Voyager
KENT PLACE SCHOOL
Voyager WINTER 2009
Discovering Science at Kent Place School By Gayle Allen, Director of Studies and Assistant Head
“A different language is a different vision of life.” — Vera Rubin, astronomer and 1993 National Science Medal winner
Asking Questions and Gathering Data “Not everything that counts can be counted and not everything that can be counted counts." — Sign hanging in Albert Einstein's office at Princeton University
Speaking of counting and what counts…what do the numbers tell us about the state of young women in science today? Have we made inroads nationally to effect change with regard to women’s participation in science within and beyond K-12 schools? As educators, where can we celebrate success? Where should we focus future efforts? For now, what assumptions do we hold about women and science, and how well do they match the statistics? How about a little quiz? Please read the following questions (based on the latest National Science Foundation statistics on women and science). Circle the letter of the answer you think is correct. Answers are listed at the end of this article.
1. Women earned approximately ___ percent of science and engineering bachelor degrees awarded in 2005 in the U.S., up from 25 percent in1966. a. 32 b. 38 c. 42 d. 50
2. In 2005, women made up 76 percent of graduate students in ___, 56 percent in the ___ sciences and 54 percent in ___. a. psychology, biological, social sciences b. biology, physical, computer science
c. psychology, physical, social sciences
d. social sciences, biological, physical sciences
3. Women made the most gains between 1995 and 2005 in ___ sciences. a. computer, physical and biological
b. psychological, biological and social
c. atmospheric, biological and social
d. earth, atmospheric and ocean
4. Women made the least gains between 1995 and 2005 in the ___ sciences. a. psychological b. biological
c. computer
d. physical
5. Women accounted for ___ percent of graduate students in engineering and ___ percent of graduate students in computer sciences in 2005. a. 22, 25
b. 10, 20 c. 30, 50 d. 50, 80
How did you do? What did you learn? Were there assumptions you held that did not hold up to current statistics? Any surprises? Are things looking up for women in science today? Well, as you can probably predict, the answer is complicated. On the one hand, you could answer that, yes, things have improved. On the other hand, you could say that the situation has worsened. Not much of an answer, huh?
Analyzing Data and Asking More Questions
When it comes to the big-picture news of women in science, the good news is that women are earning more bachelor’s degrees in science and engineering than ever before.These results speak to the increased opportunities for women to pursue science degrees, as well as the greater number of science degrees available today.These increases also point to shifts in cultural perspectives.There are fewer stigmas attached to women earning degrees in science and engineering. Over time, the number of cultural barriers has decreased.
As we analyze the data in greater detail, however, we cannot help but notice certain trends that are less positive.We see that women are gravitating more readily toward some fields than others. For example, according to the most recent National Science Foundation statistics, women hold the majority, by far, of bachelor’s degrees in the fields of health (86 percent) and psychology (77 percent).
Sixth grader Marshea Robinson learns to adjust her microscope.
Ninth grader Kelsh Keim takes notes during a biology class.
First grader Eileen Cohn works on a lab sheet that is part of a genetics unit.
This trend repeats itself at the graduate level, where women are earning 79 percent of master’s degrees in health and 78 percent in psychology. In contrast, men continue to dominate the fields of engineering, computer and related sciences, and physical and related sciences. Men are earning 78 percent of engineering and 77 percent of computer and information sciences bachelor’s degrees. At the graduate level, they are attaining 77 percent of engineering, 66 percent of computer and related sciences, and 66 percent of physical and related sciences master’s degrees.
Page 1