The Justice, March 19, 2013 issue

Page 1

ARTS Page 20

SPORTS Figueroa ’98 excels at WBC 13 FORUM Treasurer defends club proposal 11 The Independent Student Newspaper

the

SEUSS SHOW of

B r a n d e is U n i v e r sit y S i n c e 1 9 4 9

Justice

Volume LXV, Number 22

www.thejustice.org

Tuesday, March 19, 2013

GIDEON AT 50

RESIDENCE LIFE

Students attempt to anticipate housing

■ This year’s housing

results left students with an unexpected amount of oncampus openings. By MARISSA DITKOWSKY JUSTICE EDITORIAL ASSISTANT

Housing selection ended last Tuesday, eliciting mixed reactions from both students who participated in and those who pulled out of the housing lottery due to the uncertainty of the process.

Waltham, Mass.

Spaces in popular housing venues remained at unuaually high lottery numbers this year, possibly due to expectations that did not line up with housing results from previous years. “We were definitely not expecting a Rosie because usually they go out,… and we had 157,” wrote Carly Chernomorets ’16, who was pulled into a suite in Rosenthal Quad last minute despite her initial plan to live in East Quad, in an email to the Justice. According to the statistics on the Department of Community Living’s

See HOUSING, 7 ☛

JOSH HOROWITZ/the Justice

REVISITING HISTORY: Lewis and Leahy (left to right) discuss the right to counsel and its transformation since the Gideon case.

Panelists discuss Gideon ■ University President

ADAM STERN/the Justice

STRESSFUL PROCESS: Students selected housing for the fall semester last Sunday, March 10, through Tuesday, March 12, in Sherman Function Hall.

Frederick Lawrence spoke on the event panel, reflecting on Gideon after 50 years. By ALLYSON CARTTER JUSTICE SENIOR WRITER

STUDENT LIFE

Police investigating alleged verbal abuse ■ Several students have

complained about verbal abuse by University Police. By SAM MINTZ JUSTICE EDITOR

University Police are conducting an internal investigation into an alleged case of verbal abuse by a University police officer toward a student. The student, who asked to be identified by only his first name, Brian, claims that the officer swore at him

and asked if he was “challenged” during a confrontation over a parking ticket. Brian had been parked in front of a fire hydrant for several hours, and when asked, told the officer that he had not realized he was parked in a prohibited area. The officer then allegedly asked, “Are you [expletive] stupid? Are you challenged?” A report of the incident provided by the Office of Public Safety mentioned different details of the account. According to the report, the officer initially had made several

See BRANPO, 7 ☛

Four panelists convened yesterday in Rapaporte Treasure Hall for an event titled “Gideon at 50: The Future of the Right to Counsel” to mark the 50th anniversary of the Gideon v. Wainwright Supreme Court case and the continuing challenges of providing legal counsel to the poor and underserved communities. The 1963 case granted those accused of criminal, rather than only capital, charges the right to be appointed an attorney should they not be able to afford one, citing the Sixth Amendment’s guarantee of counsel. The panel featured Margot Botsford, Associate Justice to the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts, University President Frederick Lawrence, William Leahy, director of the New York State Office of Indigent Legal Services, and Anthony Lewis, author of Gideon’s Trumpet, the 1964 account of the case. Chief of Staff to the President David Bunis ’83 moderated the

event. 1n 1963, after being charged with breaking and entering with the intent to commit petty larceny, Clarence Earl Gideon requested a lawyer when asked at his trial if he was ready to proceed. After the judge denied his request, Gideon was sentenced to five years in prison; he appealed to the Supreme Court, which ruled that the denial of counsel was a violation of the Constitution. The Gideon v. Wainwright case overturned the ruling in the 1942 Betts v. Brady case, which denied counsel to indigent defendants when prosecuted by a state. Bunis directed the first question to Lewis, asking what prompted his passion for the Gideon case. Lewis responded with a passage from his book that marked the overturning of the Betts v. Brady decision. “It had a powerful emotional impact on me,” he said. Lewis said that he wrote the book “with such obvious emotion and commitment” in part because of the details of the case. Gideon’s petition to the court was handwritten, he said. “He didn’t have a hope, did he?” Lewis continued. “It was quite amazing, and that was part of the romance, for me.” Lewis added that the court even agreeing to take Gideon’s case indicated to him that they would likely

See GIDEON, 7 ☛

Wait no more

Enduring hardships

Tuition worries

Students made an app that predicts the wait time at venues in any area.

 The baseball team suffered through a rough week on its annual spring trip.

 The proposed four percent tuition increase for next year has raised concern.

FEATURES 8 For tips or info email editor@thejustice.org

overrule the Betts v. Brady ruling. Leahy said that two major realities must be recognized for the Gideon decision to be fully implemented in practice: first, that the federal government, and not only states, must fund the efforts to provide legal aid, and second, that it must bridge the gap between the funding they provide to prosecution and police forces and the lack of funding for public defenders. Botsford added that states that deal with enforcing the Gideon case on a local basis are worse off than those that deal with it on a statewide basis, such as Massachusetts. “We are incredibly lucky in this state,” she said, adding that Massachusetts representation is “excellent,” which is not the case everywhere. Lawrence emphasized the importance of due process, noting that defendants must have their inalienable rights enforced and that the government has the responsibility to make those rights enforceable. As Bunis opened the floor to audience questions, Leigh Swigart, director of programs in international justice and society at the International Center for Ethics, Justice and Public Life, posed a question about legal models of other countries that the U.S. could look to. Leahy responded that societies that

Let your voice be heard! Submit letters to the editor online at www.thejustice.org

INDEX

SPORTS 16 ARTS SPORTS

17 16

EDITORIAL FEATURES

10 8

OPINION POLICE LOG

10 2

News 3 COPYRIGHT 2013 FREE AT BRANDEIS. Email managing@thejustice.org for home delivery.


Turn static files into dynamic content formats.

Create a flipbook
Issuu converts static files into: digital portfolios, online yearbooks, online catalogs, digital photo albums and more. Sign up and create your flipbook.
The Justice, March 19, 2013 issue by The Justice - Issuu