Judge William B. Shubb Disqualification Order Prosecutorial Misconduct-Fraud on the Court

About

Location

Contact

Website Suggestion?

Search

Home

Judges

Attorney Info

United States Magistrate Judge Gary S. Austin (GSA)

CM/ECF E-Filing

Rules

Forms

Jury Info

Clerk's Office

Careers

Go

Education

Home » Judges » All Judges » Senior United States District Judge William B. Shubb (WBS)

SENIOR UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE WILLIAM B. SHUBB (WBS) United States Magistrate Judge Dennis L. Beck (DLB)

United States Magistrate Judge Stanley A. Boone (SAB) United States Magistrate Judge Edmund F. Brennan (EFB) Senior United States District Judge Garland E. Burrell, Jr. (GEB)

Robert T. Matsui United States Courthouse 501 I Street Sacramento, CA 95814

Courtroom 5, 14th Floor

Biography

United States Magistrate Judge Allison Claire (AC) United States Magistrate Judge Carolyn K. Delaney (CKD) Chief United States Magistrate Judge Dale A. Drozd (DAD) Chief United States District Judge Morrison C. England, Jr. (MCE)

United States Magistrate Judge Gregory G. Hollows (GGH) Senior United States District Judge Anthony W. Ishii (AWI)

CASE MANAGEMENT PROCEDURES

JUDGE STAFF Courtroom Deputy:

United States Magistrate Judge Craig M. Kellison (CMK)

Procedures to be followed in cases assigned to Hon. William B. Shubb

Karen Kirksey Smith kkirkseysmith@caed.uscourts.gov

United States Magistrate Judge Barbara A. McAuliffe (BAM)

(916) 930-4234

Standard Information

Court Reporter:

United States District Judge John A. Mendez (JAM)

For court reporter information and to order transcripts click here

United States District Judge Kimberly J. Mueller (KJM)

Chambers: United States Magistrate Judge Kendall J. Newman (KJN)

(916) 930-4230

United States District Judge Troy L. Nunley (TLN)

Law Clerks: Alexandra Heifetz Breann Moebius

United States Magistrate Judge Sheila K. Oberto (SKO)

Channing Turner

MOTION SCHEDULE Motion Type: Civil Day: Designated Mondays* Time: 02:00 p.m.

Motion Type: Criminal Day: Mondays* Time: 09:30 a.m.

Courtroom: 5, 14th floor Telephone: (916) 930-4234

United States District Judge Lawrence J. O'Neill (LJO)

*See dates in Standard Information

United States Magistrate Judge Michael J. Seng (MJS)

Senior United States District Judge William B. Shubb (WBS)

Judge Shubb's court calendars:

See Local Rules for proper noticing of motions.

Available hearing dates are subject to change without notice. Please verify last minute changes with the courtroom deputy.

Senior United States District Judge William B. Shubb (WBS) United States Recalled Magistrate Judge Sandra M. Snyder (SMS) United States Magistrate Judge Jennifer L. Thurston (JLT)

Case 2:09-cv-02445-KJM-EFB Document 603 Filed 10/15/14 Page 1 of 3

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

9

EASTERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

10 11

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,

12 13 14

No. 2:09-cv-02445-KJM-EFB

Plaintiff, v.

ORDER

SIERRA PACIFIC INDUSTRIES, et al.,

15

Defendants.

16 17

In July 2012, the parties to this action entered into a settlement agreement. See

18

ECF Nos. 577-78, 592. Defendants agreed to pay $55 million to the United States over

19

five years, and Sierra Pacific agreed to transfer 22,500 acres of land through ongoing

20

negotiations. ECF No. 593-3. Thereafter, the Court closed the matter, but retained

21

jurisdiction to enforce the terms of the compromise settlement. Order, ECF No. 592.

