A Home for Haiti Haiti, Port-Au-Prince 5th Year Joint Project with Patrick Smith 2017
By Joseph Chandler
TO MA S2 010
FAULT ENTRIONAL
CHANSOLME 6.0 1956
SEPT
ALPH
7 200
12
20
05 A 20
EL NO
AC ISA
GONAIVES
BOUDET
PETITE RIVIERE DE L’ARTIBONITE
OLGA 2007
ARCAHAIE
GUS
TAV 2008 PORT-AU-PRINCE
6.2 1952 CAMP PERRIN
ULT DEN FA
IN GAR
LANTA UILLO-P
ENRIQ
6.1 1953
7.0 2010
6.0 2010 JACMEL
ER
NE
STO
20
07
Faultlines
02
Earthquake 5+ 1950-
Hurricane
Tropical Storm
Population One Dot=1000 people
20 Miles 20 Km
The first exercise undertaken by Patrick and myself was an in-depth study of the environment in which we would be designing for. This was an extremely important undertaking as Haiti has one of the highest frequencies of natural disaster in the world.
PORT-AU-PRINCE 2010 EARTHQUAKE 0 0
0.5 0.5
1 Miles 1 Kilometres
Industrial Areas Neighbourhoods Shanty Areas Green Space Collapsed Buildings Damaged Buildings Landslides
We selected Port Au Prince as our primary location which over the years has been devastated by hurricanes, tsunami’s, flooding, earthquakes and landslides. As well as being one of the most disaster prone it is also one of the poorest countries in the world, with poor skilled labour, materials and infrastructure.
03
DEFORESTATION
75% OF HAITIANS LIVE IN POVERTY
WHEN CHRISTOPHER COLUMBUS CAME TO AYITI IT WAS A LUSH FOREST HOME TO INDIGENOUS TRIBES DEFORESTATION BEGAN DURING THE FRENCH COLONIAL PERIOD AND GREW WHEN COFFEE WAS INTRODUCED IN 1730
70% DEPEND ON FARMING FOR A LIVING 15000
ACRES OF TOPSOIL IS WASHED AWAY ANNUALLY
“WE’RE NOT FOOLS; WE KNOW THAT THIS IS DESTROYING THE LAND, BUT CHARCOAL IS WHAT KEEPS US ALIVE” - LIBERUS MESADIEU (FARMER)
AFTER THE 1804 REVOLUTION THE GOVERNMENT WAS FORCED TO EXPORT TIMBER TO PAY OFF A 90 MILLION FRANC INDEMNITY TO FRANCE THE RURAL POOR WERE GIVEN LAND ON MOUNTAINOUS INCLINES, AIDING SOIL EROSION AFTER THE 1954 HURRICANE INCREASED NEEDS FOR COAL, RESULTING IN THE FORESTING OF YOUNG TREES
HAITI
04
DOMINICAN REPUBLIC
We needed to select a material which was highly durable, easily workable, readily available and cheap to produce. As the island of Haiti was almost entirely stripped of its forests, resulting in loose top soils increasing risk to landslides during heavy rains, we decided a solution would be to introduce bamboo to the area, which is one of the fastest growing grasses in the world, extremely strong, easily workable and would secure the top soil.
In order to understand the cultural demographic of Haiti we undertook research into emblematic Haitian objects, features which we could then incorporate within the new proposal. It was important to do this as it meant that the new design would not be foreign concept to the people who would be constructing their own homes.
05
Community
Urban Routes
Access
Sustain Revive Belong Transition
FAMILY
06
+
SPACE
=
LAKOU
Haitian living revolves around family and specific courtyard areas known as ‘Lakou’. Shared plots of land for building houses, planting crops and socialising for up to a dozen homes. This arrangement formed the basis to our conceptual approach for the new design.
Numerous sketches were drawn thinking about the form, scale and spatial arrangement of the unit. The geometry of the building was an important factor as during high winds the building needed to be aerodynamic, deflecting as much wind as possible. Raising the unit up on stilts was another consideration, dealing with rising water during flooding.
