'& cË\Zfefd`X X
)+ ;Ă&#x2039;8>FJK ;<C )''/
Ä&#x2020;a YÂ&#x192;ci^b
<eZXiX hl\ \cj j\im\`j j`^l`e \cj gifkX^fe`jk\j# cĂ&#x2039;\Zfefd`X [\ GXcXdÂ?j \jk~ dfck [`m\ij`Ă&#x201D;ZX[X
Ef efdÂ&#x201E;j \j m`l [\ kli`jd\ 8 dÂ&#x201E;j [\ j\i leX `dgfikXek [\j$ k`eXZ`Â? g\i Xcj Zi\l\ij# ` d\eki\ dXekÂ&#x201E; \c j\l mXcfi Zfd X Z\eki\ kliÂ&#x2C6;jk`Z# X GXcXdÂ?j cX g\jZX j\^l\`o j\ek mXclfjX ` \c j\Zkfi `e[ljki`Xc Xdgc`Xi~ cX j\mX jlg\i]Â&#x2C6;Z`\ g\i XcY\i^Xi efm\j \dgi\j\j%
d
Â&#x192;i lWb de Z[_nWh#i[ [d]WdoWh f[h b[i WfW# h[dY[i$ BW fh_c[hW _cfh[ii_Â&#x152; Z[ gk_ Whh_XW W FWbWcÂ&#x152;i f[h fh_c[hW l[]WZW fej i[h gk[ Wgk[ijW Y_kjWj Z[ ]W_h[XÂ&#x192; '.$&&& ^WX_jWdji Â&#x192;i kdW jhWdgk_bĂ&#x2C6;bW beYW# b_jWj gk[ l_k Z[b jkh_ic[ _ Z[ bW f[iYW$ F[hÂ? ^_ ^W cÂ&#x192;i" XWijWdj cÂ&#x192;i f[h Z[iYeXh_h$ xi Y[hj gk[ Wgk[ij[i Zk[i WYj_l_jWji iÂ&#x152;d [bi i[ki Zei cejehi [YedÂ?c_Yi fh_dY_fWbi$ I_jkWZW [d kdW fh_l_b[]_WZW kX_YWY_Â&#x152; W bW YecWhYW Z[b 8W_n ;cfehZ}" W bW h[]_Â&#x152; Z[ bW 9eijW 8hWlW" FWbWcÂ&#x152;i YecX_dW b½WYj_l_jWj jkhÂ&#x2021;ij_YW ¸bW i[lW feXbWY_Â&#x152; Yh[_n Ă&#x2026;di Wbi /& c_b ^WX_jWdji Wbi c[iei Z½[ij_k¸ WcX kd fehj Z½WYj_l_jWj YedijWdj" ed [b i[Yjeh Z[bi Yh[k[hi i½[ij} _cfe# iWdj Wdo h[h[ Wdo$ ÂşFWbWcÂ&#x152;i jÂ&#x192; kdW [Yedec_W Z_l[hi_\_YWZW gk[" W Z_\[hÂ&#x201E;dY_W Z½Wbjh[i ckd_Y_f_i" de [i XWiW decÂ&#x192;i [d [b jkh_ic[Âť" WlWdÂ&#x201A;W @ei[f FWb[j" h[]_Zeh Z[ b½W`kdjW# c[dj _ W Y}hh[Y Z[ b½}h[W Z½;Yede# c_W _ >_i[dZW$ 7gk[ij [Z_b Z[ijWYW gk[" W cÂ&#x192;i Z[ b[i WYj_l_jWji jkhÂ&#x2021;i# j_gk[i _ fehjk}h_[i" jWcXÂ&#x192; [i cWdjÂ&#x192; kdW Z[ijWYWZW fh[iÂ&#x201E;dY_W _dZkijh_Wb" _ i_ XÂ&#x192; bW cW`eh fWhj iÂ&#x152;d [cfh[i[i c_j`Wd[i _ f[j_j[i" jWcXÂ&#x192; ^_ ^W bW c[jWbĂ&#x2C6;bÂ&#x2018;h]_W >kjY# ^_died" gk[ eYkfW fhef Z[ +&& f[hied[i$ DyJ JçC @E;LJKI@8C ;b Yh[_n[c[dj Z[ bW _dZÂ&#x2018;ijh_W beYWb" W_nÂ&#x2021; Yec bW _dj[dY_Â&#x152; Z½Wjh[kh[ del[i [cfh[i[i" ^W fehjWj W fhe# cekh[ kd dek fbW Z½ehZ[dWY_Â&#x152;
