CONTENT
PAGE NO.
ABSTRACT
2
1.0 INTRODUCTION
3
1.1 AIM AND OBJECTIVE 1.2 INTRODUCTION OF SITE
2.0 PRECEDENT STUDY
12
2.1 LIGHTING PRECEDENT STUDY 2.2 ACOUSTICS PRECEDENT STUDY
3.0 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
24
3.1 SEQUENCE OF WORK 3.2 LIGHTING DATA COLLECTION EQUIPMENT 3.3 LIGHTING DATA COLLECTION METHOD 3.4 ACOUSTIC DATA COLLECTION EQUIPMENT 3.5 ACOUSTIC DATA COLLECTION METHOD
4.0 CASE STUDY AT L45, BANGSAR
31
4.1 LIGHTING 4.1.1 Site Study and Zoning 4.1.2 Tabulation & Observation of Data 4.1.3 Sunpath Analysis 4.1.4 Lighting Fixtures and Specifications 4.1.5 Daylight and Artificial Light Contour Analysis 4.1.6 Daylight and Artificial Light Calculation and Analysis Zone 1: Dining and Kitchen Area Zone 2: Lounge Zone 3: Washroom Zone 4: Library Ground Floor Zone 5: Library First Floor Zone 6: Library Second Floor 4.2 ACOUSTICS 4.2.1 Zoning 4.2.2 Tabulation & Observation of Data 4.2.3 Outdoor and Indoor Noise Sources 4.2.4 Acoustic Fixtures and Specifications 4.2.5 Sound Pressure Level (SPL) Analysis 4.2.6 Reverberation Time Analysis 4.2.7 Sound Reduction Index Analysis
31
5.0 CONCLUSION
128
6.0 SUMMARY OF REPORT(A3)
130
7.0 REFERENCES
133
69
1
ABSTRACT
The intention of the study is to evaluate the lighting and acoustic performance and design, with L45, Bangsar, in house library-residential building, being our case study due to its context and interestingly unconventional design. This project is intended to be completed in a group of 6 students and it is anticipated that the appropriateness of lighting and acoustic installation in this community library’s design will be discovered. Throughout the research, extensive literature reviews from various sources, interview and surveys were conducted to determine the effectiveness of the lighting and acoustics in this community library to provide user’s overall comfort. Precedent studies on lighting and acoustics were done on Cleo Rogers Memorial Library and Brown Rudnick’s Mayfair Office to investigate its lighting and acoustic properties so to help us proceed with our case study. The data that was collected from L45 will be transferred into empirical formulas in order to perform the evaluation and analysis. Included in this report are technical data such as formulas, equations and calculations that estimate both luminance levels as well as noise levels respectively for both light and acoustics. The effectiveness of the lighting and acoustic designs can be deduced by the number of lighting available and the illuminance levels as well as reverberation time, sound reduction index and sound pressure level respectively. All orthographic drawings and diagrams were made with data that was collected on site. The analysis diagrams were generated using Autodesk Ecotect – an analysis software. A list of figures, tables, as well as references are provided at the end of the report to ease with navigation. The learning outcome of this study is to learn about proper lighting and acoustical strategies to be implemented in our design processes based on the standards and requirements for lighting and acoustics. An impressive architecture should have lighting and acoustical qualities that speak of the quality of the building itself.
2
1.0 INTRODUCTION 1.1 AIM AND OBJECTIVE
The aim and objectives of this project is as follows: To understand the daylighting, lighting and acoustical characteristics. To understand the lighting and acoustic requirements of an intended place. To determine the characteristics and function of daylighting, artificial lighting, sound and acoustic within the intended space. To critically report and analyse the space and suggest solutions to improvise the lighting and acoustic qualities within the space.
This project likewise expects to provide a better comprehension on the relationship between the type of materials that are utilised in terms of building materials as well as internal furnishings and finishes as well as their impacts on acoustical and lighting conditions in the building based on the functionality of the building. Understanding the volume and area of each functional space also helps in deciding the lighting requirements based on acoustical or lighting inadequacy which is reflected in the data collection. Acknowledging adjacent spaces is also essential to address acoustic concerns. In terms of lighting, the specifications of luminaries, height of each type of light and existence of fenestrations will assist in understanding the lighting conditions within each space. Backed up with precedent studies, drawing comparison with the site study, our precedent studies will aid in determining the different types of lighting and acoustics throughout this project.
3
1.2 INTRODUCTION OF SITE
Figure : Faรงade of the L45 Kurau Community Library, Bangsar
The monolithic structure of the building sits quietly in the corner of Lorong Kurau, and is rather unlikely to go unnoticed. Most people know it as the L45 Kurau Community Library. The name is conceptualized as, L stands for library/lot/lorong while 45 is the unit number itself. The function of L45 is unconventional, to say the least. The Client who wishes to remain anonymous entrusted Tetawowe Atelier with a rough brief to convert this double-storey corner terrace house into a civic space for the local community with communal living space which are actually two programs on polar opposites, one very public whilst the other very private. The architects faces the challenge of integrating community living within the public realm. This is especially challenging as L45 consists of eight loft rooms with ensuite bathrooms, common kitchen, dining area and laundry area in addition to the library. Although there is an insertion of a library in the centre of the building, the house is specifically designed to function on its own, without overlapping between the public and private realms. The library is constructed mainly of heavy concrete and white blocks which projects a sense of solidity and privacy while the steel brings an overall sense of lightness to the building that portrays the lightness of knowledge. The modernistic look with its clean
4
lines on the exterior attracts visitors to enter the domain. The various types of materials in different zones in the building provides one with a sense of tranquillity and intimacy upon entering the domains. Some of the materials used are as such: Library Ceiling Wall Flooring Opening door Furniture Column Beam Stairs
Timber & metal mesh Concrete & metal Concrete & metal mesh Timber Timber Metal Metal Metal
Lounge Ceiling Wall Flooring Opening - window Furniture
Timber Concrete Concrete Glass Timber
Kitchen + Dining Room Ceiling Wall Flooring Opening - Door Furniture
Concrete Concrete Concrete Glass Timber
Study area Ceiling Wall Flooring Column Beam Stairs
Metal mesh Metal + concrete Metal mesh Metal Metal Metal
5
Figure 4: Dining area of the L45 library
Figure 5: Brightly lit area in the library
Figure(s) 1,2,3 : Lounge at the L45 Library
6
Our reason for choosing this building is due of its egalitarian intention, the most intriguing part of it being a very expensive experiment in the creation of social democracy. Since the nature of a library is of a sensitive design, lighting design is a primary element in the library. Books can only be appreciated fully when the spaces are brightly lit. A successful library is one that has considerable uniformity in comfort levels and efficiency in use of lighting levels. On the other hand, acoustic design is also an important element as libraries require quality acoustics as they are an area of silence for the public to read, learn, work and research in. But since L45 is a fusion of a library and a residential home, it would be interesting to see how the lighting and acoustic properties are designed to make sure that both the visitors of the library and its existing residents are not disturbed. The results will also determine whether the L45 Kurau Community Library is effective in terms of lighting and acoustic performance.
Note: The orthographic plans in the next page were given by the library management
7
Figure 6: Ground Floor Plan
Figure 7: 1st Floor Plan
8
Figure 8: 1st Mezzanine Level Plan
Figure 9: Section A
9
Figure 10: Section B
Figure 11: Section C
10
Figure 12: Sectional Perspective
Figure 13: Axonometric Drawing
11
2.0 PRECEDENT STUDY 2.1 LIGHTING PRECEDENT STUDY
Introduction to Lightning Design in Library Proper ambiance of a library is generated from good lighting design. Good lighting is very important in a library for users to view reading materials under the best possible lighting conditions. As reading is the main and most important programme in a library, lighting plays a major part is the design process. Imaginative lighting helps users to redefine the relationship of between the environment and themselves. It is divided into natural light and artificial light. The dynamic daylight and the controlled artificial lighting are able to affect not only the productivity of the library users, but also to instigate and provoke different visual experiences and moods. Not all sections of a library utilises the same lighting performances. Considerations must be taken to spaces that preserves old documents as harsh lighting may damage them, and a comfortably lit area must be provide to reading zones to encourage better productivity.
The following are considerations and factors affecting lighting design: a. Purpose of space b. Area of space c. Visual comfort d. Time of usage in spaces e. Minimum illumination levels f. Light distribution for adequate performance g. Choice of illumination h. Amount of permissible/desirable distraction i.
Contrast of lighting equipment and background
12
Cleo Rogers Memorial Library
Figure 14: Cleo Rogers Memorial Library
Precedent Study
Cleo Rogers Memorial Library
Project Completion
1969
Function
Library
Location
Columbus, Indiana, US
Architect
I.M. Pei
The Cleo Rogers Memorial Library was designed by architect I. M. Pei. The concept was to harmonise with its neighbours and create a unified civic space rather than just be an isolated architectural jewel in mind. The whole idea is that of a library as an open, integrated, easy and accessible space for all.
13
Figure 15: Work Space
Figure 16: Children’s Section
Lower Section The lower section of the library is located at the east side of the building, and is shaded by the adjacent trees. The children’s library, classrooms, meeting rooms and offices are located at the lower Section of the library. It has full panel windows and doors to bring in natural lighting. The illumination of the area is also aided with down lights hidden in the concrete coffered ceiling. The tone of the bare brick adds a warm glow to the area. Since the area is highly lit by natural lighting, a softer down light is used to give a comfortable ambiance.
14
Figure 17: Main library shelvings
The Main Hall The main library is situated at the main hall which has a mezzanine level. It takes up the 3 storey space of the building. A skylight is situated at the upper mezzanine level to provide intake of natural sunlight, while the bottom mezzanine level uses 2 storey full panel glass window to bring in natural lighting. Both mezzanine levels utilises down light concealed in coffered ceiling to aid in illuminating and bring ambiance to the space. The bare red brick of the building give the library accent and a sense of warmth. As this area is the main shelving and reading area, light intensity are softer to have a soothing visual context. A lounge is provide for some light reading or conversation to take place. It is located near the full panel 2 storey windows as to fully utilise the natural lighting.
Glass Gallery The glass gallery is an extension of the main library and where computer work space are located. It is located at the centre of the building, connecting the main hall and children’s section. The glass gallery is high illuminated by natural lighting as it has full panel glass windows and roofs. This is where the workspace are located as lighting is highly appropriate for it. Downlight's are provided during night time.
15
Figure 18: Indiana room
Extension This is an extension from the library. The Indiana Room showcases local and Indiana history resources. The lighting here is illuminated by fluorescent lights and minor natural lighting from glass windows and doors. This is due to the historical documents and books stored here.
Lighting Analysis Lux Measurement
Section
Type
Difficulty of task
Recommended level
ground 1
Lower section
Moderate Difficult
400
ground 2
Main Hall
Simple
150
ground 3
Glass gallery
Moderate
250
ground 4
Extension
Moderate Difficult
400
Table 1: Lux Measurement and Recommendation
16
lux
Section
Type
Lux measurement Recommended
Lux difference
Lux level Ground 1
Lower Section
325
400
-75
Ground 2
Main Hall
410
150
260
Ground 3
Glass Gallery
3000
250
2750
Ground 4
Extension
330
400
-70
Table 2: Windowed section
Section
Type
Lux measurement Recommended
Lux difference
Lux level Ground 1
Lower Section
110
400
-290
Ground 2
Main Hall
180
150
30
Ground 4
Extension
250
400
-150
Table 3: un-windowed section
Conclusion
The majority of lighting design in Cleo Rogers Memorial Library is from natural light source, as shown with tall full panel doors and windows, and various skylight placements. With the use of natural and artificial lighting, the library possesses different lighting controls used at different parts of the building, creating ambience and suitable functions to take place. Certain areas requires some lighting adjustments as to better suit the function taken place.
