Siesta Sand - February 2025 by Brion Palmer

Commissioner Tom Knight Outlines Vision

Appeared on recent Siesta Sand Live Podcast

By Jane Bartnett

Sarasota County Commissioner Tom Knight, who took office in November 2024, shared his vision for his four-year term during a midJanuary appearance on Siesta Sand’s Siesta Live podcast.

In the wide-ranging interview with host Natalie Gutwein, Knight, a Republican from Venice representing District 3, which includes Venice, Wellen Park, and North Port, discussed his priorities as the fifth member of the Sarasota County Commission.

Knight, a well-known figure in

Sarasota County and across Florida, served as Sarasota County Sheriff for 12 years, from 2008 until his retirement in 2020. During his tenure, he managed a $121 million budget and oversaw 1,000 employees, covering law enforcement, corrections, court security, animal services, and 911 operations. His leadership was credited with reducing crime by more than 50% and earning national recognition for inmate recovery programs that lowered recidivism and

Continued on page 26

Modest Increase in Condo Insurance Rates Anticipated

oncerns that wind and flood insurance premiums for condominiums will skyrocket in 2025 may be exaggerated, according to a

During a recent online presentation to the Siesta Key Condominium Council, Mike Angers, senior vice president at

By Ned Steele

Brown & Brown Sarasota, expressed optimism about potential rate increases, despite the triple impact of Hurricanes Debby, Helene, and Milton in 2024.

“I think we’re going to do better than expected,” Angers said, noting that flood insurers have already requested an 18% increase. However, he advised

condominium associations and managers to plan for a more modest 10% rise. For wind coverage, Angers reported that rate increase requests so far have ranged from about 5% to remaining flat, with some cases even showing decreases. He emphasized that these estimates are Continued on page 18

Mike Angers, senior vice president at Brown & Brown Sarasota, expressed optimism about potential rate increases.

Work on Siesta Key roads has resumed

Resurfacing and milling work on Siesta Key roads resumed on Jan. 13 after being halted by Hurricanes Helene and Milton last year. Sarasota County initially began the project on Aug. 7 but paused it until mid-January due to the storms.

Several residential roads on the northern end of the Key, between Ocean Boulevard and Midnight Pass Road, have already been completed. In mid-January, roadwork began on Commonwealth Drive, Birdsong Lane, Dewy Place, Oakmont Place, Winding Way, Siesta Cove Drive, North View Drive, and South View Drive.

Notification to residents on the respective street work will be by door hanger, approximately 3-days in advance of the milling and paving operation.

Terra Ray, the county’s Siesta Key construction project manager, reported that work on Beach Road will start on April 20, following the Easter holiday. All the work on Beach Road will occur overnight to avoid peak tourist season traffic and to minimize impacts. Once completed, most of Beach Road from the Midnight Pass intersection will be resurfaced, with additional reinforcement planned for the heavily trafficked section near Siesta Beach.

Scheduled work on the southern end of the Key includes Point of Rocks Road,

By Jane Bartnett

Siesta Key Resurfacing

Point of Rocks Circle, Crescent Street, and Dee Place. Ray advised that intermittent lane closures will occur during the work and urged drivers and pedestrians to exercise caution.

Since August, the county has resurfaced 19 lane miles, with the entire project covering

about 37 lane miles on and off the Key. Project updates can be found on the ResurfacingSiesta Key webpage: https:// www.scgov.net/government/ capital-projects/selectedcounty-projects/resurfacingsiesta-key.

The $11.36 million project

includes milling and paving, pavement striping, Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) ramp modifications, curb repairs, roadway base repairs, and school zone sign improvements. Ray presented the project to the Siesta Key Association in June, noting that funding comes from the Sarasota County Penny Surtax. Ajax Paving is the contractor. Construction will take place Monday through Saturday, from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m., excluding holidays. The project is expected to be completed by summer.

Water Safety: A Daily Priority on Siesta Key

By Hannah Wallace

Spring comes at you fast on Siesta Key. The idyllic temps, combined with spring break school holidays near and far, draw crowds of all ages to beaches, pools, and boat-filled waterways. Unfortunately, all that exuberance and relaxation often overlooks the risks of serious injury in and around the water.

When it comes to mitigating those risks, there are professionals devoted to help. But by taking adequate steps before and during beach days and boat trips, individuals can set themselves up for safety while still enjoying everything Siesta has to offer.

First Responders Prepare for Spring

In case of trouble on the water, first responders, including lifeguards, represent “the first line of response and defense,” said Tim Dorsey, the Assistant Fire Chief of Special Operations for Sarasota County, which oversees lifeguard operations.

Many local beaches have a lifeguard presence from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., 365 days a year. But better weather

and bigger crowds call for increased vigilance.

“Every year before spring break we ramp up our operations. During spring break, holiday weekends, we increase the lifeguard presence on the beach and extend their time on the beach until 7,” said Dorsey.

“In concert with that, we have our Fire Rescue boat on the water 12 hours a day in ready patrol.

That’s in partnership with the Sarasota Sheriff and Sarasota Police department marine operations.”

Every 911 call is treated as a worst-case scenario.

“We don’t really know what’s going on until we get someone there, eyes on the scene, explained Dorsey.

“If we have any incidents— like rescue incidents, boat accidents—there’ll be two fire rescue boats and law enforcement boat on the scene. And then from there we can determine if we need to acquire more resources.”

But before it comes to that, prevention remains a top priority for first responders.

“First of all, one of the best things lifeguards do, they are constantly watching the beach,” said Dorsey.

“The watching the water to

perform some preventative actions, to stop the train of incidents that ultimately require additional resources. If they see somebody doing something wrong, they address it immediately to prevent something worse from occurring.”

Personal Water Safety

That being said, the onus for water safety isn’t on emergency services alone. Responsible behavior, along with an understanding of risks and signs of trouble, can help keep everyone safer.

Currents, marine life, heat, medical issues, and boat accidents, combined with alcohol and exhaustion, represent the most common issues in and around the water.

When it comes to natural threats, rip currents are enemy No. 1. Occurring at any time of day, a rip current is a flow of water moving quickly from the shoreline outward. Swimmers finding themselves being pulled away from shore often panic, trying to swim against the tide to return to shallow water. Unfortunately, this can lead to exhaustion, which is the real threat, even

South Bridge Repair Schedule Slips

Expect longer travel times on and off Siesta Key, as lane closures on the Stickney Point Bridge will continue into February, according to the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT).

The lane closures are part of a $2.4 million renovation of the 57-year-old bridge, originally slated for completion by the end of 2024. Delays, primarily caused by storms Helene and Milton, have pushed the expected completion date to early March, pending weather conditions, FDOT said.

FDOT does not anticipate any further full shutdowns of the bridge, though lane closures will persist “on an as-needed basis,” according to an FDOT spokesperson. These closures have caused significant traffic

delays, frustrating residents, businesses, and visitors who had hoped the work would be completed before the winter tourist season.

Concerns have been raised about potential delays in access to emergency medical services due to the lane closures.

While specific dates and times for lane closures form February were not available at press time, FDOT provides weekly updates on its RoadWatch report online.

The renovation project involves upgrading machinery, repaving approaches, and replacing structural steel components of the bridge’s movable sections. FDOT stated that marine traffic should experience minimal impact from the ongoing work.

By Ned Steele

Come experience Bay Village’s stunning and expansive renovation, where every detail was crafted to enhance the experience and beauty of this vibrant and caring community.

