ESTABLISH 1826 — OLDEST COLLEGE NEWSPAPER WEST OF THE ALLEGHENIES
Miami University — Oxford, Ohio
TUESDAY, OCTOBER 9, 2018
Volume 147 No. 6
MU EMPLOYEE INDICTED ON RAPE CHARGES FACES HEARING NEXT WEEK
JULIA ARWINE STAFF WRITER
CÉILÍ DOYLE NEWS EDITOR
Brandon Levi Gilbert, a Miami University building and grounds assistant, was indicted on five counts of sexual assault charges, including a first degree felony for the rape of a female student, in the Butler County Court of Common pleas last Tuesday. Gilbert was charged with the first degree felony for rape, two second degree felonies for attempted rape and felonious assault and two counts of first degree felonies for kidnapping, according to court documents. He posted 10 percent of his $75,000 bond and is now out of Butler County Jail. Gilbert has worked for Miami since April 2017 and is still suspended without pay from the university, Senior VP for Finance and Business Services David Creamer, wrote in a letter to Gilbert obtained from his personnel file. Judge Gregory Howard will preside over the case in the Butler County Courthouse in Hamilton, Ohio. A plea hearing will take place next week at 8:30 a.m. on Wednesday, Oct. 17. Check miamistudent.net next week for further updates on this pending case.
CLOCKWISE, FROM TOP LEFT: DAVID SEIDL, SUSAN SCOTT, VICTORIA FARNSWORTH, MARK MACNAUGHTON. CONTRIBUTED BY MIAMI NEWS AND COMMUNICATIONS OFFICE
Miami seeks to hire a new VP for IT
@cadoyle_18 doyleca3@miamioh.edu
The Information Services department is conducting a search for a new vice president and chief information officer (CIO) after J. Peter Natale retired last spring. It is the highest paid job in the IT department, and Natale’s total salary of just over $246,000 last year was the fifth highest-paid VP position on campus, according to Miami’s 2017 annual salary roster. “We are seeking an experienced, collaborative and visionary leader with exemplary communication skills to provide the necessary strategy, technology platforms and systems to influence every aspect of campus life,” said Ted Pickerill, secretary to the board of trustees and executive assistant to the university president. Pickerill is heading the search. The selection process for applicants included securing approval from the Office of Equity and Equal Opportunity, closed interviews with hiring officials and then open interviews in which the public could ask questions of each candidate. The final four candidates are David Seidl, Susan Scott, Mark MacNaughton and Victoria Farnsworth. Three of these candidates — Seidl, Scott and Farnsworth— are currently employed at different universities, while MacNaughton is an outsider to academia. David Seidl is the senior director of campus technology services at the University of Notre Dame. He has held various information security positions at Notre Dame since he first started working there in 2008. Before that, he worked in information security at Purdue University for four years. He has a broad technical background, and he emphasized his success in staff engagement and building strong relationships. Susan Scott is the associate CIO at the University of Dayton, where she has worked in technology, accounting and CONTINUED ON PAGE 3
TITLE IX
Questions surround Title IX policy change SAMANTHA BRUNN NEWS EDITOR
The Title IX policy change enacted by Miami University has left students wondering whether the university truly aims to “stand with all Miamians...to make our campus more safe and more secure,” as university president Greg Crawford stated in his annual address last week. “The recent changes have understandably prompted questions about what this will look like for our students at Miami,” Gabrielle Dralle, the university’s deputy Title IX coordinator for students, said. “I am here to help students involved in our Title IX process so they need not navigate the process alone.” Dralle said her office is committed to prioritizing the safety of students and their right to an equal education.
Miami University quickly complied with the Sixth Circuit federal court ruling, and may have been the first school affected to do so. No other university affected by the decision has publicly stated that their policy has changed. The ruling is in line with the Trump administration and U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos’ priorities in giving more rights to the accused in sexual assault cases. The University of Michigan has appealed the ruling, saying the ruling could discourage survivors from reporting their assaults and that it would negatively impact low-income students. Claire Wagner, director of Miami’s university news and communications office, said the impact on low-income students is no different than the impact under the university’s previous policy. Students who cannot afford legal
representation are at a disadvantage under both policies, but arguably more so under the new policy, by which the representative has the ability to cross-examine the other party in the case and therefore has more of a presence in the hearing. Wagner explained that the university’s previous policy allowed the accused and the accuser in these cases to avoid emotional confrontation in a hearing room by being present through web conferencing. The previous policy also allowed the accused and accuser to question one another through the hearing panel, rather than personally or through their representative. Under the new policy, Wagner claimed students could only cross-examine each other personally, and not through their representatives. But that is not the case according to the ruling, which states, “If a public university has to choose between competing
narratives to resolve a case, the university must give the accused student or his agent an opportunity to cross-examine the accuser and adverse witnesses in the presence of a neutral fact-finder.” Wagner admitted the Office of Community Standards, formerly known as The Office of Ethics and Student Conflict Resolution (OESCR), would be better equipped to comment on the policy change, but at press time, Office of Community Standards director Ann James could not be reached for comment. The Miami Student reached out to the university Title IX coordinator Kenya Ash’s office, but was redirected to Wagner’s office. @samantha_brunn brunnsj@miamioh.edu
This Issue Caged Bird(s) are freed
No stone left unturned
Bird bailed out a number of the scooter fleet that was impounded by MUPD.
Oxford Rocks is a Facebook group dedicated to exploration .
page 4
page 9
The bitter taste of reality
Starting off strong
DELISH is gone. Our columnist has something to say about it.
Miami hockey opens with series sweep for the first time in five years.
page 12
page 10
CALL FOR ART
OUTSIDE THE BOX
Spooky brews food on page 6 & 7
THE opportunity to show your work (& win money) in the
Miami University Art Museum Student Response Exhibition Spring 2019 Submission Deadline October 15, 2018 Learn more at tinyurl.com/otbsp19