khXWdÂ&#x2021;ij_YW" gk[ f[hc[jh} Yecf# jWh WcX cÂ&#x192;i j[hh[doi f[h [Z_Ă&#x2026;YWh kd febÂ&#x2021;]ed _dZkijh_Wb gk[ i½_dijWb# bWh} W bW pedW Z[ BW F_[jWj" fhef Z[ bW Y_kjWj$ I½^Wd _dl[hj_j i_i Wdoi Z½[ijkZ_i fh[l_i f[h Zkh W j[hc[ Wgk[ijW _d_Y_Wj_lW _ Wb i[j[cXh[ [i fkXb_YWh} Wb 8kjbb[jÂ&#x2021; EĂ&#x2026;Y_Wb Z[ bW =[d[hWb_jWj$ 7hW Yec[dY[d b[i jWigk[i Z½khXWd_jpWY_Â&#x152; _ fhel_i_Â&#x152; Z[ i[h# l[_i" _ [i YWbYkbW gk[ Z½kdW ikf[h# \Â&#x2021;Y_[ XhkjW Z[ *)+ c_b c[jh[i gkWZhWji" i[½d Z[ij_dWhWd '/' c_b f[h W Â&#x2018;i _dZkijh_Wb" Z[bi gkWbi cÂ&#x192;i Z½kd j[hÂ&#x201A; i[hWd f[h Wcfb_Wh _dZÂ&#x2018;ijh_[i `W _dijWbĂ&#x2C6;bWZ[i$ Âş 7gk[ij fhe`[Yj[ jh_]Wh} kd j[cfi W h[Wb_j# pWh#i[" f[hÂ? b[i f[hif[Yj_l[i iÂ&#x152;d cebj fei_j_l[iÂť" Z_k FWb[j$ :I<@O<D<EK <OGCFJ@L 8 CĂ&#x2039;<JK@L Kd Z[bi fheXb[c[i gk[ jÂ&#x192; FWbWcÂ&#x152;i" _ gk[ Â&#x192;i YecÂ&#x2018; W bW cW`eh_W Z[ ckd_Y_f_i jkhÂ&#x2021;ij_Yi" Â&#x192;i b½WbĂ&#x2C6;bkl_Â&#x152; Z½^WX_jWdji gk[ Whh_XW W b½[ij_k _ W Z[j[hc_dWZ[i Â&#x201E;fegk[i Z[ b½Wdo" Yec I[jcWdW IWdjW e [bi fedji1 jkh_ij[i Wbi gkWbi YWb Xh_dZWh i[h# l[_i _ _d\hW[ijhkYjkh[i [d f[hÂ&#x2021;eZ[i cebj Xh[ki$
G8C8DäJ <E O@=I<J GXcXd�j mX j\i ]le[X[X \c ().0 g\c i\` G\i\ \c >iXe# g\i [\]\ejXi \c j\l gfik%
8kli i\^`jkiXk g\i j\o\%
8c 9X`o <dgfi[~# cĂ&#x2039;Xep )''- \c G@9 mX ZiÂ&#x201E;`o\i \e cX ZfejkilZZ`Â? dÂ&#x201E;j hl\ \e \cj Xcki\j j\Zkfij%
8 GXcXdÂ?j# cĂ&#x2039;Xkli Zi\`o dÂ&#x201E;j \eki\ c\j [fe\j%
GXcXdÂ?j
9X`o <dgfi[~
9X`o <dgfi[~ GXcXdÂ?j
.#-(
:XkXclepX -#*/ )#).
)#'.
-' K\ii`kfi` ` gfYcXZ`Â?1 ,' Jlg\i]Â&#x2C6;Z`\ kfkXc1 (+ bd) GfYcXZ`Â?1 (.%+'' _XY% ;\ej`kXk1 (%)++#- _XY%&bd) :fdXiZX1 9X`o <dgfi[~%
+' ' )''-
)''.