Users activities demand for different kinds of lighting designs to perform various tasks, and various lighting should be adjusted to better suit the difficulty of tasks. The lighting design also affect users during the transition from one space to another, providing a different atmosphere to differentiate sections. Thus, lighting design plays an important role in building in setting the mood, ambience and function.
17
2.2 ACOUSTICS PRECEDENT STUDY
Introduction to Acoustics Design in Library
Acoustic design and performance is so important nowadays in the design process so as to provide users with an adequate level of satisfaction and moral health. Indoor noise and outdoor noise are the two main aspects that contribute to acoustical comfort. The control of these two issues play an important part in any buildings as it can affect the occupants psychologically. Many companies are working to solve the problems better and better each day and as they proceed, they learnt to play with the materials and methods of construction to produce more efficient acoustics in a space. Wooden panels are the most famous solution for acoustics for the noise and sound controls, and there are many different types of the acoustic battens that can be used in the buildings. In this precedent study we are going through the design of a building in London which have renovated the space to control the noise level of the area. Initially, there was a high amount of noise and was causing a lot of distress to its occupants, but now the building is more sustainable and properly developed to handle the many different type of programmes and events while the occupants are working. Noise can have the following adverse health effects: a. Hearing loss b. Sleep disturbances c. Cardiovascular and psychophysiologic problems d. Performance reflection e. Annoyance in responses f. Adverse social behaviour As such, articulate measures have to be carried out so as to ensure that acoustical discomfort does not exist in spaces where human occupation is kept at prolonged hours
18
Brown Rudnick’s Mayfair Office
Figure 19: Interior of the renovated space
Precedent Study
Brown Rudnick’s Mayfair Office
Project Completion
2014
Function
Office
Location
Mayfair, London, United Kingdom
Acoustic Consultant ; Acoustic Panelling Mach Acoustics ; Dalhelm Ribba Panels By AH
Brady Mallalieu Architects had carried out the phased refurbishment of the offices of London law firm Brown Rudnick’s Mayfair office at the centerpiece, the central atrium space. The property was once the home of Thomas Walker, Surveyor General of Crown Lands, and housed his extensive collection of paintings including a number by the Dutch and Italian masters. The building had been extended to the rear with a modern office building and the glass roofed atrium connects the two parts at the center of the plan.
19
Brown Rudnick uses the space for seminars and larger group meetings as well as for hospitality events and social gatherings. All these programmes were unfortunately compromised by very poor acoustics in the room. The hard, reflective surfaces caused harsh reverberation problems.
Figure 20: the glass roof and the center space from the view of one of the offices
Figure 21: the elevation of the building which shows the important role of the space.
20
The noise issue was tackled by panelling the walls with an acoustic timber batten system, to minimize noise transference, where everything was worked out scientifically. The acoustic panels that were installed was not only aesthetically pleasing and efficient, the wooden panels created amazing atmosphere and space for the center which happens to be the most important part of the building which connects all the offices and rooms together. It also minimizes the sound and noise level that was very awful and disturbing before. Now, the space is more useful due to the scientifically backed renovations that was done to the area.
Figure 22: The wooden acoustic panels all along the walls from ground level until first floor.
21
Figure 23: The other views to see how the acoustic panels had been installed.
Figure 24: The Wooden acoustic batten that has been used for this project.
Figure 25: Section of the acoustic panels and how they work.
22
Conclusion
The result of the acoustical parameters measured before and after renovation of the office shows that the acoustic performance is marginally improved. The change in acoustic environment of the office was due to the use of suitable surface materials such as the wood panelling. The RT values were decreased to the optimum values by using the wooden acoustic battens. The differences determined between the two distinct conditions of the office in term of acoustic comfort obviously show the importance the interior surface material preferences in architecture. Within this context, the undeniable need for architects to consult acoustic engineers in order to determine the proper interior surface materials to be used for spaces designed by them (especially spaces for which auditory perception is significant), besides other design characteristics such as dimensions, shape, furnishing, should be emphasized. As a conclusion, acoustic analysis is very important to achieve a better design aesthetically and practically. The control of a noise and high level of sounds are ever more important in libraries, as these spaces are for work, especially for studies and researchers. The science of acoustics and is much more important than the design of the building itself depending on programmes, hence we as architectects have to be sensitive to these issues to encourage better productivity.
23
3.0 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 3.1 SEQUENCE OF WORK
Literature Reviews Studies on lighting and acoustics performance were done before the visit to our chosen site. This is to ensure that progress along with our data collection was to be done in a smooth manner as L45 is a combination of a residential home and library, nuisance was not be tolerated. The reason was also so that we have sufficient understanding on the factors influencing lighting and acoustics performance, as well as have some insight on the proper methods of acquiring data and analysing the data collected. It would also ensure that we are able to draw an appropriate conclusion on site. Preparation of Documents Prior to the site visit, documents such permission letters were prepared to ensure that legitimate access was obtained to carry out the research at the library. The plans, sections and elevations were given in pdf format from the library management. We made sure cad the files to be printed out in proper scales for use on site and to have a simply drafted copy of the floor plans with grids of 1.5m x 1.5m as to ease our data collection. Site Visit Several site visits were done to ensure sufficient information was acquired to produce a better outcome. Before visiting, research was done on the building via interviews and literature reviews in order to be assured that the site chosen was suitable for the project. Visits were organised during different time intervals such as during the library’s peak and non-peak hours and day and night time. This was done to collect data and analyse in a later stage how different times can affect lighting and acoustics performance in the library. All sound and light sources were recorded onto paper sheets, in proper positions. We were permitted to analyse and take recordings of only the library, dining and kitchen area, lounge, and washroom. Other than the stated areas, the rest of the building was restricted to us so as not to bother the residents.
24
Photographs and sketches were taken and done on site to show types of lights and materials used as well as the amount of human activities taking place within and around to building to account these evidences.
25
3.2 LIGHTING DATA COLLECTION EQUIPMENT
Equipment Lutron Digital Lux Meter LX-101
Description It is an electronic equipment that measures luminous flux per unit area and illuminance level. This device picks up accurate reading as it is sensitive to illuminance.
Measuring Tape
The measuring tape is used to measure a constant height and distance of the position of the lux meter, which is at 1m and 1.5. The height is taken on one person as reference to obtain an accurate reading.
Digital Single-lens Reflex Camera
The camera is used to record pictures on the lighting condition of the space and its surrounding as well as the lighting appliances. It is also used to document the progress of the group.
Table 4: Lighting Analysis Equipment and Descriptions
26
3.3 LIGHTING DATA COLLECTION METHOD
Figure 26: Position of height(s) to take readings
For lighting, data collection was conducted using the Lux Meter. Readings were taken at 1.5m intervals at a sitting position of 1m and 1.5m above ground. The readings were taken at every intersection of grid line in the plan. The procedure is repeated several times to ensure the accuracy of the readings. The readings were taken at peak and non peak hours as well as during the day and night times. The readings were then analysed and compared to the standard comparison tools such as CIBSE, ASHRAE, MS1525 and LEEDS. The materiality of each component of the spaces was also recorded.
27
3.4 ACOUSTIC DATA COLLECTION EQUIPMENT
Equipment Sound Level Meter
Description A sound level meter is used to measure acoustic (sound that travels through air) measurements. It is a hand-held instrument with a microphone. The diaphragm of the microphone responds to changes in air pressure caused by sound waves.
Measuring Tape
The tape is used to measure the height to position the sound level meter, which is at 1.5m above ground. We also used the measuring tape to measure the 1.5m x 1.5m grid intervals on the floor while taking the readings.
Digital Single-lens Reflex Camera
The camera is used to record the source of noises and sounds and to snap evidences of the group work.
Table 5: Acoustic Analysis Equipment and Descriptions
28
3.5 ACOUSTIC DATA COLLECTION METHOD
Figure 27: Position of height to take readings
To obtain higher accuracy in readings, the sound level meter was placed at the same height from the ground which is 1.5m at every grid point interval of 1.5m. This standard is being used as it enables the reading of sound level meter to be more accurate. The person holding the sound level meter will not talk and make any noise during the readings so that the readings will not be affected during data recording. Each recording was done facing the same direction, to synchronize the results. The same recording process is repeated at every point on the grid and was taken during peak and nonpeak hours. The steps for taking the readings are as below: 1. Identify the grid line of 1.5m x 1.5m within the site’s floor plan for data collecting position. 2. Obtain data with sound level meter (dB), by placing the device at the designated position with the height of 1.5m above ground. 3. Wait until the readings stabilise, and record the data reading on sound level meter.
29
4. Specify the variables (noise source) that might affect the readings. 5. Repeat the same steps for peak hour & non-peak hour. 6. Consider the different acoustic conditions and compare them at peak and nonpeak hours. 7. Tabulate and calculate the data collected and then determine the acoustic quality according to Chartered institution of Building Service Engineers (CIBSE) standard.
30
4.0 CASE STUDY AT L45, BANGSAR 4.1 LIGHTING
4.1.1 Site Study and Zoning As certain parts of the L45 building are restricted to the public(they are residential living quarters), we were allowed to carry out our analysis and research at certain areas only such as the dining area, lounge, library and washroom. The accessible areas are highlighted in the sectional drawing below. Both lighting and acoustical analysis are conducted in these areas as part of the project requirement. Detailed tabulation of data will be analysed and presented in tables as conclusion for both of the categories.
Figure 28: Site Study: Highlighted part to show accessible areas
31
Site Study
Figure 29: Location Plan of L45, Bangsar
The L45 Kurau Community Library, highlighted in blue, is located in Lorong Kurau, Kuala Lumpur. The site is in the midst of a residential area highlighted in green, with a nearby commercial area in yellow. As the site is located on top of the hill, it receives a fair amount of natural light. This quality is further enhanced by the building height being taller than nearby terraces. The building receives most natural light in the afternoon from the glass roof located in the middle of the library, until the sun sets in the evening at the other side of the hill. The faรงade of the kitchen area and the lounge area draws in light through its large windows. The front faรงade of the library draws in light into the lounge and the second floor library. Most of the restricted spaces are hostels for students, where they can freely adjust the amount of natural light through the smaller window openings. The main strategy to reduce heat gain in the L45 library is by utilizing the high thermal mass of the concrete faรงade. Others include using curtains and glazed window. These strategies successfully create a cool interior environment while only having one air conditioning unit.
32
Zoning
Ground Floor Plan 1:150 Restricted Area Dining and Kitchen Lounge Library Washroom
First Floor Plan 1:150 Restricted Area Library
Second Floor Plan 1:150 Restricted Area Library
33
4.1.2 Tabulation & Interpretation of Data Dining and Kitchen Zone Lux reading (lux) Grid 3.00pm
C2 C3 C4 C5 D2 D3 D4 D5 Average
1m 160 50 45 22 115 35 95 40 70.25
1.5m 90 35 40 21 100 22 100 40 56
3.00pm (artificial light) 1m 1.5m 160 115 190 150 55 50 35 30 200 230 110 120 450 420 75 135 160 156.25
7.00pm (artificial light) 1m 20 150 35 20 80 60 450 45 107.5
1.5m 15 195 30 15 65 60 700 25 138.125
Table 6: Lux Readings at Dining and Kitchen Zone
Lounge Zone Lux reading (lux) Grid 3.00pm
E4 E5 F4 F5 Average
1m 150 80 330 25 146.25
1.5m 135 100 220 195 162.5
3.00pm (artificial light) 1m 1.5m 320 245 230 175 410 315 325 265 321.25 250
7.00pm (artificial light) 1m 80 60 80 60 70
1.5m 105 60 90 75 82.5
Table 7: Lux Readings at Lounge Zone
Washroom Zone Lux reading (lux) Grid 3.00pm
F7
1m 120
1.5m 125
3.00pm (artificial light) 1m 1.5m 220 160
7.00pm (artificial light) 1m 130
1.5m 70
Table 8: Lux Readings at Washroom Zone
34
Library Zone (Ground Floor) Lux reading (lux) Grid 3.00pm
B6 C6 D6 E6 F6 Average
1m 75 85 165 120 210 131
1.5m 120 35 200 120 230 141
3.00pm (artificial light) 1m 1.5m 130 125 180 135 400 600 355 266 470 565 307 338.2
7.00pm (artificial light) 1m 60 110 165 340 380 211
1.5m 20 50 680 650 580 396
Table 9: Lux Readings at Ground Floor Library Zone
Library Zone (First Floor) Lux reading (lux) Grid 3.00pm
B6 C6 D6 E6 F6 Average
1m 500 460 710 530 1300 700
1.5m 920 450 820 660 370 644
3.00pm (artificial light) 1m 1.5m 560 1020 460 450 710 820 560 660 1350 370 728 664
7.00pm (artificial light) 1m 140 80 170 100 95 117
1.5m 500 85 180 115 75 191
Table 10: Lux Readings at First Floor Library Zone
Library Zone (Second Floor) Lux reading (lux) Grid 3.00pm
B6 C6 Average
1m 3650 1900 2775
1.5m 3650 1900 2775
3.00pm (artificial light) 1m 1.5m 3650 3650 1900 1900 2775 2775
7.00pm (artificial light) 1m 25 50 15
1.5m 15 10 5
Table 11: Lux Readings at Second Floor Library Zone
35
Observations
Based on the lux data collected, some observations were noted along with its relevant discussions.