22

On October 9, 2014, Defendant Sierra Pacific Industries (“Sierra Pacific�) together

23

with the other named Defendants1 moved to set aside the judgment in this case for fraud

24 25 26 27 28

1

The other named-defendants include Eunice Howell, individually and dba Howell's Forest Harvesting Company ("Howell's"); W.M. Beaty &Associates, Ina (`Beaty") and the following parties (hereinafter collectively "the Landowners"): Ann McKeever Hatch, as Trustee of the Hatch 1987 Revocable Trust; Richard L. Greene, as Trustee of the Hatch Irrevocable Trust; Brooks Walker, Jr., as Trustee of the Brooks Walker, Jr. Revocable Trust, and the Della Walker Van Loben Sels Trust for the Issue of Brooks Walker, Jr.; Brooks Walker, III, Individually and as Trustee of the Clayton Brooks Danielsen Trust, the Myles Walker Danielsen Trust, the Margaret Charlotte Burlock Trust, and the Benjamin Walker Burlock Trust; Leslie Walker, Individually, and as Trustee of the Brooks Thomas Walker Trust, the Susie Kate Walker Trust, and the Della Grace Walker Trust; Wellington Smith Henderson, Jr., as Trustee of the

1

Case 2:09-cv-02445-KJM-EFB Document 603 Filed 10/15/14 Page 2 of 3

1

on the Court under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(d)(3) (the “Motion”). Mot., ECF

2

No. 593. Defendants base their Motion on the grounds that the United States'

3

prosecution of this action constituted a fraud upon the Court when the United States

4

attorneys and the Moonlight Fire investigators and their counterparts in co-pending state

5

actions, operating under a joint prosecution agreement with the United States, advanced

6

a corrupt and tainted prosecution, violated Defendants' due process rights, and engaged

7

in investigatory and prosecutorial misconduct.2 Id. Defendants allege that this

8

misconduct was perpetrated by officers of the Court and ultimately tampered with the

9

administration of justice, in a manner that wronged not only Defendants, but also the

10

Court and the public. Id. According to Defendants, the government's misconduct

11

compromised the judicial process and amounts to an unconscionable scheme designed

12

to improperly influence the Court's decisions in this case.3 Id. In fact, Defendants state

13

that they perceive the Court itself as a victim “as it has neither had the chance to fully

14

assess the trust it naturally placed in certain federal prosecutors nor the ability to do so

15

in the context of all that was eventually discovered about the thoroughly corrupt and

16

financially driven Moonlight Fire investigation.” ECF No. 593-3. Defendants ask that the

17

Court set aside the judgment and the Settlement Agreement and dismiss this action in

18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27

Henderson Revocable Trust; Elena D. Henderson, Individually; Mark W. Henderson, as Trustee of the Mark W. Henderson Revocable Trust; John C. Walker, Individually, and as Trustee of the Della Walker Van Loben Sels Trust for the Issue of John C. Walker; James A. Henderson, Individually; Charles C. Henderson, as Trustee of the Charles C. and Kirsten Henderson Revocable Trust; Joan H. Henderson, Individually; Jennifer Walker, Individually, and as Trustee of the Emma Walker Silverman Trust, and the Max Walker Silverman Trust; Kirby Walker, Individually; and Lindsey Walker, a.k.a. Lindsey WalkerSilverman, Individually, and as Trustee of the Reilly Hudson Keenan Trust, and the Madison Flanders Keenan Trust.

2

Specifically, Defendants allege, among other things, that the United States presented false evidence to the Defendants and the Court and/or concealed material evidence from the Defendants and the Court; advanced arguments to the Court premised on that false evidence, or for which material evidence had been withheld, and obtaining Court rulings based thereon; prepared key Moonlight Fire investigators for depositions, and allowed them to repeatedly give false testimony about the most important aspects of their investigation; and failed to disclose the facts and circumstances associated with the Moonlight Fire lead investigator's direct financial interest in the outcome of the investigation arising from an illegal bank account that has since been exposed and terminated. ECF No. 593.

3

28

Defendants believe that the circumstances may warrant the appointment of special master.

ECF No. 593.