Please call us at 941.966.5611 to schedule a tour and learn more.

Scan the QR Code to visit our website.

Traffic onto Siesta Key slows down due to lane closure to accommodate bridge repairs. (Photo by Ned Steele)

Key Chapel 4615 Gleason Ave

MAIN: DAN LOBECK

SPEAKER: Law O ices of Lobeck & Rowe

2024 Legislation A ecting Condominiums

SIRS Reserves, Milestone Inspections

Director Education, Financial Reports

Hidden (Latent) Construction Defect Claims Management Records Transfer, Conflicts of Interest Hurricane Protection, Criminal Penalties Association Records Access, Website Records Board Meetings, Division Jurisdiction Protections for Troublesome Unit Owners

2025 Legislative Preview

Potential Relief from IRS Reserves, Insurance Hikes Other (Legislative Session is March 4 to May 2) Question & Answer Session with Audience

Exciting additions at Siesta Village Plaza

In the heart of Siesta Key, the shopping and dining destination formerly known as Davidson Plaza has been renamed Siesta Village Plaza, welcoming a variety of new retail options.

Anchored by Kilwin’s Ice Cream on the southern corner and Cafe Gabbiano on the northern end, the plaza has seen the addition of three new stores in the past six months.

In December, Sea Bags Maine opened its doors. Located next to the Siesta Key Wine Bar and nestled between Local Bean Coffee & Tea and Siesta Village Dentistry, this boutique offers a wide range of handcrafted bags made from 100% recycled sailcloth. The store’s inventory includes wristlets, wine bags, totes, chairs, and weekend bags, making it one of 40 Sea Bags Maine locations in coastal communities.

Sailors can participate in the Sea Bags’ Sail Trade Program by bringing in used sails for recycling. Accepted sails are sent to the Portland, Maine, factory, where they are cleaned and repurposed. In return, donors receive a Sea Bags product or can opt to donate the sail’s value to a children’s sailing program. More information about the program is available at seabags.com.

During the summer, a Tommy Bahama store opened in the plaza’s corner space, offering casual coastal clothing and accessories for men and women.

The former Davidson Drug store space is under construction and will soon house an Alvin’s Island store. Long-standing retailers like Lilly Pulitzer continue to thrive in the plaza, while Southern Tide, a sister brand to Lilly Pulitzer and Tommy Bahama, is set to celebrate its second anniversary this summer.

By Jane Bartnett

Known for its active sportswear, Southern Tide serves both men and women.

Rochelle’s on Siesta, offering youthful and trendy fashion, opened in December in the former Siesta Key Chamber of Commerce space. This is Rochelle’s fifth location, featuring designers such as Beach Riot, Free People, Sunkissed Coconut, and Z Supply. The boutique also operates stores in St. Armand’s Circle, Mystic, Connecticut, and Newport and Watch Hill, Rhode Island.

Comfort Shoes Birkenstocks & More, previously located in the northern corner near

Tommy Bahama, has relocated next to Rochelle’s on Siesta, taking over the former Edward Jones space. The family-owned business has been serving Sarasota for over 30 years, offering a selection of comfort sandals, sneakers, clogs, and shoes from brands like Merrell, NAOT, Relaxology, Teva, and Birkenstocks.

Island House Tap & Grill, known for its tacos, burgers, and wide selection of craft beers, remains in its original location, adjacent to Cafe Gabbiano, which continues to draw diners with its extensive wine collection and fine dining experience.

Davidson Plaza is now called Siesta Village Plaza. (Jane Bartnett photo)

Sea Bags Maine is now open in the Siesta Village Plaza (Jane Bartnett photo)

Community Spotlight

Jonathan Poyner celebrates his fifth anniversary as manager of world-famous Siesta Beach next month.

Who runs this beautiful beach? Who do you work for?

ASarasota County operates Siesta Beach. As an employee of Sarasota County, I help manage the beach parks.

Q Where are you from?

AI am a native of Virginia Beach. Salt water is in me. I guess it’s a perfect match.

Q Were you a “beach bum” as a young person?

AI surfed and I sailed.

QIt sounds like beaches have been a part of your life for a long time. What is special to you about a beach?

AThis job is like a calling to me. When we get near water, there’s a peace that comes over us. That’s not a surprise. If you think about it, water is part of our very makeup as humans. We are 60% water. The beach parks in Sarasota County are some of the best places. I feel honored to be part of the team that manages these wonderful resources for the citizens and visitors.

QWhat did you do in your early career before coming here?

AI was a college recruiter and then a youth minister in Virginia and North Carolina. My wife was offered a teaching job in Bradenton in 2002, and we moved down

Best Beach, Best Job

By Ned Steele

here. After doing other jobs I started with the county parks and recreation department as an event and rec center organizer. Most of the job involved youth programs: Easter egg hunts, video game competitions, etc. But there were events that got me onto the beach as well: the Sandy Claws run and summer beach runs for the kids.

QLet me guess. You liked that part of the work?

A I would come to the beach to run events and dream of one day having the chance to take care of such valuable resources. I was so happy when that dream was finally realized, and my career lined up with my passion for serving others in coastal environment.

QThat would be March 2020. A rather eventful time.

AI started just as Covid hit. The beach was closed and barricaded by the police for six weeks. There was not a soul here. The land was able to breathe and restore. It was actually a great time to come into the job. Instead of hosting spring break we restored the access areas and did major, deep cleaning.

QWhat has been the highlight of your tenure so far?

AIn 2016 we undertook a $20 million renovation of the beach and facilities and turned it into what it is today.

QWhat would you say is your philosophy of operating a public beach?

A I believe that a park is the product that we deliver, but people is what it’s really all about. Some of the people who come here

are visitors from other places; some of them are people who come here every day of their lives and have their special spots on the beach. There are people from all over the world who have visited us and go back home where they look at our beach camera every day. They’re dreaming of the day they can come back here. And we will welcome them when they do.

Q What does your typical day consist of?

AVisitor service, administration, maintenance, preservation and resource management. But what I love most is to talk to the people who visit.

How many people are on the beach staff?

A We have fifty employees. Some of the work can get very rote: cleaning up the

trash, keeping the bathrooms clean. As a worker, you must know there is purpose and value to what you do. Our staff are people who make a difference, and I like to remind them of the value they bring to the public. The beach attendant is more important than my job is. Joy is service to others. Our staff has joy. You need joy to do these jobs, and our people have it.

Q How is the beach doing after the Fall hurricanes?

A It is firing on all cylinders. This was the first county beach that was reactivated, it was a priority. It is clean, safe and accessible.

Q It sounds like you love your job.

AIf you can align your joy and your passion with what you do in your career, what greater thing is there?

Poyner and some of his team (Photo by Ned Steele)

Jonathan Poyner gets to go to the beach every day for work (Photo by Ned Steele)

- Angela Rizzi, Naples, FL

- Neha Ketkar, Sarasota, FL

12-17-24 Theft

Complainant reported that he had rented two E-bikes to a customer who was staying at a condominium on Siesta Key. He reported that both E-bikes were secured to a chain link fence at the condo and that an unknown person cut the chains of the E-bikes, left the chains on the floor, and stole the E-bikes. The total value of both E-bikes is

12-03-24

Theft

Complainant reported that between approximately 11-24-24 and 12-1-24 someone stole a 12-foot by 20-foot dock located behind the victim’s home. Complainant advised the dock was wood and composite construction and had repairable damage from prior hurricanes. Complainant advised the dock was out of the water and in the backyard at the time of the theft.

