Our e-mail addresses are: Advertising: ads@sdranchcoastnews.com | Editorial: editor@sdranchcoastnews.com | Web: www.SDRanchCoastNews.com
Celebrating Our 19th Year!
National AwardWinning Newspaper
VOLUME 27 NUMBER 34
Aug. 25, 2011
High graduation rates reported for San Dieguito BY MARSHA SUTTON Senior Education Writer Using a new tracking and reporting system, the California Department of Education released graduation and dropout rates this month for the class of 2009-2010 that show that the San Dieguito Union High School District had a graduation rate of 94.4 percent, compared to a statewide rate of 74.4 percent. The dropout rate was 3.1 percent for the district and 18.2 percent for the state. The difference between the graduation and dropout rates – 2.5 percent for San Dieguito and 7.4 percent for the state – represents students removed from the cohort for a number of reasons. They may have transferred to a private school, enrolled in a school out of the district, transferred to an institution or health facility, are being homeschooled, moved out of the state or country, or died. Students remained in the cohort if they dropped out during that four-year period, completed 12th grade and exited the system without graduating, or took longer than four years to graduate. The cohort is the group of ninth- through 12th-grade students that could potentially graduate during a four-year period, in this case 2006 to 2010. This cohort includes students who entered grades 9, 10, 11 or 12 in 2006, 2007, 2008 and 2009, respectively.
The general formula used to derive the data, according to the CDE, is the number of cohort members who earned a high school diploma by the end of the 2009-2010 school year, divided by: the number of first-time ninth-graders in the fall of 2006, plus students who transferred in, minus students who were removed from the cohort after transferring to different schools, moving away or dying. Different calculation factors employed this year means that the data cannot be compared to previous years, but this year’s numbers will serve as a baseline for future data, the CDE said. For the first time, students were tracked by school districts upon entering ninth grade in 2006, so the numbers just released are considered more accurate than systems used in the past, said Rick Schmitt, SDUHSD’s associate superintendent of educational services. Before this, he said, the district used a derived rate extrapolated from a one-year estimate based on a single year of data. This new model, with the four-year cohort rate, is a more legitimate reflection of actual graduation and dropout rates, he said. Self-reported Schmitt said school districts submitted numbers to the state this year through a self-reporting system. “What the state has is what we See RATES, Page 19
DM school district sued to release documents
‘Pawing it forward’
Ricochet, the “SURFice” dog, reunites with 16-year-old quadriplegic Patrick Ivison at Dog Beach in Del Mar on Aug. 20. Patrick and Ricochet first surfed tandem together at a fundraiser two years ago. The Helen Woodward Animal Center also held a surf dog clinic for its upcoming event, the Helen Woodward Animal Center’s Surf Dog Surf-a-thon in Del Mar on Sept. 11. Ricochet will participate in the event. See page B2. PHOTOS: JON CLARK
Data suspicious on list of best high schools BY MARSHA SUTTON Senior Education Writer Self-reported data may be responsible for the disparity in rankings between Torrey Pines High School and Canyon Crest Academy on Newsweek’s latest annual list of Best High Schools, San Dieguito Union High School District officials say. The list continues to draw criticism, even though the publication says it revamped its methodology and no longer considers only the number of Advanced Placement exams and the number of graduating seniors at each school. Now there are six components: graduation rate (worth 25 percent), college matriculation rate (25 percent), AP tests taken per graduate (25 percent), average SAT/ACT scores (10 percent), average AP/IB/AICE scores (10 percent), and AP courses offered (5 percent).
JOHN R. LEFFERDINK
619-813-8222
This formula calculated that Torrey Pines was rated #90 on the June 2011 list, and Canyon Crest #306. The list reported other information for each school, including: •student-teacher ratio (26:1 for TPHS; 38:1 for CCA) •percent college-bound (92 percent for TPHS; 70 percent for CCA) •graduation rate (95 percent for TPHS; 100 percent for CCA) •AP tests per senior (4.1 for TPHS; 3.2 for CCA) •average SAT score (1834 for TPHS; 1800 for CCA) SDUHSD administrators say the list, despite the new methodology, is skewed to favor small schools, charter schools and magnet schools – and not larger, comprehensive high schools. They discount the rankings, saying they do not tell the full story and are often based on suspect data. See DATA, Page 6
BY MARSHA SUTTON SENIOR EDUCATION WRITER Del Mar parent and resident Michael Robertson filed a lawsuit against the Del Mar Union School District Aug. 8, charging the district with withholding public documents Robertson requested May 10 under the California Public Records Act. Also named in the suit is DMUSD school board president Comischell Rodriguez, for allegedly not disclosing personal emails related to the CPRA request that were sent to and from Rodriguez’s private email accounts. “Because Respondent Rodriguez possesses, maintains and controls records responsive to Petitioner’s requests that are not maintained in files located in Respondent District’s offices, Respondent Rodriguez is an indispensible part to this litigation and must be included as a respondent in order for Petitioner to obtain complete relief,” reads the suit. Robertson submitted a CPRA request on May 10 for access to files, documents and records relating to contact from March 1, 2011 between employees and representatives of the DMUSD and the California Teachers Association, a statewide teachers union of which the Del Mar California Teachers Association is a member. This request was later expanded to include communication among and between Rodriguez, DMUSD superintendent Jim Peabody, the DMCTA and its representatives, the CTA, and the California School Boards Association (CSBA). See LAWSUIT, Page 6
Let us be the light at the end of your Tunnel! www.johnlefferdink.com
ANGELA MEAKINS-BERGMAN
LISA KELLEY
CONNIE SUNDSTROM
858-405-9270
858-880-5242
858-334-8114