Observation 1: Lux reading shows that the highest amount of light contributed to the area during the day time comes from the natural daylight. Discussion 1: The presence of many openings at the areas unrestricted to us allows for natural light to become the main light source to the area during daytime.
Observation 2: The artificial lighting shows an irregular and inconsistent pattern in the readings during the day and night. Discussion 2: Due to the irregular positioning of the lights at various different angles, some areas become unaffected with the presence of the lights even during the night.
Observation 3: The library zone has a higher lux rating compared to the other zones. Discussion 3: Even though other zones are located near windows, the library is the brightest because of the presence of the glass roof. It is able to bring in a large amount of natural light that penetrates the ground floor.
36
4.1.3 Sunpath Analysis
Figure 30: Sun Path Diagrams
Overall Observation: Orientation of the building possesses frontage towards north-south and east. Party wall parallel to north southern line. Thus western faรงade possesses no openings and thus completely void of western sun. Building receives pleasant morning sun and is shaded from harsh afternoon sun and evening glare. Library Zones: Entrance foyer faces towards east. Morning light enters through slit windows on either side of the entrance door and the large windows facing directly east. These windows act as one of the main natural light sources for into the reading areas and entrance foyer, second only to the skylight at the highest level. Greeneries provide some shade but do not block out sun light completely. Materiality of wire meshed floors and
37
staircases above ground level allows for further penetration of light into the reading areas and entrance foyer. Skylight at top floor allows unrestricted sun light in throughout the day. Acting as an air-well which illuminates building with natural sunlight, thus becoming the main source of natural light for the library. Distance between skylight and top floor provide buffer zone against afternoon glare into the top floor, minimising direct sunlight unto top floor. Walls act as reflectance for sun light. Lounge Zone: The lounge is located on the south east of the building. Receives morning light through large window opening which faces directly towards the east. Southern facing windows receive indirect light in the form of reflectance unto east facing wall on the exterior. Dining and Kitchen Zone: The kitchen-dining area possesses full height operable folding doors, which when opened provide the only source of opening to the kitchen to allow light in. Full height and width opening allows maximum amount of indirect natural light as possible to illuminate the kitchen. However, due to southern facing opening, shaded buffer zone and shade from greenery, natural light is insufficient to provide for a properly lit reading environment into the kitchen and dining area throughout the day.
38
4.1.4 Lighting Fixtures and Specifications 1) Compact Fluorescent Light
Figure 31: Compact Fluorescent Light hanging in lounge area
Product name
OSRAM DULUXSTAR MINI TWIST
Size
E27
Wattage
13W
Luminous Flux
800 lm
Colour Temperature
2700 K soft white
Colour Rendering Index
≥80 Ra
Bulb finish
Warm white
Placement
Lounge
Type of fixture
Pendant
Rated ambient temperature
25°C
Table 12: Specification of Compact Fluorescent Light
39
2) Track Spotlight
Figure 32: Track Spotlight attached in front of the book shelves
Product name
Rio L45TB521
Size
55 mm diameter
Wattage
33W
Luminous Flux
400 lm
Colour Temperature
3000 K
Colour Rendering Index
100 Ra
Bulb finish
Warm yellow
Placement
Library Zone
Type of fixture
Attached
Rated ambient temperature
25°C
Table 13: Specification of Track Spotlight
40
3) Halogen Down Light
Figure 33: Halogen Down Light placed in dining and kitchen area
Product name
HALOSPOT 111
Size
111 mm diameter
Wattage
35 W
Luminous Flux
350 lm
Colour Temperature
3000 K Warm white
Colour Rendering Index
100 Ra
Bulb finish
Soft yellow
Placement
Dining and Kitchen area
Type of fixture
Hanging
Rated ambient temperature
35°C
Table 14: Specification of Halogen Down Light
41
4) Oval Bulkhead Light
Figure 34: Oval Bulkhead Light placed in the washroom
Product name
A19 LED Light Bulb
Size
E27
Wattage
60 W
Luminous Flux
800 lm
Colour Temperature
3000 K Warm white
Colour Rendering Index
100 Ra
Bulb finish
Soft white
Placement
Washroom
Type of fixture
Attached
Rated ambient temperature
49°C
Table 15: Specification of Oval Bulkhead Light
42
4.1.5 Daylight and Artificial Light Contour Analysis
Daylight Contour Diagram Ground Floor
Figure 35: Daylight Contour Diagram at Ground Floor
First Floor
Figure 36: Daylight Contour Diagram at First Floor
43
Second Floor
Figure 37: Daylight Contour Diagram at Second Floor
Analysis
The three contour diagrams above show the digital lighting analysis of the daylighting levels in the library by using the Ecotect software.
The first diagram shows a higher lux value to the southern end of the building but the deeper parts get darker and eventually the lux value drops to zero. Yet, according to our data, there is still minimal daylighting in the library zone, which only comes from the upper floors. The second diagram shows brighter areas at both ends of the space, able to attain more than 1,000 lux. The natural light is able to influence the spaces inside, drawing up the value to around 300 lux. The last diagram shows the second floor, which is the brightest of all the floors overall, scoring more than 700 lux at every point.
Although some of the lux values generated does not appear to match the data that we collected(which could be due to human error), but the pattern of the rise and fall of the overall lux level consistently follows it. As a conclusion, the digital analysis matches the gathered lux value.
44
Artificial Light Contour Diagram Ground Floor
Figure 38: Artificial Light Contour Diagram at Ground Floor
First Floor
Figure 39: Artificial Light Contour Diagram at First Floor
45
Second Floor
Figure 40: Artificial Light Contour Diagram at Second Floor
Analysis
The three contour diagrams above show the digital lighting analysis of the artificial lighting levels in the library by using the Ecotect software. The first diagram shows several areas that are brightened up by the artificial lights. These brightened spaces are essentially parts unreachable by daylight and are heavily dependent on lighting devices. The library space where the reading area is, is revealed to be brighter than other areas due to the reading activities. In the second diagram, the area to the west is illuminated better than the east side. The last diagram shows a well-lit area to the west. The digital analysis shows an overall lux level that is supposedly much higher compared to our data. This huge difference can be explained by the fact that direction of the lighting fixtures are not pointing straight down but faces different angles as the user of the space is able to adjust it at will. As result, the data we collected appears to be fluctuating.
46
4.1.6 Daylight and Artificial Light Calculation and Analysis Zone 1: Dining and Kitchen
Figure 41: Dining Area in Plan View
Figure 42: Dining Area in Sectional View
The highlighted area of the plan is the dining and kitchen area, with a total space of 14m2. The area near the sliding doors is quite well lit by natural light. The openings were faced to the south, preventing glare from the sun into this space while supplying little amount of light. Artificial lightings were used for the interior, mostly facing the
47
cooking area and dining table. The artificial lights used were the same type, which is halogen down light. Daylight Factor Calculation Average Lux Reading
3.00pm
7.00pm
1m
70.25
15
1.5m
56
12.5
Average Lux Value
63.13
13.75
Table 16: Average Lux Reading in Dining and Kitchen Zone
Time/Date/Sky
Daylight level in Average
Condition
Malaysia, E₀ (lux)
lux Daylight
reading
DF
E₁ (lux)
DF
=
Factor,
(E₁/E₀)
x
100% 20000
63.13
DF = (63.13/20000)
3pm
X 100%
30th Sept 2016
DF = 0.32%
Sunny 20000
13.75
DF = (13.75/20000)
7pm
X 100%
30th Sept 2016
DF = 0.07%
Sunny Table 17: Daylight Factor Affected by Time
Illuminance
Example
120000 lux
Brightness sunlight
110000 lux
Bright sunlight
20000 lux
Shade illuminated by entire clear blue sky
1000 – 2000 lux
Typical overcast day, midday
400 lux
Sunrise or sunset on clear day (ambient illumination)
< 200 lux
Extreme of darkest storm clouds, midday
40 lux
Fully overcast, sunset/sunrise
<1 lux
Extreme of darkest storm clouds, sunset/sunrise Table 18: Daily intensities in different condition
48
DF, %
Distribution
>6
Very bright with thermal and glare problem
3-6
Bright
1-3
Average
0-1
Dark Table 19: Daylight Factor, DF
Analysis
As shown in the table, the daylight factors of the dining and kitchen zone at both day and night are below 1% which is considered dark. This is due to insufficient light reaching the deeper part of the area. Therefore, a change in strategy should be made during the day to draw in more natural light to the interior, either by adding more openings or using materials with high reflective value. In the evening however, artificial lighting is the only way to brighten up the space.
49
Artificial Lighting Calculation Dining and Kitchen Room dimension
5m x 2.8m
Floor Area (A)
14m2
Types of lighting fixture
Halogen Down Light
Number of lighting fixture (n)
9
Lumen flux of lighting fixture (F) (lux)
350
Height of work level
0.9m
Height of Luminaire
2.5m
Mounting height (hm)
1.6m
Reflection value (%)
Rough concrete floor: 30% Rough concrete wall: 30% Rough concrete ceiling: 30%
Room index (K)
(L x W) / (L +W) (hm) = (5 x 2.8) / (5 + 2.8) (1.6) = 1.12
Utilisation factor (UF)
0.43
Maintenance factor (MF)
0.8
Illuminance level (lux)
[n(F x UF x MF)] / A = [9(350 x 0.43 x 0.8)] / 14 = 77.4
MS1525 Recommendation (E) (lux)
150 (minimum)
Number of lightings required (N)
N = (E x A) / (F x UF x MF) N = (150 x 14) / (350 x 0.43 x 0.8) N = 17
n=9
N-n= 8
8 more halogen down light is required to meet the MS1525
50
Zone 2: Lounge
Figure 43: Lounge Zone in Plan View
Figure 44: Lounge Zone in Sectional View
The highlighted area of the plan shows the lounge, with a total space of 6.3m 2. The area is quite well lit as windows are present at the two sides of the wall. The windows draw in natural light from both south and east, brighten up the interior. During the day, the artificial lights (marked in red) were almost unused. The type of lighting used here is compact fluorescent light.