Sherrif’s Report

12-05-24 Theft

Complainant owns a condo on Siesta Key but lives out of state. She reported that after she left Siesta Key in April 2024, she realized she had left behind a necklace and charm on the necklace. A neighbor, at the request of complainant, placed the necklace and charm in a nightstand at the complainant’s condo. After Hurricane Milton, the condo association hired contractors to do repairs on the condo and therefore, she advised, she believed there had been several people in and out of her condo while she was out of state. When she returned to her condo in Nov. 2024, she discovered that the necklace and charm were missing from her nightstand along with two jars of moisturizer.

12-04-24 Theft

Complainant reported that she had her E-bike at work at

a restaurant in the Village on Sept. 21, 2024, and believe that between 9 a.m. and Noon the E-bike was taken. The bike was not secured. Complainant provided a picture of the person she believes took her E-bike, as well as a picture of his backpack next to her E-bike. The pictures were submitted into evidence.

12-05-24 Battery

Sheriff’s deputy was dispatched to a work site due to an alleged battery. Complainant, the building supervisor, indicated that a worker was being removed from the job site due to his poor attitude and conflict with the alleged victim. Alleged victim indicated that he was arguing with the suspect about a specific job-related detail, the suspect then swore at the alleged victim and then a physical altercation ensued.

Looking for a good casual fish house in Sarasota, we discovered Fresh Catch Fish Market & Grill, tucked away in a strip mall on 41. What a wonderful find.

There were four of us for dinner, and we made a reservation-thankfully so, as by 6 PM on a weekday, all the dining tables were full. This place is clearly popular, and for good reason. Here are three highlights:

1. Fresh, Well-Seasoned Fish I ordered the grilled grouper sandwich on a brioche bun, and it was delicious; perfectly cooked, properly seasoned, and a generous portion. For my side, I had coleslaw, which was fresh and light, not overpowered by too much mayonnaise.

2. Relaxed, Comfortable Atmosphere

The restaurant has a casual coastal vibe. It's a neighborhood spot that feels welcoming and unpretentious, perfect for hanging out over a good meal and a cold beer. Wear your shorts and flip-flops if you want. They have outdoor patio seating, too.

3. Attentive, Efficient Service

Our server was friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable, explaining the menu without being pushy. Everyone in our group got exactly what they wanted, and all the dishes were served just as ordered. In addition to my grouper sandwich, two of us had the red snapper plate, and the other had mahi-mahi plate. Everyone raved about their meals.

If you're looking for fresh fish in a casual setting, give this place a try. You won't be disappointed. Salute!

A symbolic milestone in the recovery from 2024’s hurricanes is set to occur this month as Sarasota County wraps up operations and shuts down the makeshift debris site at the 24acre Benderson property near Stickney Point Road and South Tamiami Trail.

Wendi Crisp, a Sarasota County Solid Waste official, confirmed that the site is expected to be restored and handed back to its owner by the end of January. This marks a significant step in moving past the devastation caused by hurricanes Debby, Helene, and Milton.

In the aftermath of the storms, the county urgently

The Dump is Done

By Ned Steele

Happiness is…Love

February is the month of love, and Abel’s Ice Cream is here to make it even sweeter! The owners, Jerry and Jill Williams, have focused their attention on serving up the best ice cream around with an emphasis on bringing exciting new options to their beloved customers. In addition to their classic favorites, they now offer delicious lattes and an assortment of hot teas from the Local Tea Company to warm you up.

Looking for the perfect way to show someone you care? Abel’s has got you covered! Pick up handmade, all-natural chocolates from Sweet Shop Chocolates USA-a delicious way to sweeten your Valentine’s Day.

Or bring your sweetheart in to share a banana split or enjoy a cup or cone of one of Abel’s featured flavors like irresistible

Whether you’re an experienced athlete or just beginning your fitness journey, we have something for

Ready to take the first step? Come visit us today for a tour, a workout, or to experience our cold plunges and sauna firsthand. Let’s redefine what

needed a large space to handle the immense amount of residential and plant debris from Siesta Key and surrounding areas. A temporary agreement with Benderson Development allowed the county to use the undeveloped property. What followed were towering heaps of ruined drywall, plumbing fixtures, appliances, and uprooted trees, transforming the site into a necessary but unsightly part of the recovery process. By mid-December, the site had amassed over 580,000 cubic yards of waste. Around-theclock efforts by workers and bulldozers led to the sorting

Strawberry Cheesecake (The ultimate classic cheesecake ice cream, loaded with chunks of creamy cheesecake and a flavorful strawberry ribbon.) and Cherry Oblivion (Creamy black cherry ice cream, packed with black cherries and luscious liquid chocolate chips.)

Whether it’s a special treat for your loved one or a fun outing to enjoy together, Abel’s Ice Cream is here to make this month-and every month-extra special. Visit us today and spread the joy!

Abel's Ice Cream is located at 1886 Stickney Point Road, Sarasota in the South Bridge Plaza. Open Sunday through Thursday from Noon-9:30 pm, and Friday and Saturday from Noon-10 pm. Learn more online at www.abelsicecream.com or connect with us on Facebook and Instagram.

and relocation of residential and construction debris to a permanent landfill, while plant debris was processed into mulch.

Although the temporary dump site will close, the location will remain a point of contention. A lawsuit regarding a traffic light installed at the intersection continues to move through the courts.

Looking ahead, Benderson Development plans to transform the property into “Siesta Promenade,” a substantial mixed-use development featuring retail and restaurant spaces, apartments, offices, and an 80foot tall, 130-room hotel.

Going, going, gone…. To everyone’s relief. (Photo by Ned Steele)

U.S. Secretary Jeh Johnson offers his insights and analysis into the future of American Democracy and other critical issues. As Secretary of Homeland Security, Johnson was the head of the third largest cabinet department of the U.S. government, consisting of 230,000 personnel and 22 components, including TSA, Customs and Border Protection, Immigration and Customs Services, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, the Coast Guard, the Secret Service, and FEMA.

Visit sillsarasota.org or scan the QR code for more information. Tickets may be purchased at the door at any SILL event.

Sarasota CHURCH of the PALMS 10:30 am

Venice PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH 3:00 pm

Sarasota 1st METHODIST CHURCH 10:30 am

Venice COMMUNITY CENTER 2:30 pm

Lakewood Ranch CORNERSTONE CHURCH 11:00 am

Sarasota 1st METHODIST CHURCH 10:30 am

Lakewood Ranch CORNERSTONE CHURCH 5:00 pm Venice COMMUNITY CENTER 10:00 am

Idrinks, grab your beach gear, or stock up on beer, wine, snacks and key lime pie We have a full selection of groceries for a perfect island stay! s a y!

Hope, Faith and After

f a church is a haven for hope and faith, Siesta Key Chapel has been called upon to deliver on that mission like never before following Hurricanes Debby, Helene, and Milton.

Of its 150 year-round member families, 16—more than one in ten—lost their homes. A quarter of its 50 snowbird families had to delay their return to damaged residences.

Fortunately for those affected, the congregation has long emphasized mutual support and community, finding solace in the lofty, rustic house of worship they call “God’s treehouse.” In the immediate aftermath of the storms, parishioners and staff launched a robust outreach effort, using cell phones, emails, and door-to-door visits to identify members in need of assistance.

