Vol. 88, Issue 10
May 5, 2017
Staples High School
Inklings
INSIDE 1 7 11 17 21
News Opinions Features Arts Sports
Graphic by Melanie Lust ’19
‘13 Reasons Why’ removed for review from middle school English book rooms, Bedford library
A
Melanie Lust ’19
ll hard copies of “13 Reasons Why” were removed from the Bedford Middle School library and from Bedford and Coleytown’s English book rooms on Monday, April 24, following concerns about the popular Netflix Original show’s adaptation. According to Coleytown’s librarian, John Horrigan, the book would have also been pulled from his library, but the only copy was missing. In response to parent outcries, Superintendent Dr. Colleen Palmer sent a mass email to parents on Friday, April 21 warning of the graphic depictions of suicide and sexual assault found in the Netflix series. The email included talking points for parents to have with children who may have been watching the show. “Many students were watching it
and the content could affect adolescents, especially pre-adolescents, in various different ways,” Palmer said. “We just want parents to understand what their students are watching and give them resources so they can have thoughtful conversations with their students.” The following Monday, the books were removed from the middle schools. “I asked that we do a temporary review [of the book], and based on the level of concern from our parents, I asked that while we’re reviewing [the t.v. show], if we would not leave [the book] out,” Palmer said. “I know that middle schoolers especially might be overwhelmed by that content that they maybe don’t understand or can’t process.” According to the Westport Public School’s Board of Education [BOE] Policy Manual, typical Westport procedure for removing books consists of a ten-step
70 North Ave., Westport, Connecticut
review, where a written parent complaint is filed first through educators, followed by a review by the building principal and the Superintendent Review Committee, before reaching the Superintendent for final review. During the review, the material in question remains in schools until a decision is made. Palmer’s decision to directly pull “13 Reasons Why” from the book rooms and Bedford’s library breaks with the established Westport book review procedure. “It goes against BOE policy,” Horrigan said. “There was no written challenge so the school system has no right to [intervene].” However, Palmer defended her decision to pull the book. “Under typical situations where there is no concern about the well-being of our students, I don’t think books would be removed; I think they would remain. This was an unusual
circumstance in which parents articulated concern about the safety and well-being of students.” A committee of educators, led by Director of Technology Natalie Carrignan, has been called for additional review of the material and is set to meet the week of May 1. Added controversy surrounds the administration’s decision to pull the book from the middle school library because doing so may be in violation of the 1982 Supreme Court ruling in BOE v. Pico. The court decided in a 5-4 decision that school libraries were protected “centers for voluntary inquiry and the dissemination of information and ideas,” and that “school libraries enjoy a special affinity with the rights of free speech and press,” according to Oyez, an archive of the Supreme Court of the United States. When Palmer was asked if she continued on page 2
inklingsnews.com