O HERALD O
Visit us at: www.oheraldo.in
The Voice of Goa — Since 1900 panjim, saturday, january 29, 2011 postal reg. no. Goa 101 priCE rs. 3.00
Goa’s Heartbeat: Bonham doesn’t regret fashion mistakes Pg 4
Goa: Drug dealers carry cops on their bikes — Agnelo Pg 3
(air surcharge rs 2.00) pages 16+4
Sports: Dhoni’s team still atop, says Sachin Pg 16
cipriano: killed bY khaki
bloW bY bloW
• January 7, 2011 – Panjim police arrests Cipriano. • January 8, 2011 – Sub Divisional Magistrate releases him on bail. • January 9, 2011 – Cipriano succumbs to his injuries. SDM initiates inquiry • January 13, 2011 – SPCA takes suo moto cognizance of news reports on Cipriano in Herald. • January 14, 2011 – Goa Police appoints DySP Boussette D’Silva ask to probe into police lapses. • Januar y 24, 2011 – D’Silva submits interim report to North Goa SP and DIG. • January 25, 2011 – Panjim PI Sandesh Chodankar, PSI Radesh Ramnathkar and head constable Sandip Shirvaikar suspended. • January 28, 2011 – Panjim JMFC starts criminal proceedings. SDM Sabaji Shetye and GMCH forensic chief Dr Silvano Sapeco testify and state that Cipriano died in police custody.
SDM Sabaji Shetye to JMFC: Cipriano died in police custody TEAM HERALD PANJIM, JAN 28
A forensic expert and a sub divisional magistrate delivered a telling blow to those in the Goa Police, trying to cover up the gruesome custodial death of Cipriano Fernandes. The Sub Divisional Magistrate (SDM) Sabaji Shetye told the judicial magistrate first class (JMFC) that “Cipriano’s death occurred in custody”. No less potent was the deposition of Dr Silvano Sapeco, head of the Forensic Department of the Goa Medical College, who in clear and simple terms said that he was killed due to an injury by a sharp blunt object on the middle and left portion of his skull which caused an internal swelling of the brain. These injuries, the SDM remarked, were “fatal” and the cause of his death. In a very strong and clear deposition in court, Sheyte said “In my opinion, Cipriano’s death occurred in custody which was
revealed during my course of inquiry as per the deposition of forensic doctors who stated that injuries on Cipriano were inflicted while in police custody.”
the head) and injury 7 (left portion).” He died due to surface injuries with a blunt force object on the skull, elbow, joint, right
WhY ‘death in custodY’ If injuries to a person are caused in police custody which are a cause of his death even if he dies after being released on bail and/or during medical treatment, it is legally termed as ‘death in custody’. Shetye, it is now learnt, relied on Dr Sapeco’s findings, which were made clear to the court by the forensic expert himself. The forensic chief and a team of forensic doctors had conducted post-mortem on Cipriano’s body. This is what he told the court: “The cause of Cipriano’s death is due to sequelae of concussive head injury sustained as a result of cumulative effect of injury no. 6 (middle portion of
aspect of skull and left hand. - A few other injuries were three days old Shetye said that his inquiry is yet to come to a conclusion even as it has recorded statements of around 30 witnesses so far. The JMFC under Section 176(1) (A) had taken cognizance of the case after a human rights activist Jowett D Souza approached it after the Agasaim police station refused to register
The CM is backing the wrong horse Your police has gone out of hand: mauvin tells ravi SuJAy GuPTA PANJIM, JAN 28
Chief Minister Digambar Kamat’s steadfast reluctance to upset Home Minister Ravi Naik’s apple cart, is bound to have a severe backlash on the fortunes of the party. Notwithstanding the pressure built by party MLAs, to change his portfolio, including an open admonishment of the chief minister by Cortalim MLA, Mauvin Godinho at the last Congress legislature party (CLP) meeting in the presence of General Secretary Hari Prasad, the chief minister wants “status quo” till the next assembly elections. His personal logic, insiders
point out, is not to upset the caste arithmetic which according to him, could swing votes in as many as nine or 10 constituencies. Kamat feels that if Ravi Naik is “hurt”, the Bhandari votes in the Ponda and neighbouring Bicholim talukas could