51
Daylight Factor Calculation Average Lux Reading
3.00pm
7.00pm
1m
146.25
10.75
1.5m
162.5
8.8
Average Lux Value
154.38
9.78
Table 20: Average Lux Reading in Lounge Zone
Time/Date/Sky
Daylight level in
Average lux
Daylight Factor, DF
Condition
Malaysia, E₀
reading
DF = (E₁/E₀) x 100%
(lux)
E₁ (lux)
20000
154.38
DF = (154.38/20000)
3pm
X 100%
30th Sept 2016
DF =
Sunny
0.77.00.3……………3.. % 20000
9.78
DF = (9.78/20000)
7pm
X 100%
30th Sept 2016
DF = 0.05%
Sunny Table 21: Daylight Factor Affected by Time
Illuminance
Example
120000 lux
Brightness sunlight
110000 lux
Bright sunlight
20000 lux
Shade illuminated by entire clear blue sky
1000 – 2000 lux
Typical overcast day, midday
400 lux
Sunrise or sunset on clear day (ambient illumination)
< 200 lux
Extreme of darkest storm clouds, midday
40 lux
Fully overcast, sunset/sunrise
<1 lux
Extreme of darkest storm clouds, sunset/sunrise Table 22: Daily intensities in different condition
52
DF, %
Distribution
>6
Very bright with thermal and glare problem
3-6
Bright
1-3
Average
0-1
Dark Table 23: Daylight Factor, DF
Analysis
As shown in the table, the daylight factors of the dining area at both day and night are below 1% which is considered dark. Despite that, the daylight factor during the day is at 0.77% which is close to being average brightness, making it still possible for reading activities especially in the morning when the east side receives more light. To further increase the value, the window facing to the east should be made larger and taller to maximize the usage of the morning sun. Artificial lights had to be used at evening as the daylight factor is close to being 0%.
Figure 45: Daylighting Conditions in the Lounge Area
53
Artificial Lighting Calculation Lounge Room dimension
2.1m x 3m
Floor Area (A)
6.3m2
Types of lighting fixture
Compact Fluorescent Light
Number of lighting fixture (n)
2
Lumen flux of lighting fixture (F) (lux)
800
Height of work level
0.9m
Height of Luminaire
3m
Mounting height (hm)
2.1m
Reflection value (%)
Rough concrete floor: 30% Rough concrete wall: 30% Timber ceiling: 40%
Room index (K)
(L x W) / (L +W) (hm) = (2.1 x 3) / (2.1 + 3) (2.1) = 0.59
Utilisation factor (UF)
0.3
Maintenance factor (MF)
0.8
Illuminance level (lux)
[n(F x UF x MF)] / A = [2(800 x 0.3 x 0.8)] / 6.3 = 61
MS1525 Recommendation (E) (lux)
150
Number of lightings required (N)
N = (E x A) / (F x UF x MF) N = (150 x 6.3) / (800 x 0.3 x 0.8) N=5
n=2
N-n= 3
3 more Compact fluorescent light is required to meet the MS1525
54
Zone 3: Washroom
Figure 46: Washroom Zone in Plan View
Figure 47: Washroom Zone in Sectional View
The highlighted area of the plan shows the washroom, with a total space of 1.62m2. There are no direct natural light coming into this area, which make the area fully dependent on artificial light most of the time. The type of light (marked in red) used is an oval bulkhead light.
55
Artificial Light Calculation Washroom Room dimension
0.83m x 1.95m
Floor Area (A)
1.62m2
Types of lighting fixture
Oval Bulkhead Light
Number of lighting fixture (n)
1
Lumen flux of lighting fixture (F) (lux)
800
Height of work level
0.9m
Height of Luminaire
2m
Mounting height (hm)
1.1m
Reflection value (%)
Rough concrete floor: 30% Rough concrete wall: 30% Rough concrete ceiling: 30%
Room index (K)
(L x W) / (L +W) (hm) = (0.83 x 1.95) / (0.83 + 1.95) (1.1) = 0.53
Utilisation factor (UF)
0.3
Maintenance factor (MF)
0.8
Illuminance level (lux)
[n(F x UF x MF)] / A = [1(800 x 0.3 x 0.8)] / 1.62 = 118.5
MS1525 Recommendation (E) (lux)
150
Number of lightings required (N)
N = (E x A) / (F x UF x MF) N = (150 x 1.62) / (800 x 0.3 x 0.8) N=1
n=1
N-n= 0
The number of oval buckhead light is enough to meet the MS1525
56
Zone 4: Library Ground Floor
Figure 48: Library Ground Floor in Plan View
Figure 49: Library Ground Floor in Sectional View
The highlighted area of the plan shows the library area at the ground floor, with a total space of 13.5m2. This area is mostly lit by indirect natural light coming from the small windows by the door and the open glass roof at the second floor. The light from the glass roof passed through the holes of the metal mesh flooring at the second and third floor, reaching the interior of the library. At the evening, artificial light is a must as the lux value drop to zero. There is only 1 type of lighting device (marked in red) used here which is track spotlight.
57
Daylight Factor Calculation Average Lux Reading
3.00pm
7.00pm
1m
131
0
1.5m
141
0
Average Lux Value
136
0
Table 24: Average Lux Reading in Library Ground Floor Zone
Time/Date/Sky
Daylight level in
Average lux
Daylight Factor,
Condition
Malaysia, E₀ (lux)
reading
DF
E₁ (lux)
DF = (E₁/E₀) x 100%
20000
136
DF = (136/20000)
3pm
X 100%
30th Sept 2016
DF = 0.68%
Sunny 20000
0
DF = (0/20000)
7pm
X 100%
30th Sept 2016
DF = 0%
Sunny Table 25: Daylight Factor Affected by Time
Illuminance
Example
120000 lux
Brightness sunlight
110000 lux
Bright sunlight
20000 lux
Shade illuminated by entire clear blue sky
1000 – 2000 lux
Typical overcast day, midday
400 lux
Sunrise or sunset on clear day (ambient illumination)
< 200 lux
Extreme of darkest storm clouds, midday
40 lux
Fully overcast, sunset/sunrise
<1 lux
Extreme of darkest storm clouds, sunset/sunrise Table 26: Daily intensities in different condition
58
DF, %
Distribution
>6
Very bright with thermal and glare problem
3-6
Bright
1-3
Average
0-1
Dark Table 27: Daylight Factor, DF
Analysis
As shown in the table, the daylight factors of the dining area at both day and night are below 1% which is considered dark. During the evening, artificial light is required as the factor is at 0%. However, some part of the area during the day are quite well lit except for the deeper parts. These darker areas need artificial light to support it or else the metal mesh flooring above it should be change into a more reflective material to bring in more natural light from the glass roof.
Figure 50: Sunlight streams to the ground floor through the grills
59
Artificial Light Calculation Library Ground Floor Room dimension
1.8m x 7.5m
Floor Area (A)
13.5m2
Types of lighting fixture
Track Spotlight
Number of lighting fixture (n)
11
Lumen flux of lighting fixture (F) (lux)
400
Height of work level
0.5
Height of Luminaire
2.6m
Mounting height (hm)
2.1m
Reflection value (%)
Rough concrete floor: 30% Steel mesh wall: 60% Steel mesh ceiling: 60%
Room index (K)
(L x W) / (L +W) (hm) = (1.8 x 7.5) / (1.8 + 7.5) (2.1) = 0.69
Utilisation factor (UF)
0.4
Maintenance factor (MF)
0.8
Illuminance level (lux)
[n(F x UF x MF)] / A = [11(400 x 0.4 x 0.8)] / 13.5 = 104.3
MS1525 Recommendation (E) (lux)
300 (minimum)
Number of lightings required (N)
N = (E x A) / (F x UF x MF) N = (300 x 13.5) / (400 x 0.4 x 0.8) N = 31
n = 11
N-n= 20
20 more track spotlight is required to meet the MS1525
60
Zone 5: Library First Floor
Figure 51: Library First Floor in Plan View
Figure 52: Library First Floor in Sectional View
The highlighted area of the plan shows the library area at the first floor, with a total space of 13.5m2. This area has sufficient amount of natural light due to its closer proximately with the glass roof and a window facing the west. These two elements are enough to brighten up the interior space, making it highly suitable for reading. The window at the west side can be freely close by a curtain depending on the userâ&#x20AC;&#x2122;s preference. Despite that, artificial light (marked in red) is still the main source of light during the evening and the type of light used is track spotlight.
61
Daylight Factor Calculation Average Lux Reading
3.00pm
7.00pm
1m
700
0
1.5m
644
0
Average Lux Value
672
0
Table 28: Average Lux Reading in Library First Floor Zone
Time/Date/Sky
Daylight level in
Average lux
Daylight Factor,
Condition
Malaysia, E₀
reading
DF
(lux)
E₁ (lux)
DF = (E₁/E₀) x 100%
20000
672
DF = (672/20000)
3pm
X 100%
30th Sept 2016
DF = 3.36%
Sunny 20000
0
DF = (0/20000)
7pm
X 100%
30th Sept 2016
DF = 0%
Sunny Table 29: Daylight Factor Affected by Time
Illuminance
Example
120000 lux
Brightness sunlight
110000 lux
Bright sunlight
20000 lux
Shade illuminated by entire clear blue sky
1000 – 2000 lux
Typical overcast day, midday
400 lux
Sunrise or sunset on clear day (ambient illumination)
< 200 lux
Extreme of darkest storm clouds, midday
40 lux
Fully overcast, sunset/sunrise
<1 lux
Extreme of darkest storm clouds, sunset/sunrise Table 30: Daily intensities in different condition
62
DF, %
Distribution
>6
Very bright with thermal and glare problem
3-6
Bright
1-3
Average
0-1
Dark Table 31: Daylight Factor, DF
Analysis
As shown in the table, the daylight factor during the day is at 3.36%, falling under the bright category. Therefore, the natural lighting at this area is enough to carry out the library activities without the need of artificial light from morning to late afternoon. However, the value quickly drop to 0% when approaching evening and artificial light must be used.
Figure 53: Sunlight streams in from the second floor to the first and finally to the ground floor
63
Artificial Light Calculation Library First Floor Room dimension
1.8m x 7.5m
Floor Area (A)
13.5m2
Types of lighting fixture
Track spotlight
Number of lighting fixture (n)
15
Lumen flux of lighting fixture (F) (lux)
400
Height of work level
0.5
Height of Luminaire
2.3m
Mounting height (hm)
1.8m
Reflection value (%)
Steel mesh floor: 60% Steel mesh wall: 60% Timber ceiling: 40%
Room index (K)
(L x W) / (L +W) (hm) = (1.8 x 7.5) / (1.8 + 7.5) (1.8) = 0.8
Utilisation factor (UF)
0.45
Maintenance factor (MF)
0.8
Illuminance level (lux)
[n(F x UF x MF)] / A = [15(400 x 0.45 x 0.8)] / 13.5 = 160
MS1525 Recommendation (E) (lux)
300 (minimum)
Number of lightings required (N)
N = (E x A) / (F x UF x MF) N = (300 x 13.5) / (400 x 0.45 x 0.8) N = 28
n = 15
N-n= 13
13 more track spotlight is required to meet the MS1525
64
Zone 6: Library Second Floor
Figure 54: Library Second Floor in Plan View
Figure 55: Library Second Floor in Sectional View
The highlighted area of the plan shows the library area at the second floor, with a total space of 3.8m2. This area has the highest amount of lux reading as it is located directly beneath the glass roof, where the natural light travels in without any obstacle. At evening, a small amount of natural light still shines into the space. The artificial light (marked in red) used is track spotlight.
