Inklings
December 20, 2013 Founded in 1933 inklingsnews.com
Drama reduced in favor of engineering classes BEN GOLDSCHLAGER ’14 Web News Editor
O
n Monday, Dec. 2, the Board of Education (BOE) unanimously passed a measure that expands middle school engineering classes while making other cuts, most controversially to eighth grade drama and presentation skills classes. Reaction to the board’s decision was varied. This year, eighth graders spend one period a week in an engineering course. The proposal, to be implemented for the 2014-2015 school year, expands this to two periods per week and adds one period per week for sixth and seventh graders. To make room for the engineering classes, the measure cuts drama and presentation skills in the eighth grade and reduces it in sixth grade; computer classes in the earlier grades are also cut. This represents a cut of 12 hours of drama and presentation skills over three years, Director of Secondary Education Lisabeth Comm said. The administ ration stressed that somet h i n g had to go to make room for the engineering classes and that they did not
want to eliminate any programs. Ultimately, at the BOE meeting, Superintendent Elliott Landon called the proposal “balanced.” The administration emphasized the importance of exposing students to engineering in middle school. According to Science Department Chair A.J. Scheetz, this improves perceptions of engineering as a career. “Eleven percent of all engineers in the U.S. are female,” Scheetz said. “Giving children, including girls, that exposure would hopefully lead to a more positive perception of pursuing engineering,” he said. He also noted benefits to students’ 21st century skills, specifically the ability to critically evaluate students’ own products and then revise for improvement. However, many are against cutting drama and presentation skills at all, viewing it as essential for the development of communication skills in middle schoolers. Darcy Hicks, a parent of two middle schoolers and a specialist in curriculum development on the arts for the New Haven Public Schools, noted the “confidence and skills that come out of a drama class.” She pointed to the “alarming speed,” with which the engineering program is moving. “To go from a two month program to quadrupling the hours is rash to say the least,” she said. Her main qualm, however, is not with expanding the engineering classes but with cutting the arts. Bedford drama and presentation skills teacher Karen Mc-
Cormick, however, was mostly positive on the proposal, calling the engineering program a “really good idea.” “I think [thee BOE] means well,” she added. “They just valg more.” ue the engineering rmick said she While McCormick wishes that dramaa and presentation skills hadn’tt been cut, she agreed with the BOE that something had too be cut, and, if it had to be drama and presentationn skills, she is glad that it was the sses. “As eighth grade classes. long as they leave the sixth and sses intact, I seventh grade classes think there won’tt be a major aid. difference,” she said. Supporters off the proposal emphasized that students can learn presentationn skills without a dedicated class. “In every subject, students aree having more ce with giving and more practice presentations,” Comm said. She argued that this more than makes up for the elimination of presentation skills in eighth grade. However, some are skeptical of this approach. “Social studies teachers are there to teach social studies, and they’re busy doing that. They’re not trained nor do they have time in class to teach students how to [present] effectively,” Staples Players president Will Haskell said at the Nov. 25 BOE meeting. “Students need to enter the class with those skills already in their pockets, and that’s what middle school presentation skills does,” he added.
Popping the question Students ask teachers for college recommendations ANDREA FROST ’15 Features Editor
While the physical college application process does not begin until the beginning of senior year, some aspects start much earlier. As the months of May and June roll around, many junior teachers are flooded with one question from their junior students: will they write a letter of recommendation for college? Prior to posing this question to teachers, students are faced with many questions of their own. What teacher will write the best recommendation? When Kathryn Lieder ’14 was going through this process last spring, her guidance counselor suggested that she ask either a math or science teacher and also an English or social studies teacher, to balance her application. While this advice was very helpful, it was not the only factor that Lieder considered; she asked the teachers who she thought knew her best. “I think it’s important to not choose a certain teacher just because you did well in his or
GRAPHIC BY JULIA SCHORR ’16
Elementary school h l schedules h d l become more academic ELLIE GAVIN ’14 & JESSICA GROSS ’15 Staff Writer & Web News Editor
GRAPHIC BY JULIA SCHORR ’15
her class, but instead to choose a teacher of a class that you truly enjoyed, put a lot of effort into, and showed improvement in throughout the year,” Lieder explained. Many colleges agree with the approach that Lieder used to make her decision. According to the Vanderbilt University website regarding admissions, the university looks to a teacher recommendation to “humanize you and to tell us something we can’t find
Inside the Issue
out through your transcripts and test scores.” However, once an eager junior drops the question, it is up to the teacher to decide whether to write the recommendation or not. It’s not a required part of a teacher’s job but a favor to students, teachers said. And before teachers agree, many require that students sign a waiver that precludes the student
Continued on page 4
Teachers – They’re Just Like Us
A first grade teacher watches her students as the clock ticks towards 2:55. Little fingers rub tired eyes and stifle yawns. Beneath desks, legs shake restlessly. It’s been a long day. The teacher sighs and closes her classroom door. She grants her drained children fifteen minutes of what she calls “academic choice time.” Ten years ago, it was probably called play time, and it was probably allowed every day. “Ten years ago, elementary teachers were given a curriculum and multiple resources. They were allowed to deliver it as they saw fit for their class. A teacher could be creative in their approach, and veer off on topics that were of interest to students. There was time to delve deeply and also cast a wide net on all sorts of content,” an elementary school teacher (T1) said. Now, resources are mandated, aligned to state standards. “There is more
15
content than there are minutes in a day, and no time to teach anything but what is given.” At the same time, others said, change should occur in education. “Things get lost; other things appear,” another teacher (T4) said. “With changes in the curriculum, things always get lost in the shuffle.” Interviews with parents, students, and teachers suggest that the curriculum in recent years has become more academically rigorous and focused on testing. In accordance with this intensity, sources said, classrooms have become less playful, flexible and culturally rich. Five teachers at three different elementary schools who were interviewed asked that their names not be used. They are referred to as T1, T2, T3, T4 and T5. Superintendent Elliott Landon agreed that the system has changed and believes the changes
Continued on page 4
Girls’ Ice Hockey Goalie Casey Bang
23