PARITY OF ACCESS BY JONATHAN CORRIVEAU & MICHAEL DEITZ
1
2
PARITY OF ACCESS BY JONATHAN CORRIVEAU & MICHAEL DEITZ PRECEDENT ANALYSIS STRUCTURAL & PASSIVE SYSTEMS SITE & ECOSYSTEMS USE & scenario planning structure & INTEGRATED SYSTEMS
04 12 34 44 52
3
4
PRECEDENT ANALYSIS PHASE 1.1
5
SPACEFRAME CONSTRUCTION: STEEL SAINSBURY CENTER FOR THE VISUAL ARTS FOSTER & PARTNERS NORWICH, ENGLAND
spaceframe construction - steel Sainsbury Center for the Visual Arts / Foster & Partners / norwich, england 6Michael Deitz & Jack Corriveau
6
PRECEDENT ANALYSIS PHASE 1.1
operable glazing
adjustable Lighting & AV equipment per programmatic needs
tuneable top light
steel construction
occupiable building system zone
occupiable service zone integrated heating and cooling
double skin “Service Wall�
water retention
views through landscape
spaceframe construction - steel Sainsbury Center for the Visual Arts / Foster & Partners / norwich, england Michael Deitz & Jack Corriveau
77
SPACEFRAME CONSTRUCTION: LIGHT TIMBER LANTERN PAVILION AWP OSLO, NORWAY
spaceframe construction - light wood Lantern Pavilion / AWP / oslo, norway 8Michael Deitz & Jack Corriveau
8
PRECEDENT ANALYSIS PHASE 1.1
glass shingles with ventilation
integrated fire protection
water retention tray
light wood construction
integrated lighting conduit uplighting
spaceframe construction - light wood Lantern Pavilion / AWP / oslo, norway Michael Deitz & Jack Corriveau
99
SPACEFRAME CONSTRUCTION: HEAVY TIMBER ASPEN ART MUSEUM SHIGERU BAN ASPEN, COLORADO
spaceframe construction - steel Aspen Art Museum / Shigeru Ban / aspen, colorado 10Michael Deitz & Jack Corriveau
10
PRECEDENT ANALYSIS PHASE 1.1
integrated building systems heavy timber spaceframe
heating and cooling exposed mepfp semi-interior interstitial zone embedded water rentention
views through landscape
woven timber screen steelframe skeleton steel bridging
semi-interior interstitial stair
interior interstitial stair
spaceframe construction - steel Aspen Art Museum / Shigeru Ban / aspen, colorado
11 11
12
STRUCTURAL & PASSIVE SYSTEMS PHASE 1.2
13
14 STRUCTURAL & PASSIVE SYSTEMS PHASE 1.2 14
THERE IS NOTHING IN EVERYTHING. Nothing is our greatest opportunity. Space exists as an infinity of nothingness. Uncontrolled and without curation, it could simply extend forever from the locus of any one point. It is the role, or more fittingly “the responsibility,” of the architect to act as the wrangler of space. Through the means of form, the architect possesses the ability to frame space in such a way that it becomes something more palpable and present. Through architecture, something is made from nothing. The miracle of architectural form is the progeny of its many components, whose material qualities both create and then subsequently affect spatial perception. We know how to use materials to achieve this phenomenon; rocket science is not needed to build a simple house of stones. What we do not yet fully understand is the intrinsic relationship between material, construction, and the “scale of spaces.” Our spaces are made from structures which are themselves spaces, and whose fundamental material components can contain a space of nothingness. And with nothing comes potential. This spectrum of spatial scale within a building allows for an even greater potentiality for the varying framework of spaces which can assume unique roles. Spaces and frameworks are not mutually exclusive. Contemporary buildings are more complex than the house of stones: they contain any number of systems which bolster their livelihood and longevity yet often come with their own ecological taxation. We must begin to expect our frameworks to become something more. It is our belief that we must consider these systems in marriage with their integrated spatial presence. By designing with the “scale of spaces,” we can begin to apply systems at any point of the spatial spectrum. In this way, material components become something greater than themselves, adhering to an efficient, economic, and environmental use of space. By considering every component of architecture as a framework of space itself, we can better curate the wider spatial frameworks which we ourselves inhabit every day. Every framework must be more than itself. Everything can contain nothing.
AND EVERYTHING SHOULD COME FROM NOTHING.