65
Daylight Factor Calculation Average Lux Reading
3.00pm
7.00pm
1m
2775
37.5
1.5m
2775
12.5
Average Lux Value
2775
25
Table 32: Average Lux Reading in Library Second Floor Zone
Time/Date/Sky
Daylight level in
Average lux
Daylight Factor,
Condition
Malaysia, E₀
reading
DF
(lux)
E₁ (lux)
DF = (E₁/E₀) x 100%
20000
2775
DF = (2775/20000)
3pm 30th Sept 2016
X 100% DF = 13.9%
Sunny 20000
25
DF = (25/20000)
7pm
X 100%
30th Sept 2016
DF = 0.13%
Sunny Table 33: Daylight Factor Affected by Time
Illuminance
Example
120000 lux
Brightness sunlight
110000 lux
Bright sunlight
20000 lux
Shade illuminated by entire clear blue sky
1000 – 2000 lux
Typical overcast day, midday
400 lux
Sunrise or sunset on clear day (ambient illumination)
< 200 lux
Extreme of darkest storm clouds, midday
40 lux
Fully overcast, sunset/sunrise
<1 lux
Extreme of darkest storm clouds, sunset/sunrise Table 34: Daily intensities in different condition
66
DF, %
Distribution
>6
Very bright with thermal and glare problem
3-6
Bright
1-3
Average
0-1
Dark Table 35: Daylight Factor, DF
Analysis
As shown in the table, the daylight factor during the day is at 13.9%, falling under the very bright category. Thus, high heat gain caused by the glass roof became a problem, which is why the only air conditioning unit at the library area is located at this area as a solution to it. Glaring is not an issue as the natural light come from the above, which do not affect the reading activity present in that area. However, the value drop drastically to 0.13% in the evening. By then, natural light is replaced by artificial light.
Figure 56: The main source of daylight in the Library Zones
67
Artificial Light Calculation Library Second Floor Room dimension
1.8m x 2.1m
Floor Area (A)
3.8m2
Types of lighting fixture
Track spotlight
Number of lighting fixture (n)
8
Lumen flux of lighting fixture (F) (lux)
400
Height of work level
0.5
Height of Luminaire
1.9m
Mounting height (hm)
1.4m
Reflection value (%)
Steel mesh floor: 60% Steel mesh wall: 60% Glass ceiling: 4%
Room index (K)
(L x W) / (L +W) (hm) = (1.8 x 2.1) / (1.8 + 2.1) (1.4) = 0.69
Utilisation factor (UF)
0.33
Maintenance factor (MF)
0.8
Illuminance level (lux)
[n(F x UF x MF)] / A = [8(400 x 0.33 x 0.8)] / 3.8 = 222
MS1525 Recommendation (E) (lux)
300 (minimum)
Number of lightings required (N)
N = (E x A) / (F x UF x MF) N = (300 x 3.8) / (400 x 0.33 x 0.8) N = 10
n=8
N-n= 2
2 more track spotlight is required to meet the MS1525
68
4.2 ACOUSTICS 4.2.1 Zoning
Ground Floor Plan 1:150 Restricted Area Dining and Kitchen Lounge Library Washroom
First Floor Plan 1:150 Restricted Area Library
Second Floor Plan 1:150 Restricted Area Library
69
4.2.2 Tabulation & Observation of Data
Dining and Kitchen Zone Decibel reading (dB) Grid Normal hours C2 43 C3 46 C4 45 C5 45 D2 43 D3 46 D4 45 D5 45
Peak hours 60 63 63 60 55 56 56 55
Table 36: Decibel Readings at Dining and Kitchen Area
Lounge Zone Decibel reading (dB) Grid Normal hours E4 45 E5 45 F4 45 F5 45
Peak hours 52 50 52 50
Table 37: Decibel Readings at Lounge Area
Washroom Zone Decibel reading (dB) Grid Normal hours F7 42
Peak hours 65
Table 38: Decibel Readings at Washroom Area
Library Zone (Ground Floor) Decibel reading (dB) Grid Normal hours B6 39 C6 45 D6 43 E6 43 F6 45
Peak hours 48 52 50 48 49
Table 39: Decibel Readings at Ground Floor Library Zone
70
Library Zone (First Floor) Decibel reading (dB) Grid Normal hours B6 45 C6 46 D6 47 E6 46 F6 45
Peak hours 48 48 52 52 55
Table 40: Decibel Readings at First Floor Library Zone
Library Zone (Second Floor) Decibel reading (dB) Grid Normal hours B6 54 C6 52
Peak hours 58 55
Table 41: Decibel Readings at Second Floor Library Zone
Observations Ground Floor Non-peak hour
Figure 57: Decibels at different points of the ground floor during non-peak hours
71
Peak hour
Figure 58: Decibels at different points of the ground floor during peak hours
The two figures above show the decibels at different points of the ground floor areas. The rise in the overall sound level is obvious when comparing both. The points at the dining area are seen to have increase 10 or more decibels during peak hour when the kitchen is in use. The south part of the lounge area has a higher decibel due to its closer proximity to the dining area and the sitting space. When the library area is in use, the rise in decibel do not exceed 10 because the activities produces minimal sound.
72
First Floor Non-peak hour
Peak hour
Figure 59: Decibels at different points of the first floor during non-peak and peak hours
The two figures above show the decibels at different points of the first floor area. The rise in the overall sound level is little compared to the ground floor. The increase in the average decibel of the whole library area is only around 5 due to its quieter activities and location, being further away from the noisier zones at the ground floor.
73
Second Floor Non-peak hour
Peak hour
Figure 60: Decibels at different points of the second floor during non-peak and peak hours
The two figures above show the decibels at different points of the second floor area. The rise in the overall sound level is the lowest among the three floors. The increase in decibel at the top floor library area does not exceed 4 decibels. This may be due to the already not so quiet environment caused by nearby electronical devices, so that the rise is not very significant when the area is in use.
74
4.2.3 Outdoor and Indoor Noise Sources
Outdoor Noise Sources
Figure 61: Location of the site is highlighted in blue
Located in the midst of a residential area, the noise level is rather low as there are no major human activities going on nearby.
Figure 62: Vehicles using the road on a normal day
The exterior noises mostly come from vehicles passing by to the commercial area which is highlighted in yellow. Occasionally, sounds from the neighborhood pets and birds chirping at the trees nearby could be heard. The average decibel at the exterior
75
does not exceed 50db during normal to peak hours as no traffic jams occur in front of the library.
Figure 63: Trees that line up outside the building
Apart from providing shade, the trees located around the library also help in absorbing some of the noises.
76
Indoor Noise Sources Overall Interior Space Planning The thick concrete wall is able to minimize the amount of exterior noise from coming into the library with concrete being an average insulator. By placing the library area(reading zones) at the center of the building, the surrounding spaces act as a buffer zone to further neutralize the noise from outside. This creates a silent area with minimal disturbance at the middle of the library, where students and visitors can fully enjoy and focus on their reading. In each zone, there will be a certain device that causes noise disturbance to the occupants. Zone 1: Dining and Kitchen The dining area is connected to the kitchen area, where most of the noises are generated. The noises from the kitchen occurs when someone is cooking or using the microwave. These noises are amplified when dishes are being washed in the sink, caused by the clashing of pots and pans. However, when there are no activities happening in the kitchen, the area became rather quiet.
Figure 64: Source of noise at the Dining-Kitchen Zone
77
Human activity The human activities present in the dining area are mostly silent with the exception of eating. Some of the guest prefer to use this area to watch movies or films through their personal laptops, which produces minimal noise from the keyboard. Sliding door
Figure 65: Source of noise at the Dining-Kitchen Area
The sliding door facing to the south brings in external noise but it is very rarely opened due to the library being cooled by the air condition unit from the top level, which made it independent from relying on natural wind. Through our observation, the only time it was opened is because of the maintenance work on the external air condition unit located above the exterior of the sliding door. Toaster Oven
Figure 66: Toaster Oven placed in the kitchen
78
Electric Kettle
Figure 67: Electric Kettle placed in the kitchen
Toast Oven
Figure 68: Toast oven placed in the kitchen
Microwave Oven
Figure 69: Microwave oven placed in the kitchen
79
Ceiling Fan
Figure 70: Ceiling fan located at dining area
Auto Fan
Figure 71: Auto fan placed at the dining area
Zone 2: Lounge The lounge area is located right beside the dining area, with minimal noise sources coming from the window openings. Most of the noise come from the ceiling fan and the minimal human activity in the area. The noise here is inconsistent as it is not as much used as the other areas by the visitors except for the librarian.
80
Figure 72: Source of noise at the Lounge Zone
Human activity The librarian uses this area as a place to set up his/her laptop to surf the net. The area provides view of the approaching visitors through the windows directed at the main entrance. Briefing was done in this area for new visitors which produces little noise as to not disturb the users of the library. Ceiling Fan
Figure 73: Ceiling fan located at the lounge.
81
Zone 3: Washroom The only washroom available for the public, it was not used frequently because of the short open visit hours. Except for the human activities, the washroom also produces adequate internal noise coming from the sink and the flushing of the toilet bowl.
Figure 74: Source of noise at the Washroom Zone
Sink
Figure 75: Concrete sink in the washroom
82
Toilet Bowl
Figure 76: Toilet bowl in the washroom
Zone 4: Library Ground Floor The library at the ground level has several internal noise sources. The first is from the door facing to the east, which serves as the main entry for the library. The second noise comes from the use of the mac computer located behind the stair leading to the first mezzanine level. The final noise source comes from the human activity throughout the library.
Figure 77: Source of noise at the Library Ground Floor Zone
83
Human Activity The human activities on the ground level is the same as the levels above with a slight difference being different in location. People sit on the beanie bags provided in the corners while reading books selected from the cases made of steel mesh. Activities like flipping and choosing the books produces noises that had miniscule effect on our decibel reading device. Other activities that contribute more significant rise in volume are people having conversations or just reading the book out softly. Steel Door The main entrance uses a steel door with noticeable narrow openings at the side which lights penetrates through, letting in little external sound to the library area close to it. This door is used frequently as there are no other entrances to the library.
Figure 78: Position of the steel door
84
Computer and Keyboard
Figure 79: Position of the keyboard in the library ground floor area
Zone 5: Library First Floor The library at the first level only have two internal noise sources: human activity and auto fan. The human activity here is identical to the other floors but located near the east side of the library due to the natural light brought in by the large window. The auto fan is located at the middle of the library, ventilating the space evenly but at the same time produce little noise that does not really affect the library activities.
Figure 80: Source of noise at the Library First Floor Zone
85
Auto Fan
Figure 81: Auto fan placed at the first floor of the library
Zone 6: Library Second Floor The library at the second level is the noisiest when compared to the other levels due to its location being close to the air conditioner and a ventilation fan. Despite that, the noises produced are not loud enough to disrupt the reading activity at the area. During rainy days, the glass roof amplifies the sound of the rain drops into the area, which than channels throughout the library.
Figure 82: Source of noise at the Library First Floor Zone
86
Air Conditioner
Figure 83: AC that is placed at the second floor
Ventilation Fan
Figure 84: Ventilation fan placed at top floor
87
4.2.4 Acoustic Fixtures and Specifications 1) Ceiling Fan
Figure 85: Ceiling Fan located at lounge area.
