a CAD employee, who used to respond to the Open Records Requests, in the past, has since been terminated from the CAD and she has in her possession certain documents, including the purported “black list,” in addition to the “Not to use” list or “Not Qualified” list. Thomas A. Bazan, one of the arbitrators in the “Not to Use” See CAD, Page 4
Central Fort Bend Chamber to hold 33rd Annual Business Links Golf Tournament
2018 CFBC BUSINESS LINKS SPONSORS: (L – R) John Kennedy – TSTC - Golf Co-Chair, Dominic Robinson - CenterPoint Energy-Money Ball Sponsor, Kristin Weiss - CFBC Pres/CEO; Vince Finnegan - Finnegan Auto Group-Masters Sponsor; Gary Finnegan - Finnegan Auto Group-Masters Sponsor and Jeff Haley - Si Environmental, LLC - Golf Co-Chair.
Preparations are well underway for the 33rd annual Business Links Golf Tournament on Tuesday, July 10 hosted by Black Hawk County Club. Finnegan Auto Group is the Presenting Sponsor for the Business Links Golf Tournament. This year the Chamber will be introducing a new tournament format. Two (2) concurrent nine-hole scrambles with shotgun start at 2 p.m. - one on the front nine (holes 1-9) and the other on the back nine (holes 10-18). Top (2) teams (foursomes) from each nine will compete for the ninehole winner in a one-hole suddenTeam 1212 did to commemo- death shootout. The two nine-hole rate Memorial Day. If you want winners will then face off in the you can share it to Tip of the Spear or take the pictures and make your own post. We did a work out called the “Murph” in the afternoon when it was By SESHADRI KUMAR over 100 degrees. The workout A three-judge panel of the is: Run one mile 100 pull ups Fourteenth Court of Appeals 200 push ups 300 air squats on June 5 affirmed a judgRun one mile. All of that is ment awarding $246,788 in done while wearing at least 2 legal fees and sanctions to Fort lbs worth of body armor. The Bend ISD in a lawsuit chalworkout was created in honor lenging the District’s truancy of Lt. Michael Murphy who was practices. a navy seal team commander Judge Brady Elliott of the who won the Medal of Honor 268th District Court in Fort sacrificing himself to save his Bend County on Sept. 22, men in Afghanistan back in 2016 ordered that Fort Bend 2005. The idea is to get out and ISD receive nearly $200,000 do something painful and chal- in legal fees and sanctions, and lenging to honor the sacrifice of said he would dismiss a lawso many. I am currently recov- suit against the District. ering from that workout with In May 2015, a team of Fort some of the Protein drinks that Bend County attorneys filed a you guys sent us! Thank you lawsuit in Fort Bend County sooooooo much!” District Court challenging — Carolyn V. Bowden the legality of the Fort Bend
final shootout to determine the overall CFBC Business Links Grand Champion. A second new component to the tournament will be “The Money Ball Drop” sponsored by CenterPoint Energy. A “Money Ball” can be purchased by any person for $100 to be dropped from the Hero Signs bucket truck. Only 200 “Money Balls” will be sold. The golf ball that makes it into the hole will receive half the pot up to $10,000. If multiple golf balls make it into the hole, half the pot will be split equally amongst the winners. There is no limit on the number of golf balls a participant can purchase. Winning participants
are responsible for all applicable taxes. The Central Fort Bend Chamber will also kick-off their evening network event “The 5:05” post Golf Tournament. The 5:05 After-Party is open to all members for networking. Attendees will have opportunities to win a cash prize for “The Money Ball Drop”, Live and Silent Auctions, and a Corn Hole Toss competition. The 5:05 will begin at 5:05 p.m. at the Black Hawk Clubhouse. For sponsorship information, contact Tiffany Davis with the Central Fort Bend Chamber at 281.342.5464 or tdavis@cfbca. org. Registration is now open at www.cfbca.org.
County Truancy Court. The civil legal action, styled Roach v. Ingram, et al., was assigned to the 268th District Court. Attorneys Deron R. Harrington, Dawn Zell Wright, Susan H. Soto, and Carole Stewart Anhalt said that the Fort Bend County Truancy Court was not a Court lawfully Created Under the Texas Constitution and Fort Bend County Commissioners have no authority to create a Criminal Court of Law with Original Jurisdiction to hear “Failure To Attend School” complaints. Harrington said at that time that the legal action was necessary “to protect and defend the constitutional rights held by the students and parents of
Fort Bend ISD.” The lawsuit was against the Fort Bend ISD Board of Trustees, the Fort Bend County Juvenile Board, Fort Bend County truancy judges, and other Fort Bend County and district employees on behalf of three students, claiming procedural defects in the handling of truancy cases. The plaintiffs’ lawsuit was dismissed in September of 2017 and a judgment was entered ordering Harrington, his co-counsel, and his clients to pay the county and district defendants a combined total of approximately $500,000 in attorneys’ fees and sanctions.
Court of appeals affirms award of $200,000 in legal fees and sanctions to FBISD
See APPEAL, Page 5