Their efforts uncovered many in need, and aid quickly followed, providing emergency supplies, temporary housing, and rides to doctors. Now, nearly four months later, the support continues. “We’re helping both church members and community members move belongings

from one temporary residence to another while condos and homes are being restored, advocating for healthcare and housing services, assisting with FEMA and insurance paperwork, and providing rides to church, grocery stores, and doctors. We’re also quietly offering gift cards for gas and groceries to those who have lost work due to the hurricanes,” said The Rev. Dr. Ruth Smalt, church pastor.

While anyone on the key who experienced hardship or loss was challenged by Mother Nature, the parishioners of Siesta Key Chapel seem to have borne more than their share of the burden:

• An elderly blind man in poor health had to be hospitalized after losing his home.

• A woman whose mainland home was damaged by Hurricane Debby moved to the key, only to have Hurricane Milton destroy that one too.

• A parishioner with dementia wandered off after the storm and was rescued by a church volunteer search party.

• A displaced man fell inside his unfamiliar temporary home but still showed up on

Milton

By Ned

Joyce and Sam Tucker outside the villa they had to flee.

Mary Metzler, “Sundays are less lonely

and Recovery Milton Steele

crutches the next day to join the congregation’s help brigade.

All this assistance was rendered while the church itself dealt with its own storm damage.

“I’m sure that without the church, this would have been much worse for us,” said Joyce Tucker, a 14-year member of Siesta Key Chapel. She and her husband, Sam, moved in with family in Nokomis after Helene poured nine inches of water into their ground-level midisland villa, destroying nearly everything. “All we saved was two mattresses and a couch,”

Sam said. The couple is grateful for the emotional support and offers of help they continue to receive from fellow worshipers.

“People are still calling,” Joyce said. “They’re asking how we are doing and if they can do anything for us.”

Despite the distance, the Tuckers drive to Sunday services at the church, and Joyce runs the post-service coffee hour, where members with losses gather informally to share tips on dealing with FEMA or finding reliable contractors. “Church is restorative for us,” Joyce said.

Mary Metzler, a retired engineer, watched in disbelief as Helene’s floodwaters poured into the north island home of her late parents, where she had been staying after Debby devastated her own mainland home. When the waters reached 32 inches, she climbed onto the kitchen island and spent the night there, surrounded by floating furniture and belongings.

Smoke began seeping from her stove. “I thought I was going to die,” she recalled.

The next day, she flagged down a motorist who drove her to a friend on the mainland, where she stayed for two months until her original house was repaired. Milton, she noted, “was kind of a moot point,” as it merely sent a tree crashing onto the roof of her parents’ home. The once joyful family home now makes her physically ill each time she returns.

Mary lives alone, with no family since her parents’ passing. At the Sunday coffee hour, “I have people who ask me, ‘How can I help?’” Sunday is the day of the week when she feels less alone.

Mary Metzler bravely manages a smile in the face of visible reminders of the storms’ wrath.

The Siesta Key Chapel is known as “God’s Treehouse.

preliminary and based on current data. January typically marks the period when insurance carriers renegotiate with re-insurers, which will provide a clearer outlook.

Two additional factors could still impact rates. One is the influence of claim history on individual premiums, driven by what Angers described as the industry’s “weird algorithms.” He pointed out that claim history could affect rates.

The other factor is the recent wildfires in Southern California, which could impact storm protection rates in Florida. Angers explained that re-insurance pools mix different types of coverage, so significant losses in one area, such as wildfires, could affect the entire insurance industry.

He also cautioned that a severe 2025 hurricane season could worsen the situation.

Angers, who specializes in insurance for condominium associations, warned about another challenge: securing permits from the county for rebuilding. “It’s going to be a huge problem,” he said. “They’re trying to figure out how to do it.”

He also shared several lessons from the 2024 storm season:

“Just about anywhere can flood,” noting that flooding can occur even miles inland.

“Understand your deductibles before storms,” predicting that most condominiums will likely need to impose special assessments on owners following storm damage.

“Have a reliable contractor ready.” Angers noted that many condominiums without a contractor in place were left waiting for assistance after the storms. Some believed they had “VIP” status, only to realize too late that they did not.

Regarding concerns about policy cancellations due to storm damage from Debby, Helene, and Milton, Angers reassured attendees that such fears might be overstated. “Know that you’re OK at least for a while,” he said, referencing existing government regulations designed to protect policyholders.

“Ensure access to cash.” Angers emphasized the importance of having cash available when disaster strikes on a large scale. He recommended that condominium associations secure a sufficient line of credit before storm season or be prepared to levy assessments on owners.

6895S Tamiami Trail Sarasota, FL 34231

Stuffed Shrimp

$18

Caesar Salad … $21

With grilled shrimp or chicken With grilled shrimp or chicken

Kale Salad … $22

SANDWICHES

Grouper Sandwich … $22

Salmon BLT … $21

Mahi Mahi Sandwich … $21

Chicken Sandwich … $15

Cheeseburger … $15 Vegan Burger … $13

… $26

Orange Pecan Chicken … $17

Filet Mignon … $25

Filet Mignon & Stuffed Shrimp … $36

Filet Mignon & Maine Lobster Tail $50

Stuffed Shrimp & Maine Lobster Tail $42

Twin Maine Lobster Tails … $55

FRIED SEAFOOD PLATTERS Coconut Shrimp … $23

Gulf Shrimp … $21 Fish & Chips … $20 Fried Combo … $29

PASTA & BOWLS

Shrimp & Crab Scampi … $25

Salmon Pasta … $23

Chicken & Shrimp Curry … $22

Sweet ‘n Spicy Chicken & Shrimp $22

Jambalaya … $24

Pasta Primavera … $17

DESSERTS

Turtle Pie … $10

Key Lime Pie … $10

Sample Platter … $13

Ice Cream Bar … $7

*Prices subject to change

Valentine’s Day Sparkle at Created Gems

Mark Edwards, a jeweler and owner of Created Gems on Ocean Boulevard in Siesta Key, believes diamonds symbolize love and longevity.

“For Valentine’s Day, jewelry is always a special gift,” he said. Edwards and his wife, Barbie, have been part of the Siesta Key business community for more than 23 years. Before relocating to Sarasota, Mark owned a fine jewelry store in Farmington Hills, Michigan. A thirdgeneration jeweler, he focused on offering affordable, elegant jewelry, with a special interest in lab-created diamonds.

Long before lab-created gems gained popularity, Mark developed the trademarked

Spektralyte-created diamonds, sold exclusively at Created Gems. “They’re cut like a Tiffany diamond with 58 facets and manufactured under laboratory conditions,” he said. “Permanent and D flawless in color, they come with a lifetime guarantee and replicate the visual properties of natural diamonds.” To differentiate a Spektralyte-created diamond from a natural one, a carbon test is needed. The jewelry is mounted in either 14K gold or platinum sterling silver, offering beauty at an affordable price.

Barbie Edwards, a former television host and news editor, noted that many customers

By Jane Bartnett

seek rings, necklaces, bracelets, and earrings resembling natural diamonds that typically sell for tens of thousands of dollars.

For the Edwards, the start of every February brings back special memories.

More than 35 years ago, following her first husband’s sudden death, Barbie was newly widowed and a single mother. She was the host of a local Detroit Michigan TV show on WXYZ-TV, the ABC Detroit affiliate station and editor/owner of Main Street Magazine, a Detroit area small business publication.

