Circuit Synthesis Optimization
Hillol.Sarkar@ago-inc.com 1
Š Copyright AgO Inc 2011
www.ago-inc.com
100X Faster Simulation and Six Sigma Optimization
2
Š Copyright AgO Inc 2011
Challenges in Analog & RF Design Maximising yield • Validating greater numbers of process, voltage and temperature corners • Efficiently centering design across all PVT corners using Monte Carlo Achieving design specification • Meeting or beating performance while minimising cost of implementation • Managing greater complexity in operating and power saving modes Respin avoidance • Analog circuits are responsible for ~ 50% of IC design re-spins • Re-spins can mean missing market windows and unbudgeted costs Design porting • Moving existing circuit designs to similar technologies • Re-centering design to meet constraints of new technology 3
© Copyright AgO Inc 2011
Classic Analog Design Methodology • Design methodology has changed little over the years • Manual, iterative design with many SPICE runs Design specification & constraints
Define topology & resize devices
Spice
Physical layout & adjust Spice Extraction Layout verification 4
© Copyright AgO Inc 2011
Optimization Strategy
Description • DC Operation • Increase Margin • Quick check • Best Design Space
Description • Single Corner • Meet performance • Monte Carlo • Ready for Center
Description • All Corners • Rapid Size • Ready for P&R
AgO Optimization Strategy 5
© Copyright AgO Inc 2011
Description • Conflict • Change Priority • System Analysis
AnXplorer Goals • • • • • •
6
Quickly size W/L a circuit in a given technology Explore suitability of different design options Robust design over PVT & Monte Carlo Support all types of devices Explore results using database Optimize production yield
© Copyright AgO Inc 2011
AgO Design Methodology AnXplorer automates device sizing Design specification & constraints
Define topology
Feasibility Global
Physical layout & adjust
Extraction Layout verification
7
Š Copyright AgO Inc 2011
Centering
Porting of Existing Circuits Common challenge • Port existing design in technology X (say 180 nm) to technology Y (in 180 nm) • Ensure that original design goals are met
AnXplorer approach • Start with original sized circuit • Define variable ranges for target circuit • “One click” command • Optimises and centers with new PVT corners
8
© Copyright AgO Inc 2011
Vendor X
Same Node Porting Vendor Y
Prioritized Design Objectives • Most tools support a weight-based prioritization for multiple objectives – Designer is often unsure of relative weights
• AnXplorer supports hierarchical design objectives – User defines relative priority of different objectives
• AnXplorer achieves important objectives before optimizing others
9
© Copyright AgO Inc 2011
Implicit Objectives Correct by Construction • Imposes implicit objectives on conditions of devices at DC operating point • Customizable objectives • Detects common sub-circuits and imposes constraints on their operating conditions • Ensures a robust DC operating point • Feature only available for MOS devices
Examples of subcircuits:
• transistors in • • • • • • •
10
© Copyright AgO Inc 2011
saturation transistors in linear region current mirrors level shifters differential pairs voltage reference current mirror banks etc
Core Optimization Technology Early Optimisation tools • Frequently relied on traditional convex/gradient methods • These are known to have difficulty with multiple local minima AnXplorer • Based on Evolutionary algorithm • Capable of finding global minimum in presence of many local minima • Successfully optimised tough tests e.g. Rastrigin’s function • Optional logarithmic partitioning of design space 11
© Copyright AgO Inc 2011
Supports both simulation-based optimization & equation-based optimization
Multiple Local Minimum
12
Š Copyright AgO Inc 2011
Trade-off Analysis • Finds multiple design points satisfying design objectives • Creates exploration database for postoptimization analysis – Database stores all explored design points – Query language or GUI
• Useful for trade-off analysis with conflicting objectives • Useful for “what-if” analysis 13
© Copyright AgO Inc 2011
Industry Standard Formats Compatible with existing design flows Un-sized circuit Schematics
Definition of Design variables
Design objectives
AnXplorer
Sized and centered net list
14
Š Copyright AgO Inc 2011
Exploration database for Trade off analysis
Design Environment • Spice Simulators Silvaco SmartSpice Cadence Spectre Synopsys Spice Simulators Mentor Eldo Multi-threading support
• Operating system Red Hat RHEL 5
15
© Copyright AgO Inc 2011
Silvaco • Accurate circuit simulation • 100% HSPICE and SPECTRE compatible Netlists • Single event effect reliability analysis • A leader in run-time simulation speed • Largest collection of Spice Models
16
© Copyright AgO Inc 2011
Competitive Differentiation • One product, four optimization steps • Robust Centering to maximize yield –Monte Carlo • Implicit objectives for stable DC operation • Hierarchical design objectives • User can perform trade-off analysis • Industry standard formats and simulators • Core based on Evolutionary Algorithm
17
© Copyright AgO Inc 2011
Monte Carlo Design for Six Sigma
DFSS Company
18
Š Copyright AgO Inc 2011