Infinite Fields of Millet An Investigation into the Cosmic Distribution of Intelligent Life In this short article we examine the likelihood of intelligent species with highly developed technologies, “extraterrestrials,” occurring in widespread distributions of technocultural civilisations throughout the cosmos. As a base-reference we may take account of the so-called Drake Equation which derives a set of probabilities for the emergence, simultaneous existence, inter-contact and intercommunication capabilities of intelligent species – these however span an uncertain and disappointing range of confidence from very small to large numbers. The Drake Equation was originally devised by Dr. Frank Drake, professor Emeritus of Astronomy and Astrophysics at UCAL, in 1960. Its purpose was to quantify the number of extraterrestrial civilisations that humanity on Earth might come into contact with and to more closely quantify the uncertainties of these parameters. Here not only will the Drake Equation not be repeated but neither its parameters nor a technical analysis of it will be discussed per se. This may appear abstruse - the reason however will become clear as the treatment here will be seen to fundamentally affect axiomatic assumptions which are quite transparently implicit, and unquestioned in the classical version of the Drake Equation, and as a conclusion, dismiss the validity of any interpretation based on it. These foundational assumptions will be analysed. Note that this does not specifically dismiss the alleged, or ascertainable validity of the Drake Equation's included parameters themselves - this is neither implied nor the intention. Instead, the perspective attained will be that the classical version of the Drake Equation is wholly invalid as it excludes fundamental considerations which are strongly felt to imply and derive acutely contrasting results to any possible spectrum of interpretations based on the equation. 1
Introduction The paradigmatic background in which the original Drake Equation was formalised takes into account axiomatic assumptions which are not explicitly stated in any original or later treatment of it - these axioma may confidently be restated as follows: 1. The ontological universe is regarded to be a continuum precipitously divided into two main subcontinua - one of non-living, “inorganic” matter-energy complexes, and another of organic, living matterenergy complexes which form a continuum of organicity in which life may reach advanced levels of complexity such as evident (among others) in the human species. 2. The capacity to perceive the existence of extraterrestrial intelligent species is based on the potential occurrence of ratifiable and repeatable events falling mainly into a single category: communications between our human species and such an extraterrestrially based species based specifically on, and limited to, electromagnetic propagation and exchange of information. It is to be noted that Emag. propagation of information is limited to lightspeed as its upper limit. A. A tacit assumption of the classical Drake Equation strongly implies that communication systems based on Emag technology are specifically the only possible technical solution to inter-species communication on an inter-system basis. The term “inter-system” is here used in the sense of interstellar (or even intergalactic) planetary systems, assuming that the logical ecological home-base of an intelligent 1
For those interested in a full and extended technical treatment of the classical Drake Equation the Wikipedia article based on it is advised to be excellent. Fields of Millet Copyright © Frank Valentyn 2007 to Present; All Rights Reserved Page 1 of 30