Several years after his passing, Barbie asked a friend for advice about selling her late husband’s watches and jewelry. The friend encouraged her to visit her friend Mark Edwards at his Farmington Hills, MI, jewelry store. Mark, she told Barbie, was one of suburban Detroit’s most reputable, fair and well-regarded jewelers.

On a cold February day, Barbie placed her late husband’s jewelry before Mark in his store. She began to cry. Trying to lighten the moment, a flustered Mark quipped, “I haven’t even given you a price yet.” She laughed. With their business concluded, Barbie left the store.

Several days later, Mark went on a planned ski vacation and when he returned, his friend who had encouraged

Barbie to visit his jewelry store, contacted him. She urged Mark to call Barbie and ask her for a date. They married six months later.

The couple eventually moved from Michigan to Phoenix, Arizona, where Mark worked with chemists and engineers to develop Spektralyte-created diamonds. In Scottsdale, Barbie became a local radio talk show host.

During a 2001 vacation in Sarasota, they discovered Siesta Key. They saw a vacancy sign on a storefront at 5212 Ocean Boulevard and decided to rent the space, moving to Sarasota to open Created Gems, where they began selling their American Gem Societyrecognized Spektralyte jewelry.

Barbie became the face of Created Gems, starring in television ads on Sarasota’s Channel 7. The store, known for its slogan “big bling for little ching,” attracted both visitors and locals.

“We have customers who travel and attend formal events,” Barbie said. “They want to safely wear beautiful, red-carpet-worthy jewelry.”

Many pieces set in 14K gold retail in the hundreds of dollars, while others are priced under $100.

For Valentine’s Day, Mark and Barbie expect many regular customers.

“Jewelry and diamonds are sentimental,” Mark said. “As is

Valentine’s Day itself.” Many men, unsure of what to buy, appreciate the guidance offered by the Edwards. Created Gems is located at 5212 Ocean Boulevard, Siesta Key, and is open daily. For more information, call 941-3460988.

Barbie Edwards, co-owner of Created Gems. (Photo by Jane Bartnett)

(Top) A display of Spektralyte lab created diamond rings and bracelets set in 14K gold at Created Gems. (Bottom) Glittering Spektralyte hearts are a perfect Valentine’s day gift, priced under $100. (Photos by Jane Bartnett)

Spa Experience Siesta Key

Make It the Best Valentine’s Day Ever!

Elevate your expression of love at Spa Experience Siesta Key this Valentine's Day. With exciting new offerings and specials, you’re sure to find the perfect gift or experience. Choose from an array of couple's services, including our brand-new Valentine's Day Specials!

Strawberry Cocoa Glow

Treat yourselves to the ultimate pampering experience with our Strawberry Chocolate Indulgence Facial and Massage This package includes a complimentary chocolate hand and foot scrub, along with soothing hot stones. Begin with a calming cacao-infused massage designed to melt away tension and leave your skin silky smooth. Then, enjoy a strawberry-enriched facial featuring antioxidant-rich ingredients to nourish and hydrate your skin. This luxurious combination of cacao’s hydrating and anti-aging properties with strawberry’s natural brightening effects will leave you glowing from head to toe.

• Microcurrent Facial: Looking for anti-aging results? This treatment, known as the "secret of the stars," gently and painlessly lifts, tones, and tightens facial muscles while stimulating your body’s collagen production. Leave looking younger, refreshed, and glowing.

Why Choose Spa Experience Siesta Key?

For over 30 years, Spa Experience Siesta Key has been relaxing and pampering residents and visitors alike. Consistently earning 5-star ratings on TripAdvisor and Google, we take pride in delivering exceptional service.

Valentine's Day Bliss Cocoa and Rose Oil Massage

Indulge in the ultimate romantic escape with this luxurious treatment. Featuring the sensual aromas of warm chocolate oil and the soothing essence of rose oil, this deeply relaxing and aromatic experience is perfect for couples—or as a special treat just for you. Designed to awaken the senses and celebrate the spirit of romance, this massage is pure bliss.

Other Spa Favorites

• Signature Facial: Perfect for those who desire a blend of facial care and massage. This one-hour treatment includes a deluxe deep cleansing facial paired with an extended arm, neck, and shoulder massage—a truly rejuvenating experience.

Owner and Spa Director Connie Lewis recently expanded the spa, adding four new treatment rooms to accommodate up to 12 guests at a time—perfect for spa parties! We offer multiple couples’ rooms and can even accommodate groups of three in one room.

Our skilled and experienced team of professionals includes:

• 10 Licensed Massage Therapists

• 6 Dual-Licensed Massage Therapist/Aestheticians

• 1 Licensed Acupuncturist who is also a Licensed Massage Therapist

With so many options, you’re sure to find the perfect service and therapist to meet your needs.

Celebrate love and self-care this Valentine’s Day at Spa Experience Siesta Key!

Spa Experience Siesta Key established in 1996 is open 7 days a week and can accommodate groups of up to 12 at the same time. Larger groups may book blocks of time and use the spa for special occasions and parties. Services include 90-minute sessions for $250 and couples packages for $500.

We are located at 5700 Midnight Pass Road on Siesta Key and can be reached at 941349-4833. Easy online booking and appointments can be made at Spa ExperienceSiestaKey.com.

auratus

Contrary to what many have been lead to believe, goldfish are one of the worst fish you can put in a small tank or, even worse, a bowl. Goldfish get huge and produce way more waste than almost any other kind of similarly sized fish! However, for those with large tanks or, better yet, a pond, goldfish might just be the perfect wet pet! Goldfish come in many varieties! Orandas, Ryukins, Ranchus, etc. are perfect for those with tanks 75 gallons and above, while larger varieties, like comets or koi, are great for outdoor or indoor ponds! Goldfish are cool water fish, so no heater is necessary, and they are actually personable as well! They will often learn to recognize their owners and routines very quickly. So much for that "two second memory" myth! Goldfish tend to be very friendly with appropriate tankmates and pondmates, but will often eat many kinds of plants, so one must be careful when deciding what kinds of plants to include in their habitats.

Typical appearance and behavior

Goldfish come in all sorts of di erent shapes and colors! Orange, yellow, white, black, and red are the most common colors.

Koi are goldfish too! Koi tend to get even larger than most other varieties and can be easily identified by the "whiskers" present on each side of their mouths.

Goldfish live for a long time! An average pond comet goldfish can live 20-40 years, but the longest living koi on record lived for a total of 226 years!

• We have

Embracing the Chill: A Journey into Cold Water Therapy

By Janine Martin

Some are lucky enough to swim outdoors every day of the year, basking in the sun’s warmth even in the depths of winter. There’s a certain magic to feeling soft sand underfoot as you wade into the crystal-clear waters of the Gulf, a sensation many describe as unparalleled. While I can’t claim personal experience, I know this from the tales of others. As a Florida native, the idea of plunging into cold winter waters is daunting. Instead, you’ll find me wrapped in a blanket on the beach, waiting for the sun to return. To the yearround swimmers: I see you, and you’re incredible. For me, though, cold exposure has always been a challenge—or at least, it used to be.

but experiencing it firsthand is entirely

minimize swelling after intense exercise.

In 2014, my husband and I embarked on a tour across New Zealand, spending several months of their summer exploring bucketlist destinations. This stunning country, with its array of beautiful beaches, left a lasting impression. Yet, no matter how breathtaking the scenery, the cold waters of the Pacific Ocean were a stark contrast

to our warm paradise back home in Siesta Key. We quickly realized how spoiled we were. Determined not to be deterred by the chill, we vowed to become more resilient in the face of cold water.