07
08
Reciprocal structures are configured in such as way as to be self supporting. Each individual member provides support to the next. This type of construction has historically been used in the construction of roofs for different nomadic cultures and provide an easy and robust form of construction for the housing unit. A number of different configuration were tested in the workshop for easy of construction and strength.
When 3 or more poles overlap in turn the self supporting structure formed is called a reciprocal frame.
_4
HI DE
AS
_3
SKETC
EA HI D
SKETC
HI D
Sketch design for the potentials of reciprocal structure for the new house design. We decided that a 4 member reciprocal structure would be best suited for a square building plan. The resultant roof profile meant that the building would be able to deflect wind from all directions and gave an interesting aesthetic appearance.
S
_2
EA
S
_1
SKETC
SKETC
HI D
EA
S
Able to span large distances using minimal materials whilst supporting using simple overlapping joints.
09
10
A panel system was devised in order to allow for a modular form of construction, where the individual house owner could construct the panels in different variations to give them a sense of ownership. It also worked well in regards to maintaining the building, if there was any damage, the panel could be reconstructed and slotted back in place.
After rationalising the design we finally came up with a ‘kit of parts’ which were needed to complete your typical housing unit.
11
12
Sequential model showing the different stages of construction.
HIPPED CUPOLA
CORRUGATED STEEL SHEETING/ BAMBOO WEAVE
BAMBOO ROOF BATONS
RECIPROCAL BAMBOO STRUCTURE
COLLAPSIBLE BAMBOO WEAVE CANOPY
BAMBOO CANOPY STRUCTURE (PERMANENT) BAMBOO TRELLIS STRUCTURE
BAMBOO CANOPY COLUMN BAMBOO PANEL SYSTEM
FLOOR BUILD UP: - SPLIT AND FLATTENED BAMBOO CLUM - BAMBOO JOISTS - BAMBOO BEAMS
BAMBOO STRUCTURAL COLUMN (4 IN EACH GROUP)
RUBBLE BAG FOUNDATIONS
Exploded axonometric drawing showing how the different elements of the construction would be slotted into one another to complete the solid form of the single unit.
13
(Defensible Space) 1000mm
(Protected Core) 3000mm
(Defensible Space) 1000mm
5000mm
Breathable Facade Element (Bamboo Sections) SLEEPING AND STORAGE
Breathable Facade Element (Bamboo Weave)
Verandah Canopy Top Ventilated Openable Element Gingerbread-esque Latticework
Bamboo Trellis (South Facade)
COOKING AND SOCIALISING
14
Ground Floor Level
The single module was the basis of the design, which would provide adequate shelter for the family. This unit could then be added to when more funds were made available.
STREET (CREOLE)
5000mm
STREET (CAILLE)
(Defensible Space) 1000mm
(Protected Core) 3000mm
(Defensible Space) 1000mm
LIVING
5000mm
BEDROOM KITCHEN (COVERED OR UNCOVERED)
PLANTING ZONE
Combined module which provided an additional living area and interstitial kitchen or covered area.
15
STREET (CREOLE) (Protected Core) 3000mm
(Defensible Space) 1000mm
BEDROOM
5000mm
LIVING/KITCHEN
STREET (CAILLE)
5000mm
(Defensible Space) 1000mm
ENCLOSED
16
The combined unit could be configured into numerous iterations so that the occupant could have control over their own living environment.
STREET (CREOLE) (Protected Core) 3000mm
(Defensible Space) 1000mm
(PLANTING ZONE) 1000mm
BEDROOM
5000mm
LIVING/KITCHEN
STREET (CAILLE)
5000mm
(Defensible Space) 1000mm
PLANTING ZONE
TRELLIS
The external trellising could also be used for planting for food crops, tyeing back to the original concept of planting within the ‘lakou’
17
BEDROOM 1
LIVING/KITCHEN
1000mm
3000mm
SMALL COURTYARD (INCREASED SOCIAL ASPECT)
W.C.
2000mm
4000mm
BEDROOM 2
18
The individual and combined unit could be added to piecemeal exponentially until the occupants have enough space for their needs.