2

Case 2:09-cv-02445-KJM-EFB Document 603 Filed 10/15/14 Page 3 of 3

1

its entirety. ECF No. 593. Defendant’s Motion is currently set for hearing before Judge

2

Kimberly J. Mueller on November 21, 2014.

3

Based upon facts alleged in the Motion and accompanying Declarations and

4

Exhibits, the impartiality of the District and Magistrate Judges in the Eastern District

5

might reasonably be questioned. Therefore, on the Court’s own motion and pursuant to

6

the Code of Conduct for United States Judge, Canons 2 and 3, in order to avoid the

7

appearance of impropriety, and because a judge has a duty to disqualify him or herself if

8

his or her impartiality could be reasonably questioned, whether or not such impartiality

9

actually exists, the Court recuses itself from the above-captioned case. See 28 U.S.C. §

10

455(a). Accordingly, all District and Magistrate Judges in the Eastern District of

11

California are RECUSED from hearing case number 2:09-cv-02445 and all related

12

matters. This matter is REFERRED to Alex Kozinski, Chief Judge of the United States

13

Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, for the assignment of a judge other than from the Eastern

14

District of California to sit by designation and hear case number 2:09-cv-02445 and all

15

related matters.

16 17

IT IS SO ORDERED. Dated: October 14, 2014

18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 3

About

Location

Contact

Website Suggestion?

Search

Home

Judges

Attorney Info

United States Magistrate Judge Gary S. Austin (GSA)

CM/ECF E-Filing

Rules

Forms

Jury Info

Clerk's Office

Careers

SENIOR UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE WILLIAM B. SHUBB (WBS)

United States Magistrate Judge Stanley A. Boone (SAB)

Federal Judicial Service: U. S. District Court, Eastern District of California

United States Magistrate Judge Edmund F. Brennan (EFB)

Nominated by George Bush on August 3, 1990, to a seat vacated by Raul A. Ramirez; Confirmed by the Senate on September 28, 1990, and received commission on October 1, 1990. Served as chief judge, 1996-2003.

Assumed senior status on November 1, 2004.

Senior United States District Judge Garland E. Burrell, Jr. (GEB) United States Magistrate Judge Allison Claire (AC)

Education:

United States Magistrate Judge Carolyn K. Delaney (CKD)

University of California, Berkeley, A.B., 1960 University of California, Berkeley, Boalt Hall School of Law, J.D., 1963

Chief United States Magistrate Judge Dale A. Drozd (DAD)

Professional Career:

Chief United States District Judge Morrison C. England, Jr. (MCE)

1963-1965

United States Magistrate Judge Gregory G. Hollows (GGH)

Law clerk, Hon. Sherrill Halbert, U.S. District Court, Eastern District of California

Senior United States District Judge Anthony W. Ishii (AWI)

1965-1971

United States Magistrate Judge Craig M. Kellison (CMK)

1971-1974

United States Magistrate Judge Barbara A. McAuliffe (BAM)

1974-1980

Assistant U.S. attorney, Eastern District of California

Chief assistant U.S. attorney, Eastern District of California

Private practice, Sacramento, California United States District Judge John A. Mendez (JAM)

1980-1981 U.S. Attorney for the Eastern District of California

United States District Judge Kimberly J. Mueller (KJM)

1981-1990 Private practice, Sacramento, California

United States Magistrate Judge Kendall J. Newman (KJN)

United States Magistrate Judge Sheila K. Oberto (SKO) United States District Judge Lawrence J. O'Neill (LJO) United States Magistrate Judge Michael J. Seng (MJS) Senior United States District Judge William B. Shubb (WBS) Senior United States District Judge William B. Shubb (WBS) United States Recalled Magistrate Judge Sandra M. Snyder (SMS)

Education

Home » Judges » All Judges » Senior United States District Judge William B. Shubb (WBS) » Senior United States District Judge William B. Shubb (WBS)

United States Magistrate Judge Dennis L. Beck (DLB)

United States District Judge Troy L. Nunley (TLN)

Go