Despite our resolve, years passed with little progress. It wasn’t until the rise of the cold water therapy craze on the internet that we revisited our commitment.

Hearing about the benefits from countless sources is one thing,

Fast forward to today, and this former cold water skeptic is now an avid practitioner of cold water therapy, immersing myself in icy waters four to five times a week. Combined with strength and endurance training, yoga, and sauna therapy, I feel stronger than ever. Whether it’s swimming in the coldest seas or simply enjoying a winter beach day, I’m no longer hindered by the chill. It’s a line you’ve likely heard before, but cold water therapy has genuinely transformed my life.

For those curious about the potential benefits of cold water therapy, here’s what you can expect:

Physical Recovery:

• Reduces inflammation: Helps

• Relieves sore muscles: Provides relief from post-workout soreness.

• Flushes out metabolic waste: Assists in clearing out byproducts of exercise.

• Increases blood flow circulation: Enhances overall circulation, aiding in recovery.

Mood and Stress:

• Activates the nervous system: Triggers a relaxation response.

• Boosts relaxation: Helps in managing stress levels effectively.

Overall Well-being:

• Improved cognitive function: Some studies suggest better cognitive performance.

• Better sleep: Many report improved sleep quality and reduced fatigue.

• Reduced risk of infection: Regular immersion can bolster the immune system and lower the risk of bacterial infections.

• Enhanced cardiovascular health: Over time, cold water immersion can improve circulatory efficiency, beneficial for those with high blood pressure or diabetes.

• Increased metabolism: The body’s effort to stay warm can slightly boost metabolism.

• Improved digestive activity: Stimulating the trigeminal nerve can enhance digestive function.

The list of benefits is extensive, but don’t just take my word for it. I encourage you to explore cold water therapy and discover how it might benefit you. Visit us at The KôR to try our cold water therapy, sauna, and exercise routines. Ask questions, experiment, and find what works best for your body. Embrace the cold—it just might change your life.

About the author: Janine Martin is co-owner of The KôR located at 1955 Beechwood

Avenue in Sarasota.

Joshua Martin experiences the wonders of cold water therapy at The KoR. (Photo provided)

Renew Your Love This Valentine’s Day on Siesta Beach

Cupid, the symbol of love and Valentine’s Day, will make a special appearance on the soft sands of Siesta Beach during the annual “Say I Do Again” ceremony hosted by Sarasota County Parks, Recreation, and Natural Resources. The Valentine’s Day sunset celebration, a cherished Siesta Key tradition for more than 35 years, will take place on Friday, February 14.

This year’s romantic sunset event will feature light refreshments, music, and photo opportunities. Judge Stephen M. Walker of the 12th Judicial Circuit Court of Florida will officiate the non-denominational vow renewal ceremony. Hundreds of couples are expected to join in renewing their vows of marriage or commitment.

“A stunning sunset, singing shorebirds, and a gentle

By Jane Bartnett

breeze set the scene for love. Pair that with hundreds of couples eager to renew their vows on Valentine’s Day, and you have our beloved Say ‘I Do’ Again event,” said recreation specialist Kristie Lever. In past years, brides have donned wedding veils and gowns, while grooms have arrived in beach formal attire, sharing memories of their wedding day with fellow participants.

Couples can pre-register by calling 941-861-7275 or online at sarasotacountyparks.com.

The pre-registration fee is $15 per couple and closes on Sunday, February 9. On-site registration on Valentine’s Day is $25 per couple, payable by credit card only, with registration opening at 4:30 p.m. at Siesta Beach.

The ceremony will start at 6:00 p.m., as the sun sets, and a golden glow envelops

the beach. Judge Walker will lead the couples through their vows, celebrating love and commitment in this picturesque setting. Each pre-registered couple will receive a certificate, special gift, and flower, with similar items available for dayof registrants as supplies last. Sarasota County prohibits discrimination in all services, programs, and activities.

Judge Walker and couples at the 2024 Say I Do Again ceremony (Provided - Sarasota County)

A visiting couple celebrated their love at a beautifully framed “Kissing Booth” display. (Jane Bartnett photo)

Andrew and Lew Hereth of Sarasota celebrated in their formal wedding beach attire in past year ceremony. (Jane Bartnett photo)

reduced correctional costs. Before his time as sheriff, Knight served two years with the Sarasota Police Department and spent two decades with the Florida Highway Patrol.

Reflecting on his decision to return to public service, Knight said, “I understand the process. I’ve never been a part of the establishment. My job is to represent the entire county. If you don’t agree with what’s going on in public service, do something about it. I believe in what the citizens want, not what I want. The main thing is to bring representative government back. Are people being heard?”

Knight expressed optimism about working with his fellow commissioners: Mark Smith of District 2, Teresa Mast of District 1, Joe Neunder of District 4, and Ron Cutsinger of District 5.

“The five of us will have a good, harmonious working relationship, reflective of what’s right for this community,” he said. “We want to be respectful of each other. This is a board that may disagree on certain things, but I don’t think people will see us acting as other boards have in the past. We’re a more mature board. There are no activists on the board.”

Among Knight’s top priorities are land use, public records, and transparency in public communications, as well as addressing the influence of special interest groups on public officials. Discussing hotel development, Knight emphasized the importance of moving forward once decisions are made. “It isn’t the same as it was when I moved here in 1973. You can’t go backward,” he said, declining to comment on specific projects.

When asked about the county’s comprehensive plan, which outlines land use, economic growth, natural resources, and public services, Knight voiced frustration. “It’s been ignored on a

regular basis,” he said. “There are different opinions, from housing developments to hotels on Siesta Key. At the end of the day, moving forward and bringing back stability and credibility to the plans that citizens put in place years ago is crucial. This is the way the citizens wanted it done. I ran because a plan is in place. It should not be ignored. We need to bring representative government back.”

Knight called for increased transparency in public records, land use, and communications. “The county commission can bring some stability and credibility back to these plans. What goes on here will be scrutinized very carefully,” he said.

Looking ahead, Knight highlighted affordable housing, infrastructure, and road paving as key issues

You can put more into your 401(k) this year

on the commission’s agenda, alongside land development. He noted the importance of recent federal funding for hurricane relief, referencing a January announcement from the Department of Housing and Urban Development. “I’m really happy that we got over $200 million more dollars for hurricane relief,” he said.

“When you get voted into office, you’re expected to represent the citizens who put you there whether you like it or not,” Knight said. “Siesta Key is paradise. We have commissioners that care about the Key. My responsibility is to do the best I can to protect it.”

(Editor’s note: You can watch on our dedicated Siesta Sand Live YouTube channel or listen to it on Apple podcasts.)

What to expect from a financial advisor

If you know how important it is to invest for your future, but you’re unsure of the road to follow, you may want to get some guidance and direction from a financial professional. But if you’ve never worked with one before, what can you expect? Here are some things to look for:

• Assessment – A financial advisor will assess your current financial situation – assets, income, debts and so on – but that’s just the start. These days, advisors recognize the need to view their clients’ lives holistically. Consequently, you will see questions like this: What are your feelings about investing? How would you judge your risk tolerance? What are your individual financial goals? What hopes and dreams do you have for your family?