the inside storY move away from the Congress towards the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). And to take his argument further, there is no guarantee that Ravi will not do business with the BJP in the next elections and wean away the Bhandari (which forms more than 95% of the Hindu votes)
community. To further his argument the chief minister’s camp feels that the two ministers dropped from the Digambar team, Dayanand Narvekar and Pandurang Madkaikar, were not from the upper castes. With Ravi added to the list, the tag of being forward caste-friendly might affect the government. Unfortunately, this logic, in the ultimate analysis, does not pass muster. The Ponda, Bicholim and Sattari talukas are well policed and protected by the Dhavlikar brothers, Vishwajeet Rane and Goa Pradesh Congress Committee (GPCC) chief Subhash Shirodkar, who can get (Continued on page 10)
his complaint dated 15.01. 2011 as an FIR (first information report), stating that police officers of Panjim police were responsible for his death On Friday this court initiated criminal proceedings in the case which could pave the way for the arrest of the suspended police officers as well others on duty. Continuing the case trial, the JMFC will record statements of the suspended Police Inspector Sandesh Chodankar and the deceased’s family members on Saturday. Cipriano’s family has refused to take over Cipriano’s body till the SDM discloses his report after completion of the inquiry.
herald eXclusiVe
l
I saw him getting tortured, dragged and beaten: Georgina Nunes
— Page 2
“Unless all culprits involving in arresting and torturing my cousin are behind bars, I will not be satisfied. The driver of the Bolero jeep (Ryan) should be arrested and interrogated as he will expose lot of things as he was driving the vehicle in which Cipriano was brought from Porvorim to Panjim police station. Also, Cipriano’s shoes and bundle of money of around Rs 45,000 are missing.” — Cosme Fernandes, cousin
cVc refuses to quit HERALD CORRESPONDENT NEW DELHI, JAN 28
Central Vigilance Commissioner P J Thomas has dug his heels refusing to resign from the post even as the government and the Congress were groping in dark on how to wriggle out of the huge embarrassment on his appointment ignoring the corruption case of palmolein import pending against him. Prime Minister Manmohan Singh reportedly pulled up Law Minister M Veerappa Moily for floating reports, after meeting him on Thursday, that the CVC is being asked to resign. His reb u ke c a m e a f t e r T h o m a s protested that any such resignation would amount to acceptance of taint that is too painful for him, coming at the end of his career as a bureaucrat. Sources denied any proposal made to Thomas in this regard
and also denied any kind of offer for rehabilitation in another form if he obliged with the resignation. Such reports had surfaced in November also and were promptly denied, they said The government is keeping its fingers crossed, hoping that a face-saver may come from the Supreme Court by quashing his appointment as irregular. Its embarrassment, however, may continue for long as the court is not expected to conclude hearing on the public interest litigation (PIL) so fast to pass the judgement. The next hearing is on February 3. Congress leaders egging on the government to request President Pratibha Patil to at least suspend Thomas, as done early this month in case of Prasar Bharti Chief Executive Officer B S Lalli, were told that it is not (Continued on page 10)
Will the killers be arrested for homicide l
l
In a charge for cognizable offence of a serious nature as homicide, the charges have to be registered in the police station, paving the way for their arrest for investigations. This is likely to happen after DySP Boussette D’Silva gives his final report and SDM Shetye his inquiry report. The court can also order the police to arrest them.
in the line of fire • Police Inspector Sandesh Chodankar – suspended - could be charged with vicarious liability (where the servant acts through the master). As head of the force at the police station, he was the master. • Police Sub-Inspector Radesh Ramnathkar – suspended. • Head constable Sandip Shirvaikar – suspended. • Police Sub-Inspector Vijay Chodankar – duty officer on January 8, 8 am to January 9, 8 am – still not suspended.