(Protected Core) 3000mm
(Defensible Space) 1000mm
LIVING/KITCHEN
BEDROOM 1
STAIRS
5000mm
(Defensible Space) 1000mm
900
3100mm
3100mm
FIRST FLOOR
7100mm
GROUND FLOOR
A two story unit for constrained sites within Port Au Prince was also possible by locating a steep stair/ ladder arrangement along one of the verandas.
19
FIRST FLOOR
GROUND FLOOR
20
The double story units could also be coupled together so that extended families could all live under one roof. The central stair case would also help to provide structural stability for both units.
Reciprocal Shelter
The reciprocal frame allowed for other typologies to be constructed. A tent structure could be easily constructed to provide initial shelter following a disaster. Once funds and materials have been made available these would then be used in the construction of the single unit. A pavilion could also be constructed as a communal space for the lakou.
Pavilion
21
LIVING WALL Trellis provides a ventilated edge to the module. Trellis enables fruit and vegetable growing without requiring a large cassava patch which is especially useful in city plots.
+
Vertical climbers provide both fruit and vegetables but also extra shade to the protected core.
Water collected either straight from the home water butt or from the filtration system can be used to hydrate the cassava gardens and help the produce grow.
Climbers provide an extra layer of privacy.
WATER
EXCRETE EAT
COMPOST
ECO-SAN DRY TOILET Bacteria thrive at high temperatures (4060ยบC) and oxidise the waste into components, some of which are used in the process, thereby reducing the volume and removing pathogens. Oxygen is required during the process and as such the toilet needs to be well ventilated. Vetiver grass ash can be added to speed up the decomposition process.
22
GROW
The compost created by the eco-san toilet can then be utilised in producing crops and growing fruit bearing trees such as avocado and mango trees.
SELL
Food can be grown to either eat within the Lakou and the home or to sell at the market or from a stall.
Lakou Eco-Cycle & The Living Wall: As well as the design of the basic unit we took into consideration how the building along with the composting toilet and the surrounding area (lakou) could be utilised to provide the owners a better chance of self sustainable living.
Caille (Kay)
A study of the local housing typologies to Haiti was undertaken to understand the current forms of construction, materials and aesthetic preference. 3 different housing types were identified, the Caille, Creole & gingerbread house. Elements from all three housing types were then brought forward into the new design of the unit, making it a more familiar concept to introduce to the people of Haiti. Maximising its chance of being adopted as an alternative.
Gingerbread House
Creole
23
Housing Model Comparison
HOUSING MODULE COMPARISON Module Footprint: 25m2 Module Footprint: 25m2 Module Area: 25m2
Module Area: 25m2
Module footprint: 50m2 Module footprint: 50m2 Module Area: 50m2
Module footprint: 50m2 Module footprint: 50m2 Module Area: 50m2
2 MODULES_CAILLE
2 MODULES_CREOLE
Module Area: 50m2
Module Area: 50m2
24
1 MODULE
1 MODULE
2 MODULES_CAILLE
2 MODULES_CREOLE
Module footprint: 100m2 Module Area: 75m2
Module footprint: 25m2 Module Area: 50m2
Module footprint: 50m2 Module Area: 100m2
25
3 MODULES
2 STOREY_1 MODULE
2 STOREY_2 MODULES
26
Landscape Domestication Lakou: Visual which showed how the new units could be situated within different contextual settings.
Landscape Domestication Gingerbread House: Visual showing the more developed unit as funds and materials made available and the home owner added to their single unit.
27
RAINWATER COLLECTION STRATEGY •
Bamboo poles halved along length.
•
Capping nodes retained at each end.
•
•
Internal Nodes removed.
Gutter supported from roof frame set to a 2% fall. •
Bamboo Gutter System (Halved using traditional methods, usually machete)
Hole cut at end to locate down pipe.
Hollowed-out bamboo poles as down pipes. The water collected via the guttering system will be reused within the home for washing and cleaning, and it will be up to the homes’ discretion if they wish to drink it. If they don’t wish to, a water filtration tank is provided to each Lakou, to be maintained and topped up by the Lakou members.