Model
K15V0
Type
Ceiling fan
Power
85 W
Noise
<62 dB
Weight
5.31 kg
Table 42: Specification of Ceiling Fan
88
2) Auto Fan
Figure 86: Auto fan placed at the dining and kitchen area
Model
KQ409
Type
Wall mount (auto)
Power
25.2-54.8 W
Noise level
<60 dB
Weight
3.9 kg
Table 43: Specification of KDK Auto Fan
89
3) Air-Conditioning
Figure 87: Air Conditioner that is placed on the second floor
Model
CS-PV24SKH-1
Horse power
2.5
Cooling capacity
6.85 kW
Noise level
(Hi/Lo) 47/42 dB-A Indoor (Hi) 57 dB-A Outdoor 12 kg
Weight
Table 44: Specification of Panasonic AC
90
4) Ventilation Fan
Figure 88: Ventilation Fan placed at second floor
Model
25AQM7
Type
Wall mount propeller
Power
240 V
Cooling capacity
530
Noise level
39 dB
Weight
2.6 kg
Table 45: Specification of KDK Ventilation Fan
91
5) Toaster Oven
Figure 89: Toaster Oven placed at kitchen
Model
TEFAL TT3561
Power consumption(W)
850 W
Noise level
80 dB-A
Dimension ( W x H x D, cm)
16x18x27
Weight:
1.4 kg
Table 46: Specification of Tefal Toaster
92
6) Electric Kettle
Figure 90: Electric Kettle placed at kitchen
Model:
NC-SK1
Power consumption(W)
1850 W
Noise level
82 dB-A
Dimensions (H X W X D)
24.9 X 21.7 X 15.8 cm
Weight:
1.2 kg
Table 47: Specification of Panasonic Electric Kettle
93
7) Toast Oven
Figure 91: Toast Oven placed at kitchen
Model:
EOT-4550
Power consumption(W)
1300 W
Noise level
58 dB-A
Dimensions (L X W X H)
40 X 40 X 30 cm
Weight:
4.8 kg
Table : Specification of Electrolux Toast Oven
94
8) Microwave Oven
Figure 92: Microwave Oven placed at kitchen
Model:
MS2043DB
Power consumption(W)
700 W
Noise level
62 dB-A
Dimensions (W X H X D)
45 X 25 X 32 cm
Weight:
11 kg
Table : Specification of LG Microwave
95
9) Computer and Keyboard
Figure 93: Computer and Keyboard placed at the Ground Floor
Power consumption(W)
0.5 W
Noise level
45 dB-A
Table : Specification of Computer and Keyboard
96
4.2.5 Sound Pressure Level (SPL) Analysis
Sound Pressure Level is the average sound level, given a medium or place
Zone 1: Dining and Kitchen Non-peak hours Highest reading
=
46
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
46
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
46
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
4.6
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 4.6
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (3.98 x 10⁴)
I
=
3.98 x 10⁻⁸
Lowest reading
=
43
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
43
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
43
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
4.3
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 4.3
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (2 x 10⁴)
I
=
2 x 10⁻⁸
Total Intensities
=
(3.98 x 10⁻⁸) + (2 x 10⁻⁸)
=
5.98 x 10⁻⁸
Combined SPL
= =
10 Log₁₀ [(5.98 x 10⁻⁸) / (1 x 10⁻¹²)]
47.8
Total SPL during normal hours at this zone is 47.8 dB
97
Zone 1: Dining and Kitchen Peak hours Highest reading
=
63
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
63
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
63
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
6.3
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 6.3
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (2 x 10⁶)
I
=
2 x 10⁻⁶
Lowest reading
=
55
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
55
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
55
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
5.5
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 5.5
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (3.16 x 10⁵)
I
=
3.16 x 10⁻⁷
Total Intensities
=
(2 x 10⁻⁶) + (3.16 x 10⁻⁷)
=
2.316 x 10⁻⁶
Combined SPL
= =
10 Log₁₀ [(2.316 x 10⁻⁶) / (1 x 10⁻¹²)]
63.6
Total SPL during peak hours at this zone is 63.6 dB
98
Zone 2: Lounge Non-peak hours Highest reading
=
45
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
45
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
45
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
4.5
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 4.5
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (3.16 x 10⁴)
I
=
3.16 x 10⁻⁸
Lowest reading
=
45
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
45
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
45
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
4.5
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 4.5
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (3.16 x 10⁴)
I
=
3.16 x 10⁻⁸
Total Intensities
=
(3.16 x 10⁻⁸) + (3.16 x 10⁻⁸)
=
6.32 x 10⁻⁸
Combined SPL
= =
10 Log₁₀ [(6.32 x 10⁻⁸) / (1 x 10⁻¹²)]
48
Total SPL during normal hours at this zone is 48 dB
99
Zone 2: Lounge Peak hours Highest reading
=
52
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
52
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
52
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
5.2
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 5.2
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (1.58 x 10⁵)
I
=
1.58 x 10⁻⁷
Lowest reading
=
50
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
50
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
50
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
5
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 5
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (1 x 10⁵)
I
=
1 x 10⁻⁷
Total Intensities
=
(1.58 x 10⁻⁷) + (1 x 10⁻⁷)
=
2.58 x 10⁻⁷
Combined SPL
= =
10 Log₁₀ [(2.58 x 10⁻⁷) / (1 x 10⁻¹²)]
54.1
Total SPL during peak hours at this zone is 54.1 dB
100
Zone 3: Washroom Non-peak hours Reading
=
42
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
42
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
42
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
4.2
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 4.2
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (1.58 x 10⁴)
I
=
1.58 x 10⁻⁸
Total Intensities
=
1.58 x 10⁻⁸
Combined SPL
= =
10 Log₁₀ [(1.58 x 10⁻⁸) / (1 x 10⁻¹²)]
42
Total SPL during normal hours at this zone is 42 dB
Zone 3: Washroom Peak hours Highest reading
=
65
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
65
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
65
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
6.5
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 6.5
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (3.16 x 10⁶)
I
=
3.16 x 10⁻⁶
Total Intensities
=
3.16 x 10⁻⁶
Combined SPL
= =
10 Log₁₀ [(3.16 x 10⁻⁶) / (1 x 10⁻¹²)]
65
Total SPL during peak hours at this zone is 65 dB
101
Zone 4: Library Ground Floor Non-peak hours Highest reading
=
45
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
45
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
45
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
4.5
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 4.5
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (3.16 x 10⁴)
I
=
3.16 x 10⁻⁸
Lowest reading
=
39
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
39
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
39
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
3.9
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 3.9
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (7.94 x 10³)
I
=
7.94 x 10⁻⁹
Total Intensities
=
(3.16 x 10⁻⁸) + (7.94 x 10⁻⁹)
=
3.954 x 10⁻⁸
Combined SPL
= =
10 Log₁₀ [(3.954 x 10⁻⁸) / (1 x 10⁻¹²)]
46
Total SPL during normal hours at this zone is 46 dB
102
Zone 4: Library Ground Floor Peak hours Highest reading
=
52
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
52
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
52
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
5.2
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 5.2
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (1.58 x 10⁵)
I
=
1.58 x 10⁻⁷
Lowest reading
=
48
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
48
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
48
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
4.8
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 4.8
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (6.3 x 10⁴)
I
=
6.3 x 10⁻⁸
Total Intensities
=
(1.58 x 10⁻⁷) + (6.3 x 10⁻⁸)
=
2.21 x 10⁻⁷
Combined SPL
= =
10 Log₁₀ [(2.21 x 10⁻⁷) / (1 x 10⁻¹²)]
53.4
Total SPL during peak hours at this zone is 53.4 dB
103
Zone 5 : Library First Floor Non-peak hours Highest reading
=
47
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
47
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
47
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
4.7
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 4.7
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (5 x 10⁴)
I
=
5 x 10⁻⁸
Lowest reading
=
45
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
45
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
45
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
4.5
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 4.5
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (3.16 x 10⁴)
I
=
3.16 x 10⁻⁸
Total Intensities
=
(5 x 10⁻⁸) + (3.16 x 10⁻⁹)
=
8.16 x 10⁻⁸
Combined SPL
= =
10 Log₁₀ [(8.16 x 10⁻⁸) / (1 x 10⁻¹²)]
49
Total SPL during normal hours at this zone is 49 dB
104
Zone 5 : Library First Floor Peak hours Highest reading
=
55
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
55
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
55
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
5.5
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 5.5
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (3.16 x 10⁵)
I
=
3.16 x 10⁻⁷
Lowest reading
=
48
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
48
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
48
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
4.8
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 4.8
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (6.3 x 10⁴)
I
=
6.3 x 10⁻⁸
Total Intensities
=
(3.16 x 10⁻⁷) + (6.3 x 10⁻⁸)
=
3.79 x 10⁻⁷
Combined SPL
= =
10 Log₁₀ [(3.79 x 10⁻⁷) / (1 x 10⁻¹²)]
55.8
Total SPL during peak hours at this zone is 55.8 dB
105
Zone 6: Library Second Floor Non-peak hours Highest reading
=
54
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
54
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
54
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
5.4
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 5.4
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (2.51 x 10⁵)
I
=
2.51 x 10⁻⁷
Lowest reading
=
52
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
52
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
52
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
5.2
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 5.2
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (1.58 x 10⁵)
I
=
1.58 x 10⁻⁷
Total Intensities
=
(2.51 x 10⁻⁷) + (1.58 x 10⁻⁷)
=
4.09 x 10⁻⁷
Combined SPL
= =
10 Log₁₀ [(4.09 x 10⁻⁷) / (1 x 10⁻¹²)]
56.1
Total SPL during normal hours at this zone is 56.1 dB
106
Zone 6: Library Second Floor Peak hours Highest reading
=
58
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
58
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
58
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
5.8
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 5.8
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (6.3 x 10⁵)
I
=
6.3 x 10⁻⁷
Lowest reading
=
55
L
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
55
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/I₀)
55
=
10 Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
5.5
=
Log₁₀ (I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
Antilog 5.5
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²)
I
=
(I/1 x 10⁻¹²) (3.16 x 10⁵)
I
=
3.16 x 10⁻⁷
Total Intensities
=
(6.3 x 10⁻⁷) + (3.16 x 10⁻⁷)
=
9.47 x 10⁻⁷
Combined SPL
= =
10 Log₁₀ [(9.47 x 10⁻⁷) / (1 x 10⁻¹²)]
59.8
Total SPL during peak hours at this zone is 59.8 dB
107
Analysis of SPL
Zone Dining area Lounge area Washroom area Library ground floor area Library first floor area Library second floor area
SPL during normal hours (dB) 47.8 48 42 46 49 56.1
SPL during peak hours (dB) 63.6 54.1 65 53.4 55.8 59.8
The table shows that the washroom area produces the highest amount of sound pressure when used during peak hours, which may disturb the reading activities at the library beside it. The second highest is the dining area, which also effects the library area. Sound pressure level at the library far exceeds the recommended 40 dB, with an average of 50.4 dB during normal hours and 56.3 dB during peak hours. The difference in the overall sound pressure between two different hours is quite significant for a library, with a rise of 10 dB in average. The reason of the high sound pressure levels can be attributed to the wrong use of building materials in the library. The library is mainly built using reinforced concrete, steel mesh floorings and steel mesh bookcases, which is weak in sound absorption. The other reason that cause this problem is the spatial planning, where the library area is surrounded by the dining, kitchen, lounge and washroom. These areas transmit sound at the same time into the center of the library through vibrations via both air and dense solid building materials. In conclusion, the sound level pressure can be reduced by introducing soft and more sound absorbent materials like curtains and wood based furniture. Despite that, these efforts may not lower the sound pressure to the recommended level of 40 dB as the spatial planning and the material of the building is fixed, which could not be resolved without the deconstruction of the library.
