061109-lec-csr-marketing-a
Corporate Social Responsibility
CSR: a new challenge for a different marketing approach?
09.11.06
Manuel Demetz
1
Š Free University Bozen-Bolzano
Content 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9.
2
What is happening around us The economic principle and ethics The market and the problem of externalities The economic principle in management What characterizes CSR Effective CSR management CSR in the marketing framework CSR and competitiveness The ‚Chiquita Case‘
© Free University Bozen-Bolzano
What is happening around us Retraction of the government (lack of of political power) • Social responsible behaviour (CSR) is transferred to individuals and corporations. Pluralism and functional differentiation in society • For many of the problems in modern society a mutual agreement cannot be found; ongoing deployment of different societal systems that are not interrelated by an unifying concept of ethical/moral values. Evolvement of communication technologies (telematics) • Speeding-up of the information economy creates global competition/awareness. Not only at the business level, but also at an extended cultural level. 3
© Free University Bozen-Bolzano
The economic principle and ethics Maximising self interest defines economic behaviour • Historically, Adams Smith argued: if individuals behave as maximising their ‘self interest’ (> utility) the overall society will benefit. Free market economy and the ‘invisible hand’ • The efficiency of free markets (where utility maximising individuals behave rational) will lead to prosperity for the overall society.
4
The critique from ethics • Utility as the solely (rational) principle for decision-making and behaviour fulfils not social relevant criteria. Respectively, morality is not fulfilled at the required level.
© Free University Bozen-Bolzano
The market and the problem of externalities • Externalities are effects of transactions that are not reflected in the market price. • Externalities may be positive or negative in their consequence. • Externalities affect stakeholders that are not involved in the decision-making process/transaction. • The orthodox economic solution (Coase-Theorem): if externalities do exist, market participants will find a mutual agreement – in absence of transaction cost. The emerging problem of externalities is a main cause for the claim of corporate social responsible behaviour of corporations.
5
© Free University Bozen-Bolzano
The economic principle in management The shareholder-value approach • The management is legitimated by the shareholders to pursue their interests. • Wealth distribution (under circumstances of uncertainty) to the shareholder is the primary goal of a corporation. • Profit-maximization becomes the management-maxim. • Externalities > the theory itself makes it difficult to be concerned about externalities. The stakeholder-value approach (a real alternative?) • The management has to pursue the interest of different stakeholders (customers, employees, nation, nature etc.). • No clear maxim for the management > difficulties in defining the stakeholders and respectively the rules for the management. • Externalities > the theory itself is very ambiguous
6
© Free University Bozen-Bolzano
CSR: And what makes the difference?
7
Š Free University Bozen-Bolzano
What characterizes CSR Establishment of normative principles (business ethics) • The problem of externalities is one of the central issues of CSR; CSR consequently is concerned with normative aspects of management decisions (ethical analysis). Holistic concept of CSR (positive management theory) • To achieve sustainable competitive advantages for the overall organisation. Thus, CSR should not focus on single functional aspects in marketing, finance, etc., but primarily on strategic issues.
8
© Free University Bozen-Bolzano
Effective CSR management The normative aspect • In contrast to economic theory it is not the purpose of CSR to find a proper negotiation about (negative) externalities but to avoid negotiations. The communicational aspect • Moral communication evokes morality and thus creates moral awareness and moral behaviour. The resources based-view aspect • Stakeholders are important input factors for developing organizational-specific resources (that might by intangible) and the management should care about them.
9
© Free University Bozen-Bolzano
CSR in the marketing framework CSR as a source of innovation • Aspects of morality as source for innovation CSR as a framework for market research • Analysis of the socio-economic environment (strong focus on communication aspects = what characterizes the ‘semiotic space’ of the organization). CSR as a communication approach • Provide for dialogue-oriented communication. CSR in the brand management context • Identity oriented brand management (identity in this context should provide for valuable meaning that links the brand to social-relevant issues).
10
© Free University Bozen-Bolzano
CSR and competitiveness The main drivers • • • •
Managing risks to earn/maintain a license to operate Enhance corporate reputation and brand image Improve relations with stakeholders/communities Improve access to markets and customers • Network economy • Increase employee morale and thus productivity
11
© Free University Bozen-Bolzano
Thank you for your attention.
Manuel Demetz
12
Š Free University Bozen-Bolzano