• Recommendations – Only after fully understanding your needs, goals and preferences will a financial advisor recommend any investment moves. There are no “one-size-fits-all” solutions. You may want to steer clear of individuals claiming to be financial advisors who “guarantee” big returns with no risk. In the

investment world, there are few guarantees, and every investment carries some type of risk.

• Communications – Financial professionals communicate with their clients in different ways, but you should always feel free to reach out to an advisor with any questions or concerns. Most financial advisors will want to meet with clients at least once a year, either in person or through an online platform, to review their investment portfolios. During the review, the financial advisor will help you determine if any changes are needed. But financial advisors won’t wait a full year to contact clients to discuss a particular investment move that might need to be made. Also, depending on the firm you choose, you should be able to go online to review your portfolio at your convenience.

• Technology – A financial advisor can employ a variety of software programs to help clients. For example, a financial advisor can determine the rate of return you might need to attain specific goals, helping shape your investment strategy. But there are also a lot of “what ifs” in anyone’s life, so an advisor can use hypothetical

illustrations to show you where you might end up if you take different paths, such as retiring earlier (or later) than you had planned or putting in more (or less) money toward a specific goal, such as education for your children. Anyone’s plans can change, so the ability to view different potential scenarios can prove valuable.

Above all, a financial advisor can help you feel more confident as you pursue your goals.

Among investors who work

with a financial advisor, 84% said that doing so gave them a greater sense of comfort about their finances during the COVID-19 pandemic, according to a survey conducted in 2020 by Age Wave and Edward Jones. And during times of market turbulence, such as we’ve experienced this year, a financial advisor can help you avoid overreacting to downturns. When unexpected events crop up, such as a lapse

in employment, a financial advisor can suggest moves that may enable you to avoid major disruptions to your financial strategy. Conversely, when a new opportunity emerges, perhaps from an inheritance or some other windfall, your financial advisor can help you take advantage of it.

Navigating the investment landscape can be challenging – but the journey can be a lot smoother if you’ve got the right guide.

Joe St. Onge, ChFC® Financial Advisor, Edward Jones Investments 5011 Ocean Blvd., suite 205 Siesta Key, FL 34242 (941)-346-0560 phone (941)-320-4030 mobile Joe.StOnge@ edwardjones.com

This article was written by Edward Jones for use by your local Edward Jones Financial Advisor. Edward Jones. Member SIPC. -- Advertorial --

Sarasota County Commissioner Tom Knight (Photo provided by Sarasota County)

Presents

Watch all the Siesta Sand Live Episodes on our dedicated YouTube channel or listen on Apple Podcasts.

EPISODE 8

Newly elected District 3Sarasota County Commissioner and former Sarasota Sheriff Tom Knight shares his vision for the future.

EPISODE 7

J udie Berger, Siesta Key resident of 30 years and the #1 realtor on Siesta Key since 2005 working for Premier Sotheby’s shares an update on the Siesta Key real estate market for 2025.

Jean Cannon, former SKA board member and local champion of the mini-reef program and Siesta Key’s canal water.

EPISODE 6

Actor, comedian, and Siesta Key resident Steve White.

EPISODE 5

Lourdes Ramirez, Siesta Key resident and advocate.

EPISODE 4

Dave Balot, Siesta Key hotelier and business owner

WHAT: A weekly talk show video featuring segments on news, community leaders, business, and all things Siesta Key!

WHO: Brought to you by the Siesta Sand with host Natalie Gutwein, SKA Board Member, Siesta Sand columnist, and realtor on Siesta Key.

WHERE: The Sniki Tiki located in Captain Curt’s Village at 1204 Old Stickney Point Road

WHEN: Every Thursday at 9 a.m.

WHY: To provide residents and visitors from around the world all the current information impacting life on and around Siesta Key.

HOW TO WATCH & LISTEN: In-person at the Sniki Tiki, online at Siestasand.us, our dedicated Siesta Sand Live YouTube channel, our dedicated Siesta Sand Live Facebook page, and listen on Apple Podcasts.

Siesta Sand Live is Sponsored by

Siesta Sand Live host Natalie Gutwein.

Highs and Lows of Properties Sold on Siesta Key

The

$10,350,000

This picture-perfect home is in the Cocoanut Bayou neighborhood. This home was redesigned by Clifford Schultz and could be featured in House Beautiful. The gated parcel is almost 2/3 of an acre, complete with mature tropical landscaping. The home features an oversized Chicago brick motor court with a 3-car side entry garage. The custom wood detailing throughout includes mahogany entry doors, crown moldings, cased impact windows, shiplap ceilings, wainscoting, custom built-ins and more. A gourmet kitchen with Campbell Custom Cabinetry featuring a butler’s pantry, a beverage station, Wolf appliances and an entertaining island complete with additional seating. The main house has a foyer gallery wall, soaring ceilings, picture perfect views, a Holiday sized living room, a coveted great room, a morning room, a private office, as well as a spectacular Owner’s suite. The owner’s suite has a large sitting area, a spa inspired bathroom and 2 walk-in closets. The second floor has a hobby room, 3 ensuites and a flex room. The guest house above the garage has a kitchenette, a great room and an ensuite with private entrance near the main home. The outdoor veranda is complete with kitchen, dining and living areas. T. A resort style pool with travertine pavers, a separate spa, a large garden, and 2 boat docks complete this waterfront lifestyle.

Courtesy of Coldwell Banker

LOWEST PRICED SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE

141 GARDEN LANE

$685,000

Charming coastal cottage nestled in the heart of Siesta Key, this delightful 2-bedroom, 1.5-bath cottage is located just a short stroll away from one of Siesta Key’s best-kept secret beaches, this home is the perfect retreat for those seeking tranquility with easy access to pristine sands and turquoise waters. Sitting on an expansive 10,000+ sq. ft. lot, this property offers ample space and privacy with room to expand, garden, or create your own tropical oasis. The home’s classic terrazzo flooring stretches throughout, creating a cool, stylish, and durable surface that reflects the cottage’s unique charm and mid-century roots. While the property has been impacted by recent storms, cleanup is underway, and with a little TLC, this cottage has the potential to shine as a cozy island haven. Ongoing cleanup and repair work post-storm, a rare opportunity to customize and restore.

Courtesy of Michael Saunders

HIGHEST PRICED CONDO

1000 SEAGROVE LANE, #PHN

$5,900,000

The Seagrove Beach House is a midrise building with only 8 exclusive residences. The Penthouse North is the premier residence in the building featuring unobstructed views to the west and north of the beautiful white sand beach and Gulf of Mexico. The spacious interior has over 3,000 sq. ft. of air-conditioned living space with an open floor plan, Gulf views from all main living areas and an open, gourmet kitchen with top-of-the-line appliances. The large wrap around terrace features see-through glass railings, an outdoor kitchen with gas grill and plenty of room for lounging or al-fresco dining. Penthouse North has its own, approximately 5,000 sq. ft., rooftop garden with spectacular 360° views, fire pit, outdoor kitchen, putting green and lounge chairs. You must see this to believe it. There is nothing like it on Siesta Key!

Courtesy of Allen Real Estate Services

LOWEST PRICED CONDO

5830 MIDNIGHT PASS RD, #46

$350,000

Look at this Siesta Key gem, a walk away from the white powdery sand of Siesta Key Beach. Unit sold as is. Currently being renovated after water intrusion after Hurricane Helene, no water intrusion during Milton. Owner’s renovation cost is estimated to be $20,000 to $25,000. Come see and make this unit your own.