108
4.2.6 Reverberation Time Analysis
Zone 1: Dining and Kitchen Space volume = 42m3 500hz Non-peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Concrete -Steel mesh -Concrete -Concrete -Glass -Timber -Concrete -Timber -Timber --
1 1
1.45 m2 8.4 m2
0.05 0.06
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.07 0.5
1 1 1 1 1 7 1 --
14 m2 14 m2 9 m2 1.82 m2 1.82 m2 0.86 m2 7.25 m2 42m3 (Volume)
0.05 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.05 0.15 0.15 0.007
0.7 0.7 0.9 0.27 0.09 0.9 1.09 0.29
Ceiling Floor Door Table Chair Cupboard Air Total (A)
5.51
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 42) / 5.51 = 1.22s
2000hz Non-peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Concrete -Steel mesh -Concrete -Concrete -Glass -Timber -Concrete -Timber -Timber --
1 1
1.45 m2 8.4 m2
0.05 0.04
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.07 0.34
1 1 1 1 1 7 1 --
14 m2 14 m2 9 m2 1.82 m2 1.82 m2 0.86 m2 7.25 m2 42m3 (Volume)
0.05 0.05 0.05 0.18 0.05 0.18 0.18 0.007
0.7 0.7 0.45 0.33 0.09 1.08 1.31 0.29
Ceiling Floor Door Table Chair Cupboard Air Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
5.36
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 42) / 5.36 = 1.25s
109
500hz Peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Concrete -Steel mesh -Concrete -Concrete -Glass -Timber -Concrete -Timber -Timber --
1 1
1.45 m2 8.4 m2
0.05 0.06
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.07 0.5
1 1 1 1 1 7 1 --
0.05 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.05 0.15 0.15 0.007
0.7 0.7 0.9 0.27 0.09 0.9 1.09 0.29
--
2
14 m2 14 m2 9 m2 1.82 m2 1.82 m2 0.86 m2 7.25 m2 42m3 (Volume) --
0.46
0.92 6.43
Ceiling Floor Door Table Chair Cupboard Air Human Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 42) / 6.43 = 1.05s
2000hz Peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Concrete -Steel mesh -Concrete -Concrete -Glass -Timber -Concrete -Timber -Timber --
1 1
1.45 m2 8.4 m2
0.05 0.04
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.07 0.34
1 1 1 1 1 7 1 --
0.05 0.05 0.05 0.18 0.05 0.18 0.18 0.007
0.7 0.7 0.45 0.33 0.09 1.08 1.31 0.29
--
2
14 m2 14 m2 9 m2 1.82 m2 1.82 m2 0.86 m2 7.25 m2 42m3 (Volume) --
0.46
0.92 6.28
Ceiling Floor Door Table Chair Cupboard Air Human Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 42) / 6.28 = 1.07s
110
Zone 2: Lounge Space volume = 31.5m3 500hz Non-peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Concrete -Steel mesh -Timber -Concrete -Glass (Big) -Glass (Small) -Timber -Timber -Concrete --
1 1
10.5 m2 17.6 m2
0.05 0.06
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.53 1.06
1 1 1 1
6.3 m2 6.3 m2 11.2 m2 0.81 m2
0.2 0.05 0.1 0.1
1.26 0.32 1.12 0.08
1 4 1 --
1.17 m2 0.86 m2 1.5 m2 31.5m3 (Volume)
0.15 0.15 0.05 0.007
0.18 0.52 0.08 0.22
Ceiling Floor Window
Table Chair Air Total (A)
5.37
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 31.5) / 5.37 = 0.94s
2000hz Non-peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Concrete -Steel mesh -Timber -Concrete -Glass (Big) -Glass (Small) -Timber -Timber -Concrete --
1 1
10.5 m2 17.6 m2
0.05 0.04
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.53 0.7
1 1 1 1
6.3 m2 6.3 m2 11.2 m2 0.81 m2
0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05
0.32 0.32 0.56 0.04
1 4 1 --
1.17 m2 0.86 m2 1.5 m2 31.5m3 (Volume)
0.18 0.18 0.05 0.007
0.21 0.62 0.08 0.22
Ceiling Floor Window
Table Chair Air Total (A)
3.6
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 31.5) / 3.6 = 1.4s
111
500hz Peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Concrete -Steel mesh -Timber -Concrete -Glass (Big) -Glass (Small) -Timber -Timber -Concrete --
1 1
10.5 m2 17.6 m2
0.05 0.06
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.53 1.06
1 1 1 1
6.3 m2 6.3 m2 11.2 m2 0.81 m2
0.2 0.05 0.1 0.1
1.26 0.32 1.12 0.08
1 4 1 --
0.15 0.15 0.05 0.007
0.18 0.52 0.08 0.22
--
2
1.17 m2 0.86 m2 1.5 m2 31.5m3 (Volume) --
0.46
0.92 6.29
Ceiling Floor Window
Table Chair Air Human Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 31.5) / 6.29 = 0.8s
2000hz Peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Concrete -Steel mesh -Timber -Concrete -Glass (Big) -Glass (Small) -Timber -Timber -Concrete --
1 1
10.5 m2 17.6 m2
0.05 0.04
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.53 0.7
1 1 1 1
6.3 m2 6.3 m2 11.2 m2 0.81 m2
0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05
0.32 0.32 0.56 0.04
1 4 1 --
0.18 0.18 0.05 0.007
0.21 0.62 0.08 0.22
--
2
1.17 m2 0.86 m2 1.5 m2 31.5m3 (Volume) --
0.46
0.92 4.52
Ceiling Floor Window
Table Chair Air Human Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 31.5) / 4.52 = 1.12s
112
Zone 3: Washroom area Space volume = 3.4m3 500hz Non-peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Concrete -Concrete -Concrete -Concrete -Glass --
1 1 1 1 1 --
4.1 m2 1.74 m2 6.3 m2 1.62 m2 3.2 m2 3.4m3 (Volume)
Ceiling Floor Door Air
0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.1 0.007
Total (A)
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.21 0.09 0.32 0.08 0.32 0.02 1.04
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 3.4) / 1.04 = 0.52s
2000hz Non-peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Concrete -Concrete -Concrete -Concrete -Glass --
1 1 1 1 1 --
4.1 m2 1.74 m2 6.3 m2 1.62 m2 3.2 m2 3.4m3 (Volume)
Ceiling Floor Door Air
0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.007
Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.21 0.09 0.32 0.08 0.16 0.02 0.88
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 3.4) / 0.88 = 0.62s
113
500hz Peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Concrete -Concrete -Concrete -Concrete -Glass --
1 1 1 1 1 --
--
1
4.1 m2 1.74 m2 6.3 m2 1.62 m2 3.2 m2 3.4m3 (Volume) --
Ceiling Floor Door Air Human Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.1 0.007 0.46
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.21 0.09 0.32 0.08 0.32 0.02 0.46 1.5
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 3.4) / 1.5 = 0.36s
2000hz Peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Concrete -Concrete -Concrete -Concrete -Glass --
1 1 1 1 1 --
--
1
4.1 m2 1.74 m2 6.3 m2 1.62 m2 3.2 m2 3.4m3 (Volume) --
Ceiling Floor Door Air Human Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.05 0.007 0.46
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.21 0.09 0.32 0.08 0.16 0.02 0.46 0.88
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 3.4) / 1.34 = 0.41s
114
Zone 4: Library Ground Floor Space volume = 33.75m3 500hz Non-peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Concrete -Steel -Plastic -Plastic --
2 1
18.75 m2 3.78 m2
0.06 0.06
Sound absorption (Sa) 2.25 0.23
1
13.5 m2
0.06
0.81
1 1 1 1 --
13.5 m2 3.75 m2 0.3 m2 0.86 m2 33.75m3 (Volume)
0.05 0.06 0.14 0.14 0.007
0.68 0.23 0.04 0.12 0.24
Ceiling Floor Door Table Chair Air Total (A)
4.6
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 33.75) / 4.6 = 1.17s
2000hz Non-peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Concrete -Steel -Plastic -Plastic --
2 1
18.75 m2 3.78 m2
0.04 0.04
Sound absorption (Sa) 1.5 0.15
1
13.5 m2
0.04
0.54
1 1 1 1 --
13.5 m2 3.75 m2 0.3 m2 0.86 m2 33.75m3 (Volume)
0.05 0.04 0.14 0.14 0.007
0.68 0.15 0.04 0.12 0.24
Ceiling Floor Door Table Chair Air Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
3.42
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 33.75) / 3.42 = 1.58s
115
500hz Peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Concrete -Steel -Plastic -Plastic --
2 1
18.75 m2 3.78 m2
0.06 0.06
Sound absorption (Sa) 2.25 0.23
1
13.5 m2
0.06
0.81
1 1 1 1 --
0.05 0.06 0.14 0.14 0.007
0.68 0.23 0.04 0.12 0.24
--
3
13.5 m2 3.75 m2 0.3 m2 0.86 m22 33.75m3 (Volume) --
0.46
1.38 5.98
Ceiling Floor Door Table Chair Air Human Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 33.75) / 5.98 = 0.92s
2000hz Peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Concrete -Steel -Plastic -Plastic --
2 1
18.75 m2 3.78 m2
0.04 0.04
Sound absorption (Sa) 1.5 0.15
1
13.5 m2
0.04
0.54
1 1 1 1 --
0.05 0.04 0.14 0.14 0.007
0.68 0.15 0.04 0.12 0.24
--
3
13.5 m2 3.75 m2 0.3 m2 0.86 m2 33.75m3 (Volume) --
0.46
1.38 4.8
Ceiling Floor Door Table Chair Air Human Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 33.75) / 4.8 = 1.13s
116
Zone 5: Library First Floor Space volume = 31.05m3 500hz Non-peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Concrete -Timber -Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Glass --
2 1
17.25 m2 3.78 m2
0.06 0.06
Sound absorption (Sa) 2.07 0.23
1 1 1
4.14 m2 5.04 m2 4.32 m2
0.05 0.05 0.06
0.21 0.25 0.26
1
13.5 m2
0.06
0.81
1 --
2.25 m2 31.05m3 (Volume)
0.1 0.007
0.23 0.22
Ceiling
Floor Window Air Total (A)
4.28
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 31.05) / 4.28 = 1.16s
2000hz Non-peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Concrete -Timber -Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Glass --
2 1
17.25 m2 3.78 m2
0.04 0.04
Sound absorption (Sa) 1.38 0.15
1 1 1
4.14 m2 5.04 m2 4.32 m2
0.05 0.2 0.04
0.21 1.01 0.17
1
13.5 m2
0.04
0.4
1 --
2.25 m2 31.05m3 (Volume)
0.05 0.007
0.11 0.22
Ceiling
Floor Window Air Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
3.65
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 31.05) / 3.65 = 1.36s
117
500hz Peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Concrete -Timber -Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Glass --
2 1
17.25 m2 3.78 m2
0.06 0.06
Sound absorption (Sa) 2.07 0.23
1 1 1
4.14 m2 5.04 m2 4.32 m2
0.05 0.05 0.06
0.21 0.25 0.26
1
13.5 m2
0.06
0.81
1 --
0.1 0.007
0.23 0.22
--
4
2.25 m2 31.05m3 (Volume) --
0.46
1.84 6.12
Ceiling
Floor Window Air Human Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 31.05) / 6.12 = 0.81s
2000hz peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Concrete -Timber -Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Glass --
2 1
17.25 m2 3.78 m2
0.04 0.04
Sound absorption (Sa) 1.38 0.15
1 1 1
4.14 m2 5.04 m2 4.32 m2
0.05 0.2 0.04
0.21 1.01 0.17
1
13.5 m2
0.04
0.4
1 --
0.05 0.007
0.11 0.22
--
3
2.25 m2 31.05m3 (Volume) --
0.46
1.84 5.49
Ceiling
Floor Window Air Human Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 31.05) / 5.49 = 0.9s
118
Zone 6: Library Second Floor Space volume = 13.5m3 500hz Non-peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Glass -Steel mesh --
2 1
4.8 m2 3.6 m2
0.06 0.06
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.58 0.22
1 1
4.5 m2 2.52 m2
0.1 0.06
0.45 0.15
--
13.5m3 (Volume)
0.007
0.09
Ceiling Floor Air Total (A)
1.49
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 13.5) / 1.49 = 1.45s
2000hz Non-peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Glass -Steel mesh --
2 1
4.8 m2 3.6 m2
0.04 0.04
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.38 0.14
1 1
4.5 m2 2.52 m2
0.05 0.04
0.23 0.1
--
13.5m3 (Volume)
0.007
0.09
Ceiling Floor Air Total (A)
0.94
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 13.5) / 0.94 = 2.3s
119
500hz Peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Glass -Steel mesh --
2 1
4.8 m2 3.6 m2
0.06 0.06
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.58 0.22
1 1
4.5 m2 2.52 m2
0.1 0.06
0.45 0.15
--
0.007
0.09
--
2
13.5m3 (Volume) --
0.46
0.92 2.41
Ceiling Floor Air Human Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 13.5) / 2.41 = 0.9s
2000hz Peak hour Compone nts
Material
Quantity
Surface Area Absorption (S) coefficient (a)
Wall
-Steel mesh -Steel mesh -Glass -Steel mesh --
2 1
4.8 m2 3.6 m2
0.04 0.04
Sound absorption (Sa) 0.38 0.14
1 1
4.5 m2 2.52 m2
0.05 0.04
0.23 0.1
--
0.007
0.09
--
2
13.5m3 (Volume) --
0.46
0.92 1.86
Ceiling Floor Air Human Total (A)
Reverberation time (RT)
= (0.16 x Volume) / A = (0.16 x 13.5) / 1.86s = 1.16s
120
Analysis of reverberation time
Zone
RT 500hz (normal hour) Dining 1.22s Lounge 0.94s Washroom 0.52s Library ground 1.17 floor Library first 1.16s floor Library second 1.45s floor
RT 2000hz (normal hour) 1.25s 1.4s 0.62s 1.58s
RT 500hz (peak hour) 1.05s 0.8s 0.36s 0.73s
RT 2000hz (peak hour) 1.07s 1.12s 0.41s 0.81s
1.36s
0.92s
1.13s
2.3s
0.9s
1.16s
The table above shows the reverberation time of each zones under different conditions. The dining area has an overall reverberation time that exceeds 1 second, causing the sound from the kitchen activity to decay slower therefore creating a noisier space. This may affect nearby spaces especially the library reading area since there are no real solid walls separating the areas. The lounge area has a significant lower reverberation time when the noise is around 500hz, which is 30% lower than those at 2000hz. This is due to the introduction of timber ceiling and glass windows, that only have half its absorption coefficient value at 2000hz. The washroom area has the lowest reverberation time of all the zones, with each lower than 0.62 seconds. The library area has high reverberation time at each level, exceeding 1.1 seconds, which is considered bad as the reading activities favour quiet spaces with shorter reverberations. The choice of building materials like concrete and steel mesh are a huge factor to this problem as most of it have a fairly low absorption coefficient. Fortunately, the reverberation time shortens significantly during the peak hours with the presence of people, lowering it to more acceptable levels especially in the library area. The introduction of wooden or high absorption value furniture can further help with this problem. Not only that, the overall reverberation time of the library can also be reduced by installing curtains at the windows and glass sliding door.