Gi`dXi`
@e[Â&#x2019;jki`X :fejkilZZ`Â? J\im\`j
=fek @ @[\jZXk %
GXcXdÂ?j# Zfd Xcki\j dle`Z`g`j kliÂ&#x2C6;jk`Zj# kÂ&#x201E; XcĂ&#x2014;clm`fej [Ă&#x2039;_XY`kXekj \e [\k\id`eX[\j Â&#x2026;gfhl\j [\ cĂ&#x2039;Xep
Le j\Zkfi hl\ g\ij`jk\`o CX g\jZX Zfd\iZ`Xc Â&#x201E;j leX [\ c\j XZk`m`kXkj dÂ&#x201E;j `d$ gfikXekj [\ cX Z`lkXk ` ]fek [Ă&#x2039;fZlgXZ`Â? [`i\ZkX ` `e$ [`i\ZkX g\i X ki\j d`c g\ijfe\j% AlekXd\ek XdY \c gfik [\ JXek =\c`l [\ >lÂ&#x2C6;ofcj# \j ZXgkli\e gifg [\ )%''' kfe\j [\ g\`o cĂ&#x2039;Xep# fe [\jkXZX cX ]Xdf$ jX >XdYX [\ GXcXdÂ?j% <c Dlj\l [\ cX G\jZX cfZXc Â&#x201E;j k\jk`dfe` [\ cX _`jkÂ&#x17D;$ i`X [Ă&#x2039;Xhl\jkX XZk`m`kXk% 8ZklXcd\ek# \cj g\jZX[fij kiX[`Z`feXcj k\e\e Y\e\Ă&#x201D;Z`j ^i~Z`\j X c\j jlYm\e$ Z`fej Xc ZfdYljk`$ Yc\# g\iÂ&#x17D; c\j glaX[\j \e \c gi\l [\c g\kifc` Zfdgc`hl\e cĂ&#x2039;XZk`m`kXk%
ÂşB[i W`kZ[i gk[ h[X[c Z[ b½;ijWj iÂ&#x152;d [d \kdY_Â&#x152; Z[ bW gkWd# j_jWj Z[ f[hied[i Y[diWZ[i gk[ j[d_c$ F[hÂ? [bi jkh_ij[i de [ijWd [cfWZhedWji1 h[X[c _d]h[iiei f[h '. c_b ^WX_jWdji _" [d Z[j[h# c_dWZ[i Â&#x201E;fegk[i Z[ b½Wdo" j[d_c Z[if[i[i ikf[h_ehi" [d gkÂ&#x201E; YWb \[h Z[ifb[]Wc[dji Z[ d[j[`W" feb_# Y_W" [jYÂ&#x201E;j[hW$ _ de YeXh[c kdW jWnW jkhÂ&#x2021;ij_YW Yec W b[i 8Wb[WhiÂť" [nfb_YW [b h[]_Zeh FWb[j$ Kd _d\ehc[ h[Y[dj Z[ bW IeY_# [jWj Z[ JWnWY_Â&#x152; I7 ^Wl_W _dZ_YWj gk[" h[if[Yj[ W bW Yh_i_ _cceX_# b_}h_W" FWbWcÂ&#x152;i ^Wl_W [ijWj bW Y_k# jWj Z[ =_hedW ed cÂ&#x192;i ^Wl_W XW_nWj [b fh[k Z[b c[jh[ gkWZhWj$ 7cX kd Z[iY[di Z[b +". " [i Yej_jpW W ($'/) [khei$ F[h Wb fh[i_Z[dj Z[ bW 9Wc# XhW Z[ 9ec[hÂ&#x201A; Z[ FWbWcÂ&#x152;i" NWl_[h H_X[hW" Wgk[ijW i_jkWY_Â&#x152; Â&#x192;i i_c_# bWh [d jeji [bi ckd_Y_f_i gk[ j[d[d kdW WbjW jWnW Z[ i[]ed[i h[i_ZÂ&#x201E;d# Y_[i" Âşf[hÂ? FWbWcÂ&#x152;i jÂ&#x192; kd fbki [d [b fh[k Z[bi ^WX_jWj][i" f[hgkÂ&#x201E; [dYWhW gk[ i_]k_ kdW c_YW cÂ&#x192;i YWh gk[ Wbjh[i bbeYi" jÂ&#x192; kdW l_ZW fhÂ?f_W jej b½Wdo" WcX cebji i[hl[_i" YWf_#
<cj \og\ikj fg`e\e OXm`\i Afj\g I`Y\iX GXc\k Ă&#x2C6;8dY \cj Zi\l\ij# mXd Ă&#x201D;^liXi Xcj ZXk~c\^j Xc ZfjkXk [\ Dfek\iZXicf ` ;lYifme`bĂ&#x2030;
Ă&#x2C6;CX efjkiX \Zfefd`X Â&#x201E;j [`m\ij`Ă&#x201D;ZX[X ` ef \j YXjX efdÂ&#x201E;j \e \c kli`jd\Ă&#x2030;
