Reporter of the Year – Stephen Shaw Award 15 ENTRIES
1
Markham Economist & Sun | Kim Zarzour
Kim Zarzour’s work is impressive. All three of the stories submitted required a huge amount of research and relationship building. The subjects of two of the entries were very important aspects of what seems like the never ending subject of COVID-19. The one featuring families of residents of Woodbridge Vista long-term care home was both detailed and heartbreaking. The third story in the package really stood out and, in my experience, is unique. It is the story of a sexual assault victim pushing for restorative justice, against the advice and ingrained approach of the criminal court system. That story was powerful and hopeful. It offered a light in the midst of a very dark subject, and in the midst of a very challenging year for all of us.
2
Vaughan Citizen | Jeremy Grimaldi
3
Richmond Hill/Thornhill Liberal | Sheila Wang
The three entries which formed Jeremy Grimaldi’s submission were all very important hard news stories. The entry dealing with workplace violence at Southlake Regional Health Centre had to be a very difficult one to pin down, given the fears of employees for their jobs. The tow truck turf wars entry revealed a very seamy side to an industry most of us take for granted, and the story of Aaron Bank-Sedore’s suicide and its effect on his family was very powerful.
The work of Sheila Wang in detailing the effects of COVID-19 in the York Region, including the many graphs she created, is truly impressive. Residents of this hard hit region have excellent local information as a result of her research, and this goes to the heart of what community journalism is all about. Her extensive research on the bankruptcy of a Richmond Hill councillor is also an impressive piece of work.
HONOURABLE MENTION
Caledon Enterprise | Karen Martin-Robbins – Karen Martin-Robbins is obviously a very versatile reporter. Her research on these stories, and the amount of emotion shown about the victim of human trafficking and the teen fighting brain cancer must have drawn in thousands of readers. The third story on a longstanding environmental issue was well explained and very balanced.
Judge Frank Bucholtz
Oshawa This Week | Tim Kelly – Tim Kelly’s work stood out. There were many stories relating to the horrific murder-suicide in Oshawa that left five people dead, but his story about the events on the ball field the night before was exceptional. The detailed and painstaking look at Taunton Road and its future was put together very well and would be of interest to almost all readers.
Columnist Black Press Media and Retired Editor Langley Times, BC
Wasaga/Stayner Sun | Ian Adams – Ian Adams’ three stories showed his versatility and research abilities. He also captured a lot of human emotion in two stories related to near deaths. Well done.
Frank Bucholtz is a retired community newspaper editor, and a freelance writer and blogger with more than 40 years of media experience. He worked for community newspapers in Surrey, Langley, White Rock and other parts of the B.C. Lower Mainland and Fraser Valley. He served as editor for both the Langley Times and the Surrey Leader. He has judged various categories in the OCNA awards over the past eight years. He also serves as a judge with the Jack Webster Foundation, which presents annual awards to B.C. journalists in all media. He is a past winner in both the CCNA and BCYCNA journalism awards.
GENERAL COMMENT
Wow. We may be a year or more into COVID-19 and several years into very challenging times for the community newspaper industry, but superb journalism remains intact. All 12 of the entrants in this category submitted very solid work. These ranged over a huge variety of subjects - showing that despite the financial challenges in the industry - people in newsrooms are focused on doing their best for their communities. The top six all could have finished first. It was a very tough decision. However, it had to be made. All the winners showed by their work that they are solid and intrepid reporters, performing a community service to thousands of readers.
Sponsored by: Ontario Power Generation ONTARIO COMMUNITY NEWSPAPERS ASSOCIATION
2020 | BNC Awards Results
37