121
4.2.7 Sound Reduction Index Analysis
Zone 1: Dining and Kitchen
Figure 94: SRI at Dining and Kitchen Zone
Wall
Material
East
Reinforced 8.7 concrete wall Glass Sliding 9 door
South
Surface Area (m2)
East wall total SRI (R)
= 45dB
South wall total SRI (R)
= 10dB
SRI (dB)
45
Energy T x Area transmission coefficient (T) 3.16 x 10⁻⁵ 2.75 x 10⁻⁴
10
0.1
0.9
Analysis The calculation only factors in 2 walls as the west leads to the kitchen area and the wall to the north is made of steel mesh with lots of openings. The table shows that the east wall has a significant higher sound reduction index compared to the south wall due to the difference in building material.
122
Zone 2: Lounge
Figure 95: SRI at Lounge Zone
Wall
Material
Surface Area (m2)
SRI (dB)
East
Reinforced concrete wall Window Reinforced concrete wall Glass window
9.69 0.81
45 10
Energy T x Area transmission coefficient (T) 3.16 x 10⁻⁵ 3.06 x 10⁻⁴ 0.1 0.08
3 11.21
45 10
3.16 x 10⁻⁵ 0.1
South
East wall total SRI (R)
South wall total SRI (R) T
T
= [(T₁ x A₁) + (T₂ x A₂)] / (A₁ + A₂) = 7.65 x 10⁻³
R
= 10log₁₀ (1/T)
9.48 x 10⁻⁵ 1.12
= [(T₁ x A₁) + (T₂ x A₂)] / (A₁ + A₂) = 0.08
R
= 10log₁₀ (1/T) = 11dB
= 21dB Analysis The calculation only factors in 2 walls as the west leads to the dining area and the wall to the north is made of steel mesh with lots of openings. The table shows that the east wall has almost twice the amount of sound reduction index comparing to the south wall. This situation is caused by the presence of a large glass window, which made up around 70% of the south wall.
123
Zone 3: Washroom
Figure 96: SRI at Washroom Zone
Wall
Material
Surface Area (m2)
SRI (dB)
East
Reinforced concrete wall Reinforced concrete wall Glass sliding door Reinforced concrete wall Reinforced concrete wall
1.74
45
Energy T x Area transmission coefficient (T) 3.16 x 10⁻⁵ 5.49 x 10⁻⁵
0.9 3.2
45 10
3.16 x 10⁻⁵ 0.1
2.84 x 10⁻⁵ 0.32
1.74
45
3.16 x 10⁻⁵
5.49 x 10⁻⁵
4.1
45
3.16 x 10⁻⁵
1.29 x 10⁻⁴
South
West North
East wall total SRI (R)
= 45dB
West wall total SRI (R)
= 45dB
North wall total SRI (R)
= 45dB
South wall total SRI (R)
T
= [(T₁ x A₁) + (T₂ x A₂)] / (A₁ + A₂) = 0.08
R
= 10log₁₀ (1/T) = 11dB
Analysis The east, west and north wall has the same sound reduction index of 45dB due to the use of reinforced concrete and plain rough surface. The wall to the south only have a quarter of the SRI value of its surrounding walls as a huge part of it is a glass sliding door. The sliding door should be replaced with materials with higher SRI value as it is directly connected to the library area.
124
Zone 4: Library Ground Floor
Figure 97: SRI at Library Ground Floor Zone
Wall
Material
Surface Area (m2)
SRI (dB)
East
Steel door
3.75
38
East wall total SRI (R)
Energy T x Area transmission coefficient (T) 1.58 x 10⁻⁴ 5.93 x 10⁻⁴
= 38dB
Analysis The only real wall in this area is the east wall, which is made of a huge steel door with a SRI value of 38dB. Despite the door’s position - facing to the street, the SRI value is high enough to keep out exterior noise due to the normally quiet neighborhood. The other walls are made of steel mesh.
125
Zone 5: Library First Floor
Figure 98: SRI at Library First Floor Zone
Wall
Material
Surface Area (m2)
SRI (dB)
East
Glass window
2.25
10
East wall total SRI (R)
Energy T x Area transmission coefficient (T) 0.1 0.23
= 10dB
Analysis Same like the library at the lower floor, the east wall is the only real wall at this zone, which is made of a huge glass window with an SRI value of 10. This may be a problem as the window is facing to the street and any exterior noise can be directed into the library space causing loud noises even if the neighborhood is generally quiet.
126
Zone 6: Library Second Floor
Figure 99: SRI at Library Second Floor Zone
Analysis All of the walls at this area is made up of steel mesh. Noises from any direction can just penetrate easily.
127
5.0 CONCLUSION
Lighting Performance in L45 The daylighting in the library is sufficient for its activities in areas near openings like the windows at the lounge, the glass sliding doors at the dining area and the glass roof at the top floor. However, daylight is unable to reach the deeper parts of the building causing the overall daylight factor of these zones to drop. The calculations using the Lumen Method also shows that there is lack of artificial lightings in all zones except for the washroom. This happens because of the choice of lightings and the direction they face which is inconsistent and irregular due to the adjustability. Suggestions for Improvement To see a significant improvement in daylighting, more openings should be constructed along with the introduction of a more reflective materials in the library rather than the rough and dark surfaces of the concrete. The change of higher lux value artificial lightings especially in the library areas will help raising the illuminance level to meet the requirements according to MS1525. In addition, more lightings can be installed with fixed directions.
Acoustics Performance in L45 A standard library has a standard reverberation time of less than 1 second for it to be speech intelligible. However, the acoustics in the building is generally high for a library. The factors of the problem are: spatial planning, activities in the kitchen, choice of building materials and the use of electronic devices. The library area is located in the middle of the building, surrounded by different spaces which means that any noises produced in other areas will be transmitted to the center, affecting the sound level of the library area. The rise in decibel is especially significant when the kitchen is in use as the two zones are only separated by steel mesh walls with multiple openings. The choice of steel mesh for the top floors and staircases also contributed to the noise produced when traveling on it. Lastly, electronic devices like air
128
conditioner, ventilation fan and kitchen appliances are the main source of noise in the building Suggestions for Improvement To reduce the sound level traveling into the library area, solid concrete walls should be used in place of the steel meshes, since it increases the sound reduction index of that area. The reverberation time of all the zones can be reduced by using furniture with high absorption coefficient value.
Conclusion The L45 library could use a lot more improvement in order to produce a better environment for the users within the library area. Even though there are rooms which much better lightings and acoustics, they are only available to those who rented them. Proper maintenance should be done to the devices to reduce the noise coming from them. Adjustable windows are also not suitable for a library in such a quaint space as it is the source of noise leakage. In the end, a library as a whole should at least meet the minimum recommended level standards so that the activities are not disrupted, increases productivity, and encourages improved psychology to its visitors.
129
6.0 SUMMARY OF REPORT(A3)
130
131
132
7.0 REFERENCES 1. 133, E. (2016). Soundproof Cow - EccoTone Linear 133, Wood Soundproofing Panel, Wood Acoustic Panel. Soundproof Cow. Retrieved 1 November 2016, from http://www.soundproofcow.com/product/eccotone-linear-133/ 2. Absorption coefficients building materials finishes RT60 alpha coefficient acoustic absorbing absorbtion floor seating wall ceiling miscellaneous materials - sengpielaudio Sengpiel Berlin. (n.d.). Retrieved November 01,2016,from http://www.sengpielaudio.com/calculator-RT60Coeff.htm 3. Celsus: A Library Architecture Resource - Cleo Rogers Memorial Library, Columbus Indiana. (2016). Libraryarchitecture.wikispaces.com. Retrieved 4 November 2016, from https://libraryarchitecture.wikispaces.com/Cleo+Rogers+Memorial+Library,+Columbus+Indiana 4. Clarke, J. (2001). Energy simulation in building design. Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann. 5. Corrodi, M. & Spechtenhauser, K. Illuminating: Natural Light in Residential Architecture. 6. Grondzik, W. & Kwok, A. Mechanical and electrical equipment for buildings. http://www.pioneerlighting.com/new/pdfs/IESLuxLevel.pdf. (2011) (1st ed.). 7. Jodidio, P. & Strong, J. (2008). I.M. Pei. New York: Rizzoli. 8. Lighting design considerations. (n.d.). Retrieved November 01,2016,from http://www.slideshare.net/mominzaki/lightingdesign-considerations 9. Long, M. (2006). Architectural acoustics. Amsterdam: Elsevier/Academic Press. 10. Low Voltage Halogen Lighting. (n.d.). Retrieved November 05,2016,from http://www.hafele.co.uk/shop/images/External/pages/104-72.pdf 11. Nadia Aloui. (2014) Performance evaluation of an acoustic indoor localization system based on a fingerprinting technique 12. Noise Reduction Technical Data and Results. (n.d.). Retrieved November 01,2016,from http://www.magnetite.co.nz/noise-reduction-technical-data-and-results.html 13. Pitts, G. (2000). Acoustic performance of party floors and walls in timber framed buildings. High Wycombe: TRADA Technology Ltd. 14. POLICY, P., Interviews, V., & Index, A. (2016). Brown Rudnick Office, Mayfair, London / Brady Mallalieu Architects Architecture Lab. Architecture Lab. Retrieved 28 October 2016, from http://architecturelab.net/brown-rudnick-officemayfair-london-brady-mallalieu-architects/ 15. Sabine, P. (1932). Acoustics and architecture. New York: McGraw-Hill. 16. Steffy,G. (2002). Architectural lighting design. John Wiley & Sons. 17. The Concept Of Sound Pressure (SPL). (n.d.). Retrieved November 01,2016,from http://www.instructables.com/id/The-Concept-Of-Sound-Pressure-SPL/ 18. VergeĚ s, M., Meyers, J., & Alavedra, I. (2007). Light in architecture. Antwerp: Tectum Publishers.
133