Courtesy of Keller Williams

Keeping it Real

Looking Into 2025: A Real Estate Perspective on Siesta Key

Wouldn’t it be nice if we had a crystal ball to forecast the year ahead? As we reflect on 2024 and prepare for 2025, that kind of insight would certainly come in handy. The past year has been particularly challenging for Siesta Key—three hurricanes (yes, don’t forget about Debbie), a turbulent election year, higher interest rates, and now the ongoing cleanup efforts. To be honest, I wasn’t sure what I’d uncover when I pulled the sales data for 2024.

My first thought: “How do you even define a typical market on Siesta Key?” Real estate is hyperlocal, shaped by unique events. Yet, sales on Siesta Key are often affected by events that don’t influence Sarasota, let alone the rest of the world. Take 2018, for example—Red Tide hit hard in August, sparking fears about the future of Siesta Key real estate. Yet, just a couple of years later, the COVID-19 pandemic brought an unprecedented boom to the housing market.

Now, as we enter 2025, we’re left to analyze the trends and make predictions. What does this mean for homeowners considering selling? How might these trends affect buyers

By Natalie Gutwein

entering the market? To better understand what lies ahead, I decided to look back over the past decade, and some of the insights were surprising.

A Decade of Market Trends

New Listings

The first metric I analyzed was the number of new single-family residential listings (excluding condominiums). In 2014, there were 324 listings. By 2024, that number had risen slightly to 360. Aside from the anomalies of 2021 and 2022, which saw just 304 and 281 listings respectively, the seven-year average between 2014 and 2020 was 349. Over the decade, this number has remained remarkably consistent.

Days on Market

What about cumulative days on the market? Have the hurricanes caused properties to linger longer? Surprisingly, no. Between 2014 and 2019, the average time on market was 171 days. Excluding the COVID-era anomalies, today’s market still performs better. In 2023, the average was 109 days, and in 2024, it’s only slightly higher at 127 days.

Total Sales

The total number of sales has experienced some extremes but has now stabilized. Recordbreaking years like 2020 (261 sales) and 2021 (301 sales) have

given way to more typical figures. In 2023, there were just 121 sales, and in 2024, we’ve returned to an average of 178 sales—consistent with the 173 average from 2014 to 2018.

List

Price vs. Sale Price

Has post-hurricane recovery created more room for negotiation? Statistically, not really. The closed price-to-list price ratio remained steady at 94% between 2014 and 2019, peaked at 100% in 2022, and has since normalized to 95% in 2024.

Home Values and Price Per Square Foot

Here’s where the real story unfolds--home values have nearly doubled over the past decade. The average sales price of a single-family home on Siesta Key rose from $1.2 million in 2014 to $2.4 million in 2024. Price per square foot has followed a similar trend, climbing from $372 in 2014 to $732 today.

Sales Volume

Sales volume tells a fascinating story all its own. From 2014 to 2024, total sales volume for single-family homes on Siesta Key more than doubled, climbing from $201 million to over $416 million. However, the journey hasn’t been without its twists. After an extraordinary $592 million in 2021—a peak fueled by the booming COVID market—sales volume plunged to $245 million in 2023. That said, our team was proud to contribute $121 million in sales

during that record-breaking year. Today’s figures point to a more normalized yet still vibrant market, reflecting sustained demand and steady growth.

Looking Ahead to 2025

So, what can we expect in 2025?

The election is over, the Federal Reserve has cut interest rates, and a new administration is in place, bringing potential policy shifts. Several properties are being sold at lot value or in unfinished states. As the island recovers, many homeowners are still in the process of rebuilding.

For sellers, pricing accurately will be critical to attracting serious buyers in 2025. Few buyers are willing to spend their time looking at overpriced homes, and many will ignore properties that require significant updating. For buyers, the ongoing cleanup efforts may present opportunities to find homes priced at lot value or with renovation potential.

I firmly believe in the concept of mean reversion—that markets eventually return to their long-term averages. While sales

volume is likely to remain high, we may see a slight increase in the number of homes sold. However, it’s clear that Siesta Key is not experiencing a fire sale. We’re still selling sunshine and sand—it just comes with a few more challenges for now.

For more insights and in-depth discussions about all things Siesta Key, check out my podcast, Siesta Sand Live on YouTube, Apple Podcasts, and Spotify. Guests so far include Commissioner Mark Smith, Judie Berger, hotel owner Dave Balot, and Siesta Key activist Lourdes Ramirez. Simply search “Siesta Sand Live” on your preferred listening platform. Stay sunny, Siesta!

*This article contains insurance policy numbers based on personal experience. Please consult your insurance broker for more information.

(Natalie Gutwein is a licensed Realtor with Premier Sotheby’s International Realty’s Judie Berger Team and a member of the board of directors of the Siesta Key Association.) (Data accurate as of July 10 from Stellar MLS.)

for strong swimmers.

The solution? Keep calm and swim in one direction or the other, parallel to shore. Rip currents are rarely wider than 25 yards, and they only pull you outward, not under.

If you are in trouble in the water, for whatever reason, signal to lifeguards by waving your arms and calling out (if you can). They’re looking for those communications.

Still, it can take tremendous poise to ask for help when you want to use your arms to stay afloat. Lifeguards know— and everyone should remember—that the signs of potential drowning are often more subtle. “The universal sign is pushing down to try to stay on top of the water,” said Dorsey. Other signs of trouble include bobbing up and down, not clearing hair out of the eyes, and ineffective paddling or flailing under the surface.

Even though the lifeguards are watching, you should always keep an eye on your buddies, too. “Make sure everybody’s paying attention to what’s going on,” said Dorsey. “You don’t want to suddenly turn around and be like, ‘Where did Bob go?’”

Alcohol Amplifies Risk

Whatever your personal predilections, the fact is that many people are going to drink—especially over spring break. The key remains education and personal responsibility.

“Alcohol impairs people’s ability, both on the beach and in the Gulf and on the Intracoastal Waterway,” said Dorsey. Drunk driving remains dangerous for boaters, too, even just for navigating the local channels. Remember, sandbars and shallow spots may have shifted

significantly after this past summer’s storms.

And while we often talk about alcohol impairment, it’s worth noting that alcohol-induced adventurousness is also an issue. Risky behavior while driving a boat can go very badly, very quickly.

“Keep the alcohol in moderation,” Dorsey added. “We want people to enjoy their time but enjoy it safely.”

Pool Safety

Unlike our public beaches, private pools usually don’t have lifeguards, and they’re always right there, whether you’re using them or not. That makes individual water safety even more vital.

“No. 1, if you’ve got children, you want someone to be the ‘water watcher.’ Whether it’s parents or older siblings, keep an eye on small children,” said Dorsey.

Pool gates have become a necessary standard for protecting children and pets (and, let’s face it, adults who have over-indulged) from falling in the pool. But these circumference fencing systems only work if they’re set up. If you take down on Sunday and leave it down the whole week, you’re courting disaster. (Nowadays, Dorsey points out, pool alarms, which sound when someone is unexpectedly in the pool, are an effective and increasingly common safety measure, too.)

Here on Siesta, we live our lives in constant proximity to the water. That familiarity can lead to complacency. But spring break is a good time to remind ourselves of all the ways an everyday experience on the key can turn scary.

“Emergencies can happen at 2 in the morning or 2 in the afternoon,” said Dorsey. “All these things can any time.”