jWd_W cWhÂ&#x2021;j_cWÂą Â&#x192;i kdW f[j_jW Y_k# jWj ed bW gkWb_jWj Z[ l_ZW [i dejWÂť$ F[b gk[ \W Wbi i[hl[_i" [b i[Yjeh Yec[hY_Wb Â&#x192;i kd Z[bi cÂ&#x192;i WYj_ki Z[b ckd_Y_f_ _ Z[b Yed`kdj Z[ bW YecWhYW" f[hÂ? jWcXÂ&#x192; i½Wcfb_W [d Wbjh[i YWcfi$ F[h [n[cfb[" b½>ei# f_jWb Z[ FWbWcÂ&#x152;i" gk[ [dYWhW gk[ Z[fÂ&#x201E;d Z[b 9ediehY_ 7ii_ij[dY_Wb Z[b 8W_n ;cfehZ}" Â&#x192;i kdW \edj Z½eYkfWY_Â&#x152; f[h W ]W_h[XÂ&#x192; Zk[i c_b f[hied[i$ AlXe G\[if :_l\k$D`jjÂ&#x201E;
:X[X m\^X[X dÂ&#x201E;j Zi\l\ij ;Ă&#x2039;lk`c`kXk
:;I GK; L7D 9EC;Dw7H W Whh_XWh [b '//+" [bi Yh[k[hi jkhÂ&#x2021;ij_Yi gk[ l_i_j[d FWbWcÂ&#x152;i lWd Wk]c[djWdj [d decXh[ Z½[iYWb[i _ [d fWiiWj][hi$ ;b fehj beYWb Â&#x192;i [b i[]ed Z[ 9WjWbkdoW" Z[i# fhÂ&#x192;i Z[b Z[ 8WhY[bedW" [d h[Y[fY_Â&#x152; Z½Wgk[iji ^ej[bi Ă&#x2020;ejWdji1 _ Wgk[ij Yh[_n[c[dj lW Zkh W _dWk]khWh kdW delW [ijWY_Â&#x152; cWhÂ&#x2021;j_cW [b fWi# iWj c[i Z[ cW_]" gk[ lW _cfb_YWh kdW _dl[hi_Â&#x152; Z[ )&& c_b [khei$ F[h Wb fh[i_Z[dj Z[ bW 9WcXhW Z[ 9ec[hÂ&#x201A;" NWl_[h H_X[hW" W cÂ&#x192;i Z[b X[d[\_Y_ [YedÂ?# c_Y" b½Whh_XWZW Z[ jkh_ij[i Z[ Yh[k[hi W`kZW ÂşW ZedWh#dei kdW _cWj][" kdW cWhYW Z[ FWbWcÂ&#x152;i" ed lWc Ă&#x2026;]khWh Wbi YWj}b[]i Wb YeijWj
Z[ Y_kjWji Yedieb_ZWZ[i [d Wgk[ij }cX_j" Yec WhW Cedj[YWhbe e :kXheld_aÂť$ <CJ GI<LJ1 =I< 8 C8 EĂ LK@:8 <JGFIK@M8 ;b fehj Z[ FWbWcÂ&#x152;i jWcXÂ&#x192; Â&#x192;i kd Z[bi cÂ&#x192;i _cfehjWdji Z[ bW d}kj_YW [ifehj_lW W bW 9eijW 8hWlW$ De eXijWdj W_nÂ?" iÂ&#x152;d \h[gÂ&#x201D;[dji b[i gk[_n[i f[bi fh[ki [b[lWji Z[bi WcWhhWZehi" ieXh[jej YecfWhWji WcX [b Yeij Z[ bW H_l_[hW <hWdY[iW$ F[h W H_X[hW" W_nÂ? [i Z[k Wb \[j gk[ W <hWdÂ&#x201A;W Âşde ^_ ^W b½[if[YkbWY_Â&#x152; Z[ iÂ?b gk[ ^_ ^W WgkÂ&#x2021;Âť _ gk[ bW bb[_ Z[ fehji [ijWjWb b_c_jW b[i YedY[ii_edi W )& Wdoi$ ÂşF[h jWdj" kdW _d\hW[i# jhkYjkhW fehjk}h_W" gk[ `W Â&#x192;i YWhW" ^W Z½Wceh# j_jpWh#i[ Yec W c}n_c [d Wgk[ij bWfi[Âť" Z_k$
:I<L<IJ ;< CLO< 8 G8C8DäJ <c )''.# \c gfik [\ GXcXdÂ?j mX i\Yi\ feq\ ^iXej Zi\l\ij hl\ mXe i\Xc`kqXi leX ki\ek\eX [Ă&#x2039;\jZXc\j ` hl\ mXe XZfjkXi X dÂ&#x201E;j [\ )) d`c gXjjXk^\ij Xc dle`Z`g`% 8c^lej mXe j\i1 :I<L<IJ ?\Yi`[\Xe Jg`i`k J\XYflie C\^\e[ JkX[ 8djk\i[Xd K_fdjfe ;\jk`ep K_fdjfe Jg`i`k N`e[ Jg`i`k N`e[ Jli]
<J:8C<J G8JJ8K><IJ ( /* + .0( (). - /%00( ) )%+-' ( 0+ , (%,'-
KFK8C )''. *' ))%(/+