15 15
CONSTRUCTION SEQUENCE
CONCRETE FOUNDATION
HOLEDECK WAFFLE SLAB
TIMBER CANTILVER SUPPORT
TIMBER FRAMING
TIMBER SPACEFRAME
TIMBER FRAMING
TIMBRE SPACEFRAME
SYSTEMS & ENCLOSURE
LOUVERED SCREEN
16 STRUCTURAL & PASSIVE SYSTEMS PHASE 1.2 16
17 17
STRUCTURAL MATERIAL DISTRIBUTION concrete timber
18 STRUCTURAL & PASSIVE SYSTEMS PHASE 1.2 18
PERMANENCE VS IMPERMANENCE permanent impermanent
19 19
GROUND FLOOR N
20 STRUCTURAL & PASSIVE SYSTEMS PHASE 1.2 20
UPPER LEVEL N
21 21
UPPER LEVEL rcp N
22 STRUCTURAL & PASSIVE SYSTEMS PHASE 1.2 22
ROOF PLAN N
23 23
SECTIONS
SECTION a-a
24 STRUCTURAL & PASSIVE SYSTEMS PHASE 1.2 24
SECTION b-b
SYSTEMS INTEGRATION ARRANGEMENT primary secondary tertiary
25 25
TYPICAL FLOOR SYSTEMS INTEGRATION
TERTIARY SYSTEMS HYDRONIC HEATING & COOLING
SECONDARY SYSTEMS
PRIMARY SYSTEMS
26 STRUCTURAL & PASSIVE SYSTEMS PHASE 1.2 26
COLUMN CAPITAL DETAIL
27 27
FLEXBILE FLOOR CONSTRUCTION
28 STRUCTURAL & PASSIVE SYSTEMS PHASE 1.2 28
CURTAIN WALL CONNECTION DETAIL
29 29
SYSTEMS INTEGRATION
30 STRUCTURAL & PASSIVE SYSTEMS PHASE 1.2 30
31 31
MODEL PHOTOS
32 STRUCTURAL & PASSIVE SYSTEMS PHASE 1.2 32
33 33
34
SITE & ECOSYSTEMS PHASE 2
35
36
“By 2070, with a three-foot sea level rise, [Seaport] could be inundated at high tide every month... That will put 88,000 people at risk of flooding and could knock out major rail and road corridors. Such a scenario would result in $1.4 billion in annual costs from structural damage, business and property losses, and related factors.� Climate Ready Boston
37
existing conditions FORT POINT, BOSTON
38 SITE & ECOSYSTEMS PHASE 2 38
site circulation
39 39
boston land composite
40 SITE & ECOSYSTEMS PHASE 2 40
fort point sea level flooding
41 41
fort point heat index
42 SITE & ECOSYSTEMS PHASE 2 42
fort point accessibility & commute times
43 43
44
use & scenario planning PHASE 3
45
46
use & scenario planning
“In the intellectual Athens of America, our world class art, historical, and educational institutions comprise a narrative of art spaces that is out of sync with the reality of artists living and working in Boston.� Phillip Zminda, Boston Art Review
47
SCENARIO PLANNING potentials
48 use & scenario planning PHASE 3 48
49 49
SCENARIO PLANNING
50 use & scenario planning PHASE 3 50
In 1987, Massachusetts Cultural Council (MCC)’s allocated budget was roughly $27 million. Adjusted for inflation, this number should approximate $50 million. Yet, in 2018, the budget sits at just around $14 million.
If just 30,000 to 40,000 Amazon workers moved into Greater Boston as new residents, they, along with their significant others, children, and other roommates, would translate to approximately 75,000 to 100,000 new residents scattered across the Boston metro area. In the seven years since Amazon decided to cluster its headquarters in Seattle’s South Union neighborhood, home prices have surged by 83% and rents by 47%
51 51
52
structure & integrated systems PHASE 4
53
SITE STRATEGIES
54 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 54
PROGRAM SPATIAL DISTRIBUTION
55 55
connectivity of access
56 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 56
SITE PLAN
57 57
SCENARIO 1 : ARTIST COOPERATIVE
58 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 58
BELOW GRADE + 0’
SCENARIO 2 : social housing
BELOW GRADE + 0’
59 59
SCENARIO 1 : ARTIST COOPERATIVE
60 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 60
ground floor + 24’
SCENARIO 2 : social housing
ground floor + 24’
61 61
SCENARIO 1 : ARTIST COOPERATIVE
62 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 62
typical floor + 41’
SCENARIO 2 : social housing
typical floor + 41’
63 63
SCENARIO 1 : ARTIST COOPERATIVE
64 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 64
roof + 93’
SCENARIO 2 : social housing
roof + 93’
65 65
SCENARIO 1 : ARTIST COOPERATIVE
66 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 66
67 67
SCENARIO 2 : social housing
68 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 68
69 69
construction sequence
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
70 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 70
71 71
SUMMER STREET ELEVATION
72 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 72
SERVICE ROAD ELEVATION
73 73
comfort systems
74 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 74
75 75
hydronic systems artist cooperative
social housing
76 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 76
HVAC Systems artist cooperative
social housing
77 77
plumbing artist cooperative
social housing
78 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 78
79 79
enclosure details
80 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 80
81 81
332 summer street
view from congress street
82 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 82
ramp entrance
83 83
332 summer street
summer street entrance
84 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 84
artist studio
85 85
332 summer street
co-working space 86 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 86
studio apartment 87 87
332 summer street
shared lounge
88 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 88
roof terrace
89 89
90 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 90
91 91
92 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 92
93 93
94 structure & integrated systems PHASE 4 94
95 95
“When a lack of arts funding is compounded with soaring rent prices due to gentrification, emerging artists lose access to space, full stop. Space to live, spaces to create, and spaces to show their art—with more and more galleries shuttering their doors—dissipate. Devoid of access to space, artists will be forced out of Boston. And without any artists, Boston’s eclectic and brilliant art scene as we know it will cease to exist.” Phillip Zminda, Boston Art Review
96