Bamboo Halved
Water Collection Tank Semi-submerged underneath the floor of house to keep water cool and shaded. Water scarcity is a problem in Haiti, thereby providing collection point helps to alleviate the issue to the homes.
Water Filtration
28
Different strategies were developed to maximise the buildings potential for things such as rainwater collection which could then be purified and used for drinking or washing and watering plants. This was simply a section of bamboo split into two pieces and hollowed out.
Perimeter Verandah
Due to the extreme temperature experienced in Haiti throughout the year it was important to provide adequate solar shading and ventilation to the unit. This was achieved by encasing the central living space with an open terrace which runs around the perimeter providing shading throughout the day.
Perspective section 2 story unit: Solar shading study
29
NTILATION STRATEGY
TILATION STRATEGY ections/off cuts will be threaded together and located at the top of each panel in order to allow for the free flow of air to cross ventilate through the space.
ons/off cuts will be threaded together and located at the top of each panel in order to allow for the free flow of air to cross ventilate through the space.
Ventilation Louvres
e has a core and external veranda, creating a protected interstitial space allowing air to circulate around and through the core.
Cross Ventilation
Ventilation Strategy PERSPECTIVE SECTION 2 STORY UNIT: VENTILATION
s a core and external veranda, creating a protected interstitial space allowing air to circulate around and through the core.
PERSPECTIVE SECTION 2 STORY UNIT: VENTILATION
30
The perimeter terrace allowed for free flowing air to circulate around the core reducing internal temperatures. Circular cut sections of bamboo where used to create ventilation louvers at the top of each panel, allowing cross ventilation to circulate through the enclosed space.
Vertical Splicing Joint
Rubble Bag Foundations
In order to make the unit as easy to build as possible for its owner we rationalised the number of different construction techniques needed. Meaning that all the construction could be done using only a spade, machete and binding.
Reciprocal Roof
Structural Elements: Single Story Module
Fish Mouth Joint
31
32
The foundation consisted of digging four 900mm x 90mm x 600mm holes into which rubble bag would be staked, utilizing previous rubble from past disasters. The individual columns would then be nestled within the central space between the ruble bags and bedded in with more sand and rubble. This form of construction allowed for movement during and earthquake.
CO
EC
TIO
N
FI S H M O
UT
H
NN
We personally tested a number of joinery techniques in order to determine which was the easiest to construct and the strongest. We finally settled on a fish mouth connection with binding. This form of joint could be repeated for all area of the panel constructed.
33
JOINERY: ROOF CONSTRUCTION
STAGE 1: • Mark out using a 3000x3000mm square • In the center place a smaller square of 1000x1000mm at roughly 35 degrees to the larger square.
STAGE 2: • Lay the bamboo poles one on top of the other as shown above, in relation to the small square. • In each pole, drill a hole through the top and bottom of of the pole at the large square end. • Thread twine several times through all 4 poles to hold in tension.
STAGE 3: • Gradually close the inner square making it smaller and increasing the pitch of the frame. • The outer twine square should now be taught. • Lash each pole to its supporting counter part • Split 2 poles in half to go on top of the frame.
STAGE 4: • Once happy with the pitch check all lashings are tightened. •Secure the halved bamboo gutters to the supporting poles. •Overlay the corrugated steel sheeting to mark out the shape to be cut
OPEN/CLOSE In the event of an impending storm, the canopy above the verandah will be able to close down and cover the top ventilation openings to the core, thereby providing extra protection to the inhabitants.
Retracting Canopy during Heavy wind and rain
34
The decision to use a reciprocal structure to form the roof meant that the structure would be self supporting reducing the amount of technical joinery needed. Corrugated steel panels were chosen as they were durable readily available and cheap. An additional panel was added to the canopy structure which could be closed down over the ventilation louvers during heavy wind and rain.
M
SP
LI C
IN G J OINT
TI G H T E
NE
D
BA
BO
O
A splice joint was developed to connect two vertical members. A locating piece of bamboo is place within the hollowcore of the bamboo column and bound by twisting the string around two pieces of timber which were then tied back to the column to form a spine.
35
36